Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout6280 RESOLUTION NO. 6280 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA, ADOPTING ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN REVIEW GUIDELINES FOR MULTIPLE-FAMILY AND COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL ZONES PER SECTION 9295.6 OF THE ARCADIA MUNICIPAL CODE WHEREAS, the text amendment revising the City's Architectural Design Review standards (TA 2001-003) was initiated by the Development Services Department to amend the City's current Architectural Design Review Guidelines and establish new guidelines for multiple-family and commercial and industrial projects; and WHEREAS, Section 9295.6 of the Arcadia Municipal Code, as amended states that General design review criteria for multiple-family projects and commercial/industrial projects shall be established by resolution of the City Council; and WHEREAS, on November 27, 2001 a public hearing was held before the Planning Commission on said matter at which time all interested persons were given full opportunity to be heard and to present evidence; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission voted 4 to 0 with one member absent to recommend to the City Council approval of the new design review guidelines; and WHEREAS, on January 15, 2002, the City Council held a public hearing on said text amendment; and WHEREAS, as part of the record of this hearing, the City Council reviewed and considered: 1. All staff reports and related attachments and exhibits submitted by the Community Development Division of the Development Services Department to the City Council; 2. The record of the Planning Commission hearing regarding Text Amendment TA 2001-003; 6280 3. All information and material and documentation presented as part of the public testimony at the Planning Commission public hearing on November 27, 2001, including the staff report, the environmental documents (including the Negative Declaration); and WHEREAS, the City Council adopted the Negative Declaration for Text Amendment TA 2001-003 at its meeting on January 15, 2002; and WHEREAS, the above recitals are hereby incorporated as part of the findings set forth below. NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA DOES HEREBY RESOLVE AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the factual data submitted by the Development Services Department to the City Council is true and correct. Section 2. The City Council finds: 1. That the revised guidelines do not impose an overriding style, limited color palette, or an artificial theme, but attempt to promote the positive design characteristics existing throughout the City as well as promote quality designs that have been carefully considered in the context of the City. 2. That separate design guidelines have been created for multiple- family projects and for commercial/industrial projects providing more detailed guidelines that are specific to each type of development. 3. That although the guidelines provide flexibility, projects will be reviewed based on the intent of the guidelines. Section 3. That for the foregoing reasons, the City Council approves the revised architectural design guidelines as set forth in Exhibits A and B attached hereto. Section 4. This Resolution shall take effect upon the effective date of Ordinance No. 2155. Section 5. The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. -2- 6280 Passed, approved and adopted this Sth of Februarv ,2002. ATTEST: ~ APPROVED AS TO FORM: , ~hP-~ City Attorney -3- 6280 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) SS: CITY OF ARCADIA ) I, JUNE D. ALFORD, City Clerk of the City of Arcadia, hereby certifies that the foregoing Resolution No. 6280 was passed and adopted by the City Council of the City of Arcadia, signed by the Mayor and attested to by the City Clerk at a regular meeting of said Council held on the 5th day ofF ebruary, 2002 and that said Resolution was adopted by the following vote, to wit: A YES: Councilmember Chandler, Chang, Kovacic, Marshall and Segal NOES: None ABSENT: None 1:~fC...---,J -4- 6280 EXHIBIT A - RESOLUTION 6280 -M:- ENERAL DESIGN CRITERIA ~FOR ALL PROJECTS The design elements that establish high quality architectural style include the following: . Simple, multi-planed pitched roofs . Open rafters/tails with large overhangs . The appearance of "thick" walls . Courtyards, arcades, intimate spaces . Tile details . Deep-set window and door openngs . Offset wall planes . Fountains and other unique details . Building masses with the incorporation of one and two story architecture . Sequencing of enclosed space/arches The elements that detract from architectural quality include the following: . Truncated or rion-existent roof over- hangs . Flat roofs without decorative parapets . Plastic tiles . Highly reflective tiles . Roof tiles of primary color (green, orange, blue, etc.) · Exposed pipe columns . Reflective material on windows on all floors . The aj:lpearance of thin walls . Plastic awnings Materials that contribute, to good quality architecture are: · Stucco, smooth, sand or light lace fInish . Wood, as an exposed structural material · Clay or concrete roof tiles . Native fieldstone . Wood window casements . Wood, as an accent material . Brick, as an accent material . Wrought iron . Tile, as an accent material · Slumpstone garden walls Materials that detract from quality architecture are: · Metal or alilininum sidinglroofmg . Wood shingle on walls . Plywood siding . Plastic tile . Pipe railings . Metal/concrete stairs . Slump block (for building walls) · Unmilled, bare aluminum window frames -'ITEPLANN1NG noise, vibration, odor, and other factors that may have an adverse effect on the environment. 1. Namral amenities such as views, trees and similar features unique to the site should be preserved and incorporated into develop- ment proposals. 5. All mechanical equipment on the site shall be appropriately screened from view. Large vent stacks, and similar features should be avoided and, if essential, shall be screened from view or painted so as to be nonreflective and compatible with building colors. Site planning refers to the arrangement and relationships of building, parking, pedestrian spaces; open space, landscape and other associated uses to one another. 6. All backflow prevention devices shall be screened from public view per the standards set forth in the Development Services Department and integrated into the site plan in a way that does not detract from the appearance of the building. " : ':"~-:~:'~~:~'~.K)Fk1:f;:,,:Y~~ .:::A~1.}/~,:..t:~;.'~ :;-: .. 2. The location, configuration, size, and design of new buildings and structures, or the alteration or enlargement of existing development shall be visually harmonious with their sites and compatible with the character' and quality of surrounding sites, buildings, and structures. Examples of screening of backflow devices 3. The height and bulk of proposed buildings and structures on the site should be in scale and in proportion with the height and bulk of buildings and structures on surrounding sites, and should not visually dominate their sites or the neighborhood. 4. The development of the site should protect the site and surrounding properties from Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 2 7. Proposed lighting should be so lbmitedso as to avoid glare and to reflect the light away from adjoining property and public rights-of-way. 8. The design of accessory structures, fences, and walls should be hannonious with the principal building and other buildings on the site. Insofar as possible, the same building materials should be used on all structures on a site. 9. The design of the bUildings, driveways, parking areas, landscaping, lighting, solar facilities, and other sight features should show proper consideration for the visual effect of the development upon other ,properties from the view of the public rights-of-way and from eye level at grade on the adjoining properties. lO. Trash collection areas shall be located where the noise of trash Plckl!p intrudes minirnaliy into the re~j<l.~ti~ ufuts on the site or adjacent propertle~; 11. Trash collection areas shaiJ. not intrude into m:ljor lines of sight from residential units or landscape~ open areas of the subject development or adjacent properties. Examples of well-designed trash enclosures ~,~~,;\",.::{,;~~;,~~;tr :~i';J~i~~~ttl~1;~~;f.~~~.i:.,,__ ".'1"""-'" .,"".1 ,. \. ~.' ,. ~:~~.,~~~. . ,','~:':I'..-' ,,-:-~~,.,j' :-::~:::--. 12. Utility facilities must be placed under- ground whenever feasible. Service, utility and trash areas must be carefully treated and integrated into the site plan in a way that does not detract from the public view. Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 3 ',' ,j'!.;' ,.:':':""-~"':':"'~'-""~':"':':"-;'i':.;-:..:',:,~.,:~:;,:..~~.t.,.:..,;~.t.:.:,r./?f.'~~!,~,.,'.t.",,_-,..5'.'.'::.'._~,~,,1,.,._'..,.:. '. "';':"":"':'~::':"""'_:""""""" . - A .' : " '. ,. ,.' - :. ~;.~,;;~:;~~~G~~e~~;i~::kt:' Example of transtormer screening 13. Proposed projects shall accommodate existing mature trees wherever feasible and shaJl provide for their protection during construction. "",. 14. New landscaping materials shall be of a size arid quality appropriate to the scale of the proj ect. 15. Landscaping shall be an integral part of the project, arid conceptual landscape plans shaH be submitted as part of the design review. 16. Landscaping areas shaJl be provided to enhance walkways. 17. On larger sites, develop focal points to create a sense of identification, Iand- scaping, fountains, textui-ed pavement, and changes in pavement levels. 18. StructUres for mailbpxesshaJl be designed to be.' 'Compatible with the , building materials and' cOIlstfl!qed of durable materials. ,,;. OUlLDING COMPOSITION The building base should visually anchor the building, establishing a strong connection to the ground and the site. The base of the building should appear more massive than the upper stories. The upper stories of the building should exhibit a lighter character than the base, possibly by reducing floor area and building mass. Architectural details on the upper stories should be at a scale that relates to the overall building composition. As a general rule, massing and details should be simple and proportionate to the scale of the building. Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 4 General Comments 1. The architectural treatment of buildings and structures and their materials, textures and colors shall be visually harmonious with . existing buildings and structures, and surrounding development, and shall enhance the appearance of the area. 2. Architecture and landscaping design elements shall be considered in their overall visual design to be harmonious and attractive. Review shall include: materials, textures, colors, illumination, and landscaping. 3. Garish, non-hannonious or out-of-character colors should not be used on any building face, or roof visible from the street or from an adjoining site. Exposed metal flashing or trim should be anodized or painted to blend with the exterior colors of the building, 4. Deep eaves, overhangs, canopies, and other architectural features that provide shelter and shade should be encouraged. 5. Exterior project lighting shall be designed to contribute to the aesthetic quality of the project. 6. Breaking up a building expanse into smaller scale units such as 20-25 foot modules can minimize the physical mass of a building. 7. Efforts should be made to graduate the physical mass of a building consisting of tlu:ee stories or more by using the proportions of a step.' Stepping the upper levels of tall buildings back from the street. will make the building seem less imposing to the pedestrian. 8. New buildings should respond to or enhance the architectural elements of adjacent buildings. By respecting the de~ign details of existing structures such as rooflines and buildin,g' setbacks, a transitional tteatin,ent between new and old will begin to deveiop 9. The bulk and mas$ of new buildIDgs should nHiite to the prevailing scale of existing buildings. 10. Walkways, landscaping and perimeter walls shall be designed to minimize visual intrusion into adjoining properties. 11. Street elevations shall be further enhanced by planting 36" box specimen trees. The number and location of trees shall be determined by the Development Services Department based upon lot size, design and' placement of units. Buildin2 WallslFacades Expanses of flat building walls shall not exceed 25 feet in width without providing architectural indentations and/or projections with a minimum depth of 2 feet and aminimum width of 6 feet, so as to provide opportunity for shade, shadow, and visual relief. Articulation of the building fayade can be achieved by utilizing recessed doors and windows, reveals, changes in surface texture and variations in tile building plan. These techniques help divide a wall plan into smaller components that relate to human size and scale. 1. Exterior walls, especially at ground level, shoJild include elemep.ts to build depth and character on the wall plane. Emphasize windows, trellises, roof overhangs, recessed or projected stories, columns, balconies, wainscots and awnings. Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 5 2. Garage doors facing the street shall be discouraged. 3. Appropriate materials for walls and facades include, but are not limited to: stucco, stone, tile, split-faced block, brick and wood lap siding. ~'~F,'~;.~;~.~{:.-,,: 4. A balanced color palette should be kept using the correct proportions between the lighter "base colors" and the brighter "accent colors" on each building. Buildings with large walls should have a subtle base color. The base color on smaller buildings or those with more elaborate detail can use slightly stronger tones. In general, earth tone wall . colors should be predominant including off-white, cream, or light pastels, avoiding the strong pink and salmon hues. 5. Finish materials should m-ap the exterior corner and terminate at the' inside corner. Such treatments will alleviate the appearance of a "wall paper" application and will give a sense of permanence to a structure. 6. The use and quantity of different building materials should be minimized. Simplistic designs that adopt the architectural components and finish materials of adjacent buildings are encouraged. 7. Utilize reveal patterns, changes in materials, building pop outs, columns and recessed areas to create shadow patterns and depth on the wall surfaces. Rooflines 1. Special attention should be paid to the articulation of the top portion of buildings; long, unbroken, horizontal rooflines are not acceptable. The roofline of a structure should provide visual interest and should be used to de-emphasize a building's mass. This can be achieved by the use of offsets and other methods to articulate the horizontal and vertical plane of the building through . the introduction of horizontal bands, comices and stepbacks. Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 6 2. Rooflines should be broken at intervals no greater than 50 feet by loggias, changes in height or stepbacks to reinforce the typical building increment of 25 to 50 feet. Interesting and varied roof forms are encouraged. . 3. Roof forms should be consistent with the building design style. 4. Decorative roof treatments should continue around the building. Using decorative roof treatments only in locations that are visible from a street or alley view is not appropriate. 5. Residential buildings shall not be designed with flat roof construction. 6. Rooftop equipment shall be concealed from view andlor integrated within the architecture of the building. Windows I, Windows should be designed to coordinate with the architectural design of the building, 2. Doors and windows must be coordinated and must have quality molding and framing. ~GfDRIVEWAYS 1. Tuck under, below grade parking shall be discouraged. 2. Long straight driveways and walkways. shall be mitigated through curvilinear approaches, landscaping, and changes in textures andlor colors. ~"b;r5;~~~:;Sfj!M ff~~ ,,' I" -, r"" \ J' II "II i I I' ': -", ,,,,,,!U,j'"' '-'-'-r'" :' ,I:! '" ;_._-"1 "''''1" ~0r':-- .:._:'; "';'__'~"IJ::,-~':-- ':- U';~' ., .==-,-_,,_,,:,,:,~~,l:- , I ,..",1- .: ",~~-::"J.,;'=7-i'I"'I' '.." :I~---- ~ ~,,-,.,,~";<'tiJ,,7"'.I!. ' . -. 'I c, ,:~::_~~~~;7~::':tt~i~~~_:':~li 3. Driveways shall be enhanced by the USe of differeIlt .textures including but not limited to st~i>ed concrete.. pavers, grass-crete, Laillj,~9~pe pockets shall be provided where possi!?l~!ldj!lcent to the buildingsapg walls., H':' :,,~,.~~t~','''', '. . '::t.........';:'-.;,:..,." \..':i~..., ,'. -.' .' Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 7 ,..,.,.:,..,. \~:~)~{-i . ,., ~~~~ ~----:-_ ./.'~.:;IJ~'\i'~~ .- 'L;" 1 ,~~:':"'l"-"'~"'-=-=-- . "fl.',:';'!I' L ,.:,;~~~.>'"..r .~. '.:': ,,~\. f',....":~~~ ~~~:~'~~~~J~~,J' ,.' '''; )~~' .,., .'_::' -=,+,~,~;~~~~~1~ ~ANDSCAPEELEMENTS 1. Landscape elelllents include plant materials, walls, sub. shelters, lighting, fountains, and paving materials. 2. Desirable landscape elements include: · . Pedestrian scaled lighting · Plant materials and structures that provide shade, color and contrast. · Seating opportunities such as raised planters and walls. 3. It is desirable to make new development look "established". Planting new trees that are older and better developed is superior to planting small underdeveloped saplings. 4. A mixture of 24-inch, 36-inch and 48-inch box trees, 5 and 15 gallon size shrubs and ground cover should be used. 5. Areas not occupied by buildings or parking shall be permanently landscaped with live plant materials. . 6. Landscaping should be developed to contain a combination of low, medium and tall plant materials as appropriate. Low planting should be used in the foreground, proceeding back to the tallest In the background. 7. Plant materials must not be concentrated in only one area but should be distributed throughout the site. 8. When limited space is available, the use of raised planters, window boxes, potted plants and the installation of vines may be solutions for areas with limited open space. 9. Blank walls are encouraged to incorporate planters and or clinging vines to soften the wall surface. The planting area should be continuous and extend to an appropriate height to ensure its effectiveness. Exhibit A - Resolution 6280 8 10. Planting shall be used to soften or screen parking areas, alleyways, trash and service areas. iI~\.~:"" ~:":~)~~~:~l\&~\}~ f ~.~~;;r.;f",,,, ,,' " '";, ~ ., .,~;,~;,,)~1; , ~...,...f".._==-;...;" :i,.', ;. .~.~., ..,",. .-. ~ I.,:,": . :i.):.~~\~ '1~..'~1~! -\id!Jr 1/ ~~:;~~~:t;~~~~t.~~:~~~~:;~~. . . .}~{.:\. ~:. .:c~~~~:~~f*' ~~ ~,...,,'i<'~ "'"",.,.."l':~'" .{!" . ' '-\@ill"" " . ~t~;',':r;~~~;~i~~~~Ji ~ ~,';:;:..:y.;;1\',!f,~\,1 "\\ "\ m---'I'!"I"~I~ 'N~', f.'.';,':",.,')~,:',:.,,,,, .. ~~ I, ~, ~'''I ,":.".':':S;'.'." "rh' \~~"'.,."., \""', ., ," ' JlH:I~ - .~~Sj:.I;-. . , ~ ._...,~~~;Jolr' _ :.JJ,~,lr ~,~~i ~~>~~~.~~, _::""_~;~'~'.r ___ ..,~" ,.,!'i'I'~" ~~__ ~ ~.'"'I...~~~,.~t ~ J . ",', 11. Deciduous and evergreen trees should be used to provide a variety of texture, color and form in planting areas. 12. Flowering trees, vines and shrubs and unusual trees are encouraged as focal points. 13. Decorative non-screen walls should have a minimum height of 18 inches and a maximum height of 4 feet. The fInish materials and design should be compatible with the architectural character of adjacent buildings. 14. For a clean, fInished look and durability, walls should incorporate a wall cap and pilasters at entry points, 15. Though landscape architects must be careful not to overplant, desigIl concepts shall reflect spacing of plants which allows for complete cover of planting areas in a reasonable amount of time. 16. Semi-permanent mulching such as bark is not an acceptable groundcover solution. Such bark shall not be used as an alterative for ground cover, or other landscape material. Bark being used for moisture retention and weed control is encouraged. Exhibit A - Resolution 6~80 9 EXHIBIT B - RESOLUTION 6280 ft. NERAL DESIGN CRITERIA OR ALL PROJECTS I The design elements that establish high quality architectural style include the following; . Simple, multi-planed pitched roofs Open rafters/tails with large overhangs The appearance of "thick" walls Counyards, arcades, intimate spaces Tile details Deep-set window and door openngs Offset wall planes Fountains and other unique details Building masses with the incorporation of one and two story architecture Sequencing of enclosed space/arches . . . . . . . . . The elements that detract from architectural quality include the following; . Truncated or non-existent roof over- hangs Flai roofs without decorative parapets Plastic tiles Highly reflective tiles Roof tiles of primary color (green, orange, blue, etc.) Exposed pipe columns Typical franchise designs, logos and colors. Reflective material on windows on the ground floor The appearance of thin walls Plastic a\\'llings . . . . . . . . . Materials that contribute to good quality architecture are; . Stucco, smooth, sand or light lace finish Wood, as an exposed structural material Clay or concrete roof tiles Native fieldstone Wood window casements Wood, as an accent material Brick both as an accent material and facades on commercial buildings Wrought iron Tile, as an accent material Slumpstone garden walls . . . . . . . . . Materials that detract from quality architecture are: . Metal or aluminium siding and roofing Wood shingle on walls Plywood siding Plastic tile Pipe railings MetaVconcrete stairs Slump block (for buildings walls) Unmilled, bare alwninium window franles . . . . . . . OITE PLANNING Site plalming refers to the arrangement and relationships of building, parking, pedestrian spaces, landscape and other associated uses to one. another. I. Natural amenities such as views and similar features unique to the site should be preserved and incorporated into develop- ment proposals. 2. The location, configuration, size, and design of new buildings and structures, or the alteration or enlargement of existing development shall be visually harmonious with their sites and compatible with the character and quality of surrOlmding sites, buildings, and structures. 3. The height and bulk of proposed buildings and structures on the site should be in scale and in proportion with the height and bulk of buildings and structures on sunounding sites, and should not visually dominate their sites or the neighborhood. 4. Building setbacks may include plazas, entry nooks and outdoor cafe seating subject to the City's Zoning regulations. 5. Buildings are encouraged to be sited at or near the front propelty line with inviting and detailed elevations to strengthen the desired image for the area. This will create a "building street edge" that unifies separate buildings into a tightly knit district. Large blank walls adjacent to the street frontages are discow'aged. -- ~ t~~ lfm ~ D ~~1 if.'''1 .. ... _ _.fit ,,>l('~ ... QiI j ( ..... g '''~,a ~~ , A'I~. ' ~ ,I ~, w:;::o:I~' ~~I I]' lc-.'" """.'!l r"'" I' ,'. ',.;.)!~I ~r----; lifIl \,1.1-1..." I 'Cl ) ,( " o ,0 ,.., ! . .. " ;1 ',_ 1,- I :) ~l lJJW0W,i.;i~,~ -- " ill .. Desirable Site Plan 6. When buildings must be located back from the street, smaller, freestanding structures (i.e. flower market, coffee bar) can be used to provide a street front presence and provide some buffer to the parking. ~:~p';g~i~,:;::~ii,E:(if.;, W ,t'l j v.r.~;,q~w;~:. l~i ~~d~r(~ ~ f'77T, I;'J I IlK., 1m ,i~1~'~'t ~ ._1 j~ 'I ,tll; 18' 101 I 'IJ ,,' 1';.:;0 ~ .r-; 1!!IIII~'III"""'-I' i!i I r UJ.UJJJJj.J.lH.L~J...L. 1 j ~i j " \~._-" -- " ---.-. ~:.:.j'" .-.~ ~ ? "~ .~,- 'g t.T.z;;j',,'\iI,~-:E' Undesirable Site Design . ... .-.__. --.-. _._-.---- ...- ^. -.- ~.._-_.- '[' . ' . ".....:::.:..~..r II I flf.~t-~Kt1<~f~}:.:'I~!' ,,,,,,,,:.?J,;;:I~~ 'i'\! I' II"'~~: I~~:,:?:~';::(i,~:r,~ f"iJ;?~:i::!<;~~~',;. I:: ~- ill~I?;;>1~ :"'~~- -I;"\,,, : ii' I ""'- ,~= '::;:!& c' I, Ii ::-1'j.--~ - I I [L-c-.J7 T7')' T I rr ')'11" T '1;'~I'-i' 1~1;'~;' l~ : ~bo~~~ ~Q~O~~~~ :::it-- ,,~"" .( rr-~r~( G=:=i1 ImP , 'i;?,"-'Cil-t1't'--O_A_! "",;:'. ~ I~ ! ~ i ~ ------;ii,'----...J.:jj:>---'------. --' f . ". - - - ',~~iam Desirable Site Designs Exhjbit B - Resolution 6280 2 7. "L" shaped shopping centers should be avoided. Shopping centers should incorporate either a clustered, village- oriented, or pedestrian oriented site plan or utilize external pads at the street edge for visual interest. 8. On larger sites, buildings should occupy a minimum l5% of the total property frontage. Such siting together with substantial landscape treatment reinforces and strengthens the streetscape. 9. The development of the site should protect the site and surrounding properties from noise, vibration, odor, and other factors that may have an adverse effect on the environment. ] O. All mechanical equipment on the site shall be appropriately screened from view. Large vent stacks, and similar features should be avoided, and if essential, shall be screened from view or painted so as to be nonreflective and compatible with building colors. 11. Utility facilities must be placed underground whenever feasible. Service, utility, loading and trash areas must be carefully treated and integrated into the site plan in a way that does not detract from the public view. 12. The design of accessory structures, fences, and walls should be harmonious with the principal building and other buildings on the site. Insofar as possible, the same building materials should be used on all structures on a site. 13. The design of the buildings, driveways, loading facilities, parking areas, signs, landscaping, lighting, solar facilities, and other sight features should show proper consideration for the visual effect of the development upon other properties from the view of the public rights-of-way and from eye level at grade on the adjoining properti es. Crta.p1C!W$UI pnOPEHTY I UNr: ; " CliClllt p/azQ~ in P/tIflIiIi.rillocalloru ",- -~ - . 14. Off-street parking and loading facilities should function efficiently with minimum obstruction of traffic on surrounding streets and alleys. ] 5. Trash collection areas shall not intrude into major lines of sight from residential units or landscaped open areas of the subj ect development or adjacent propeliies. 16. Trash collection areas shall be located where the noise of trash pickup intrudes minimally into the residential units on the site or adjacent properties. 17. Proposed projects shall accommodate existing mature trees wherever feasible and shall provide for their protection during construction. 18. New landscaping materials shall be of a size and quality appropriate to the scale of the project. Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 3 19. Landscaping shaH be an integral part of the project, and conceptual landscape plans shall be submitted as part of the design reVlew. 20. Landscaping areas shaH be provided to enhance walkways. 21. Proposed lighting should be so located so as to avoid glare and to reflect the light away from adjoining property and public rights-of-way. ...... J . _""n " A On larger sites, develop focal points to create a sense of identification. Plazas, landscaping, fountains, art work, textured pavement, changes in pavement levels, and building tower features may be combined to create focal points. 22. All backflow prevention devices shall be screened from public view per the standards set forth in the Development Services Depanment and integrated into the site plan in a way that does not detract from the appearance of the building( s). ~o ~j. Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 4 OUILDlNG COMPOSITION The building base should visually anchor the building, establishing a strong connection to the ground and the site. The base of the building should appear more massive than the upper stories. Building details and public art elements are encouraged to provide visual interest and a sense of discovery. Details should be comprehensible to passing pedestrians and proportionate to the scale of the building. The upper stories of the building should exhibit a lighter character than the base, possibly by reducing floor area and building mass. Architectural details on the upper stories should be at a scale that relates to the overall building composition. As a general rule, massing and details should be simple and proportionate to the scale of the building. The length and depth of cantilevers should be minimized. ~ UNDESIRABLE 'DESIRABLE General Comments 1. The architectural treatment of buildings and stnlctures and their materials, textures and colors shall be visually harmonious with existing buildings and structures. and surrounding development, and shall enhance the appearance of the area. 2. Design and location of proposed signs should be consistent with the provisions of the zoning ordinance and with characteristics of the area in which the site is located. Signs should be designed to be in keeping with the use to which they are related. Sign materials should be compatible with the materials and colors used on the exterior of the structUre to which the sign is related and should be complementary to the appearance of the building. ' 3. Architecture, landscaping, and signage design elements shall be considered in their overall visual design to be harmonious and ExhibitB - Resolution 6280 5 attractive. Review shall include: materials, textures, colors, illumination, and landscaping; and design, location, and size of signs attached to buildings; and the design, location, and size of any free- standing sign. 4. Garish, non-harmonious or out-of-character colors should not be used on any building face, or roof visible from the street or from an adjoining site. Exposed metal flashing or trim should be anodized or painted to blend with the exterior colors of the building. 5. Deep eaves, overhangs, canopies, and other' architectural features that provide shelter and shade should be encouraged. 6. Exterior project lighting shall be designed to contribute to the aesthetic quality of the project. 7. On new or rehabilitated commercial and/or industrial projects, space for signage shall be designed into the building elevations. A sign program shall be submitted with plans for architectural design review. 8. Brealcing up a building expanse into smaller scale units such as 20-25 foot modules can minimize the physical mass of a building. 9. Efforts should be made to graduate the physical mass of a building consisting of three stories or more by using the propOliions of a step. Stepping the upper levels of tall building's back from the street will make the building seem less imposing to the pedestrian. 10. New buildings should respond to or enhance the architectural elements of adjacent buildings. By respecting the design details of existing structures such as rooflines and building setbacks, a transitional treatment between new and old will begin to develop. Deviation from the architectural character of an area may be appropriate when the design direction of the district is undergoing transformation or to express an appropriate architectural statement. 11. The bulk and mass of new buildings should relate to the prevailing scale of existing buildings. -"",-::,..-";;" ~---. ,. ._~ _--- ';;0 ~.-::#~ "",ll ~--" ~- '~~:;'---:r,'" ~ ...:=-- --~ ..........,1''':-}.'" i1v ~ ~~;-;?2:--- f;:;.'~--r~~ ~i~ ~,~ ,~ ~ fi'"-' ~ ll'l~" or;-~'i : ,','. ~ 'I'; ,1<,/; if:,;'s' r.' ---'~"i'-L '_:J'"o.o.~_ ~Jlli-l/;i I~ ',t.;:y.: !i~".: ld .~ .....-~ ..'..' ~;:rt._ " ~i:l\,>'_ .....,1 ,-, ". ,...." -',. ll,":;)I ::;.---" #'-'-" i If:l)il&' i' JIII.0l'I:j1i))j~.1R-. =-.- r:"i \. 1;' JIm ~t.! ,: \L ~ - ~ :"-=-:::=-, ~~ ~~ ,,'~. '~-"'",,,,r,.; .='i'iICC"Ai;;' .".~.i;;>'lI".~.\'< ~.. -==-- ~~ .~, : :.....~;;m,.w'!1n:.:..~'I'._:-'.,...., ".*'.! \-)1';''- "':"-'~-"" :;;: i ~.,:,~;' './'>.~.;'1fy' < j'~ ,~', ._.....'- ,-~.~ .... ::;:}:-;:;;n" -~ tr"'~ \: ld!.';-"'.N///;'~--i.~_..~~ ~- ~/J\ JJ ,.<,\1'1 , :,~:H '--';""f.r;:-!l\:', ...:J.; "",,," I'~-- cH.,' "'I ".\i'" ~ll~li! 0,,'ll"lt!Prrl,,"~'.', ' ,- r~ ...~,.~. ~~,' '. >~'II- _, I' "r. :;:l,t ....1 _ ';,' ,~.~ ' ~ &],..,) : .~. . ,; ):,..:, I-':"\~" ,~.-;...::;'_, __ , ,,1~ ~ .:! r-~\.' . ~.::\ ----...: ?\,...... . f~~.:..1i...,;'..."~g~I~~~~.,.'..i/,--- ~~., ~/"L~5t:.:-''''' '...-....---,..--t ~ ~ ."Ir-.' I\~' -.~......~_..' ',_~',l_---31"::'::"',: ~\U"'ri(r'~ ":>=:--1-" ~,- ,;.- :>2 ~"'~~ , """'=~~-~ --.~ Building Massing in scal,e with existing building.s rEfPWOfS!\1fS /\ COI/SlSllIii , ' ~ II/sEiWlfID01V GWltlG FOeSJ!@WL~'IF2E51 Pi>0VJ!)[VITITC \i ;fl!F;f5) l'~ r--, ,I 'J ' . ". I ' .J' I I iI 'D t::! III / \. r--I " ~ 't\' --I---r--"1 t:::::=l . ! --, , . -,j H Ui; !J ';i'ji, Ii " f ~d r::- IV,: _,":l~l ~ ,1. ~,',\ ! \ ~ '." -': ~. ~<l"l1 !,,, ~~ ~i~, I; p;;: P1p.' {14$- ~j~ '. {;;: ~ k." ~':f,i PROVIDE CON~STFIIT MA.SS!IIG "I ... .o.r.- 12. Adjacent buildings shall be compatible in height and scale, yet it is best if buildings side-by-side vary slightly in height. Exhibit B ~ Resolution 6280 6 13. Corporate architecture and generic designs are not recommended. The design of each project must be compatible with buildings within the area. Building WallslFacades Articulation of the building fac;:ade can be achieved by utilizing recessed doors and windows, reveals, changes in surface texture and variations in the' building plan. These techniques help divide a wall plan into smaller components that relate to human size and scale. 1. Large expanses of flat building walls shall be avoided by providing sufficient building articulation. Vertical and horizontal wall a11iculation including architectural indentations and/or projections should be well integrated into the building design and consistent with the architectural vocabulary of the particular style being proposed so as to provide opportunity for shade, shadow and visual relief. ') Exterior walls, especially at ground level, should include elements to build depth and character on the wall plane. Emphasize windows, trellises, arcades, roof overhangs, recessed or projected stories, columns, balconies, wainscots and awnings. ' 3. Detailing of walls at the ground level should complement the adjacent pedestrian or landscape 'area, providing an appropriate transition from the ground plane to the building. 4. Appropriate materials for walls and facades include, but are not limited to: stucco, stone, tile, split-faced block, brick and wood Jap siding, Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 :1 /' ^ ' I ,~ ' / ,,/ '-.. /'-...\ / .""" ~.\~-........ / ;/ / 0 ~ "-2\\"'\~",\ ' , , / , /~,j,.;\\j';\N / I J> ~ 'J, V"" ~\~1V f', / /1",,-, /Jy .rl .~ ~'Ii)) I / ~ lfL ' I ! ~~tJ ," ~ ~_ ,~J1 .:~~:. I...."" "..~,~..:_,~~ 100>."1..101;1 , ,R'II.......I\I...w..o;i.l,~ Ad:1ar,;cl*~ ,. . ..-~ I 'M 9 ~ ", .t. _ii~( r~~~" ,liIIi,!,I! ',;"."!lc'''""..~..;. I'. '~''\i:i;;ifuoi''''.;''~fIi.'. :~;~;:.; '-'-~ . ':tt, .-; . '~--. ,..<.': . n I ,,~ , ': ~!' ,,' ,., .... ..-" ~ ",?~....._,,, ':>J:'l. -:~- ,..:;~"- . ::~~~~ 7 5. Discouraged building materials include highly reflective materials, unpainted or smooth monolithic concrete, T-l I 1 siding, speed (interlocking) or precision block or non-textured block and metal. Conugated metal may be appropriate for a rustic or railroad style architecture. 6. A balanced color palette should be kept using the correct proportions between the lighter "base colors" and the brighter "accent colors" on each building. Buildings with large walls should have a subtle base color. The base color on smaller buildings or those with more elaborate detail can use slightly stronger tones. In general, earth tone wall colors should be predominant including off-white, cream, or light pastels, avoiding the strong pink and salmon hues. 7. Finish materials should wrap the exterior corner and terminate at the inside corner. Such treatments will alleviate the appearance of a "wall paper" application and will give a sense of permanence to a structure. 8. The use and quantity of different building materials should be minimized. Simplistic designs that adopt the architectural components and finish materials of adjacent buildings are encouraged. 9. Exposed concrete masonry units and split faced concrete masonry units with integral color and texture may be used, but is discouraged as a primary building materials, especially in the commercial zones. 10. Utilize reveal patterns, changes in materials, building pop outs, columns and recessed areas to create shadow patterns and depth on the wall surfaces. 11. Organize the facades of a large project or building into several visually distinct parts to create the appearance of several small buildings. 12. Use recesses and projections to visually divide building surfaces into smaller scale elements. 13. Breaking down the massing and scale of larger buildings creates a pedestrian-scaled collection of smaller individualized elements that is in keeping with the overall concept. Rooflines 1. Special attention should be paid to the articulation of the top ponion of buildings; long, unbroken, horizontal rooflines are not acceptable. The roofline of a structure should provide visual interest and should be used to de-emphasize a building's mass. This can be achieved by the use of offsets and ot~er methods to anicu1ate the horizontal and vertical plane of the building through the introduction of horizontal bands, cornices and stepbacks. ,/'l""-'-. :~l &,",",:,,""':1 /....-;.--"\~ :- /'// \ Ii' /::;>~"'1Y'11 j .1S::-1r":~t~-:~(Jt1)J) /' /' /' \"\ /. I ~,,,,- /" ~ \ '/.... ;;:) Kq'/ /~~J' i )/) I I ",7 !,/' , /' "" ''\. // " " ',1/' ~. Full roofs are encouraged Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 8 2. Rooflines should be broken at intervals no greater than 50 feet by loggias, changes in height or stepbacks to reinforce the typical building increment of 25 to 50 feet. Interesting and varied roof forms are encouraged. 3. Roof forms should be consistent with the building design style. c, '. ~ 4. Decorative roof treatments shonld continue around the building or terminate in a logical manner. Using decorative roof treatments only in locations that are visible from a street or alley view is not appropriate. 5. Special attention should be given to buildings with flat roof construction. Parapets should generally be fInished with cornices or other horizontal decoration depending on the architectural style of the building. 6. Rooftop equipment shall be, concealed from view and/or integrated within the architecture of the building. Entn'ways 1. B u'ilding entrances should face and open onto the sidewalk. This design approach promotes pedestrian activity and creates a spatial rhythm as a user travels from one storefront to another. This is not the case when stores are set back from the sidewalk, with entry doors that face the parking lot. 2. Building entries should be recessed for visual interest and to provide a sense of arrival to the structure. '. ;;11', "4' r:.' ,'".~. '1111I.' "I 'J':';, ,-' f _~~_. _ .. n , t I-~t~;;;;t(~~::. :1" . 'j , '" .' . . -.,-,,- '7:\\' . J ~ Jf; ~ ~ '. : ~.:,-. ~~,:" . . 3. Design details such as decorative trim' elements should be incorporated at the entry. Carefully coordinated changes in color and texture also help to provide contrast and a sense of scale. 4. ,Buildings situated at the comer of a public street should provide a prominent corner entrance. ~~:::-- -"').'1", .: .~;, ;.'.". .'.....,.:-:;. :,..,}..". "'lor."". Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 9 5. All storefronts should be highly detailed using elements that create texture, shade and shadow, a sense of entry and pedestrian scale. 6. Use doors, windows and openings to add extra texture to the wall plane: 7. Doors to retail shops should contain a high percentage of glass in order to view the retail contents and the people inside.' . 8. Awnings and signage to clearly demarcate building entries will help orient pedestrians. w:.~~;:" :;::,if-~~'~-"~~,~;t;::~~? ~.~, ~"e!fg' j1 ':-I~;;..'.:,;! , ~~~;~ ~:~:'- .~ !k'.:;'r.;,..:A~ ::;~:,!.~(:f( . .'. ..'/-:',..... t' i"'."': ::':~~ , ': 3:.::::':;" ~~~\/~~, ,;~;1?:=,_ ~ .'r~-~' j ~'-j rl1 l ~ t::;~<~"'.1'" J ~'~~~;~tr:45,:t~~~? ' UNDESIRABLE ..,.;.;i.,"''t.~ ~.~~-:~ '~!\.~~,{('~ ,-~,.;r;:Zgf;C:G:0r ~J" ..~- w;:ft-~:.?"'~'~:'::':-:':'----':~7i- aZt~%: :, ~ ~;:1l~PiJ--J.;:.A.~WC, J'-""i, _..:.. -.. - . '.H'?! _ "'r-r'5l' \:. I~ Xu~' .:t ~r;-r- -~ ~,:,~J.~~y~~~~V\ JJ:~~J ~",., :':""~...:-~:.., DESIRABLE " ~""~". - 9. The main pedestrian entrances to buildings shall be enhanced. Options to consider is the use of colored and textured paving materials, which are appropriate to the design of the building. 10. Walkway paving materials shall provide walking surfaces that are even surfaced and easily negotiated. Windows 1. Windows should be designed to coordinate with the architectural design of the building. Display windows should face the sidewalk to create a spatial rhythm that hei ghtens the interest at the pedestrian level. 2. Large, uninterrupted surfaces of glass without architectural divisions are discouraged. Powder coated colors should be encouraged instead of using' typical anodized aluminum. Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 10 3. Reflective or mirrored glass is Pl'ohibited. 4. Opaque glass surfaces are generally discouraged. 5. Efforts should be made to provide maximum transparency (e.g. windows) on first floor facades. Attention should be paid to materials, placement, depth of recess and ornamentation such as window grilles. The design objective should be to obtain 50% transparency of first floor facades in retail/pedestrian districts. 6. Storefront windows should be as large as possible and no closer than 18" from the ground. 7. When windows are added or changed, it is important that the new design be sympathetic to and compatible with the fenestration of surrounding structures. Introducing or changing the location or size of windows or other openings that alter the architectural rhythm or character of the original building is discouraged. 8. Doors and windows must be coordinated and must have quality molding and framing. Awnings ]. Awnings shall be of a durable, commercial grade fabric, canvas or similar materials having a matte finish. Awning frames and supports should be painted or coated metal or other non-corroding materials. Glossy or shiny plastic or similar awning material is not recommended. Translucent or "backlit" awnings which allow light to pass through are strongly discouraged. 2. Cloth awnings should coordinate with the architectural expression of a building, generally avoiding long and continuous treatments. Aawnings are encouraged and should be designed to coordinate with the architectural style of the building. r~i:~.:~':i'!;;;' :. ~'-~~;.~'~~.z!t,,':'::~.;...~r~:..-::': .I~1><l<>.~"'O" .........,.", .,'t:\"aa'.(ff""'''''''V_ I~...:<_. fi.1~:i~~..fi':t.!' r'.~"':.~.:.;~,j~..~~~iU' :JLUIUL i QltUJ 'j~I"=""c,c"",,,::: .i;~.~~... ',. !~i.':1i~' .~ llil .,.... .--. ! i:li~!i;~JII~l~ :1: ;~;-f.I~-?,:~'IL~ "',.""'-...,:11.""'''......'1...1 n/t...-4rf>........&lI'l{l'r..... -...., -. 3. Awnings and signage to clearly demarcate building entries will help orient pedestrians 4. A solid color with matte finish is recommended rather than bright colors, unless used sparingly as an accent. 5. Awnings should not be wrapped around buildings in continuous bands. Place awnings onJyon top of doors, windows and other openings. }#~~~..~.~.~\\.~.~:~~.~i~.. )~,'~ l~J !1l"I.t:'ltB:'-;-oiJ ../ ll~",_hj ~~-;t ,', ,7';:-) (............_ ~ ~..7-=-___~--;1./ ~,/ ;.r'i~: I "" o' ..".---;....,. ~'-r 1r '.~ '-,' ;;-', il':;'-;;'11~" "" "'..:;;,.;::.' )1 ~ ;it:,~!.;~ II I ,j.........': , w" ~ '1/' ,.;: ii, ~ !,J; ;,..-:::,;i::~;i ..--'. ~ " ~r'l ~-, ~ w......"L" r""-'-~""'" t.~..j, ~ ~,. ~''''"'"'~it l"I'~""_~; ~'-'-;';';II )J'- ~~''''/ :~:~"r'~~":,f!tI;'::,,,,;,,'~,_-::.~r r\,~~\!"", l~l :-\"" '-";:;'~' ;.l ~;::''''''~~'''''''''_.J ~~ II .__ . !,', 1(. ~. ,,=-~ ~-_.;.:; ~ "'.,,1' t.::..:J." .; 'J.l.~-"...Jn .::::- ~ _' --'~~l 'J(,~ " h-~~-=:--- <:::~~.:.~~;~~~ / .:~~~~ ~----/ ~....s.... -"'-.. "'.'-'--. 6. Awnings with imprinted slgnage are allowed. Signage letters shall be complimentary to the awning in color and Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 11 not less than 6" in height nor greater than 8". Lettering shall be limited to side or front fascia of the awning. 7 . Awnings if lighted, shall be lighted with a direct architecturally interesting fixture. 8. Aluminum awnings or "brow" canopies generally detract from the character of the building and are discouraged. 9. When there are several businesses in one building, awnings of the same color should be used with simple signs on the valance flap (not to exceed 8 inches) and (6 letters) that ma)' vary in type sryle and color to differentiate the individual businesses within the building. , . - - - . ,q ". :~. " ~ \~ i ;':, ~ "'.'."1 I," ~",~ ~ \.-- ",---==- j;"=r-;~>}~--;~~""3; ~~ l~-l< . l r1 fjJj Cd i ~ ~':l;~~ Ii I ,==~ , 4=-c';\ - _~-i ;,i-:r= L~~~t ~.-. ;~ 11~li.' '_'-1' ~'~'" ::J..' "" f' . - ,,~:. : .... ....' i4:"'~__ \ i~ ! ~.. ~ ;1 .-::::-., ~.: ) ,.-. ,-- ...-- iI, ~ ~"'~,~."~,'T~ i ~'.~~~~! ~ ,,:1 ... "~- Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 ]2 OIGNING Signing plays an important role in the success of any business by providing business identification. When signs are integrated into the building design they provide a personal quality that contributes to the ambiance of the commercial complex or streets cape, especially the more unique signs. Conversely signs may intrude upon pleasant surroundings when they are applied as an afterthought. The following guidelines are intended to balance the legitimate needs for business identification with the need to prevent visual clutter that detracts from a project's character. . General Sign Guidelines 1. A sign program should be submitted ,,,,ith plans for architectural design review. The sign program should coordinate with the building architecture including the use of internally consistent materials, colors and textures. Space for signage shall be designed into the building elevations that are adjacent to public streets. The sign progran1 should coordinate with the building architecture including the use of internally consistent materials, colors and teXtures. Signage and graphics should be conceived as an integraJ part of the buildings architectural design, not applied as an afterthought. 2. Sign colors should complement the colors used on the structures and the. project as a whole. 3. The total number of colors used in anyone sign should be limited. Small accents of . several colors may make a sign unique and attractive, but the competition of large areas of many different colors decreases readability. Too many colors used simultaneously can confuse and negate the message of a sign. Even the most carefully - , planned sign may look unattractive due to poor color selection. 4. Faddish or bizarre typefaces should be avoided if thev are difficult to read. , 5. The number of lettering styles should be limited in order to increase legibility. A general rule is to limit the number of different letter types to no more than two for small signs and three for larger signs. 6. Letters and words should not be spaced too close together. Crowding of letters, words or lines will make a sign more difficult to read. Conversely, over-spacing these elements causes the viewer to reach. each item individually, again obscuring the message. As a general rule, letters should not occupy more than 75% of the sign panel area. 7. Symbols and logos should be used in place of words whenever appropriate. Picto- graphic images will usually register more quickly in the viewer's mind than a written message. 8. The following materials are recommended for signs: . Wood (carved, sandblasted. etched and property sealed, primed and painted or stained). . Metal (formed, etched, cast, engraved and properly primed and painted or factory coated to protect again corrosion). · High-density pre-formed foam or similar materials. New materials may be very appropriate if properly designed in a manner consistent with these Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 13 guidelines, and painted or otherwise finished to compliment the architecture. . Custom neon tubing in the fornl of graphics or lettering may be incorporated into the sign design. . Controlled background signs a mounting base for individual sIgn characters. 9. Flat Plexiglas illwninated sIgns are discouraged. Plexiglas signs with "push through" letters may be considered if the letters onl y are illwninated and the background remains unlighted. 10. Internally illuminated plastic-faced cabinet signs are discouraged. I!. Individually mounted internally illuminated channel letter signs are appropriate. Reverse channel letter signs are preferred. Raceways shall be avoided where possible; and, if exposed, painted to match the color of the building. 12. If it is possible to ilJuminate the sign by an indirect source of light this is usually the best arrangement because the sign will' appear to be better integrated with the building's architecture. Light fixtures in front of the structure cast light on the sign and' generally a portion of the face .of the structure as well. Indirect lighting emphasizes the continuity of the structure's surface and signs become an integraL part of the fa9ade. 13. Backlit solid letters (reverse channel) are preferred to internally illuminated panletter sIgns. 14. Signs that advertise the occupant business through the use of graphic or crafted symbols, such as shoes, keys, glasses or books are encouraged. Figurative signs Exhibit B - Resolulion 6280 may be incorporated into any of the allowable sign types. Po1cIMonument Signs 1. Pole signs shall be discouraged for new construction and renovations. 2. Monwnent signs that are well articulated and well proportioned are preferred for project entries. ~~'f:S,~;~'fjr-' OukCreek I \.k iL.-1C \ ,~/.'. '::j ~"/,,j / .' enter '." . "-":""'::=11,..._-=.-."-:--..._..~......-":::-~L---- .... 1" " 3. Monument sIgns should be well proportioned and accented with landscaping. The signs should be in scale with adjacent buildings and' landscape areas. r,'i"2l., "jl,y, h..:-. .> /1'; I~,: '.,{-), f~'\>~~" \,,\/.",:i ~";rj~c,l 1>_.., '"lv' .J\ r;,,~2> d' r-r- I . . -"-- rct._ . ..I., I- ii ("~i C ==:J ! ~. II;!' ~ ).12 ;'. ~'~\~\,'.. .. . . ." . ! II i! . (, . I -. 1 - 1- " \ jl\\ -.. ! ___" :...... . . ! .1 \" ~ ~ 14 ( ,10' I /'~ Sign Area ~~I ~ ;a ~' a: .~ ~ - ~~ ~--- .~ .D....a...k.-T.rr.,. PILU ~ ,~', i I "\. ;,ltj'{f; ~~ ~!. \,., ~\.(. -- \ g I , "1" I t. "oj; I:'" t-::. ,-:1 :'- "......~~:; ,. i Y H~: Q J1 ',,':'.. I 41.,,: "':1 I ~ '. ." '! J "1 "":. ;"'-1" . -j I ~ -:-.~~~""' ~ Sign Area "l'.;- 4. Monument signs shall incorporate complimentary colors, materials and lettering fonts. Said colors and materials shall be consistent with the building materials. More than one material for the monument structure is recommended. 5. Proj ect signs shall be discouraged from having any type of signing other than center identification and the address. 6. Freestanding monument signs should be placed perpendicular to the street. 7. Freestanding monument signs should be placed so that vehicular sight distances at entry driveways are not negatively affected. 8. Solid architectural sign bases and sides are highly desirable. Each sign should incorporate a base that is a minimum of 12 inches high. The materials should match an architectural element of the commercial development it serves. 9. Each monument sign should be surrounded by a landscape planter that extends a minimum of:1 feet in all directions beyond the base of the sign. a ~ Projecting Signs/Hanging Signs 1. Handcrafted, wall mounted and hanging signs are a recommended way to provide clear 3l1d direct guidance for pedestrians, These signs are encouraged to be wlique 3l1d convey a business image. ?~~ ~.'. '.r ~ ,~~;f-:~~"- -~j, '~,' .-":;'. !..... ~~ ",- ~';-~i ~l,'~ .. :---~..-,; ,&~I" " <~"-... ~" . ~ I ',.i1l ~'..t;:?;" . :'1)"II,i[I". ~::~,' :.~~~ -.- --\... ~ i~ "":~!~~V.i\;ll i 'ti J ~~~~i ; i; , . Irk.; !,;,dz L.L. ~~.J-!.:l [I. ...-::-~ ,.~_-- ='- ~~~~::;:-.-'- ~~'-.- ~.?-~ ..L=Z~-~ -r' )f~ '". ,"-: Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 15 2. The number of projecting slgns per business shaH be limited to one. The distance between projecting signs on a building shall be at least 50 feet for maximum visibility. 3. Projecting signs shaH be hung at a 900 angle from the face of the building. 4. On a multi-storied buiiding, the sign should be suspended between the bottom of the second story windowsills and the top of the doors or windows of the first story. On a one-story building, the top of the sign should be suspended in line with the lowest point of the roof. 5. The bottom of the sign should maintain at least a 10' pedestrian. clearance from the sidewalk level. 6. Decorative iron and wood brackets that support projecting signs are encouraged. '-2 '-~' . ..' ......,t.} )j , ,.~'.~ ,.,'i" .. ..;i . . .~; 'it . ;. ~ co. .. ,~ 7. The lines of the brackets should harmonize with the shape of the sign. The most importan.t feature of a bracket should be its ability to hold up the sign. 8. To avoid damaging brick and stonework, brackets should be designed so that they Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 16 can be bolted into masonry joints when possible. Wal1Sil(Ils 1. The following types of walls signs are recommended: . Dimensional letter forms with seamless edge treatments . Reverse channel lettering with halo lighting . Cut or fabricated steel, painted or unfinished . Polished metal . Etched metal or glass, sandblasted glass . Dimension, shapes and forms of metal, hardwoods, glass or other material with a permanent appearance. . Halo or exposed channel neon . Silhouette ilhunination . Front lighted signs. . Dimensional geometric shapes and three-dimensional fonns 2. The following signs are discouraged: . Conventional plastic faced box or cabinet signs . Internally illuminated signs, except backlit signs where only the lettering is illuminated 3. Internally illuminated letters with "halo effect" . 4. Wall signs should be integrated into the building design, compliment the architecture and be compatible with the building colors and materials. 5. Signs proposed to be located on buildings having an existing sign, shall be designed (size, location, colors, lighting, materials, Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 etc.), and considered in relationship to other signs on the building, and compatible with the architecture of the building. 6. Use a brief message; the fewer the words, the more effective the sign. Words should be used to convey primary jnformation only. The text of perinanent storefront signs should be limited to the name of the business; address and/or generic type of goods or services offered. '~lt "~ .~: ,:~J ~ ;!t'i~a i ,,"" ~ ~ lOt f. ~ S::~(.: oJ' -. 17 7. All signs should fit comfortably into their storefront architecture leaving sufficient margins and negative space on all sides. Thickness, height and colors of sign lettering and graphics should be visually balanced and in proportion to other signs on the building. ';".p..:." ~C:"IO"";"'i:':::~;i:::' ~;:.~'~1. ~~~F::' ,:'. _,...~~_~-=--:,'..'_~..::r ~v .:i~~'~~~.~;?f\~~~~l ';...~.~, ~;. 8. Internally illuminated plastic-faced cabinet si gns are discouraged. Awnin~ Si~ns 1. Quality building and awning signs of appropriate size and scale with the building face are encouraged. 2. The text should be located only on the fabric valance flap of the awning. The letter color should be compatible with the awning and the building color scheme. 3. Text copy should be limited to the name of the business sonly. ;:I~#~:~~~i; ~iE:o ,~Sl~(-,.... .....1111"(11.'011/ - rum I ' SI\1U1 orr ;!;. ":~ {~, ....".'tlCQ anll' ,"', i.~, III" I"" I ':, ''',' i ~ ~ II t. ~ .' 1m' I~j~ ',I~: ~rn . 'I(';jGl~t1 Jj~ ~~~: '-L_,~ r ~ --- ." -. , 4. When initially installed, awnings should be provided with removable valances and end panels to acconunodate future changes in sign copy. Painting cloth awnings in order to change sign copy is strongly discouraged as this will decrease the fire resistantJretardant properties of the treated canvas. 5. TIle shape, design and color of fabric awnings should be carefully designed to ,coordinate with and not dominate the architectural style of the building. Where other fabric awnings are used on the building, the design and color of the sign awnings and all other awnings should be coordinated. 6. Internally illuminated awnings with or without signage are discouraged. Window Signs 1. Window signs shall not cover more than 25% of the area of each window. Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 18 Illuminated signs shall not exceed 10% of the window area. 2. Window signs should be limited to individual letters placed on the interior surface of the window and intended to be viewed from outside. 3. The text or sign copy of a window sign should be limited to the business nan1e and brief messages identifying the type of product or service. 4. Window signs should be grouped to minimize blocking views into the stores. 5. Temporary window signs advertising specific products are prohibited. Elihibit B - Resolution 6280 19 *RKING Large expanses of paved parking detract from surrounding businesses and are visually unappealing. Properly designed and land- scaped parking lots enhance the urban environment by providing shade and greenery while providing shoppers and visitors with convenient access. 1. Parking areas should not dominate the site in areas adjacent to any street. Parking should be concentrated in areas away from the street and behind front pad buildings when possible so that parking lots do not dominate the appearance of the site. ~~~.. ., '=::'" ~. ., ' I ':ii' . I.. , I, It.e,; ..n ~..;; ~ ... .. r:~_~ ..v.0.1 ." '^"' ffi"-~l"i~ ~~~'f~~~l. i"',: ii, ';).' '. I I " j-" , I ,.' ,. I IJ '. I 1/, . ~I_ i ~) ~Jc~~~'Jd~i -- - -- -.- (( , ' -. I ii' 11~~~g -,.="2:;;;:",,,,1,;,,- -- ,"_i;~.,.'i;:;,;:';_ ')\1 i I', F'i'Ij ~;:;;;:;.,.."..,.A;.'B""'I'(ffi "~';':""';;,'C'~""":'l I 'l' I 'l'i';'Fi~ ,:pji'c;""'i'r.::::1Xf;k' ;jr~::'i'l "j' i ""-=,)J,.. --~ ~ ~'~r' I ,~?L_,_>._ .;. .7 ,iC- ...,__~.J,?'! I ,-__J I I""':; ~ 9 9 <::) I (" ~, ~ ,1 Q l;l :t' C'll 'l-j i i! I I I 111" j ii' " ,'" i bLL" [LL,d, ,,)J \ ~~ "' ,--'=i\ r--'. .--"t '-J .---:::-\ I ,;:.~-"-_.. '-'~)71r--t I q ~r ~ 1Ir0!l' \. ,;E~_J.~iL_"--~'-_ "f-i!;1' . I~'L._, ~j ~-_.O . -~~r;~.' - ----, 2. Parking lots should be separated from buildings by a raised walkway and landscape strip of at least 7 feet in width. Parking aisles or spaces should not directly abut the building. 3. Driveway openings should not be located near street intersections. 4. Parking lots should be designed and located - - contiguous to each other so that vehicles can travel from one private parking lot to the other (reciprocal access) without having to enter the street. 5. Include decorative paving materials and use of color in sidewalk and pavement areas at pedestrian/automobile contact zones. The change in surface material provides a visual element that is aesthetically pleasing and a safety feature that defines the pedestrian space. ~ I 6, Accent parking lots with landscaping that highlights the importance of the driveway from the street, frames the major circulation isles and highlights pedestrian pathways. , 7. Minimize pedestrian and automobile conflict by incorporating a dedicated pedestrian pathway through the parking lot area in large projects. Pedestrian ways should be incorporated in parking lots, where possible, using accented paving, treUises and lighting. 8. Parking lot entrances should be well signed, well planted and shared by adjacent properties where possible. 9. Parking lots should be well landscaped (at least one tree per four spaces) with trees and shrubs to provide shade and soften the impact of larger expanses of paving. Trees with large canopies are encouraged. Accent Exhibit B.- Resolution 6280 20 trees at entries and end of parking bays are also suggested, 10. The width of a planter for any tree in a parking lot shall not be less than six (6) feet including the curb areas. 11. Low planter walls and/or landscape berms shoul d be used to buffer parking lots from the street scene. -= " . \ t ..--. - " t" ";':J ~ "I" 'l ._,,", <"" ~:';'i: . ~ 1I~"" ,iL.. .B..-.."",_~._ .---.-c.:;;!ITf ---.._=~ l_,aollUD,.;..otiwl"'lfolU;,-.., :;frC)t ~ill ::;4~ ~~ .":1" d[~ , ~i1l!: ~+.. . d~lT" ~,~~i'~ _ J;*~ ___ .,"~b. - ..l~'- I~I "" UUt;W'*'l.~"'<;jI~. 12. Parking garages should provide retail or other commercial uses at the sidewalk level whenever possible. 13. Special attention shall be given to the location and number of vehicular access points and their relationship to vehicular and pedestrian traffic on the adjacent public rights-of-way. 14. Landscape buffers required between the parking areas and adjacent public rights-of. way and adjacent residentially zoned property shall not be included in the calculation of the required interior land- scapmg. 15. Additional landscape required for screening adj acent uses. space may be or buffering from 16. The design of lighting fixtures and their structural support should be of a scale and architectural design which is compatible with on-site buildings. If possible, a light standard theme should be provided throughout the site. (See fl!ustrarion J 8) 17. Light fixtures should be selected based upon use. Pedestrian scale lighting should be used near building entrances and along walkways. Site IngressfEgressfEntry Design 1. Developments should coordinate access/ egress points with median openings and existing driveways on the opposite side of the roadway. 2. A clear and well-designed entry into the project site should be created using walls, signage, paving, and planting to visually link the site entry to the building(s). 3. In large parking lots with over 100 parking stalls, a main entry drive should extend from the public street to the front cross aisle and should: Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 21 . Include a minimum 7-foot wide . landscaped center median from the public street to the first bisecting parking aisle. . Include two 7-foot wide landscaped parkways flanking both of its sides and do not have any parking stalls along it. . Provide deep entry drives, The first aisle juncture that intersects the main entry drive should be placed at least 40 feet back from the property line or public street right-of-way to provide adequate queuing distance off the street. . Provide adequate spacing between neigh boring commercial, industrial or multi-family entry drives. Entry drives should be located a minimum of 200 feet apartment and at leaSt 100 feet from any street intersection property line. Also access drives should be located a minimum of 20 feet from side property lines unless a shared drive is provided. Pedestrian Access 1. Separate cars and pedestrians. Parking areas should be designed so that pedestrians walk parallel to moving cars in parking aisles. The need for pedestrians to cross Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 parking aisles should be minimized. Landscape islands walkways should be used to connect parking and building entries, " " ," m 2. Clearly defined pedestrian access should be provided from transitlbus stops to primary building entrances. In large projects v.~th over 100 parking stalls, pedestrian walkways should be provided through parking areas. . 3. All projects should demonstrate connection of the onsite pedestriari circulation system to the offsite public sidewalk by including a minimum 4-foot wide sidewalk from the street to the onsite pedestrian circulation system, ~~~ .~~~,. -==[ ".J-.':.;~=:,............"'f. ;"'-"......t "- r,.... - '-I" . '-.-.; '"'--- o""{!Jv'i~r7 ,- ...:-;", ~ ..~. v-::;.... ,'(>, .....-}'-- I'" ,... J}"--'-'J f\I.... '. '\i ,..., ~-o:- -, ...;f.~' - ~. -_.._~~' .;.:: .''-'~'K,~- '" /~', ,.~ ,. '-v', ,.or _ ~~-9;::;>~ . ' ~. ~'\. '"'~.. J 'l..''''' -~~~' ,-'. .".,1'",,' ,-~ ~ ~,',--:"":>"?:i::-i--- ,~....,,,- '" ,v;. ~~,- "".' ~.r; "'- '~...~~~.'~-.::.'-- . j'v, ~ /".:;~"ir~ ~ :,1._ ~'--..v -' '- '1_'?~~~>'~ . . 1)"~~\'~r::;x...,. . '. ,-",Y::~:;4 ", '.....'.:J#Z.,?' . ......... . ,,~- ~v:;.x' '- ......... -"'''''',,/'''' ...... , " 4. Asphalt sidewalks are prohibited. 22 5. Emphasis on pedestrian crossings of driveways and major circulation aisles should be accentuated at building entries by extending the sidewalk out into the parking aisle/lane. 6. Pedestrian spaces shall have detailed and well-articulated paving design. Materials may include concrete or brick pavers, tile, scored and textured concrete or stone. 7. Provide breaks in low walls and planters to provide for convenient and logical pedestrian circulation. 8. Unarticulated, minimally scored, plain concrete paving is not allowed in pedestrian areas. 9. Provide sidewalks and pathways to and from parking lots, buildings and other public spaces. This pedestrian circulation must be enhanced with lighting, planting, benches, fountains, public art, trellises and textured paving or other elements as appropriate to the style of the space and adjacent buildings. Loading, Delivery and Service Facilities 1. Consider areas for loading. Loading facilities should not be located at the front . of buildings where it is difficult to adequately screen them from view. 2. When commercial/industrial buildings back or side residential properties, loading and delivery areas should be located at the side of the building away from residential property . 3. Loading spaces adjacent to residential properties are strongly discouraged. 4. Loading docks should not be located within 100 feet (50 feet if fully enclosed within a building) of residentially zoned property. 5. A loading space should be provided for each freestanding restaurant. 6. Loading area activities should not be visible from a public street. Screening Should be complete and should match the design of the building. C' 1- ~~l_ Woo, Jond$copJ1'1g and be17n$ sere-SM Indusflial .""~~ -. "O'OOiIF. ,- ..~.:-~. ~ ' ! ' \ , .'_.~ ~ .' '.(~= ~- EE :\. .---- . --..,;::<i>:::;'~u --'~~- - - ~ ~ I ~ ~ 1!1 ~ I" i t~ l;l 114 ~i ~ 0- ~",,~w~'~"Jj,~i Land~ccrpe beflY'l/buf(os' -vb ;#.,"~4 ~1'. :*"." '1 Ill. ~ .m..._........,.. ~ : ;~H:~~:~:~~b:;;: '" i HL4~L@:~ftg; ~ r loUd wall I SfiYSc. yora , ~ IS ~ l'i ~ I ~ ~ .. II.! ~ ;!li; ii ~~ t~ap. 1C1Hf! ha or~'dr nlbackl ~ Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 0' -, 7. Service Facilities include trash enclosures, storage areas, utility cabinets, utility meters, etc. Said areas shall be sited where they will not create a nuisance for adjacent uses. 8. Service facilities should be located and designed for easy access by service vehicles and each tenant 9. Alleys, when available, should be used to gain access to service entrances. loading docks and refuse collection facilities. ,~~ -,- - --=-..;..~ -- '. -'~ / ...:.-~~/; ~~------''''~~''i:.<< ~;/~ - ( , ~'~1. r--- j;> \Lijj ~', ~.f-"./" \ ,.~ ,.) l !.:ll./- ~ ~ ~ .,--/ \ 1,) ~ .~ l i~~~.?~ // ~ rf. ..-.......__ ;~i~ UV~ /""-,, "'...,-'" :, ;'1 ~// . -"""', -,_,' ,,)l......-/-' . , ~ANDSCAPEELEMENTS J. Landscape elements include plant materials, walls, site furniture, sun shelters, lighting, fountains, art work and paving materials. 2. Desirable landscape elememsinclude: · Special features such as fountains and . art work . Pedestrian scaled lighting . Plant materials and structures that provide shade, color and contrast. . Seating opportunities such as benches, raised planters and walls. 3. It is desirable to make new development look "established". Planting new trees that are older and better developed is viewed as superior to planting small underdeveloped saplings. 4. A mixture of 24-inch, 36-inch and 48-incb box trees, 5 and 15 gallon size shrubs and ground cover should be used. 5. Planters and pots should be located where pedestrian flow will not be obstructed. Consider placing pots in locations where deep building recesses exist, where access is discouraged, to provide definition to spaces and adjacent to blank walls to add interest to architectural monotony. 6. Planters should be durable and have natural earth tones that compliment the adjacent architecture. Materials should consist of cast stone, masonry or stucco materials. 7. In fully paved areas where tree planting is needed, tree grates should be used. A distinctive shape that combines a circle and Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 24 square should be used, where possible, with the square end adj acent 0 paving edges or curbs. Tree openings should be expandable to allow for tree growth. 8. Parking lots should include landscaping that accents the importance of driveways from the street, frames the major circulation aisles, and highlights pedestrian pathways. Driveways should have visual cues for drivers such as distinctive landscaping and directional signs. /"'. .~'''':, -, \, . "- -.0 .....,..;.--..;.._""""":::..-' _ r:- ....... ,~""'l"'1-' '", . )'0(" _____ ii"1fJV'\~"'; ;'- __t..,' , .;J" '" vv- , .... C'-~~'" "'.(~.'\5 ,... . ,. ., L-..' }" ....);; cV; ~' ',' .="--~".: ~ -:;.1-" ......- ~'4...!: ..:', .'..,:' .'::-7-- v..'\).w-..... ;.'- V ~~ " \'i ">:. r"....J...joid~/~. ' /"..,q-..' . ;~'1 .....,-'1 ~ '''. . '?3(.., '" - =.';:>,- ,,- '-'-~ J '\ r. .... .~.~ "'--.." "/". ''I' l- .or)''.,' . .1'- '" ..' '" , -.. 9. Areas not occupied by buildings, parking or commercial activities shall be pem1anently landscaped with live plant materials, Hardscape is permitted where pedestrian activity occurs and in minor areas where such application is appropriate. Permanent landscaping shall consist of landscaped areas at the ground level, in planters or in potted containers. 10. Landscaping should be developed to contain a combination of low, medium and tall plant materials as appropriate. Low planting sh,?uld be used in the foreground, proceeding back to the tallest in the background. 11. Plant materials mu.<;t not be concentrated in only one area but should be, distributed throughout the site. 12. When limited space is available, the use of raised planters, window boxes, potted plants and the installation of vines may be solutions for area with limited open space. <' 13. Blank walls are encouraged to incorporate planters and or clinging vines to soften the wall surface. The planting area should be continuous and extend to an appropriate height to ensure its effectiveness. fT'"JflTj--' i l' J" .J! . ,1#?1.. . i v.i.llii;:!'illii :,~~r,;t~."" I ...."', '-:~~~',i;;"'h : .' ' "1 . C f" !l", ''', ; I'. . """"". ,. , I ' . , -L. .tn~ ptontom Into ..O~1 '" tmaJ. up lbr J~tit M(! oddllitMl<l. Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 25 " 14. Planting shaH be used to soften or screen parking, trash and service areas. 15. Flowering trees and colorful planting should be used to accent vehicular and pedestrian entries. ] 6. Deciduous and evergreen trees should be used to provide a variety of texture, color and form in planting areas. 17. Flowering trees, vines and shrubs and unusual trees are encouraged as focal points. 18. Decorative non-screen walls should have a minimum height of 18 inches and a maximum height of 4 feet. TI1e finish materials and design should be compatible with the architectural character of adjacent buildings. fl_" U::., E:".:.!...~_<.-!'~'- [r~~---i-f it. ,---- J~ :'~::.:. .-._...:.....:-:.::-..::.:::.:.L !..:d _-::::::--.... . ." ...\. :Er -- ~.:_~~..r;':i- "'--;:.. JEj--' .,-,~,:c.>- n;l."=- i~,', .~..:;.~,;::.ri';~~"},>,-(: '. t1?i-. \;i:~:;~Ji1;~~!:r:J; . .' C;'i mt:' :rOr.;zl;U.::=r. '~:"'==-1;;' ~ .-. "~,:-.._~:~..,_.li. ~~~~~~-- .~'~&~; Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 19. For a dean, finished look and durability, walls should incorporate a wall cap and pilasters at entry points. 20. Whimsical gates and ironwork can reflect the character of a business, restaurant or project. Designs are encouraged to incorporate artistic details into the landscape. 21. Though landscape architects must be careful not to overplant, design concepts shall reflect spacing of plants which allows for complete cover of planting areas in a reasonable amount of time. 22. Semi-pem1anent mulching such as bark is not an acceptable groundcover solution. Such bark shall not be used as an alterative for ground cover or other landscape material. Bark being used for moisture retention and weed control is encouraged. OITE AMENITIES Site an1enities form elements of commonality which help to establish an identity of an area and provide comfort and interest for its users. The more common the element, the richer and more identifiable the character becomes. Individual site amenities within a non- residential setting should have common features, such as color, material and design to provide a cohesive environment. Seating Seating is an important amenity. to be provided throughout the site. Benches are appropriate within parks and plazas in intimate settings or where flexibility in the location of the seating is desired. 26 1. Seating in the public right-of-way should be incorporated into the design of the other streetscape furnishings. ':;~,~')r.;: .,'f"',r-'-miI.~__ :'i.h''1~'t/''k'". .~. :'~1}~th;rJl!!Dft!~l'7l11.f J...t!lnII15.'-' ....,..,~....,....- !t.,/111l11.....-- - " ....~~:.::~~~\;~.d1111!L.!,.... ...~-:..._::...--:::::::-- ..'~y':.q'p.. ' b,,~.~~..:::--- ----::::::-~~-;;;. : .....;.1l..(t.m [; -~~~..-~.-;:::::-.;:o-":"'''''--''':'':~~''l..p.-<.'.-;'';''''':'' .~si~:- ~~ ~mr?:i~~~:~~~~~~;:.::'.~ ~it!ri~~1!ff~-Wt?t \" 'j~-:"-.-:-":;-::,''':'''~''''-,:~:>(--, ~:. <>. (~ '4.-." I.' ""- ..... i~:~~;";'~>C~'~_:~ ~~-. 'i:,:~i~>::"-~-~i:{ "' ' ',.. . ";~'~:~'....."<{i~'Ul~~~~:~~u~ x.... .' ~ "\:. :.~.:.. ~'., '.' ~. 2. Wood benches should use smoothly finished, exterior grade members. 3. Benches should range from four (4) to eight (8) feet in length. Intermediate anns are recommended for longer benches. 4. Seating should be provided III plazas. Where applicable, plaza users should be provided with a choice between active (i.e. watching goings-on) and passive (i.e. private) seating. 5. Benches should not be used for any type of advertising purposes. ~.:. .I? ~ ~;i(:",jt~.:.,,3i"'.,,~__ . ~$~r~'l;m,~,r;jt"",,~"",. '.-, .-r-~-r:;~?~~~";:;~~~~I~~~;~ .":;;t~r-' .--:---"l~"""'" "';';~~"'"". -..., . /1_ -'")/;/ ...:-.:::-,.:'><..;;':-f'~~~ I I :J~''':::::'- ., L ""i-';~;';:'-;;:-.." ...!: ...""f-.-__-::.-----l----v-:....:~"t:"": , "'I : .. j II ~;:j . I "'''"'''''>;1'' --\---' , ,': 11 !----->-.;. ...J,r:~.:...J.:'. 'J I.L' j '-_1-- {_.~~_ I . - --."1-----1" -. - . . . -. .,j,!.,. Public Art Public art may be considered as objects in our environment for public use and enjoyment that may display the following characters: . historic . aesthetic . functional Public art can be found in the form of: . Sculpture . Monuments . Murals . Fountains . Anunenities such as seating: lights, sIgns Art associated with nonresidential buildings is encouraged that invites participation and interaction, adds local meaning, interprets the community by revealing its culture or history, and/or captures or reinforces the unique character of a place is encouraged. 1. The settillg of public art should be considered in its design; likewise, the impact of physical space and nearby structures on public art should be considered. 2. Freestanding pieces of art or sculpture should be placed to avoid locations where it would compete with a storefront or obstruct a pedestrian path, create a traffic hazard or compete with another piece of art or sculpture. 3. Art should be deployed in concert with either features, such' as a plaza or architectural features that ac1G1owledge and respond to the presence of the art and make Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 27 the art an integral part of site development rather than a stand-alone object. 4. TIle selection and placement of the art should be part of the design process, rather than being left to the last minute as an afterthought. By thinking of the location placement and kind of art early on, this art has the chance to imonn and influence the character of the overall development. B us Stops/Shelters 1. Bus stops/shelters should be integrated into the setting through design of benches, lighting and landscaping to create a sense that the bus stop "belongs to" the surrounding neighborhood. 2. Bus shelters shall be coordimited through the Development Services Department. Exhibit B - Resolution 6280 28