HomeMy WebLinkAboutDECEMBER 16,1997
VIIO \0
39:0302 / -V / h it!
C(
I
CITY COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS ARE AUDIO AND VIDEO TAPE RECORDED AND ON FILE IN THE OFFICE OF
THE CITY CLERK
MINUTES
CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA
and the
ARCADIA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
REGULAR MEETING
DECEMBER 16, 1997
The City Council and the Arcadia Redevelopment Agency met in a Regular Meeting on
Tuesday, December 16,1997. at 6:00 p.m. in the Conference Room of the Arcadia City
Hall Council Chambers.
1.
ROLL CALL: PRESENT: Council/Agency Members Chang, Kuhn, Young, and Harbicht
ABSENT: Council/Agency Member Kovacic (arrived at 6:15 p.m.)
It was MOVED by Council/Agency Member Chang, seconded by Council/Agency
Member Young and CARRIED to EXCUSE the absence of CounCil/Agency Member
Kovacic.
2.
I 3.
. 3a.
;) r)' (~
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION
None.
CLOSED SESSION
Pursuant to Govemment Code Section 54957.6 to confer with the City labor negotiators,
Dan Cassidy and William R. Kelly. regarding Teamsters Local 911, AFSCME Local
2264, AFFA, APOA, Management and non-represented employees.
4.
RESOLUTION (See page 2.)
ARA-180
(ARA 5-Year
Implem. Plan)
At 6:04 p.m. the City Council RECESSED to the Closed Session which concluded at
6:55 p.m. The Regular Meeling RECONVENED in the Council Chambers at 7:00 p.m.
5.
INVOCATION Dr. Sharron Stroud, Center for the Celebration of Life
6.
PLEDGE OF
ALLEGIANCE James Dale, Director of Administrative Services
I
7.
ROLl. CALL PRESENT:
ABSENT:
Council/Agency Members Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
12116197
39:0303
ANNOUNCEMENT Mayor Harbicht announced the Arcadia Beautiful Commission toured the City the
evening of December 15 and will be touring the City this evening to judge home and I
business holiday decorations in preparation of making their annual awards. He reminded
television viewers to turn on their holiday lights.
8.
PRESENTATIONS As a token of their appreciation for the opportunity to work on the City's Downtown 2000
(Landscape Streetscape Project, Roberto Perez and Jesus Lara. representatives from Landscape
West, Inc.) West, Inc. presented to the City the landscape beautification achievement award
plaque their finn received from the California Landscape Contractors Association and
Superior Controls, Inc. of Anaheim, California honoring their work on this project. The
representatives from Landscape West, Inc. said it was an honor to work on this project
with the City and being able to present the plaque to the City of Arcadia. The award was
for the category of "Municipalities Maintenance".
(Arcadia
H/R Comsn.)
O/~() ,/1
9.
The Mayor and Councilmember Chang, liaison to the Arcadia Human Resources
Commission, presented each member of the commission with the Mayor's Certificate of
Commendation in honor and appreciation for their work in advising Council on matters of
human resources policy and serving as a disciplinary hearing appeals board for Human
Resources. Arcadia Human Resources Commission members receiving this award were
Bob Baderian, Bill Kem. Gordon Penharlow. Richard Tauer, and S. H. Wen,
Chairperson. Mayor Harbicht thanked the commission members on behalf of the
citizens of Arcadia for the time and effort they put into this City commission.
SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FROM STAFF REGARDING AGENDA ITEMS
None
I
10.
QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIU REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY REGARDING AGENDA ITEMS
None
11.
ORD. & RES.
READ BY TITLE 11 was MOVED by Councilmember Young. seconded by Councilmember Kuhn and
ONLY CARRIED that ordinances and resolutions be read by title only and that the reading in
full be WAIVED.
12.
PUBLIC HEARING
12a.
RESOLUTION City Manager William Kelly presented RESOLUTION No. ARA-180: "A RESOLUTION
NO. ARA-180 OF THE ARCADIA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY APPROVING THE ADOPTION OF
(ARA 5-Year AN UPDATED FIVE-YEAR IMPLEMENTATION PLAN FOR THE CENTRAL
!mplem. Plan) REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA."
(ADOPTED)
D(,'IO _ "to
Peter Kinnahan. Economic Development Administrator. presented the staff report and
recommendation for this resolution. In part, Mr. Kinnahan stated that AB 1290, the
Redevelopment Reform Law (1993), requires the creation of an "Implementation Plan."
The Arcadia Redevelopment Agency created the implementation plan in December 1994
by the adoption of Resolution No. ARA-175. The law also requires agencies to update
its plan between the second and third year, writing it for another five years.
The Agency is now in the process of updating the plan, tonight's agenda contains a I
revised ~pdaled plan which covers the next five years. In two years the Agency will
need to write a new plan. The plan can be amended with a public hearing at any time.
2
121l6/97
I
I
I
39:0304
Staff has attempted to make this plan as all-inclusive as possible so that any possible
project that could occur in the project area is addressed.
Basic assumptions incorporated in the plan are: (1) estimates of tax increments to be
received by the City in the future are conservative due to the uncertainty of future growth
in the project area even though growth looks quite promising. The lingering property tax
assessment appeals filed by property owners in the project area could result in reduction
of property tax revenues to the City by as much as $135.000 and; (2) workload and
working staff will remain the same (two (2) professionals, and one (1) part-time clerical);
and (3) the goal of the redevelopment process is to achieve significant economic retum
to the City and the Redevelopment Agency. The underlying principle of this
implementation plan is to bring in additional taxes to the City.
Projects are listed in the plan with existing and planned projects. The most significant
new project is in the housing area. The intent of the Agency is to do a major senior
housing project which will benefit low and moderate income individuals. There is no
legal requirement for the Agency to assist in providing new housing for those individuals
previously relocated by the Agency; the earlier adopted plan and this update proposes to
voluntarily attempt to assist 55 year old seniors in very low and moderate income ranges
with a senior citizens housing project or projects. Project specifics and
recom_mendations will be brought forward at a later date. .
Agency members commended staff for an excellent, well done plan.
Agency Member/Mayor Harbicht OPENED the public hearing.
No one came forward to speak in favor of or opposition to this item.
It was MOVED by Agency Member/Mayor Pro tem Kovacic, seconded by
AgencY/Council Member Kuhn and CARRIED to CLOSE the Public Hearing.
It was MOVED by Agency/Council Member Young. seconded by Agency/Council
Member Kuhn and CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to APPROVE the Updated Five-
Year Implementation Plan (FY 1994-1999) by ADOPTING Resolution No. ARA-180.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Agency/Council Members Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
13.
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION
Garland Roberson, Sullivan's Paint, 134 E. Huntington Drive, on behalf of the Arcadia
Business Association, reported on the completion of this year's phase of the downtown
holiday lighting project and thanked the merchants who donatedfunds, and volunteers
who worked on this project. He also thanked the City and Dave Mc Vey, Building
Maintenance Supervisor. for coordinating this project, and gave special thanks to Randy
Diaz from Maintenance Services who did the actual wrapping of the lights in one day.
The resulting budget savings will allow electrical outlets to be installed in ten additional
palm trees. In response to Council's question Mr. Roberson stated lighting was installed
on the palm tree trunks because installation on the palm fronds would create a higher
maintenance cost due to the constant growing and falling off of the fronds.
3
12/16/97
39:0305
A new project suggested by Mr. Roberson was related to the stop signs on First Avenue
and improving the traffic flow in the downtown area. He suggested removing the stop I
signs at Alta and California Streets, leaving the one at Bonita Street. Mr. Roberson
stated citizens have conveyed to him their dislike for the stop signs and have begun to
frequent businesses in surrounding cities rather than deal with the stop signs on First
Avenue. Council agreed to explore this item which will include a safety analysis, and
requested staff to return with a recommendation..
Jim Rider. Arcadia Brewing Company, 107 S. First Avenue, commented in part that
professional service businesses provide additional traffic flow in the redevelopment area
and should not be precluded in Council's future consideration of proposals for businesses
in that area. Although this type of traffic flow is different than retail businesses that
generate sales tax revenues for the City, it is still exposure for the existing businesses in
the redevelopment area and has been beneficial for those in that area.
Regarding the stop sign at the intersection of First Avenue and California Street, Mr.
Rider commented that California Street is too narrow for the vehicles currently utilizing
this thoroughfare. He stated in conversations with the First Avenue School principals
regarding traffic on California Street; their suggestion was to limit the weight of the
vehicles permitted on that section of the street. Mr. Rider requested that Council
investigate this suggestion for traffic safety. l-1e "'so :c.::.,,~,,(! !he school principals
stated there is a new school bus issue to take effect January 1, 1998 th<lt ,c~'.I:'-es the
drivers, when stopping to load and unload students particularly at the school site. to
always turn on their flashing lights. Most students at this school are dropped off by
parents which creates a tremendous traffic jam with the busses. The width of this street
is a significant factor that should be considered by Council.
Mayor Harbicht requested the City Traffic Engineer review these matters regarding I
California Street.
Carol Walker. commercial real estate broker. representing East Huntington Drive
property owners Faye B. Stabler, Margaret Wamer and Lawrence Landis, delivered
letters to the Council from each of them and conveyed their concern regarding the
proposed changes to the CBO zoning regulations (Item 21 c. on the agenda). All
expressed their concern and hope the Council would consider both "retail" and "general
commercial" businesses in the CBO area by not restricting the area to "retail" business
only. A great hardship would be created for property owners with an inability to rent
property if Council rezones to "retail" businesses only.
Lvle Wilson, Arcadia resident, stated he has been approached by many residents living
on Longden Avenue (between Temple City Boulevard and the county area near the
Monrovia city line) regarding information that the City may be increasing the speed limit
to 45 mph on Longden Avenue. Council responded that they are not aware of any
information that this is being considered.
Mr. Wilson had concerns and comments regarding items 21d, e & f on the agenda this
date. He expressed hope that Council would have full discussion regarding the personnel
reclassifications; changes in duties, pay, efficiency, benefits. and felt the City should
review any reclassification after a time period to make sure the reclassification was in
the best interest of the City.
Regarding deregulation of electrical service effective January 1. 1998. Mr. Wilson had
concerns about billing processes the new ~Iectric companies would be using. He also I
expressed his opinion that [he proposed utility tax increase would not "cure" the City's
budget problems.
j
12116/97
I
I
I
14.
YOUNG
(Tree Lights)
(Sis. City
Comsn.)
(City Council
Election)
KUHN
(Rec. Dept.
Classes)
CHANG
'(Christmas Tree
Recycling)
(United Way
Campaign)
39:0306
MATTERS FROM ELECTED OFFICIALS
Councilmember Young commended staff for the creative installation of Christmas lights
on the west lawn tree at City Hall.
As the Council liaison to this commission Mrs. Young requested volunteers to help
coordinate a 25th year celebration of the City's relationship with Newcastle, Australia.
Newcastle is excited about this and has already begun working on the project. Arcadia's
Sister City Commission will begin discussing this at their January 1998 meeting.
Council member Young announced she will not be seeking re-election in April 1998.
Mrs. Young wished all a Merry Christmas.
As the Council liaison to the Recreation Commission, Councilmember Kuhn announced
registration is underway for the winter recreation classes and vacation programs.
Mrs. Kuhn wished Happy Holidays to all. She also expressed how beautiful all the
holiday lights look throughout the City. ,
Councilmember Chang announced Arcadia residents may recycle their Christmas trees
by removing all tinsel, ornaments, lights. and stands, and then put them out on the curb
on the regular trash pick up day between December 26, 1997 and January 10, 1998.
Trees over five feet (5') tall should be cut in half.
Dr. Chang announced the United Way Campaign is now underway in the City of Arcadia.
He encouraged everyone to help the needy by participating in this campaign along with
donations of food to the Arcadia Board of Realtors' Can Tree food drive, and children's
toys for the Arcadia Police Department's Annual Toy Drive.
(City Tree The City's Tree Lighting Ceremony kicked off the holiday season and was enjoyed by
Ltg. Ceremony) many families who participated in this event, especially the children who enjoyed the
snow.
He wished Arcadia residents and employees a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
(Arcadia Chapter Councilmember Chang attended the Holiday Open House held Thursday. December 11
Am. Red Cross at the home of Mr. and Mrs. Mickey Segal. . Dr. Chang commented the home was
Holiday beautiful; the entertainment from Arcadia High School and the food were great. All
Open House) expenses were covered by donations, with the proceeds going to the American Red
Cross.
(Senior CitizensFriday, December 12 was the Arcadia Senior Citizen's Commission's Holiday Party for
Holiday Party) Senior Citizens. Dr. Chang commented it was a very successful event and thanked all
volunteers for their efforts. .
(Downtown
Holiday Street
Lighting)
Councilmember Chang complimented the Arcadia Business Association and their
volunteers on the Downtown Holiday Street Lighting project. The volunteers thanked by
Dr. Chang were: Garland Roberson, Sullivan's Paint; GiI Stromsoe. Mark Schaefer and
Associates; Richard George, First Avenue Florists; Jerry Mascott, Mascott Insurance;
Steve Leeming, The Frame House; Chris Walker, Pro Bike. Their hard work was
commended which has enhanced the beautification of the downtown area.
5
12/16/97
(Arcadia
Chinese
School
Donation to
AEF)
39:0307
Councilmember Chang announced the Arcadia Chinese School students and parents
donated $9,000 to the Arcadia Educational Foundation (AEF) at the school's Christmas
Party on December 5. With Dr. Chang's $1.000 donation, a total of $10,000 was
presented Mickey Segal on that evening for the AEF computer and modern technology
programs for the Arcadia Unified School District classrooms.
I
KOVACIC
(Councilmember Mayor Pro tem Kovacic responded to Councilmember Young's announcement to not
Young) seek re-election in April stating it has been an honor serving with Mrs. Young and he has
benefited from her expertise and experience.
(Fire Dept.'s
EI Nino
Survival
Workshop)
Mr. Kovacic announced that on January 22, 1998 at 7:00 p.m. the Arcadia Fire
Department will present an EI Nino Survival Program in the Council Chambers. This
presentation will provide preparation information and will last about one hour. Plans are
currently underway for a "hands on" Flood Preparedness Workshop also to be held in
January; information as to date, time and location will be forthcoming.
(Employee Mayor Pro tem Kovacic stated the City of Arcadia will be having its annual Employee
Holiday/Recog. Holiday Party on Thursday. December 18 where forty-nine (49) long-term employees will
Party) also be honored. Mr. Kovacic announced the names of those long-term employees who
have served the City for 15, 20, 25 and 30 years..
(Arcadia T of R Mr. Kovacic encouraged all to attend the Tournament of Roses Parade to cheer on
Float) Arcadia's float. The Arcadia Tournament of Roses .~.sscci3tion has worked each year Iv
put on a beautiful floal indicative of Arcadia. This year the Arcadia High School
Marching Band's 350 students will also be participating in the parade.
Mayor Pro Tem Kovacic wished fellow Councilmembers and all Arcadians a Merry I
Christmas, Happy Hanukkah. and best wishes for a healthy and prosperous New Year.
HARBICHT
(Council member Mayor Harbicht commented on Councilmember Young's choice to not seek re-election in
Young) April and expressed his appreciation for her years of service.
("Speaking of
Arcadia"
Program)
(Council
Candidate
Workshop)
(Free Smoke
Detectors)
Mayor Harbicht announced the latest production of the "Speaking of Arcadia" program
began airing on cable television December 15, with the show giving a behind-the-scenes
look at security at Santa Anita Fashion Park. The Police Department has a substation in
the mall along with a holiday season volunteer ham operators program which provides
additional security coverage from the mall roof every evening. He encouraged everyone
to view this program which provides interesting information and reassures the mall is a
very safe place to shop.
The Mayor reported the City is offering a Council Candidate Workshop January 8, 1998
in Council Chambers. This event will last all day and allow plenty of time for
questions. Reservations are required, however attending the workshop does not commit
one as a candidate. A reprinted Council Candidate Manual will be available at City Hall
December 17 from the City Manager or City Clerk's offices.
Mayor Harbicht announced that Radio Shack has supplied the Arcadia Fire Department
with smoke detectors which will be distributed upon request at any of the City's fire
stations free of charge. Under special circumstances the Arcadia Fire Fighters
Association can arrange for delivery and installation of these smoke detectors for
Arcadia Residents.
I
6
12/16/97
I
I
I
39:0308
(Christmas Tree Mayor Harbicht also announced the Arcadia Fire Department has a flyer giving tips for
Safety) Christmas tree safety available at various City facilities.
(City
Investments)
(Sure Pay
Plan - Water
Department)
(Bus Bench
Roofs)
(Advertisin9 on
Dial-A-Ride
Vehicles)
.15'n_~ __
APRIL 14,1998
ELECTION
RESOLUTIONS
IOJ()".tO
The Mayor stated the City's investment policy is very conservative; Councilmembers are
given such a list on a quarterty basis for review. The investment policy is considered on
an annual basis and ratified. The City's portfolio has gained about $25,000 over the last
month and has not been adversely affected by the recent stock market fluctuations.
Mayor Harbicht reminded residents of the, Water Department's Sure Pay Plan in which
individuals can sign up to have water bills automatically paid from a checking account,
saving postage and writing of a check. Over 500 people have signed up for this program
to date.
A concerned Arcadia businessman phoned Mayor Harbicht regarding bus bench roofs to
protect bus riders on hot or rainy days. The City looked into this matter several years
ago, but did not proceed for various reasons. Council requested that staff bring forward a
report regarding the feasibility of this idea and of utilizing Proposition A funds.
As a revenue generating idea Mayor Harbicht suggested the idea of selling advertising
space on the City's Arcadia Transit (Dial-A-Ride) vehicles. Council requested staff to
begin exploring the income potential, the pros and cons of doing such a project and
return with a report.
" , - .
CITY CLERK
City Clerk June Alford announced her office has been very busy preparing for the
April 14. 1998 election, and that nominations for four (4) seats on the City Council will
open on Monday, December 22, 1997 at 7:30 a.m. The nominations will close on
January 16, 1998 if all incumbents have filed their nomination papers. If an incumbent
does not file by January 16, 1998 the nominating period will be extended to January 21.
1998 for people other than incumbents. In response to Council. Mrs. Alford responded
that if Councilmember Young does not file by January 16, 1998, that four year Council
position will be extended to January 21, 1998; if the incumbent for the two year position
files by January 16,1998. that particular position would then be closed.
15a.
RESOLUTION The City Clerk presented a report and read the title of Resolution No. 6024: "A
NO. 6024 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA.
(Utility User ORDERING THE SUBMISSION TO THE QUALIFIED ELECTORS OF THE CITY OF
Tax Measure A ARCADIA A CERTAIN MEASURE RELATING TO THE UTILITY USER TAX RATE AT
4/14/98 Elect.) THE GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION TO BE HELD ON TUESDAY. APRIL 14, 1998
(ADOPTED) AS CALLED BY RESOLUTION NO. 6017."
ItJ;$O '.J.O City Attorney Miller commented in part and explained specifics of the wording for the
ballot Measure A, Exhibit "A". The measure would increase the Utility User Tax to 7%,
which would revert back to 5% in four years on April 15, 2002..
Council commented in part that there has not been a groundswell of support from
Arcadia residents to promote this maller to reinstate budget reductions Council was
forced to make. The holidays may be a factor in lack of voter response at this time; April
1998 is not in forefront of people's minds. Some Councilmembers have received
indications that some sort of a citizen support group will form as the election gets closer,
and City Council candidate's response to this issue will also be a determining factor.
Council is also concerned whether this measure will be approved by the voters if simply
put on the ballot without promotion. and voters' response after the failure of the Fire
Suppression District.
7
12116/97
39:0309
Council discussed and gave staff direction regarding the actual wording of the Measure
A question to be submitted on the ballot.
I
It was MOVED by Councilmember Young, seconded by Councilmember Kuhn and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to ADOPT Resolution NO. 6024.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang, Kovacic. Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
15b.
RESOLUTION
NO. 6025
(City Library
Employees -
Measure B
4/14/98 Elect.)
(ADOPTED)
10 ~c -or!
The City Clerk presented a report and read the title of Resolution No. 6025: "A
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA,
CALLING AND GIVING NOTICE OF THE HOLDING OF A GENERAL MUNICIPAL
ELECTION ON TUESDAY, APRIL 14. 1998 FOR THE SUBMISSION OF A PROPOSED
CHARTER AMENDMENT RELATING TO CITY LIBRARY EMPLOYEES:
City Attomey Mike Miller commented that this resolution is before Council due to past
negotiations which resulted in the agreement that this item would be put forward as a
ballot measure which will involve an amendment to the Arcadia City Charter. Proposed
wording has been sent to the Teamsters Union reoresenting these employees; there has
been no negative response. The City Manager and Library ",ai::::gement have reviewed
the wording also. This measure would place certain lIibrary employees in the classified
service ofthe City.
It was MOVED by Council member Young. seconded by Councilmember Kuhn and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to ADOPT Resolution NO. 6025.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn. Young and Harbicht
None .
None
I
15c.
RESOLUTION The City Clerk presented a report and read the tiUe of Resolution No. 6026: "A
NO. 6026 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA,
(Ballot Measure SETTING PRIORITIES FOR FILING WRITTEN ARGUMENTS REGARDING CITY
Arguments MEASURES CONCERNING THE UTILITY USER TAX RATE AND A CHARTER
4/14/98 Elect.) REVISION REGARDING THE CITY CIVIL SERVICE SYSTEM AND DIRECTING THE
(ADOPTED) CITY ATTORNEY TO PREPARE AN IMPARTIAL ANALYSIS.'
It!.:s i). ; fJ City Clerk June Alford explained that "The City Council or any member of the City
Council authorized by that body may file a written argument for or against a City
measure. These arguments are due for filing on January 6. 1998. If more than one
argument is submitted for or against a City measure the election code mandates that the
City Clerk accord priority as follows. The first priority is the legislative body. which in this
case means the City Councilor an authorized member of that body. Number two is an
individual voter, or an association, or a combination who are bona fide sponsors or
proponents of the measure. Number three is a bona fide association of citizens.
Number four would be individual voters."
City Attorney Mike Miller supplemented Mrs. Alford's comments by stating in part that
this is an optional resolution for both measures if the Council wants to establish a priority
position for arguments and submit arguments. For Council's clarification Attorney Miller I
further clarified the prioritizations set forth in this resolution.
g
12116/97
I
I
I
39:0310
Staff responded to Council's Question regarding the signers of a wrillen argument. stating
in part, that the maximum number of signers would be five (5), including the author. And
Council could designate council members to worite the arguments. There is a required
ten (10) day public examination period for wrillen arguments after they are filed and prior
to printing. If changes are needed regarding this maller, a special Council meeting could
be called to resolve any issue.
After considerable discussion regarding whether or not Council should designate
someone to write arguments in favor of or against the ballot measures, no
Councilmembers were designated.
It was MOVED by Councilmember Young, seconded by Mayor Harbicht and CARRIED
on roll call vote as follows to ADOPT Resolution NO. 6026 without authorizing any
Council member to write arguments in favor of or against the ballot measures. and to
designate January 6. 1998 as the final date for submission of such arguments to the City
Clerl<.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Council members Chang. Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
15d.
RESOLUTION The City Clerk presented a report and read the title of Resolution No. 6027: "A
NO. 6027 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA.
(Ballot Measure PROVIDING FOR THE FILING OF REBUTTAL ARGUMENTS FOR CITY MEASURES
Rebullal SUBMITTED AT MUNICIPAL ELECTIONS (MEASURES A & B - ELECTION OF APRIL
Arguments 14,1998."
Elect. 4/14/98)
(NOT City Allomey Mike Miller commented in part that this resolution is strictly optional,
ADOPTED) however. it does provide for the rebullals to the arguments for and against a measure
1030 ~1.1() and does add to the election materials.
It was MOVED by Councilmember Chang. seconded by Mayor Harbicht and CARRIED
on roll call vote as follows to NOT ADOPT Resolution NO. 6027.
15e.
RESOLUTION
NO. 6028
(Ordering the
Canvass of the
Elect. 4/14/98)
(APPROVED)
If!) .s f) 4 ;>(1)
Discussion following the motion in part consisted of reasons for not including rebullal
arguments in the voter information which often confuses the voter and is often redundant
of the arguments in favor of or against a measure.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Council members Chang, Kovacic. Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
The City Clerl< presented a report and read the title of Resolution No. 6028: "A
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA,
ORDERING THE CANVASS OF THE GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION TO BE HELD
ON APRIL 14. 1998, TO BE MADE BY THE CITY CLERK OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA."
City Clerk June Alford explained that this is basically a "balancing" of the election
returns. During ,the canvass. which occurs the week following the election date, an
inspection of returns from all voting precincts. absentee ballots, the precinct officers'
statements on the reverse side of precinct rosters takes place to verify the ballots issued;
voted, spoiled and unused.
9
J 2116N7
39:0311
It was MOVED by Councilmember Chang, seconded by Councilmember Kuhn and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to ADOPT Resolution NO. 6028.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang. Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbichl
None
None
I
16.
THE CITY COUNCIL RECESSED IN ORDER TO ACT AS THE
ARCADIA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
17a.
MINUTES
(Nov. 18 and
Dec. 2. 1997)
(APPROVED)
17b.
(ARA Annual
Report -
FY 1996-1997)
(APPROVED)
()G?;) . I~-
It was MOVED by Councilmember Young. seconded by Councilmember Kuhn and
CARRIED to APPROVE the Minutes of the November 18, 1997 and the December 2.
1997 Regular Meetings.
Mr. Kinnahan. Economic Development Administrator. stated in part, that State law
requires that the Arcadia Redevelopment Agency prepare and submit a report within six
months after the end of the fiscal year to the State of California Department of Housing
and Community Development (HCD), the State Controller, and the legislative body (City
Council). The annual report was prepared by staff of the Economic Development
Division and the Agency's auditors, Lance, Soli and Lunghard. and also includes the
Agency's audit. The report briefly summarizes the actions taken by the Agency in this
fiscal year with particular attention given to the financial situation of the Agency. In the
report the auditors found the Agency has acted in compliance with state laws, regulations
and policies that govern redevelopment.
I
It was MOVED by Agency member Chang, seconded by Agency member Young and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to APPROVE the ARA Annual Report - FY 1996-
1997.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Agency members Chang. Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
17c.
Neg. Decl. & DDA On October 7, 1997 the Redevelopment Agency considered a proposal from ICD/Heatfiex
(Emkayl (ICD) for an instrumentation office and assembly facility on the Emkay Remnant Parcel
ICD Heatflex located at the northwest corner of Santa Clara Street and Fifth Avenue. The Agency
Project - NW indicated that while the use was acceptable, more work was required on the architectural
Comer - Santa design of the building. Revised site plans were submitted this date to the Agency, with
Clara & 5th Ave.) the request to approve the revised concept elevations and the plan, and an Amended
(APPROVED) and Restated Disposition and Development Agreement (DDA). This would approve an
= assignment of the baiance of Emkay's development obligations to ICD and permit the
~6?<:) ,p~ construction of an 18,000 square foot office and assembly facility on the remnant parcel
by December 31. 1998. Additional details of this project are setforth in the December
16, 1997 staff report. Mr. Peter Kinnahan, Economic Development Administrator, noted
that this business will generate approximately $20,000-$25.000 in tax income to the
Agency.
I
10
12116197
I
I
I
39:0312
It was MOVED by Agency Member Young. seconded by Agency Member Chang and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to APPROVE the ICD architecture and hardscape
site plans and design; and APPROVE the amended and restated DDA among the
Arcadia Redevelopment Agency, Emkay Development Company and ICD/Heatflex, Inc..
subject to minor revisions approved by the Agency Attorney as to form, and
AUTHORIZE the Executive Director to EXECUTE all documents related thereto on
behalf of the Agency.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
Agency Members Chang, Kovacic, Young and Harbicht
None
Agency Member Kuhn
None
18.
ADJOURNMENT The meeting of the Arcadia Redevelopment Agency ADJOURNED to January 6. 1998 at
6:00 p.m.
19.
20.
20a:
MINUTES
(Nov. 18 and
Dec. 2,1997)
THE CITY COUNCIL RECONVENED
CONSENT ITEMS
APPROVED the Minutes of the November 18, 1997 and the December 2. 1997 Regular
Meetings.
20b.
(ARA Annual APPROVED the Arcadia Redevelopment Agency Annual Report for Fiscal Year 1996 -
Report - 1997; and DIRECT staff to transmit said report to the State of California Department of
FY 1996-1997) Housing and Community Development (HCD) and the State Controller.
()6ft) .,/\
21.
THE ABOVE CONSENT ITEMS 20a, AND b, APPROVED ON
COUNCILMEMBER YOUNG. SECONDED BY COUNCILMEMBER
CARRIED ON ROLL CALL VOTE AS FOLLOWS;
MOTION BY
KUHN AND
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
CITY MANAGER
21a.
(Centennial City Manager William Kelly stated in part that Council's adoption of Resolution No. 5995
Celebration on June 3, 1997 established the Arcadia Centennial Celebration Commission and
Comsn.) authorized staff to solicit interested citizens to serve on this body. The resolution called
(APPOINTMENTS) for fifteen (15) commission members to be appointed. At the December 2, 1997 Council
., , meeting staff was directed to submit a matrix to Council with the names of forty-one (41)
. f.... ,," applicants so that each Council member could cast their choice for appointments to the
commission
It was MOVED by Councilmember Young, seconded by Mayor Harbicht and CARRiED
on roll call vote as follows to APPOINT the first fifteen (15) names on the list as follows:
Jim Barrows. Dorothy Denne, Jo Ann Scott, Warren Shaw, Joyce Hansen, Mary Hansen,
11
12116/97
39:0313
James Helms. Jr.. Teresa Hsu, Carol Libby, Mildred Shaw, Theresa Huang, Roger Lu,
Eva Procter, Richard Proctor. and Patricia Williams..
I
A short discussion followed regarding members of the same family serving on the
committee. the appointment process. inclusion of remaining applicants to serve on sub-
committees.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Council members Chang. Kovacic, Kuhn. Young and Harbicht
None
None
The Mayor noted that letters will be sent to all commission applicants.
21b.
CBD Zoning Donna Butler, Community Development Administrator, presented the staff report and an
Regulations - overview of this item. In August. 1997 Council requested the Planning Commission
Downtown Area review the Central Business District (CBD) Regulations for effectiveness and
(Prepare Text recommend appropriate changes if necessary. The existing regulations prohibit
Amendment) professional and business offices along Huntington Drive and First Avenue in the
06"') . Downtown area unless they are in an existing building designed for office use. The
." '>t. -~ proposal was not to change that aspect of the regulations, but to update the regulations
as they relate to the existing businesses and the future development and growth of the
CBD zone.
The Planning Commission held four (4) study sessions at which time property owners or
representatives of the property owners in the Downtown area were present. The focus of
the study was to discuss "retail" versus "general commercial" uses. the definition of retail,
signage. and outdoor displays and promotional devices. The Planning Commission's I
recommendations were presented for Council's review and consideration.
Considerable discussion ensued. In response to Council's questions, staff replied in part,
by providing the new proposed definition of "retail" as determined by staff and the
Planning Commission, explaining a new proposed category of "consumer services", how
new businesses are categorized within the regulations, "grandfathering" of existing
businesses that could be affected by regulation modifications, determination of use,
signage, and conditional use permits. Impact of the proposed regulation changes to
business areas of the City other than the CBD was also discussed.
Councilmember Young commended the Planning Commission for its thoughtful and
complete work on this report.
It was MOVED by Council member Young, seconded by Councilmember Kuhn and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to DIRECT staff to prepare the appropriate text
amendment based on the proposed changes to the CBD Zoning Regulations.
Mayor Pro tem Kovacic expressed concerns regarding furthering the restriction of
business types permitted to occupy the first floor of a building in the Downtown area.
Mayor Harbicht directed that the Planning Commission consider Council's intention of
increasing foot traffic in the CBD area in its designation of the types of businesses
permitted for this area.
Councilmember Kuhn expressed concern that the use designation may be too restrictive
but that while moving forward with this item,. perhaps the designations should be I
reassessed.
12
12116/97
I
I
I
39:0314
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
21c.
CITIZEN'S COMTE.City Manager Kelly presented the staff report regarding the possible formation of a
Utility Tax - "Citizen's Committee" associated with t~e April 1998 ballot measure to increase the
Measure A utility tax by 2%. Any committees established by the City Council would be subject to
(NO ACTION) the Brown Act; their meetings open to the public. agendas and formal notices posted,
1(' ., etcetera. Limitations to such a committee's activities was also reviewed. Alternatives to
'-~ ~ formation of a committee were also discussed.
Mayor Pro tern Kovacic reviewed previous Council discussions and concepts regarding
the purpose and formation of such a committee. Mr. Kovacic favored a citizen's
committee to provide the educational resources and a fair and objective analysis of the
utility taxissue to the voters.
Councilmember Kuhn expressed that the committee should come from grassroots and
not be bound by bureaucracy. The educational aspect of this measure is very important
and staff can be available to the public for informational materials. Mrs. Kuhn stated she
would not be in support of a formally appointed committee. .
Councilmember Young concurred with Mrs. Kuhn stating that a grassroots group would
be much stronger in their efforts. Mrs. Young suggested the City Council conduct open
community meetings of which she would be supportive.
Councilmember Kuhn offered assistance to any citizen group wanting information or
education about the proposed utility tax measure.
Value and validity of such an appointed committee was questioned by Mayor Harbicht,
as the information could be provided to citizens by City staff. Therefore, he toowas not
in favor of appointing a committee.
21d.
JOB Donna Butler. Community Development Administrator. presented the staff report and
CLASSIFICATION recommendation for revision of the Transportation Services Officer position
(Transp. Svcs. classification. Ms. Butler stated this position has been vacant since April 1997;
Officer - Pos. recruitment began in March 1997, interviews were conducted, however no qualified
Revision) candidate was found. Currently. a consultant on contract with the City works 50 - 70
(APPROVED) hours per month at the rate of $65 per hour. This was the least expensive of all
O",.)U _ /0 consultants found. The consultant is doing a fine job, but has other consulting jobs to do.
A comparison was conducted with other similar city transit services positions and it was
found the salary offered was very close to the bottom. The duties have been increased
and expanded for this position which requires greater experience. Finding a qualified
person is important, therefore the City must maintain a competitive salary schedule.
Among numerous other duties the Transportation Services Officer oversees the Arcadia
Transit service and researches for all funding sources available for transit and
transportation related issues. The Human Resources Commission has given their
approval for the necessary upgrading of this position.
Staff responded to Council, stating the Human Resources staff conducted the position
comparison. the compensation stated in the staff report did not include benefits, and the
suggested pay range is midway between the highest and lowest being offered at other
cities. Steps within the pay range and criteria for placement on those steps were
13
12/16/97
21e.
JOB
ClASSIFICATION
(Human Res.
Manager -
Pos. Revision)
(APPROVED)
Ci ~.) (l .f/"
21f.
Retirement
Service Credit
(Prepare
Resolution &
RECEIVE &
FILE RPT.)
();UtJ "Ii)
39:0315
explained. Recruitment efforts executed in an attempt to fill this position were also
reviewed.
I
It was MOVED by Councilmember Chang, seconded by Councilmember Young and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to APPROVE the revision of the classification of
Transportation Services Officer, and establish a new salary schedule of $3,784 - 4,600
per month.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn. Young and Harbicht
None
None
James Dale. Administrative Services Director presented the staff report and
recommendation to revise the Human Resources Manager position classification stating
in part that it has become aware that the City is no longer offering a competitive salary
when an employee leaves for a similar position at a higher salary. Currently the City is
recruiting for a Human Resources Manager since the departure of Gary Rogers in
September 1997.
The role of the Human Resources Manager has changed greatly over the last several
years expanding into many new areas some of which are risk management, labor union
relations/negotiations, sexual harassment, workers compensation, benefits
administration. etcetera. This is a key position in the City organization; the
compensation Arcadia offers is significantly below the current market, approximately
$1.000 below the average monthly salary of the survey cities. Staff is recommending
the salary be increased to $5.016 - $6,097 per month representing a $700 increase
(about 13%) to attract qualified candidates who can successfully perform the duties
assigned. The Human Resources Commission has reviewed and approved the revised
position classification and proposed salary adjustment.
I
Staff responded to Council's inquiries in part stating the salary does not include benefits.
clarifying areas overseen by this position, and the prevention of liability exposure a
qualified person in this position can provide. The cities utilized in the comparison study
were EI Monte, Covina, Pasadena, West Covina, Monterey Park, Monrovia. Alhambra
and Burbank. The current salary Arcadia offers for this position falls 15.6% ($993 per
month) below the average salary offered by these cities.
It was MOVED by Councilmember Young, seconded by Mayor Harbicht and CARRIED
on roll call vote as follows to APPROVE the revision of the classification of Human
Resources Manager, and establish a new salary schedule of $5,016 - 6,097 per month.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Council members Chang, Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
James Dale, Administrative Services Director presented the staff report and
recommendation regarding a retirement service credit for eligible employees.
In its efforts to balance this fiscal year's budget Council has eliminated the position of
Equipment Maintenance Superintendent which facilitated the downsizing and
reorganization of the Maintenance Department. The elimination of the position will result
in an employee being laid off. Staff requested that Council consider a severance
package for the employee which will provide an additional retirement service credit of
two (2) years.
I
1-1
12//6/97
I
I
I
22.
22a.
ORDINANCE
NO. 2082
(Prohibiting
Clotheslines -
front & side
yards)
(ADOPTED)
t'JS 1ft) ~ ,6 ..
39:0316
The current layoff policy entitles this employee to a severance package which would cost
the City as much as $19.000. The employee is near retirement age. has served the City
in a stellar manner, a dedicated, loyal member of the City team. The layoff will have a
serious. lasting impact on the individual. II is not uncommon for a City to provide some
financial cushion or incentive for employees laid off in a downsizing situation. The
elimination of this position will result in a savings to the City of nearly $75,000 annually,
the two (2) years service credit will cost an estimated $27,900, resulting in a net savings
to the City for the initial year of $47,100 and over $75,000 annually thereafter.
Staff responded to Council in part by clarifying figures utilized in determining actual
package costs to the City.
It was MOVED by Council member Chang, seconded by Mayor Pro tem Kovacic and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows to DIRECT staff to bring back to the City Council a
resolution for adoption that fulfills the requirements as defined in Govemment Code
Section 20903.5; and RECEIVE AND FILE the report as evidence that the costs
associated with the service credit were made public.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Council members Chang. Kovacic. Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
CITY ATTORNEY
The City Attomey presented for adoption and read the title of Ordinance No. 2082:
"AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA,
CALIFORNIA. AMENDING THE ARCADIA MUNICIPAL CODE BY ADDING SECTION
9405.18 TO THE PROPERTY MAINTENANCE AND NUISANCE ABATEMENT CODE
(TEXT AMENDMENT 97-004)." .
It was MOVED by Council member Kuhn. seconded by Council member Young and
CARRIED on roll call vote as follows that ORDINANCE NO. 2082 be and it is hereby
ADOPTED.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Councilmembers Chang. Kovacic, Kuhn, Young and Harbicht
None
None
ADJOURNMENT At 10:07 p.m. the Regular Meeting of the City Council ADJOURNED to 6:00 p.m.,
(Jan. 6,1998) Tuesday. January 6, 1998 in the Conference Room of the Council Chamber for a
Regular meeting to conduct the business of the City Council and any Closed Session
necessary to discuss personnel, litigation matters or evaluation of properties.
ATTEST:
~J
. June D. Alford. Citv
c./ .
/~~
Robert C. Harbichl. Mayor of the Cny of Arcadia
15
12116/97