Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1-1-00 - 12-31-00 (2)AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 11, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 99 -015 301 Joyce Ave. Alexander Gomez Sleeter, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the approval of excessive pruning of two neighboring oak trees (Sec. 9704b.1). Approved subject to the condition that 2 new 36" boxed oak trees be planted under the supervision and approval of an arborist 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -001 411 E. Huntington Dr. Alex Magat Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -002 2307 S. Sixth Ave. Michael D. Klipa Approved for a 20'x30' 3 -car garage. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -003 1611 Rodeo Rd. Andrew Lee Requesting 428 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 498 spaces required for a proposed 1,121 sq. ft. dental office to be within an existing shopping center (9269.5). Requesting a rear yard coverage of 40.5% in lieu of 25% permitted for a detached garage and storage area (9252.2.9.1). Requesting a 6' -0" solid masonry wall in lieu of 5' -0" permitted along a street side yard (9252.2.12.2). Approved subject to the following conditions: 1. That a landscape and irrigation plan be submitted subject to the review and approval of Development Services Department. The landscaping shall be dense to minimize the stark affect of the wait 2. The solid masonry wall between the Pilaster columns shall be stucco treated to match the exterior of the dwelling. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMIT11 E MEMBERS PRESENT: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by January 19, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 00 -001 808 Magnolia Ln. Bade Construction Co., Inc. Denied 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo Continued to 2/8 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -005 1 Altura Rd. John & Catherine Fara Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMI1°I'EE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Sleeter, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the removal of an oak tree within the front yard area in order to accomm ate a driveway for a new single - family residence (S . 9704b.1). Req sating a 30' -0" front yard setback in lieu of 40' -6" requi for,.iiew single- family dwelling. The required tba is the average of the two nearest developed lots :2). Requesting a 12' -0" street side yard setback in lieu of 20' -0" required to convert an existing attached two -car garage into a recreation room (9212.2.3.1). Huang, Butler, Rowe Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 2, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM Revised ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 00 -001 808 Magnolia Ln. Bade Construction Co., Inc. Denied 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo Continued to 2/8 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -005 1 Altura Rd. John & Catherine Faraone Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMI'I°I"EE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the removal of an oak tree within the front yard area in order to accommodate a driveway for a new single - family residence (Sec. 9704b.1). Requesting a 30' -0" front yard setback in lieu of 40' -6" required for new single- family dwelling. The required setback is the average of the two nearest developed lots (9251.2.2). Requesting a 12' -0" street side yard setback in lieu of 20' -0" required to convert an existing attached two -car garage into a recreation room (9212.2.3.1). Huang, Butler, Rowe Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 2, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -006 2326 Florence Ave. Ja Ao Robinson Huang ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMIT °1'EE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting a 30' -0" front ya • setback in lieu of 40' -6" required for new single -f .. ily dwelling. The required setback is the average • ' the two nearest developed lots (9251.2.2). R4uesting the following modifications for a proposed f eestanding BBQ and patio cover: A. A 6' -0" building separation in lieu of 10' -0" required between the proposed patio cover post and a recreation room (9252.2.9.1). B. A 4' -0" overhand encroachment into the southerly side yard setback in lieu of a permitted 2' -0" overhand (9252.2.7.2). C. A 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" required for the BBQ structure (9252.2.9.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting an accessory portion of a new single- family residence to have a height variation of 21' -0" to 27' -0" in lieu of 16' -0" permitted when located 25' -0" from the rear yard property line (9251.2.9.1.) Approved subject to the condition that the applicant shall submit a landscape and irrigation plan that shall provide at a minimum the plantini 24" box trees adjacent to the rear accessory portion of the house to provide visual relief subject to staff's review and approval. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -006 2326 Florence Ave. Ja Ao Robinson Huang Continued to 2/22/00 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting the following modifications for a proposed freestanding BBQ and patio cover: A. A 6' -0" building separation in lieu of 10' -0" required between the proposed patio cover post and a recreation room (9252.2.9.1). B. A 4' -0" overhand encroachment into the southerly side yard setback in lieu of a permitted 2' -0" overhand (9252.2.7.2). C. A 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" required for the BBQ structure (9252.2.9.1). Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 14, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -010 411 E. Huntington Dr., #114 Xiu Zhen Fang Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -011 41 E. Live Oak Ave. Susan Brown Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -013 247 E. Forest Ave. Stephen Lam Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -014 1111 S. First Ave. Chinnaportn Korprapun Approved 5. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -003 939 Hampton Rd. Scott Yang/Jeff Lee Approved subject to the arborist's recommendations. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 428 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 498 spaces required for a proposed 466 sq. ft. acupuncture clinic to be within an existing shopping center (9269.5). Requesting two wall signs (Cal Fed., California Federal Bank) with a combined area of 130 sq. ft. in lieu of 25 sq. ft. permitted, for any exterior sign when located within a C -0 zone property (9261.4.1.). Requesting a 4' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 5' -0" for the following: A. A conversion of an existing single car garage into a living area B. An addition/remodel of an existing kitchen and dining room (9252.2.3.). Requesting a 4' -0" to 5' -0" wrought iron fence and column height, in lieu of 3' -0" permitted along the front property line (9252.2.12.1.). Requesting the construction of a circular driveway within the drip line of two oak trees in the front yard area (9704b.1.). Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by March 21, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 28, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -016 29 E. Huntington Dr. Hanfu Lee Approved subject to the ARA's approval of the proposed remodel/addition for the retail space and dental office. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -017 529 Workman Ave. Justin Kao Approved subject to the following condition: 1. The circular driveway shall he revised so the sycamore tree located in the public right -of way shall not be disturbed subject to staff's review and approval. 2. The applicant shall submit an arborist's report evaluating the tree trimming for the oak trees located in the rear yard ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 7 parking spaces (4 on -site and 3 in the City Parking District) in lieu of 25 on -site spaces for a remodel and addition to provide 2,177 sq. ft. of retail space and 2,315 sq. ft. of dental office (9264.3.4 & 9269.5). Requesting a 5 7' -6" required addition to an (9252.2.3). ' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of for a proposed 2,620 sq. ft. single -story existing 1,570 sq. ft. single - family home Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be tiled by April 4, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 28, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -016 29 E. Huntington Dr. Hanfu Lee Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -017 529 Workman Ave. Justin Kao Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Murphy, Rowe. Nicholson Requesting 7 parking spaces (4 on -site and 3 in the City Parking District) in lieu of 25 on -site spaces for a remodel and addition to provide 2,177 sq. ft. of retail space and 2.315 sq. ft. of dental office (9264.3.4 & 9269.5). Requesting a 5- -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -6" required for a proposed 2,620 sq. ft. single -story addition to an existing 1,570 sq. ft. single - family home (9252.2.3). COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy. Rowe. Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Pining There will he a Live working day appeal period. Appals are to be filed by April 4, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL II, 2000 ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -019 650 W. Duarte Rd., #107 Dr. David Ng Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -020 1101 Panorama Dr. Designer Series Pools & Spas Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Murphy. Rowe. Nicholson Requesting 244 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 338 spaces required for a proposed 773 sq. ft. dental office to be within an existing office complex center (9269.5). Requesting an 8' -6" street side yard setback in lieu of 20•-0" required to build 0 pool & spa (9251.2.11). COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy, RoNve. Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Pilling There will be a live vforking day appeal period. Appeals are to be tiled by April 18, 2000 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL 25, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -018 11711 Clark St. George Good Approved subject to the condition that existing buildings have blue stripping and that the entry canopy be renovated with a stucco finished subject to staffs review and approval. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -023 420 Arbolada Progressive Builders Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -024 1964 El Sereno Dr. Anthony Montes Approved subject to the condition that exterior materials and roof tiles be compatible with the house subject to staffs review and approval. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -026 426 Columbia Rd. Edward and Teresa Munoz Approved Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 108 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 117 spaces required for a proposed 30,368 sq. ft. expansion to an existing 28,040 sq. ft. industrial building (9269.5). Requesting a 48' -6" front yard setback, for a bay window, in lieu of the average front yard setback of the neighboring properties which is approximately 50' -3 ". (9251.2.2). NOTE: The ARB of the Santa Anita Oaks has approved the proposed plans. Requesting an 816 sq. ft. second floor addition to the main dwelling on a single - family zoned lot (R -1) with two single - family residences (9251.1.1.). Requesting the following modifications for an addition to the main dwelling: A. To allow a 3' -0" northerly side yard setback to be maintained in lieu of the 7' -0" required to relocate the existing two -car garage easterly 21' -0" (9252.2.3). B. To allow a 5' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of the 7' -0" required for a 38' -4" long, one -story addition to the rear of the house (9252.2.3). C. To allow a 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of the 7' -0" required for a new air - conditioning condenser to be located between the existing rear bedroom and bathroom (9252.2.1.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by May 2, 2000. 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -027 2535 S. Santa Anita Ave. Eddy Ip Approved subject to the following conditions subject to staff's review and approval: 1. Request "A" is to be revised to permit 3' -8" to 4' -2" high masonry columns in lieu of 3' -0" permitted 2. Light standards shall be limited to the driveway entry columns 3. The installation of decorative fence shall be subject to staffs review and approval prior to any installation 6. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -028 502 E. Camino Real Ave. David and Monica Olson Approved subject to the condition that a covenant, approved by the City Attorney, be recorded indicating that the recreation room will not be utilized as living quarters. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: NOTE: The ARB of the Santa Anita Village Assoc. has approved the proposed plans. Requesting the following modifications for a proposed wrought iron fence to be placed between existing decorative masonry columns along the site's front property line: A. 3' -8" to 5' -2" high masonry columns in lieu of 3' -0" permitted (9252.2.12.1). B. A front yard fence setback of 2' -3" in lieu of 3' -0" required from the front property line (9252.2.12.1.) C. A 1' -2" masonry base in lieu of an openwork design (i.e., a minimum of 4" between vertical and horizontal members). (9252.2.12.5.). D. A height of 3' -0" to 5' -0" in lieu of 3' -0" permitted for the proposed decorative wrought iron fencing to be placed between the masonry columns (9252.2.12.1.). NOTE: Said fence was built without permits and the owner wishes to legalize the existing design. Requesting the following modifications to enlarge a recreation room attached to the rear of a detached two -car garage: A. An 8' -4" street side yard setback along Fifth Ave. in lieu of 15' -0" (9252.2.9.1. and 9252.2.3.1). B. 1,260 sq. ft. of accessory structure (i.e., a 350 sq. ft. two -car garage, 670 sq. ft. recreation room, and 240 sq. ft. of breezeway /covered walkway) in lieu of an 800 sq. ft. maximum that is based on 50% of the existing one - story, 1,600 sq. ft. house (9252.2.9.1). Murphy, Nicholson, Rowe Burnett, Kasama, Phung Page 2 4/25/00 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 9, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -025 444 E. Huntington Dr. Tim Cox, Plazamerica, Inc. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -030 1009 N. First Ave. Lourdes Manalastas ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting a 3' -0" by 4' -0" double -sided lease sign along Huntington Dr. in lieu of 4 sq. ft. in area per face that is permitted for such leasing purposes (9262.4.10). Requesting a 3' -0" westerly rear yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" for a proposed attached two -car garage in conjunction with a remodel and addition to the existing single - family residence. This property is zoned R -2. (9253.2.6) There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by May 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 23, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -031 357 W. Duarte Rd. Magdalena Mok/HMK Const. Approved subject to the condition that the water fountain shall not exceed 4' high. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -032 509 Workman Ave. Lai Fu Chong & Rosanna Au Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -033 150 N. Santa Anita Ave. Frank Xie for E -Tech Trading Co. Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Murphy, Busch, Nicholson Requesting the following modifications for a water fountain and an existing decorative wrought iron fence to have masonry columns with 16" tall light standards: A. 4' -4" to 5' -4" high wrought iron fencing in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0" (9252.2.12.1). B. 5' -0" high masonry columns to be located at the driveway and pedestrian entries in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0 ", (9252.2.12.1). C. A proposed 6' -0" high water fountain in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0 ", (9252.2.12.1). D. A front yard fence setback of 1' -0" in lieu of 3' -0" required from the front property line (9252.2.12.1). NOTE: The wrought iron fencing and water fountain were built without City approvals, and the owner wishes to legalize such construction. Requesting an open porch that is approximately 20" above the adjacent grade and extends 7' -0" into the required front yard setback in lieu of 18" height with a 6' -0" encroachment (9252.2.8). Requesting a parking modification of 242 existing parking spaces in lieu of 247 required for a stock trading company to occupy 4,481 sq. ft. of general office space (9269.5). Murphy, Busch, Nicholson Kasama, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by May 31, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 13, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -034 400 Rolyn Pl. Stemcyte, Inc. Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -035 1009 N. Santa Anita Ave. A -Star Signs Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -036 378 Torrey Pines Dr. Bluth Development Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -037 411 E. Colorado Blvd. Sanyao Int'l Approved 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -038 1009 S. Sixth Ave. Sanyao Int'l Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 26 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 75 spaces required for a proposed biomedical laboratory to occupy an existing 15,000 -sq. ft. building (9269.5). Requesting a monument sign to be located within a special setback and to be within 100' of residentially zoned property in lieu of no monument sign permitted within said area (9320.65.3 & 9262.4.6.3.). Requesting a 5' -0" side yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" for a proposed badminton court (9250.3.3). Requesting one tandem parking space in lieu of providing a standard 3 -car garage (9252.2.6). Requesting a proposed decorative wrought iron fence with 18" high light standards on top of masonry columns at the driveway and pedestrian entries along the site's front property line and A. 3' -0" to 4' -0" high wrought iron fencing in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0" (9252.2.12.1). B. 3' -6" high masonry columns located along the front property line in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0 ". The columns at driveway and pedestrian entries will have 18" high light standards. (9252.2.12.1) Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by June 21, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 27, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -004 28 W. Grandview Ave. OC Construction Approved subject to the condition that 36" oak trees be planted on 20 W. Grandview, location to be determined by an arborist. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -029 1752 Wilson Ave. Hector Battifora Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -039 1540 Hyland Ave. Franco Noravian Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -040 21 E. Las Flores Susie Phan Approved, a covenant is to be recorded for the pool and gym room limiting the use and that a landscape and irrigation plan be submitted for the rear yard area. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the following modifications: A. To permit an encroachment into the dripline of two neighboring oak trees located along the site's easterly side property line (9704b.1). B. To permit the removal of an oak tree located in the center of the property (9704b.1). Requesting the following modifications for proposed additions to an existing main dwelling: A. 6' -10" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -0" required for a proposed bedroom and bathroom addition to align with the existing southerly elevation (9252.2.3). B. 8' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -0" and a 10' -0" rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0" for an 80 sq. ft. library extension (9252.2.32. & 9252.2.4). C. 7' -6" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -0" required for a proposed air conditioning condenser (9252.2.9.1.1 & 9252.2.3). Requesting a 3' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" for a proposed 588 sq. ft. detached garage to be within the rear yard area (9252.2.3). Requesting the following modifications for a proposed pool house /accessory structure: A. A rear yard coverage of 38% in lieu of 25% permitted (9252.2.9.1.) B. A floor area of 67% of the main dwelling's ground floor area in lieu of 50% permitted (9252.2.9.1). COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal. period. Appeals are to be filed by July 6, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 11, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 99 -015 301 Joyce Ave. Alexander Gomez Sleeter, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the approval of excessive pruning of two neighboring oak trees (Sec. 9704b.1). Approved subject to the condition that 2 new 36" boxed oak trees be planted under the supervision and approval of an arborist. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -001 411 E. Huntington Dr. Alex Magat Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -002 2307 S. Sixth Ave. Michael D. Klipa Approved for a 20'x30' 3 -car garage. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -003 1611 Rodeo Rd. Andrew Lee Requesting 428 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 498 spaces required for a proposed 1,121 sq. ft. dental office to be within an existing shopping center (9269.5). Requesting a rear yard coverage of 40.5% in lieu of 25% permitted for a detached garage and storage area (9252.2.9.1). Requesting a 6' -0" solid masonry wall in lieu of 5' -0" permitted along a street side yard (9252.2.12.2). Approved subject to the following conditions: 1. That a landscape and irrigation plan be submitted subject to the review and approval of Development Services Department. The landscaping shall he dense to minimize the stark affect of the wall 2. The solid masonry wall between the pilaster columns shall be stucco treated to match the exterior of the dwelling ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by January 19, 2000. ROLL CALL: AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 00 -001 808 Magnolia Ln. Bade Construction Co., Inc. Denied 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo Continued to 2/8 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -005 1 Altura Rd. John & Catherine Fara Approved Sleeter, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the removal of an ooxk tree within the front yard area in order to accomm ate a driveway for a new single - family residence (S 9704b.1). Req ing a 30' -0" front yard setback in lieu of 40' -6" requi fortiew single- family dwelling. The required b is .the average of the two nearest developed lots .2) ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMI'I"1'hE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting a 12' -0" street side yard setback in lieu of 20' -0" required to convert an existing attached two -car garage into a recreation room (9212.2.3.1). Huang, Butler, Rowe Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 2, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM Revised ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 00 -001 808 Magnolia Ln. Bade Construction Co., Inc. Denied 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo Continued to 2/8 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -005 1 Altura Rd. John & Catherine Faraone Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMI'1°I'EE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the removal of an oak tree within the front yard area in order to accommodate a driveway for a new single - family residence (Sec. 9704b.1). Requesting a 30' -0" front yard setback in lieu of 40' -6" required for new single- family dwelling. The required setback is the average of the two nearest developed lots (9251.2.2). Requesting a 12' -0" street side yard setback in lieu of 20' -0" required to convert an existing attached two -car garage into a recreation room (9212.2.3.1). Huang, Butler, Rowe Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 2, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -006 2326 Florence Ave. Ja Ao Robinson Huang ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMI'1"1EE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting a 30' -0" front ya • setback in lieu of 40' -6" required for new single -f ily dwelling. The required setback is the average e ' the two nearest developed lots (9251.2.2). R4uesting the following modifications for a proposed eestanding BBQ and patio cover: A. A 6' -0" building separation in lieu of 10' -0" required between the proposed patio cover post and a recreation room (9252.2.9.1). B. A 4' -0" overhand encroachment into the southerly side yard setback in lieu of a permitted 2' -0" overhand (9252.2.7.2). C. A 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" required for the BBQ structure (9252.2.9.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM 11E ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -004 182 W. Las Flores William Longo Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting an accessory portion of a new single - family residence to have a height variation of 21' -0" to 27' -0" in lieu of 16' -0" permitted when located 25' -0" from the rear yard property line (9251.2.9.1.) Approved subject to the condition that the applicant shall submit a landscape and irrigation plan that shall provide at a minimum the planting 24" box trees adjacent to the rear accessory portion of the house to provide visual relief subject to staff's review and approval. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -006 2326 Florence Ave. Ja Ao Robinson Huang Continued to 2/22/00 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMI'I"I'hE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting the following modifications for a proposed freestanding BBQ and patio cover: A. A 6' -0" building separation in lieu of 10' -0" required between the proposed patio cover post and a recreation room (9252.2.9.1). B. A 4' -0" overhand encroachment into the southerly side yard setback in lieu of a permitted 2' -0" overhand (9252.2.7.2). C. A 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" required for the BBQ structure (9252.2.9.1). Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by February 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 14, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -010 411 E. Huntington Dr., #114 Xiu Zhen Fang Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -011 41 E. Live Oak Ave. Susan Brown Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -013 247 E. Forest Ave. Stephen Lam Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -014 1111 S. First Ave. Chinnaportn Korprapun Approved 5. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -003 939 Hampton Rd. Scott Yang/JeffLee Approved subject to the arborist's recommendations. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 428 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 498 spaces required for a proposed 466 sq. ft. acupuncture clinic to be within an existing shopping center (9269.5). Requesting two wall signs (Cal Fed., California Federal Bank) with a combined area of 130 sq. ft. in lieu of 25 sq. ft. permitted, for any exterior sign when located within a C -O zone property (9261.4.1.). Requesting a 4' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 5' -0" for the following: A. A conversion of an existing single car garage into a living area B. An addition/remodel of an existing kitchen and dining room (9252.2.3.). Requesting a 4' -0" to 5' -0" wrought iron fence and column height, in lieu of 3' -0" permitted along the front property line (9252.2.12.1.). Requesting the construction of a circular driveway within the drip line of two oak trees in the front yard area (9704b.1.). Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by March 21, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 28, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -016 29 E. Huntington Dr. Hanfu Lee Approved subject to the ARA's approval of the proposed remodel/addition for the retail space and dental office. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -017 529 Workman Ave. Justin Kao Approved subject to the followini condition: 1. The circular driveway shall be remised so the sycamore tree located in the public rij'ht -of ivay shall not be disturbed subject to staff's review and approval 2. The applicant shall submit an arborist's report evaluatinL the tree trimminfi for the oak trees located in the rear yarn ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 7 parking spaces (4 on -site and 3 in the City Parking District) in lieu of 25 on -site spaces for a remodel and addition to provide 2,177 sq. ft. of retail space and 2,315 sq. ft. of dental office (9264.3.4 & 9269.5). Requesting a 5' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -6" required for a proposed 2,620 sq. ft. single -story addition to an existing 1,570 sq. ft. single - family home (9252.2.3). Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Plug There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by April 4, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 28, 2000 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -016 29 E. Huntington Dr. Hanfu Lee Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -017 529 Workman Ave. Justin Kao Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Murphy. Rowe, Nicholson Rcqucsting 7 parking spaces (4 on -site and 3 in the City Parking District) in lieu of 25 on -site spaces for a remodel and addition to provide 2,177 sq. ft. of retail space and 2,315 sq. ft. of dental office (9264.3.4 & 9269,5). Requesting a 5. -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -6" required for a proposed 2.620 sq. ft. single -story addition to an existing 1,570 sq. ft. single- family home (9252.2.3). COMMTII'hE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy. Rowe. Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Phung There will he a live working day appeal period. Appeals are to be tiled by April 4, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICA'T'ION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL 11, 2000 ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES CONFERENCE ROOM ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -019 650 W. Duarte Rd., #107 Dr. David Ng Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -020 1101 Panorama Dr. Designer Series Pools & Spas Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Murphy. Rowe. Nicholson Requesting 244 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 338 spaces required for a proposed 773 sq. ft. dental office to be within an existing office complex center (9269.5). Requesting an $ -6" street side yard setback in lieu of 20•-0" required to build a pool & spa (9251.2.11). COMMI'1 "IEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Phung There will be a live working day appeal peuod. Appeals are to be tiled by April 18, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL 25, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -018 11711 Clark St. George Good Approved subject to the condition that existing buildings have blue stripping and that the entry canopy be renovated with a stucco finished subject to staffs review and approval. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -023 420 Arbolada Progressive Builders Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -024 1964 El Sereno Dr. Anthony Montes Approved subject to the condition that exterior materials and roof tiles be compatible with the house subject to staffs review and approval. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -026 426 Columbia Rd. Edward and Teresa Munoz Approved Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 108 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 117 spaces required for a proposed 30,368 sq. ft. expansion to an existing 28,040 sq. ft. industrial building (9269.5). Requesting a 48' -6" front yard setback, for a bay window, in lieu of the average front yard setback of the neighboring properties which is approximately 50' -3 ". (9251.2.2). NOTE: The ARB of the Santa Anita Oaks has approved the proposed plans. Requesting an 816 sq. ft. second floor addition to the main dwelling on a single- family zoned lot (R -1) with two single - family residences (9251.1.1.). Requesting the following modifications for an addition to the main dwelling: A. To allow a 3' -0" northerly side yard setback to be maintained in lieu of the 7' -0" required to relocate the existing two -car garage easterly 21' -0" (9252.2.3). B. To allow a 5' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of the 7' -0" required for a 38' -4" long, one -story addition to the rear of the house (9252.2.3). C. To allow a 6' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of the 7' -0" required for a new air - conditioning condenser to be located between the existing rear bedroom and bathroom (9252.2.1.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by May 2, 2000. 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -027 2535 S. Santa Anita Ave. Eddy Ip Approved subject to the following conditions subject to staff's review and approval: 1. Request "A" is to be revised to permit 3' -8" to 4' -2" high masonry columns in lieu of 3' -0" permitted 2. Light standards shall be limited to the driveway entry columns 3. The installation of decorative fence shall be subject to staffs review and approval prior to any installation 6. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -028 502 E. Camino Real Ave. David and Monica Olson Approved subject to the condition that a covenant, approved by the City Attorney, be recorded indicating that the recreation room will not be utilized as living quarters. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: NOTE: The ARB of the Santa Anita Village Assoc. has approved the proposed plans. Requesting the following modifications for a proposed wrought iron fence to be placed between existing decorative masonry columns along the site's front property line: A. 3' -8" to 5' -2" high masonry columns in lieu of 3' -0" permitted (9252.2.12.1). B. A front yard fence setback of 2' -3" in lieu of 3' -0" required from the front property line (9252.2.12.1.) C. A 1' -2" masonry base in lieu of an openwork design (i.e., a minimum of 4" between vertical and horizontal members). (9252.2.12.5.). D. A height of 3' -0" to 5' -0" in lieu of 3' -0" permitted for the proposed decorative wrought iron fencing to be placed between the masonry columns (9252.2.12.1.). NOTE: Said fence was built without permits and the owner wishes to legalize the existing design. Requesting the following modifications to enlarge a recreation room attached to the rear of a detached two -car garage: A. An 8' -4" street side yard setback along Fifth Ave. in lieu of 15' -0" (9252.2.9.1. and 9252.2.3.1). B. 1,260 sq. ft. of accessory structure (i.e., a 350 sq. ft. two -car garage, 670 sq. ft. recreation room, and 240 sq. ft. of breezeway /covered walkway) in lieu of an 800 sq. ft. maximum that is based on 50% of the existing one - story, 1,600 sq. ft. house (9252.2.9.1). Murphy, Nicholson, Rowe Burnett, Kasama, Phung Page 2 4/25/00 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7 :45 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 9, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -025 444 E. Huntington Dr. Tim Cox, Plazamerica, Inc. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -030 1009 N. First Ave. Lourdes Manalastas ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting a 3' -0" by 4' -0" double -sided lease sign along Huntington Dr. in lieu of 4 sq. ft. in area per face that is permitted for such leasing purposes (9262.4.10). Requesting a 3' -0" westerly rear yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" for a proposed attached two -car garage in conjunction with a remodel and addition to the existing single - family residence. This property is zoned R -2. (9253.2.6) There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by May 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 23, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -031 357 W. Duarte Rd. Magdalena Mok/HMK Const. Approved subject to the condition that the water fountain shall not exceed 4' high. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -032 509 Workman Ave. Lai Fu Chong & Rosanna Au Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -033 150 N. Santa Anita Ave. Frank Xie for E -Tech Trading Co. Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Murphy, Busch, Nicholson Requesting the following modifications for a water fountain and an existing decorative wrought iron fence to have masonry columns with 16" tall light standards: A. 4' -4" to 5' -4" high wrought iron fencing in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0" (9252.2.12.1). B. 5' -0" high masonry columns to be located at the driveway and pedestrian entries in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0 ", (9252.2.12.1). C. A proposed 6' -0" high water fountain in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0 ", (9252.2.12.1). D. A front yard fence setback of 1' -0" in lieu of 3' -0" required from the front property line (9252.2.12.1). NOTE: The wrought iron fencing and water fountain were built without City approvals, and the owner wishes to legalize such construction. Requesting an open porch that is approximately 20" above the adjacent grade and extends 7' -0" into the required front yard setback in lieu of 18" height with a 6' -0" encroachment (9252.2.8). Requesting a parking modification of 242 existing parking spaces in lieu of 247 required for a stock trading company to occupy 4,481 sq. ft. of general office space (9269.5). Murphy, Busch, Nicholson Kasama, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by May 31, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 13, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -034 400 Rolyn P1. Stemcyte, Inc. Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -035 1009 N. Santa Anita Ave. A -Star Signs Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -036 378 Torrey Pines Dr. Bluth Development Approved Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting 26 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 75 spaces required for a proposed biomedical laboratory to occupy an existing 15,000 -sq. ft. building (9269.5). Requesting a monument sign to be located within a special setback and to be within 100' of residentially zoned property in lieu of no monument sign permitted within said area (9320.65.3 & 9262.4.6.3.). Requesting a 5' -0" side yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" for a proposed badminton court (9250.3.3). 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -037 Requesting one tandem parking space in lieu of 411 E. Colorado Blvd. providing a standard 3 -car garage (9252.2.6). Sanyao Int'1 Approved 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -038 1009 S. Sixth Ave. Sanyao Int' 1 Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Requesting a proposed decorative wrought iron fence with 18" high light standards on top of masonry columns at the driveway and pedestrian entries along the site's front property line and A. 3' -0" to 4' -0" high wrought iron fencing in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0" (9252.2.12.1). B. 3' -6" high masonry columns located along the front property line in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0 ". The columns at driveway and pedestrian entries will have 18" high light standards. (9252.2.12.1) COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by June 21, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 27, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -004 28 W. Grandview Ave. OC Construction Approved subject to the condition that 36" oak trees be planted on 20 W. Grandview, location to be determined by an arborist. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -029 1752 Wilson Ave. Hector Battifora Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -039 1540 Hyland Ave. Franco Noravian Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -040 21 E. Las Flores Susie Phan Approved, a covenant is to be recorded for the pool and gym room limiting the use and that a landscape and irrigation plan be submitted for the rear yard area. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the following modifications: A. To permit an encroachment into the dripline of two neighboring oak trees located along the site's easterly side property line (9704b.1). B. To permit the removal of an oak tree located in the center of the property (9704b.1). Requesting the following modifications for proposed additions to an existing main dwelling: A. 6' -10" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -0" required for a proposed bedroom and bathroom addition to align with the existing southerly elevation (9252.2.3). B. 8' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -0" and a 10' -0" rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0" for an 80 sq. ft. library extension (9252.2.32. & 9252.2.4). C. 7' -6" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -0" required for a proposed air conditioning condenser (9252.2.9.1.1 & 9252.2.3). Requesting a 3' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0" for a proposed 588 sq. ft. detached garage to be within the rear yard area (9252.2.3). Requesting the following modifications for a proposed pool house /accessory structure: A. A rear yard coverage of 38% in lieu of 25% permitted (9252.2.9.1.) B. A floor area of 67% of the main dwelling's ground floor area in lieu of 50% permitted (9252.2.9.1). Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by July 6, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., WEDNESDAY, JULY 11, 1999 COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM THERE WILL BE NO MODIFICATION COMMITTEE MEETING ON TUESDAY, JULY 11TH. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JULY 25, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -005 1104 E. Camino Real Amy Yu Lan Huang 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -041 1245 W. Huntington Dr. Leonard Chanda Jr. 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -042 150 N. Santa Anita Ave. Steve Tessier, Signs by Steve `N' Son THE APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED THAT THIS ITEM BE CONTINUED TO THE 8/8 MEETING. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the removal of an oak tree which is located 2' -0" from the existing dwelling (9704b.1). Requesting 51 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 94 spaces required for a proposed 2,809 sq. ft. medical office use to be located within a portion of an existing office building (9269.5). Requesting to enlarge an existing monument sign : A. A 10' -0" high monument sign within the 10' -0" special setback along this portion of N. Santa Anita Ave. in lieu of a maximum height of 4' -0" for a monument sign within a special setback (9314.3 & 9320.65.15). B. A second freestanding sign located 165' away in lieu of 200' between freestanding signs on contiguous lots sharing a common parking area (9262.4.6.0 & 9262.4.6.C.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by August 2, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, AUGUST 8, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -042 150 N. Santa Anita Ave. Steve Tessier, Signs by Steve `N' Son Continued to 8/22/00 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -043 203 E. Duarte Rd. Sanyao Int'1 Approved subject to the condition that the trash enclosure be relocated. 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -044 2725 Longley Way Dwight Cheney Continued to 8/22/00 4. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -006 1145 Rancho Rd. Mulligan Landscape Serv., Inc. Approved subject to the conditions listed by the arborist. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Huang, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting to enlarge an existing monument sign : A. A 10' -0" high monument sign within the 10' -0" special setback along this portion of N. Santa Anita Ave. in lieu of a maximum height of 4' -0" for a monument sign within a special setback (9314.3 & 9320.65.15). B. A second freestanding sign located 165' away in lieu of 200' between freestanding signs on contiguous lots sharing a common parking area (9262.4.6.0 & 9262.4.6.0 .1). Requesting the following modifications for a parking lot for a 5,620 sq. ft. general office building: A. 16 parking spaces in lieu of 23 spaces (9269.5) B. 8 compact spaces (50 %) in lieu of a maximum of 3 compact spaces (20 %) (9269.7 & 9269.7.1). C. No landscaping within the parking area in lieu of a minimum requirement of 5/5 (300 sq. ft.) (9269.13 & 9263.5.1.1) D. 3' wide landscape buffer along the northerly edge of the parking lot in lieu of a minimum 5' wide planter between a commercial parking lot and an adjacent residential zone (9269.13). Requesting a rear yard coverage of 46% in lieu of 25% permitted for a proposed workshop /accessory structure (9252.2.9.1). Requesting an oak tree encroachment within the protected zones of several oak trees to re- landscape the front yard, redesign and replace the driveway, and build new front yard property line fences and walls. Note: This proposal is being reviewed by the ARB of the Santa Anita Oaks HOA. Huang, Rowe, Butler Burnett There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by August 16, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, AUGUST 22, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -042 150 N. Santa Anita Ave. Steve Tessier, Signs by Steve `N' Son Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting to enlarge an existing monument sign : A. Request "A" conditionally approved: To be redesigned subject to staffs approval to provide an additional B. cabinet for a maximum of three tenants and to retain the existing tenants' cabinet. Request "B" denied. 2. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -044 2725 Longley Way Dwight Cheney Approved subject to the condition that the rear yard setback be increased to 5' and a landscape and irrigation plan be submitted to Planning prior to construction. A covenant is to be recorded prohibiting conversion to a guest house. 3. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -007 360 Campus Dr. Richard McNulty /Holy Angels Church CONTINUED WILL BE RE NOTICED 4. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -008 1305 Ramona Rd. Thomas & Joni Neal Approved subject to the condition that during construction an arborist is to supervise the any impact on the trees. A 10' -0" high monument sign within the 10' -0" special setback along Santa Anita Ave. in lieu of a maximum height of 4' -0" for a monument sign within a special setback (9314.3 & 9320.65.15). A second freestanding sign located 165' away in lieu of 200' between freestanding signs on contiguous lots sharing a common parking area (9262.4.6.0 & 9262.4.6.C.1). Requesting a rear yard coverage of 46% in lieu of 25% permitted for a proposed workshop /accessory structure (9252.2.9.1). Requesting the construction of a solid masonry block wall to be constructed within the drip line of three oak trees (9704b.1). Requesting the encroachment of a proposed 400 sq. ft. bedroom addition to the main dwelling to be within the drip line of two oak trees located within the southerly side yard area (9704b.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by August 16, 2000. 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -045 200 Longley Way Freeman Han Approved subject to the condition that the existing bay window shall be redesigned to be consistent with the new cantilever. 6. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -046 2112 S. Second Ave. Paul Miller, architect for Bogdan and Lucia Coralic Approved. Request `B" was approved to be limited to a 6' addition with the property line wall limited to a maximum height of 4', if it is to be extended. Request "E" is to include additional landscaping along the north property line. 7. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -047 324 W. Camino Real Billy Ngo Approved Requesting a 16' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of the 25' -0" special setback required for the following: A. To enclose an open porch area to accommodate a dining room expansion (9320.18.1). B. To enclose a breezeway between the single - family home and detached garage to accommodate a laundry room (9320.18.1). Requesting the following modifications: A. A 37' -0" front yard setback in lieu of the required 38' -9" for a new covered porch (9252.2.2 & 9320.66.14. B. C. A 4' -10" north side yard setback in lieu of the required 7' -0" for an 8' -0" long front addition and a 19' -6" long rear addition to the garage to align with the existing setback (9252.2.3). A 5' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of the required 7' -0" for a 25' -0" long bedroom and bathroom addition to the rear of the house to align with the existing setback. The bathroom will include an 8' -0" wide, 6" deep window shelf projection (9252.2.3 & 9252.2.7.2). D. A 4' -0" north side yard setback in lieu of the required 7' -0" for a new 208 sq. ft. storage building at the northeast corner of the property (9252.2.9.1). E. Paving of 56% (1,513 sq. ft.) of the required front yard in lieu of the maximum 40% (1,086 sq. ft.) to create a circular driveway. (9252.2.14). Requesting the following modifications for a proposed decorative wrought iron fence and water fountain: Page 2 8/22/00 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: A. 4' -0" to 4' -9" high masonry columns located along the front property line in lieu of a maximum height of 4' -0" (9251.2.13.1). B. 5' -3" high masonry columns at the pedestrian entry in lieu of a maximum height of 5' -0 ". The columns at pedestrian entries will have 18" high light standards (9251.2.13.1). C. 5' -8" and 6' -3" high decorative wrought iron gates at the driveway and pedestrian entry in lieu of a maximum height of 5' -0" (9251.2.13.1). D. 6' -0" high water fountain in lieu of a maximum height of 5' -0" (9251.2.13.1). NOTE: Said fence and water fountain were not built according to the approved plans and the owner wishes to legalize the work. Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson Burnett, Kasama, Phung Page 3 8/22/00 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 12, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -007 360 Campus Dr. Richard McNulty for Holy Angles Church Approved subject to the condition that the masonry wall be built only along easterly property line with a return to the southerly rear property line that would be no closer than 4' -0" from the nearest oak tree with the remaining fence being constructed of new chain link. 2. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -009 359 W. Camino Real Paul Wang Approve, subject to the condition that the applicant follow the recommendations as setforth in the arobirst's report. 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -048 140 W. Longden Ave. Kok Chee Approved 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -049 1231 S. Tenth Ave. Ricky Wn Continued to 9/26/00 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -050 2317 S. Fourth Ave. LCT Design Group Approved subject to the condition that a landscape and irrigation plan be submitted for staff's review and approval. Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the construction of a solid masonry block wall within the drip lieu of three oak trees (9704b.1). Requesting the construction of a spa within the drip line of an oak tree (9704b.1). Requesting a 3' -6" high decorative wrought iron fence atop an 18" block base to be constructed along the westerly and easterly side yard property lines in the front yard area. The overall height of the fence would be 4' -6" in lieu of 3' -0" (9252.2.12.1). Requesting the installation of a swimming pool on a R -1 zoned lot with two single - family dwellings (9292.1.4.17.a). Requesting a rear yard coverage of 35% in lieu of 25% permitted for a proposed detached 3 -car garage (9252.2.9.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by September 19, 2000. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kalemkiarian, Nicholson, Rowe Burnett, Kasama, Phung Page 2 9/ 12/00 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, September 26, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -049 1231 S. Tenth Ave. Ricky Wn Approved subject to the condition that the block wall be constructed around the perimeter of the proposed pool area. Said block wall shall be extended on the southerly side yard to abut the existin' block wall. 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -051 225 & 255 E. Santa Clara St. NE corner of 2nd Ave. and Santa Clara St. Ron Busante for WF Const. Approved subject to the condition that the trash enclosures are to be relocated to provide two additional parkin' spaces. Parkin' space numbers 124 and 125 to be adjusted to accommodate fire walls. Parkin' in stora'e rooms to be striped per code. Complete ADA paths of travel to be shown. Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting the installation of a swimming pool on a R -1 zoned lot with two single- family dwellings (9292.1.4.17.a). Requesting the following modifications for the number and design of the parking spaces for two 20,772 sq. ft., 3 -story office buildings: A. 185 parking spaces in lieu of 239 spaces required for a deficiency of 54 parking spaces (9269.5). B. 44 (24 %) compact parking spaces in lieu of the maximum 20% (37 spaces) allowance (9269.5.1). C. 68 57 of the standard parking spaces are substandard in width and/or depth. The required sizes for standard parking spaces is 9' -0" wide by 20' -0" deep, or 11' -6" wide by 20' -0" deep when the parking space is next to a wall or when columns are within 4' -0" on both sides of the open end of the parking stall (9269.7.1). D. -1-6 8 of the compact parking spaces are 8' -0" wide in lieu of 10' -6" wide as required when the parking space is next to a wall or when columns are within 4' -0" on both sides of the open end of the parking stall (9269.7.3). E. A 24' -6" wide aisle in lieu of 25' -0" required for 90° angled parking spaces. This is only for one double - loaded aisle serving 12 parking spaces (9269.7.1). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by October 3, 2000. 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -052 315 Vaquero Rd. Jack and Jeanne Goss Approved subject to the condition that a covenant be recorded subject to the review and approval of the City Attorney. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -053 330 E. Forest Ave. Robert Fillhart Approved 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -054 809 W. Huntington Dr. Yassar Ballat (Tony's Liquor) Continued to 10 /10 6. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -010 141 California St. Polyland Const. Approved subject to the condition that two 36" box trees be planted subject to the arborist's report. Existing tree is to be removed. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting a 6' -0" northerly side yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" required for a proposed pool house (9251.2.3). Requesting a 3' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 5' -0" required to attach an open carport to an existing single - family dwelling (9252.2.3). Requesting a proposed free- standing monument sign on a C -O zoned property (9261.4.1). Requesting an encroachment within the drip line of an oak tree in the front yard area for the construction of an 8 -unit residential condominium project. (9704b.1). Kalemkiarian, Nicholson, Rowe Burnett, Kasama, Phung Page 2 4/25/00 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, OCTOBER 10, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -054 809 W. Huntington Dr. Yassar Ballat (Tony's Liquor) Approved subject to the condition that the base of the sign be redesigned subject to review and approval of Planning. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting a proposed free - standing monument sign on a C -O zoned property (9261.4.1). Rowe, Nicholson Burnett There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by October 17, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, OCTOBER 24, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -011 1210 Valencia Way Andy Lee Approved 2. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -012 401 S. Third Ave. Sanyao Int'l Approved subject to the condition that no concrete shall be placed around the base of the tree subject to an arborist's report 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -056 & ADR 00 -035 11892 Goldring Rd. Victor Huang Approved ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting an oak tree encroachment for a new 2,600 sq. ft., two -story house. The subject oak tree is toward the back yard and a masonry planter is proposed to be built around it. Requesting an encroachment of a 2 -unit residential condominium project to be within the drip line of an oak tree which is located on the site's northerly property line (9704b.1). Requesting a zero rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0" for a new industrial building adjacent to residentially zoned property in the City of El Monte. The rear portion of the building is proposed to be approximately 28' tall. (9266.2.2.2). Kalemkiarian, Nicholson, Rowe Kasama, Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by October 31, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -013 272 W. Orange Grove Sanyao Int'I Approved subject to the following conditions: 1. The applicant shall follow the recommendations as set forth in the arborist's report. 2. The proposed circular driveway shall be redesign to reduce impacts to the trees subject to the review and approval of the Community Development Administrator. 3. An arborist shall be on -site to monitor construction within the dripline of the oak trees. 2. PUBLIC HEARING TR 2000 -014 839 W. Duarte Rd. David Huang Approved subject to the condition that two 36" box oak trees be planted subject to the arborist's approval. 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -055 522 W. Woodruff Ave. Yuk Hung Siu CONTINUED TO 11/28/00 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -057 1201S. Baldwin Ave. Kamran Aryal Approved Kalemkiarian, Butler, Rowe Requesting an oak tree encroachment for the construction of a new residence: A. Encroachment into the dripline of 3 oak trees for a new circular driveway within the front yard area (9704b.1). B. Encroachment into the dripline of 3 oak trees within the site's rear yard area for a proposed accessory building (9704b.1). The subject property is currently undeveloped. The proposed development has been reviewed and approved by the Santa Anita Oaks Homeowner's Assoc. Requesting the removal of an oak tree located along the westerly side yard setback for the proposed construction of a new condominium project (9704b.1). Requesting a 4' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -6" required for a 320 sq. ft. addition to an existing detached garage (9252.2.3). Requesting a 20' encroachment into a 50' special setback along Baldwin Ave. for a proposed architectural tower element of a commercial facade remodel (9320.5.3). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by November 22, 2000. 5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -058 1120 W. Orange Grove Isras Chatkeon Approved subject to the condition that two Carolina Cherry trees be planted behind the rear window area. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Requesting the following modifications to convert an existing 688 sq. ft. cabana into a guest house : A. B. C. A gross floor area of approximately 688 sq. ft. in lieu of 600 sq. ft. permitted (9251.2.10.3). A 5' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 13' -0" required (9251.2.10.3.8). An 11' -0" southerly rear yard setback in lieu of 35' -0" required (9251.2.4). The proposal has been reviewed and approved by the Rancho Santa Anita Property Owner's Association. Kalemkiarian, Butler, Rowe Burnett, Phung Page 2 9/12/00 AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 28, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: 1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -055 522 W. Woodruff Ave. Yuk Hung Siu CONTINUED TO 12/12/00 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson Requesting a 4' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -6" required for a 320 sq. ft. addition to an existing detached garage (9252.2.3). There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by December 6, 2000. AGENDA ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE 7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, DECEMBER 12, 2000 CONFERENCE ROOM OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: I. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -055 522 W. Woodruff Ave. Yuk Hung Siu CONTINUED TO 1/9/01 2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 2000 -059 175 W. Wistaria J. Chang Approved 3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 00 -060 1505 S. Baldwin Ave. Dino Clarizio Approved subject to the condition that there be an 8' westerly and an 8' easterly rear yard setback. The subject area must be landscaped subject to review and approval of Planning. 4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 00 -061 222 E. Sycamore Ave. Y. Tony Song Continued to 1/9/00 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kalemkiarian, Butler, Rowe Requesting a 4' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -6" required for a 320 sq. ft. addition to an existing detached garage (9252.2.3). Requesting two existing 10' -0" long by 5' -0" high curved decorative block walls that abut the driveway entry to remain in lieu of a maximum height of 3' -0" within the front yard area (9251.2.13.1). The fence was not installed in accordance with approved plans. Requesting the following modifications for a 539 sq. ft. single -story storage building on a commercial property: A. B. An 18" westerly side yard setback in lieu of a minimum 10' -0" side yard setback required with no portion of the structure encroaching through a plane projected from a 45° angle as measured at the ground level when adjacent to a residentially zoned property (9263.2.3.b). An 18" southerly rear yard setback in lieu of a minimum 20' -0" rear yard setback required with no portion of the structure encroaching through a plane projected from a 45° angle as measured at the ground level when adjacent to a residentially zoned property (9263.2.4.b). Requesting a proposed 6' -6" westerly side yard setback in Lieu of 25' -0" required for a single -story addition to the main dwelling (9252.2.3). The proposed plans have been reviewed and approved by the Highland HOA. Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Kasama Phung There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by December 20, 2000.