Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1993 Annotated Mod Com Agendas (2)i. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-069 301 Santa Cruz Road Wei -Tsu Liu Approved. 3-0, 2. PUBLICfEARING MC 93-070 240 W. Walnut Ave. Joyce Soong Approval of items 1-4. Denial of item 5 with the following rendition remove cooking facilities TO DEC 1 6 1993 AGENDA COUNCIL ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE &15 A.M., TUESDAY, DECEMBER 14,1993 MODIFICATION COMMITTEE MEETING 8:15 a.m. in the f onfprensr Room A 5' -6' southerly side yard setback in lieu of 6 required for a proposed 1200 sq. ft. addition to the rear of the house (Sec.9252.2.4). The proposed addition will align with the setback of the existing house. The following modifications are to permit an existing guest house. 1) A 5' -0" westerly side setback in lieu of 10' -2" required (Sec. 9251.2.4). 2) A 5'-0" distance between the guest house and a storage shed (Sec. 9251.2.8). 3) 700 square feet in lieu of the 600 square foot maximum allowed for guest houses (Sec. 9251.2.8). 4) 2 existing bedrooms in lieu of 1 allowed (Sec. 9220.2.4). 5) A kitchenette in lieu of no cooking facilities allowed (Sec. 9220.2.3). COMMPI'1hE MEMBERS PRESENT: Commissioner Daggett, Feinberg, Kasama PLANNING DIVISION REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski, Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, December 21 1993 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 23, 1993 MODIFICATION COMNIITTEE MEETING 8:15 a.m. in the Personnel Conference Rooni 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93 -065 428 Palm Dr. Anne Cheng Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93 -066 510 W. Norman Ave. Wing Kwong Chan Denied Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-067 1101 W. Huntington Dr. G.W. Services Inc. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC93 -068 339 W. Norman Ave. M.D. Stewart Approval of (A) and denial of (B). Approval of (A) with the condition that the required landscaping around the proposed tennis court be subject to the approval of the Planning Division, COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Huang, McIntyre and Nicholson PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Stokes and Kasama T NOV 2 4 1993 COUNCIL Request a height of 6 to the top of the existing light fixtures and 5' -9" to the top of the existing gates in lieu of the 4'-0" maximum for an existing block wall /wrought iron fence in the front yard area (Sec. 9283.8.7). Request to permit a building height modification of 26' -2" in lieu of the maximum height requirement of 25' -0" for a proposed two - story residence in the R -1 zone (Sec. 9252.2.1). Request a Modification to allow a water vending machine to be mounted into the exterior wall of an existing supermarket (Sec. 9263.6.5). Requests for a easterly side yard setback encroachments for a proposed tennis court and light standards in lieu of a minimum setback of 10' -0" required on an R-0 zoned property (Sec. 9256.3.1) A) 5' -0" side yard setback for the tennis court playing area B) 4' -6" side yard setback for the light standards There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, December 2, 1993 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 93 -011 935 Singingwood Dr. ASC Landscaping Inc. Approved, provided that the applicant submit a final plan that would be based on the conceptual plan, which was drawn by the committee. and that it be subject to the review and approval of the Planning Department and the Rancho Santa Anita Property Owners Association. Also, the final plan must comply with all recommendations pertaining to the preservation of the trees, as outlined in the certified arborist report. 2. PUBLIC HEARING TR 93 -012 1251 Oakw000d Dr. Crosby Design & Construction Inc. Approved, with the condition that the applicant comply with all recommendations pertaining to the preservation of the trees, as outlined in the certified arborist report. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9,1993 An encroachment permit into the protected zone of six mature Oak trees in the front yard for a proposed driveway and brick pillars(Sec 9704.b.1). An encroachment permit into the protected zone of two mature Oak trees in the front and side yards for a proposed new block wall (Sec 9704.b.1) COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Commissioner Huang, Feinberg and Nicholson PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, November 16, 1993 TO NOV 1 2 1993 COUNCIL 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-062 1000 S. Eighth Ave. Peter Liao pproved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-063 1833 S. Second Ave. Sunny & Lisa Wong Approved ,, 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC93-064 431 E. Las Flores William Scott Approved subs to the architecture of e • arage enlargement being reviewed by the Planning Department compatibility with the existtng AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, OCTOBER 26,1993 COMMI'rIhE MEMBERS PRESENT: Hedlund, Connors, and Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski, Kasama An overall height of 5'-0" to add four light fixtures on top of four existing 4' -0" high brick pilars (Sec 9283.8.7). A 403 sq. ft. bedroom and dining room addition to a legal nonconforming property with two houses on a R -1 lot (Sec. 9292.1.4.15). A 4' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 7-0" for a proposed addition to the side of an existing garage (Sec. 9252.2.4). There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, November 3, 1993 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 93 -010 1051 Fallen Leaf Rd. California Pools & Spas, Inc. for Dr. & Mrs. Stewart Approved subject to the gas line being installed by either boring or hand trenching, 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-061 260 Whispering Pines Summit Mr. Gordon Stone , Stone & May Landscape Architects for Mr. Hou tin Kong Approved subject to the new fencing. gates and pillars being located behind the City'Q five foot landscape easement, COMMI1 1 hE MEMBERS PRESENT - PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, OCTOBER 12, 1993 Hedlund, Rowe and Butler Kasama There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, October 19, 1993 To OCT 141993 COUNCIL Requesting an Oak Tree Encroachment Permit for a gas line from the existing gas meter at the front property line to the pool equipment in the back yard. The gas line will be placed in a trench that will impact the root systems of two oak trees in the front yard. Requesting the following fence, wall and pillar heights in lieu of the maximum 4' -0" height for front yard improvements: A. A 6-0" high wrought iron front yard perimeter fence with 7-0" high brick pillars. B. Three 7-0" high wrought iron pedestrian gates with 8' -0" high brick pillars. C. 12 high wrought iron driveway gates with 9' -0" high brick pillars with 18" high decorative Lamps. 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-009 57 W. Sycamore Ave. Orlando Clarizio AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 28, 1993 A) The wood fevre was approved suhjert to the following conditions • Approved Requesting an encroachment into the protected zone of two oak trees located along the easterly side property line as a result of the construction of an existing wood fence and the cutting of a neighboring oak tree at 49 Sycamore Ave. 1 ,. r" •• r" • • r,, .. 2) The fence Shall incorporate cut -outs in any part that is in close proximity to the trunk of an nak tree. The rut -nuts shall provide at least 8" to 10 -" of clearance from any part of the oak free 13) The unauthorized rutting of the neighbor's oak tree is to be remedied by the fallowing actions which are all to he cmmuleted by October 79. 1993 and prior to anti final inspections for t • • • 4 . 1 • CI IS y " by Mr. Claririn at 57 W. Sycamore Ave.z limb that was cut off of Mr. Jackson's oak tree 2) The three new California Live flak Trees may he selected by Mr. C'laririo but shall he approved by a certified arborist 3) The three new California Line Oak Trees shall he placed and planted by, nr under the supervision of a certified arborist. The locations of the new oak tree shall be subject to Mr. Jackson's review 4) The certified arbnrist that will approve. place and plant the there new California live Oak Trees shall he selected by Mr. Jackson 5) All of the costs of these remedial actions shall he paid for by Mr. CIarizio 0 A certified arborist shall evaluate the impacts that the existing driveway has had upon the front yard nak trees and the replacement of that driveway shall he done in accordance with any recommendations made by the certified arbnrist 2. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -054 547 Workman Ave. Chin -Yuan Chen COMMI l lbE MEMBERS PRESENT. PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting the following modifications: A. A 28' -0" front yard setback in lieu of the 35' -0" special front yard setback for new porch cover posts (9320.77.1). B. A 30' -0" front yard setback in lieu of the 35' -0" special front yard setback for a 429 sq. ft. two- bedroom and one bathroom addition to align with the existing 30' -0" front setback (9320.77.1). Daggett, Feinberg, Nicholson K asa ma There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, October 5, 1993 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -049 920 W. Orange Grove Donald & Sally Tapert Approved subject to the condition that the landscaped hedge remain and be maintained and that the proposed plans conform to the visibility standards set froth by the Planning Department The applicant must comply with all recommendations pertaining to the nreservatinn of the oak tree. as outlined in the arhorist report 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-009 57 W. Sycamore Ave. Orlando Clarizio Continued to .September 2R . 199.3 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -052 1201 S. Baldwin Ave. Burlington Coat Factory Approved . The existing banner sign parallel to Baldwin Ave. must he placed higher; immediately, 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-053 1320 -1322 S. Baldwin Ave. Mr. Jeff Wang for Mr. Ku Fu Jiang Conditionally approved. The misting projecting roof sign is to he removed and a revised design is to he submitted to the Planning Department for further review. 5. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-054 547 Workman Ave. Chin -Yuan Chen Continued to .September 28 1993 AGENDA AnC.ADIA 1.11 Y MODIFICATION COMMFI . cE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 14,1993 A request for a 6' -0" high wrought iron fence with 7-0" high entry pilasters with 30" high lights mounted atop of the pillars in lieu of 4'-0" maximum. All the above are located within the front yard and driveway entrance (9283.8.7). Requesting an encroachment into the protected zone of two oak trees located along the easterly side property line as a result of the construction of an existing wood fence and the cutting of a neighboring oak tree at 49 Sycamore Ave. Requesting two 84 sq. ft. banners in lieu of the 32 sq. ft. maximum allowed for banner advertising and the time period to extend until November 1, 1993 in lieu of the maximum 30 cumulative days allowed (9262.4.13). Requesting a parking modification for 1 handicap and 4 compact parking spaces (there are 6 existing compact spaces) in lieu of 7.34 spaces to allow a 48 square foot front entrance expansion and facade remodel for a medical /dental office building (92695 & 9269.5.1). Requesting the following modifications: A. B . A 28' -0" front yard setback in lieu of the 35' 41" special front yard setback for new porch cover posts (9320.77.1). A 30' -0" front yard setback in lieu of the 35' -0" special front yard setback for a 429 sq. ft. two - bedroom and one bathroom addition to align with the existing 30' -0" front setback (9320.77.1). There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:03 p.m, Tuesday, September 21,1993 6. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -055 41 E. Live Oak Ave. Coast Sign Inc. for California Federal Bank Approved along with the ADR color scheme, Request "B" <hall not erreed a maximum height of .5' -0" 7. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -056 1235 Highland Oaks Dr. Dave Munushian Denied 8. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -057 670 Hampton Rd. Mr. & Mrs. Juan DeLeon Approved. with the condition that all building/rnof materials he those as presrrihed by the Santa Anita Oaks Home Owner's Association, 9. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -058 15 El Dorado St. Robert Guntenspergen for Mr. and Mrs. Bazin Conditionally approved. The design shall be revised to inclu•e the Modification Committee's suggestions and shall he Requesting the following modifications: 10. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-059 121 Alice St. Ben Lundgren for The Arcadia Presbyterian Church Conditionally apprnned. The property punter shall dedicate 15 font radius earner rut- ff for street and side:m lk purpntn and at proposed imrronements .than not encroach into the public right -of -way, COMMITTEE ME BERS PRESENT: Daggett, Feinberg, Nicholson PLANNING DEFt REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski, Kasama, Stokes A. To exceed the maximum area allowed by 1 square foot in lieu of the 25 square foot maximum allowed as a result of a proposed new front wall sign (9261.4.1). B. To permit a free standing sign within the special setback on Live Oak Ave. and in lieu of no free standing signs permitted in the C-0 zone (9320.50.2 & 9261.4.1). Requesting a 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of the required 10' -0" for a 24 sq. ft. bathroom addition (9252.2.4). Requesting a 3' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 15-0" required for a proposed storage shed (9251.2.4). Requesting the following modifications for a 538 sq. ft. two - story addition to a legal nonconforming single- family house in an R -3 zone. Section 9255.1.5.1 allows for up to 1,000 sq. ft. to be added with an approved modification. The R -1 regulations apply to such additions: A. A 5'4" west side setback for the 2nd floor in lieu of 109' -0" (9252.2.4). for romplianre B. A 22' -0" rear setback for both floors in lieu of 25-0" for the 1st floor and 35' -0" for the 2nd floor (9252.2.8). Requesting a modification to allow a monument sign with two changeable sign boards in lieu of no sign structures in an R -3 zone (9255.1.4). Modification Committee 9/14/93 Page 2 Continued to 9/14/93 Approved ■ 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-049 920 W. Orange Grove Donald & Sally Tapert 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-050 1801 S. Eighth Ave. Conrad Schlick 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-051 & TR 93-008 1115 W. Foothill Blvd. C.M. Carrasco AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITI EE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, AUGUST 24, 1993 Apprvoed witht he condition that that applicant comply with the conditions as set forth by the certified arborist on the necessary care and development around the subject oak tree affected by the proposed development. 0'01 ? j N 0 L A request for a 6-0" high wrought iron fence with 7-0" high entry pilasters with 30" high lights mounted atop of the pillars in lieu of 4' -0" maximum. All the above are located within the front yard and driveway entrance (9283.8.7). Requesting the following modifications: A. A 15' -0" rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0" required for a proposed addition to the existing main dwelling (9252.2.8.) B. A 5-6" side yard setback in lieu of 6' -9" required for the same proposed addition (9252.2.4.). Requesting the following modifications: A. A 6'-0" wrought iron fence with masonry pilasters within the front yard area in lieu of the 4' -0" maximum required (9283.8.7.). B. An Oak tree encroachment permit into the protected zone of two mature oak trees as a result of the proposed wrought iron fence and masonry pilasters (9704.b.1.). COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Amato, McIntyre, Nicholson PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski, Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 3:00 p.m., Tuesday, August 31, 1993 � 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-007 1235 Ramona Rd. Mladen & Dusanka Grbavac Approved with the condition that the applicant comply with all recommendations pertaining to the preservation of the tree, as outlined in the certified arborist report. 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-043 380 W. Camino Real Handah Int'1, Inc. Denied 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-044 109 S. First Ave. Todd Peterson Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-045 517 W. Las Tunas Dr. Tsai Chen Approved 5. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-046 239 Arbolada Dr. Designer Home 2010 Approved AGENDA A _ARIA L11 Y MODIFICATION COMMIT E 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, AUGUST 10, 1993 A request to encroach into the protected zone of a mature oak tree in the front yard, due to a proposed construction of a new two story single - family residence (9704.b.1). r x 99 L' � •..j e L - Li v Requesting the following modifications: A. A 13' -0" first floor easterly rear yard setback in lieu of 35-0" required. (9251.2.6.) 13. A 20' -0" second floor easterly rear yard setback in lieu of 35' -0" required (9251.2.6.). The above request was previously approved by the Modification Committee on February 11, 1992, however, the time period allowed to begin construction on the request has expired. A request for parking modification for 8 spaces in lieu of 22 required for an existing coffee bar and proposed nail salon (9269.5.) Requesting the following modifications: A. A 44.43% (555.33 sq. ft.) lot coverage within the required 25-0" rear yard in lieu of 25% (312.5 sq. ft.) for a 3 car garage. B. A 36.72% (3511.35 sq. ft.) Iot coverage in lieu of 35% (3346.875 sq. ft.) A request for a 42' -0" front setback in lieu of 54' -0" average front setback of the adjacent properties which is required for a proposed addition to the main dwelling (9252.2.2.) There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, Aueust 17,1993 0, 6. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-047 400 S. Baldwin Ave. Jeanie Hanks Van Amen for the Santa Anita Fashion Park Mall Approved with the condition that all the temporary signs be removed by October 1994. 7. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-048 320 E. Duarte Rd. Eric Cole Conditionally approved. The game room portion of the proposed accessory building shall be maintained as one large room. The property owner shall execute and record a covenant, in a form approved by the City Attorney, the specifies the usa of the accessory building. COMMI I I hE MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting the following temporary signs in lieu of the allowable real estate signs and temporary banners for the current expansion of the Santa Anita Fashion Park Mall (9262.4.10. & 9262.4.13.) A. Two 160 sq. ft. temporary free - standing signs. B. Six 32 sq. ft. rotating information free- standing signs. C. Four rotating direction free - standing signs varying in size from 6 to 32 sq. ft. Requesting a total accessory building floor area of 1,166 sq. ft. in lieu of a maximum of 665 sq. ft. for an existing 150 sq. ft. gazebo and a proposed 1,016 sq. ft. shop, bathroom, and game room. The maximum accessory building floor area allowed is 50% of the ground floor area of the main building (9252.2.11.) Amato, Feinberg and Nicholson Halminski, Kasama, Stokes MnriifiriHnn C'nmmiHaa 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-035 1030 S. Sixth Ave. Cletus Verlato Denied 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-041 17 Andrea Lane Thomas & Devote Bayless Approved. with the condition that the proposed fence be wrought iron (as opposed to chain link) and not exceed a height of 5-0" atop the existing pool deck area of he northerly property at 1845 N. Santa Anita Ave. The new wrought iron fencing shall match the existing wrought iron framework at the northerly property as well. 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-042 512 W. Duarte Rd. Our Savior Lutheran Church Approval of the proposed size, location and Sign Architectural Design Review color scheme. COMM). I I EE MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COM !TEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, JULY 27, 1993 Huang, McIntyre, Butler Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, August 3, 1993 1 0 ,PUP 2 i C OUNCIL 3.,., Request to construct an 800 sq. ft. detached four -car garage on a lot with two nonconforming single - family dwellings in the R -1 zone. The proposed four -car garage is to serve the two separate dwellings (9292.1.4.17c). Request a height of 11' -0" for a proposed fence along the northerly rear property line, in lieu of the 6' -0" maximum (9283.8.8.). NOTE: The subject property is on a lower elevation than the adjacent property to the rear (1845 N. Santa Anita Ave.) The proposed height is measured from the lowest adjacent grade, which accounts for the 11 foot height request. Request a free standing sign in the R -3 zone in lieu of no free standing sign permitted within 100 feet of residentially zoned property (9262.4.6.). 1. PUBLIC'HEARING NO. MC 93-036 1437 Caballero Rd. Jim Shearer Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-037 21 E. Huntington Dr. Virginia Dochnahl Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-038 426 Santa Cruz Rd. Mike Stewart Approved With the condition that a clinging vine subject to the Planning Department review be planted along the face of the wall facing the street side. 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-039 & TR 93-006 53 E. Orange Grove Ave. Ernest & Gunde Posey A. Approval of Request A and B. with the condition that the applicant comply with B. the conditions as set forth by the certified arborist on the necessary care and development around the subject oak tree. 5. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-040 619 S. First Ave. Dave Szany & Assoc. Approved AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, JULY 13, 1993 Requesting the following modifications: COMMA IhE MEMBERS PRESENT: Huang, McIntyre and Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski and Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, July 20, 1993 fill, j a i ic) COUNnn Requesting to retain an existing landscaped wood fence on the perimeter of a proposed tennis court in lieu of a masonry block wall (9256.3.7). Requesting 2 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 10 spaces for a proposed beauty salon (9269.5). Requesting a height of approximately 6' -0" in lieu of 4' -0" for a proposed solid masonry wall within the required side yard on the street side of a corner lot (9283.8.7). A 5' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" for the relocation of a proposed 560 sq. ft. detached two - garage (9252.2.4.). An Oak Tree Encroachment Permit, as a result of the proposed relocation of the garage, into the protected zone of a mature oak tree located on the rear property line (9704.b.1). Requesting 8 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 9.4 spaces for a proposed dental office (9269.5). 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-032 310 Whispering Pines Dr. Charles Bluth Approved. with the condition that the "full" staircase leading to the attic be changed to a "pull- down" staircase. 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -033 41 W. Arthur Ave. Hsiao Hau Chou Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-034 1822 Watson Dr. Ernie Lauria Denied AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMJTTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 22, 1993 COMMIT !EE MEMBERS PRESENT: Hedlund, Feinberg, Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Stokes TO JUN 2 4 1993 CCUNC9t_ Requesting the following building height modifications in lieu of the maximum height requirement of 35' -0" for a proposed two -story residence and 16-4' for the proposed detached garage in the R -M zone: A. A main dwelling roof height of 41' -3" (9250.3.1). B. A chimney height of 46-0" (9250.3.1). C. A garage height of 25'-6" in lieu of 16'4" allowed for accessory structures (9250.3.5). The request was previously approved by the Planning Commission on April 9, 1991, however, the time period allotted to commence construction has expired. Requesting a 6' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" for a proposed bedroom addition to be kept in line with the existing main dwelling (9252.2.4). Requesting a 20' -0" front setback in lieu of the 25' -0" standard front setback for a proposed single -story bedroom addition (9252.2.2). There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, June 29, 1993 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -029 701 S. Old Ranch Rd. Carlton & Marla Maese Denied 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-030 157 E. Camino Real Ave. Sin -Yu Chun Approved et 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-031 1201 Oaklawn Rd. Gary Jacobsen Approved subject to the following conditions: 1. Construction of a 4' -0" masonry wall extension with brick headers, to extend along the property line on Arbolada St. to the driveway. 2. A metal gate. painted to match the wall shall secure the opening to the trash bin. 3. fasmine or some other type of creeping vine shall be placed across the finished wall for landscape purposes. In addition, Podacarpus or other tall /fast growing shrubbery shall be provided adjacent to the southwesterly side property line. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 8,1993 COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Hedlund, Feinberg and Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski, Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, June 15, 1993 JU 9 0 CoUNCsa Requesting a 6' -0" high masonry block wall along the northerly side property line, in lieu of the 4' -0" maximum height within the street side setback of a reverse corner lot (9283.8.7). Requesting a height of 5' -8" in Lieu of the 4' -0" maximum for four light fixtures to be mounted on brick pillars (9283.8.7). Requesting a height of 6' -0" for masonry trash enclosure within the street front and side yard area in lieu of the 3' -0" to 4' -0" maximum height allowed (9283.8.7). 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -024 609 Estrella Ave. Mr. Ralph Chiechi Conditionally Approved. Approval is subject to the conditions listed in the Public Works Memorandum of 5/18/9, and t o t he condition that a landscape and irrigation plan for the street side of the wall be submitted for review and a..roval o the Plannin • 1 -, 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-025 Requesting the following modifications: 1332 S. Fourth Ave. Ms. Rose Murphy Conditionally approved subject to the applicant securing the necessary permits and inspections. Applicant shall pay the applicable penalties for having constructed the garage without the required p ermit s 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 - 026 2819 S. Bradford Ave. Jonathan Su Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 - 027 5511 N. Peck Rd. Andrew & Jeanette Hudig AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMI 1 1 LL 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 25, 1 993 MAY 2 7 1293 COUNCIL Requesting a height of 6' -0" in lieu of 4' -0" for a garden wall along the west street side property line (El Sereno Dr.) to enclose the backyard (9283.8.8). artm•nt. A. A 14' x 20' one -car garage for the legal non -co nforming rear house (9292.1.4.17.(c). B. A Conditionally Approved as follows: Request (A): The existing 85 sq. ft. wall sign shall be reduced to a maximum of 40 sq. ft. B Request (B): Approved as existing. The existing freestanding sign at the curb must be removed. A distance of 47' in lieu of 10' -0" between the new garage and the rear house (9252.2.11.) Requesting the following modifications for an addition: A. A 5' -0" northerly side yard setback in lieu of 6' -0" required for for a 33' -0" long single -story addition to be in line with B . A 5' -0" separation from the proposed addition and the existing garage in lieu of the 10'-0" minimum distance required between structures (9252.2.11.) Requesting the following modifications: • To permit an existing 85 sq. ft. wall sign in lieu of the 40 sq. ft. maximum allowed for signage area (9262.4.6.) To permit an existing canopy sign in lieu of no canopy signs allowed in the M -1 zone. There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Wednesday, June 2, 1993 5. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -028 665 -671 Naomi Ave. & 1310 -1326 S. Baldwin Ave. The Hale Corp. for Michael Fortanasce A. B. Conditionally approved as follows: 1. The conditions outlined in the 12/7/92 memo from the Public Works Department. 2. A covenant subject tothe review and approval of the City Attorney shall be executed by the owners toprovide mutual ingress and egress across their rear parking areas. 3. The parkin area shall be designed, striped and labeled in comsliance with the Arcadia Municipal Code, the accessibility requirements, and so that the utility poles do not interfere with any of the parkin aces aisles driveways or other ingress and egress areas. 4. Wheel stops or 6" high concrete curbing shall be provided for all parking spaces. 5. A masonry trash enclosure with solid metal gates shall be provided to adequately accommo- date a minimum of two (2) commercial bins. 6. Landscaping and irrigationplans as well as detailed construction plans shall be submitted for review and approval to the Plannine Depart- ment. Requesting the following parking modifications: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Daggett, McIntyre, Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Kasama, Stokes 64 parking spaces with 14 compact spaces in lieu of 65 spaces with 13 compact spaces for a 2,600 sq. ft. addition to a physical therapy office building (9269.5 & 9269.5.1). 19 parking spaces in lieu of the existing 21 spaces for the realignment of the parking area behind the businesses fro nting 1310 -1326 S. Baldwin Avenue (9269.5) Modification Committee 3/23/93 Page 2 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -021 1415 S. Tenth Ave. Bruce Olson Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -022 1015 Singingwood Dr. Yuho Nagata Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -023 2524 Lee Ave. Luis Nunez Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-005 1004 Singingwood Dr. Alfredo Jose Approved subject to the recommendations of the certified arborist. COMM I I Ih.E MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: AGENDA ACADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMM. . EE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 11, 1993 Hedlund, McIntyre, Butler Kasama, Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, May 18,1993 TO MAY 1 3 1933 Requesting the following modifications for an acciiQ>I-& a'( C 2 L single - family residence: A. A 32' -0" front setback in lieu of 35' -0" (9320.72.1). B. A 1' -0" encroachment into the required 6' -11" north side setback for a 5' -0" wide bay window (9252.2.4). Requesting the following height modifications in lieu of the 4' -0" maximum for an existing block wall and gate entrance in the front yard (9283.8.7). The existing wall heights were constructed without Planning Department's approval. A. A maximum height of 5' -2" to the top of two brick pillars in the foreground at the driveway entrance and a height of 6' -0" to the top of two brick pillars at the gate entrance. B. A height of 2' -1" for two light fixtures atop the pillars in the foreground and a height of 2' -7" for two light fixtures atop the pillars at the gate entrance, for maximum heights of 7 -3" and 8' -7 ". C. A maximum height of 5' -8" for the wrought iron gate entrance. D. A maximum height of 4' -3" for the mailbox at the curb. Requesting the following modifications for an addition: A. An 18' -0" rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0" required for a bay window area on the first floor. The existing rear yard setback on the first floor is 20' -0" (9252.2.2.8). B. A 20' -0" second floor rear yard setback in lieu of 35' -0" required for the proposed second floor addition to be kept in line with the first floor of the existing main dwelling (9252.2.8). Requesting the encroachment into the protected zone of two oak trees due to the proposed construction of a block wall along Dexter Ave. and Singingwood Dr. (9704.b.1). The proposed block wall was previously approved by the Rancho Santa Anita Homeowner's Association and the City of Arcadia. 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-004 1440 Carmelita Place Jao Eddie & Ching Shin Lee Approved with the condition that a fence be Dlaced around the tree during construction. Approved AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL 27, 1993 COMMIT 1 LE MEMBERS PRESENT: Amato, McIntyre, Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, May 4, 1993 APR 2 9 1993 COUNCIL Requesting the encroachment into the protected zone of a mature oak tree in the rear yard due to a proposed addition to the main dwelling (9704.b.1). 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-020 To permit a proposed 16' x 26' attached patio cover at the 1610 ErMonte Ave. northeast corner of the house which requires the following. The Paul & Leona Schreiner modifications: A. An 8' -0" north side setback in lieu of 13'-4" so that the patio cover can align with the house B . A 4 rear setback in lieu of 35' -0 ". The existing house has a 24' -0" rear setback. 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-001 925 Hampton Rd. Shirley Spencer 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-002 115 W. Sycamore Rd. Tom & Maria Spata APPLICATION WITHDRAWN BY APPLICANT 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. TR 93-003 1129 Fairview Ave. Melissa Chen COMMIT I'tE MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8 :15 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL 13,1993 Requesting the encroachment into the protected zone of two mature oak trees in the easterly side /rear yard, due to a proposed addition to the main dwelling (9704.b.1). Requesting the encroachment into the protected zone of nine mature oak trees around the perimeter of the property, due to the construction of a new block wall (9704.b.1). Requesting the encroachment into the protected zone of nine mature oak tree in the westerly side yard, due to the construction of a new block wall for a 10 -unit condominium project (9704.b.1). There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, April 20, 1993 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-014 182 W. Camino Real Ave. Gaetano D'Aquino Request 'A' was conditionally approved. The two foot area on the street side of the wall is to be landscaped and is subject to the approval of the Planning Department. Request 'B' was partially approved. A 3' -0" rear setback and a 5' -0" street side setback were approved for the equipment so that it can be located in the southwest comer of the property. The reduced setbacks for the gazebo were denied. Requests 'C' and 'D' were denied. 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 320 Armada Rd. David & Jane Strauss A. B. C. D. Approved subject to the condition that a covenant be filed with the City attorney stating the accessory building will not be used as a guest house. 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-016 1740 Holly Avenue Alfred Raine Approved AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 23,1993 Requesting tt. following modifications: 'ISO MAR 2 5 1993 COUNCIL A height of 6' -0" in lieu of 4' -0" for a stucco wall within the 25-0" special street side setback along El Monte Ave. (9251.2.5., 92818.7. & 9320.18.2.) Modifications for a spa with a gazebo style cover: 1) A 10' -0" street side setback in lieu of 25-0" for the spa and gazebo (9251.2.5. & 9320.18.2.) 2) A 5-0" rear setback in lieu of 10' -0" for the spa and gazebo (9251.2.8.2.) 3) A 3' -0" rear setback in lieu of 10' -0" for the spa heating and pumping equipment (9251.2.8.2.) A 5-0" rear setback in lieu of 10'-0" for four, 10' -0" high decorative columns (9251.2.8.2.) Approximately 990 sq. ft. (24.65%) of landscaping in the front yard in lieu of 2,007.5 sq. ft. (50 %) (9251.2.13.) Requesting a rear yard lot coverage of 28% (465 sq. ft.) in lieu of a 25% (406 sq. ft.) maximum for a proposed hobby and pottery room (9251.2.8.) Requesting the following modifications for a 17-6" tall, 18' x 40' (720 sq. ft.) recreational vehicle carport in the southeast corner of the property: A. Coverage of 960 sq. ft. (27.43%) of the required rear yard instead of 875 sq. ft. (25%) (9251.2.8.) B. A 17 -6" height in lieu of 16-0" (9251.2.8.) C. A 5' -0" easterly side setback in lieu of 10' -0" (9251.2.8.1. & 9251.2.4.). There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, March 30, 1993 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -017 875 Hugo Reid Dr. Paul & Liz Westphal Approved with the condition that the existing driveway is closed off. 5. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -018 26 E. Huntington Dr. S & D Investments Request 'A' was approved for a period of six months. Request 'B' was denied. lI 6. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -019 2119 Holly Ave. Peter Amundson Approved COMMIT 1.6E MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting a 5' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 7-6" required for a proposed 272 sq. ft. bathroom and walk -in closet addition to the rear of the house and a 225 sq. ft. bedroom addition to the front of the house (9252.2.4.). The proposed additions will align with the setback of the existing house. Requesting the following modifications for three vinyl "For Lease" signs in lieu of one non -vinyl sign with up to 4 sq. ft. per side (9263.4. & 9262.4.10.): A. Two 3' x 6' signs on the front marquee, and B . A 4' x 5' sign on the rear wall. Requesting a 20'-6" front yard setback for a proposed 487 sq. ft. bedroom and bathroom addition in lieu of 40' -0" required (9320.39.1.) The addition will align with the front of the existing house. Huang, Mdntyre and Butler Halminski, Kasama There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, March 30, 1993 Modification Committee 3/23/93 Page 2 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-012 615 N. Old Ranch Rd. Lynda G. Beckstrom Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-013 1004 Singingwood Dr. Alfredo Jose Approved" with the Rancho Santa Architecutrat Review Board's condition that the proposed wall be sloped down to a maximum height of 5' -0" at the existing driveway entrance. * If lights are to be attached, the ARB recommends a maximum wall height of 4'-6" and a lamp height of 1' -6 ". AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 9, 1993 COMMI I 1 EE MEMBERS PRESENT: Huang, McIntyre, Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Kasama and Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, March 16, 1993 TO MAR 1 1 1993 COUNCIL Requesting a height of 6' -0" in lieu of 4' -0" to extend a block wall within a special street side setback along Colorado Blvd. The wall will match the existing wall to the west that encloses the back yard (9251.25., 9283.8.8., & 9320.10.2). Requesting a height of 6' -0" for a block wall in lieu of 4' -0" maximum on the street side (Dexter Ave. ) of a corner lot. (9283.8.7.) 1. Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-009 2808 Winthrop Ave. Mr. Mong -Tung Li Denied 3. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93 -010 1051 Monte Verde Dr. Crosby Design & Construction for Robert Garrett Approved with the condition that a covenant be filed, securing that the structure will remain an accessory building (detached 2-car garage /pool recreation room) and not be converted to a guest hou 4. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-011 11500 Clark St. Wilfred Hsu for Clark- Goldring, Ltd. Approved PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-008 1009 N. Santa Anita Ave. Carol D'Egidio COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 23,1993 l Requesting 25 existing on -site parking spaces in lieu of 27 spaces required for a proposed 1,150 square foot mbrlicd office u4e within a retail center (Sec. 9269.5). Requesting the following modifications to convert an existing playroom into a guest house /accessory living quarters: A. B. C. D. TO FEB 2 5 1993 c3'JcIL Two bedrooms in lieu of one bedroom (9220.2.4). 715 gross square feet in lieu of 600 square feet (9220.2.8). Maintain the existing connection with a two -car garage in lieu of a freestanding guest house (9220.2.9.c). An existing 3' -0" north side setback in lieu of 6' -0" (9220.2.9.d). Requesting the following modification for a detached garage/ accessory building: A. A 5' -0" easterly side setback in lieu of 10' -0" required. B. 26% occupancy of the required rear yard area in lieu of 25% maximum for a proposed 910 square foot one -story detached garage /accessory building (maximum building square footage allowed in required rear yard area is 875 square feet) (9251.2.8). Requesting the following parking modifications for a new industrial project: A. 22 parking spaces in lieu of 23 (9269.5). B. A 3' -0" encroachment of one parking space into the 5' -0" wide on -site landscape planter at the corner of Clark and Kardashian Streets for a standard parking space in Lieu of a compact space (9269.13.13). Hedlund, McIntyre, Butler Halminski, Kasama, Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, March 2, 1993 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-007 160 W. Camino Real Ave. Wang Development & Construction for Mr. and Mrs. Chen Denied the 5 wrought iron gates. Approved the existing light fixtures on the 4' -0" block pillars for an overall height of 5'-6 ". COMMIE 1EE MEMBERS PRESENT: Hedlund, McIntyre, Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 9, 1993 Requesting a height modification of 5'-6" in lieu of 4' -0" for the the driveway gates and lights along the front property line. (Sec. 9283.8.7., 9283.8.8., 9314.3. & 9320.8.6.) There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Wednesday, February 17, 1993 1. PUBLIC HEARING NO. MC 93-006 600 -604 N. Santa Anita Avenue G E Busse, Architect for Stephen M. Lojeski and Charles & Ming H. Wu, et al AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 26, 1993 6) That the trash enclosure be secured with solid metal gates. COMMI1 L bE MEMBERS PRESENT: Daggett, McIntyre and Butler PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: Kasama There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, February 2, 1993 The following modifications for a new 2,500 sq. ft. one -story general office building and an 1,800 sq. ft. one -story dental office building: A) A 10' -0" front setback for both buildings in lieu of 35' -0" special setback along Santa Anita Avenue (9320.65.13.) B) A 15-0" southerly street side setback in lieu of the 25' -0" special setback along Newman Avenue and an additional 5' -0" encroachment for a 38' -0" long decorative entry cover for the dental office building (9320.57.7.) C) Nineteen on -site parking spaces to be available for both buildings in lieu of 21 spaces (9269.5.) D) A 3' -0" high freestanding monument sign in the C -O zone in lieu of no freestanding signs for the dental office building (9261.4.1.) ACTION: Conditionally approved. The conditions of approval are as follows: 1) That the parking lot be secured after business hours to prevent any unauthorized use of the parking lot. 2) That a reciprocal parking agreement, in a form approved by the City Attorney, be executed and recorded by the owners. 3) That there shall not ever be any vehicular access across the northerly property line of 604 N. Santa Anita Avenue from the adjacent commercial development(s) and that the landscaping and garden wall along the northerly property line be maintained in a manner consistent with the plans filed for this application. 4) That the landscaping for this proposed project be subject to review and approval by the Planning Department, and that any trees proposed and /or required for this project be a minimum size of 24" box trees. 5) That any lighting for the proposed parking lot be subject to review and approval by the Planning Department. 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-001 230 W. Camino Real Sam & Geraldine Rodgers Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93 -002 301 W. Huntington Dr. Cecilia A. Consiglio for Santa Anita Realty Ent., Inc. Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93 -003 352 E. Haven Ave. Ted Rigas Approved APPLICATION 7 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-005 106 W. Naomi Ave. Bill Molina Approved COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: PLANNING DEPT. REPRESENTATIVE: AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 8:15 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 12,1993 MODIFICATION REQLIEST(S) Requesting an 8' -0" westerly side setback in lieu of 10' -1" required for a proposed bathroom addition. The addition will not align with the existing setback (9252.2.4). Requesting a parking modification of 460 parking spaces with 21.3% (98 spaces) compact spaces in lieu of 493 spaces required with 20% (92 spaces) compact for a 3,228 sq ft , one -story radiation and oncology suite addition (9269.5., 9569.5.1. & 9276.2.11). A. Requesting a 3' -0" side yard setback in lieu of 5'-6" to add a one -car garage onto the west side of the house (9252.2.4). B. Requesting a height of 7-0" in Lieu of 3' -0" within the visibility area along the Fifth Avenue side yard to replace the existing wrought iron gates with solid wooden gates and replace the existing wrought iron fencing with solid concrete blocks (9283.8.7, 9283.8.8, 9314.3 & 9320.26.1). Conditionally approved: That there be no openings in the west wall of the new attached, one -car garage. That the replacement gates along Fifth Avenue either swing in toward the property or slide parallel with easterly property line. The new gates are not to swing out toward the street That a guest house covenant, in a form approved by the City Attorney, be executed and recorded by the owners prior to the issuance of any permits for the garage addition and the replacement of the gates and fencing_ 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 93-004 Requesting the following modifications: 648 Estrella Ave. John Wong A. A 5-0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of T-6" for an addition to match the existing setback (9252.2.4). B. Front bay windows to encroach 18" into the 30' -0" special setback along Estrella Ave. (9320.23.2). Requesting a 4' -9" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 6' -0" for a proposed addition to the rear of the house. The addition will align with the existing setback (9252.2.4). Daggett, McIntyre, Woolard Kasama, Stokes There is a five working day appeal period. Appeals for the above applications should be filed by 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, January 19, 1993