HomeMy WebLinkAbout1-1-98 - 12-31-98AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 13,1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -001
130 E. Sycamore
David Viboolkij
Approved subject to the condition that a covenant be
filed with the City of Arcadia prohibiting the use of
the building to be use Jar the purpose of accessory
living quarters.
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98-002
402 W. Lemon Ave.
John and Susie Krost
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -003
450 E. Huntington Dr.
Outdoor Lighting & Advertising
Approved
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -004
452 W. Longden Ave.
Ying -Ming Huang
Denied
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a 5'-6" side yard setback in lieu of 10' -0"
required for an existing multi- purpose building on the
westerly property line (9252.2.4).
Requesting the following modifications:
A. A 20' -0" street side yard setback in lieu of a 40' -0"
special setback for a covered terrace (9320.39.1).
B. A 30.82' street side yard setback in lieu of a 40' -0"
special setback for a proposed garage /addition to main
dwelling (9320.39.1).
Requesting to display a 65 sq. ft. banner for an additional 30
days in lieu of a 32 sq. ft. banner for a maximum of 30
calendar days per year (9262.4.13).
Requesting to maintain a 44'-0" front yard setback for a new
two -story residence in lieu of 58' -6 ", the average of the two
adjacent properties (9252.2.2)
COMMACOMMI I-11.E MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy. Rowe and Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday. January 21. 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JANUARY 27, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1.
PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -005
535 W. Lemon Ave.
John Sheng
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting to maintain the existing 960 sq. ft. detached
building (with kitchen facilities) as a guest house, in lieu of
no kitchen or cooking facilities allowed and the 600 sq. ft.
maximum floor area for guest houses (9220.2).
Approved subject to the filing of a covenant and that
the building comply with all Building Code requirements.
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -006
296 Hacienda Dr.
Jay Johnson for
Gary Forillo
Approved subject to the condition that the applicant
obtain approval from the Santa Anita Oaks
Homeowner's Association for the 5' -0" setback;
Otherwise the subject garage shall maintain an
8' -0" side yard setback, as previously approved
by the HOA.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMIT 1'1;E MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Requesting a 5' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of
13' -0" required, for a new four -car garage, which will
replace the existing garage. The existing garage is setback
approximately 5' -0" from the westerly property line.
Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Stokes
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, February 4, 1998.
ROLL CALL:
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10,1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98-008
901 S. Baldwin Ave.
(formerly occupied by Color Tile)
Trust Bank
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a total of 11 -13 parking spaces including the use
of tandem spaces in lieu of 21 standard parking spaces to
convert a retail building into a bank (9269. Et seq.)
Approved with the conditions listed below:
1. The maximum number of employees at any one time
shall not exceedfive.
2. There shall not be an automatic teller machine (ATM)
at this location.
3. Any freestandinx sign shall be located to the south of
the parking lot driveway.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMI'1 -1EE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kasama
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Thursday, February 19, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -009
1201 S. Baldwin Ave.
Sign Wize for Burlington Coat Factory
Approved subject to the condition that the applicant/
Tenant paint the building which Burlington Coat
Factory occupies and $510.00 be paid in cash/cashiers
Check within five working days.
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -010
1000 S. Baldwin Ave.
Friar Tux
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -001
211 E. Foothill Blvd.
Jerry Fabio of K.L. Charles & Assoc. for
Ralphs Grocery Co.
Application withdrawn by applicant
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting an 814 sq. ft. sign on the side and rear walls of the
business in lieu of the 600 sq. ft. maximum allowed
(9262.4.4).
Requesting 60 days in lieu of 30 for a temporary banner
located on the front of the building facing Baldwin
(9262.4.3).
Requesting the removal of a mature oak tree because of
The damage it is causing to the parking lot (9704.b).
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Rowe, Nicholson
COMMIT TEE MEMBERS ABSENT: Commissioner Murphy
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, March 4, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 10,1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -011
205 Hacienda Dr.
Norman Wong
Approved
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -012
735 W. Duarte Rd.
David Collazo
Approved subject to the condition that one handicap
Parking space be provided with a marked pathway.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a 77' -6" front yard setback, in lieu of the 92' -0"
average front setback of the two adjacent properties
(9251.2.2).
Requesting 2 parking spaces in lieu of 6 for a 1,000 sq. ft.
sole - practitioner's chiropractic office (9269.5).
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Stokes
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, March 18, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MARCH 24, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -013
2405 S. Santa Anita Ave.
Mark Yam
Approved
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a 38' -0" front yard setback, for a garage extension
in lieu of the 50' -0" which is the average of the two adjacent
properties (9251.2.2).
Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Stokes
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, April 1, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., WEDNESDAY, APRIL 15, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
o
THERE WILL BE NO MODIFICATION
COMMITTEE MEETING ON
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 15, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, APRIL 28,1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -015
2633 S. Baldwin Ave.
Long Dragon Realty
Approved
Commissioner Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting to display a 144 sq. ft. banner for an additional 60
days in lieu of 32 sq. ft. for a maximum 30 days per calendar
year (9262.4.13).
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -016 Requesting modifications for a 2- bedroom/1 -bath addition to
311 S. Fifth Ave. to a legal non - conforming, single- family residence in an R -3
Bennett Lee zone:
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -017
1100 San Carlos Rd.
Roberto Macatangay
Approved
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -018
468 W. Norman Ave.
Kent C.K. Wu, architect
Approved
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
A. An addition of 594 sq. ft. m lieu of the allowed 500 sq.
ft. (9255.1.5.1).
B. A rear yard setback of 12' -0" in lieu of 25' -0"
(9255.1.5 and 9252.2.8).
Requesting a 6' high garden wall along the site's southerly
street side property line (along Foothill Blvd.) in lieu of a
a maximum 5' height standard (9283.9.1.c & 9283.9.3).
This approval has been conditionally approved by the Santa
Anita Oaks Architectural Review Board.
Requesting the following modifications for the encroachments
into the protected zone of two oak trees:
A. The first floor portion of a new house to encroach into
the protected zone of an 18" diameter oak tree along the
west side property line.
B. A new front yard concrete block wall/wrought iron
fence to encroach into the protected zone of a 12"
diameter oak tree near the northwest corner of the
property.
Bruckner, Rowe, Kasama
Halminski
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, May 5, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 AM., TUESDAY, MARCH 24, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -013
2405 S. Santa Anita Ave.
Mark Yam
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Commissioner Murphy, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a 38' -0" front yard setback, for a garage ex-tension
in lieu of the 50' -0" which is the average of the two adjacent
properties (9251.2.2).
There Will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday April 1. 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 12, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -018
1212 S. Second Ave.
James Lutz
Commissioner Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a 50' -0" front yard setback in lieu of the 70' -0"
average of the adjacent neighbors (9252.2.2)
Approved a 60' front yard setback
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -019 Requesting the following modifications for additions to the
1839 Oakwood Ave. existing residence:
Carolyn Bell
A. A 31'-6" front yard setback ii lieu of the 34' -3"
average of the adjacent neighbors for a new covered
porch (9252.2.2).
B. A 6' -9" northerly side yard setback in lieu of the 7' -7"
for a garage and bathroom addition (9252.2.4).
C. A 17' -0" interior garage depth in lieu of the required
19' -0" for one of the two parking spaces (9252.2.21).
NOTE: This proposal has been approved by the Highland
Oaks ARB.
Approved, requests `A" and `B ", request "C" withdrawn
by applicant.
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -020
533 Foothill Blvd.
Eric Shu
Denied
4. TIME EXTENSION MC 97 -020
270 Arbolada Dr.
J. Young & B. Andrews
Approved
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Requesting the following modifications for a new two -story
residence:
A. A 65' front yard setback in lieu of the 74'-6" average of
the adjacent neighbors (9251.2.2).
B. A 25' rear yard setback in lieu of 35' for an attached
pool room and trellis covered patio (9251.2.6).
NOTE: This proposal has been approved by the Santa
Anita Oaks ARB.
Requesting a one -year time extension that will expire on May
27, 1998, granting a 5' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of
10' -0" required for a proposed tennis court and an oak tree
removal request for a tree located in the center of the rear
yard.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Kasama
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, May 19, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, MAY 26, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -003
357 W. Duarte Rd.
Art Del Rey
Approved subject to the condition that 3, 48" box
replacement trees are to be planted on -site with
at least one tree in the front yard Planting to be
supervised by a certified arborist
2. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -004
765 Anoakia Ln.
Ai Buangsuwon, architect for Eric Han
Approved subject to the following conditions:
1) Further evaluation by an arbor& selected by the HOA
and construction mitigation measures.
2) Removal approved subject to 2, 48" box replacement trees to be
planted under the supervision ofa certified arborist.
Encroachment approval subject to construction mitigation
measures.
Commissioner Bell, Butler, Nicholson
Requesting the removal of an oak tree located within the
westerly rear yard area (9704.b.1.)
Requesting the encroachment into the protected zone of an oak
tree to acconunodate a garage, master bedroom and
bathroom addition.
NOTE: This proposal has not been approved by the Rancho
Santa Anita Property Owner's Association's ARB.
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -021
228 Duarte Rd.
Mr. and Mrs. Chang
Rescheduled for June 911` meeting.
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -022
425 E. Winnie Way
Graham Briggs
Approved
5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -024
1310 S. Baldwin Ave.
B &KSigns
Approved subject to staffs approval of the awning
material.
Requesting an overall building height of 30' -0" in lieu of
25' -0" permitted for a proposed new residence (9252.2.1).
Requesting a 5' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of
7'-4" required for a proposed bedroom and bathroom
addition (9252.2.4).
Requesting a height of 4' -0" in lieu of 2' -0" required for the
installation of a proposed marquee sign, along the westerly
building frontage canopy (9262.4.7).
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, June 2, 1998.
6. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -025
960 W. Orange Grove Ave.
Tien Tien & \ruh Wai Li
Rescheduled for June 9th meeting.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMM11 11 E MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed room
addition:
A. A 65' -3" front yard setback in lieu of the 70' -0"
required per the average of the adjacent neighbors (62'
and 78'/9251.2.2).
B. A 12' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 13' -0"
Required for the installation of an a/c unit (9251.2.4).
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 9, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -021
228 W. Duarte Rd.
Mr. and Mrs. Chang
Approved
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -023
1107 S. Tenth Ave.
Mr. and Mrs. Ding
Commissioner Bell, Butler, Nicholson
Requesting an overall building height of 30' -0" in lieu of
25' -0" for a proposed new residence (9252.2.1).
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed
accessory building:
A. For accessory buildings to exceed 69% of the ground
floor area of the main dwelling in lieu of the maximum
of 50% (9252.2.11).
1. The remodel of an existing pool house and lanai
into a new recreation room;
2. A new 861 sq. ft. four -car garage;
3. An existing 266 sq. ft. covered patio.
B. A 5' -3" northerly side yard setback in lieu of 5' -10"
(9252.2.4).
1. To retain the existing side setback for the proposed
expansion of the existing pool house;
2. The new four -car garage to be kept in line with the
pool house.
C. A distance of 6'-6" between structures in lieu of 10'-0"
required for the existing covered patio and pool house
(9252.2.11).
Approved subject to the condition that a covenant be filed
Regarding the use of the recreation room.
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -025
960 W. Orange Grove Ave.
Tien Tien & Yuh Wai Li
Approved
ORAL CONIMUNICATIONS
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed
room addition:
A. A 65' -3" front yard setback in lieu of the 70' -0"
required per the average of the adjacent neighbors (62'
and 78'/9251.2.2).
B. A 12'-0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 13' -0"
Required for the installation of an a/c unit (9251.2.4).
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: 11:1i, Butler, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski
There will be a five Nvorking day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, June 16; 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -026
17 W. Magna Vista Ave.
Chengton Ent.. Inc.
Approved
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -027
307 W. Duarte Rd.
Terence Kwok
Denied
2. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -005
408 -412 Genoa St.
Sunny Development
Approved subject to the condition that the property
owner plant a total of three (3) coast live oaks under
the supervision of a certified arborist prior to final
building inspection. Two (2) 36" oaks within the front
Yard and one (1) 48" with the rear yard
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Commissioner Bell, Butler. Nicholson
Requesting a 26' -0" westerly rear yard setback in lieu of
35' -0" required for the proposed second -story addition
(9252.2.8).
Requesting a 6'-4" westerly side yard setback in lieu of
9' -2" for an existing residence which is proposed to be
partially demolished and rebuilt (9252.2.4).
Requesting the removal of one oak tree located within the
middle/front yard area for the development of a 4 -unit
condominium project (9704b.1).
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Bell, Butler, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, June 30, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JULY 14, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -028
1331 Oaldawn Rd.
Jeff Wang
Approved subject to the condition that the owner file
a covenant stating that the guest house may not
contain a kitchen facility nor may it be used for
rental purposes.
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -029
601 Las Tunas Dr.
Margaret Juarez
Approved subject to the condition that standardized
Lettering be incorporated and that the base of the
Sign be detailed with brick and orstucco.
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -030
895 Coronado Dr.
Michael Cate
Approved
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -031
320 E. Foothill' Blvd.
Mr. Terry Earll of Century 21 Earll, Ltd.
Request "D" approved, all others continued to 7/28.
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, July 22, 1998.
Commissioner Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting a 20'-6" southwesterly rear yard setback in lieu of
25' -0" required for the proposed conversion of an existing
car port into a guest house (9220.2).
Requesting a free - standing sign (monument sign) to be within
the special setback along Las Tunas Dr. (9320.46.2).
Requesting the following modifications:
A. A 31' -0" in lieu of 33' -0" front yard setback for a
proposed bay window (9252.2.2).
B. A 3' -0" side yard setback in lieu of 5' -7" for a play
house (9252.2.4).
C. A building separation of 2' -0" in lieu of 10' -0" between
the play house and the main dwelling (9252.2.11).
Requesting the following modifications for a sign:
A. Two free standing signs in lieu of one. A new two -
sided, internally illuminated monument sign in addition
to the existing one -sided wooden post - mounted sign.
(9252.2.2).
B. Encroachment into the vehicular visibility area by the
new freestanding sign to encroach into the vehicular
visibility.
C. A distance of approximately 2' -0" between the
freestanding signs and the building in lieu of the
minimum 3' -0" required.
D. Display of a temporary banner for 60 consecutive
days in lieu of two 30-day periods separated by at
at least two weeks.
5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98-032
401 W. Lemon Ave.
Francis and Grace Tang
Approved subject to the condition that landscaping
be maintained along the north property line
6. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -033
924 Monte Verde Dr.
Frank and Mara Chimenti
Approved
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Requesting a 20'-0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of a
special 40'-0" setback along Holly Ave. for a new
single - family residence (9320.39.1).
Requesting a gable roof height of 25'-0" in lieu of
20' -0" permitted within the required easterly side yard
setback area (9252.2.4).
Bruckner, Parker, Nicholson
Halminski and Kasama
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, JULY 28, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
Commissioner Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -031 Requesting the following modifications for a sign:
320 E. Foothill Blvd.
Mr. Terry Earll of Century 21 Earll, Ltd. A. Two free standing signs in lieu of one. A new two -
sided, internally illuminated monument sign in addition
to the existing one -sided wooden post- mounted sign.
(9252.2.2).
Continued to 8/11
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -034
1605 Holly Ave.
Anil Kim Thai
Denied
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -035
5611 Peck Rd.
C.B. Nichols Egg Ranch
Approved
B. Encroachment into the vehicular visibility area by the
new freestanding sign to encroach into the vehicular
visibility.
C. A distance of approximately 2' -0" between the free-
standing signs and the building in lieu of the minimum
3' -0" required.
D. Display of a temporary banner for 60 consecutive
days in lieu of two 30-day periods separated by at
least two weeks.
Requesting to permit a 13' -4" westerly rear yard setback in
lieu of 25' -0" required for a first -story portion of a proposed
two -story residence (i.e. a patio cover and multi- purpose
room) (Sec. 9252.2.8).
Requesting a 6'-0" high monument sign in the M -1 zone.
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -036 Requesting the following modifications for proposed one-
1721 S. Eighth Ave. story additions to the main dwelling:
Alex Ugrik
A. A 16' -9" front yard setback (from Eighth Ave.) in lieu
of 25' -0" required for additions to a bedroom and living
Approved, subject to the condition that a room (9252.2.2).
southerly 6' -O" high property line wall be built
and finished on both sides at the applicant's expense. B. A 5' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of 6'-6"
required for a bedroom and bathroom addition
(9252.2.6).
C. A 15' -0" westerly rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0"
required for a bedroom addition (9252.2).
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett, Kasama
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, August 5, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, AUGUST 11, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
Commissioner Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
1. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -031 Requesting the following modifications for a sign:-
320 E. Foothill Blvd.
Mr. Terry Earll of Century 21 Earll, Ltd. A. Two freestanding sings in lieu of one. A new two -
sided, internally illuminated monument sign in addition
to the existing one -sided wooden post- mounted sign.
(9252.2.2).
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -037
1431 Caballero Rd.
Rocco & Kathleen Liberio
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -037
1107 S. Tenth Ave.
Justin Ding
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
B. Encroachment into the vehicular visibility area by the
new freestanding sign to encroach into the vehicular
visibility.
C. A distance of approximately 2' -0" between the free-
standing sign and the building in lieu of the minumum
3' -0" required.
D. Display of a temporary banner for 60 consecutive days
in lieu of two 30-day periods separated by at least two
weeks.
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed two -
story addition and rebuilt of the main dwelling:
A. A 61' -0" front yard in lieu of the required 66' -0"
Average of the two neighbors for a bay window and
porch (9251.2.2).
B. A 10' -0" northerly side yard setback in lieu of 11' -1"
required for a game room, guest bedroom, bathroom
and the garage (9252.2.4).
NOTE: The Santa Anita Oaks Home Owner's Association
has approved the architectural design of this
proposal.
Requesting to delete a condition of approval of MC 98 -023
that requires the removal of the existing south wall of a
workout room for a proposed 475 sq. ft. addition.
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, August 19, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, AUGUST 25, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -039
285 W. Foothill Blvd.
Wes Lind
Approved subject to the condition that the wall be
finished with brick as approved by the Santa Anita Oaks
Homeowner's Association.
Butler, Rowe. Nicholson
Requesting an overall solid wall height of 4'-0" in lieu of a
2' -0" solid wall permitted within the front yard area
(9283.9.1).
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -040 Requesting the following modifications for proposed
183 W. Las Flores Ave. improvements to the main dwelling:
Shen Yuan Wu
A. A 16' -0" easterly 2nd floor side yard setback in lieu of
the 20' -0" required, to convert an existing attic space
into a bedroom (9292.1.2.4 & 9292.1.4.21).
B. A 22' -0" westerly street side yard setback in lieu of the
25' -0" special setback along El Monte Ave. for a
family room rebuild (9320.18.2).
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -041
1759 Claridge St.
Mur -sol Coast.
Approved
Requesting the following modifications for existing
paving and fencing for a new dwelling:
A. Paving of 66% (832 sq. ft.) of the required front yard
in lieu of a maximum coverage of 50% (631 sq. ft.)
(9252.2.22).
B. A driveway gate. at the front property line, with a
height of 6' -8" in lieu of a maximum height standard
of 5' -0" (9283.9.1.b).
C. Side yard fences and gates with heights of 7' -0" for the
southerly side yard and 8' -0" for the easterly side yard.
both in lieu of a maximum height standard of 6' -0"
(9283.9.3).
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, September 2, 1998.
PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -042
2100 & 2102 S. Sixth Avenue
Jeff Wang - Contractor for Mr. & Mrs. Ma
Approved
5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98-043
2701 Winthrop Ave.
Lai Ching -Chueh Ho
Approved
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
COMMI1'LEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Requesting the following modifications for the proposed
expansion of the main dwelling (rear house) on a R -1 zoned
lot with two legal - nonconforming dwellings (9292.14.17):
A. To maintain the existing 3'-4" northerly side yard set-
back in lieu of 7'-0" required to convert the existing
595 sq. ft. garage into two bedrooms and a bathroom
{9252.2.4 & 9292.1.4.17(a)}
B. A 3'-4" northerly side yard setback in lieu of 7'-0"
required for a 500 sq. ft master bedroom and
bathroom addition to align with the existing northerly
side yard setback {9252.2.4 and 9292.1.4.17 (a) }.
C. Addition of a 677 sq. ft. two -car garage and
laundry/storage area {9292.1.4.17(a) &(c) }.
Requesting a height of 5' -0" in lieu of the 4' -0"
maximum height standard within the 40' -0" special setback
along Las Tunas Drive for a block wall along the rear
(westerly) property line and a wood fence to enclose the
backyard area (9314.3 & 9320.46.4)
Butler, Nicholson, Rowe
Burnett, Kasama
2
8/25/98
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 8, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -044
2409 Albert Way
Fairhaven Development Corp.
Requests `B" and "C" approved
Request "A" approved for a 30'-0 "front yard setback
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting the following modifications for a new two -story
residence:
A. A proposed 25' -0" front yard setback in lieu of 35' -0"
required (9252.2.2).
B. A 31' -0" rear yard setback in lieu of 35' -0" required
(9252.2.8).
C. A total lot coverage of 37.6% in lieu of 35% permitted
(9252.2.14).
COMMI 1'1'EE MEMBERS PRESENT: Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, September 16, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 22, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -006
127 -131 Forest Ave.
Lilly Lii
Approved
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -045
101 W. Palm Ave.
Fuei An Lai
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -046
1518 S. Fourth Ave.
Terry Lee
Approved
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -047
38 E. Huntington Dr.
WF Construction, Inc.
Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting encroachment of a wrought iron fence into the
drip line of an oak tree located within the westerly rear yard
area (9704b.1).
Requesting a portion of a single -story addition to the main
dwelling to be 20' -0" in height in lieu of a 12' -0" standard
(9252.2.4).
Requesting a 34' -2" front yard setback for a proposed porch
in lieu of a 35' -0" special setback along Fourth Ave.
(9320- 32.6).
Requesting modifications to the parking regulations to
remodel an existing commercial building. The remodel
will reduce the building size and provide on -site parking
The parking lot across the alley will no longer be
available for this building. The parking design will be
modified as follows:
A. 7 on -site parking spaces in lieu of 14 on -site shared - use
spaces for a 4,625 sq. ft. commercial building
(9264.3.4.A.3).
B. 6 compact spaces and 1 van accessible handicap
parking space in lieu of 5 standard size spaces, 1 van
accessible handicap space and 1 compact space
(9269.5.1).
Approved subject to the condition that the
property owner execute a covenant to participate
in the shared use parking provisions of the CBD zone.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Bruckner, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski, Irma
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Wednesday, September 30, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, OCTOBER 13, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -048
1801 S. Eighth Ave.
Conrad and Dadee Schlick
Approved request "A"
Request `B" approved to allow I5' -0" setback for the
Entry way. 11' -0" setback was denied
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -049
21 E. Las Flores Ave.
Brad Hubbard of Guardian Builders
Denied
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed
addition to the main dwelling:
A. An 8' -0" westerly rear yard setback in lieu of 25' -0"
required for a proposed single -story addition to the rear
portion of the main dwelling (9252.2.8).
B. An 11' -0" to 15' -0" front yard setback in lieu of 25' -0"
required for a new porch and entryway (9252.2.2).
Requesting a 5' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 8' -0"
to rebuild and add onto the easterly side of the first floor
portion of the house (9252.2.4).
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Kalemkiarian, Rowe. Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett Halminski
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, October 20, 1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, OCTOBER 27,1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98-050
85 W. Longden Ave.
Sue Selinski
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE:
Kalemkiarian. Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed
addition to the main dwelling:
A. A 3'-0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -5"
required for the conversion of a garage /storage area into
livable space, and the expansion of two bedroom areas
(9252.2.4).
B. A 3' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of 9' -5"
required for a proposed detached 2-car garage
(9252.2.4)
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, November 3, 1998.
THERE WILL
BE NO
PLANNING
COMMISSION
OR
MODIFICATION
COMMITTEE
MEETING ON
TUESDAY,
NOVEMBER 10,
1998.
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -007
521 Workman Ave.
James Li, for Maple Builders Inc.
Approved subject to the condition that two 24" box oak
trees be planted under the supervision of a certified
arborist within the rear yard
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -051
939 Hampton Rd.
Jeff Lee
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -052
1250 Oakhaven Ln.
Dr. Morns Yip
Approved
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -053
101 W. Palm Ave.
Zuei Lai
Approved
5. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -054
400 E. Huntington Dr.
Chicago Pizza & Brewery, Inc.
Approved subject to the condition that all
banners be removed by January 15, 1999.
6. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -055
74 Woodland Ln.
Westwood Design for
Mr. and Mrs. Gilchriest
Approved
Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting the removal of an oak tree located at the site's
northerly rear property line, for the proposed construction
of a new block wall (9704b.1).
Requesting to permit a 70' -0" front yard setback in lieu of
89' -0" for a proposed covered porch addition to the main
dwelling. The required setback of 89' -0" is the average of
the two adjacent properties (9251.2.2).
Requesting a 7' -6" northerly side yard setback and a 5'-0"
southerly side yard setback in lieu of 10' -0" for single -story
portion of the main dwelling. The proposed work is
considered a rebuild (9252.2.4).
Requesting a building height (height at top of plate) of 20' -0"
in lieu of 12' -0" for a proposed single -story portion of the
main dwelling addition to be within the first floor setback
(9252.2.4). This is a re- submittal due to changes made to the
previously approved modification.
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed banner:
A. To permit two temporary banners: a 7'- 6 "x5' -6" at 41.25
sq. ft., and a 10 -0"x10'x0" at 100 sq. ft. in lieu of a
maximum total surface area of 32 sq. ft. permitted
(9262.4.13).
B. To allow the temporary banners to be displayed beyond
the standard thirty (30) continuous days allowed
(9262.4.13).
Requesting a 5' -0" southerly side yard setback in lieu of
11' -2" for a proposed workshop addition to be attached and
in line with the existing garage (9251.2.4).
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Thursday, December 3, 1998.
7. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -056
85 W. Longden Ave.
Neil Smith for Mr. & Mrs. Selinski
Approved subject to the condition that the northerly
rear yard and westerly side yard areas be paved in
concrete and gated
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Requesting a 5' -0" westerly side yard setback in lieu of
9' -5" for a proposed garage (9252.2.4).
COMMrr1'EE MEMBERS PRESENT: Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Burnett, Halminski
2
11/24/98
AGENDA
ARCADIA CITY MODIFICATION COMMITTEE
7:45 A.M., TUESDAY, DECEMBER 8,1998
COUNCIL CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ROOM
ROLL CALL:
1. PUBLIC HEARING TR 98 -008
22 Fano St.
NCK Development
Approved subject to the condition that 3 replacement
trees be planted within the front yard area.
2. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -057
161 E. Pamela Rd.
Thomas Anderson
Approved
3. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -058
1605 Holly Ave.
Anh Kim Thai
Approved a landscape plan to be submitted for
staff's review.
4. PUBLIC HEARING MC 98 -059
710 S. Golden West Ave.
Maple Builders for Chuang Hung Chih
Denied
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Kalemkiarian. Rowe, Nicholson
Requesting the removal of an oak tree located near the
westerly property line to accommodate a new residential
condominium project (9704b.1).
Requesting the following modifications for a proposed
room addition:
A. A 5' -0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -1" for a
proposed music room addition (9252.2.4).
B. A 4'-0" easterly side yard setback in lieu of 7' -1" for a
proposed wall mounted a/c unit (9252.2.1.1).
C. A proposed extension of the rear property line wall to be
up to 7'-6" in height in lieu of 6' -0" (9283.9.3).
Requesting a 30' -0" easterly front yard setback in lieu of
40' -0" special setback along Holly Ave. for a proposed two -
story residence (9320.39.1).
Requesting a 27' -0" building height in lieu of a maximum
of 25' -0" for a two -story residence under construction
(9252.2.1).
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Kalemkiarian, Rowe, Nicholson
COMM. DEV. DIV. REPRESENTATIVE: Halminski
There will be a five working day appeal period. Appeals are to be filed by Tuesday, December 15, 1998.