The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutItem 3a: Consideration of policy regarding property address changesmoo.r^.n n eurmc s, t`9u STAFF REPORT Development Services Department DATE: July 3, 2012 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council FROM: Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager /Development Services Directory-l4- By: Jim Kasama, Community Development Administrator and Don Stockham, Building Official 9-1 SUBJECT: REPORT, DISCUSSION AND CONSIDERATION OF POLICY REGARDING PROPERTY ADDRESS CHANGES Recommendation: Customer - requested address changes should not be reinstated. SUMMARY At the May 15, 2012, City Council meeting, Ms. Maggie Chan, a local realtor, asked the City Council to again consider reinstating the practice of processing customer - requested address changes, which is most frequently associated with a desire to eliminate the number four from an address, or at least so that the address number does not end in a number four. The practice of changing address numbers based on a customer request was stopped approximately six years ago because of the staff time involved. The City Council agreed to take another look at this matter, and it was scheduled for the July 3, 2012 meeting. Attached is an updated time and cost study based on Fiscal Year 2012 -13 personnel and operating budgets. This study shows that the cost of processing an address change would be approximately $2,600, which is the fee that should be charged if the City Council decides to reinstate the current customer - requested address change process. BACKGROUND The Development Services Department stopped processing customer - requested address changes approximately six years ago. However, addresses are still changed in some circumstances; such as, for corner lots when the orientation of a house is changed to the other street, and for subdivisions. The customer - requested address changes were stopped because of the high volume of Address Changes July 3, 2012 Page 2 requests, the time involved to process the requests, the impact on other duties, the difficulties it created for City record keeping, and the confusion that it caused for other agencies that rely on address numbers for their operations. The City Council discussed this matter at three meetings in 2011; May 3rd, June 7t" and November 1St. The staff reports for those discussions are attached. The discussions ended with customer - requested address changes not being reinstated. At the May 3, 2011, City Council meeting, staff presented a report on the City's policy regarding customer - requested address changes, which had been stopped approximately five years earlier. Staff informed the City Council that if customer - requested address changes are to be reinitiated, a thorough cost - allocation analysis should be done to enable recovery of the costs associated with processing address changes. The City Council voted 3 -2 to have staff return with a cost - allocation report at a future meeting. On June 7, 2011, staff presented to the City Council a cost - allocation study prepared by Building Services that indicated a fee of $1,250 would cover the City's costs. However, rather than reinstitute customer - requested address changes with the new fee, the City Council voted 3 -2 to rescind Resolution No. 5569 that had been adopted in 1991 and established a $500 fee for address changes. At the City Council meetings on September 6 and 20, 2011, Mr. Daniel Luong and his realtor, Ms. Jean Tang, addressed the City Council. Ms. Tang's presentations emphasized a particular address, 44 W. Wistaria Avenue. She sent the attached email with three attachments to the City Council: 1) 99 signed statements from neighbors in support of changing the address of 44 W. Wistaria Avenue; 2) a table of address numbers 13, 4, 44, & 444 in Arcadia and nearby cities; and 3) address change application forms from the Cities of San Gabriel, Monterey Park, and Alhambra. In response to Ms. Tang's comments and request to reinstate customer - requested address changes, the City Council agreed to a third discussion, which occurred at the November 1, 2011, meeting. Prior to that meeting, the attached article was published in the Sunday, October 2, 2011, edition of the Pasadena Star News, and in response to the article, the six attached letters and emails were received. At the November 1, 2011, City Council meeting, staff informed the Council that a new cost - allocation study had been prepared with the assistance of the Administrative Services Department, and that the cost to process a customer- requested address change would be approximately $2,250. The City Council was addressed by Ms. Barbara Birney and her realtor, Mr. Jeff Bowen. They Address Changes July 3, 2012 Page 3 explained that the Asian community's superstitions in regards to the number four become heightened if there is a double -4, and that if an address number ends in "44," the property value is lessened by as much as $100,000. The November 1, 2011, discussion ended with the City Council asking Mr. Bowen to provide some factual data to substantiate that the properties with addresses ending in the numbers 4 or 44 are less valuable, and the City Council voted 5 -0 to table this matter until such data is provided. In response to the City Council's action, the attached two correspondences were received. One from Mr. Bowen, and the other was submitted anonymously. Mr. Bowen did not request that the City Council reconsider this matter. Also, the attached follow up article was posted by the Pasadena Star News on November 3, 2011. At the May 15, 2012, City Council meeting, Ms. Maggie Chan, a local realtor asked the City Council to again consider reinstating the practice of processing customer - requested address changes. In response, the Mayor made a motion to have this matter on a future agenda, and a majority of the City Council agreed to take another look at this matter. DISCUSSION For many years, address changes were granted for any reason, and requests were rare. In the early 1990s, the number of requests increased significantly, and the requests were primarily based on a desire by a buyer, seller or realtor to avoid the number four, which in many Asian cultures is considered especially unlucky or objectionable; much in the way many Western cultures avoid the number 13. Also, a fee of $500 was imposed to cover the administrative costs associated with the process and to dissuade frivolous changes of addresses. The fee did not discourage requests for address changes. Anecdotally, realtors and developers would say that while the elimination of the number four from an address is very important, the inclusion of the number eight, which is considered fortuitous, could substantially improve the attractiveness of a property. And, the prospects of having a desirable address number seem to become an integral part of the real estate transaction process. If customer - requested address changes are reinstated, it is likely that most requests would be to acquire a preferred or lucky number, rather than to eliminate an objectionable number. Approximately six years ago, the processing of customer - requested address changes was stopped, and there were multiple reasons for stopping the practice. The process is very time - intensive and detracted from the performance of other duties; the urgency displayed by customers to complete the process placed an unwarranted priority on the process; the $500 fee did not cover the City's costs; and in many cases, inquiries would arise months and even years later, and it took an inordinate amount of time to research and document the information needed to resolve those inquiries. Address Changes July 3, 2012 Page 4 To determine the current cost of an address change, Building Services contacted all of the City Departments for their processes, personnel, and time involved in accommodating an address change, and Administrative Services provided the costs associated with those services — see the attached time and cost study. The address change process is initiated with Building Services, which notifies the other City Departments and outside agencies. The City processes are as follows: Building Services • Applicant submits the address change request and fee — a preliminary determination is made of the address change possibility and the address numbers available • Verify validity of existing address and determine that the requested address is possible — in -house records are reviewed and a field survey is conducted • The applicant is notified as to whether, or not, the requested address number is acceptable • A notice of the address change is issued to the other City departments and outside agencies: • Administrative Services • Business Licensing • Code Services • Engineering Services • Fire Department • Library • Planning Services • Police Department • Public Works Services — Administrative & Water Services • Arcadia Unified School District • AT &T • Chamber of Commerce (commercial & industrial addresses) • Champion Broadband • Los Angeles County Assessor • Los Angeles County Registrar of Voters • Los Angeles County Tax Collector • Other Water Agencies (if applicable) • Southern California Edison • Southern California Gas Company • Time Warner Address Changes July 3, 2012 Page 5 • United States Postmaster • Verizon • Waste Management • Verify receipt of address change notices • Update digital and hardcopy records • Respond to and follow up with inquiries and errors — this can sometimes occur months and years afterward Administrative Services • Update digital and hardcopy records and monitor billings to verify payments based on new address Business Licensinq • Determine if subject address is associated with any licenses or permits, and update records as applicable Engineering Services • File notice for future cross - referencing and update maps Fire Department • Update digital files, and update maps at the three fire stations and in each vehicle /apparatus (approx. 20) Planning Services • Update digital and hardcopy files and maps Police Department • Update maps Public Works Services • Update digital files, maps and water meter records • Repaint address number on curb It has not been determined what affect an address change has on all of the outside agencies, but there have been some recurring issues: Address Changes July 3, 2012 Page 6 • The Arcadia Unified School District routinely follows up with Building Services to verify that the address change is not the result of a new unit • It is apparent that the Los Angeles County Assessor does not update its records unless some other activity is associated with the address change, such as a change of ownership, significant construction, or some other change in valuation • Mail delivery is initially disrupted unless the applicant also files a change of address with the Post Office • Inquiries from outside agencies tend to occur many months, and even years after an address is changed, and responding to these inquiries is time intensive, and often of some urgency to the person needing verification and documentation of the address change A step that could be added to the process is the recording of a notice of the address change. A recorded document should appear during any title search of a property, and the County Recorder's Office is a reliable outside agency at which such documentation could be readily available. This step would add to the cost of processing an address change. A notice for recordation should include the legal description of the property, which should be reviewed by Engineering Services, and the City Clerk/City Attorney's Office would review the document to be sure it is in recordable form, and oversee the recordation process. FISCAL IMPACT Attached is an updated time and cost study based on Fiscal Year 2012 -13 personnel and operating budgets. This study shows that the cost of processing an address change is approximately $2,600. However, the current process does not include the aforementioned recording of a notice with the County Recorder's Office, which should be added to the process if the City Council decides to reinstate customer - requested address changes, and in which case, the time and cost study should be revised to adjust the fee accordingly. It is anticipated that there would be 20 to 25 address change requests in the first year following reinstatement of the process. RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the City Council not reinstate customer - requested address changes. The process is time intensive and detracts from the customary duties of the Community Development Division, and adds to the workload of other City Departments. If the City Council is to reinstate customer - requested address changes; it is recommended that staff be directed to add to the process the recording of a Address Changes July 3, 2012 Page 7 document with the County Recorder's Office and revise the time and cost study to determine the fee that should be charged for an address change. The process and fee should be presented to the City Council at a future meeting in a resolution for formal adoption. Approved: Dominic Lazzar City Manager Attachments: Time and Cost Study dated July 3, 2012 May 3, 2011 Staff Report June 7, 2011 Staff Report November 1, 2011 Staff Report Email from Ms. Jean Tang with 3 attachments Star News Article — October 2, 2011 Six Correspondence Regarding Address Changes Letter from Mr. Jeff Bowen dated November 6, 2011 Anonymous correspondence received November 8, 2011 Star News Article — November 3, 2011 ADDRESS CHANGE TIME AND COST STUDY July 3, 2012 Hourly Rate Hours Cost Administrative Services Sr. Accounting Technician 69 47� ' 1 138.94 -- -- - -_ _2.00 } _--- Building Services - Building Technician, 71.181 - 6.001 427.08 -_ - -. Building Official -- - 139.07 - - 4.00 - -- 556.28' Business License Business License Officer) 72.96 1 .. 0 33 � � 24.08 -- - -� Engineering Services - 1 Assistant En meer 95.73 4.00_ 382.92 - - Sr. Administrative Assistant_ - 71.181 + 0.08 5.69' Fire Department - - - -- - _.- .- - - - -- — - - - - - -- 1 - -- - -- - - - - -_ III -- Radio Captain p i- 141.64 � 3.00 424.92 Planning Services - - -- - - - - - -- -- - - -- a L - Community Development Administrator 165.30 -- 0.25 41.33_ Sr. Administrative Assistant 71.18 1.00 71.18 Associate Planners - - 95.73 0.501- 47.87 Police Depart-me n t - - - - - -- - -- - -- Dispatchers - 80.54 - - -- 0.081 6.4411 153.99 Public Works Administrative Assistant 102.66 150 Associate Civil Engine -- - -- 0.50, 2.00 84.221 260.701 - -- Streets Maintenance Crew Supervisor' 130.351 f— 1 -- 'Total Time &Cost - - 25.24 -- -- -4 $2,625.63 ' 1_..- -- 63 Address Change Time and Cost Study July 3, 2012 r -� Incurp tnd Aay�x.'S.nl Y01 o� STAFF REPORT °junity of'� Development Services Department DATE: May 3, 2011 TO: Mayor and City Council FROM: Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager /Development Services Director= By: Jim Kasama, Community Develo ment Administrator and Don Stockham, Building OfficU e'er SUBJECT: REPORT, DISCUSSION AND DIRECTION REGARDING CUSTOMER REQUESTED PROPERTY ADDRESS CHANGES Recommended Action: Provide Direction BACKGROUND At the March 15th Council Meeting, the Council requested a report on the City's policy related to proposed address changes. The Development Services Department stopped processing customer requested property address changes approximately five years ago. Addresses are still changed for corner lots when the orientation of a house is changed to the other street, or for new subdivisions and lot splits. The customer - requested address changes were stopped because of the volume of requests (20+ per year) and the difficulties and confusion that it created for City record - keeping and for other agencies required to be notified. In addition, address changes are very time intensive and required substantial staff time. Customer requested address changes generally had no purpose other than to change the number because it was considered unlucky. DISCUSSION For many years, the City granted address changes for any reason, and requests were rare. In the early 1990s, the number of requests increased significantly, and a fee of $500 was imposed to cover the administrative costs associated with the process, which is comprised of the following steps: ■ Accept an application for an address change. This includes a review of records to determine that a new address number is available ■ Field verify that the address choice is available and sequential ■ Process application, which entails circulating the request to other City departments to verify that the new address is acceptable • Prepare a form letter to inform other City departments and outside agencies of the address change — at last count, 23 departments and agencies are notified ■ Issue new address and change address in permit system and all related files; paper as well as digital. It is assumed that all other City departments and agencies also do this In addition to staff time, there are the attendant material costs for office supplies, photocopying, postage, and vehicle expenses for the field work. And, despite sending written notifications to the various departments and agencies, there are frequently problems because not all records are updated or a specific person (e.g., utility service person or postal employee) does not receive the notice. These problems usually arise soon after the address change, but in many instances they come up years after the new number assignment. Confusion among the many agencies notified is common. There are instances when an address change is warranted, or a new address number is necessary, such as in the case of a corner lot or a subdivision. In such cases, not only does the address number change, but the street name of the address also usually changes. Other instances for a new address would be the addition of a unit; residential or corfimercial. In the 1990s, when the volume of requests for address changes increased significantly, the requests were often not associated with any new development. Rather, the requests were based on a desire by a buyer, seller or realtor to avoid the number 4, which in many Asian cultures is considered especially unlucky or objectionable; much in the way many Western cultures avoid the number 13. The fee of $500 was imposed to cover the costs of processing address changes, and was also intended to avoid the frivolous changing of addresses. However, because there is a strong affinity for numerology in many Asian cultures, the fee did not dissuade any address change applications. Anecdotally, realtors and developers would say that the elimination of the number 4 from an address, or the inclusion of the number 8, which is considered fortuitous, would substantially improve the attractiveness, if not the actual value of a property. A phone survey was conducted of the surrounding cities regarding their process and fees for address changes. Monrovia and San Marino do not allow address changes. Monrovia stopped due to clerical errors and confusion at outside agencies and San Marino never allowed changes. Temple City, Rosemead and San Gabriel allow this process and receive between 2 and 15 per year. Sierra Madre also allows the process but rarely receives a request. It is estimated that Arcadia would receive 20 - 25 per year if the process was reinstated. In terms of fees, San Gabriel charges $1180 and Temple City charges $500, the same as Arcadia. Other cities charge a nominal fee less than $200. Address Changes May 3, 2011 Page 2 FISCAL IMPACT The elimination of address changes and the attendant $500 fee did not have a noticeable effect on the City's General Fund. If address changes are to be re- initiated, the Development Services Department recommends a thorough cost - allocation analysis by all affected departments to be sure that the City recovers the costs of processing address changes. Even if full cost recovery analysis is implemented, staff time will be involved which could impact service levels depending on workloads. RECOMMENDED ACTION Provide direction. Approved: De-r. -ep Pg,,..g� Donald Penman, City Manager Address Changes May 3, 2011 Page 3 - - THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK - - DATE: June 7, 2011 TO: Mayor and City Council STAFF REPORT Development Services Department FROM: Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager /Development Services Director -'z9- By: Jim Kasama, Community Development Administrator an Don Stockham, Building Official.A_ SUBJECT: REPORT, DISCUSSION AND DIRECTION REGARDING CUSTOMER REQUESTED PROPERTY ADDRESS CHANGES Requested Action: Provide Direction BACKGROUND At the May 3, 2011 City Council Meeting, there was discussion regarding the City's policy on property address changes. The May 3, 2011 staff report is attached. Staff had recommended that if address changes are re- initiated, that a thorough cost analysis be done so that an appropriate fee can be charged to recover the City's costs associated with processing an address change. After the discussion, the City Council requested that staff provide an analysis of the staff time and costs involved in the process of changing property addresses. DISCUSSION Building Services contacted all of the City Departments, and they provided information about their processes, personnel and time involved in accommodating an address change. This information .was used to calculate the cost of processing an address change — see the attached spreadsheet. The address change process is initiated with Building Services, which notifies the other City Departments and outside agencies. The City processes are as follows: Building Services • Applicant submits address change request and fee — preliminary determination of address change possibility and address numbers available Verify validity of existing address and determine that the requested address is possible — review in -house records and conduct a field survey • Notify applicant that requested address number is acceptable • Prepare and issue notice of address change to other City departments and outside agencies: • Administrative Services • Business Licensing • Code Services • Engineering Services • Fire Department • Library • Planning Services • Police Department • Public Works Services — Administrative & Water Services • Adelphia • Arcadia Unified School District • AT &T • Chamber of Commerce (commercial & industrial addresses) • Champion Broad Band • Los Angeles County Assessor • Los Angeles County Registrar of Voters • Los Angeles County Tax Collector • Southern California Edison • Southern California Gas Company • United States Postmaster • Verizon • Waste Management • Verify receipt of address change notices • Update digital and hardcopy records • Respond to and follow up with inquiries and errors Administrative Services • Update digital and hardcopy records and monitor billings to verify payments based on new address Business Licensing • Determine if subject address is associated with any licenses or permits, and update records as applicable Engineering Services • File notice for future cross - referencing and update maps Address Changes June 7, 2011 — page 2 Fire Department • Update digital files, and update maps at the three fire stations and in each vehicle /apparatus (approx. 20) Planning Services Update digital and hardcopy files and maps Police Department • Update maps Public Works Services Update digital files, maps and water meter records • Remove and repaint address number on curb It has not been determined what affect an address change has on all of the outside agencies, but there are some recurring issues: • The Arcadia Unified School District routinely follows up with Building Services to verify that the address change is not the result of a new unit • It is apparent that the Los Angeles County Assessor does not update its records unless some other activity is associated with the address change, such as a change of ownership, significant construction, or some other change in valuation • Mail delivery is disrupted unless the applicant also files a change of address with the Post Office FISCAL IMPACT If address changes are re- implemented, the Development Services Department recommends a fee of $1,250 to cover the processing costs so that there is no fiscal impact to the City. REQUESTED ACTION Provide direction. Approved: Donald Penman, City Manager Attachments: May 3, 2011 Staff Report Spreadsheet: Address Change Time and Cost Study Address Changes June 7, 2011 — page 3 - - THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK - - Mint 7. 1N7 STAFF REPORT Development Services Department DATE: November 1, 2011 TO: Mayor and City Council FROM: Jason Kruckeberg, Assistant City Manager /Development Services Director!5Lr-- By: Jim Kasama, Community Development Administratflr,' �nd Don Stockham, Building Official 71- SUBJECT: REPORT, DISCUSSION AND CONSIDERATION OF POLICY REGARDING PROPERTY ADDRESS CHANGES Requested Action: Provide Direction BACKGROUND At the June 7, 2011 City Council meeting, the Council voted 3 -2 to rescind Resolution No. 5569, which was adopted in 1991 to establish a $500 fee for address changes. This action took place after the second discussion on the subject. The first discussion was at the May 3, 2011 City Council meeting, which ended with the Council requesting that staff provide an analysis of the time and costs involved in the process of changing property addresses. The analysis was presented to the City Council at the June 7, 2011 meeting, and that discussion ended with the rescission of Resolution No. 5569. Attached for reference are the May 3, 2011 and June 7, 2011 staff reports. At the City Council meetings on September 6 & 20, 2011, a local realtor, Ms. Jih (Jean) Tang addressed the Council about customer requested address changes; in particular, about 44 W. Wistaria Avenue. She also sent an email to the Council about this subject, which included three attachments: 1) 99 signed statements from neighbors in support of changing the address of 44 W. Wistaria Avenue; 2) a table of address numbers 13, 4, 44, & 444 in Arcadia and nearby cities; and 3) address change application forms from the cities of San Gabriel, Monterey Park, and Alhambra. In response to Ms. Tang's comments and request to allow address changes at the September 20, 2011 meeting, the Council agreed to revisit the matter. Because the City Council feels that this matter deserves the attention of the full Council, it was scheduled for this meeting to avoid prescheduled absences from the two October meetings. At that time, the City Council also directed that staff not prepare any new analysis of the issue, or devote any additional staff time, but to resubmit the earlier reports. The subject of addresses with the number '4' and the City's policy on changing addresses were the topics of the attached article that was published in the Sunday, October 2, 2011 edition of the Star News newspaper. In response to the article, the five attached letters and emails were sent to the City Council. FISCAL IMPACT The June 7, 2011 staff report recommended a fee of $1,250.00. Since then, the City has negotiated new Memoranda of Understanding with the various employee groups, and the Administrative Services Department has comprehensively calculated the overhead costs attributable to the various Departments involved in processing address changes. The result of these changes is that the total cost is now estimated to be $2,282.16. Based on this updated study (attached) a fee of $2,250.00 could be charged for the processing of an address change; if the City Council wishes to reinstate the, practice. Staff estimates that there would be 20 to 25 address change requests per year, at least in the first year following reinstatement of the practice. RECOMMENDATION Provide direction. Approved: Donald Penman, City Manager Attachments: May 3, 2011 Staff Report June 7, 2011 Staff Report Star News Article from Sunday, October 2, 2011 Edition Correspondence Regarding Address Changes Updated Time and Cost Study dated November 1, 2011 Address Changes November 1, 2011 Page 2 � -20- 2011 Subject: signed supprting letters and more for address change Dear Mayor and Councilmen: I have been working for the family since February this year. I can feel what they have suffered and how frustrated they are.They are not superstitious and they don't care about the number at all. At the time they purchased this house, address change was allowed. 3 years ago, city terminated the policy without notice and made them the victim of "44 ". Without changing the number, there is no way for them to get fair market value. Why they have to take it just becuse of the number? We are wondering why the city terminate the policy while the other cities still doing it. Don't you feel it is not fair? As far as I talked with residence I met on the street, only a few heard about this from the news a few months ago. General public do not believe that address change is not permitted any more in Arcadia. I did some research on surrounding cities as attached . I hope that you can reconsider this matter. There is another seller with "44" address will apeal today. Thank you very much for the hard word you have done to the city! Sincerely Yous, Jean Tang RENAX Premier Properties DRE #01755519 (626) 456 -3815 My name is: U 11 L i I live on: ,� / ; W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the prop" owner of the afurementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave.: Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, 1 am competent to do sir. 1 support . Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the Imes of the State of California. r SlgnaNre C Date I C I My name is: 'y�i'_�y ( j i I live on: _ e W. .. Wistaria Ave.. Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the afaremcntiuned property. ( lr on ) I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home prim for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. i am competent u. do so. I support Ma. Ginn Ton and make the Declaration trader penalry of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Date My name is: C,n 1'C I live on: G 0 �, W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because fner address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature / G? � V -15� Date ----- I live rot: 9 Ui W- Wistaria Ave, Teadla CA 91007. f am alsu the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers office home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. i Signature _`.�--- /:_2�_..,_,.__r- __,.___. Date d I % My name is: .6ilC= i %� ✓'LNG I live on: Ste_. W. Wistaria Ave.. Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchases of her hone as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature Date 1-17 My name is: _------ ----- --- c 1 live M 4.-S W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding home,. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. Ali If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. I Signanne --...----------------- ---- ------ i-`------- Date I I My time is: 1 ICL^'( e( .�1-�' I live on:(� W. Wistaria Ave,, Arcadia. CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned properly. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impart on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature -- ��--- Date -- My name is: n j tin i I live on: W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007. lam also the property owmrer of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina'I on in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave.. Changing he address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block became her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding houses. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms Gina Ton add make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature n i � Date _ E My name is: /;, I live on: 1,,�./_ W. R'istaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address ot'44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and snake the Declaration under penalty of perjury wider the laws of the State of California. Signature - - -- a— [ _ Date 1 live on: _ b' S W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Avc., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding home.. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. if called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Una Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature C� Date r My name is: I live nn: (,�z-I. W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA. 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W'.1Vrstana Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her- address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. #tmreom)>eteetlto'd'o so. I support Ms. Gina "Ion and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. /o ' Signature L �" ,; - 7,Gc.f.�;l< -- Date t ll My name is: r) I live on: W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina I on in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Si�uantre r Date I My name is: II OA; ✓ 1 live on: , )3 W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 R', Wistaria Ave.. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home m well as the surrounding homes. I snake this Declaration from Personal knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1. support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of periurr under the laws of the State of California. signature -- -- - - - - - -- Date r My name is: I live on: W. Wistaria Ave.. Areadir, C�. 91007, I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address w211 have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all furore purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City- Council. I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make The Declaration under penalty, of perjury under the law's of the State of California. Signature Uatr 4 Mynameis ._l`!.&a..T � I live on: 7 Zn R'. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007. [ am also the propene owner of the aforementioned property. i support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave.. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all fume purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support A1s. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty, of perjury under the laws of the State of California. i Signature Date 2. — I0 �/-- ._.__---- --------- -- M7 name is: I five on: 3.I W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007. 1 am also the properly owner of the afurementioued property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave.. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent n do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Date _ i My name is: I live on: 7— W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA. 91007.1 am also the properM- owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of ber home as well as the surroundine homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. i It called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, 1 am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Stare of Califomia. I .. Signature Date ?i A it My name is: q—," J r "N — I live ou: 3,03 W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007. lam also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina "l min her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. It called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I. support Ms. Gina 7 on and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Sienawre __---- /rte------- ---- ._ —. - ____ Date My name is: i �n w'• lY +e,.._[,}],�,, I live on: ._ W. Wisteria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in ber attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because het address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as thr surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penally of perjury under the laws of the State of Califomia. Signature � )ate _..--....0. _._ a NaL r- � i I My name is:�,��,c I live on 2n C' W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 R'. Wistaria Ave., .I Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as web as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I ant competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the law; of the State of Califomia. Silmature Date I I i i My name is: I live on: �J - W. Wistaria Ave.. Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the prop", owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave.. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of het borne as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature -_ Date 9 �.� My name is: = -= ------ ------------- -.._- I live on: i W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007. I ant also the property owner of the of'or4mentioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave.. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration tram Personal Knowledge. I called to be a witness betore the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature ",-4- Date My name is: 1'�l�L17t1 i�.t.�i1 I live on: W, Wistaria Ave., Arcadia; CA 91007.1 ant also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton ht her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge, If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of penury under the laws of the State of Califomm. nc' Signature — Date My name is: L 1, L� 4RN,� v I live on: ?& W. Wistaria Ave., Arcadia, CA 91007.1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of'44 W. Wistaria Ave.. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the ontire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the sumounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of penury under the laws of the State of California. r JlPnarUIe '`-!�� C/ Date _ /:/ °� / �"O /,/ hly name is: �i� I live on: ' �� R'. W'istu ' ve, Arcadia, CA 91007, I am also the property owner ofthe aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton in her attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave., Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire block because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Grin Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. i �i Signature Date My came is: tiz L I live on: ;3116' 3 G E S >n d _ , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned propem% I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Lonna in their attempt to change her address of 44 W Wataria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Tom and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signaturp Data �__._•:, r My name is:t I live on: .._ �- -= �3 _ � J , Arcadia CA 91001 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned propeny. I support Ms. Gina s on and her son Daniel Lumte in their attempt to change her address of 44 TV HIrsraria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of peel'ury under the laws Of the state of California Signature Date — �-- � My name is: 'A �-� I live on: _.., _ _ - Arcadia CA i ma also due I I .owner of a aforementioned property. I support ALs. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 9. W'israria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be s witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ion and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the state of California. Signature t /�! Hate My name is: - -- I live on: 15- >-1 Arcadia CA 9100b. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of I! W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ion and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury tinder the laws of the State of California. i Signature _,_, l � Date My name is: M C Usk J I live on: Q0.5 E hind „, U,�A— , Arcadia CA 9100 I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to chance her address of 10 9. Wlsrarda Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depreases the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent m do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and matte the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California, Date 5151! My name is: I live on: _�5.3._/Sc, (S � Arcadia CA 91007. lam also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Oina'fon and her son Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of N li: Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge . if called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Too and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the Iaws of State of C:ahfomia. , r' 'J Date i My name is: -- Ilive on: 7�t5 - f�L'. ✓Ifs �i Sf� A VEArcadia CA 9100 I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina'1'on and her son Daniel Luting in their attempt to chance her address of I! fi'. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surtoundinahomes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called cat be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, 1 an competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina 'I -on and make the Declaration under penalty of pMun� under the laws ofthc State of Califomia. Signature - i Datc My name is: I live our .10 P, P, Arcadia CA 91 Oft" I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luting in their attempt to change 6e7 address of 44 W Wisraritr Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declamtion from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support M.s. Gina 9'on and make the Declaration under penalty of perjtvy under the laws of the State of California. Signature i Date i I MV name is: I live on: >I S C WL L %tu y Arcadia CA 9104 I am also thr property owner of the afo property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her sou Daniel Lumng in their attempt to change her address of44 W Wistaria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price fin all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina l on and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature %4z' 1 Date My name is: I live on: _ =1 > ✓r • qp, a 4, 1 JITP— . Arcadia CA 9I00� I am also the properly owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina'fon and her son Daniel Luone in their attempt to change her address of44 W WPAarier Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because ber address depresses the home price for all hm= purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia Citv Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the law;, of the State of California. f °•Sipnature �� - � L- �r.GC� r,, My name is: '�f"f� 1 %U,, !"I I live on: � \F .__�'1y.G r_ r, _ _ _ , Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact tot die entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as tilt . surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a wimess before the Arcadia City Comncil, I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Cana Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of calitomia. Signature t li Date ` I i M - My name is:122 i Le y __7\�' :' . Arcadia CA 910i 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire cornmunity because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. 1 ran competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina'lon and make the Declaratimu under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of <'alifomia. Signer Date 77 " My name is: -------- I live on: %� _ `_ 25 (-" ! rpvirt�' , Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property, own of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their snenpt to change her address of 44 W. R lataria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price tot all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council,' f am competent to do so. I support Ms. Guia Ton and make the Declaration under penalty, of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature llae _� My name is: j0i�hc 'G"^� _�- •u_.. —. ,. I live on: p " �. �' Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of44 H. li'israria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surroondnia homes. I 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. i If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. l am competent to do so. i support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Cahfomia. Signature ------------------- Daze ---- ='----.. .— My name is: (4,(t� I live on: //0 t i -rA a N-LP kyl- , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her Ron Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of 44 1f: I[Vweria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding (tomes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury, under the laws ofthe State of California. Signature Date My name is! /-q r C t P -D-I ft I live on: (7 &_!. LEE F1.Ofi F-S4a4; Arcadia CA 9100'. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Yon and her son Daniel Luome in their attempt to change her address of 44 W: Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Krunvledge. If called to be a wimess before the Arcadia City Council, 1 am competent at do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Store of Califomiu. Signature JL2��,- 3 %ji, ✓1'^- Date 1 My name is: _--i ✓ ✓G.�t -L'�_U 1 live on: '— u-, L ay f %vr S 4u , Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the propem, owner of the aforementioned property, I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Nviaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire commu» try because her address depresses the home price for al I future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a wimess before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Calit'omia. Signature d c Dare mil' y__— _L, L__ - ---- _ r- - Mynanteis: Vi 14 t I live on: � _ /J14 AJ jrJ /Alreadin CA 91007. lam also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luting ht their attempt to change her address of 44 W. W'lsiaria Ave. Chattgittg her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge, If called to be a wimess before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. 1 support Ivis. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under die taws of file State of California. Sigmatutc. -_fy, ----------- Datc .__.__.._5 -�) 3-U iI i My name is: L-- L.Lr�--------- 1 live on: .3 rG /,J. 4.A S :F-JO Z-S AVe- , Arcadia CA 9100?. 1 am also the propem, owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a wimess before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent n, do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and male the Declaration under penally of pequn under the laws of the State of Califon is. Signature Date L J I My name is: I live on: 1 I L nLt _ , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned propeM, I suppon Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address of 44 W Wistaria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of ha home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am campetent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury corder the laws of the State of California. n Signatures , Date-- ---------------- My name is: `�/ ) - K. 7Y t I live on: 4f 1 �v./ %lur A lr cr /i?Gy,(i.�„ Arcadia CA 91007. lam also the property owner of the aforetrrcntioned TAP• I support Ms. Gina Ton and tier son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address of 44 FE Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws Of the State of California. li Signature ------------- -._. Date My name is: >tc v` - L ✓\ I live on: ''C l.i- I AS T =LC)r��F5 kOr , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address of 44 If. WWaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the Jaws of the State of California. Signature Date My name is: I live on: i�t Q- v ^1kAV A( .I}..�,p Arcadia CA 91007. l ant also the property owner of the af� -T rmen�ti o61 Pr rt I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address ()f44 FK Wrstaria Aec. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina'lon and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Slaw urc - - ------.... Date C tIQY U'L �Qh.�j_ M7 name is: ,1. t I lire on: 4f_JJ- �i Q1"f11 Q+ti 1�'dF, Nr t,Amadia CA91007. lamalsothe property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W W7slantr Ave. i Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the hone price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding, homes. I make this Declaration firms Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration antler penalty of penury under the laws of cite State of California. I Signature Date i--- - - - - -- — — - -- -- — My name is:. 1 live on: 117 ../r�..ia! ^aix]__..L 'u -' Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the — —oaf er' . property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and ber son Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the canto: community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowiedec. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council_ 1 am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and stake the Declaration under penalty of penury under the ]asys of the State of California. Signature t Date My name is: I live on; L4 Arcadia CA 91007. lam also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina T on and her son Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of 44 If'. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding hones. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and snake the Declaration under penalty of penury under the laws of the State of California. Signature L- -.'?`:- �....__ t 4� Dale ------ - - - - -- Mvnameis: Alft'S1E 1 live on: l _ r Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforenentioded property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Imong in their attempt to change her address of 44 TV Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina'lon and make the Declaration underpenalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature (,y°j Date 9 A 11 My name is: 6koe I live on: )/2- !;&n 0gcec- L- 1.�.:____._....., Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wiswria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton said make the Declaration under penalty of perjury trader the laws of the State of California. Signature Date 7 My name is: I live on: i U! _St, Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the afaretnen rated property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luring in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wtswria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council. f am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina *1 on and make the Declaration under penalty of perjtny under the laws of the State of California. Signature Date My name is: I live on: f 15 i "--> r "" b�a� 7Jr , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina'I'on and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wisaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature Date -' My name is: -��ii 1�:� } .��CYf live on: u7 �0, #1 jq 6l.`P.l Ut` ,Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to chengu her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ape. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the hone price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. I If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, t am competent to do so, 1 support Ms. Gina Ion and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Sig»anrc �I 4 'Date _1' My name is: k, i ' ` Ir 1 lWCM3 I live on: 2 .1 if , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the - -T property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina l on and her son Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of44 A: W'iumiaAve. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a tvimess before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina ion and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature _ _ 11&S�'._- - ------ ._ Date1 Y My name is: ...it%v V � w I live on: CA 91007. 1 am also the -- ------- -------- propem- owner of the aforementioned. properly. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Lucas in their attempt to change her address of44 W. W'israrieAve. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the borne price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina "Ion and make the Declaration under penalty of perjur)� under the laws of the State of California. i Date / ,��7"'// I I I /' 99 My name is: v �' ff Ul I live out: I hr\ Y 1 , Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned toperty. I support Ms. Gina 'I on and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 R: Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the, home price; for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I suppon Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. yIf�� Signamr l,—. �` l— L �'�-- Date I L) i My name is: ----------- I lire on: RZJi 54x1 �� .nil —, Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina l on and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 W: W ixtaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community, because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I suppon Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty, of perjury under the lacy. of the State of California. Signature tom_ - i� Date . 1 My name is 1_J� fi I live un: �91' �� 6 fYk�- �� Arcadia CA 91007. i am also the property owner of , af�ed property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel l.uoug in their attempt to change her address of 44 W: W7viarin Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all failure purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the taws of the State of California. Signature •"'�/1-'_____ Date My name is: _'-,4 7 kL 'rm h S Z--e—, I live on: Y / Sr `5 R o crJ �,;.nc/ kve� Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina T on and her sun Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address of44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. It called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. l am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature ----------------- _ —.- Date ., �«� 7 .o r 1 �I VIII I live on: //.i / 3f n-W �ecn-In, , Arcadia CA 91007, 1 am also the property owner of file aforemenG$aed propem . I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature Date II My name is: ? t- a n •�rikll 1 live on: .7 w ; .5 • Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the ator 6 mentioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Tou and her situ Daniel Luting in their attempt to change her address of 44 W: !4 rstaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entiree community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent o do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under dtc laws of the State of California Signature= `'_,''- Dote 9 i c % z-W My name is ion 0.he �'ewti - }--- - ------ — I live on: a >�y,l 5 e f 13 cad, _- - - - - -, Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned proper'(),. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Lonna in their attempt to change her address of44 H: W'isariu Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial hnpuct on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all fume purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support. Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under pcnahy of perjury under the laws of the Sate of California. Stenxtac (aT Date _ ' Y - .2.0 My name is: I live nn: Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned proptity. 1 support Ms. Gina Tort and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address ni 44 W. Wislaria Ave. Changing ber address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of ber home as well as the surrounding homes. i make this Declaration from Personal knowledge, If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support his. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Sate of California. i i 4 Dato -- -- - - - - -- -------- ------------- - - �I I My tame is: 3IHNLj C11 il I-JAtiC I live on: t '1 1-tn 12b 5T A ✓F , , Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also thc. property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina T'on and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to chartge her address ol'44 W Wislaria Ave- Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home it well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal knowledge. I f called to be a witness before the Arcadia Cit} Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Grin Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. r-- Signature _ �J Date: 4 lip l l My name is: ` J �11 . �7 � I live on: t'�O bu w p 1A /7GY1 i/L ,, Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the afurementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of'44 W: Wlsraria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community hecattse her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Persoual Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. 1 am competent to do sus I support Ms. Ginu Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Sate of-California. i Signature . 1 t Date My name is: I live on'. r el CA 9100 , 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property'. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of 44 W Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community beeauce her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declarution under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature v Daze --`- i My name is: Y I live o¢: a �? ate+ —eiri e. Arcadia CA 9100_ 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned proper. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a wimess before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Store of Califomiu v Signature Date My name is:!lif�. - -.. I live on:7!�.-- �(/��, , Arcadia CA 9100 —. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to chance Weir address of44 If. Wistariu Ave. Changing her address will have a heneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home us well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Dechtmtion from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature _ Dare 9 / f—/ 11 My name is: i live nn: ��Arcadia CA. 91M1am also the property owneranioned property.. % 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of44 IM Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I nm competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjun under the laws of the State of California. Signature I Date 1 My name is: I live on: 1,,. 37 ZS% ��f�.l"? -- /� ?, , Arcadia CA 9100..__. t am also the propem, owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 W: H2rraria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowicrigc. ❑'called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, 1 am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and uwke the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Suite of California. Signal= Date Date My name is •— I live on: - W Z- 5-yvlt2'�C� ' -.�� '� I' , Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned pmperfy. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 0. R'ivaria Atv. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before rile Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration tinder pahalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature T Date i i My name is: ,__ --- kosjs mxlr'T C. jI 6PIoC; I live otc I( W AVE, Arcadia CA 9100_. f am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Lunne in their attempt to change their address of4417. Wigaria Ave. Changing her address Will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature i C Date Mv name is! I live on: -hl'- Arcadia CA 91007. lam also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luoug in their attempt to change their address of44 W: Witraria Avc. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of ha home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from personal Knowledge. If galled to be a witness before the Arcadia City Counell, l ant competent to do so. I suppon Ms. Gina Ton and stake the Declaration tinder penalty of perjury render the laws of the State of California. Signature ��c- Eut� /,_ - -(i'--c�✓ ------------ - f/ Vii' i it My name is: �1 /FI I live on: i�7c -6A, /�� r Arcadia CA 9100_. 1 am also Cf- fP�.a,/+a -- the property owner of the aforemention prop 1 support Ms. Gina 'Ion and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire cornmunity because her address depresses the home price for at) future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Kimwlcdec. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the lawn of the State of California, Signature Date 7 �`rc L My name is: K I live on. ..0 -1_`?- "'' ! <tzG Y O� Z , Arcadia CA 9100_ _. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned propem'. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 H : FfUtaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as to surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration front Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury wider the Jaws of the Stoic of California. �� .. t2. Sienature Date �4F C, r My name is: _ Vl�l f i live nn: yyk Ma Y�ow %< Attrg ., , Arcadia CA 91oo b. 1 am also the property owner of a aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina'fon and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 H! Wisrario Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If caved to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration wider penalty of perjury tinder the laws of the State of California. Signature Wfelii� Date / My name is ! �� ✓CY ✓; ' /'1 A- I live nn: P) ``' ; (� /�-i- �-r. , �!��' . ! % -� . Arcadia CA 91007. I am also the property owner of the aforementinned pmpem•. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change her address of44 HC H'Waria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial unpact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina'[ on and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Califomia. Signature _ r Date My name is: 1 /1// C Il 1 / C /a, //�� O9 Zl I live on: L ?7 1W, L'LCA� 4 i/P , Arcadia CA. 9100_. I am also the property owner of the ifforeme6oned 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of 44 If' . &istaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depreases the home price for all future purchasers of her home as wall as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury tinder the laws of the State of California. r A 1 Date I live om —A1L-6KkLP A14 __ AIJAV— f(a�,-Arcadia CA 91007. lamalso the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Crine'1 on and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address I of 44 W. Wistaria Arr. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the enure corm sanity because her addmss depresses the }come price for all timire purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. 1 support Daniel Luong and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under die laws of the State of California. Signature Daic I My name is: I live on: G��lYf ft��Qa�,�ry�'1r1'Adl�,,f Arcadia CA 910(r. lam also the property owner of the aforementioned. property. I support Ms. Gma'1'on and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to charmc their address cf 44 W. Wistaria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council- I am competent to do so. I support Daniel Luong and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury tinder the laws of the State of California. Sitmature Date LI' My name is: I live on- 1,±' _P1 ,7 Arcadia CA 9100 — . I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her ttm Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of 44 N: WtstariaAre. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. iJ called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. 1 am competent to do so. i support Ms. Giaa Tom and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws (it the State of California Darr A M7 natnc is:.---- -� --- - - - - -- - --- --- - - ---- r I live on: C:- J Arcadia CA 9100. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property i I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in Uteir attempt to change their address of 44 W R9staria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impacr on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration front Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Calftbmia. Signature Dart My name is: l/p I live on: ,� acf_ _.fief u AYInJ, `.Arcadin CA 9100 __ Iamalso the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of 44 R: W uraria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I snake this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City CounciL I am competent to do so. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Calhomia. y _ � Date , / !� 2.c /- + /-- -- ----- --'--_...-- My name is: - .fiu' 'n � 1 1 I live on_ ' a (se—'a, __ , Arcadia CA 91006. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property, I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their auempt to change their address of 44W Wistaria Ave. Ganging her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire commmnity because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge, It called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Daniel Luong and make the Declaratitm under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature Date c �cel Mynameis: cv W ,L'1, I live on: �.:— �_A -v,C- . Arcadia CA 9100. I am also the property o ner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Grin Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to cYtange their address of 44 If: Wisrwia Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. 1. make this Declaration dorm Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. t� I Date �q•?nn My name is: I live on: i 2 Arcadia CA 9100 1 ant also the property owner of the afore ^entitmed property. 1 support Ms. Gina Tan and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact an the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all furore purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council. 1 am, competent to do so. I support his. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. SignawC. '7 �yC —' Date My name name is: I live on: ;.i, t� / �j_b��c. -t { -_ -fit Arcadia CA 9100_ 1 stn also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina'lon and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address f44 W Wistaria Ave, Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire communtty because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. 11 called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. i I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty ol. perjury under the laws of the State of California. Sigtawe Dare i i My name is: I live on: 3a� VV VVd m/ , e__ " Arcadia CA 91IX16. lam also the property owrnr of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers; of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Connell, I am competent to do so. I support Daniel Luong and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under tilt laws of the State of California. Signature 6i A �pn'�✓ My name is: -V'Z 4111 leir1 N.4 I live on: I, _ - .1- AC/'t Arcadia. CA 9100_ . 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of 44 A: Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers other home as well u the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the taw:, of the State of California. Signature Date %C^ 4 u MV namC la: c�+ ! � V 1/ f� i I live on: j C � ) ; - il% CW m : AVP ' , Arcadia CA 9100_. I am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 W Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her borne as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. support Ms. Gina Tan and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Stan; of California. Signature �; ` -- ' ---- - --` -- Date my name is: I live on: 26 C G /- 47N � /� '`l�_ , Arcadia CA 9100 7 I am nlso the property owner o f the afaremenrinned propen)•. I support Ms. Ginu Ton and her son Daniel Luang in their attempt to change their address of 44 If. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding home;. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council.. 1 am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws Of the State of California, ✓(� Signature Date I F-,*-",--,--,-,------, My name is: I live on: ��q LOS Arcadia CA 9100_, , lam also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina •Ion and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change their address of 44 W Wicaaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature Date _� ' 13 vale My name is: /' c. a tA, F' 1 live nn: L� —1 i 6 p y r f Arcadia CA 91007. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel Luong in their attempt to change her address of 44 9. Wistaria Ale. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surroundmg homes. 1 make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to he a witness before the Arcadia City Council. 1 am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina'I on and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws ofthe State of California. Signature c, Dare t V x v (i r M,v name is: i ✓ h _ �1 P�G1 I live cur: t �.�._.....� j:�YrL' n�rr Arcadia CA 9100. 1 am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. I support Ms. (Tina Tom and her son Daniel Luring in their attempt to change their address of 44 W FFWaria Are. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home puce for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness hetore the Arcadia City Council, l am competent to do so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signature _7,' ; ylr�, -- I., My name is: LPLA47J !�NZ7g7�29i l I live on: /b? / ti . ri, fr' Au �yrr , Arcadia CA 9100.6 i am also the property owner of the aforementioned property. 1 support Ms. Gina Ton utd her son Daniel Diong in their attempt to change their address of 44 W. Wistaria Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City Council, I am competent to do so. I support luong's family and [Hake the Declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California. Signal My name is: _ J't ? ' I live on: _37 4J tOt-Y;S vArZ Arcadia CA 9100. I am also the property owner of the aforctuenti med propernl. I support Ms. Gina Ton and her son Daniel l.uortg, in their attempt to change their address of 44 I6: Ikioariu Ave. Changing her address will have a beneficial impact on the entire community because her address depresses the home price for all future purchasers of her home as well as the surrounding homes. I make this Declaration from Personal Knowledge. If called to be a witness before the Arcadia City (lorucil, I am competent to du so. I support Ms. Gina Ton and make the Declaratiou under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State cf Calitomia. Signature; .�r„�: �� Date. ° N 7 O 2 rn a) Q a) cn a) E O C a a N to Cn Cl) co N CA co Il- co 00 C) N C` M co O Cl) co M co M_ M CO M M 0 Cl) Cl) 00 � M O O Lr) N O N 7 L9 r N N — N O co Q ti co CD CD co co CD co C` CD m O a0 O O O 00 O O O_ O O_ O O_ O O_ O O_ O O O Cn CA m 0) _O CA CA O) O O Cn O CA CA N 7. U rn m m co co co m U m U U U U U U m m m m m m m cc m m Q E m .0 E m m m m m m c a m m m m m m m m m m m m m L 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 0 2 2 U) Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q al � N > (� m U U m Q w > a) m c — m Q Q m E c ° E o U C13 m (n z 2 'S = O CL cn LL- LL O FL U a) m N W W N 'd Q m x ° N 7 O 2 rn a) Q a) cn a) E O C Z 3: W W v v v v v v v v �v O Lr) O M O O r-_ O N O r — O O O N CD O Cl) Cl) O M Cl) 00 00 N O 00 ('7 I� ti N (� ti LO LO to "Zi' O_ � r 00 O_ )` r r O LT O O D) CA _O d) O _O O) O O (A O) m m m m U U U U Y Y Y Y m m m m m m m m m U m m m m c- a U U U U m U U U U > m m m m m m m m m ai a) "v _0 '0 � E 'o 16 16 � a� m m a� co U U U U U L U U O O O O Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q N Q > 0 Q Mn Q > Q D U) > m m Q Q m O � N C U) m O C ` O m m a m O C m N a- O Fn V_) 'O O m m m O D m _N 2 - Q S U z Of -i W IL 2 Q Z 3: W W v v v v v v v v �v a a C to s v a+ O C fA a E a a s s 3 ai ba C R s u L a .o E C a L L O L O O a s a y O Z a a CL E 0 u a a 0 a s C O E m .v C O a s N .m m u L a x� C} � O O O O O O rl ei rl ri a M � I Y •� L 'u a E F� ;v m _ N w LM w ra Q a c c TO m Q ai ba C R s u L a .o E C a L L O L O O a s a y O Z a a CL E 0 u a a 0 a s C O E m .v C O a s N .m m u L a 04"', � Ci'- r of Ban GiIb if Date: Property Owner Name: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ENGINEERING DIVISION APPLICATION FOR ADDItESS CHANGE Phone Number: C__} - Existing Address: Proposed Address: Reason: ❑ Personal Preference ❑ Address Verification ❑ Address Changes in Conjunction w/ Building Permit ❑ Other - Procedure for requesting a change of address: The Change of Address fee is $ 1,180.00. • The following documents must be provided: o Copy of Grant Deed o. Copy of electric utility bill o Site plan showing adjacent properties and addresses • The request will be reviewed by Police, Fire, Engineering, Planning, and Building. Please allow 3 -5 weeks for processing. • If approved, the owner must inform all public agencies and utility companies that provide service to the property. The City will notify the U.S. Postal Service. • If the request is not approved the property owner will be refunded 80% of the fee. Signature of Applicant: FOR CITY USE ONLY ❑ Approved ❑ Denied By Engineering Div.: — Notes: Date of Decision: City Hall: 425 South Mission Drive, San Gabriel, California's Mail: P.O. Box 130, San Gabriel, California 91778 -0130 626- 308 -2800 * FAX 626 -458 -2830 F:1Community Develonmentl Enaineerina\Enaineerina\Address ChanaelCHANGE OF ADDRESS Form 2011.docx o� o>ur��,� . s H V i,.701(1: j' if e'9LIfOR��P.1 Fee: $638.00 Paid Acct. 10 -614 APPLICATION FOR ADDRESS CHANGE Section 16.040.060 of Monterey Park Municipal Code Property Owner: Mailing Address: Telephone Number: Property Address: Assessor's Parcel Number: Proposed Property Address: Document Presented for Proof of Ownership: Signature For Office Use Only. ❑ APPROVED ❑ REJECTED Reason: Signature of Approving Official s:' engineering \templata�address\address change appGcation.de< Revised July, 2009 t N K O o o a � .o -u Erin 8 M ~ Q O o, F51 m ❑ O ❑ k Z N W F 0 ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ el z N ,q 4 1 t 1 8 3 St o � lot tie x ° 06 -- I H xs 8g o 162 to c� K O o o a � .o -u Erin V o, h/ ��dD 5unclay, 4c,f, 2, ?,0 // pasadenastamews.com I A3 Addressing number 4 Superstition hurts .Arcadia `home sales By Brenda Gazzar Staff Writer ARCADIA - The fear of four ha, prompted Arcadia officials to agree tc revisit the city's scontroversi&policy of not allowing ;homeowners !tc change their addresses. Months after: upholding the policy, the City Council has .agreed to con• sider it again'after several homeown• ers complained they can't sell their homes at fair market value due to a popular Chinese belief. The number four is considered unlucky by many in'the Chinese cul- ture since it sounds like the word for death in ,Mandarin. And addresses with multiple fours are considered particularly inauspicious. "It has a real impact on people," Mayor Gary Kovacic said. "I don't think we can cast it off as a nutty superstition. I think we have to look at the true economic impact of this, whether you believe in this supersti- tion or not." Arcadia has an Asian population approaching 60 percent, and many potential buyers in the city are 'Chi- nese, officials have said. The issue, which -was 'discussed -at. the Sept. .20 City Council meeting, will likely be placed on the Nov. 1 agenda, City Manager Don Penman said, "It's probably one that merits a full council," he said, rnoting that not all five council members will be present at future council: meetings until then. "It looks like it will be a significant discussion, and who knows how it's going to end up." In June, the council voted 3 -2 to rescind a policy on the books since 1991 that allowed customer - requested address changes for a fee. Unaware the council had approved the policy years before, the Development':Ser- vices Departmentstopped allowing it about five years ago due to a high volume of requests and difficulties it created for city record- keeping, offi- cials have said. Daniel Luong, 28, said he and his mother have been trying to sell their WaItIMIMMl'Staff Photographer Daniel Luong and his .mother have been trying to sell their home at 44 W. Wistaria Ave:'in.Arcadia since March, but have had no success. The number four is considered unlucky by many in Chinese culture. Arcadia has an Asian population near 60 percent and many potential buyers in the city are Chinese, officials said. home at 44 W. Wistaria Ave. since March, when his father. unexpectedly passed away. "We are desperate, and we feel that we are the victims in this case," he told the council on Sept. 6. Luong said his next door neighbor, who has an older home and almost the same lot dimensions, was able to sell his property for $1.7 million "within weeks" of listing it. In con - trast,'their home has'been listed for months unsuccessfully for just over $1.4 million, he said. "Every offer we've received, has been contingent on whether -the address was able to be changed or not," Luong said. More than a dozen potential buyers were interested in that property, but when they found out that the city was not going to change its policy, "they walked away," said Jean Tang of RE /MAX Premier Properties. "This is not ... superstitious stuff," she said in an email. "This is a real situation (that) exists in our society right now as more and more Chinese immigrants move to Arcadia" Homeowner Man Tat Chin, who lives at 44. W. Foothill Blvd., also has requested the council reverse its pol- icy, noting in -a letter that "buyers have told us they will not even con - sider living in a house numbered 44." Tang said she has collected more than 100 signatures from Arcadia resi- dents who, are opposed to the -city's current policy. Several cities in the San Gabriel Valley allow homeowners to change their address for a fee, including Rose- mead, Temple City, Alhambra and West Covina. But Councilman Roger Chandler, who voted against reinstating the pol- icy in June, said he'thinks it would be "bad public policy" to change it. Not only would, the city have to notify some ;20 agencies so that the new addresses can be updated'invari, ous systems, any errors or lack of notification: could affectfirst,respond- ers in an emergency, he said. "Personally, I don't think .q,✓ should operate public policy on super- stition," Chandler said. brende:gaaanaagmeom 626.578.6300, ext. 4496 ` SONNY CONSTRUCTION a DEVELOPMENT CORP 68 GENOA ST UNIT A ARCADIA CA 91006 Phone 626 - 3744083 Uc B737977 Fu 626- 574 -8693 Gary A. Kovacic, Mayor City of Arcadia City Council P.O. Box 60021 Arcadia, CA 91066 -6021 Dear Mayor Kovacic, RECEIVED CITY OF AR.CADIA OCT 17 2011 CITY couNCIL October 5, 2011 I am writing to you as a concerned Arcadia citizen, business owner, and Arcadia real estate developer in regards to the issue of allowing property address changes. Aware of the ongoing issue, I wanted to voice my support in allowing property owners to apply to change their addresses. As a real estate developer there are times where we do not purchase properties ending with a "4" for development, even though the property is in a desirable location. This is not due to our personal superstitions but it is a fact that these properties are harder to resell once they are complete. Property values are lower if it has an address ending with a "4." We understand the City's point of view of not allowing address changes for safety reasons, however many of our neighboring cities (with a good Asian population) allow such change with no issues. To combat unwarranted and frequent address changes, I suggest that the City raise the fee substantially, perhaps to $2,000 45,000 so that only serious homeowners will go through the process. In return this will help hire additional staff to process applications if needed. Also, the City can limit the number of times a property can change the address so there won't be unnecessary and frequent requests. We believe properties should be valued based on their characteristics and location and not be affected by a simple number that could be changed. We cannot control what people's superstitions are but sadly it is a fact that this number affects home values negatively. I trust the City will be fair in the assessment and will make a decision from an economical, not superstition standpoint. Respectfully yours, Sunny Chan / President Jeffrey K Bowen 1919 Wilson Avenue Arcadia, California 91005 October 5, 2011 Arcadia City Council City Hall 240 W. Huntington Drive Arcadia, California 91007 Mayor and Council, RECEIVED rrTY OF ARCADIA OCT 0 6 2011 G,lTy COUNCIL I am very pleased that you have decided to re -visit the issue of allowing Arcadia homeowners to change their street address slightly, for a fee, to remove a number "4 ". (Pasadena Star -News, October 2, 2011) I have been a realtor in Arcadia since 1985, and I know the significant financial impact a "4" has on the sale of a property. Like it or not, it is a big problem, today. I am preparing to list a home in Arcadia with the address of "44 ". The sellers are keenly aware, as am I as their realtor, that their address is going to present a challenge, ultimately impacting the price, unless they are allowed to change the address. Please give this issue fair consideration, and think how you would feel, if you lived in a house numbered "44 ", and wanted to sell it in the Arcadia real estate market, as it exists today. cerely, r, effrey K. Bowen From: Iaelandtom(daol.com fmailtodaelandtom0aol.com] Sent: Monday, October 03, 20115:00 PM To: City Council Email Subject: To Roger Chandler Dear Councilman Chandler, I so appreciate your position on the "number 4" address matter. No one group should be given preference over the laws of our City. I just sent this to the Star News: Regarding your article, "Addressing number 4," here is yet another, "exception" being contemplated for a particular group of people. Look around Arcadia and notice the bending of the law regarding business signs and window advertisements. Not a pretty sight to this long time Arcadian. This is the second time I have had to write about this, "number 4" fiasco, and I hope it's the last. While sorry for the owners who can't sell, this IS America and I trust any new residents are aware of our regulations before choosing to come here. Lael Blocker Arcadia (626) 446 -0912 I hope you will continue to oppose any change in the existing policy. Welcoming immigrants is one thing, but catering to their unique beliefs is another. My regards and thanks, Mrs. Leal Blocker From: Terri Anderson [mailto:terberyOmsn.coml Sent: Monday, October 03, 20116:41 PM To: Mary Buttice Subject: To The Entire City Council: Houses With a Number Four in the Address A home with a number 4 in the address in Arcadia, owned by an Asian, doesn't sell. The homeowner blames the non -sale on an Asian superstition regarding the number 4. If my husband & I were to own the same home and it didn't sell - what could we blame It on? We wouldn't have an excuse nor answer other than it's a lousy economy right now. And yes, we are Caucasian. We are sick to death of honoring other ethnicities' quirks, rules and superstitions. We live in the United States of America. Yes, we welcome all who come here legally to live. But we have taken it to the extreme. We have the worst economy in history. People are out of work. To bend rules for a silly superstition Is a slap in the face to the Americans who have lived and worked here their entire lives. And the cost of such a frivolous change? The city and state economies can't sustain this hit - changing maps, emergency personnel information, etc. It is not a simple number change. Surely a buyer will come along to buy a property with a "4" In the address. But until then, let the homeowner join the rest of Americans who are trying to sell in a buyers' market. Either re- evaluate your home, the price you want, or enhance the home's assets. If my husband and I were to somehow buy a home /property in an Asian country and that real estate had 666 or the number 13 in its address - could we ask the Asian government to change the number to suit our beliefs? I think not. Please keep Arcadia as it is. We have already suffered through the monster mansions. To ask the local government to change the residential address system to suit a certain ethnic group so it will enhance the resale value is absurd. Our local government has more important issues It should be addressing and not an address - that may or may not mean the sale of a home to a nervous seller. Terri Anderson Arcadia From: Mike Jones [mailto : mike ljean2@0verizon net] Sent: Tuesday, October 04, 201112:34 PM To: City Council Email Subject: Address changes I don't believe the City Council should entertain the thought about allowing immigrants to this city to change their address because numbers in the address are superstitious in their beliefs. I live on South Tenth and there are plenty of Asians buy houses here and could care less about numbers in the address. Are you going to let Asian immigrants and real estate agents come here and step on our culture and create animosity between Asians and the citizens of this community? Immigrants that come to the United States of America need to adapt to our way of life and our culture and not rape our Country of our benefits afforded to U.S. citizens just because they have a lot of money!! As far as I can see Councilman Rodger Chandler Is the only one that can see through this superstitious hokey pokey as a waste of TAX PAYER'S money and not be impressed by someone because they have a lot of money!! On another note what does It take to get Public Works to fill pot holes? I live on S. Tenth between Camino Real and Duarte Rd. my self and a few neighbors have called to get pot holes filled, they came buy filled five or six then left. There are some on this street that are pretty good size that remain to be fixed. They use a quick cold patch that floats out after a couple rain storms, why can't Public Works use a hot asphalt and roll It and be done with it instead of coming back year after year. Sincerely: Mike Jones October 25, 2011 City of Arcadia Mayor Peter Amundson Dear Mr. Amundson: j6bvn Min support the City's decision of not allowing - changing numbers on the address. The change is mainly to benefit real estate agents' earningslcommission due to irrational Asian superstition. My address has 4 on it for two decades and it doesn't bother me a bit. Sincerely, Andy Lin �K (Fv Y in L I ,*n_._� 1\ Jeffrey K. Bowen 1919 Wilson Avenue Nov Arcadia, California 91006�� yr co November 6, 2011 Mickey Segal City Council 240 W. Huntington Drive Arcadia, CA.91007 Subject: Street Address Changes, Proposed As a follow -up to your request, at the City Council meeting, I offer you the following response. I moved to Arcadia as a child, with my family in 1950. I have watched Arcadia grow and prosper since then. Our City was developed primarily with the sale of individual lots, with custom horses being built upon those lots. It wa:, i,YGt developed with huge tracts, like so many cities. As a result, it is not an easy task to give you specific and exacting comparable facts, with regard to the sale of one house with, say, two number fours, versus one without. I will do my best to answer your request (see attached). I do know, however, that in the course of my daily profession of selling real estate in Arcadia, addresses ending in the number four are a challenge, and the more fours, the bigger the challenge. That knowledge comes from experience and is very real. Sincerely, ii ��•- if i ---feff Bowen DRE #00890644 cc: All Members of the City= Council According to Current MLS Records (Multiple Listing Service) November, 2011 44 W. Foothill Blvd, Arcadia 201 Days on the Market. "No Sale" 444 W. Huntington Drive, #220, Arcadia 89 Days on the Market. "Sold" 444 W. Huntington Drive, #211, Arcadia 177 Days on the Market. "No Sale" 244 Arbolada Drive, Arcadia 450 Days on the Market. "No Sale" 344 W. Foothill Blvd., Arcadia 141 Days on the Market, "No Sale" 44 W Wistaria AV Arcadia 91007 3 W- Pamela kd ( >^ 0tr`tT Status: XlSanta Anita Terrace Central ML #: A *Camino Real Ave I' Laundry: APN: W °Winne -way 'i?� Bathtub, Shower Orig. List Price: W'*'rJW Ave._.._ I Eating Area: Price Per Sqft: Shard M I .I -w Lemon Ave (144 Wistaria Ave County: N Pool: Property Type: W wistaria Ave__ None Bedrooms: )� Sprinklers: Bath(F,T,H,Q): W Las Fiore; Ave -- Arcadia a. - -E- Las - Flores Ave Sqft (Src): w Arthur Ave 5 E Arthur -'Ave Ac /LotSgft (Src) YY Longden Ave E Longden Ave AC: l View: Parking n Pool: Parking: Horse: ®2011 Mimsoa Cep 4*000 NAVIEg ina/erTele ACa ;.Inc. List Price 000 Hold Do Not Show A11073405 5788002018 $1,468,000 $657.59 Los Angeles Single Family Residence /D 3 3,0,0,0 2,167 /Assessor's Data 0.44119,095 (A) Yes Yes No Area: 605 -Arcadia Stories: One Level DOM /CDOM: 93193 Cross Street: Santa Anita Ave Entry Location: Units Total #: 1 Map Book: Year Built: 1952 1ASS Senior Communitv: N Sale Type. Standard Lease Considered: N Description *Baldwin Stocker School* Moving in condition. Huge lot (95x201 sqft) with potential to add addition for a bigger house or build your dream home. Beautiful Immaculate interior. Previous owner converted 2 bedrooms into one big master suite and converted the garage into a bedroom. There is a good size detached storage room behind the carport. Buyer to verify themselves with city. Property is priced as "land value" and is sold at its "as is" and "where is" condition. Interior Features Fireplace: Family Room, Living Room Cooling: Central Heating: Natural Gas Laundry: Individual Room Interior: Bathtub, Shower Rooms: Master Bedroom Eating Area: Formal Dining Room Floor: Wall -To -Wall Carnet. Hardwood Exterior Features Pool: None Spa: None Patio: Deck Sprinklers: View: Mountain Structure: Outdoors: Yard Fence: Lot/Community: Lot - Level /Flat Leval: Garage and Parking Gar Att/Det.: Parking Space: 2 Parking: Land Lot Number: 17 Block Number: Tract Number: 13414 Lot Dimensions: Association Name: Association Phone: Lease /Fees Land Fee /Lease: Fee Land Lease Amount: Land Transfer Fee: Land Lease Purchase Terms — Possession: Cooking Appliances Appliances: Utilities: 220 Volt Location: Style: Ranch Exterior: Roofino: Comoosition Garage Spaces: 0 Zone: Units Total Number: 1 Builder's Tract: Assessment: None Complex/Community: Association Dues: Association Amenities: Date of Land Lease Renew: Stove Dishwasher Carport Spaces: 2 RV Dimensions: # of Remotes: School Information School District: Elementary School: Junior High School: High School: Listing Terms: Cash To New Loan Make of Home: Model Name: Model Code: Arcadia Unified Baldwin Stocker First Ave Arcadia High ycl n run - rcesluunoar rage 1 or L ML #: A11073105 Printed By Jeffery Bowen DRE: 00690644 on 11/02/11 Office /MLS . SO Comp: 2.50% Dual Var Rate: No Listing Office: (3467) Re /Max Premier Prop Arcadia Listing Agent: (A37547) Jih Tang LA DRE: 01755519 List Date: 06/0912011 Modification Date: 09/22/2011 Agent Remarks: Currently number "44" can not be changed Comparable Information Date of Pending: 93193 DOM /CDOM: Selling Agent: SA DRE: Co- Selling Agent: CoSA DRE: Show Instr.: Appointment Only, Call Listing Agent Key Safe Desc.: No Key Safe Key Safe Loc.: Call Listing Agent LO Phone: 626 - 229.2200 LO Fax: 626- 229 -2201 List Type: Exclusive Right To Sell Service Type: Full Service Listing Paid: Int List/Addrss: Yes /Yes VOW AVM? /Comm ?:Yes /Yes Showing Type: Showing Name: Showing Phone: Phone Contact Priority 1. LA Cell: 626 -456 -3815 Please no contingency on number changesl . End Date: Selling Office: Co- Selling Office: Financing Type Used: Selling Price: List Price: $1,425,000 Original Price: Sold Terms: �yern run - KE!Siaenaai rage L of 2 ML #: A11073405 Printed By Jeffery Bowen DRE: 00890644 on 11/02/11 CALLING A SPADE A SPADE 11 It is truly very gratifying to realize that there Mv— sWWome people who can speak their opinions without being afraid 0f4 someone being offended 11 1 *r The actions of the three councilmen who voted against our M community allowing certain nationalities to change our rules regarding private home " numbers" was truly amazing and very admirable 1 There are always two sides to every debate, however in this case, it just did not make any sense for all of our entire community to bow to the wishes of just a handful of people. There will always be conflicts arising out of the "beliefs" of the different ` ,, nationalities that make up any community 11 Some have true meaning and others just are coming from the "I beliefs" of a handful of certain citizens. The fihi l path that's followed by any City council really needs to take into serious consideration how it will effect the entire community. Even when cetain actions or beliefs effect various types of Businesses monetarily, they need to be exposed for what they really are and who is behind them. There is absolutely No reason for us to bend over and give into these various types of human "beliefs" which effect our entire community! Congratulations to the three councilmen who had the nerve to stand their ground and NOT allow just a few special Homeo vners that `kind of `personal` anion `to just �sndisfy their personal beliefs .►11 ARCADIA TAMA YEPS 111 Arcadia address-change up the issue in June, argued that it was an easy thing that could be done to help the city's policy debated again in citizens who are having trouble fight of fear of four By Brenda Gazzar, Staff Writer Posted: 11/03/2011 11:29:20 PM PDT 4RCADIA - A city policy that does not allow property owners to request a change in address, respite concerns some have about the fear of the number four, will remain in place for now. Although the City Council upheld its policy in June in a 3 -2 vote, it debated the issue again this week after several residents complained they were having difficulty selling their homes at fair market value due to a traditional Chinese belief. The number four is considered unlucky by some in the Chinese culture since it sounds like the word for death in Mandarin and Cantonese. Street addresses of 4, 44 and 444 are considered particularly inauspicious, according to local real estate agents, Councilman Mickey Segal, who voted in June to uphold the policy, said Tuesday he would reconsider his vote on the issue if "factual information" was offered demonstrating the number four in street addresses was indeed affecting property values in the city. "It triggers a number of questions for me since I'm a numbers guy, and numbers usually don't lie," Segal, an accountant, told his colleagues. "in order for me to make an informed and intelligent decision, I need the facts that support the argument that it affects real estate prices." Otherwise, he said, "it's purely speculation." But Councilman Bob Harbicht, who first brought selling their homes. Some of these residents have lived in their homes for decades and consider them their most valuable asset, he said. "We could so simply change it," he said, noting the city had allowed it for 16 years before it stopped taking requests about five years ago. "We have experience with this," The city could fully recoup its costs by charging a recommended fee of about $2,250, he said. The city's Asian population is close to 60 percent and many potential buyers in the city are Chinese. Barbara Birney told the council Tuesday that after her husband became paralyzed recently, they have found themselves in a position of having to sell their home, which has a street address of 44 Ontare Road. "We're being told (by real estate agents) that because our number is 44, that it could cost us maybe even $100,000," she said, asking the council to reconsider its position. SAVE up to 64 Pius, get a FR FE GiRs Special Code! 4SD69ZWN Print Povtrered By N.'. rt h �'_` ~T http: / /www.pasadenastarnews.coni/fdcp ?unique = 1320680397963 Another resident, Daniel Luong, who lives at 44 W. Wistaria Ave., said he has been trying to sell his home unsuccessfully since March. He and his real estate agent say they have received numerous offers conditional on him being able to change his home address. Councilman Peter Amundson said he was concerned that the city could be flooded with requests for address changes and noted there was room for error when notifying all the necessary agencies of the change, including the post office. Several real estate agents, including Luong's, said after Tuesday's council meeting that they would try to provide Segal and the rest of the council with the information requested. The June vote by the council rescinded a policy on the books since 1991 - but not in practice - that allowed customer- requested address changes for a fee. Unaware the council had approved the policy years before, the Development Services Department stopped allowing it about five years ago due to a high volume of requests and difficulties it created for city record- keeping. Arcadia real estate agent Jeff Bowen said he thought it would be difficult to find apples -to- apples comparisons that would satisfy Segal's request since unlike Rancho Cucamonga, Arcadia doesn't have rows of tract homes that are identical. "In Arcadia, the houses are all custom - built, they were sold as lots, this isn't a tract city, and it's not built that way," he said. Finding equivalent comparisons is "extremely difficult to do but I'm willing to sit down on the computer and try to do something for him." brenda.gazzar@sgvn.com 626 -578 -6300, ext. 4496 Print Powered By A� littp:/ /v;ww.nasadenastaniews.com /fdcp ?unique= 1320680397963 11 /7/2011