HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 3a & c: Minutes: November 1 & 15, 2011 53:0186
CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 2011
CALL TO ORDER - Mayor Kovacic called the meeting to order at 5:00 p.m.
ROLL CALL OF CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY MEMBERS:
PRESENT: Council/Agency Member Amundson, Chandler, Harbicht, Segal and Kovacic
ABSENT: None
STUDY SESSION/CLOSED SESSION PUBLIC COMMENTS
CLOSED SESSION
a. Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(a) to confer with legal counsel
regarding the case of Youniian ("Richard") Zhang, an individual and Ruxia ("Nancy")
Lianq, an individual v. City of Arcadia, et al. (Los Angeles County (Pasadena)
Superior Court Case No. GC047929.
b. Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(b)(1) to confer with legal counsel
regarding anticipated litigation —two (2) cases.
STUDY SESSION
a. Report, discussion and direction regarding a Text Amendment to create a single
resolution for Development Standards, Design Guidelines and Design review
processes for all five of the City-designated Homeowners' Associations.
Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager/Development Services Director reported that Study
Sessions were held on July 19, 2011 and September 20, 2011 to review and discuss a Text
Amendment to create a single resolution for Development Standards, Design Guidelines and
Design review processes for all five City designated Homeowners' Associations (HOAs); and that
after hearing comments from staff, the Homeowners Association and Architectural Board Members,
the City Council directed staff to finalize the resolution and bring it back to a future meeting for City
Council adoption.
Mayor Kovacic adjourned the Study Session at 7:05 p.m.
THE CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY CONVENED TO OPEN SESSION
Mayor/Agency Chair Kovacic called the regular meeting to order at 7:10 p.m.
INVOCATION — Reverend John Payton, Point Loma Nazarene University
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE — Joel Chen, Arcadia High School Marching Band
ROLL CALL OF CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY MEMBERS:
PRESENT: Council/Agency Member Amundson, Chandler, Harbicht, Segal and Kovacic
ABSENT: None
11-01-11
53:0187
REPORT FROM CITY ATTORNEY/AGENCY COUNSEL ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
City Attorney Deitsch reported that prior to the regular meeting, the City Council met in a Closed
Session to consider the two (2) items listed on the posted agenda, no reportable action was taken.
In addition, Mr. Deitsch reported that the City Council met in a Study Session to hear a report from
staff and discuss a proposed Text Amendment to create a single resolution for development
standards, design guidelines and design review processes for all five of the City-designated
Homeowners' Associations; and that after hearing comments, the City Council directed staff to
finalize the resolution and bring it back at a future meeting for City Council adoption.
SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FROM CITY MANAGER/EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
REGARDING AGENDA ITEMS - Mr. Penman announced there was no supplemental information.
MOTION TO READ ALL ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS BY TITLE ONLY AND WAIVE THE
READING IN FULL
A motion was made by Council Member Chandler, seconded by Council Member Segal to read all
ordinances and resolutions by title only and waive the reading in full.
PRESENTATIONS
a. Presentation of Commendation to Reverend John Payton, Point Loma Nazarene
University.
b. Presentation of Proclamation to the 2011 Arcadia Festival of Bands Chairperson
Betsy Burcham.
c. Presentation of Certificate to Arcadia residents Claire Liu and Sarah Liu for their
musical accomplishments.
1. PUBLIC HEARINGS
a. Consideration of General Plan Amendment No. GPA 11-02 and Zone Change No.
ZC 11-01 for 650 West Huntington Drive.
Adopt Resolution No. 6799 approving General Plan Amendment No. GPA 11-02 to
change the General Plan Land Use Designation of the property at 650 West
Huntington Drive from "Commercial (0.5 FAR)" to "High Density Residential (12-30
DU/AC)".
Recommended Action: Adopt
Introduce Ordinance No. 2291 approving Zone Change No. ZC 11-01 to change the
zoning of the property at 650 West Huntington Drive from "Commercial Office/C-0"
to "High Density Multiple-Family Residential/R-3".
Recommended Action: Introduce
Jim Kasama, Community Development Administrator reported that the applicant is requesting a
General Plan Amendment to change the Land Use Designation of the site from Commercial with a
floor-area-ratio of 0.5 to High Density Residential with a density of 12 to 30 dwelling units per acre
and a Zone Change to re-zone the property from Commercial Office to High Density Multiple Family
11-01-11
53:0188
Residential at 650 W. Huntington Drive; he explained that in 2006, a 76-unit senior housing project
was approved, but due to the recession, the owner abandoned the project and in April 2011, the
applicant received approval from the Planning Commission to expand the existing office building
and subdivide it into medical office condominiums; that the applicant and owner decided that a
multiple-family residential would be the best use of the site; that the owner feels the site is a
desirable residential location because of the close proximity to the mall, Methodist Hospital, the
County Park and Arcadia High School; that Development Services staff recommends approval of
the requested General Plan Amendment and Zone Change.
Mayor Kovacic announced for the record that a letter dated October 31, 2011 from Annick J.
Downhower and a letter dated November 1, 2011 from Molly Robbins were received regarding this
item.
Mayor Kovacic opened the public hearing.
Scott Young, part-owner of 650 W. Huntington Drive appeared and provided background
information regarding the property and the project.
A motion to close the public hearing was made by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council
Member Amundson and seeing no further objection, Mayor Kovacic declared the public hearing
closed.
It was moved by Council Member Chandler, seconded by Council Member Amundson and carried
on roll call vote to adopt Resolution No. 6799 approving General Plan Amendment No. GPA 11-02
to change the General Plan Land Use Designation of the property at 650 West Huntington Drive
from "Commercial (0.5 FAR)" to "High Density Residential (12-30 DU/AC)".
AYES: Council Member Chandler, Amundson, Harbicht, Segal and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
It was moved by Council Member Chandler, seconded by Council Member Segal and carried on roll
call vote to introduce Ordinance No. 2291 approving Zone Change No. ZC 11-01 to change the
zoning of the property at 650 West Huntington Drive from "Commercial Office/C-O" to "High Density
Multiple-Family Residential/R-3".
AYES: Council Member Chandler, Segal, Amundson, Harbicht, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
b. Consideration of Special Use Permit No. SUP 11-01 to allow Circus Vargas in the
southwest parking lot of Santa Anita Park with performance from November 24
through December 5, 2011.
Recommended Action: Approve with conditions
Jim Kasama, Community Development Administrator reported that an application was filled by Mr.
Landon, a representative from Circus Vargas to allow a circus with entertainment, lighting and
music inside a 147 foot diameter big top tent in the southwest parking lot area of Santa Anita Park
for eleven (11) days beginning November 24, 2011 through December 5, 2011 with 20
performances; he indicated that there will be no animal acts, games of chance, or mechanical rides
and alcohol will not be sold or served; that Circus Vargas will provide security and restroom trailers
11-01-11
53:0189
and that parking will be handled by Santa Anita Park; he stated that the applicant does not plan on
putting up signs but instead will advertise on the radio, in local newspapers, through the internet, on
television and at local businesses; and that staff recommends approval of the Special Use Permit
subject to the conditions of approval listed in the staff report.
Mayor Kovacic opened the public hearing.
Mr. Landon, a representative of Circus Vargas appeared and addressed City Council concerns.
A motion to close the public hearing was made by Council Member Chandler, seconded by Council
Member Harbicht and seeing no further objection, Mayor Kovacic declared the public hearing
closed.
It was moved by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council Member Chandler and carried on roll
call vote to approve Special Use Permit No. SUP 11-01, subject to staffs conditions of approval.
AYES: Council Member Segal, Chandler, Amundson, Harbicht and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Scott Hettrick, Executive Director of the Chamber of Commerce appeared and commended the
School District and the Police Department regarding the lock down at High School today; he
congratulated Methodist Hospital and Council Member Segal on a very successful Crystal Ball
Event; he commended the Historical Society on the tribute to the writer of the Arcadia High School
fight song; he announced the upcoming High School play "39 Steps" coming up in a couple of
weeks and provided information on other upcoming events and activities around the community.
At the request of Mayor Kovacic, Police Chief Guthrie provided a report and update regarding the
lock down at Arcadia High School and Holly Avenue Elementary School earlier today.
REPORTS FROM THE CITY COUNCIL AND CITY CLERK
Council Member Chandler had nothing to report.
Council Member Segal thanked all the residents and everyone who attending the Crystal Ball on
Saturday night; and he announced that a net $500,000 was raised for the Hospital's Emergency
Department.
Council Member Amundson thanked the Fire and Police Departments for all they do; and
announced Veteran's Day on November 11th and thanked all the Veterans.
Mayor Pro Tem Harbicht commented on the Crystal Ball event and congratulated Mr. Segal on a
successful event; he congratulated Chief Guthrie and the Police Department on their efforts today
and everyday; he commented on the fires last week which were contained and well managed.
Mayor Pro Tern Harbicht noted that a few months ago he suggested a study session to discuss
what would be involved in building a new City Hall including what options were available for
financing; he recalled that about 4 years ago, the City Council approved moving forward with the
design and working drawings of a new City Hall and noted that a significant amount of money was
spent on those drawings; he requested two more Council Members support his request to have
11-01-11
53:0190
staff provide a brief report showing what the estimated cost was of building a new City Hall at the
time the City Council approved building a new City Hall; and what the estimated cost would be to
build a new City Hall today; he commented that the gymnasium was approximately $1.5 million
under estimate; and that the resurfacing of the City Hall soccer field was significantly under
estimate; he indicated that construction today is 10% to 20% less than it was 4 to 5 years ago; he
also requested information on what the cost of the bonds would have been then including the
interest the City would have had to pay to repay it and an estimate of what the cost of the bonds
would be today since interest rates are lower to see if it would be worth studying the issue and
exploring various options. Council Member Segal and Mayor Kovacic concurred.
At the request of Mr. Penman, Mayor Pro tern Harbicht clarified that a memo be distributed only to
the City Council for their review and they will decide if they would like to agendize it at a later date.
City Clerk Barrows also thanked Police Chief Guthrie and Fire Chief Trabbie for all their
departments do; he congratulated Reverend Payton on his retirement; he provided information on
the Festival of Bands and announced that Betsy Burcham is the Chairperson of the Festival of
Bands; and he provided some personal comments about Joel Chen.
Mayor Kovacic also complimented police and fire for all they do especially in the last couple of
weeks and today with the lockdown at the two schools; he congratulated Council Member Segal on
the role he played in planning the Crystal Ball and also congratulated the honorees Mr. & Mrs.
Whittman; he announced Coffee with the Mayor on November 4 at the Community Center and
invited everyone to attend; and announced the Arcadia Interfaith Action Group Thanksgiving
Service on November 21 at 7:00 p.m. at Holy Angels Catholic Church; the Festival of Bands on
November 19th; a Veterans Day celebration at the Community Center on November 8th at 11:30
a.m.; and the Historical Society celebrated Tony Antista who composed and wrote the Arcadia High
School fight song and Beautiful Santa Anita and stated that the Arcadia High School Pep Band
made a special appearance.
2. CONSENT CALENDAR
CITY COUNCIL ITEMS:
a. Approve the Regular Meeting Minutes of October 18, 2011.
Recommended Action: Approve
b. Authorize and direct the City Manager to execute a one (1) year extension to the
Professional Services Agreement between the City of Arcadia and the Ferguson
Group for Federal Legislative Advocacy Services in the amount of$65,000.
Recommended Action: Approve
c. Approve street closures for the 58th Annual Festival of Bands on Saturday,
November 19, 2011.
Recommended Action: Approve
d. Approve the purchase of computer equipment and related peripherals in accordance
with the City's Computer Replacement Program.
Recommended Action: Approve
11-01-11
53:0191
e. Reject the low bid from Pro Tech Engineering, the apparent low bidder, due to a
nonresponsive bid; and authorize and direct the City Manager to execute a contract
to the next lowest responsible bidder, Flatiron Electric Group, Inc. for construction of
the Fiber Optic Connections to City facilities in the amount of$71,590 and approve a
10% contingency.
Recommended Action: Approve
f. Award a purchase order contract to Rotolo Chevrolet for the purchase of two (2)
Chevrolet pickup trucks in the amount of$47,613.
Recommended Action: Approve
g. Authorize and direct the City Manager to execute a Legal Services Agreement
between the City and the City's defense attorney firm, Carpenter Rothans and
Dumont regarding a rate increase.
Recommended Action: Approve
Mayor Pro Tern Harbicht requested Consent Calendar Item 2.e be pulled for separate discussion.
It was moved by Council Member Harbicht, seconded by Council Member Amundson and carried
on roll call vote to approve Consent Calendar items 2.a through 2.d and 2f and 2.g.
AYES: Council Member Harbicht, Amundson, Chandler, Segal and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
In response to a question by Mayor Pro Tern Harbicht regarding Consent Calendar Item 2.e, Phil
Wray, City Engineer responded that the project bid documents required a Class "A" Contractor's
License; that Pro Tech Engineering only had a Class "C" License; and that all other bidder's had the
required Class "A" Contractor's license.
It was moved by Council Member Harbicht, seconded by Council Member Chandler and carried on
roll call vote to approve Consent Calendar items 2.e.
AYES: Council Member Harbicht, Chandler, Amundson, Segal and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
CITY MANAGER/EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR ITEMS
a. Report, discussion and consideration of policy regarding property address changes.
Recommended Action: Provide direction
Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager/Development Services Director reported that back in
March 2011, the City Council requested a report regarding the City's policy on address changes;
that Study Sessions were held in May and June 2011 and copies of those staff reports were
included as part of the agenda; he provided a brief report of the May and June meetings and City
Council direction at those meetings; he noted that at the City Council meetings of September 6 and
20, residents and local realtors appeared requesting the City Council reconsider the City's policy of
not allowing homeowners to change their addresses; that staff went back and reviewed the fee
originally proposed to cover the City's cost of processing an address change and now recommends
11-01-11
53:0192
a fee of up to $2,250 based on a much more comprehensive look at the overhead costs based on
different department's review of the project.
Barbara Birney, an Arcadia resident appeared and encouraged the City Council to reinstate the
address change policy; she stated that her husband was recently placed in a skilled nursing facility
and they are now faced with selling their home and because their address is "44" it could cost them
up to $100,000.
Jeff Bowen, an Arcadia resident and local realtor appeared and stated that buyers are sensitive to
the address with the number"4" as it adversely affects the selling price; and feels that the seller be
allowed to change the address, for a fee, to accommodate the removal of the number "4"; and he
encouraged the City Council to reinstate the address change policy.
It was moved by Council Member Harbicht, seconded by Council Member Segal and carried on roll
call vote to table the City's policy related to address changes, until such time as proof is submitted
where the number"4" has affected the selling price of a home.
AYES: Council Member Harbicht, Segal, Amundson, Chandler and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
b. Approve the Relocation Plan for the North Santa Anita Properties, a budget
allocation for the remaining relocation cases and to secure the site once relocation is
complete, and of lease terms for 33 and 37 West Huntington Drive (the Self Storage
Building) to relocate tenants from the North Santa Anita Properties.
Recommended Action: Approve
Jerry Schwartz, Economic Development Manager reported that in August 2010, the Redevelopment
Agency purchased two commercial buildings at 101-111 and 121-159 North Santa Anita Avenue;
and on April 5, 2011,. the Agency approved a contract with Overland Pacific & Cutter ("OPC") to
oversee the relocation of the tenants in these two buildings; he advised that with the restrictions
placed on the Agency by current law regarding Redevelopment, Agency action is important to allow
the relocation process to continue; he advised that some tenants have chosen to move to other
locations in Arcadia; that no tenants have been forced to move; that OPC has followed the typical
relocation process for the tenants that have moved, providing them with assistance with their move
and making sure they received relocation benefits that are appropriate and lawful; that before the
Agency can start the process to force the remaining tenants to move by issuing 90 day notices, the
Agency must approve a Relocation Plan for the properties; he reported that the 2011-2012 Agency
budget included $80,000 for the relocation of the tenants; that approximately $77,500 has been
spent to date and that OPC has estimated the cost to relocate the remaining tenants is $400,000.
He further reported that once the building is vacant, the site will be fenced to keep it free from
vagrants and vandalism and requested a budget allocation of $2,600 from Agency reserves; that
the funding for asbestos removal and demolition of the two buildings is in the approved 2011-12
CIP budget; that several tenants are interested in moving into the Arcadia Self Storage building
which is owned by the Agency; he discussed the lease terms for both sites; and advised that the
total cost for relocation and fence rental is estimated at$402,600.
11-01-11
53:0193
It was moved by Agency Member Segal, seconded by Agency Member Harbicht and carried on roll
call vote to approve the Relocation Plan for the tenants at 101-111 and 121-159 North Santa Anita
Avenue; the budget allocation for the remaining relocation cases and to secure the site once
relocation is complete; and the lease terms for 33 and 37 West Huntington Drive (the Self Storage
Building) to relocate tenants from the North Santa Anita properties.
AYES: Agency Member Segal, Harbicht, Amundson, Chandler and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ADJOURNMENT
The City Council/Redevelopment Agency adjourned this meeting at 9:10 p.m. to Tuesday,
November 15, 2011, 5:30 p.m. in the City Council Chamber Conference Room located at 240 W.
Huntington Drive, Arcadia.
James H. Barrows, City Clerk
By:
Lisa Mussenden
Chief Deputy City Clerk/Records Manager
11-01-11
53:0194
CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 2011
CALL TO ORDER- Mayor Kovacic called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
ROLL CALL OF CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY MEMBERS:
PRESENT: Council/Agency Member Amundson, Chandler, Harbicht, Segal and Kovacic
ABSENT: None
STUDY SESSION/CLOSED SESSION PUBLIC COMMENTS
CLOSED SESSION
a. Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(a) to meet with legal counsel
regarding the Claim of Houji Zhang.
STUDY SESSION
a. Report from Arcadia Downtown Business Association concerning establishing a
Property Based Business Improvement District (PBID).
Jerry Schwartz, Economic Development Manager provided a report regarding the Arcadia
Downtown Business Association (ADBA) establishing a Property Based Business Improvement
District (PBID); he reported that on January 18, 2011, the ADBA requested Agency assistance to
hire a consultant to guide their group; that on February 15, 2011, staff presented some options to
fund different phases of the downtown consulting work and on March 15, 2011, the Agency
approved a contract with Urban Place Consulting to work with the ADBA to help them understand
some of the strengths of the downtown and areas for growth and improvement. He indicated that
the consultant distributed a survey about the downtown, assisted them with creating a non-profit
status, developed a logo and website for the ADBA and assisted the ADBA in recognizing some of
the potential advantages of a Business Improvement District; the ADBA invited and meet with
representatives of other downtown areas to discuss their experiences with their downtown
organizations; the ADBA voted to pursue a Property-Based Business Improvement District (PBID)
for downtown Arcadia and explained the process of forming a PBID; he advised that the Urban
Place Consulting contract does not include guiding the ADBA through the PBID process; and noted
that if the Agency wanted to provide redevelopment funds for the PBID process, it would require a
new contract; however he explained that a new contract could not be completed at this time with the
temporary limits placed on activities by redevelopment law until the State Supreme Court makes a
decision on two Redevelopment Bills by mid-January of 2012. He advised that staff could request
bids from consultants to work with the ADBA on the PBID process so that a recommendation can
be placed on a future agenda once the ruling on redevelopment law is made, if directed by the City
Council; he mentioned that the formation of a PBID could take approximately 8 months to complete
and is expected to cost between $50,000—70,000.
Matt McSweeny, owner of Matt Denny's reported on how the ADBA Mission Statement and Core
Group was created; he stated that Urban Place Consulting prepared a report including their own
evaluation of the downtown and the benefits of a PBID and the timing process, including a
downtown map showing ADBA's proposed boundaries; he discussed ideas for marketing the area
as more businesses come in due to the Gold Line; and briefly explained the reasons why the ADBA
11-15-11
53:0195
needs financial assistance from the City/Agency; he indicated that an annual budget of
approximately $200,000 is needed to fund the programs and activities that Downtown Arcadia
needs.
A representative of Urban Place Consulting was present to answer questions; he also indicated that
a Business Improvement District (BID) would help improve the economic vitality of the area by
receiving annual mandatory assessments from business or property owners and the BID was
explained.
It was moved by Council/Agency Member Harbicht, seconded by Council/Agency Member Segal
and carried on roll call vote to approve the cost of funding the formation of the BID; and directed staff
to proceed with an RFP with the understating that final approval is subject to the court's ruling on
redevelopment law.
AYES: Council/Agency Member Harbicht, Segal, Chandler, Amundson, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
b. Report, discussion and direction regarding Downtown Parking Study Status
Report.
Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager/Development Services Director reported that in March
2011, the City approved a Professional Services Agreement with Walker Parking Consultants for a
Downtown Parking Study; and that Walker Parking in coordination with Development Services staff
conducted field surveys, an online user preference survey, two downtown community meetings and
a preliminary parking analysis.
Linda Hui, Transportation Services Manager reported that in March 2011, the City Council approved
a professional services agreement with Walker Parking Consultants to conduct a parking study in
the downtown; she indicated that Walker Parking Consultants in coordination with the Development
Services Department staff conducted field surveys, an online user preference survey, two
downtown community meetings and a preliminary parking analysis; she provided the City Council a
report concerning the status of the parking study.
The City Council unanimously directed staff to continue working on the downtown parking study and
report back on any additional parking options for the downtown business area.
Mayor Kovacic adjourned the Study Session at 6:45 p.m.
THE CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY CONVENED TO OPEN SESSION
Mayor/Agency Chair Kovacic called the regular meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
INVOCATION — Reverend Julie Bryant, Arcadia Episcopal Church of the Transfiguration
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE — Police Volunteer Vince Foley
ROLL CALL OF CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY MEMBERS:
PRESENT: Council/Agency Member Amundson, Chandler, Harbicht, Segal and Kovacic
ABSENT: None
11-15-11
53:0196
REPORT FROM CITY ATTORNEY/AGENCY COUNSEL ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
City Attorney Deitsch reported that prior to the regular meeting, the City Council met in a Closed
Session to consider the one (1) item listed on the posted agenda, no reportable action was taken.
In addition, Mr. Deitsch reported that the City Council met in a Study Session to hear a report from
the Arcadia Downtown Business Association concerning establishing a Property Based Business
Improvement District (PBID) and on motion by Council Member Harbicht, seconded by Council
Member Segal, the City Council unanimously endorsed in principal efforts to establish a Property
Based Business Improvement District in the downtown business area and authorize City staff to
assist with initial tasks to establish the improvement district; and the second study session item
related to a report, discussion and direction regarding the downtown parking study update; he
reported that in March 2011, the City Council approved a professional services agreement with
Walker Parking Consultants for a downtown parking study; that the parking study is well underway,
Walker Parking Consultants in coordination with the Development Services Department staff have
conducted field surveys, an online user preference survey, two downtown community meetings and
a preliminary parking analysis; the Council received a report from City staff concerning the status of
the parking study and staff will report to the City Council in the future on additional parking options
for the downtown business area.
SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FROM CITY MANAGER/EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
REGARDING AGENDA ITEMS - Mr. Penman stated there were no supplemental reports.
MOTION TO READ ALL ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS BY TITLE ONLY AND WAIVE THE
READING IN FULL
A motion was made by Council Member Chandler, seconded by Council Member Segal to read all
ordinances and resolutions by title only and waive the reading in full.
PRESENTATIONS
a. Presentation of "Believe in Arcadia... Volunteer!" Award to the Arcadia Police
Department Volunteers.
1. PUBLIC HEARINGS
a. Appeal of the Planning Commission denial of Healthy Oak Tree Removal Application
No. TRH 11-05 to remove two Coast Live Oak trees that are located on the common
rear property line of 130 West Longden Avenue and 123 West Birchcroft Street
based on the residents' allergy to Oak trees.
Recommended Action: Conditional approval
Jim Kasama, Community Development Administrator reported that the owner and resident of 130
W. Longden Avenue, Mrs. Linda Lee filed an application to remove two healthy Coast Live Oak
trees located in the common rear property line with 123 W. Birchcroft Street because her two young
sons are highly allergic to the Oak trees; and that the neighbors at 123 W. Birchcroft Street have
consented to the removal of the trees; he indicated that Mrs. Lee purchased the property in March
2011 and at that time was not aware that her sons had allergies; that the applicant provided test
results which showed they were both severally allergic to Oak trees; and noted that the application
included a letter from a certified arborist which staff contacted and photographs of the trees. Mr.
11-15-11
53:0197
Kasama advised that the photographs were unacceptable and that allergies are not considered a
hazard for Oak tree removal purposes and based on the arborist's report and the application was
denied; the Modification Commission expressed concerns that this case could have policy setting
implications because of the applicant's reasons for the removal of the Oak trees and voted 3-0 to
refer it to the Planning Commission and the Planning Commission voted 4-0 (one Commissioner
absent) to deny the application; Mayor Pro Tem Harbicht appealed the Planning Commission's
decision because of the potential precedent setting implications of the application.
Mayor Kovacic opened the public hearing.
The applicant Mrs. Linda Lee appeared and provided photographs showing the allergic reactions
the Oak trees have caused her children and urged the City Council to allow her to remove the Oak
trees on her property.
Jerry Pearson appeared and spoke in opposition of allowing the removal of the Oak trees and feels
that a precedent will be set and expressed that cutting down the trees will not solve the allergy
problem.
Betsy Caputo appeared and also spoke in opposition of allowing the removal of the Oak trees and
feels that cutting down the trees will not solve the allergy problem.
Richard Larson appeared and commented on the oak tree on the property and felt that if the oak
tree is infected, it should be removed.
A motion to close the public hearing was made by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council
Member Harbicht and seeing no further objection, Mayor Kovacic declared the public hearing
closed.
It was moved by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council Member Chandler and carried on roll
call vote to approve Healthy Oak Tree Removal Application No. TRH 11-05 based on staff's
conditions of approval, which included the location of the trees as problematic and the condition of
the trees based on prior trimming; but not based on the health issues of the residents.
AYES: Council Member Segal, Chandler, Amundson, Harbicht, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Nicole Reed, President of PTA at Highland Oaks Elementary School provided a report and
highlights on various and upcoming activities at Highland Oaks and definitions of THANKS as it
relates to the school and community; she thanked Detective Ashby who spoke to the 5th graders
during Red Ribbon Week about the dangers of smoking, alcohol and drugs.
Paul Snyder an Arcadia resident appeared and complained about a business that he feels is
performing abortions and urged the City Council to help move this business out of Arcadia.
REPORTS FROM THE CITY COUNCIL AND CITY CLERK
Council Member Chandler wished everyone a happy and safe Thanksgiving.
11-15-11
53:0198
Council Member Segal reminded everyone that Saturday is Arcadia's Festival of Bands and
encouraged everyone to attend; he wished everyone a Happy Thanksgiving; and announced that
Arcadia Beautiful Commission will be judging holiday awards on December 8, 2011 and residents
should contact the City Manager's office to nominate a property.
Council Member Amundson announced Breakfast with Santa on December 3; he thanked the
Arcadia Police Volunteers for all they do; he noted the different services and discounts Waste
Management provides to Arcadia residents; he thanked Mr. Snyder for bringing his concerns to the
City Council's attention; and wished everyone a Happy Thanksgiving.
Mayor Pro Tem Harbicht announced that tonight is the opening night of the "39 Steps" play at the
Arcadia Theatre and encouraged everyone to attend.
City Clerk Barrows announced the Festival of Bands on Saturday and provided information
regarding closed streets and traffic; he thanked the City Council for recognizing the Arcadia Police
Volunteers; he congratulated Captain Paul Foley, Captain Larry Goodman, Lt. Mike Castro and Sgt.
John Bonomo on their recent promotions; he provided an update of Arcadia High School Football
games and statistics; he wished everyone a Happy Thanksgiving and announced his personal
thanks.
Mayor Kovacic complimented Chief Guthrie and the City Manager Don Penman for the promotional
ceremony that took place earlier in the day; he encouraged everyone to attend the Thanksgiving-
services by Arcadia Interfaith Church at Holy Angels Church on Monday; he wished everyone a
Happy Thanksgiving and announced his personal thanks.
2. CONSENT CALENDAR
CITY COUNCIL ITEMS:
a. Adopt Resolution No. 6800 authorizing submittal of the FY 2011-2012 Transportation
Development Act—Article 4 Claim Forms to receive Capital and Operation Funds for
Arcadia Transit.
Recommended Action: Adopt
b. Adopt Ordinance No. 2291 approving Zone Change No. ZC 11-01 to change the
zoning of the property at 650 West Huntington Drive from "Commercial Office/C-0"
to "High Density Multiple-Family Residential/R-3".
Recommended Action: Adopt
c. Authorize the City Manager to execute a one (1) year contract extension with J & S
Striping for Street Striping and Pavement Marking Services in the amount of
$85,092.
Recommended Action: Approve
d. Accept all work performed by J A Salazar Construction & Supply Corp. for
Installation of the Pressure Reducing Station from Zone 2 to Zone 2A proiect as
complete and authorize the final payment to be made in accordance with the contract
documents.
Recommended Action: Approve
11-15-11
53:0199
e. Accept all work performed by Parc Specialty Contractors, Inc. for the Lead Paint
Abatement and Painting of the Sierra Madre Boulevard Bridge over the Sierra Madre
Wash as complete and authorize the final payment to be made in accordance with
the contract documents.
Recommended Action: Approve
It was moved by Council Member Amundson, seconded by Council Member Segal and carried on
roll call vote to approve Consent Calendar items 2.a through 2.e.
AYES: Council Member Amundson, Segal, Chandler, Harbicht, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
CITY MANAGER/EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR ITEMS
a. Accept a donation of a bronze statue of Lucky Baldwin from Margaux Viera; approve
the location where said statue would be installed; approve the use of City funds to
pay for the project; direct staff to pursue the creation of a pedestal, dedication plague
and associated landscaping and lighting; authorize the City Manager to execute an
Agreement on the City's behalf with Ms. Viera outlining the responsibilities of each
party concerning this project.
Recommended Action: Approve
Linda Garcia, Communications, Marketing and Special Projects Manager reported that Margaux
Viera, the great, great, great granddaughter of Lucky Baldwin has proposed donating a 9' tall cast in
solid bronze statue of Lucky Baldwin for display on public property; she provided detailed
information regarding the proposed 9' tall statute, the pedestal, the proposed location as the Rose
Garden, security for the statute, cost and the schedule; and noted that the artist Mrs. Viera selected
is Alfred Parades. She indicated that in 2005 a trust fund was established with $25,000 from
Westfield to be used specifically for"public art"; and that once details of the project are in place, a
more specific cost estimate will be available; and advised that the total cost may exceed the
$25,000 available in the trust fund and any additional money will come from the General Fund or
the Capital Outlay Fund.
It was moved by Council Member Chandler, seconded by Council Member Segal and carried on roll
call vote to move forward with the project; and approved spending no more than $25,000 on the
project.
AYES: Council Member Chandler, Segal, Amundson, Harbicht, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
b. Consideration of a Five Year Lease with the Arcadia Chamber of Commerce for City-
owned property at 388 West Huntington Drive.
Recommended Action: Approve
Jerry Schwartz, Economic Development Manager reported that the current five year lease with the
Arcadia Chamber of Commerce for City owned property at 388 West Huntington Drive expires on
December 3, 2011; that the lease rate is $400 per month or$4,800 per year and will continue at the
same rate; that in exchange for the reduced rent rate, the Chamber provides a number of general
11-15-11
53:0200
services that benefit the Arcadia business community and community at large; and recommended
renewal of the five year lease with the same terms.
It was moved by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council Member Harbicht and carried on roll
call vote to approve the five year lease with the Arcadia Chamber of Commerce for City-owned
property at 388 West Huntington Drive.
AYES: Council Member Segal, Harbicht, Amundson, Chandler, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
c. Report on Federal Safe Routes to School Grant Fund.
Recommended Action: Accept the Grant Fund
Phil Wray, Deputy Director of Development Services/City Engineer reported that Linda Hui,
Transportation Services Manager applied for and was awarded a grant in the amount of $647,000;
that Caltrans received 332 applications statewide and Arcadia's application was one of the 27
selected from District 7 (Los Angeles and Ventura Counties); and explained that the funds are
100% reimbursable which means a local match is not required.
Linda Hui, Transportation Services Manager reported that the Federal Safe Routes to School
program will fund pedestrian improvements in the Hugo Reid Elementary School area; she
explained that the program provides funding to projects that remove barriers that prevent students
from walking or bicycling to school; that the barriers include lack of infrastructure, unsafe
infrastructure and lack of programs that promote walking and bicycling; she noted that the goal of
the Safe Routes to School Program is to reduce childhood obesity. She indicated the application
proposed pedestrian infrastructure improvements such as sidewalks, crosswalks and street corner
enhancements as well as pedestrian warning signs and pedestrian signal modifications in the
general vicinity of Hugo Reid Elementary School; and helps improve pedestrian safety and
infrastructure to encourage more pedestrian activities by students.
Mayor Pro Tern Harbicht thanked and congratulated Linda Hui and Phil Wray for obtaining the grant
funds.
It was moved by Council Member Harbicht, seconded by Council Member Chandler and carried on
roll call vote to authorize the City Manager to accept the Federal Safe Routes to School Program
grant funding.
AYES: Council Member Harbicht, Chandler, Amundson, Segal and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
d. Consideration and discussion regarding possible submission to the voters of
Transient Occupancy Tax ("TOT") Ordinance amendment.
Recommended Action: Provide direction
City Attorney Steve Deitsch reported that the City of Arcadia currently has a Transient Occupancy
Tax Ordinance which imposes a tax of 10% on the occupancy by transients at any hotel; he
explained that the City was recently sued by guests of a certain hotel who have occupied a room for
more than 30 days; he stated that as a result of the pending litigation, the City Attorney office
reviewed the City's long standing Transient Occupancy Tax Ordinance and decided to bring forward
11-15-11
53:0201
for consideration the possibility of submitting to the voters an ordinance that would amend the
Transient Occupancy Tax Ordinance; he noted that a copy of the proposed ordinance is attached
as part of the staff report and includes provisions that require direction from the City Council prior to
finalization; he explained that if the City Council decides to proceed with an amendment, the
proposed ordinance would be submitted to the voters for approval at the April 10, 2012 General
Municipal Election; and that under Proposition 218 any new tax or an increase in a tax would have
to be submitted to the voters at a general municipal election; he indicated that a memorandum is
included in the agenda that highlights the issues that were focused on in drafting the proposed
ordinance amending the Transient Occupancy Tax Ordinance. He advised the City Council that if
they were interested in going to the voters with the amended ordinance that they may want to give
consideration to (1) extending the period of taxable transiency from 30 to 90 days; (2) increase the
occupancy tax of 10% or increase now and impose it at a later date, or (3) set a non-taxable floor
under which the tax could be charged.
It was moved by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council Member Harbicht and carried on roll
call vote to approve the proposed ordinance (measure) for submission to the voters of a Transient
Occupancy Tax Ordinance amendment at the April 10, 2012 General Municipal Election as
prepared by the City Attorney; that the length of stay for taxation purposes be changed to 90 days
and no change to the rate increase or floor charges.
AYES: Council Member Segal, Harbicht, Amundson, Chandler, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
e. Introduce Ordinance No. 2293 adding Section 1703 to Chapter 7 of the Article 1 of
the Arcadia Municipal Code authorizing the City to conduct City Elections by All Mail
Ballot and to establish local rules and regulations for the conduct of City Elections
within the City of Arcadia.
Recommended Action: Introduce
City Attorney Steve Deitsch reported that Ordinance No. 2293 authorizes the City to conduct City
Elections by all mail ballot on any established election date whether under the California Elections
Code or the City Charter by resolution of the City Council, for any purpose, including the election of
municipal officials or officers or for any measure to be submitted to the voters; that the City Council
at a study session on January 18, 2011, unanimously voted to authorize conducting the April 10,
2011 General Municipal Election as an all mail ballot; and that the City Charter and Municipal Code
are currently silent on the issue of all mail ballot elections. He provided that Elections Code Section
4000 which governs mailed ballot elections, only authorizes mailed ballot elections for a limited
scope of issues which does not include general elections for municipal officials or officers; and
without an amendment to the Municipal Code, the City would not legally be authorized to conduct
the scheduled General Municipal Election by all mail ballot. He explained that the proposed
ordinance for consideration establishes that the City may, by resolution of the City Council, from
time to time, conduct all mail ballot elections for any City election including general municipal
elections or for any measure to be submitted to the voters; he noted that the proposed ordinance
does not call for an all mail ballot election for any specific date and any action to call such an
election would need action by City Council resolution; that a resolution call an April 10, 2012
General Municipal Election by all mail ballot will be presented at the December 6, 2011 City Council
meeting along with Ordinance No. 2293 for second reading and adoption. Mr. Deitsch
recommended that the City Council introduce Ordinance No. 2993 authorizing the City to conduct
City Elections by all mail ballot and to establish local rules and regulations for the conduct of City
elections within the City of Arcadia.
11-15-11
53:0202
Mayor Kovacic requested that the staff report on December 6, 2011 for an all mail ballot election
address increased voter participation and cost savings as justification for an all mail ballot election.
It was moved by Council Member Segal, seconded by Council Member Chandler and carried on roll
call vote to introduce Ordinance No. 2293 adding Section 1703 to Chapter 7, Article I of the Arcadia
Municipal Code authorizing the City to conduct City elections by all mail ballot and to establish local
rules and regulations for the conduct of City elections within the City of Arcadia.
AYES: Council Member Segal, Chandler, Amundson, Harbicht, and Kovacic
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ADJOURNMENT
The City Council/Redevelopment Agency adjourned this meeting in memory of Phil Sexton at 9:05
p.m. to Tuesday, December 6, 2011, 6:00 p.m. in the City Council Chamber Conference Room
located at 240 W. Huntington Drive, Arcadia.
James H. Barrows, City Clerk
By:
Lisa Mussenden
Chief Deputy City Clerk/Records Manager
11-15-11