No preview available
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSNEW-18-0964 1 / ,.+ City of Arcadia, CA Permit NO. SNew-18-0964 Development Services Department Permit Type:Single Family New 240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 Work Classification:SFR-New Dwelling • r (626)574-5416 Permit Status: Issued ARCADIA Issue Date: 10/08/2018 1 Expiration: 04/06/2019 Addr NO. Dir Prefix Street Name Street Suffix Unit City,State,Zip Parcel Number ( 111 Hacienda DR Arcadia,CA 5770002013 Contacts RAMY ZAIFMAN Owner CL DESIGN Applicant 27 TANNERS RD,GREAT NECK, NY 11020 (914)473-6592 ZJUDYRAMY@GMAIL.COM (626)255-9337 BOWDEN DEVELOPMENT INC* General Contractor(B) 212 W Foothill, Monrovia,CA 91016 (626)303-7917 Description:5 BED,5 1/2 BATH,LIVING,DINING, KITCHEN, ( Valuation: $ 1.059,769.12 Tenant LIBRARY/OFFICE,GREAT ROOM,LAUNDRY, 4-CAR GARAGE, MUD RM,FOYER,ATRIUM,DETACHED POOL CABANA (AKA: Total Sq Feet: 7,283.00 Plan Check#18-964 Plan#32602 SOLID COVERED PATIO)WITH CHANGING RM AND 3/4 BATH Fees Amount Payments Amount Paid Building Issuing Fee $44.35 Total Fees $32,275.04 Building Permit Fees $7,848.00 Cash/Receipt#REC-001388-2018 $10,010.92 Building Plan Review Fee $5,101.20 Cash/Receipt#REC-002524-2018 $22,264.12 Cal Green Plan Check $510.12 Amount Due: Energy Plan Review Fee $1,569.60 $0.00 Grading Issuance Fee $44.35 ' Grading Permit Fee(1-1000 CY) $450.00 Grading Plan Review Fee $850.00 Green Building Standard $43.00 LID Plan Check Fee $100.00 COMPLETED Off Site Plan Check(Per Site) $240.00 CALLS FOR INSPECTIONS Parks&Recreation Fee(SFR) $10,696.05 Request for inspection by telephone at 626-574-5450. Leave a message Single Family Fire Plan Check $280.00 requesting the address,timeframe and what inspection item is needed. Single Family/Condo/Townhome Impact $1,983.00 Fee Solid Waste Management Fee $6.25 This permit/plan review expires by time limitation and becomes null and Strong Motion Inst.Program Res $137.77 void if the work authorized by the permit is not commenced within 180 days SWMF FEE 2 $1.00 from the date of issuance or if the permit is not obtained within 180 days SWMF FEE 2 $1.00 from the date of plan submittal.This permit expires and becomes null and WELO Permit Fee $625.00 void if any work authorized by this permit is suspended or abandoned for 180 WELO Permit Issuance $44.35 consecutive days or if no progressive work has been verified by a City of WELO Plan Check $1700 00 Arcadia building inspector for a period of 180 consecutive days. Total: $32,275.04 7 October 08, 2018 Issued By: Date October 08,2018 Page 1 of 1 %FA• WOW 1 PERMIT/PLAN REVIEW APPLICATION Ew• Development Services Department,240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 , ` Arcadia, CA 91066-6021, (626) 574-5416,Fax(626) 447-9173 City of Arcadia LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION ❑ I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following: Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000,of Division 3 of the Business and ) Professions Code,and my license is in full force and effect. ❑ I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self-insure for workers' License Class S License No.3ZZ lP LO Exp. Date 3131 f lq compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the �L performance of the work for which this permit is issued. Signature of Contractor `i a/_ OWNER-BUILDER DECLARATION ❑ I have and will maintain workers'compensation insurance,as required by Section ❑ I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am exempt from the Contractors 3700 of the Labor Code,for the performance of the work for which this permit License Law for the following reason(Section 7031.5,Business and Professions is issued.My workers'compensation insurance carrier and policy numbers are: Code.Any city or county which requires a permit to construct,alter,improve, Carrier On F lk c demolish,or repair any structure,prior to its issuance,also required the applicant Policy Number for such permit to file a signed statement that he or she is licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Contractors License Law(Chapter 9(commencing with Section (This section need not be completed if the permit is for one hundred dollars or less) 7000)of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code)or that he or she is exempt there from and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of ❑ I certify that in the performance of the work for which this permit is issued,I shall Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the workers' penalty of not more than five hundred dollars($500)): compensation Laws of California,and agree that if I should become subject to the workers'compensation provisions of Section 3700 of the Labor Code,I shall ❑I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole forthwith comply with those provisions. compensation,will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for Date ‘0 I q1 1`-� Signature //"e-A,. sale(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, or who does such work himself or herself or through his or her own employees,provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for WARNING: Failure to secure Workers'Compensation coverage is unlawful, sale.If,however,the building or improvement is sold within one(1)year of and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to one completion,the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he or she hundred thousand dollars($100,000),in addition to the cost of compensation, did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). damages as provided for in Section 3706 of the Labor Code, interest, and attorney's fees. ❑I, as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY who builds or improves thereon,and who contracts for such projects with a I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that there is a construction lending agency contractor(s)licensed pursuant to the Contractors License Law). for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued (Section 3097, Civil Code). ❑ I am exempt under Section 7044,Business and Professions Code,for this reason: Lender's Name Date Signature Lender's Address IMPORTANT: APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR A PERMIT SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS SET FORTH ON THIS APPLICATION AND THE FOLLOWING: 1. The City's approved plans and permit inspection card must remain on the job site for use by City inspection personnel. 2. Final inspection of the work authorized by this permit is required.A Certificate of Occupancy must be obtained prior to use and occupancy of new buildings and structures. 3. Per South Coast Air Quality Management District(AQMD)regulations,renovation and remodeling work that results in the removal,stripping,or altering of asbestos containing materials requires an asbestos survey and removal prior to disturbing the asbestos. Please contact AQMD at(909)396-2000 for r further information. lame \ C0‘41 ,2/��� ]TitleV.)\—i % ( 0 ie.cA ne-gck c r ' PRINT NAME • I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct and that I am the owner or duly authorized agent of the owner. I agree to comply with all City ordinances and State Laws relating to buildin construction. I hereby authorize representatives of the City of Arcadia to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. ignature ``'71W' iC L Date NOTES Building Inspections Date Insp. Plumbing Inspections Date I Insp. //7 /4 / , �J1 c' 100. Setbacks 210. Under hr./bldg.drain ,..,,K.; / C./ l `�( 101. Rough grade ' � 211. Copper underslab 102. Figs.&forms 27/- * L 212. Rough plumbing ,/ /1.,-Ar // /f // ' l.0 ��+� S 103. Pre-slab 213. Routh'as �! / 104. Floor joists 214. Shower pan 5>74' ,L// f%77G� 7reGii'!( 105. Steel 215. Water heater °/ 106. Grout lift 216. Roof drains 107. Shear nailing 5---Z-ii _ 217. Building sewer e-il i r /,-;:v.-7, 7/� _ 108. Diaph nailin. 218. Water servi Z-63011 1:,,,,f .4).41-)s„) u/� p ,,,,a e-CACM„q B 109. Roof nailing i 219. Final.asAIWA 110. Framing gyf r ,-/y.--L 220. Fixtures 2*1 1•1 9 PP A-� •R•+n✓hien•> t t1/4 111. Occ./Area Sept.Wall 221. Final plumbing -Z' t__ p ),,,,/, 4 leo,,% A_ of t•Io uSF •D 112. Sound walls 222. Sewer cap/demo.-) 113. T-bar.rid j ' i- e9 ,i / ../ ( Insp. � (..5.s� 2Lt�E St ( 114. Insulation-Flr. Pool Inspections Date / 115. Insulation Wall �' 240. Excavation/steel /��G, /‘-.7 �� 116. Insulation-Ceil. i j I 241. Rough plumbing /� / l '��` 117. Drywall nailing �� 242. Light shell/bonding O 4 5 4/4 y� (ez' f/'c �/ 118. Interior lath A► ;1 // 243. Underground conduit ./ / �' 119. Exterior lath -2 `j 7 244. P-trap ,) 120. Finish grade 245. Gas line&test /Z•1 /9 ,/CJ 121. Final building 246. Fence,gates&signs ., �N��L / o� 7Y�Fi�-9� 122. Final demo/lot clear 247. Pool heater /I /. 248. Final electric L ,, ei , I / i PC Electrical Inspections Date Insp. 249. Final.lumbin. 150. Power pole 41.61,SED 1,'' •1"q roil' , moi_ / `'_L .i/�.4 . /I:�.Ir 250. Pool cover , ' n 151. Sales lot lighting 251. Pool final -p7 i' / /ij/f t! J/r �i//�D!✓li C 152. Underground conduit 01 /7 153. Underslab conduit Reroof Inspections Date Insp. ! /��(r� �L a: /' / . 0/ 154. UFER ground - -�/ 270. Pre-reroof insp. 6P/4_ 0g5-e' ZPS oil • 155. Water ground V�9_l 271. Roof framing / /i �/. 156. Rough electrical 1- 272. Sheathing nailing G1/L / 157. Fixtures 273. Final reroof ./'f l e 5 ' / /S�!a ' /rte 158. G.F.C.I. - "/,,fG'4ft 1 , /j 1;24,1771) 1, 159. Es et.bondin. Sign Inspections Date Insp. 160. Service panel ,- Aft / 280. Setback/overhang ' . !I/ " i /./..-. . - 161. Fi.al etectri. iL 281. Footin. %,i ariv'h - / %! _�� ��� 282. Conduit/wirin. 71 / � /�Mechanical Insiections Date Inst. 283. Disconnect / / _/ii/ ir 180. Venting/flue 284. Final sign aL/ Cp�� 1���/4 -eC reCi� 181. Furnace/A.C. 182. Rouch HVAC 729-11 .1 '. ' •I•' I . Date Insp. _ r/ doe-4of4-4 183. Fire dampers 290. Fire alarm 184. Furnace compartment 291. Underground supply fiQ �( 185. Combustion air 292. Fire sprinklers r boar/S S /��k elk 1 q4vii 186. Smoke detectors 293. Monitor system 187. Metal F.P.rough 294. Hood dry chem. 188. Compressor setback 295. Final 189. Commercial hood 190. Duct shaft Sewers&Offsite Insp. Date Insp. 191. Final mechanical 'Z[) J 300. Lateral(main to P/L) 301. Saddle/Y Block Wall Inspections Date Insp. 302. Cess...l filled 200. Footings 303. Sidewalk 201. Steel/rebar 304. Driveway 202. Grout lift 305. Curb replacement 203. Final wall 306. Trash bin CID CL DESIGN A Ny ,--, ,--t -- --0 IMF r C01102 St IV 111111111111111 1 "a"v`MnK.' , <1414,v Ar ..,......,, aw mr m, : Akir lika. 1 FINs la ma u a —rs:riTairam1 p p , 1 1 RENvas. In0 0A¢ L ----------- -0OR �. 1 r1 \ 1 1 •o-o 11 1 ' \ MIEGICSIllift...'•-0• 'iL)nIM\ , 1a'-0121-0• nv �',0-0• 11 I \I g� V �J/:J .. I, I�� --•'-,, 11 Y PROJECT 5 �( 1 b."- hsioi°.+4fm. iQ p'� ��®Sq,-•.m7A°.••e4�a�6 rg,�r adt'' '•� 11 " a sl�� 6P si w,.6-2e. y _ 11=i 7iialk , i SINGLE E} �$c• 3cr 1 .� Il - • n .IU' ll • as ill :II z FAMILY �� - ° £5 - F O- , = !SII n,� •F , RESIDENCE a € ��II �' e•. }fy [!sem' .:may 11 1'' 'IR,, m n�acnos a+. m� ,1 .... n i s' n '-^I I , ; ARCADIA.CA 91006 N a eases ($- :: :. ..� �.- - k r..... g Iir ill .;n`r1�3� ' m 2, �'CC 1 *b.'. , :ate" O o gar PILE 2 .d r Q-�M°r _ -- .fir 1 p - � � �I IIi r:f 2 it JII =- ri 'Y -NOP Y'S �i i SITE PLAN fCC� p_rm�o o,: I _ _� lYix t1. 1.2 ca 1 a Ash' s �g = 1 a 111 C IN -:...-4:41.7-• , F.+Vj � . n N 6 •�' ��_�! W , vt,:i...io.,70,1 l -0 �• • PA -. jOrsfr 7Y +J'�s-.��R(["•'S_� -v. . 1 6 . 6 v�- 6 6 if I iviii WIN N ,Fw 1•••••.-_ .1•�ys: �I1��atll®0E".HU11l1IN���CH8G41/61R6�+ Y a WZ 6• «Y,;6 l.!Skit ogre a/z:/zon Aft �� Ill*•���1�7t3���- ..e•'. ....�isscro.«: 5 �1 Z 1 SCALE As NiffillOM orii�mi x-6•_Y 21-0• 2a-a' 21 utttt ott... IL.-:. x11 1 DRAIN CL SHEET , 1 a II a•0• .. `,1 i A-1.1 C `01 OSITE PW+ \�1 1. II S 6 SKIT $s t sy Certificate No.20121023-905 ARCADIA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT 150 South Third Avenue,Arcadia,CA 91006 • (626) 821-8300 Ext. 6732 Certificate of Compliance for Payment of Developer Fees (Education Code §17620,et seq. &Government Code §65995,et seq.) Effective July 24,2017 Current rate in effect applies at the time of imposition of fees/payment. ProjectAddress/APN: 111 Hacienda Dr. , Arcadia , CA 91006 Number of Units in Project: 0 n e Plan Check Number: 18-964 [ 1* [XI** [ l** Exempt: [ ]500 sq.ft.or less(residential addition/expansion/remodel) Residential Commercial/Industrial [ ]Other: $3.20/sq.ft. $0.51/sq.ft. Area in Sq.Ft.: 3, 5 3 Receipt Number: 330426 Total Fee: Check Number: $12,009.60 00006618 Owner's Name: R a m y Z a i f m a n Owner's Address: 27 Tanners Rd. , Great Neck, NY 11020 Phone Number: (914) 473-6592 Email: zjudyramy@gmail .com Representative's Name& Contact Info(if appl.): Troy French (626) 303-7917 *The above-described development has been determined to be exempt from the developer fees of Education Code §17620,et seq., and Government Code§65995,et seq.,and a Building Permit may be issued therefore. ** All fees due to the Arcadia Unified School District, under provision of Education Code §17620, et seq., and Government Code §65995, et seq., as a prerequisite to the issuance of a Building Permit by the Building Department of the City of Arcadia, City of Monrovia,City of Sierra Madre,City of Temple City,and County of Los Angeles,Department of Public Works have been received. Based on the information presented above,this Certificate of Compliance is hereby executed. owv:tzss_.ea_dConnie Chu Senior Administrative Asst . 10/8/18 Signature of District Representative Name/Title Date of Issuance ➢ The District charges a $100 fee to process reinstatement of the Developer Fee Certificate of Compliance resulting from an "insufficient funds"check in addition to a$35 fee for the returned check. Only cash or a Cashier's Check will be accepted as payment thereafter. ➢ The District charges a$100 fee for any amendments to or cancellation of a Developer Fee Certificate of Compliance formerly issued on any type of development. ' If 500 sq.ft.or less is the reason for exemption,any future additions,expansions,or remodels to the property that result in the past aggregate square footage to exceed the allotted 500 sq. ft. will be subject to fees at the current rate for the entire square footage of the development. ➢ Owner/developer may request a refund of fees paid to the District within 12 months of payment only in the event the Building Permit expires or the project is canceled without commencement of construction in accordance with Education Code section 17624(all other requests for refunds must be made in accordance with the fee protest procedures set forth in Government Code §66020). All refunds will be reduced by a $100 administrative fee. The refund check will be issued in the name of the owner/developer and mailed to the address of payee. PURSUANT TO GOVERNMENT CODE§66020(d),OWNER/DEVELOPER HAS A PERIOD OF 90 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF ISSUANCE OF THIS CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE TO PROTEST THE IMPOSITION OF FEES Applicant confirms that he/she is authorized to sign on behalf of the owner/developer and that the information he/she provided to the District is true and accurate to the best of his/her knowledge. Signature of Applicant: �C Name: ' 10 1 Fc ei11 On. WHITE—City/County YELLOW—Fiscal Services PINK—Business Services GOLD—Applicant Certificate of Compliance(7-24-17) .11+1'; h ( ' t— RIESZ! -ill Certificateo Occupancy City of Arcadia - \ , Development Services Department—Building Division �} This certificate issued pursuant to the requirements of the e California Building Code certifying that at the time of issuance this structure was in compliance with the various ordinances of the City regulating building construction or use. y �,..:. Permit No. SNew-18-0964 / ;y ��: 'fix' Building Address: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia,CA 91007 !:. Permit Type: Single Family New Effective CBC: 2016 CRC Occu anc Code: R3/U Zone Code: // \4;-` j p y R/D l\ \ Final Date: May 5, 2020 Type of Construction: TYPE V-B, SPRINKLERED I ` ,1 Owner: Ramy Zaifman & Judy Chang � !; i" ,),(/' , , ... :„. , t (7 . ..„, ,-.1 — \ - _____,7' , 0,,, _ , , s ,,,,.. Kenneth Fields,B ildin: • tial i % 1 p7 i\.\\ Post in Conspicuous Place /Y" '�__� - y — V �� V / \,„,.. / ' �� / y , AS BUILT GRADING PLAN GENERAL NOTES: I LS C.7 _• $ 1. ALL TTRNXDIJ 05TH ME ROM SHALL0 D0 DONE RI ACCCOORDANCE NTH M OTT O ARCADIA STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS AND0. BE•Y O.OT.0”.0 MA THAT IT DPM TO 3055.[00.0 HA 1TT-,opl0 ax0.y6L.1L pJ AR 4 _ " OF Rum 0L OR�OS AOD0500 ATC°MA,SASS REPOT NO y(d 1Na0 6Y:,Ma4LL STAID I w m 2 PRIOR TO M STMT O GRADING ALL EXISTING VEGETATION AND DEBRIS NQLANG EMTMC STRUCTURES rOonOOS WNDATION%RUBBLE.TREES.AND ROOT SYSTEMS SHALL BE MIMED FROM M DTE TO M SATISFACTION O THE SOILS A. M UIMErtMDEO OW DOME.RTL BE KSPOKKE T PROESROMAL NFACTON N ACCORDANCE OtT AMNO 1 O M 2013 n ENGINEER. CALIFOR,BEiAENIA A L NOIR NO.00.S.I0 1 - / N ' © 1- 3. REMOVAL O OEMS.EMMG DLL AND DISTURBED NATURAL SOILS SHALL BE EXCAVATED 10 M SATISFACTION O THE SOTS GRADING NOTES: / - n�n{�� `v iii ENGINEER. 1. ,ILL aux.STALL ED..TO MIME RL CHM.L PMT,,SECNIN ALIO O M DO O AKA.MUIOPAL COOS. I' MK•12 6 g© m i A M SOILS ENGINEER STALL MN NSPCC,5T EXPOSED SCRS AND ANY MAT..OVER EXCAVATE.SHALL MN BE MADEnAA I 1��. 1. IN ACCORDANCE.ITN THE SOILS ENGINEER'S RECOMMENDATIONS AND AS CONT..°M THE SOILS REPORT. A. �'� i MULCH 2-S BS PIM. .� 6 S. M EXPOSED SOILS SHALL THEN BE SCARIHCD TO A MOWN DEPT/OF 6 INCHES BROUGHT TO WCKR MCISTURE CONTENT s IMLAXMN O.RL SL OPE N R 20 , +� I /- I BUILDMO ING CODE ORACTED O AT LEAST 90 II EQUIVALENT COMP CTION SHALLME .DOUBNSY.DAS XTERIMCD BY Bv u[1HWS SOECRiMO M SOILS MOWER.NDIX J CF THE 2015 iORNIA Eel 1 .AKAR LOGITS Or NAM.CUT MO M. X W I z To R 6. TX All,O M ATTENTIONGSUBSURFACE S STRUCTURES AK ENC NTEREOEPAASOONI NRPOK PROCEEDINGTHEY EIREA R BE RKDIATELT BIE000NT .. ML BIL NO NU SLOB TO K CM.CTEO m MT TM TRAM INK.(9010 OF MAIDRR.MOOT \ M KEN 9Y M CHEF N suSOMO DOOR I � 3 ). THE CONTRACTOR SHALL TME PROTECTIVE K0500(5 50 M SOT TO OUSE ANY HIIID,SILT OR MOMS TO K DEPOSITED ONTO 6 [SMATEQ PLRIro TAO COINt110x O GIIAOR: HAS I �m JJ( 1+`.' 0P.M0020 DR ADJACENT PROPERTY AT ALL TOES DURING CONSTROCTION.ANY MUD O DEBRIS ON PUBLIC PROPERTY S 000 BE n w REMOVED 040 CIATELY;DUST SHALL BE CONTROLLED BY WATER..DR OMR APPROVED METHOD TMpUCNOUT M GRADING OCTOOEN AND MURK CONSTRUCT.OPERATION. TANG K CMLLRBT. OCTOBER TA 2019 ' PROVE • OAK 20• • rt FENCE 6. AOR TO THE START Of ANY BUIL..CONSTRUCTOR TIC CONTRACTOR SHALL FURNISH M CITY NOIR CERTIFICATIONS FROM 1. OMAN.ER•M FROM OTT OF ARCADIA O.DOES.FOR ALL.O. CT MIL ENGINEER ANO SOILS ENGINEER 11.1AT BUILDING PAD S SGRADES ARE RIM.0110 FOOT O M APPROVED PLANS ANDB•A CITRUS THAT M PROPER COMPACTION HAS KEN°STAKED. 6 MOM0.WISIO10 REPLACE MCC.O DAMMO CPB AM OJT.5411.4 Am/OR P.O.,TO M SATSACTNN O M Ott p I L/ • • 9. NO GRACRG SHALL COMMENCE MTNXUT OBTAINING A GRADE.PERM,AIA NOTIFYING M BUILDING NSPECTOR 24 HOURS PRIOR ONYKI.....c.0.00 INSPLCTO Al 6K)).0..0.Al„A....,..O ro CDI4MKTd O CTT° .i0 10200 3 ALL i TO START O ROD. �' Cpi,LTDD TO TION D M NRC NMS MM.MC.BRE*TO FINAL F KS' - - T0. RE1PG4•ILITY FOR GRACING AND INSPECTOR SMALL K ASSUMED BY M ENGINEER O RECORD M ACCORDANCE NTH BERCI.•T MONS Am OEM MN....ROTI TO ACO.TAKE. APPENDIX J O M 2016 CALiONNIA BUILDING CODE. 1 Y NN N noL6RAL.STATE.AND LOCAL LAWS AD REGULATIONS KRUNNG TO CLEAN AIR LOAN RATER COMPLY 11. M SOLS ENGINEER SHALL ALSO 0 RCSPONSBLE TO DERRY AIA REPORT THAT HOER COMPACTION NAS BEEN R LAINED BY 6 . .0 REp.REBE 3 O I -. ` SUBCONMACTON AND AGENCIES CONCERNING UMI.LINE MC ML INCLUDING,OUT NOT OWED TO SEVERS.RATER LINES II. KOR OLDER ML NMECT M EXGAVATw Al M 60TOM O OLOR-EXCAVATION TO WERKE THAT M SRS S ADEQUATE.RDI �L� (/ QCCMKAL,GAS FINAL LANDSCAPE IRRIGATION LANES BECM.CTOM, ..T/ P. '•S�II' B • 12. CERTNCATES Ce FINAL LOT GRADING AK TO BE SUBRTTED TOM DRUG AND SACT.DINSON PRIOR TO M FINAL ENGINEER'S NOTICE 7'01 CONTRACTOR: I r`JJ" I �{1 ., VERDIN°INSPECTION. MEM ANF,NDENRw.o Winn O STPNCTMfS SROMH ON MSE PLANS.R[XT...IT A KARGI O AVABAKE KOOKS m TIT 6*0 O 00 MOKEL0A.MK MD NO EMTNG IO 2152 MOCK,NOK SOW ON MK NN4 M • •�I� ,. A�9 13. AN'AS-BLMT'GRADING LIAR AND CC TARE..O COMPLIANCE NM SAO GRADING KAN IS 10 K SURNAMED TO M CONTRACTM�KWIEDTTY 0 05500 UTWMT MEASRES O PROTECT M UTILITY UES SNOW OM MK DRANK.M CO.ACTCR OAK 1}9 Bo..ANI)SART'DIVISION PRIOR TO RELEASE O GRACING BOA AND PRIOR TO FINAL GRADING MRECTIOL I FGR M UTILITY PPE%COMA.CR STRUCTAKS SONO OR RAT SROM ON MSE _J�- I.. A SLOPES EXCEEDING 5'IN METRICAL HEON1 AND EXCEEDING 5:1 KOBE AK TO K PLANTED NN APPROVED PLANT TM CONTANK&KO AOM THAT HE 51/ALL MILK SOIL AND COMPLETE REWTSRITT rO M.IC•NTE COMM.MIRO M CONK O c IJ l�, ...r MATERIAL AND POMADED NTH APPROVED WATERING 50510 TALK T tt PROCTO.THAT MIS SHALL ONLY CONINUNRr NO NOT BE LAIRD ON(PRO• •'> COVERED rill �.• TO IONONG 1140 05000TCT'[MND NAT 1M FMO.CONTRACTS* AMINO N,OKKK 00.0 00 MO 000 TDM OWER NOM D.C.MMLLESS row ' I KNCC {I, =556 O 15. NO AOJUSKK1 O ELEVATION SHALL BE MAK*MOUT PRIOR WM.APPROVAL DE M BUILDING am..AIA M GAL AK FON M OMEIR TO M MM.. O; ' F.S.=596./5 CKGNEC O RECORD. R. TNM ALL 4000RN 1 ALL COMM.AA 941.045.•O GIRL REVERT ALL 0K.EPAN E5 TO M EN0M0 P.K.TO M O I I .0!II/ 16. ALLLLP.C.C.RATER CARRYING DEVICES RUTH MNMN SLOPES LESS THAN OK RRL K WATER TESTED PRIOR TO M FINAL CommIRI I'• .TON SH. T KSWAL PONDING N EVIDENCE AT ME OF INSPECTION SHALL BE CAUSE FOR KIROVAL AND REPLACEMENT I - IT. ALL WALLS OVER 3 FT.IN FINISH HEIGHT REQUIRE SEPARATE KNOTS AND MSPECTON. Z I •{1 I�I BEi T6. ALL TORR 011014 M PIRUC RIGHT O MAY KOURES PORMITS OA MSPECTAN 154.0 BY M ENGNCCRMG M YRON. j►• �rI ' M 19. ADING CONTRACTOR SHALL NOTIFY M SOILS ENGINEER NOT LESS THAN 12 HR.IN ADVANCE O M LOCATOR O ANY SOILS ,ti .OM_:�• :'��+' ",• PROPOSED FON IMPORT.EACH NODOSE°SPORT SOURCE SHALL BE SAMPLED.TESTED.AND APPROVED POO TO DELIVERY O • •V7.1-:7:1 U L 9�� `, SOILS FOR USE W M GTE. F.F.ms9�.00 a • E. .•AD=5-6.33`..I I IILCR SOIL REPORT RECOMMENDATIONS: DAVE 12'0 T.ii■f�-TL -�.�R+��rc AD RFmMEmme. D•r..0..TT...,.........'.a.m....•....I...R..N»e..N....r 2P". 0 -...r.,-1-4.,...-.,INNOWT 25 (24K �n�.0•,, r.R....I....Y1..,P..r..,m...N.» .fie. « ....M,....M..•••..M..,.M.1.r.. aR.H;" r ..R......,,m.c....a».eHuw.....r«.N.iN.r..Miw..:...«..IM.�.a».•....«I.,.u..»PAPP. • L en... PARwwrA r4..9.w..ww.R..•na..,,..e.e«....11/...... I 0000,1.e...."/"..-.-. ' eU..eP.IN••••••...n.•.e.•TI.....Pw.ww.a ww.µwowu.,F Pon..a cow D....•.11.•••Awrr.rr.e«NRERORIrs.varr.Mr ,,����-._ `_ ,,. .1..... 6'. OKRA M• y ' w.AL.e. AM ei,...bmAwAsCAAMH..r...MFm.a NNi...,u.1....AF.e� m.m,...e•rr,e.r•. ...Nr e........ .m...40.4.....D.1NFni 0 ,�-__ lima •eM•.a'.•••..M..9..M....MHF..»...N....r.r1�.. N••N.rw..»..»......»..+FM»•AAAI,. I 8 J �....1•:r•.H.re.».wy 4.1PAPP«..e,.H.e+,..NA.........,1. ..... ...... w .aNr CARP•..Tr.M.,.•n.10.M.NN..r 411 w •./IR......'»........�:`r°.r.".W .. .D..m.M.,...... �.d.•.., ..r.w...•.1....•.P.•.,m.....« ..N•me*«....NM..1•..»w.•M.rN...•...,� /0111.1.,/,41.1 c,,;., ... .M me*NOM.NW ra••,ra1•.m•MIN• M..•ond*O.a MAMA..a.•..IN r w...wm•.•..wa..n I .h•,•MWmi•..W~ MiWn calm..••.......nrRY Mabr .•AL1 ea iarn.bw Mm a».P.••F•.vm.••••••.**•10.1,m»o•. ILLTKPORGOIENSTELIPIKI T...M. ....WbEp.4.......Me...Nw...•Oriw..,r.,. A....................• e .b.• m. *non=Inn m.l P. an ••Hdme•Ie .Prte..> 11•P.1.•p....»M'••►11»MN«..m.w.Yrw**1•...•wN A99REVIATMS: ................/.0••••••................... `e sMw.�Iw«I.�MM1•1..••..I0..r•..••Pm.R..•s..i••«..M.. CM'_(OICU TSOL .Nwr«wroe.•..I.M.wMI0000TI.aM...NNF.m...mr M.r•..m.,... T'e•. fJD�_CURB Aro OUTER u.n......r.l..e..ASTH MISTML e....N.........•M....w.......•....« , DAL--DORIPLIKAY APRON 82.21KoaY•R o.•M •Tv NIMH+4 m+.a..u.e.•...•..e...r»INN.WAN. ®__®DM POLE W Is .1161110 F`.Meip.....°DD.MNT�••••en un.r.2N.IMm1.•e.1IS TO.. Plot N.N1DRAMr O ANI•mn of rmM,NBE..r•..•....>Nw...n.T....r •m......T»Re,...w *0*0W..O. ......N......M.r...m Z Cc 8 ..i..•.».....N....ri...•KM......R+..Tr..•I... wie,.LaEVA,aM p a « -.,�........r....»»•.m1..,..•�.5• ..•....mod r.....,.«e.....N.•P.r•..•,m«.•.wr...., DSD/ENGINEERING g a O2 T• n eammr•R•T.N4•.•m.m 0.0T.0A.nW,. A...1•A~Y.w.M ...IMeN•...e.w..•wu.O6r•s• SEL_._BEENALE OE :..m•»•.Nr.•»..NM .NON....A.....«a.P....0•.I5«r.....a4...M0.r.m. SW-- APPROVED W v An O.* _ ......•A.M.a.•SPP...M...•.....• I.. '.;»....,•.0«.. K__...o■E s•DV® MAY 04 2020 1- Q .I.po n pent=T'0,•".00 ebutir 050A 0001 •h ,E......._..,M DP DUI.EIlVAl10N (� - p A..a.a1=....A .'.. •.:.....a.m. :'em..m..."Av�I.:. 'H___._wo H��ALF.�ER BY: ' _ 1Ila..•..u......1.Me°'"P.+.m.»...».,.a..»PUPA«... LEGEND: K VICINITY MAP k, a _DSTPEAPDD RA �°�M AP D° S`�°'e .- a Ca n OA*T•I*•*SOW,l�r.0TI*0 IMID•A0*M0~•Pm•PM.NNR.SONR...A.mm.. (.R,I.._.FJOSTNG ELEVATOR E • 0. •.Ma ».NeR.,IwD..4..D..S.N..1a.......Nr.N.m. D.N. OTKIKTTINITGROOKM..Tsal.•....1.1....0.I.a.M.I.e........MO SALO__.MWroSEO ELEVATION OEM. lea Pim Ow..,P••C.Rw..••m .«. •. r. . m. », »anis P....... . .., •....,. �.66}._.EOBlMO COMOUR %.Y. • .e.. i.n�» .°SEN CA.19,, 6.C.V.••••C•s E.�•.W T.ee.Y. .___.OIARMOE IATIEKI OM • T«.•�r*Pr Km.•m.•......M 3r,.eAm EnO.ANMEI.A.«..•b..VI.. PRDPOBED STAUCIVRE o=NPG•L.E_ X-30-2020.mm..,N.*..Han re.. ...PRo.oKo HAH50BLVIPE AIE/ITB-osp-ow_ ,_.PWK HYORANr • EARTH WORK QUANTITIES: OWNER: BENCHMARK: LEGAL DESCRIPTION: -----...oven CLOG°ATOM FRlCOMPILRD n,IOW • • CUT: 350 CU.. PLL: 332 CUM) AAA.ZMRAN CT KTCHMMN M.369 LSI O TRACT 11014.IN THE CT O MUDIA COUNTY DE LOS 030511100 SEWER __OAK TREE oRP UNE on, w� • OVER EXCAVATION/RECM.CTOM IMO COPD. LES STATE OF GALLEON~AS PER MM RECORDED N BOOK•1. LRTERAL LACATON ///+�+�E9 21 TAMERS RD.. H'VCMMO'ORM•T.DTLOA TAN[. PAGES 21 10 29.O MMS.IN THE COUNTY RECORDER OFFICE OF SAID C-1 TIE YARD.,SHORN HEREON IS FOR KNOT MO BCIAING mNPUSES M ...KO.MX. NOR11H CURB HACIENDA ORM.LM'REST COURIIY 1'01 BE PIEID VERIPIED 1 f010R SHALL BE RE5ONSOLC FOR VERIMG O THE 021001 S • • ELEVATOR 3133.29. AM:5110-002-013 . - 6 Mn 1D2 _ . . _ AS BUILT GRADING PLAN \ . • 3 ,Iniino . = 0 ° •..,... ,,... ... . ' OAK PROTECTOR E.; ? 12 .;-6..•106R000.5620"' 321.49' •-•',.. . / § 2 OAA It) •....., -\\ I I! / OAK 30'• k: ej 11:-L 1 V.,. I. ... q • •Pr• t To4 - MUCH • ..0 "• 1.16.',,... 1•1116.1111141PrilitP.4illaAtri4.1..CrOkti.agadiS• OAK 1 ell. •. . I ; I 1 1/4N 41"0 S ' '-.-'''''''' '....0.61-•.•WM'11 ,• - - .. • • Com• a U i§ , W . e e m -...... .... IA,SYCAMORE IN ,, V •• 9'2 \ER. • \ 1:1-:( . . • IIP W .. I i g 1911 II ill\ . 1, I A)Highest existing 594.70 lit... \e' • ... TY , -,-. I P 1 ,I: 8)LorLeist existing 59410.96 rr's,,, . . .. .... \AWL tR.\ ,•-• 0 .r.0 0,,Air-,,, ? ' C) Averoge existing 592.83 :itillifillird1,111110. ..-- ''' \ \ I BUILDING A., .1-I.r.JIIT ,. 0 . O., L • iiill ' ' ." ;;X:1;111. ' e F.F.=593.50 PAD=592.83 , ...,... , -...--- Ali_ r ............. , 4-•. .-/ ,' , o M.- 111211 _ . , , ® /..., . , . . , .... ' ..--.' '‘. -• . : - _ ,, • .• . . • ... , s .• OAK 55'• . , . . .. .- ......' '.). 1 I .' 11. , • 4 e ., .. POSED .. , -; .: '0%.,, • \Nol ... -i LROPIr- • 1 .-'' 1,01,,,,z). , I • p• ,, ro, I,-• . MULCH I. •.1 Ih. _ • ,.. I . , ,.... ......,_ A,. • OAX 29'6',1 1 ... V r . . . .• .0 Ii ' Om 20-o •, .;''' PiAr4 GRAVEL\ 4 .g mmr•- 111 .. .- , . gm effi ''71 / L0:2' 'OAK 20 ' IIIP 1 ......_ ,z. 1.6, , , GARAGE .•-' 1 GARAGE i A I F.F.=593.00 ; ily --- \ mi ' • • ............... I • , •., :-., • . xi NuiCo fs '- ....E0.00 •••• <4.4 '4„., ..........,.. ., , • ., wicHi .„,..• ..... .._ Vel IliilinliN 12 .. .1 .bici-•••••11.ak:aasirkz• ,:pro 5:-/..-• L .I. ...„,%It TiTiVo - TB'ON( II'' .-. 111111111111 Wm NI PM Erkiiiii- r f-. , •130 PROM• •Et • ......- 100_ : ki. -''' 1 j ,- • .--..w. _ , _ ,,z--1 ....._ . : , N owe: E 1 5 •• N 005620"W II" 326.10' .. ...- ,V . .- 1.3' ; ;' 4.,• , \' .1' / 4, •. 0 z,-, •P., / 2 0 :T,6 • , - • ri , I : - I ' . • CONSTRUCTION NOTES: ' I 0 EMT.DRIVEWAY APPROACH TO BE REMOVED (D CONSTRUCT INTEELOCKM0 PAVER OrrszrALe se....orrc PIPE wro:o.s.ler PROPOIED FL ..roman.POP-UP AU.. . ORM.%CARTIOR.ro.vv. AKA Of LOT .036 NI rr. SE OcComnexT r mom OVER TOP OF mu FOOTINGS •NA.( PS "= ,,, r -1 A SON 1EWER DOAN 0.781 ACM $0111741.DOWNSPOUT PER AnclaxEcofiku.ouu. . MAR Of°RENO:CAVA/10N PER SOL REPORT PPATIPARED IN rr 1 • EXISTING 35X T1750 ili PP i -114a1TWIT17171 .. ACTED TOPSOIL X NPERNOUS . _ OUARTECH CONSLATANTS •.. ,.., .11=111=R=MIIII"-."." 0 THE DIFFERENCE IN G.R.E ON EA.ROE OE A P.N.]BLOM iniThili PROPOSED 2V4 9703- 2 > . .,,.....L____. _,„.. qtTEE 0 cc 8 WALL SHALL NOT BE LORE THIN 12-INCH PER BURP. A 0 =1,-5=-, pr LEP. IOU X MINIM. ..... CEPARTNENT REOMETAENTS. o ............ C)corlsmcz zo onx.GARDEN WNL t-'70 13, , 111GM NKR•MAN MS p 0 zi, SDONS/RUC,FENCE OR BLCCA WALL PER ARCHITECTURAL PLAN SECTION THRU A-,1f GRAVEL ONFILTERV"., /III..22 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..,.u. LOW REACT DEVELOPMENT CONSTRUCTION NOTES: g 0 ct EXISTING BUILDING 1-0 BE REMOVED SECTION THRU kip ENING WM.. ' IOR.i !", , Z 0 EXDSTINO BLOCK WALL TO REM. CONSTRUCT r SCH 20 PIPE WON 0.5%MN. EXISTING TREE TOSE REMOVED CONSTRUCT A"AREA DR. MULL rE PVC PIPE SCH.80 WEIN 0.5%MIN BL ST IQ\'‘. ,a,7 NM 10.08ED .eePrj-144‹.1 DArco BASIN OE TAA(TTL ...101•4;le (D TYPICAL POP UP DRAINAGE EMITTER r.s PRONGS MANN 11-11.COKR PER RIP Of WALL ICON. (3) woman.no.o.(PORTORAIED PIPE) LU la Loose...NV LANDSCAPE rfflo.nor.PER LANDSCAPE PLAN 0. - GENERAL TREE PROTECTION NOTES: C.) o Ws 1 8 our CARE SHALL N 1..TO rzonor EX..nrus TO norm room 0 ... „, 0 ERSTINO FENCE TO RENAM CARA. OW. NOTES: ft EXISTING DPW..APPROACH To BE REMOVE° I fl s4,71TFA'R.s.....17AND:CF.E.,..c1161,..."137ID'A.:11.0CTMAJIITE'DoritTLIV 0 EMT,.DRIVEWAY TO REMAIN ' j . He', NE-6111W NS,.Or C..RE Mr.GRADE ARNIN THE TRU 000.91.E.UR DONNA AN GRADE ON 0i0.St.Of A 51MOARD • S k 0 NAND TOGAS NO.VORA.MOW,ROOTS.DO NOT OJT ROOTS OASR 2.ONTALL NOS pop,-arum.Emrrrot PER woos ao WW1 CO APPROVED 4156123, ! '• '• '• ___ .---------_.'.T t..'. -,. .k.„,,,„1,,, ,,,.• KOCK N.SHALL NOT 22 MOW NMI 12-00.TES PER DIAMLIIR.MO..NEL NRE MED.ROOTS NEN IMPE CANNOT BE b" -Awf,..,._...!'gri r Nom=on N.A.A;j-,e, NLIN mac 12.2•10 INIAMOTENT REOLIMIENTS. RELOCATE.DO NOT 3100.13 SCR OR OTHER MATERIALS YR.TM CCON7T7R1C-17.57Pir 0.7E0 NAT NORIO.IAIN'APER BET.HERE. ' o ' ' MEI 3/...-TT ONTINDO ROCA OMR.ARIA,AND CO NOT BTASH CIENICALS OR FOL../UNDER TRU CANOPIES.PRONDE OCCASIONAL DECT.WATER.AS NECESSMY TO KEEP m-sg-2020 TREES 1101.1.UNTIL ME NEW*morn:.SYSTEM IS INSIALLED n7,:l.:,:zr,NTER cm 8113 aci-t. 6 PERFOR ATFO PIPE OAK PROTECTION NOTES: m-oss-oos g CONSTRUCT 0-AREA mum BACTION THRU C-C sAcnoN THRU D-D THE CO.T.C.0 SHALL O.9./NAT ALL RECESS..REASONS AN NI NAGE TR PROMO ANY OAK DSD/ENGINEERING <11104I6--- 0 CONSTRUCT X AREA DRAM rtmrs rm.IE.DAMAGE°.put D.rtmonctto TREE(AMMO REPORT mtorrotLe rum.Al TM 1,10' TRU PROTECTNE ZEINECTIN)WS/et 01 PLACE AT ALL Tn...WAN ON THE AINCOIST'S REPORT OR APPROVED EARTH WORK ouAHTmEA: OWNER: BENCHMARK: LEGAL DESCRIPTION: .......•16.1.10TA NIE OUTS.EDOE Or TREE TRUNK 11.NOT SHOW rENC.NAV BE ROVED TERPORAIT. TO NAM rat NECESSARY ONISTRUCTION ACM.BUT OINL 22 RP BACK AS OUICARY AS POSSIBLE NO OVER EXRACER. 'RGUMLES.STATE O.r CAtLoRsOs..M RER Amry'MEENOEO II, ER.OTV NPEAR.ASCmAPoE cCcOrNSEeTNRACURCoOOS.RENA . 0 MAY 04 2020 CUT: 330 COVE 011 332 04.00 RANTEISACOY BNCHAMA NO360 LO1 Of TRACT 11074.N TIC C.Of ACA. COUNTY Of LOS 068016 AND OVNG OCOAS P EURENTMNANNEAZ EXCPT.EO .VAO/RECOMPRCTION MO M:, V 0060 220006200..A. Mor 'N owROPICSEf mmBY (01 -2 P. NOM CURB 10.2.0.9 SOIL LIME VEST co,my, INE YARDAGE SKIM HEREON IS EC.POMO MAO mom PURPOSES.ore ....".° PROMARC OR MYDRAIAJC SOL EXCAVAITEN TOOLS.AND ROOTS LARGER INAN I-vr.WOAD NV 02 Olt 1.,,,I.,20t...22,".3.66,1,..€ CONTRACRTOR SHALL OE RESPONSIBLE 008 400111100 OF ltE 0112201TES. N222 1.32222 MVP 22 CONTWOUSIN 1.110111.0...OUT COMMA.. ELEVATION 525.22. PPM 57711-0122-013 SHEET 2 OF 2 WT. • - • Y ' Op 40 �r.+�n' t; a ,ARCAD•. .4b\ �o. ORI'ORATEO- CITY OF ARCADIA 240 West Huntington Drive Arcadia, CA 91007 FINAL GRADING VERIFICATION ATTENTION: Community Development Administrator SUBJECT: Grading Verification for Project No. 18-058-003 Address: 111 Hacienda Drive Gentlemen: Finish grading operations have been completed for Project No. 18-058-003 for Lots through (if applicable) and has been inspected by the undersigned Registered Civil Engineer or Licensed Architect. Based upon the observations, the grading subsequent to the Rough Grading has been completed in accordance with the approved plans and specifications and is in substantial conformance with the final grading plan approved by the City and no unauthorized deviations were made. All required surface drainage devices have been installed. Provisions have been made for drainage of surface waters around proposed buildings and their appurtenances. QaOFEss/p ( 414 IIPArg''(Ce-f e --- c §---- (0. cl,"(/ *C' • • !FF tic Engineer (Signature) & / 40870 m Architect(Signature) XI Exp.3-31-21 R.C.E. No. 40870 R.P.A. No. Civil Date: March 9, 2020 meq'of cAoc— Received and approved: /f - Date: => �f '_2_f , ' '5.D./P ng cc: C.D.D./Maint. Ser. C.D.D./Building ` `` County of Los Angeles `--, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & SAFETY DIVISION PUBLIC WORKS' Los Angeles Regional Uniform Code Program STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION REPORT FORM STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION means the visual observation of the structural system, for general conformance to the approved plans and specifications, at significant construction stages and at completion of the structural system. Structural observation does not include or waive the responsibility for the inspections required by Section 108. 1704 or other sections of the Los Angeles County Building Code. (Sections 106.4.5, 1709) Report No. 5 This report includes all construction work through 2 6 4 day of I ONE- ,20 1 1 Page No. I of j Project Address: Structural Observer of Record (SOR): SOR Phone o.: t t 1 H a,c.; ,6, 12 r, A rcc .'a , ONs Z. ret r clN Pg.__ ( 56 z) b ( Building Permit No.: Structural Observation Observr Professional Lic./Reg. No.: Observer0one No.: performed by: Z . M1c.NP�.L st)-1461 5-5266 (. 62-) 63 --191 OBSERVED STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS AND THEIR CONNECTIONS FOUNDATION WALL FRAMES FLOOR ELEMENTS/CONNECTION OBSERVATION LOCATION ❑Footing, Stem Walls ❑ Concrete ❑ Steel Moment Frame ❑ Concrete tri lik,oD F(LAM 11467 ❑ Mat Foundation ❑ Masonry ❑ Steel Braced Frame ❑ Steel Deck ❑ Caisson, Piles, R4 Wood ❑ Concrete Moment ❑ Wood OF 11-1E C4Stt7FitCie_ Grade Beams Frame ❑ Retaining Foundation ❑ Others: ❑ Masonry Wall jE Others: Hillside Special Anchors Frame Ku-24;- 01A-01-, Others: ❑ Others: NOTED DEFICIENCIES with the proposed corresponding corrective actions with respect to general conformance with the approved plans or in the load path: (A final report by the structural observer which states that all observed deficiencies have been resolved is required before acceptance of the work by the building officials.) l'\'=7 04-1 ClcA c- "2 OG-S 1 t21.)Rt MG, t'rt(5 vl,S( . I DECLARE THAT THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE: 1. I AM THE ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT RETAINED BY THE OWNER TO BE IN RESPONSIBLE CHARGE FOR THE STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES. QROFESSiO 2. I, OR ANOTHER ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT WHO I HAVE DESIGNATED ABOVE AND IS ��O \� MiCild 41-"fe UNDER MY RESPONSIBLE CHARGE, HAS PERFORMED THE REQUIRED SITE VISITS AT A. �4,. cPa F2 EACH SIGNIFICANT CONSTRUCTION STAGE TO VERITY IF THE STRUCTURE IS IN 'v S 5?66G-2GENERAL CONFORMANCE WITH APPROVED PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS; w z � )m) �(P IO Z 3. ALL NOTED DEFICIENCIES WHICH REMAIN TO BE CORRECTED HAVE BEEN INDICATED t. ABOVE; ' (5' cS'a /)., UCTURi.at' 4. I RECOMMEND THAT ACCEPTANCE OF THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS BY THE COUNTY OF(,pt1FUI, 1 OF LOS ANGELES BE WITHHELD UNTIL ALL OBSERVED DEFICIENCIES ARE � CORRECTED. 6/4 AO i 9 6� /Zoll (STAMP OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER) SIGNATURE OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER DATE Version 1.0(2008 LACBC) Jan. 10 2008 V . County of Los Angeles PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & SAFETY DIVISION .. n'p Los Angeles Regional Uniform Code Program STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION REPORT FORM STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION means the visual observation of the structural system, for general conformance to the approved plans and specifications, at significant construction stages and at completion of the structural system. Structural observation does not include or waive the responsibility for the inspections required by Section 108, 1704 or other sections of the Los Angeles County Building Code. (Sections 106.4.5, 1709) Report No. 4- This report includes all construction work through 213' day of y-€.4, . ,20 i( Page No. 1. of Project Address: Structural Observer of Record (SOR): SOR Phone No.: 11 NPcLt -s VA VVttX�- Pc12-c-Avi A. >: E - ‘--“u-til, 9014.1 (5-6Z) 663-6/41q9 Building Permit No.: Structural Observation Observr Professional Lic./Reg. No.: Observer Phone No.: 5 N -10_04164_ Performed by: Z - l`1ke.4fAt . 46I j— 5 26C, OBSERVED STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS AND THEIR CONNECTIONS FOUNDATION WALL FRAMES FLOOR ELEMENTS/CONNECTION OBSERVATION LOCATION Ip Footing, Stem Walls ❑ Concrete ❑ Steel Moment Frame ❑ Concrete 'Apoµ FT'A. TK4.C(l ❑ Mat Foundation ❑ Masonry ❑ Steel Braced Frame ❑ Steel Deck tLr,tfyF_ . v.i.V• fr,.,>a ❑ Caisson, Piles, ❑ Wood ❑ Concrete Moment ❑ Wood s Grade Beams Frame o µF Al ❑ Retaining Foundation ❑ Others: Li Masonry Wall ❑ Others: 1-ttt>:• Wt Tb ® 2f" Hillside Special Anchors Frame M Others: G).0_ ❑ Others: Cji tv WI NOTED DEFICIENCIES with the proposed corresponding corrective actions with respect to general conformance with the approved plans or in the load path: (A final report by the structural observer which states that all observed deficiencies have been resolved is required before acceptance of the work by the building officials.) t C3' 0g- -t G1 1.1 Gtr o13-5rr2Jcto PJRLM i 'L-((s tic sii- . I DECLARE THAT THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE: 1. I AM THE ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT RETAINED BY THE OWNER TO BE IN RESPONSIBLE CHARGE FOR THE STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE --�, REQUIREMENTS OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES. Q�OFESgfO c���yv VAiCyge fr9l 2. I, OR ANOTHER ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT WHO I HAVE DESIGNATED ABOVE AND IS ��lr ��� UNDER MY RESPONSIBLE CHARGE, HAS PERFORMED THE REQUIRED SITE VISITS AT i EACH SIGNIFICANT CONSTRUCTION STAGE TO VERITY IF THE STRUCTURE IS IN ! C7 `' S 5266 G7 z Lli GENERAL CONFORMANCE WITH APPROVED PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS; 11\* EXF? 6 10 mm 3. ALL NOTED DEFICIENCIES WHICH REMAIN TO BE CORRECTED HAVE BEEN INDICATED \ (-P 6'1, * ABOVE; 4 �/c�'UCTI.) .\P�� ```',':"..„- _,//"..C/1.1,5?'-,-",-`` pF 4. I RECOMMEND THAT ACCEPTANCE OF THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS BY THE COUNTY ..._.�F ./j OF LOS ANGELES BE WITHHELD UNTIL ALL OBSERVED DEFICIENCIES ARE 2/2-5240(q CORRECTED. Y /2--B/7--019 (STAMP OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER) SIGNATURE OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER DATE Version 1.0(2008 LACBC) Jan. 10 2008 County of Los Angeles PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & SAFETY DIVISION Los Angeles Regional Uniform Code Program STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION REPORT FORM STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION means the visual observation of the structural system, for general conformance to the approved plans and specifications, at significant construction stages and at completion of the structural system. Structural observation does not include or waive the responsibility for the inspections required by Section 108, 1704 or other sections of the Los Angeles County Building Code. (Sections 106.4.5, 1709) Report No. This report includes all construction work through ZO lit day ofd_ ,20 I I Page No. I of I Project Address: Structural Observer of Record (SOR): SOR Phone No.: t t HA C-1‘44 vA VO- _ A rze/40 0 , c-A t t906 Gf-Ordrd-- .rap 0562)$G 3-effect Building Permit No.: Structural Observation Observr Professional Lic./Reg. No.: Observer Phone No.: �ll'lEK)-t -0964 Performed by: 5'6h6 5- 5z6e2 (56z)Y,63- g4ici OBSERVED STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS AND THEIR CONNECTIONS FOUNDATION WALL FRAMES FLOOR ELEMENTS/CONNECTION �/ OBSERVATION LOCATION 1 Footing, Stem Walls ❑ Concrete ❑ Steel Moment Frame ❑ Concrete tptt.1 t Ki.4 ❑ Mat Foundation ❑ Masonry ❑ Steel Braced Frame 0 Steel Deck ro-tletk Fr t Tt ❑ Caisson, Piles, 0 Wood 0 Concrete Moment 0 Wood Grade Beams Frame ZIµF • %405 4, A ❑Retaining Foundation 0 Others: ❑ Masonry Wall 0 Others: Hillside Special Anchors Frame Others: kn,5 *-/�•3. 0 Others: NOTED DEFICIENCIES with the proposed corresponding corrective actions with respect to general conformance with the approved plans or in the load path: (A final report by the structural observer which states that all observed deficiencies have been resolved is required before acceptance of the work by the building officials.) 1.k' b�F(U�c�cK 00)3f i/coo t70 K104 THIS VIS1T- I DECLARE THAT THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE: 1. I AM THE ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT RETAINED BY THE OWNER TO BE IN RESPONSIBLE CHARGE FOR THE STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES. QRESS/OM CHiti 2. I, OR ANOTHER ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT WHO I HAVE DESIGNATED ABOVE AND IS M`. ' ' n lv J' ,: em_ i s � UNDER MY RESPONSIBLE CHARGE, HAS PERFORMED THE REQUIRED SITE VISITS AT O.0 EACH SIGNIFICANT CONSTRUCTION STAGE TO VERITY IF THE STRUCTURE IS IN S 5266 G, z GENERAL CONFORMANCE WITH APPROVED PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS; v:\ 6.*A..19 r w rn 3. ALL NOTED DEFICIENCIES WHICH REMAIN TO BE CORRECTED HAVE BEEN INDICATED * * ABOVE; 1l TRUMI)F�P��\P 4. I RECOMMEND THAT ACCEPTANCE OF THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS BY THE COUNTY � CM..\ OF LOS ANGELES BE WITHHELD UNTIL ALL OBSERVED DEFICIENCIES ARE /�%r� CORRECTED. Z ‘7z0Y (STAMP OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER) SIGNATURE OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER DATE Version 1.0(2008 LACBC) Jan. 10 2008 ,, . County of Los Angeles PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & SAFETY DIVISION n^ Los Angeles Regional Uniform Code Program STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION REPORT FORM STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION means the visual observation of the structural system, for general conformance to the approved plans and specifications, at significant construction stages and at completion of the structural system. Structural observation does not include or waive the responsibility for the inspections required by Section 108, 1704 or other sections of the Los Angeles County Building Code. (Sections 106.4.5, 1709) Report No. 2. This report includes all construction work through 11 day of Fe/49 . ,20 11 Page No. t of Project Address: Structural Observer of Record (SOR): SOR Phone No.: X11 NACitt,NrA 1'X, M 7 A - Ci 1% c'b I.., 1-1lz 1M-L< SAN.& C56z) 863-(=C`t?i9 Building Permit No.: Structural Observation Observr Professional Lic./Reg. No.: Observer Phone No.: 5lulu_I6_og64- performed by: Z.., TAtew , Sia 5 '52-66 C5--6z) 0,63 "1 c6/ 9 OBSERVED STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS AND THEIR CONNECTIONS FOUNDATION WALL FRAMES FLOOR ELEMENTS/CONNECTION OBSERVATION LOCATION EFooting, Stem Walls E Concrete ❑ Steel Moment Frame ❑ Concrete i-ANt W tioUe7c.. Fr14) ❑ Mat Foundation ❑ Masonry ❑ Steel Braced Frame 0 Steel Deck 1- ��4F ❑ Caisson, Piles, 0 Wood 0 Concrete Moment 0 Wood H nS Grade Beams Frame F"itcl''\ THf- 1 (i3Ac.) ❑Retaining Foundation ❑ Others: 0 Masonry Wall ❑ Others: t"JA14- &f LAVtl`IG09ICS Hillside Special Anchors Frame TC T%4'L OAF. StvE vF-- ®'others: Nn'S. p%- . ❑ Others: MC- HotJ ,f.. NOTED DEFICIENCIES with the proposed corresponding corrective actions with respect to general conformance with the approved plans or in the load path: (A final report by the structural observer which states that all observed deficiencies have been resolved is required before acceptance of the work by the building officials.) Aw l Lt e i fti Ot35E1ZV 'J tA'VE S-Nt . ( t . NOTE: c tlAt2 or Au. Rgt6At 5 1/44.9J o112,. 4. your‹ e-e"LCI TE 5r, Fi 't 15A-c{ . 1-0u1 1rd F12o'1ST• Go1 A7 30101 AT F't`�1 1 S '51KocitigAtkif 9-KJ too 4(A 2 t gOt wA I gig. lisvc.42 c .sG - i s "-Lt vocuo wg.T 5E4 r)4014)c-1,5 l 5 ©.V-! I DECLARE THAT THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE: 1. I AM THE ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT RETAINED BY THE OWNER TO BE IN RESPONSIBLE CHARGE FOR THE STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THEFcSS10 REQUIREMENTS OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES. ItMC[Mei 4-- � �9‘ 2. I, OR ANOTHER ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT WHO I HAVE DESIGNATED ABOVE AND IS 4 � �UNDER MY RESPONSIBLE CHARGE, HAS PERFORMED THE REQUIRED SITE VISITS AT ;RS 5266 EACH SIGNIFICANT CONSTRUCTION STAGE TO VERITY IF THE STRUCTURE IS IN ' — H m GENERAL CONFORMANCE WITH APPROVED PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS; c7/10./_ 77 3. ALL NOTED DEFICIENCIES WHICH REMAIN TO BE CORRECTED HAVE BEEN INDICATED is 'r`�Q- ABOVE; .�u'T STRUC1 � l'f .•,. OF CPA-";;;,/ 4. I RECOMMEND THAT ACCEPTANCE OF THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS BY THE COUNTY -- - OF LOS ANGELES BE WITHHELD UNTIL ALL OBSERVED DEFICIENCIES ARE 2/iii/Z49 1? CORRECTED. l __ 2A/Z4f21 (STAMP OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER) SIGNATURE OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER DATE 1 Version 1.0(2008 LACBC) Jan. 10 2008 County of Los Angeles PUBLIC WORKS, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & SAFETY DIVISION Los Angeles Regional Uniform Code Program STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION REPORT FORM STRUCTURAL OBSERVATION means the visual observation of the structural system, for general conformance to the approved plans and specifications, at significant construction stages and at completion of the structural system. Structural observation does not include or waive the responsibility for the inspections required by Section 108, 1704 or other sections of the Los Angeles County Building Code. (Sections 106.4.5, 1709) Report No. This report includes all construction work through day of ,20 1 Page No. of d Project Address: Structural Observer of Record (SOR): SOR Phone No.: " , t C1412A 1912., r - CA (51-14.1 t 562)863 -61961q Building Permit No.: Structural Observation Observr Professional Lic./Reg. No.: Observer Phone No.: 5 -1� -0ci6,4- performed by:L tAlcl'IPs 50-, 5 - 5 2.66 C56z)863 -9'a`19 OBSERVED STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS AND THEIR CONNECTIONS FOUNDATION WALL FRAMES FLOOR ELEMENTS/CONNECTION OBSERVATION LOCATION Eif Footing, Stem Walls E Concrete ❑ Steel Moment Frame 0 Concrete vw+r f- TIia6-1 0 Mat Foundation 0 Masonry 0 Steel Braced Frame 0 Steel Deck 1- 2_ u� ttg..i,rir 0 Caisson, Piles, 0 Wood 0 Concrete Moment ❑ Wood Grade Beams Frame V). ❑ Retaining Foundation 0 Others: ❑ Masonry Wall 0 Others: Hillside Special Anchors Frame 0 Others: 0 Others: NOTED DEFICIENCIES with the proposed corresponding corrective actions with respect to general conformance with the approved plans or in the load path: (A final report by the structural observer which states that all observed deficiencies have been resolved is required before acceptance of the work by the building officials.) talo D 14 LA-I 4 0 t3S ✓ p t) RIAN161 15 V t',t . I DECLARE THAT THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE: 1. I AM THE ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT RETAINED BY THE OWNER TO BE IN RESPONSIBLE CHARGE FOR THE STRUCTURAL T ,�pION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE nFESS/0 REQUIREMENTS OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES. 2. I, OR ANOTHER ENGINEER OR ARCHITECT WHO I HAVE DESIGNATED ABOVE AND IS �� y ' `Ae r0 UNDER MY RESPONSIBLE CHARGE, HAS PERFORMED THE REQUIRED SITE VISITS AT i - ti S 5266 c) EACH SIGNIFICANT CONSTRUCTION STAGE TO VERITY IF THE STRUCTURE IS IN rrn n GENERAL CONFORMANCE WITH APPROVED PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS; DT b 30l 3. ALL NOTED DEFICIENCIES WHICH REMAIN TO BE CORRECTED HAVE BEEN INDICATED * StRUC�nli>."����Q� ABOVE; OF C `i A 4. I RECOMMEND THAT ACCEPTANCE OF THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS BY THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES BE WITHHELD UNTIL ALL OBSERVED DEFICIENCIES ARE 2 I? CORRECTED. a �S/Zol I (STAMP OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER) SIGNATURE OF STRUCTURAL OBSERVER DATE Version 1.0(2008 LACBC) Jan. 10 2008 INSPECTOR'S DAILY REPORT OF COMPACTED FILL Job Name ` Job Location Job No Page of ,--1 kVI)_ i 11 [tr „ A ( / General Contractor Grading Contractor Date Day of Week Grading Shift Hrs Con ractor's Supt of Foreman 8 Signature Field Tech ' Hrs on Site 1 c\ G(-28-rt From(s( h To Source an scription5 of Fill Materials Approximate Fill Yardage Total Read Placed this shift Total to date c r �� Weather Report Sequence No. • Test— Test Elevation Soil Fill Test Dry %of Max Remark No. Location or Type Moisture Density Dry Depth /o IDs/cu ft Density - OA -51+4 t Fty , v. -3-4 , -i,.., s n � '� 2s,,ess, c•-riiien A- • .. elictA,G*5- C - e-rit- thisd. oM /ciAs QS ier Z4_ 4.4 - ..;ttie:141, - f •KII(C1/4,- alat -_ "Irrrt,/ cry-k7011\ (I cyraPf - _.-I 183 �i4f I4 / Remarks (Describe equipment used hauling, spreading, watering, condition and compacting; also report thicknes lifts, removal of poor soil insufficiently compacted, and comment in unusual events.) _A :7.4 ---.....11L .......m.....4116, c r....._ or•en......P.,...., r. r' . i i SketchC=IMINIMMINIL� T' ---L,.ir---u---_ , /(1, , a. tlY rL f� 1 S' ----a=r — t *..,_ Copy to Client ( ) Copy to WI ( I CAL LAND ENGINEERING, INC. Company Policy Four le)hours minimum Charge(including travel time) �y Quartech Consultants, Inc. by: CONSTRUCTION STAKING PLAN - GRADING I_______ \ LOCATION: 111 HACIENDA DR ARCADIA CA 91006 -- APN: 5770-002-013 I DATE: 01-09-2019 N. T. S. t'..\M 'q 74.5' 74.5' - o N 00'56'20" W 321.49' ^e ' 5 0 5.0 -101 10 58' 3 5� -•-- -\ 4 �1 2 1 M 1 �'omo �I AKA ..- .dam 'it .� " c0 r W ';IIC ERB .■�,.;•� iiia■ �''1_ iii I� ;; , I I °m° �.' ��1t1- ���ir�t♦I\ 11 i II ��i i Ti gymmg . li 'hs4,.16W1N1rifi'rlipfii •! \ 0 5.0 8e � 83.5' '�' -w C _I__-II rr' lld;..�. =0== ,ti 70.48' i 68.0' ,imii 149.0'01I I \ BUILDING , I II��� F.F.=593.50 i1003 16.68' 6 3 -' I / PAD=592.83 N I N I II 7 5 1 i or,: 1D- 4-1-:0L 10. 2' 6 ___ •' N 00'56 20 W TBM=593. 0 326.10' -x C) 74.5' 74.5' 1 # FF ELEV TOP HUB CUT/FILL DRSCRIPTION LEGEND 0 ELEV CO 1 593.50 591 .19 F 2.31 5' 0/S BE X SET L&T ON TC LS 8407 W LAND Z 2 593.50 590.31 F 3.19 5' 0/S BE o�P� 4 1 • FD L&T ON TC LS 6999 ((/'1AG� Z 3 593.50 592.40 F 1.10 5' 0/S BL 5 a CK C. LEE < { z 4 593.50 593.64 C 0.14 5' 0/S BE o ® FD 1"IP & TAG LS 7783 (::\\N. 5 593.50 593.84 C 0.34 5 0/S BC 6 593.50 591.46 F 2.04 5 0 S BL/ ® SET 2"X2" HUB&T LS 8407N0. 8407 \ Zr Fl- 7 596.75 595.39 F 1 .36 6' 0/S BC4lF `8 596.75 595.89 F 0.86 5' 0/S BC 0 SET 1"X2" HUB OF CALF q m r- 9 596.75 596.23 F 0.52 5' 0/S BC b w a 10 596.75 596.30 F 0.45 5' 0/S BC 0 SET "X" FACE CBW FOR TBM u N w • 4 • • . ARCDIA/ TTcc CITY OF AR CADIA ' __,ATe�''° 240 West Huntington Drive Arcadia, CA 97007 ROUGH GRADING VERIFICATION ATTENTION: Community Development Administrator SUBJECT: Grading Verification for Project No. 18-058-003 Address: 111 Hacienda Drive Gentlemen: Rough grading operations have been completed for Project No. 1-058 003 • for Lots through (if applicable) and has been inspected by the undersigned Registered Civil Engineer or Licensed Architect. Based upon the observations, the rough grading of the lot(s) listed above have been completed in conformance with plans marked "APPROVED" by the City. The work includes but is not limited to the following: grading to approximate final elevations; staking of property lines; location and gradient of cut and fill slopes; location, cross- sectional configuration and flow-line gradient of drainage swales and terraces; berms installed where indicated; and required drainage slopes provided on building pads. Enclosed herewith is a Soil and Compaction Report for the Building Division which is required on all new construction sites prior to footing inspection. owOFEss;0 Engineer (Signature) � �� Architect (Signature) Na C �oa70 m R.C.E. No. 40870 ' a R.P..A. No. Date: C�att.aoP�\P Received and approved: Date: C.D.D./Planning cc: C.D.D./Maint. Ser. C.D.D./Building o9{{ t Cal Land Engineering, Inc. 11 dba Quartech Consultants Geotechnical, Environmental, and Civil Engineering December 24, 2018 Ramy Zaifman do Loh and Associates, (CL design) 1704 E. Cortez Street W. Covina, California 91791 Attention: Mr. Christopher Loh Subject: Soil Compaction Report, Proposed Residential Development, 111 Hacienda drive, APN: 5770-002-013, Arcadia, California QCI Project No.: 18-058-003C Reference: Report of Geotechnical Engineering Investigation, Proposed Residential Development, 111 Hacienda Drive, APN: 5770-002-013, Arcadia, California QCI Project No.: 18-058-003GE Ladies and Gentlemen: This report presents results of our field density tests performed on the proposed building pad and abandoned pool backfill at the subject site. The site conditions, field and laboratory test results, and post-grading recommendations are presented as follows: SITE CONDITION This report present result of our field density tests performed on the abandoned pool backfill and proposed single-family residence. The existing pool shell and associated structures was removed to exposed competent natural ground. The depth of removal was approximately seven foot below the adjacent grade The pool was backfilled to design grade with fill material. The fill placed under this report should be classified as primary structure fill. The building pads are depicted on the attached Site Plan (Figure 1) were excavated to a minimum depth of four feet below the final pad grade, and four feet horizontally beyond the building footprint. The loose and/or disturbed soils were removed and exposed competent natural soils within the building pad area. FIELD DENSITY TEST 1. Field density test was performed using the Nuclear Gauge Method (ASTM D-6938-10) and/or Sand Cone Method (ASTM D-1556-07). The field density test results are presented in Table I. Approximate locations of the test are shown on the enclosed Site Plan (Figure 1). 2. Field density tests were performed at random locations to check compaction effort provided by the contractor. The test results exceeded minimum required relative compaction of 90 percent. The test results herein are considered representative of the compacted area. LABORATORY TESTING The laboratory maximum dry density and optimum moisture content for the onsite and import soils were determined according to laboratory standard ASTM D-1557-12. The following table presents the test result of representative soil samples collected from the subject site: 576 East Lambert Road, Brea, California 92821; Tel: 714-671-1050, Fax: 714-671-1090 c Ramy Zaifman Page 2 QCI Project Number: 18-058-003C December 24, 2018 TABLE II LABORATORY TEST RESULTS Soil Type Maximum Dry Density Optimum Moisture Content (pcf) (k) A- Brown silty sand 130.0 8.0 B-Brown fine coarse silty sand 133.5 8.0 POST-GRADING RECOMMENDATIONS 1. All utility backfill should be brought to near optimum moisture content and then compacted to obtain a minimum relative compaction of 90 percent of the laboratory standard. 2. Soils generated from footing excavations to be used on onsite should be compacted to 90 percent minimum relative compaction, whether it is to be placed in landscape areas or within areas to be improved. This material must not alter positive drainage patterns away from the structural areas. 3. All trench excavations should conform to CAL-OSHA and local safety codes. REGULATORY COMPLIANCE The field compaction tests were performed in accordance to the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard procedures. The test results would not indicate the conditions of the subsurface materials underlying the fills. The engineering performance of the underlying materials and other materials are therefore not included in this report. Our field observation and soil tests were conducted in conformance with generally accepted professional engineering practices, and no further warranty is implied nor made. This report is subjected to review by the controlling authorities of this project. This opportunity to be of service is appreciated. If you should have any questions, please call the undersigned. Respectfully submitted, CalLand Engineering, Inc. (CLE) dba Quartech Consultants (QCI) QApf ESS/p* 44" AGK C.4e4.11(04..\ Q frirde /(40No.2153 Expp n Jack C. Lee, GE 2153 °C 'S/ / JerryLin /Principal Engineer ,QFpr N�`Ge.\tilr Project Engineer C Q,? Encl.: Figure I—Site Plan ' r'M\F"--, Dist: (4)Addressee 576 East Lambert Road, Brea, California 92821; Tel: 714-671-1050, Fax: 714-671-1090 c Ramy Zaifman Page 3 QCI Project Number: 18-058-003C December 24, 2018 TABLE I FIELD DENSITY TEST SUMMARY Depth Moisture Dry Relative Test Test Test Soil Below Content Density Compaction Test NO. Date Location FS (ft) (%) (pcf) (%) Type Method X-1 11-27-18 Building Pad 2 9.3 119.3 91.8 A N X-2 11-27-18 Building Pad 2 8.7 117.9 90.7 A N X-3 11-27-18 Building Pad 2 10.1 119.5 91.9 A N X-4 11-27-18 Building Pad 2 9.4 119.2 91.7 A S X-5 11-27-18 Pool Backfill 6 10.2 119.6 92.0 A N X-6 11-28-18 Building Pad 2 9.3 118.7 91.3 A N X-7 11-28-18 Building Pad 2 10.0 117.9 90.7 A N X-8 11-28-18 Building Pad 2 8.7 118.3 91.1 A S X-9 11-28-18 Building Pad 2 8.1 117.3 90.2 A N X-10 11-28-18 Building Pad FS 9.4 118.0 90.8 A N X-11 11-28-18 Building Pad FS 9.6 118.8 91.4 A N X-12 11-28-18 Pool Backfill 4 10.8 120.4 92.6 A S X-13 11-28-18 Pool Backfill 4 10.6 118.0 90.8 A N X-14 12-04-18 Building Pad FS 9.7 119.1 91.6 B N X-15 12-04-18 Building Pad FS 8.7 120.5 92.7 B N X-16 12-04-18 Building Pad 2 9.1 120.2 91.8 A S X-17 12-04-18 Building Pad 2 9.9 120.7 91.4 A N X-18 12-04-18 Building Pad 2 9.0 117.4 90.3 A N X-19 12-12--18 Building Pad 2 7.0 119.8 90.8 A N X-20 12-12-18 Building Pad 2 7.1 119.6 90.6 A S X-21 12-14-18 Building Pad FS 9.3 122.4 91.7 B N X-22 12-14-18 Building Pad FS 8.3 121.1 90.7 B N X-23 12-14-18 Building Pad 2 10.7 123.9 92.8 B N X-24 12-14-18 Building Pad 2 9.1 121.8 91.2 B S X-25 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 7.4 122.7 91.9 B N X-26 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 7.5 123.0 92.1 B N 576 East Lambert Road, Brea, California 92821; Tel: 714-671-1050, Fax: 714-671-1090 I Ramy Zaifman Page 4 QCI Project Number: 18-058-003C December 24, 2018 Test Test Test Depth Moisture Dry Relative Soil Below Content Density Compaction Test NO. Date Location FS(ft) (%) (pcf) (%) Type Method X-27 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 8.1 121.9 91.3 B N X-28 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 7.9 123.4 92.4 B S X-29 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 8.5 123.5 92.5 B N X-30 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 7.7 122.6 91.8 B N X-32 12-17-18 Building Pad FS 7.6 123.2 92.3 B N Note: FS = Finish Surface N=Nuclear Gauge Method S=Sand Cone Method 576 East Lambert Road, Brea, California 92821; Tel: 714-671-1050, Fax: 714-671-1090 .14 1 i I 1 N 00 S6'20'W 321.49' 1 1 1 1 1 r X-24 \"-- X-25 X-10 X-1 1 X-26 1111 BUILDING X-4X-3 X-11 1 \ . I ---J X-28X-23 X-27 X-22 1 X-19 I I X-18 -I X-9 X-14 X 7 u. j WI X-30 I _ X-2 N 1 BUILDING X 12 N 7, X-17 - 1 $ X-31 I EX. P00 -GARAGE j----� GARAGE �1 IX-5 X 29 X-13 I Ih(-15 X-6 / 41 z\._ X-20 X-21 I X-16 L X-8 I L J I- 1 II 'j N 00'36'20 W 326.10' i i I 1 I CalLand Engineering, Inc. Project Address: dba Quartech Consultants LEGEND APN: 5770-002-013 Geotechnical, Enviromental & Civil 111 Hacienda Drive Engineering Services Arcadia, California X-1 Approxmiate Field Density Test Location ZQ Approximate Limit of Compacted Fill Placed Under Purview of This Report NOT TO SCALE SITE PLAN 12/18 FIGURE 1 4," '*. City of Arcadia, CA Permit NO. Plum-18-1985 Development Services Department Permit Type:Plumbing 240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 Work Classification:Plumbing Residential Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 (626)574-5416 Permit Status:Issued ARCADIA Issue Date:10/24/20181 Expiration: 04/22/2019 Addr NO. Dir Prefix Street Name Street Suffix Unit City,State,Zip Parcel Number 111 Hacienda DR Arcadia,CA 5770002013 Contacts RAMY ZAIFMAN Owner DNC PLUMBING Plumbing Contractor 27 TANNERS RD,GREAT NECK, NY 11020 (C-36) (914)473-6592 ZJUDYRAMY@GMAIL.COM 2627 LOMA AVE,SOUTH EL MONTE,CA 91733 (626)443-6366 Description:PLUMBING FOR SF NEW Valuation: $ 0.00 Tenant Total Sq Feet: 0.00 Plan Check# Plan# Fees Amount payments Amount Paid Bar Sink $12.46 Total Fees $621.36 Bathtubs/or Combo $12.46 Cash/Receipt#REC-002680-2018 $621.36 Clothes Washer $12.46 Amount Due: $0.00 Dishwasher $12.46 Garbage Disposal Fee $24.92 Gas System(Outlets) $93.20 Kitchen Sink 537.38 COMPLETED Laundry Trays $12.46 Lavatories $112.14 Lawn Sprinkler System on One Meter $18.74 Plumbing Permit Issuance Fee $44.35 CALLS FOR INSPECTIONS Sewer Connection on Property $31.16 Request for inspection by telephone at 626-574-5450. Leave a message Shower $62.30 requesting the address,timeframe and what inspection item is needed. Solid Waste Management Fee 2 $1.00 Water Closet $87.22 Water Heater and/or Vent $46.65 This permit/plan review expires by time limitation and becomes null and void if the work authorized by the permit is not commenced within 180 days Total: $621.36 from the date of issuance or if the permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date of plan submittal.This permit expires and becomes null and void if any work authorized by this permit is suspended or abandoned for 180 consecutive days or if no progressive work has been verified by a City of Arcadia building inspector for a period of 180 consecutive days. October 24, 2018 Issued By: Date October 24,2018 Page 1 of 1 OF AR `i,,,tFogy,'e, PERMIT/PLAN REVIEW APPLICATION >i ' Development Services Department,240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 4 0 Arcadia, CA 91066-6021, (626) 574-5416,Fax (626)447-9173 m44itY oLN City of Arcadia LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION ❑ I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following: Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000,of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code,and y license is in full force and eff•ct. / ❑ I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self-insure for workers' License Class icense No. ��i Signature of Contractor GU -✓ Exp. Dated/i`3�� compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the r r performance of the work for which this permit is issued. OWNER-BUILDER DECLARAi N ❑ I have and will maintain workers'compensation insurance,as required by Section ❑ I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am exempt from the Contractors 3700 of the Labor Code,for the performance of the work for which this permit License Law for the following reason(Section 7031.5,Business and Professions is issued.My workers'compensation insurance carrier and policy numbers are: Code.Any city or county which requires a permit to construct,alter,improve, Carrier193 V r (ZS: demolish,or repair any structure,prior to its issuance,also required the applicant Policy Number G� for such permit to file a signed statement that he or she is licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Contractors License Law(Chapter 9(commencing with Section (This section need not be completed if the permit is for one hundred dollars or less) 7000)of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code)or that he or she is exempt there from and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of • I certify that in the performance of the work for which this permit is issued,I shall Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the workers' penalty of not more than five hundred dollars($500)): compensation Laws of California,and agree that if I should become subject to the workers'compensation provisions of Section 3700 of the Labor Code,I shall ❑I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole forthwith comply with those provisions. compensation,will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Date !a/ /r g Signature ac,....— Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, or who does such work himself or herself or through his or her own employees,provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for WARNING: Failure to secure Workers'Compensation coverage is unlawful, sale.If,however,the building or improvement is sold within one(1)year of and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to one completion,the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he or she hundred thousand dollars($100,000),in addition to the cost of compensation, did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). damages as provided for in Section 3706 of the Labor Code, interest, and attorney's fees. ❑I, as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY who builds or improves thereon,and who contracts for such projects with a I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that there is a construction lending agency contractor(s)licensed pursuant to the Contractors License Law). for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued (Section 3097, Civil Code). ❑ I am exempt under Section 7044,Business and Professions Code,for this reason: Lender's Name Date Signature Lender's Address IMPORTANT: APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR A PERMIT SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS SET FORTH ON THIS APPLICATION AND THE FOLLOWING: 1. The City's approved plans and permit inspection card must remain on the job site for use by City inspection personnel. 2. Final inspection of the work authorized by this permit is required.A Certificate of Occupancy must be obtained prior to use and occupancy of new buildings and structures. 3. Per South Coast Air Quality Management District(AQMD)regulations,renovation and remodeling work that results in the removal,stripping,or altering of asbestos containing materials requires an asbestos survey and removal prior to disturbing the asbestos. Please contact AQMD at(909)396-2000 for further information. Name r3L - -- Title Cnn�/2�C7o PRINT NAME I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is co rect and that I am the owner or duly authorized agent of the owner. I agree to comply with all City ordinances and State Laws relating to buildi construction. I hereby authorize representatives of the City of Arcadia to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. Signature L i Date /O /7v41--pg City of Arcadia, CA Permit NO. Elec-19-1001 Development Services Department Permit Type:Electrical 240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 Work Classification:Electrical Residential (626)574-5416 Permit Status:Issued ARCADIA Issue Date:05/29/2019 Expiration: Addr NO. Dir Prefix Street Name Street Suffix Unit City,State,Zip Parcel Number 111 Hacienda DR Arcadia, CA 5770002013 Contacts RAMY ZAIFMAN Owner SUNNY ELECTRIC AND CONSTRUCTION Contractor 27 TANNERS RD,GREAT NECK,NY 11020 INC* (914)473-6592 ZJUDYRAMY@GMAIL.COM 11561 E 169th,Artesia,CA 90701 (562)809-1549 751194 Description:ELECTRICAL FOR SFR/NEW,400 AMP SERVICE, Valuation: $ 0.00 Tenant TWO 100 AMP SUB PANELS Total Sq Feet: 7,283.00 Plan Check# Plan# Fees Amount Payments Amount Paid Distribution Panel $32.96 Total Fees $816.92 Electrical Permit Issuance Fee $47.01 Cash/Receipt#REC-01342-19 $816.92 Motors,Generators 1-10 hp $65.92 BldgAmount Due: $0.00 New Residential Accessory (sq ft $70.91 area) New Residential Elect.(sq ft area) $582.64 SolidResidential Services upm n 400 amps $16.48 complETED Solid Waste Management Fee 2 $1.00 Total: $816.92 CALLS FOR INSPECTIONS /, � �� Request for inspection by telephone at 626-574-5450. Leave-a message �J L� requesting the address,timeframe and what inspection item is needed. This permit/plan review expires by time limitation and becomes null and void if the work authorized by the permit is not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance or if the permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date of plan submittal.This permit expires and becomes null and void if any work authorized by this permit is suspended or abandoned for 180 consecutive days or if no progressive work has been verified by a City of Arcadia building inspector for a period of 180 consecutive days. May 29, 2019 Issued By: Date May 29,2019 Page 1 of 1 GD F R I;A, 4 .• PERMIT/PLAN REVIEW APPLICATION i13et' Development Services Department,240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 ,/. Arcadia, CA 91066-6021, (626) 574-5416,Fax(626)447-9173 City of Arcadia LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following: Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000,of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code,and my license is in full force and effect. ❑ I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self-insure for workers' License Classes/0 License No.73-I I? Exp. Date 6-2-02-I compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued. Signature of Contractor \3 OWNER-BUILDER DECLARATION I I have and will maintain workers'compensation insurance,as required by Section I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am exempt from the Contractors 3700 of the Labor Code,for the performance of the work for which this permit License Law for the following reason(Section 7031.5,Business and Professions is issued.My workers'compensation insurance carrier and policy numbers are: Code.Any city or county which requires a permit to construct,alter,improve, Carrier � '\� I L demolish,or repair any structure,prior to its issuance,also required the applicant Policy Number for such permit to file a signed statement that he or she is licensed pursuant to the (This section need not be completed if the permit is for one hundred dollars or less) provisions of the Contractors License Law(Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000)of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code)or that he or she is El I certify that in the performance of the work for which this permit is issued,I shall exempt there from and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the workers' penalty of not more than five hundred dollars($500)): compensation Laws of California,and agree that if I should become subject to the workers'compensation provisions of Section 3700 of the Labor Code,I shall 1:1I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole forthwith comply with those provisions. compensation,will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for _Z 7 sale(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License 1' 7-1 Signatiue Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, or who does such work himself or herself or through his or her own employees,provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for WARNING: Failure to secure Workers'Compensation coverage is unlawful, sale.If,however,the building or improvement is sold within one(1)year of and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to one completion,the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he or she hundred thousand dollars($100,000),in addition to the cost of compensation, did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). damages as provided for in Section 3706 of the Labor Code, interest, and attorney's fees. IJ I, as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY who builds or improves thereon,and who contracts for such projects with a I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that there is a construction lending agency contractor(s)licensed pursuant to the Contractors License Law). for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued (Section 3097, Civil Code). 0 I am exempt under Section 7044,Business and Professions Code,for this reason: Lender's Name Date Signature Lender's Address IMPORTANT: APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR A PERMIT SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS SET FORTH ON THIS APPLICATION AND THE FOLLOWING: 1. The City's approved plans and permit inspection card must remain on the job site for use by City inspection personnel. 2. Final inspection of the work authorized by this permit is required.A Certificate of Occupancy must be obtained prior to use and occupancy of new buildings and structures. 3. Per South Coast Air Quality Management District(AQMD)regulations,renovation and remodeling work that results in the removal,stripping,or altering of asbestos containing materials requires an asbestos survey and removal prior to disturbing the asbestos.Please contact AQMD at(909)396-2000 for further information. me /C/— 5, �--o in Title -`� PRINT NAME I ertify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct and that I am the owner or duly authorized agent of the owner. I gree to comply with all City ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction. I hereby authorize representatives of the City of A dia to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. v Signa Date —a fl /J *, City of Arcadia, CA Permit NO. Mech-19-1432 Development Services Department Permit Type:Mechanical 240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 Work Classification:HVAC New System, Residential Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 (626)574-5416 Permit Status:Issued ARCADIA Issue Date:07/25/2019 Expiration: Addr NO. Dir Prefix Street Name Street Suffix Unit City,State,Zip Parcel Number 111 Hacienda DR Arcadia, CA 5770002013 Contacts RAMY ZAIFMAN Owner 20th Century Air 20th Century Air Contractor 27 TANNERS RD,GREAT NECK,NY 11020 P 0 Box 638,Earp,CA 92242 (914)473-6592 ZJUDYRAMY@GMAIL.COM (714)777-6641 511598 Description:THREE NEW HVAC SYSTEMS FOR SFR/NEW Valuation: $ 0.00 Tenant Total Sq Feet: 0.00 Plan Check# Plan# Fees Amount Payments Amount Paid Compressor<3 Ton(up to 3 hp) $59.58 Total Fees $167.17 Furnace or Burner<=100,000 BTU $59.58 Cash/Receipt#REC-01915-19 $167.17 Mechanical Permit Issuance Fee $47.01 Amount Due: 'fry--/—�'r $0.00 Solid Waste Management Fee 2 $1.00 I- I complETED Total: $167.17 `` //e41 M ;43;'04,(Y CALLS FOR INSPECTIONS Request for inspection by telephone at 626-574-5450. Leave a message requesting the address,timeframe and what inspection item is needed. This permit/plan review expires by time limitation and becomes null and void if the work authorized by the permit is not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance or if the permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date of plan submittal.This permit expires and becomes null and void if any work authorized by this permit is suspended or abandoned for 180 consecutive days or if no progressive work has been verified by a City of Arcadia building inspector for a period of 180 consecutive days. July 25, 2019 Issued By: Date July 25,2019 Page 1 of 1 OF AR '1.111 '4 . PERMIT/PLAN REVIEW APPLICATION Development Services Department,240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 4'°°i.,°f Arcadia, CA 91066-6021, (626) 574-5416,Fax (626)447-9173 City of Arcadia ,/LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION L1_Lhereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following: TT Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000,of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code,and my license is in full force and e ffect./.Z) I ❑ I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self-insure for workers' License Class License No. 57 Exp. Date / _ , compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued. Signature of Contractor r i OWNER-BUILDER DECLARATIO 1:1I have and will maintain workers'compensation insurance,as required by Section 1:1I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am exempt from the Contractors 3700 of the Labor Code,for the performance of the work for which this permit License Law for the following reason(Section 7031.5,Business and Professions is issued.My workers'corn ation irancp carrier and policy numbers are: Code.Any city or county which requires a permit to construct,alter,improve, Carrier ( L demolish,or repair any structure,prior to its issuance,also required the applicant for such permit to file a signed statement that he or she is licensed pursuant to the Policy Number provisions of the Contractors License Law(Chapter 9(commencing with Section (This section need not be completed if the permit is for one hundred dollars or less) 7000)of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code)or that he or she is exempt there from and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of ❑II certify that in the performance of the work for which this permit is issued,I shall Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the workers' penalty of not more than five hundred dollars($500)): compensation Laws of California,and agree that if I should ome subject to the workers'compensation provisions of Section 3700 of th abor Code,I shall 1:1I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole forthwith co ply with those provisions. compensation,will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Date Signature Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, or who does such work himself or herself or through his or her own employees,provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for WARNING: Failure to secure Workers'Compensation coverage is unlawful, sale. If,however,the building or improvement is sold within one(1)year of and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to one completion,the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he or she hundred thousand dollars($100,000),in addition to the cost of compensation, did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). damages as provided for in Section 3706 of the Labor Code, interest, and attorney's fees. ❑I, as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY who builds or improves thereon,and who contracts for such projects with a I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that there is a construction lending agency contractor(s)licensed pursuant to the Contractors License Law). for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued (Section 3097, Civil Code). ❑ I am exempt under Section 7044,Business and Professions Code,for this reason: Lender's Name Date Signature Lender's Address IMPORTANT: APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR A PERMIT SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS SET FORTH ON THIS APPLICATION AND THE FOLLOWING: 1. The City's approved plans and permit inspection card must remain on the job site for use by City inspection personnel. 2. Final inspection of the work authorized by this permit is required.A Certificate of Occupancy must be obtained prior to use and occupancy of new buildings and structures. 3. Per South Coast Air Quality Management District(AQMD)regulations,renovation and remodeling work that results in the removal,stripping,or altering of asbestos containing materials requires an asbestos survey and removal prior to disturbing the asbestos. Please contact AQMD at(909) 396-2000 for further information. Name S &�-e Title \ PRIi?AME I certify that I have read this application and stat• that the above information is correct and that I am the owner or duly authorized agent of the owner. I agree to comply with all City ordinances a•/, State Laws relating to building construction. I hereby authorize representatives of the City of Arcadia to enter upon the above-mentio s e pr!f,pr! erty for inspection purposes. 7/) /1 ? Signature ' / Date City of Arcadia, CA Permit NO.Wall-19-0226 Development Services Department Permit Type:Wall 240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 Work Classification:Wall-Garden Wall (626)574-5416 Permit Status:Issued ARCA D1A Issue Date:03/26/2019 Expiration: Addr NO. Dir Prefix Street Name Street Suffix Unit City,State,Zip Parcel Number 1111 Hacienda DR Arcadia, CA 5770002013 013140 vautaraneetwassw,l Contacts RAMY ZAIFMAN Owner BOWDEN DEVELOPMENT INC* Contractor 27 TANNERS RD,GREAT NECK,NY 11020 212 W Foothill,Monrovia,CA 91016 (914)473-6592 ZJUDYRAMY@GMAIL.COM (626)303-7917 322620 Description:BLOCKWALL PER APPROVED PLANS.6' H X 250'LF Valuation: $ 14,760.00 Tenant ON EAST SIDE OF PROPERTY. Total Sq Feet: 0.00 Plan Check t Plan# Fees Amount Payments Amount Paid Building Issuing Fee $47.01 Total Fees $374.01 Building Permit Fees $320.75 Cash/Receipt#REC-00767-19 $374.01 Solid Waste Management Fee $6.25 Amount Due: $0.00 Total: $374.01 •2. p! 191 VIM) VIII./9 Oa* -a;hK etiGT7l7�✓,Nr cr�f S=� ;71,4 ( CALLS FOR INSPECTIONS Request for inspection by telephone at 626-574-5450. Leave a message requesting the address,timeframe and what inspection item is needed. This permit/plan review expires by time limitation and becomes null and void if the work authorized by the permit is not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance or if the permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date of plan submittal.This permit expires and becomes null and void if any work authorized by this permit is suspended or abandoned for 180 consecutive days or if no progressive work has been verified by a City of Arcadia building inspector for a period of 180 consecutive days. March 26, 2019 Issued By: Date March 26,2019 Page 1 of 1 %VA; 0,µvoR3/44. 4 .-PERMIT/PLAN REVIEW APPLICATION E411/' Development Services Department,240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 , Arcadia,CA 91066-6021, (626)574-5416,Fax(626)447-9173 City of Arcadia LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION 0 I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following: Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000,of Division 3 of the Business and fessions Code,and my license is in full force and effect. 0 I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self insure for workers' icense Class �� Lice No� � Exp. Date compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the ignature of Contractor �\ performance of the work for which this permit is issued. j)WNER-BUILDE' LARATIO ❑ I have and will maintain workers'compensation insurance,as required by Section CII hereby affirm under pe of perjury that I am exempt from the Contractors 3700 of the Labor Code,for the performance of the work for which this permit License Law for the following reason(Section 7031.5,Business and Professions is issued.My workers'compensation insurance carrier and policy numbers are: Code.Any city or county which requires a permit to construct,alter,improve, Carrier ON ' fi� demolish,or repair any structure,prior to its issuance,also required the applicant Policy Number for such permit to file a signed statement that he or she is licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Contractors License Law(Chapter 9(commencing with Section (This section need not be completed if the permit is for one hundred dollars or less) 7000)of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code)or that he or she is ❑ I certify that in the performance of the work for which this permit is issued,I shall exempt there from and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the workers' penalty of not more than five hundred dollars($500)): compensation Laws of California,and agree that if I should become subject to the workers'compensation provisions of Section 3700 of the Labor Code,I shall CII, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole forthwith comply with those provisions. compensation,will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for Date '-� ' 1 SignatureCtiLej, sale(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License 1 Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, or who does such work himself or herself or through his or her own employees,provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for WARNING: Failure to secure Worke ompensation coverage is unlawful, sale.If,however,the building or improvement is sold within one(1)year of and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to one completion,the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he or she hundred thousand dollars($100,000),in addition to the cost of compensation, did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). damages as provided for in Section 3706 of the Labor Code, interest, and attorney's fees. ❑I, as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY who builds or improves thereon,and who contracts for such projects with a I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that there is a construction lending agency contractor(s)licensed pursuant to the Contractors License Law). for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued (Section 3097, Civil Code). ❑ I am exempt under Section 7044,Business and Professions Code,for this reason: Lender's Name Date Signature Lender's Address IMPORTANT: APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR A PERMIT SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS SET FORTH ON THIS APPLICATION AND THE FOLLOWING: 1. The City's approved plans and permit inspection card must remain on the job site for use by City inspection personnel. 2. Final inspection of the work authorized by this permit is required.A Certificate of Occupancy must be obtained prior to use and occupancy of new buildings and structures. 3. Per South Coast Air Quality Management District(AQMD)regulations,renovation and remodeling work that results in the removal,stripping,or altering of asbestos containing materials requires an asbestos survey and removal prior to disturbing the asbestos. Please contact AQMD at(909)396-2000 for further information. Name M Vel1.Y `Title 62.1.4r S u (, �RINT NAME v I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct and that I am the owner or duly authorized agent of the owner. I agree to comply with all City ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction. I hereby authorize representatives of the City of Arcadia to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. oe Signature Date L i i •*. City of Arcadia, CA Permit NO. FIRE-19-1166 Development Services Department Permit Type:Fire 240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 Work Classification:Fire S rinkler Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 P (626)574-5416 Permit Status:Issued ARCADIA Issue Date:07/11/2019 Expiration: 12/17/2019 Addr NO. Dir Prefix Street Name Street Suffix Unit City,State,Zip Parcel Number 111 Hacienda DR Arcadia, CA 5770002013 ,,.. ;.. Contacts RAMY ZAIFMAN Owner CRAIG FIRE PREVENTION* Contractor 27 TANNERS RD,GREAT NECK,NY 11020 123 E CENTRAL AVENUE AVE, MONROVIA,CA 91016 (914)473-6592 ZJUDYRAMY@GMAIL.COM (626)357-4045 1037827 Description: FIRE SPRINKS FOR SF NEW 80 HEADS Valuation: $ 13,400.00 Tenant Total Sq Feet: 0.00 Plan Check#19-1166 Plan# Fees Amount Payments Amount Paid Fire Issuance $47.01 Total Fees $1,052.06 Fire Permit Fees $304.05 Cash/Receipt#REC-01797-19 $352.06 Solid Waste Management Fee 2 $1.00 Cash/Receipt#REC-01589-19 $700.00 Sprinkler Heads $700.00 Amount Due: $0.00 Total: $1,052.06 171 COMPLETED CALLS FOR INSPECTIONS Request for inspection by telephone at 626-574-5450. Leave a message requesting the address,timeframe and what inspection item is needed. This permit/plan review expires by time limitation and becomes null and void if the work authorized by the permit is not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance or if the permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date of plan submittal.This permit expires and becomes null and void if any work authorized by this permit is suspended or abandoned for 180 consecutive days or if no progressive work has been verified by a City of Arcadia building inspector for a period of 180 consecutive days. July 11, 2019 Issued By: Date July 11,2019 Page 1 of 1 of AN PERMIT/PLAN REVIEW APPLICATION Development Services Department,240 West Huntington Drive,Post Office Box 60021 meshy of Ned. Arcadia, CA 91066-6021, (626) 574-5416,Fax (626) 447-9173 City of Arcadia LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION 0 I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following: Chapter 9(commencing with Section 7000,of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code,and my license is in full force and effect. ❑ I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self-insure for workers' License Class &14 Signature of Contractor &enseVri )-2' Exp. Date 1 l Ze(t' compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued. , � OWNER-BUILDER DECLARATION 1 have and will maintain workers'compensation insurance,as required by Section 1:1I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am exempt from the Contractors 3700 of the Labor Code,for the performance of the work for which this permit License Law for the following reason(Section 7031.5,Business and Professions is issued.My workers'compensation insurance carrier and policy numbers are: Code.Any city or county which requires a permit to construct,alter,improve, Carrier ON =//-.- demolish,or repair any structure,prior to its issuance,also required the applicant Policy Number cN/4-4 for such permit to file a signed statement that he or she is licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Contractors License Law(Chapter 9(commencing with Section (This section need not be completed if the permit is for one hundred dollars or less) 7000)of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code)or that he or she is exempt there from and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of ❑ I certify that in the performance of the work for which this permit is issued,I shall Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the workers' penalty of not more than five hundred dollars($500)): compensation Laws of California,and agree that if I should become subject to the workers'compensation provisions of Section 3700 of the Labor Code,I shall ❑I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole forthwith comply with those provisions. compensation,will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for Date VI" tti Signature <4°--7 i)414-df(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, or who does such work himself or herself or through his or her own employees,provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for WARNING: Failure to secure Workers'Compensation coverage is unlawful, sale.If,however,the building or improvement is sold within one(1)year of and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to one completion,the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he or she hundred thousand dollars($100,000),in addition to the cost of compensation, did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). damages as provided for in Section 3706 of the Labor Code, interest, and attorney's fees. ❑I, as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project(Section 7044,Business and Professions Code:The Contractors License Law does not apply to an owner of property CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY who builds or improves thereon,and who contracts for such projects with a I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that there is a construction lending agency contractor(s)licensed pursuant to the Contractors License Law). for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued (Section 3097, Civil Code). ❑ I am exempt under Section 7044,Business and Professions Code,for this reason: Lender's Name Date Signature Lender's Address IMPORTANT: APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR A PERMIT SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS SET FORTH ON THIS APPLICATION AND THE FOLLOWING: 1. The City's approved plans and permit inspection card must remain on the job site for use by City inspection personnel. 2. Final inspection of the work authorized by this permit is required.A Certificate of Occupancy must be obtained prior to use and occupancy of new buildings and structures. 3. Per South Coast Air Quality Management District(AQMD)regulations,renovation and remodeling work that results in the removal,stripping,or altering of asbestos containing materials requires an asbestos survey and removal prior to disturbing the asbestos. Please contact AQMD at(909)396-2000 for further information. ame Ciw. �) u/ Title I a l"( PRINT NAME I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct and that I am the owner or duly authorized agent of the owner. I agree to comply with all City ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction. I hereby authorize representatives of the City of Arcadia to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. gnature C/'lei ).4— Date ( 1/ ( / cr ti4 OV rtv�c'9 r 4! C.' WPM 7 got� ' » � Avry_ i Sr 901�` ccN °j"aityot MEMORANDUM Fire Department DATE: February 7, 2020 TO: BUILDING DEPARTMENT INSPECTOR John Zurick FROM: FIRE DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: FIELD INSPECTION ADDRESS: 111 Hacienda Drive THE FOLLOWING ITEMS WERE CHECKED FOR CONFORMANCE WITH APPLICABLE FIRE DEPARTMENT REQUIREMENTS: I DATE / INITIAL TYPE OF INSPECTION FINAL INSPECTION FIRE SPRINKLERS 2-7-2020 Mark Krikorian FIRE ALARMS HOOD & DUCT KNOX BOX OCCUPANCY 2-7-2020 Mark Krikorian COMMENTS: Emailed Bldg. Dept. 2-7-2020 Rita Aim. ' ® • ° . � PLANNING SERVICES e�aaltetB < ATTENTION: /S DATE: 3 /4 FROM: BUILDING SERVICES INSPECTOR: j 67/ PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1/l Cief_gi 1)f I PERMIT#: PLAN#: CONTRACTOR: 3--i( PHONE#: / /. /C)� 7 OWNER: PHONE#: PLEASE INSPECT THE FOLLOWING ITEMS FOR COMFORMANCE WITH APPLICABLE PLANNING REQUIREMENTS. TYPE OF INSPECTION DATE & INITIAL DATE & INITIAL FINAL APPROVAL LANSCAPING/IRRIGATION \„ a ) NIA i \ 04A1/Pri Ab TRASH ENCLOSURES `�-x J PARKING/DRIVEWAYS , ( -� 11 12C q I-1, 2CD STORAGE AREAS _— MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT , 11 12CJ Q12 f x\) WALL HEIGHT ?A. \f1.(,1,-)1 BACKFLOW SCREENING � l COMMENTS: ' ► 4st-AW 1 C I I' b `€ c 7 -76&\c/c- a fit- G\0 r- '�� v s • ''� C 1 Vkms , - w- O` UIQ • ` �,LICA A rig go rv_ ' _ • a-C to A :PC CA Ott ": _ We ul „t,„ WATER DIVISION uan (O ATTENTION: DATE: 041. FROM: BUILDING DIVISION INSPECTOR: '30/7/. ADDRESS: /// /41C/fTA4 ✓�,J� PERMIT NO.: PLAN NO.: CONTRACTOR: affn PHONE NO.: r 7 - 034i,7 OWNER: PHONE NO.: PLEASE INSPECT THE FOLLOWING ITEMS FOR CONFORMANCE WITH APPLICABLE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS REQUIREMENTS. Type of Inspection Date & Initial Date& Initial Final Approval Meter Location (R5/90 Blackflow Devices �/ Irrigation System _ `� a5/AO Fire Sprinkler System a/a5/ao ?-/A1/2v Meter Clear A.P.P. a/asjao Swimming Pool i§5 cY( 5/210 COMMENTS: 4-1o,,,,. 2bLO xasY Rp `-1lNy3y� �A yroyQ�yl�� A.R.T. 50o Zz)1c1-7D oic rt s P T ,fes ..7 ]_.Y\ _ _,. _•— _ .. � t:t;^: ,�:fc.1 �a'- 4. t- — CITY OF ARCADIA r lig . it • '. WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING DOCUMENTATION PACKAGE :-, .. CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION ti This certificate is to be filled out by the project applicant and the property owner upon completion of i the landscaping project. i-i • • Project Information Date of Project Completion Permit Type and No. [. Project Address '� 1, \ \ \ \--\OCA end a 'DV-. f. Name of Pro ct Applicant a5q Title iName of Property Owner 4��v J�� ��L� Jo ; ; : Company Name&M ••n Addr r Mailing Address ;., -Z 12- w• Poo th i 0(• .er;r CA- 1 ( 0 ( C , e Telephone and Fax No(s)e Z 6) 3 3 7 f i Telephone and Fax No(s). i. Email AddressJ Email Address i st rept CLRS Dcl c.4 dcuelopicAl.6,6 fv‘ ---------_ 1. 0 is t. Project Applicant - The signer of the landscape design plan, signer of the irrigation plan, the P: licensed landscape contractor that installed the landscaping and irrigation, or a licensed :r professional that performed periodic site observations to verify that the project is consistent with the Water Efficient Landscaping Documentation Package for the project and that the project t. complies with Ordinance No. 2267 and the Governor's Executive Order No. B-29-15. .i. "I/we certify that based upon periodic site observations, the work has been substantially , completed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2267 and the Governor's Executive Order No. B-29-15 and that the landscape planting and irrigation installation conform with the criteria `fi `u and specifications of the approved Landscape and Irrigation Plans and Landscape Documentation Package and acknowledge that the project may be subject to inspection and a Landscap Water dit to verify that the project is maintained in compliance with a Ordinance No. 67 d t Governor's Executive Order No. B-29-15." `: • € 1: Signature Date 6 _ /_ j 6' i. Name( nt)6,Aivi rcetiAdc Telephone and Fax No(s). q t 6) y 2 ? 2 3 t: Title License No. or Certification No. ', 1 J � YL-A-- 322-6-0 Company f D /of Email Address /,I ��f/� / / p t t Cv 9-f' t 1( ,,denC�j©f,(� d�04 M 4i✓ eo o A/6-t I . Mailing Address ( . // �/ q 2 l 2 0' 6. ; I I GA)flu of e/) / `.t �Y I Property Owner _. : "I/we certify that I/we have received copies of all the documents within the Water Efficient It Landscaping Documentation Package for our project and that it is my/our responsibility to see that .•t the project is maintained in accordance with the Landscape and Irrigation Maintenance Schedule j. for the project and in compliance with Ordinance No. 2267 and the Governor's Executive Order No. '` B-29-15, and I/we acknowledge that the project may be subject to inspection and a Landscape Water Audit to veri th t the project is being maintained in compliance with Ordinance No. 2267 and the Gov- nor' x utive Order No. B-29-15. il /, fr6 -/ l f! Property o ne' ' S ature(s) Date 1 1 - Revised July 6, _. 11 - ______.. ul 2015 t -.-..,...r.,..,---.,:::::_-_-..,•,:- ._ .. _.._. mac- .,_.._s.,_. s....«___z • '_x,,._,,,i,.....,,,•s.',,..,..,,,,,,..,,,,44,-, 011 City of Arcadia DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Inter-Departmental Inspection Request Date: Public Works Inspector To: From: v 1/2,7 Address: /// /74(Cie41 // Permit No.: Contractor: 1-/1 Phone No.: 9 .3 z 7 Owner: Phone No.: Please inspect the following items to ensure that the Contractor/Developer is in compliance with all conditions of approval established for the project, and that the work performed meets the City's standard for Public Works construction: Type of Inspection Date & Initial Date& Initial Final Approval Drainage Grading Erosion Control Offsite Improvements Street Improvement(s) (conduit, curb/curb & 9' gutter, curb numbers, driveway approach, parkway planting, sidewalk, street light, traffic flow, etc.) Sewer(s) (lateral,grease/san interceptor, saddle,wye, etc.) COMMENTS: SO-113 WASTE MANAGEMENT COUNTY SANITATION DISTRICTS OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY 1955 Workman MBI Road,Whittier,CA 90601-1400 Mailing Address:P.O.Box 4998,Whittier,CA 90607-4998 Grace Robinson Hyde Telephone:(562)699-7411,FAX:(562)699-5422 Chief Engineer and General Manager www.lacsd.org Counter Hours: 7:00 a.m.-4:00 p.m.Mon.-Thurs. 7:00 a.m.-3:00 p.m.Fri. Application No.: 5770002013-002 Date: October 5,2018 SEWERAGE SYSTEM CONNECTION FEE RECEIPT APN: 5770 002 013 District No.: 15 Owner/Situs Address Applicant Information NORBERT LAMOREAUX Ramy Zaifinan(owner) 111 HACIENDA DR Troy French ARCADIA,CA 91006 212 W.Foothill Blvd. Monrovia,CA 91016 ' Phone: (626)303-7917 Facility Type Measure of Use Unit Rate Amount Single Family Home D 1.00 DU Single Family Home N 1.00 DU $4,210.00/DU $4,210.00 111 HACIENDA DR,ARCADIA Base Line Credit 1.00 CUs $4,210.00/CUs ($4,210.00) Connection Fee Due $0.00 Type Abbreviations N-New or Additional;C-Change of Existing;E-Existing to Remain;D-Demolition of Existing;T-Tenant Improvement of Existing;S-Septic to Sewer Includes demolition of 1.00 DU of existing Single Family Home Processor: Erika Ballesteros Approver:Fit beth Pad DISTRICTS D.C.: , 1 I OF LOSSANITATION ANGELES COUNTY Payment Received Check No. � Amount Troy French $0.00 Cti APPROVED GRACE ROBINSON HYDE CHIEF ENCINEER&GEN.MGR.1 Valid-Only VVhetr9tampO DOC#4763733 THIS IS NOTA CONNECTION PERMIT. A CONNECTION PERMIT IS REQUIRED BEFORE CONNECTING TO ANY SEWER. CITY OF ARCADIA WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING - ORDINANCE NO. 2330 LANDSCAPE DOCUMENTATION PACKAGE - SECTION A PROJECT INFORMATION Date: 5-31 -2018 Project Name: Single Family Project Applicant: Howard Fang (for Two Trees Design, Inc.) Project Address and Location: Street Address Assessor Parcel Number 111 HACIENDA DR. 5770-002-013 Arcadia Tract/Parcel Map No.and Lot Number(s) Tract # 11704 Lot 6 California 1 91006-2349 Nearest Cross Street RAMONA ROAD Project Type (Please check all that apply): X New ❑ Rehabilitation X Single-Family Residential ❑ Private ❑ Public ❑ Multiple-Family Residential ❑ Commercial/ Industrial ❑ Mixed-Use ❑ Institutional (i.e., hospital, school, etc.) ❑ Other Please fill in the information below to describe the landscape project: Total landscaped area 16971 (sq. feet) Total turf area 2360 (sq. feet) Total non-turf area 14611 (sq. feet) Total active recreational areas (sq. feet) Total area of Special Landscaped Areas (sq. feet) Total irrigated landscape area 8835 (sq. feet) Total non-irrigated landscape area 8136 (sq. feet) Please check the Water Supplier for this project: ® City of Arcadia Water Services — 11800 Goldring Road, Arcadia, CA 91006 — (626) 256-6650 ❑ East Pasadena Water Company — 3725 Mountain View Ave., Pasadena, CA 91107 — (626) 793-6189 ❑ Sunny Slope Water Company — 1040 El Campo Dr., Pasadena, CA 91107 — (626) 568-4266 ❑ California American Water — 2020 Huntington Drive, San Marino, CA 91108 — (831) 646-3252 ❑ Golden State Water Company — 110 E. Live Oak Avenue, Arcadia, CA 91006 — (626) 446-1372 Acknowledgment: I agree to comply with the requirements of the City of Arcadia Water Efficient Landscaping Ordinance and submit a complete Landscape Documentation Package. Applicant's Signature � Date --7 (/ ? eY December 1,2015 I CITY OF ARCADIA WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING - ORDINANCE NO. 2330 LANDSCAPE DOCUMENTATION PACKAGE - SECTION B PROJECT CONTACTS — The project applicant and other individuals may receive inquiries or notifications of all proceedings regarding the Water Efficient Landscaping Documentation Package. Please provide the name, mailing address, email address, and telephone no(s), etc. of each person to receive such inquiries and notifications. 1. Project Applicant Name Telephone and Fax Number(s) HOWARD FANG 626-475-9819 Title Email Address Project Manager/Principal 2treesdesign®gmail.com Company Mailing Address Two Trees Design, Inc. 2071 La France Ave. City State Zip Code South Pasadena CA 91030 2. Property Owner Name(s) Telephone and Fax Number(s) Ramy Zaifman Mailing Address Email Address (Same as project address) City State Zip Code Arcadia CA 91008 3. Licensed Landscape Architect Name Title Camille Perng Principal Company License No. Two Trees Design, Inc. 5840 Mailing Address Telephone and Fax Number(s) 1832 San Diego St. (same as above) City Email Address West Covina (same as above) State Zip Code Website CA 91030 4. Certified Irrigation Designer Name Title Company License No. Mailing Address Telephone and Fax Number(s) City Email Address State Zip Code Website -Continued on next page - -4 - December 1, 2015 1111 CITY OF ARCADIA WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING - ORDINANCE NO. 2330 LANDSCAPE DOCUMENTATION PACKAGE - SECTION B (continued) 5. Landscape Installation Contractor Name Title Company License No. Mailing Address Telephone and Fax Number(s) City Email Address State Zip Code Website 6. Irrigation Installation Contractor Name Title Company License No. Mailing Address Telephone and Fax Number(s) City Email Address State Zip Code Website 7. Landscape & Irrigation Maintenance Contractor Name Title Company License No. Mailing Address Telephone and Fax Number(s) City Email Address State Zip Code Website 8. Certified Irrigation Auditor Name Title Company License No. Mailing Address Telephone and Fax Number(s) City Email Address State Zip Code Website - 5- December 1, 2015 4 CITY OF ARCADIA WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING - ORDINANCE NO. 2330 WORKSHEET - SECTION C THIS WORKSHEET IS REQUIRED TO BE FILLIED OUT BY THE PROJECT APPLICANT Reference Evapotranspiration (ETo) Rate = 50.2 inches per year The ETo for the Arcadia area is based on the State Department of Water Resource, Reference Evapotranspiration rate (ETo) for the City of Monrovia-Appendix`A`of the State MWELO. Hydrozone# Plant Irrigation Irrigation ETAF Hydrozone ETAF I Estimated Total & Planting Factor Method Efficiency (PF + IE) Area x Area Water Use Description (PF) (IE) ; in sq. ft. (ETWU) Regular Landscape Areas 1) NW 0 None 0 0 8136 0 0 2) LW 11 0.15 Drip 0.81 0.19 207 39.33 1224.11 3) MW 3-10 _0.5 Drip 0.81 0.62 53033287.86 102331 .35 4) Warm Turf 1,2 0.7 Drip 0.81 , 0.74 2360 1746.40 54354.95 5) Pool 0.85 (Pool) 0.75 1 .13 965 1090.45 33939.17 Totals (A) (B) Avg: 0.36 16971 6164.04 Special Landscape Areas (SLAs)-Includes areas irrigated with recycled water 1 1 1 Totals (C) (D) ETWU Total 191 ,849.58 MAWA 290,512.97 Hydrozone # & Planting Description - e.g., 1) Lawn/Turf, 2) Low Water Use Plantings, 3) Medium Water Use Plantings, etc. Plant Factor(PF)- Irrigation Method-Overhead Spray or Drip Irrigation Efficiency(IE)-0.75 for Overhead Spray, 0.81 for drip ETWU (Annual Gallons Required)= ETo(50.2)x 0.62 x ETAF x Area MAWA(Annual Gallons Allowed)= ETo(50.2)x 0.62 x[(ETAF x Area)+((1-ETAF)x SLA)] 0.62 is a conversion factor to convert acre-inches per acre,to gallons per square foot per year Area is the total Regular Landscape Areas SLA is the total Special Landscape Areas ETAF is 0.55 for residential areas, and 0.45 for non-residential areas ETAF Calculations Regular Landscape Areas: Average ETAF for Regular Landscape Areas must be 0.55 Total ETAF x Area (B) Total Area (A) Average ETAF B+A All Landscape Areas Total ETAF x Area (B+D) Total Area I (A+C) Sitewide ETAF (B+D)_(A+C) -6- December 1,2015 r—• CITY OF ARCADIA WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING - ORDINANCE NO. 2330 PRESCRIPTIVE MEASURES COMPLIANCE OPTION - SECTION D As an option to completing the Worksheet (Section C) and prior to the approval of any Design Review and/or Plan Check for a project that meets the thresholds for this Option, compliance with all of the following items is mandatory and must be documented on a landscape plan. 1) ❑ Submit Sections A& B of the Landscape Documentation Package which includes the following elements: A) ❑ Date B) ❑ Project Applicant C) ❑ Project Address D) ❑ Total Landscape Area in Square Feet, including a breakdown of turf and plant material E) ❑ Project Type F) ❑ Water Supply Type (e.g., potable, recycled)and Water Supplier G) ❑ Contact Information H) ❑ Applicant Signature and Date with Statement: "I agree to comply with the requirements of the City of Arcadia Water Efficient Landscaping Ordinance and submit a complete Landscape Documentation Package." 2) ❑ Incorporate compost at a rate of at least four cubic yards per 1,000 square feet to a depth of six inches into landscape areas, unless contra-indicated by a soils test 3) ❑ Plant Material shall comply with the following: A) ❑ Install climate adapted plants that require occasional, little, or no summer water (average WUCOLS plant factor of 0.3) excluding edibles and areas using recycled water, for 75% of the residential planting areas, and 100% of the non-residential planting areas B) ❑ A minimum three-inch layer of mulch shall be applied on all exposed soil surfaces of planting areas, except in turf areas, creeping or rooting groundcover areas, or direct seeding application areas where mulch is contra-indicated 4) ❑ Turf shall comply with all of the following: A) ❑ Turf shall not exceed 25% of the landscape area in residential areas, and there shall be no turf in non- residential areas B) ❑ Turf shall not be planted on sloped areas that exceed a slope of one-foot vertical elevation change for every four feet of horizontal length C) ❑ Turf is prohibited in parkways less than 10 feet wide, unless the parkway is adjacent to a parking strip and used to enter and exit vehicles. Any turf in parkways must be irrigated by sub-surface irrigation or by other technology that creates no overspray or runoff 5) ❑ Irrigation systems shall comply with the following: A) ❑ Automatic irrigation controllers are required and must use evapotranspiration or soil moisture sensor data B) ❑ Irrigation controllers shall be of a type that does not lose programming data in the event the primary power source is interrupted C) ❑ Pressure regulators shall be installed on the irrigation system to ensure the dynamic pressure of the system is within the manufacturer's recommended pressure range D) ❑ Manual shut-off valves (e.g., a gate valve, ball valve, or butterfly valve) shall be installed as close as possible to the point of connection to the water supply E) ❑ All irrigation emission devices must meet the requirements set in the ANSI standard, ASABE/ICC 802- 2014, "Landscape Irrigation Sprinkler and Emitter Standard." All sprinkler heads installed in the landscape must document a distribution uniformity low quarter of 0.65 or higher using the protocol defined in ASABE/ICC 802-2014. 6) ❑ At the time of final inspection, the applicant must provide the owner of the property with a Certificate of Completion (see page 8), including the Irrigation Schedule, and Schedule of Landscape and Irrigation Maintenance. -7- December 1, 2015 CITY OF ARCADIA ice! . WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING - ORDINANCE NO. 2330 CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION This certificate is to be filled out by the project applicant and acknowledged by the property owner(s) upon completion of the landscaping project. 1. Project Information Date of Project Completion Permit Type and No. Project Name and/or Address Project Applicant and Title Property Owner _ I Company Name&Mailing Address Mailing Address Telephone and Fax No(s). Telephone and Fax No(s). Email Address Email Address 2. Answer the questions below: a. Date the Landscape Documentation Package was submitted to the City of Arcadia b. Date the Landscape Documentation Package was approved by the City of Arcadia c. Date that a copy of the Water Efficient Landscape Worksheet or Prescriptive Measures Compliance Option was submitted to the project water supplier 3. Project Applicant — Certification — The signer of the landscape design plan, signer of the irrigation plan, or the licensed landscape contractor(s) that installed the landscaping and/or irrigation is to certify that the landscape project has been constructed/installed in accordance with the approved Landscape Documentation Package and in compliance with Ordinance No. 2330 and State law. Where there have been significant changes made in the field during construction/installation, "as-built" or record drawings shall be included with this certification. "I/we certify that based upon periodic site observations, the work has been completed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2330 and State law, and that the landscape planting and irrigation installation conform with the criteria and specifications of the approved Landscape and Irrigation Plans and Landscape Documentation Package and acknowledge that the project may be subject to inspection and a Landscape Irrigation Audit to verify that the project is maintained in compliance with Ordinance No. 2330 and State law." Signature Date Name(print) Telephone and Fax No(s). Title License No.or Certification No. Company Email Address Mailing Address 4. Property Owner-Acknowledgment "I/we certify that I/we have received copies of all the documents within the Landscape Documentation Package and the Certificate of Completion for our project and that it is our responsibility to see that the project is maintained in accordance with the Landscape and Irrigation Maintenance Schedule for our project, including a diagram of the irrigation plan that shows the hydrozones posted with the irrigation controller, in compliance with Ordinance No. 2330 and State law, and I/we acknowledge that the project may be subject to inspection and a Landscape Irrigation Audit to verify that the project is being maintained in compliance with Ordinance No. 2330 and State law." Property Owner(s)Signature(s) Date 5. Include the following documents with this Certificate: a. Irrigation Schedule—The parameters for setting the irrigation schedule on the controller(s)per Ordinance Section 7554.5.C. b. Schedule of landscape and irrigation maintenance per Ordinance Section 7554.5. c. Landscape Irrigation Audit Report per Ordinance Section 7554.3.E. d. Soil Analysis and Management Report(s), if not previously submitted with the Landscape Documentation Package per Ordinance Section 7554.4. e. Verification of implementation of recommendations from soil analysis report per Ordinance Sections 7554.4 and 7554.6. -8- December 1, 2015 A FILE NO. + DATE 4Z-2-6 --/S ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD (COMMITTEE) FINDINGS AND ACTION A. PROJECT ADDRESS (/ / X14 t/€ D/4 ,AT -//C/// B. PROPERTY OWNER 7i4e}/� `7' Z4'/G'1 fN ADDRESS (IF DIFFERENT) C. FINDINGS (only check those that apply, and provide a written explanation for each check) 1. The proposed construction materials 1„1/ ARE, [] ARE NOT compatible with the existing materials, because J/Mi`-i-WZ_ 770 de:34-4e) - /Y)AreA/ALS WS 40A/ • 2. The proposed materials [] WILL, [] WILL NOT have a significant adverse impact on the overall appearance of the property, because • 3. The proposed project [] IS, [ NOT significantly visible from the adjoining public rights of way, because G09/a-G-E 4204-A-4 T 'ESS 4. The proposed project [] IS, KIS NOT significantly visible from adjoining properties, because 6-L.c= S 7#y • 5. The elements of the structure's designRE, [] ARE NOT consistent with the existing building's design, because 572 - G(SE 6. The proposed projects, [ ] IS NOT in proportion to other improvements on the subject site or to improvements on other properties in the neighborhood, because 5-70,41 7. The location of the proposed project [] WILL, LL NOT be detrimental to the use and enjoyment and value of adjacent property and neighborhood neighborhood, because "IAA/ye G--,1-44-0 TALe5E5 93J' 5C/ 57,AJ �'c,f c',w� e-- 8. T8. The proposed project's setbacks [ 0, [] DO NOT provide for adequate separation between improvements on the same or adjoining properties, because /1-,/doe e/e) f t . 4 i Ai D635•4;72 wee.h. •lIPA-F ?6c1 , • 9. OTHER FINDINGS D. ACTION b /APPROVAL [ ] APPROVAL SUBJECT TO THE FOLOWING CONDITION(S) [ ] DENIAL E. DATE OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD'S (COMMITTEE'S) ACTION F. BOARD (COMMI itE) MEMBERS) RENDERING THE ABOVE DECISION ,Lo,Qe-v 8,eie,r9-D -1-b 4/L)A- spa-1�ir✓ G. REPRESENTING THE 3/9J7 /c4I/7`,4 Com} 1Q ,1iFebelll4U 5 ASSOCIATION H. APPEALS Appeals from the Board's (Comiaittee's) decision shall be made to the Planning Commission. Anyone desiring to make such an appeal should contact the requirements, fees and proceedures. Said appeal must be made in writing and delivered to the Planning Department 240 W. Huntington Drive; Arcadia, CA 91006, within seven (7) working days of the- Be*ard's (Committee's) decision. I. EXPIRAT?ON OF APPROVAL If for a period of one (1) year from the date of approval, any project for which plane have been approved by the Board (Committee), has been unused, abandoned or discontinued, said approval shall become null and void and of no effect. 4 6 A ' August 30, 2018 `AylFO&v 1+, Ramy Zaifman { a 27 Tanners Road ii :� �». r7+ Great Neck, NY 11020 co\ �•• %a,t9 al 0° SUBJECT: Tree Permit for the Removal of a Healthy Protected Tree No. TRH 18-09; Revised Conditions of Approval per August 28, 2018 Planning Commission Meeting city of PROJECT ADDRESS: 111 Hacienda Drive Arcadia Dear Mr. Zaifman: At its August 28, 2018, meeting, the Planning Commission voted 4-0 with one Commissioner absent to DENY the appeal and uphold the Development Development Services Department approval of Healthy Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18- Services 09, a request to remove the five healthy Oak trees #9, 10, 11, 12, 13, and trees #3 and 8 per the submitted arborist report, subject to the following Department amended conditions: 1. The five (5) healthy Coast Live Oak trees shall not be removed until a grading and/or building permit has been issued for the construction of Jason Kruckeberg the new residence. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy Assistant City Manager/ permit for the new house, a total of three (3) replacement Coast Live Development Services Oak trees shall be planted in the front yard area of the subject Director property. The size and location of the trees shall be determined by the City's Certified Arborist, and approved by the Planning & Community Development Administrator or designee. A follow-up report shall be submitted to the City that the trees were planted. 2. If the property owner chooses not to pursue with the construction of the new house, the approval to remove the five (5) health Oak trees shall become null and void, and the property owner would be required to plant one 48-inch box tree within the front yard area for the removal of the diseased oak trees. The location shall be determined by a Certified Arborist and approved by the Planning & Community Development Administrator, or designee. A follow-up report shall be submitted to the City that the tree was planted prior to the expiration of this approval. 3. A Certified Arborist shall be on-site to monitor all activity taking place within the dripline of the oak trees to remain, and for the planting of the on-site replacement tree(s) and shall submit weekly monitoring reports to the Community Development Administrator, or designee. If the arborist determines that any inappropriate work has occurred, or that the tree(s) have been harmed, all work shall be stopped until adequate remediation has been performed.to the satisfaction of a certified arborist and the Community Development Administrator, or designee. 4. The applicant shall defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City of Arcadia and its officials, officers, employees, and agents from and 240 West Huntington Drive against any claim, action, or proceeding against the City of Arcadia, Post Office Box 60021 its officials, officers, employees or agents to attack, set aside, void, or Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 (626)574-5415 (626)447-3309 Fax www.ArcadiaCA.uov 1 � 1 annul any approval or conditional approval of the City of Arcadia concerning this project and/or land use decision, including but not limited to any approval or conditional approval of the City Council, Planning Commission, or City Staff, which action is brought within the time period provided for in Government Code Section 66499.37 or other provision of law applicable to this project or decision. The City shall promptly notify the applicant of any claim, action, or proceeding concerning the project and/or land use decision and the City shall cooperate fully in the defense of the matter. The City reserves the right, at its own option, to choose its own attorney to represent the City, its officials, officers, employees, and agents in the defense of the matter. 5. Within 30 calendar days after the decision for this project, the property owner/applicant shall execute and file with the Community Development Administrator or designee an Acceptance Form available from the Development Services Department to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. There is a ten (10) day appeal period from the date of the Planning Commission's decision. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Community Development Division with a $600.00 appeal fee by 4:30 p.m. on Friday, September 7, 2018. You will be notified if an appeal is filed. A building permit must be obtained prior to any construction activity. Please contact Building Services at (626) 574-5416 to determine the type of documentation, plans, and fees for the appropriate permit. This approval letter must be presented to Building Services to initiate the permitting process. Approval of TRH 18-09 shall not be of effect unless the property owner and applicant have executed and filed the enclosed Acceptance Form to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. The Acceptance form is due now and if it is not received by October 1, 2018, this approval will become null and void. You may visit the City's website at www.ArcadiaCA.clov/noticesanddecisions to view this notice. If you have any questions, please contact Peter Sun, Associate Planner at (626) 574- 5444, or by email at psun@ArcadiaCA.gov Sincerely, DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Community Development Division / Planning Services Peter Sun Associate Planner c: Lisa Flores, Planning & Development Services Administrator Dave Thompson, City of Arcadia Street Superintendent r I'.'. CITY OF ARCADIA ACCEPTANCE FORM Development Services Department Community Development Division-Planning Services 240 West Huntington Drive Arcadia, CA 91007 APPLICATION NO.: Health Protected Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18-09 SUBJECT PROPERTY: 111 Hacienda Drive I am/We are the applicant(s), and the owner(s), or th duly authorized representative(s) of the owner(s), respectively, of the project an real property that is the subject of the above application(s). I am/We are aware of, understand, and accept, all t e provisions and conditions imposed upon the project and real property that ' the subject of the above application(s), and also understand that noncomp ' nce with said provisions and conditions shall constitute grounds for the immedi- e suspension or revocation of any approvals granted through said application(s). I/We certify and declare under penalt of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE DATE PRINT NAME PROPERTY OWNER'S SIGNATUr DATE PRINT NAME Approval o' your application shall not be of effect unless the property owner and applican ave executed and filed this Acceptance Form to indicate awareness and ac• -ptance of these conditions of approval. The Acceptance form is due now . d if it is not received by Monday, October 1, 2018, this approval will bec'me null and void and all fees will be forfeited. Issued 8/30/18 i . 4e McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 March 1,2018 Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck,NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: Recently you contacted me concerning an Oak tree which was severely cut on your property located at I 1 1 Hacienda Drive,Arcadia. An Arborist Report was prepared and submitted on February 7, 2018. I was recently informed that the City has asked for the appraised value of the tree and a recommendation regarding the planting of Oak trees on the subject property equal to the assessed value of the tree. The subject tree was a 16 inch diameter Coast Live Oak. It was located just 7 feet east of the block wall along the west boundary.This is very close to the wall and in time would have damaged the wall.The tree was crowded by other nearby Oak trees causing it to lean and grow into the neighbor's back yard in a westerly direction. It was not visible from the street and the crown was unbalanced and asymmetrical. I took these factors into account while utilizing the Trunk Formula Method of Tree Appraisal.After carefully applying this formula I determined that the actual appraised value at the time of the severe tree cutting was$1,130.00.This value would be roughly equivalent to the planting of 4-24 inch-box size trees or 2-36 inch-box size trees. The area where the previous Oak was located would not be suitable for replacement tree planting for the reasons that I just stated. I am therefore recommending that the replacement Oak trees be concentrated near the rear or north boundary. There is no masonry wall there and the planting of additional trees in this area would assist in providing screening and privacy. Attached is a copy of the tree appraisal form. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or my office at(81 8)240-1358. Yours trul , William R. McKinley,Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants � a Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No 1 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1.Species Quercus agrifolia 2.Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3.Trunk Diameter Measured at 54"above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 16" 4.Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure. 30% 5.Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution= (30% site + 30%placement+ 30%contribution)_3= 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6.Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. 9.Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60"box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 • 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 862.00 a Group 3 tree 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4 4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 201 12.Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11)-Trunk area in 60" box(line 6) 177.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price(Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $13,954 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13)x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10) $1,130.23 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $1,130.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience. Inc Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 • McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 April 12,2018 Mr. Peter Sun, Associate Planner City of Arcadia 240 West Huntington Drive Arcadia,CA 91066 Dear Mr. Sun: Recently you contacted me concerning a 16 inch D.B.H. Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak tree which was severely cut on the property located at 111 Hacienda Drive,Arcadia. You requested some language concerning the replacement tree and its recommended planting location as well as planting and tree maintenance guidelines. The replacement Oak tree should be planted in the hack yard of the subject property approximately 60 feet easteof the west boundary block wait and ughlr -feet=soutl f the north boundary fence. The purpose of selecting this location is to provide additional screening and privacy along the north boundary. The replacement tree planting location will be marked with white landscape paint by the Project Arborist after consultation with the property owner. It is recommended that the replacement tree be a•24 inch-box size Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. At the planting site,the tree should be laid on its side and the bottom boards removed. The depth of the planting hole should be 3 inches less than the height of the root ball in the box/container. The excavation area should be one foot wider than the width of the box on all four sides.This is to allow enough room to cut the metal bands once the tree is in the planting hole.The planting hole area should be thoroughly wetted prior to planting. Once the metal bands are cut and removed then the wood box sides can be removed from the hole.The roots around the sides of the rootball must be roughened to allow them to break out into the native soil. After setting the tree in the hole the backfill soil can be placed around the sides of the rootball and planting hole and tamped to eliminate air pockets. No soil must be placed over the top of the tree's root ball. A berm should then be placed around the edge of the tree planting hole. The berm should be filled with water and allowed to drain. If the water drains quickly a second application of water may be needed. Automatic watering systems should replicate these conditions. Arborists and Environmental Consultants f 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 The tree should be supported by two lodgepole tree stakes placed on either side of the trunk near the edge of the rootball. Tree ties should be placed around the trunk above the scaffold limbs and attached to the tree stakes.The nursery stake which comes with the tree should be carefully removed.The berm around the tree should be filled twice per week for the first month and then once per week for the first year. The next 5 years the tree's berm should be watered one time per month. After a 5 year establishment period the tree should only receive water during the normal rainy season in drought conditions. Following establishment the tree should be mulched with a 2-4 inch layer of wood chips, wood shavings or landscape bark. Future pruning of the new replacement native Oak should be minimized. In some cases trees coming from the nursery may exhibit poor structure. It is best to correct any such defects when the tree is young. Minimize pruning and try to preserve the low-growing branches while the tree is young to assist is in developing good trunk taper. Coast Live Oaks should be pruned in the summer in hot,dry weather so that they do not contract Powdery Mildew or Witches Broom on the foliage. An I.S.A. Certified Arborist should perform all necessary pruning. Gardeners should not be employed to prune trees. They do not have the training,skills and equipment to prune trees correctly. It is understood from your email that the property owner shall be responsible for providing pictures to the City of Arcadia that the replacement tree was planted. The City requires that the photographs must be reoeiaredaariilein.96-derys. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(81 8)426-2432 or my office at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, K1:27A • / William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists . Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants r A ' August 30, 2018 ,Pao l+ ti ii! } Ramy Zaifman •? � 27 Tanners Road I li 0 r" Great Neck, NY 11020 o,� #�,,• 0m�,��r e�,.�° SUBJECT: Tree Permit for the Removal of a Healthy Protected Tree No. TRH 18-09; Revised Conditions of Approval per August 28, 2018 Planning Commission Meeting City of PROJECT ADDRESS: 111 Hacienda Drive Arcadia Dear Mr. Zaifman: At its August 28, 2018, meeting, the Planning Commission voted 4-0 with one Commissioner absent to DENY the appeal and uphold the Development Development Services Department approval of Healthy Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18- Services 09, a request to remove the five healthy Oak trees #9, 10, 11, 12, 13, and trees #3 and 8 per the submitted arborist report, subject to the following Department amended conditions: 1. The five (5) healthy Coast Live Oak trees shall not be removed until a grading and/or building permit has been issued for the construction of Jason Kruckeberg the new residence. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy Assistant City Manager/ permit for the new house, a total of three (3) replacement Coast Live Development Services Oak trees shall be planted in the front yard area of the subject Director property. The size and location of the trees shall be determined by the City's Certified Arborist, and approved by the Planning & Community Development Administrator or designee. A follow-up report shall be submitted to the City that the trees were planted. 2. If the property owner chooses not to pursue with the construction of the new house, the approval to remove the five (5) health Oak trees shall become null and void, and the property owner would be required to plant one 48-inch box tree within the front yard area for the removal of the diseased oak trees. The location shall be determined by a Certified Arborist and approved by the Planning & Community Development Administrator, or designee. A follow-up report shall be submitted to the City that the tree was planted prior to the expiration of this approval. 3. A Certified Arborist shall be on-site to monitor all activity taking place within the dripline of the oak trees to remain, and for the planting of the on-site replacement tree(s) and shall submit weekly monitoring reports to the Community Development Administrator, or designee. If the arborist determines that any inappropriate work has occurred, or that the tree(s) have been harmed, all work shall be stopped until adequate remediation has been performed to the satisfaction of a certified arborist and the Community Development Administrator, or designee. 4. The applicant shall defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City of Arcadia and its officials, officers, employees, and agents from and 240 West Huntington Drive against any claim, action, or proceeding against the City of Arcadia, Post Office Box 60021 its officials, officers, employees or agents to attack, set aside, void, or Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 (626)574-5415 (626)447-3309 Fax www.ArcadiaCA.¢ov annul any approval or conditional approval of the City of Arcadia concerning this project and/or land use decision, including but not limited to any approval or conditional approval of the City Council, Planning Commission, or City Staff, which action is brought within the time period provided for in Government Code Section 66499.37 or other provision of law applicable to this project or decision. The City shall promptly notify the applicant of any claim, action, or proceeding concerning the project and/or land use decision and the City shall cooperate fully in the defense of the matter. The City reserves the right, at its own option, to choose its own attorney to represent the City, its officials, officers, employees, and agents in the defense of the matter. 5. Within 30 calendar days after the decision for this project, the property owner/applicant shall execute and file with the Community Development Administrator or designee an Acceptance Form available from the Development Services Department to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. There is a ten (10) day appeal period from the date of the Planning Commission's decision. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Community Development Division with a $600.00 appeal fee by 4:30 p.m. on Friday, September 7, 2018. You will be notified if an appeal is filed. A building permit must be obtained prior to any construction activity. Please contact Building Services at (626) 574-5416 to determine the type of documentation, plans, and fees for the appropriate permit. This approval letter must be presented to Building Services to initiate the permitting process. Approval of TRH 18-09 shall not be of effect unless the property owner and applicant have executed and filed the enclosed Acceptance Form to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. The Acceptance form is due now and if it is not received by October 1, 2018, this approval will become null and void. You may visit the City's website at www.ArcadiaCA.qov/noticesanddecisions to view this notice. If you have any questions, please contact Peter Sun, Associate Planner at (626) 574- 5444, or by email at psun@ArcadiaCA.gov Sincerely, DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Community Development Division / Planning Services • • Peter Sun Associate Planner c: Lisa Flores, Planning & Development Services Administrator Dave Thompson, City of Arcadia Street Superintendent r CITY OF ARCADIA ACCEPTANCE FORM w/ Development Services Department Community Development Division-Planning Services 240 West Huntington Drive Arcadia, CA 91007 APPLICATION NO.: Healthy Protected Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18-09 SUBJECT PROPERTY: 111 Hacienda Drive I am/We are the applicant(s), and the owner(s), or the duly authorized representative(s) of the owner(s), respectively, of the project and real property that is the subject of the above application(s). I am/We are aware of, understand, and accept, all the provisions and conditions imposed upon the project and real property that is the subject of the above application(s), and also understand that noncompliance with said provisions and conditions shall constitute grounds for the immediate suspension or revocation of any approvals granted through said application(s). I/We certify and declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE DATE PRINT NAME PROPERTY OWNERS SIGNATURE DATE PRINT NAME Approval of your application shall not be of effect unless the property owner and applicant have executed and filed this Acceptance Form to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. The Acceptance form is due now and if it is not received by Monday, October 1, 2018, this approval will become null and void and all fees will be forfeited. Issued 8/30/18 • A ' July 5, 2018 Ramy Zaifman fti . 27 Tanners Road . Great Neck, NY 11020 \ �j 'Num Y,c�°� SUBJECT: Tree Permit for the Removal of a Healthy Protected Tree No. TRH 18-04 City of PROJECT ADDRESS: 111 Hacienda Drive Dear Mr. Zaifman: Arcadia The public comment period for the Notice of Pending Decision for the above mentioned application ended on April 4, 2018. The Development Services Department received several phone calls and emails regarding the removal Development of the protected Coast Live Oak tree from neighbors who were concerned Services about the removal of a healthy tree that had been in their neighborhood for years. Department As required for each protected tree application, the Development Services Department (Department) requires an arborist report to be submitted with the application. The report, along with comments received from the neighbors, is Jason Kruckeberg the basis for the Department's determination for the application. In addition, Assistant City Manager/ site visits may be required to get a better understanding the request being Development Services considered. Unfortunately, the tree requested to be removed, a 16-inch Director diameter Coast Live Oak was topped prior to the submittal of the application and arborist report. Once contacted, the property owner submitted the required application and arborist report. The report indicated that due to the damage caused by the unpermitted cutting/pruning of the tree, severe and irreparable damage had been done and the only reasonable alternative was the complete removal of the tree. Therefore, given the circumstance, the Department has conditionally approved the request to legalize the unpermitted partial removal of the tree. The application is subject to the following conditions: 1. Due to the number of existing oak trees on the lot, one replacement 36" box Coast Live Oak tree shall be planted in the back yard of the subject property. The tree shall be planted per the arborist report's recommendation approximately 60 feet east of the west boundary block wall and roughly 6 feet south of the north boundary fence. The arborist shall be on site to mark the location and to monitor the planting of the tree. The tree shall be planted prior to issuance of certificate of occupancy for the proposed new house; a follow-up report shall also be submitted to the City. 2. If the applicant does not move forward with the construction of the new house, the tree shall be removed and replaced with a replacement tree as specified in Condition No. 1 by January of 2019. 3. The tree shall be removed during the demolition process of the existing house and associated structures as part of the construction 240 West Huntington Drive process for the new proposed house. Post Office Box 60021 Arcadia,CA 91066-6021 (626)574-5415 (626)447-3309 Fax www.ArcadiaCA.uov 4. The applicant shall defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City of Arcadia and its officials, officers, employees, and agents from and against any claim, action, or proceeding against the City of Arcadia, its officials, officers, employees or agents to attack, set aside, void, or annul any approval or conditional approval of the City of Arcadia concerning this project and/or land use decision, including but not limited to any approval or conditional approval of the City Council, Planning Commission, or City Staff, which action is brought within the time period provided for in Government Code Section 66499.37 or other provision of law applicable to this project or decision. The City shall promptly notify the applicant of any claim, action, or proceeding concerning the project and/or land use decision and the City shall cooperate fully in the defense of the matter. The City reserves the right, at its own option, to choose its own attorney to represent the City, its officials, officers, employees, and agents in the defense of the matter. 5. Within 30 calendar days after the decision for this project, the property owner/applicant shall execute and file with the Community Development Administrator or designee an Acceptance Form available from the Development Services Department to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. There is a 10 working-day appeal period from the date of the approval. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Community Development Division with a $600.00 appeal fee by 5:30 p.m. on Monday, July 16, 2018. You will be notified if an appeal is filed. The purpose of the enclosed Acceptance Form is to indicate awareness and acceptance of these conditions of approval. The Acceptance form is due now and shall be submitted to the City no later than 30 days from the decision date. You may visit the City's website at www.ArcadiaCA.qov/noticesanddecisions to view this notice. If you have any questions, please contact Peter Sun, Associate Planner at (626) 574-5444, or by email at psun@ArcadiaCA.gov Sincerely, DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Community Development Division / Planning Services 171141 ' Peter Sun Associate Planner c: George Raptis, raptisg@caciqueinc.com Marlene Arevalo, grandmar9810@gmail.com Lisa Flores, Planning Services Manager Dave Thompson, City of Arcadia Street Superintendent r . q tAii McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 March 1,2018 Mr.Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck,NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: Recently you contacted me concerning an Oak tree which was severely cut on your property located at I 1 1 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia. An Arborist Report was prepared and submitted on February 7, 2018. I was recently informed that the City has asked for the appraised value of the tree and a recommendation regarding the planting of Oak trees on the subject property equal to the assessed value of the tree. The subject tree was a 16 inch diameter Coast Live Oak. It was located just 7 feet east of the block wall along the west boundary.This is very close to the wall and in time would have damaged the wall. The tree was crowded by other nearby Oak trees causing it to lean and grow into the neighbor's back yard in a westerly direction. It was not visible from the street and the crown was unbalanced and asymmetrical. I took these factors into account while utilizing the Trunk Formula Method of Tree Appraisal. After carefully applying this formula I determined that the actual appraised value at the time of the severe tree cutting was$1,130.00.This value would be roughly equivalent to the planting of 4-24 inch-box size trees or 2-36 inch-box size trees. The area where the previous Oak was located would not be suitable for replacement tree planting for the reasons that I just stated. I am therefore recommending that the replacement Oak trees be concentrated near the rear or north boundary. There is no masonry wall there and the planting of additional trees in this area would assist in providing screening and privacy. Attached is a copy of the tree appraisal form. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or my office at(818)240-1358. Yours trul , ....e..Ati/fr,_ ie 9775 William R. McKinley,Consulting Arborist • American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A �j International Society of Arboriculture. Arborists and Environmental Consultants fF f[f t , Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 1 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1.Species Quercus agrifolia 2.Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3.Trunk Diameter Measured at 54"above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 16" 4.Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure. 30% 5.Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution= (30%site+ 30%placement+ 30%contribution)_ 3= 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6.Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1 482 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. 8.Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. 9.Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 964 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. $2, HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim,CA Sept.,2001 10.Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $62.00 a Group 3 tree. 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 201 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60"box) Trunk area of subject tree(Line 11)-Trunk area in 60"box(line 6) 177.25 13.Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price(Line 10)+ Installed tree cost(Line 9) $13,954 14.Appraised Value Basic tree Dost(Line 13)x Species rating(Line 2)x Condition rating(Line 4)x Locs}tion Rating(Line 5).(Note:we generally round to the nearest$10). $1,130.23 Notes:Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is$1,130.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 r � 40 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 April 12,2018 Mr. Peter Sun, Associate Planner City of Arcadia 240 West Huntington Drive Arcadia,CA 91066 Dear Mr. Sun: Recently you contacted me concerning a 16 inch D.B.H. Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak tree which was severely cut on the property located at 111 Hacienda Drive,Arcadia. You requested some language concerning the replacement tree and its recommended planting location as well as planting and tree maintenance guidelines. The replacement Oak tree should be planted in the-backyard of the subject property eppcwcimetely44 feet eastra the.wst bo+u1ary bloek•wail andN eugliar6--feet=south.of $ie north boundary fence, The purpose of selecting this location is to provide additional screening and privacy along the north boundary. The replacement tree planting location will be marked with white landscape paint by the Project Arborist after consultation with the property owner. It is recommended that the replacement tree be a624 inch-hox oizeQuercus-s ifvlia or Coast Live Oak. At the planting site,the tree should be laid on its side and the bottom boards removed.The depth of the planting hole should be 3 inches less than the height of the root ball in the box/container.The excavation area should be one foot wider than the width of the box on all four sides. This is to allow enough room to cut the metal bands once the tree is in the planting hole. The planting hole area should be thoroughly wetted prior to planting. Once the metal bands are cut and removed then the wood box sides can be removed from the hole. The roots around the sides of the rootball must be roughened to allow them to break out into the native soil. After setting the tree in the hole the backfill soil can be placed around the sides of the rootball and planting hole and tamped to eliminate air pockets. No soil must be placed over the top of the tree's root ball. A berm should then be placed around the edge of the tree planting hole. The berm should be filled with water and allowed to drain. If the water drains quickly a second application of water may be needed. Automatic watering systems should replicate these conditions. Arborists and Environmental Consultants - c-. �� cK nley 8. Assoc. la Les (818) 240-1358 The tree should be supported by two lodgepole tree stakes placed on either side of the trunk near the edge of the rootball. Tree ties should be placed around the trunk above the scaffold limbs and attached to the tree stakes. The nursery stake which comes with the tree should be carefully removed.The berm around the tree should be filled twice per week for the first month and then once per week for the first year.The next 5 years the tree's berm should be watered one time per month. After a 5 year establishment period the tree should only receive water during the normal rainy season in drought conditions. Following establishment the tree should be mulched with a 2-4 inch layer of wood chips, wood shavings or landscape bark. Future pruning of the new replacement native Oak should be minimized. In some cases trees coming from the nursery may exhibit poor structure. It is best to correct any such defects when the tree is young. Minimize pruning and try to preserve the low-growing branches while the tree is young to assist is in developing good trunk taper. Coast Live Oaks should be pruned in the summer in hot,dry weather so that they do not contract Powdery Mildew or Witches Broom on the foliage. An I.S.A. Certified Arborist should perform all necessary pruning. Gardeners should not be employed to prune trees.They do not have the training,skills and equipment to prune trees correctly. It is understood from your email that the property owner shall be responsible for providing pictures to the City of Arcadia that the replacement tree was planted.The City requires that the photographs must.awaeasis+eda+within 9 days. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or my office at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, William R.McKinley,Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree Protection Plan 111 Hacienda Drive Arcadia, California Prepared for: Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck, NY 11020 Prepared by: William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist #WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture 1734 Del Valle Avenue Glendale, CA 91208 Arborists and Environmental Consultants 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 September 20, 2018 Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck,NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: Recently Peter Sun, City of Arcadia contacted me concerning a tree protection plan for your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia. I was asked to review the plans and prepare a Tree Protection Plan for all the Oak and Sycamore trees located on or near the subject property. This report is a supplement to the original Arborist Report. The following report summarizes my findings: Background On Monday, September 10, 2018 at 1:30 p.m. I met with Todd Bowden, General Contractor to walk the site with the proposed building plans and identify proposed encroachment areas near the Oak and Sycamore trees on the site. The Tree/Site Inspection Section describes my observations concerning the subject trees. Tree/Site Inspection Tree#1—There will be no impact to this Coast Live Oak. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline or approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. Tree#0P2—The proposed new driveway will encroach to within 8 feet of this Coast Live Oak tree's trunk on the northeast side. The new driveway will be excavated 8 inches from the existing grade. The impact to the tree is moderate. Minor root pruning may be involved.No pruning of the tree's crown is required. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 20 feet from the tree's trunk however once work in this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to within 6 feet from the tree's trunk on the east side. Tree#3—This diseased, declining,hazardous Coast Live Oak will be removed by permit.No tree protection fencing is required. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 1 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#4—The new driveway will be installed 16 feet west of the Coast Live Oak's trunk. The existing paving surrounding the Oak will be removed. Minor walkway work will take place within the dripline. Minor twig pruning of the tree canopy may be required over the new driveway. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 30 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#5—The existing driveway will be removed within the dripline of this Coast Live Oak. The existing house will be removed. A new house and footings will be installed in the same general location within the dripline of this Oak. No pruning will be required. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 28 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#0P6—The existing house will be removed and the new house and footing will be 2 feet west of the current house location.No pruning will be required. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 25 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk on the west side of the tree. The south fence area can remain. Tree#7—Coast Live Oak will be preserved. The existing house and patio areas on the south and west sides of the tree will be removed. A new house and courtyard area will be constructed within the dripline of the tree. The new house will be 16 feet away.No pruning will be required. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 25 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#8—Coast Live Oak is diseased and dying. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#9—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#10—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 2 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#11 —Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia. No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#12—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia. No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#13—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia. No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#14—Coast Live Oak will not be encroached upon. The northeast corner of the new house will begin at a point 14 feet from the tree's trunk.No pruning will be necessary. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 12 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to 10 feet from the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#15—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 37 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#16—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed. There is a 12 inch stem which grows low over the existing lawn which will require pruning back to allow 8 feet of clearance. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 28 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#17—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed. The tree is located 2 feet northwest of the old shed. The existing shed will be removed. Minor pruning will be necessary to trim small twigs and branches to provide clearance on the west side of the tree for the proposed cabana. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 32 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 3 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#18—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 14 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#19—California Sycamore is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the driplines of the surrounding trees. This tree is within the tree protection fencing perimeter. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#20—California Sycamore is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the driplines of the surrounding trees. This tree is within the tree protection fencing perimeter. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#21—Coast Live Oak will be encroached upon. The footing for the cabana measuring 12 inches by 12 inches will encroach to within 10 feet of the trunk. Minor twig pruning will be necessary to provide clearance for the proposed cabana building. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 20 feet from the trunk. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be moved back to a point 6 feet from the trunk allow access to construct the cabana. Tree#22—Coast Live Oak will be encroached upon. The proposed cabana will encroach to within 12 feet from the trunk.No pruning will be necessary. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 15 feet from the trunk. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be moved back to a point 8 feet from the trunk allow access to construct the cabana. Tree#23—Coast Live Oak will be encroached upon. The proposed cabana will encroach to within 17 feet from the trunk on the northeast side of the tree. Minor twig pruning will be necessary to provide clearance for the proposed cabana building. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 24 feet from the trunk. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be moved back on the northeast side to a point 12 feet from the trunk allow access to construct the cabana. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 4 Ole McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 General Observations The subject property appears to have been part of an Oak Woodland Plant Community prior to development. The trees growing on or near the subject property are primarily native Coast Live Oak with a few native California Sycamore trees. The proposed new single family home construction will require the removal of 5 healthy Coast Live Oak trees by permit from the City of Arcadia. These include: Tree#9, Tree#10, Tree#11, Tree#12 and Tree#13. There will be 2 unhealthy Coast Live Oaks removed from this property. They are Tree#3 and Tree#8. The Coast Live Oak which was previously severely cut back will be removed as per the City's direction and a replacement 36 inch- box size Coast Live Oak will be planted in the back yard approximately 60 feet east of the west boundary block wall and roughly 6 feet east of the west boundary fence as per the City of Arcadia, Development Services Department letter dated July 5, 2018; Healthy Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18-04. The City of Arcadia,Development Services letter dated August 30,2018 states that approval of Healthy Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18- 09 for five healthy trees#9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 and unhealthy trees#3 and 8 is approved with the condition that 3 replacement Coast Live Oak trees be planted in the front yard. The size and location of these replacement trees shall be determined by the City's Certified Arborist. I have spoken with the landscape architect and have reviewed the proposed landscape plan and it appears that the proposed design and improvements will not adversely affect the health of the existing native Oak and Sycamore trees. Recommendation Based upon my inspection of the subject trees and property it is my professional opinion that the proposed new single family home and improvements have been designed in such a way as to minimize the numbers of trees required to be removed. Just 5 out of 23 trees will be removed due to conflicts with the new house design. The other 2 trees to be removed are diseased, unhealthy and are dying. Their removal is completely unrelated to the proposed construction. In addition to the tree protection fencing requirements already stated earlier in this report I would recommend that the following tree protection measures be implemented during construction: 1) Install tree protection fencing around Oak and Sycamore trees to be preserved prior to commencement of work and maintain fencing in a vertical,upright condition throughout the construction period. 2) Minimize excavation and trenching within the drip line of the protected trees. 3) Roots which are cut or otherwise damaged should be pruned to the side of the excavation with a clean, sharp pruning tool and kept covered with burlap and wetted daily until the excavation area can be backfilled. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 5 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Recommendation-Continued 4) Minimize storage of building materials and equipment within the drip line of the Oak and Sycamore trees in order to minimize soil compaction. 5) Prohibit dumping of foreign substances such as excess soil,concrete,cement, stucco,paint, etc. within the drip line of the trees. 6) Designate an area outside the drip line of the trees to clean and wash equipment so as not to impact the root zones of the protected trees. 7) Pruning of limbs and branches of trees shall be performed by a State Licensed Tree Contractor under the supervision of an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. 8) All pruning shall comply with ANSI A-300 Pruning Standards and Best Management Practices. 9) An I.S.A. Certified Arborist should be hired to oversee and supervise all work within the drip line of the remaining protected Oak and Sycamores. 10)The recommended size for the 3 replacement Coast Live Oak trees in the front yard of the subject property is a 24 inch-box size tree. This size is the most commonly planted size landscape tree because it is large enough to stand virtually on its own and the root ball is much larger and more well-developed than smaller size trees. This size also establishes quicker and out performs larger trees in a short period of time. Summary/Conclusion In conclusion, it is my professional opinion that in order to build the proposed new single family home it will be necessary to remove 5 healthy Coast Live Oak trees from the subject property. It is my understanding that a Healthy Protected Tree Removal Permit will be issued under the condition that 3 replacement Coast Live Oak trees will be planted in the front of the subject property. The size and location of the replacement trees will be determined by the City Certified Arborist. A proposed replacement tree planting plan is included at the end of this report. There will also be 2 unhealthy, diseased, dying trees removed through the issuance of an Unhealthy Protected Tree Removal Permit. The Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 6 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Summary/Conclusion-Continued Coast Live Oak which was partially cut down will be removed under a City Healthy Protected Tree Removal Permit with the condition that a 36 inch-box size replacement Coast Live Oak tree be planted in the back yard. The proposed improvements will encroach upon most of the dripline areas of the remaining Oak and Sycamore trees. Once work commences in these areas it will be necessary to move the tree protection fencing in order to perform the required work. The proposed landscape plan has been carefully studied and reviewed by the landscape architect and project arborist and this design should not adversely affect the health of the Oak and Sycamore trees. All construction work within the driplines of the Oak and Sycamore tree will be supervised and monitored by the project I.S.A. Certified Arborist. If the above stated recommendations and tree protection measures are followed and complied with then the remaining trees should survive and contribute to the value of the subject property and surrounding neighborhood for many years to come. Limitations Information contained in this report covers only those areas that were examined and reflects the condition of those areas at the time of inspection. The inspection was limited to visual examination of accessible areas without excavation,drilling or boring. Arboriculture is not an exact science and there is much that is still to be learned about trees. The observations and recommendations provided in this report reflect the latest research,knowledge and training available through university and professional research. There is no warranty or guarantee, expressed or implied, that problems or deficiencies of the trees or property in question may not arise in the future. Thank you for the opportunity to serve you and your environmental and horticultural needs. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or you may call my office phone at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, 02// .c..- • William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 7 I Pyywi o F1ISTNC SEES .VECYEN MEC WrikIFN 91HUB5_k SCRFFNS. (MAID COVERS. • [gin',•PFSs AAD ri f, - ENPS E..)!7R. "MAORE:R' - '}Prcu,o rz W' - ( yr U ).we nnE . -i3 EAE.TALO TEAT wd lANA»A M7 3 u� T�7..._ 1 Re'•w5 Np1ED�MAN 1p .� Sva nxr! » r(DTSI 7i(�Ni��nDiNF.4��RAv�wl�l»E�A.»Iul `AUEwA �i C E.� f,�� (naY UM) B. LJ ,r 1101 A-olANWA— / / SEK I6AC US TASK SivE-S,PEM' R":=L PO.W - 0C[ ON .--..._. 36101.01110CA,TORO 28.1716'ER611nG IRE.(C DASNED 36 t !RFO. LESE RARE M) 'D. IS•.IFN.�b-LIA00.BO[UOIVL,No U s Gl INt-[fu`'$N,[o=g,No (BACK YARD) JAPONICA (.�.\ j LNFS)10 BYCl MROV(wDi ON * 13'OM i rMiigwi=NM)O SDKI WNS AE O.MOD(u) x e.r .i• COYER N fTh„„.. .'gftM�w TEO sEms�E w-1�"__ ® via-��wWtvA�l .. i• CAILON rovuwFs T9T_.»vpa Y • GM O TS.L._.NOly1111%04112-1'-' x AE Al• ol IPOn=OOR) res:-h(mn....kw v�� 0 racaucp.ylNa}cAn*ur_c� ,---_,..,....„7_,„... ® 3-� I;7 RtiM O ;, --`. (x )— ilk :•;=uu�'�1�A�p�aP T 0 Tr.RFNlNr: wOEn(1) J� 3r6cT'owAM xEw LEAS.,y�0[�Ax M '1'-..moi t��'�• 0 lbw,1 vA,AMEE 4,1 UTE Tuc(./u) * s sAA. :4Sg (e iE�Rafcx (D eKS EON SPARuiI _ (N)E 1N.OWE FOCOCAN(w)OM C1w110.10 (()t5•C•R 10:012,....11.1641:4.,,\ _(A)LO.OAR N 11171001001 n'Mm REN. »OFY IONi \ •wxRVRON'<`A� (EI OAR TO Kw. •i) r_(N)36•N w1 FENCE (N)36-F MI FENCE7), 1[)OAR TR¢TD (()pAx TREE t0 REYtlN.OV 3'�y / l�',MAI DAO ROun ,`1 RE NCI P[A tl1A.L`w Dar ROLE' it-- \ - oI H xcw HA GRAVEL 0,Da.SONE (E)SRYIAY TO!C wCNDVEO ®/�� �� . rt- Aup•DE K "."':--7-t --- 11D YMRO / »()%YIFMNVOAMEI COvtR AW . ... Sp. ' SCREEN FRW S�¢iiU PaOVDO (R)•1"Er mob DECK • G..a s�/: / i+_0 \' .i ii a3W �A WVsise OF !� W ✓ti + p p,,p,g, T''' A+ t +7�\_ V fit�i c —�� CI y E_. a••�• a 0�0<F' •+ Ir ,r e\l`N i. 41! t_It! '4�!4-1.$.1: .r-(rnr '13C, sas,a°p'� R(u01 MOrOAC•E»uus.+C AND (a oRAxGE TREE ro aEUAw- Z. .i. _ �s Nf¢ At►!�• IEA „Z COVER PARMwv LAW.ARO 1 GALLON P-.4,-,,L .. F=;r : w H �'-� v 4 41i-7.: ,..31. aa• p•r� 'Au NEW DO 6 w1.KNEE 1-* ;(T 5 -.4 N 1 • EI o¢s roteE 7 �—'�- as j Ii.y tEl oAN r0 Rrww'N N [ '�4�[[R [[ ( 11 l�_q, 1 (n7 NaE:AI.AR CJT TX: I.. C'C t [�1 Re Y�$ ., 3 -{IIF IMFRu1i -� ....1, .- y„'-e::d '�_E �6� 1 Iw01CCiIW ZONE ¢ SFOxE AROUND!AA•VA- ;..A0164 w.f ..w '+Tv ` _ ....... A^{��6 ,� 3 C SPF < R ` iF r` ; �I, I }_ 'l AA,, VR 'pe� .r� li ” •- o-.S ..5-r' I r q A J ,,.. ol..,...,1.,.„.... see a": 1 N - I •''.� •AI:'A r � e, .I� it a',�t•4 .w rf, a - a• stft1 r 3 , (E)OM it,KM , , . t— En� ,'OPE .S '�F)I F L txy S 1 • 1 tR rs FI ,.�_- s�z Dw i Rw TO —�-7.-;."1:17:-:,,;,". A le ,--....s_710„ 5 ( _.. -.a iaapip d (A>Ruud SPA TO RE FUMED / ` i#1 1E. �. ". ♦ DE.o � (o f r� . 4K�a� .."-` .M COKO CABANA'S fRRSN FECON—' w (( MC. ♦YR i 3. ••-7 ) -1 •{r 1 '� Fq 47. �-- ;. -^'T? OEYAMNO � 1104 • .. a'aa EFS- :tia I , y' 4c 0, ...: 1.17•••1 r..,l G'akdr�R' :_ ;T -RS� .1 � aM-h'A.;... - w.•,*at 7.aeok eir,**vol.-Aa+.t/w..w:n©wE,_.ell.-7...--,..,-:'_. ...a.oFsa ooe.-s.e"e� w.. (E)OAR To 1(wea, •.. .r • .,. r Mai OP K)I'' A / »R _ -1 (�)Po noN o s1E.D DRVEwAor AND (x)uuECH(Dw IOx[)OZnEAM ONt BE MuOVFD� ( [D R MF ES 1RC[S CA$OPr EINI»D CABANA (E)UEb OAR N1M SCREEN NEDOF ANO mRia0 new C NCL.DItiAWAv T OR)ta/1,1.OCN PA WA (N1 POO[pE[N.M 0'ARRFGK (f) r MFx.. (N)AurC SwNO OATS (E)OAR 10 RERAN NRF Siem BEIFEE»A.A-ct.1 YAB S•R'ODS 10 MRPEYOVEO- • (N)wlDLLct»PAWN NMI MING DAR TOPES TO LE s fBw ro PLu•w wM ROMAN VAN NLYMOO w +LW Pc"mc•aNA wt•wEP,d r COMC 11.000K COURTYARD SPACE ESPALIER KO. (*)l0TERD1r ME a-0 Of lN)AUEOETAIAE GARDEN SET N sMPS DRR 2018 1_..,,(:,,t;,,, TWO TREES ... F,(a tt' SINGLE FAMILY HOUSE N,- s.LT a DES GN, INC. w�M M , •...___. CONCEPTUAL C 4 ! _'t " so " -t LANDSCAPE PLAN L..�.,,, - .. ..••, ill HACIENDA RD. Tn•w'-r .- I1.7..=::.1... .........n ARCADIA.CA . . 1 . 1 1 011t MEM,IIIIff ,- . 1 i ... 1-- 1 X•' -Al \ , ii#,T=1:114,400.V. •.8' ( .1;:.',1' ,,,/. : 4-;1-; -,*4 ..;;;‘' [1 : , i- - ‘,.., 4.4S -T.' ' •"').:1.!",t91 1:1: ,lripol lrl' ' - '• h 'itil V.. '''--; ' • -rmi ' DO:' , f::.i:::-...7.:...: i:::-:i. '-. ck 'z', ' .../z. *eivr maiwir 0m ' '-iii.14.i:5-,7`i-..-e.tritt-fr--ITI ''' : .---1 .'''— -- 'V 7: - .• Kr-" '1.111 • N1 7 ii11,1iit4(A'''1 1 '.tti , '1 ,:'.4i•-- .' -'-, :—--ir f, noFo.os P.e1 Ir4e4..,.Ow -t , ._-,-,..--,--,.;. -.---1. . -ill, . . __ . :: ,_,... ..,t; ......,--1,........, ,r. ,,, ..... 1 1 — ORNAMEI — 201 OAK / 70' VERaGE ®F willik �Ktlry �c�!) N-111 SCREEN . moor , _,__,_, ,......., ,..,..„. ,,,,.......„, ,,„..... .ff..,._..imm_._.._......._...,..................__._,.......„.___,,7;,_ irlocirtfliw_ ---4c , ,.., _.....i.___.„ ...... ... ........ ....,; ...,.... ,„,• ,., ,,, .......milwidi)111,1 ,t, % ,' ,''•.;"' • ' •.'' • ,' .'OW • .• ) 14•* • 1 . v..0 . ,...4., No, ..14.!...'s,&, . 0-)t„,..111),.....: - -, ii , Alla ipit.wort et 0 .' • % : .' - .- • .' • '' • lith if 4" 'itii e is_--_*- • , iltibriiitt-or.41tItt oPP,..... 19profPikol . ..- . .,.. ,.. . -. .,10. ...0Ai.(- .10 ,, to 0 kl,:#4,....tt, ,), • .,_.... .. - =toil. . � PEA GRAVEL � 49 e, P ** o „ • Oil '�01 *ter t Pita .*de • 9 +, ._ - _.-. , - o* * I (N) 6' POOL 1• .,0"' Qd;�e. Jik,t i�dP' fi'.'.. • A` • r`m. 'lE" SAFE FENCE °in Ci�ilir gi ea. . i1�, . � �C t/� ;_ �r� ga•�t''",; .moo°ewe .. dik . ... .. `.:`••.. . ,-g. * *�C,- 01..0,0.( r•is Ambin • iiip:rAi.,s.1.4,6: .0.57-00sir t • • •.. '1(� -T.. . .. ) )11-iionsegoviiii 533 -�•,aEfial . '.'. • . ` ,0 Are t = :.....---- C:1• s • - :' A •• 1.°ell* low:4i _ch7.7, ,• \ oblite:eoce., _nu! a hil,......vvo - - - - - - '- -0, * *--• ._ 9111111111!..... tra -11)"� t. w . . . • . 'F . . * w + i ` : 1.0.e . 1 = sS �W . . w . wa. '. . , \., Jima 10 A. 43,. .. ie, ,i �g7 ' .'...".4 '...f., 4.4 Y. 9. * 7_ lk1 '".... Lif.f), litfil •. 11,..44114j„,......1111./1:11, • * ••• * v., * *,„ ,.„ . . . .0; 4, ,. 11.11 , ,: . w w . t . . - . . v a . . y i !� 4.J.'_:r,M�. •.. - ``• v ._ "•_. +•- 1 -.i i e °� • . . . r 0s• '+ -t ^(E) OAK w F_ � tik { a3 •0..: . • • �{ • • 94D2) Mrl. • 4. it" � ,►� .r. •a -,,. ,. . 04. a . . . • . ... . •i ! 4 4 IN IliallaVII 1011111*111 ilitillimillillif ' ''' 4 immotaniiir.;13111111I alieuvrimilairattlitif.:1,11516,10, ':', ,‘,.., :, .., 'T..;. ,:',.1,..,:4' ,7.,, ,,_ 4' .11 , ..,,:: ,. , 111 I MEI .�a. ■ air _ � .-", •• • � . s �•.--,-.:,. .... .:2:,,;..,„....,....:.,,,, ,. . - .:., , �1 / • f�� D1 {��^� .--.4.7,...-4.9....-..,..01,- �r-{f;' �d .� �: �tdy _ 1 Curriculum Vitae WILLIAM R.MCKINLEY—MCKINLEY & ASSOCIATES 1734 Del Valle Ave. Email: william@mckinleyarborists.com Work (818)426-2432 Glendale,CA 91208 Website:http://wwrw.mckinleytn•boristsconn/ Home(818)240-1358 SUMMARY of QUALIFICATIONS Practicing Consulting Arborist.Member of American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA).Certified Arborist,International Society of Arboriculture since September 30, 1999.I.S.A.Arborist#WE-4578A. Recognized Oak Tree Expert throughout Southern California.Prepare arborist reports for developers, homeowners and attorneys.Assess the landscape value of trees.Assess and identify hazardous trees in the landscape.Provided hillside and Oak Woodland landscape and irrigation recommendations.Provide expert witness testimony on arboriculture related cases.Public speaker and presenter at community service group meetings,homeowner's association meetings and speaker at professional seminars and conferences. Presenter at Trees,People and Our Urban Environment Seminar,March 2002.Arbor Day Guest Speaker, City of Glendale,March 2005.Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2010,Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2012,Arbor Day Guest Speaker,Glendale,March 2014. FULL TIME EMPLOYMENT HISTORY City of Glendale,Parks,Recreation & Community Services Park Services Manager-Contract Administration 2001-present Performs contract administration for Park Services Section.Manage grounds maintenance for sports fields, community buildings,parks,medians,and historic areas.Administers the City's landscape maintenance contract.Writes contract specifications.Administers the bidding process.Awards contracts to successful bidders.Conducts construction meetings and oversees the construction and inspection for these projects. Performs and assumes all former duties and responsibilities under the former Administrative Analyst position.Writes arborist reports.Hazardous tree assessment.Serves as expert witness in tree related cases. Administrative Analyst 1988-2001 Administer landscape maintenance contract for medians,reservoirs,pump houses and misc.areas. Administer and supervise the Division's Work Management System involving the scheduling and tracking of work and performance of over 50 full-time employees.Supervise one part-time data entry employee and supervise and coordinate with the California Conservation Corps,Boy Scouts and other community service volunteers in the parks.Supervise,monitor and report water and utility usage in the parks.Administer and supervise all tree planting projects and programs including the Arbor Day and Urban Forest Donation programs.Assist with budget preparation and acquisition of capital equipment.Prepare Capital Improvement Project specifications and assist with administering contracts.Administer the City of Glendale's Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Coordinate with Planning,Permit Services,Engineering, Building,Neighborhood Services and Fire Department to insure the care and protection of trees,both during and after construction. Review grading,construction,landscape and irrigation plans.Modify and approve plans as necessary to protect indigenous trees.Perform field inspections on hazardous trees and make recommendations to park staff and the public.Serve as code enforcement officer and paralegal during Administrative Office Hearings regarding Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Perform tree and landscape appraisals.Served as special show and marketing consultant to the Glendale Rose Pruning and Garden Show Committee. Assistant Planner-Parks 1983-1988 Assisted in park inventory development and implementation of the Work Management System.Served as guest speaker at the National Parks and Recreation Conference on the subject of computers and their role in park maintenance.Supervised the Capital Improvement Project Construction at Pacific Park and Brand Park.Coordinated with and supervised California Conservation Corps.Crews in planting,staking and tying hundreds of trees as part of the Arbor Day Program.Served as Arbor Day Co-Chairman,Glendale Rose Pruning&Garden Show Co-Chairman and President of Glendale Beautiful.Served as Ways and Means Chairman C.P.R.S.District XIV. F EDUCATION 1983 California Polytechnic University,Pomona Bachelor of Science Degree, Park Administration Graduated Magna Cum Laude,Grade Point Average:3.57 1983-Present CEU's-University of California,Landscape Contract Maintenance,Hazardous Tree Identification&Assessment,Specimen Tree Appraisal,Advanced Tree Appraisal Theory and Practice,Tree and Landscape Liability—Trees and the Law. Oak Tree Symposium Graduate,Knowledge of oak tree physiology and native plant habitat.ASCA 2007 Consulting Academy, National Arbor Day Foundation Graduate,Symposiums: Construction Around Trees;Trees and the Law.Recognized Tree Expert:City of Los Angles,County of Los Angeles,City of Pasadena.City of La Canada Flintridge,City of Burbank,City of Calabasas,County of Ventura,City of Santa Clarita. HONORS &ACTIVITIES 1999 - Present- Certified Arborist-International Society of Arboriculture 1996-1999-Secretary/Treasurer, C.P.R.S.Park Operations Section 1994-1995 - President, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1994-1995- Treasurer, Glendale Beautification Advisory Council 1992-1994 -Treasurer, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1993, 1994, 1995 C.P.R.S.Park Operations Scholarship First,Second and Third Year,Graduate,Pacific Southwest Maintenance Mgmt.School 1988-1990—President,Glendale Beautiful 1980, 1981 - Twice placed on Dean's Honor List 1982 - Who's Who in American Colleges and Universities 1978 - Recipient of Wayne Striker Memorial Scholarship 1975 - Awarded Eagle Scout Rank,Boy Scouts of America Member- American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA) Member - International Society of Arboriculture Member - Western Chapter,International Society of Arboriculture Member—Glendale Beautiful Past Member - National Arbor Day Foundation Past Member - California Oak Foundation REFERENCES Randall S.Stamen,Attorney/Arborist (951)787-9788 Susan&Gary Sims,Sims Tree Specialists (951)685-6662 Peter&Diana Harnisch,Harnisch Tree Care (626)444-7997 PROFESSIONAL SERVICE FEE Site Inspection - $100.00 per hour Consultation - $125.00 per hour Arborist Report - $150.00 per hour Public Hearing - $200.00 per hour Arbitration - $225.00 per hour Deposition - $250.00 per hour Court Witness - $350.00 per hour .. 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Arborist Report 111 Hacienda Drive Arcadia, California Prepared for: Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck, NY 11020 Prepared by: William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist #WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture 1734 Del Valle Avenue Glendale, CA 91208 Arborists and Environmental Consultants McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 March 9. 2018 Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck.NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: Recently you contacted me concerning your plans to construct a new single family home on your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia. I was asked to review the plans, inspect the trees and determine which trees would require removal and prepare a report. The following Arborist Report summarizes my findings: Background On Friday, February 9, 2018 I received your signed proposal concerning the Arborist Report. I met with your sister-in-law,Nancy Chang and Christopher Loh your architect at your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia and went over the proposed building plans. On Wednesday, February 14, 2018 I arrived at the subject property and began measuring and evaluating the health and condition of the trees. The Tree/Site Inspection Section describes my observations concerning the subject trees. Tree/Site Inspection Tree #1 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 19 inches in diameter at D.B.H. (Diameter Breast Height)as measured 54 inches above the soil grade. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 20 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 7 feet north of Hacienda Drive and 4 feet east of the west circular driveway entrance. The tree is situated in an ivy bed. It leans and grows 30 degrees south over Hacienda Drive. There is epicormic sprouting on the trunk. A small 5 inch diameter cavity was observed on the east side of the tree's trunk at a point 18 inches above the ground. Minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the tree's bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. There is decay in the old pruning wounds. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is severely unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Arborists and Environmental Consultants Pale 1 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#0P2 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 18 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 30 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located on the neighbor's property near the front yard of the subject property. It is 34 feet north of Hacienda Drive and 6 feet west of the western driveway of the subject property. It is situated in a shrub bed surrounded by Privet and Camellia shrubs. This single trunk specimen forms 2 unequal size stems at a point 6 feet above the ground. These stems form a narrow V-shaped crotch at their union. There is included bark tissue at the union creating weak structure. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by other nearby Oak trees. Bleeding cankers are visible on the lower trunk. The tree is exhibiting signs of Phytophthora a root disease. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Tree#3 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 40 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 40 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 80 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 25 feet north of Hacienda Drive and 22 feet east of the driveway along the west side of the property. It is situated in an ivy bed. The crown has been pruned and raised. There are multiple bleeding cankers along the lower 7 feet of the tree's trunk. This single trunk specimen develops 2 co-dominant stems at a point 10 feet above the ground. The stems form a normal U-shaped saddle at the union. The tree has a 3 foot long vertical stress crack on the north side of the trunk. There are sunken areas on the trunk just above the root crown. The bark tissue is checking and cracking along the lower trunk. White fungal tissue is visible where the bark has exfoliated. I sounded the trunk and it resonated indicating that there are hollow areas where decay is present in the lower trunk. The foliage size and color appears to be normal. 1 would estimate that approximately 20%of the tree's crown is composed of dead wood. The crown density is sparse. The tree is clearly declining and dying. It appears to have Phytophthora a type of root disease and heart rot decay within the main lower trunk. This tree is potentially hazardous and is in very poor health and condition. Rating: D- Tree#4 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 24 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 30 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 44 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 37 feet north of Tree#3 and 5 feet east of the west side of the circular driveway. The tree is situated in a 4 foot diameter circular brick tree well. The base of the tree's trunk or root Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 2 lg. McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued crown is located 9 inches below the surrounding soil grade. Oak leaf debris surrounds the trunk. The lower trunk area appears to be intact. No mushrooms, cavities or decay was observed. There is minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree leans 30 degrees southeast. The crown has been pruned and raised. A limb approximately 9 inches in diameter has been pruned and removed on the east side of the tree's trunk 6 feet above the ground. Old bleeding from a wound is visible on the north side of the tree's trunk. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree appears to be in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Tree#5 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 18 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 28 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 48 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 15 feet south of the southeast corner of the existing house and it is 10 feet west of the wrought iron fence near the east boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Star Jasmine ground cover grows under the tree. The tree's roots are partially paved over by the circular driveway and brick walkway. It is a single-trunk specimen which forms 2 co-dominant stems at a point 7 feet above the ground. There is included bark tissue at the union of these stems creating weak structure. The tree leans 15 degrees south. It is crowded by the neighbor's Oak tree. The subject tree has narrow crotches and weak structure.The crown has been pruned and raised. The tree is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Tree#0P6 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 20 inches in diameter at D.H.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 25 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 30 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located in the neighbor's side yard roughly 10 feet north of the southeast corner of the subject property house and 2 feet east of the wood fence which runs along the eastern boundary of the subject property. It is situated in an irrigated shrub bed. Tobira Pittosporum shrubs surround the tree's trunk. The tree leans 30 degrees south. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#7 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 24. 24 and 30 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 25 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 50 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 3 Ote McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Con tin a ed roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard. It is 7 feet east of the western house extension on the existing house and 24 feet north of the main portion of the existing house. The tree is situated in a 14 foot diameter circular planter. Camellia and Gardenia shrubs grow nearby. Irrigation is present. The tree has 3 co-dominant stems which form a union at a point 4 feet above the ground. A fourth trunk or stem was cut on the southwest side of the tree. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is balanced with minor asymmetry. The trunks have been cabled for support. The foliage size and color appears normal.The crow-n density is fair. The tree is in above average health and condition. Rating: B- Tree#8 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 19 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 31 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 31 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 15 feet north of Tree#7 and 7 feet northeast of the northeast corner of the western house extension. The tree is situated in a small shrub planter surrounded by Holly. Irrigation is in the nearby planter within the tree's root zone. The tree leans 30 degrees northwest. Bark tissue is missing at the root crown on the west side of the trunk. The bark tissue on the trunk is checking and cracking.No growth cracks are visible along the trunk. There is minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. Old pruning wounds have not closed. Decay is present at these pruning sites. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. It is crowded by another nearby Oak. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. It is stressed and is clearly dying. The tree is in very poor health and condition. Rating: D- Tree#9 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 14 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 25 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 25 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is northeast of Tree#8 and 14 feet east of the southeast corner of the existing swimming pool. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Azalea, Camellia, Moraea and Ferns grow nearby. The lower trunk is intact. No mushrooms, cavities or decay was observed. It has co-dominant stems with included bark tissue creating weak structure. The tree leans slightly north and is crowded by other Oak trees on the south side. The crown grows north. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#10 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 12 and 13 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 35 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 57 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 11 feet southeast of Tree#9. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Azalea and Camellia shrubs grow nearby. The tree leans 30 degrees east however some of the limbs extend west. The tree is semi-balanced with minor asymmetry. It has co-dominant stems with included bark tissue creating weak structure. The tree is crowded by other nearby Oaks. The crown has been pruned and raised. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#11 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 20 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 24 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 30 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 9 feet south of Tree#10. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Camellia shrubs surround the tree's trunk. The tree leans 15 degrees southeast. It has a vertical. linear form of growth habit. The tree is crowded by other nearby Oaks. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. It has been pruned and raised. The foliage size and color appears normal.The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Tree#12 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 22 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 32 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 34 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 31 feet north of the northeast corner of the existing house and 15 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub bed. English Ivy grows nearby. The tree grows upright. It forms 2 co-dominant stems with included bark tissue at a point 9 feet above the ground. The tree has weak structure. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical growing mostly on the south, east and west sides. Overhead utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#13 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 5 and 17 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 30 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 41 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page Igo McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 17 feet north or Tree#12 and 14 feet west of the block wall which runs along the east boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Camellias and Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. Oak leaf mulch surrounds the tree's trunk. There is a small patch of exfoliating bark tissue at the root crown on the west side. There is minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The crown has been pruned and raised. The tree is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown grows eastward. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#14 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 12 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 12 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 22 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 30 feet northeast of Tree#13 and 3 feet west of the block wall which runs along the east boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub bed. Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. The crown has been pruned and raised. Overhead utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is semi-balanced with minor asymmetry. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood was observed in the tree's crown. The tree is in poor health and condition. Rating: D Tree#15 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 8 and 22 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 37 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 37 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 6 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary and it is 40 feet north of Tree#14. The tree is situated in a shrub bed. It is surrounded by Tobira Pittosporum shrubs. Utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The tree leans 30 degrees south. It has been pruned and raised. The tree is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#16 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 12 and 16 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 28 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 33 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 23 feet west of Tree#15. The tree is situated in a shrub bed near the edge of the lawn. It is Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 6 Plre McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued crowded by other nearby trees. The tree leans and grows southwest. The 12 inch diameter stem grows low over the nearby lawn and may need to be cut back. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. Dead wood is visible in the crown. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#17 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 17 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 32 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 34 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 28 feet northeast of Tree#16 and 2 feet northwest of the existing wood shed. The tree is situated in a shrub bed. Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. It leans 15 degrees northwest. There is a stress crack on the south side of the trunk. Heavy Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. It grows in a westerly direction. The foliage size and color appears normal.The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#18 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 10 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 14 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 18 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 26 feet northeast of Tree#17 and 3 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary. It is situated in a natural mulch area. The tree is crowded by other nearby trees. It grows northwest. Overhead utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Tree#19 is a Platanus racemosa or California Sycamore. The tree measures 18 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 27 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 70 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 9 feet north of Tree#I5 and 8 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary. The tree is situated in a shrub bed. Cast Iron Plants surround the tree's trunk. There is missing and exfoliating bark tissue on the west side of the trunk above the root crown. Severe Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the tree's bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. headed and topped. Epicormic growth was observed near these pruning cuts. There is a large 7 inch diameter dead limb on the south side of the tree. Decay is visible. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The tree has begun to grow new leaves. The tree is in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 7 1114 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#20 is a Platanus racemosa or California Sycamore. The tree measures 14 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 18 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 18 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 10 feet southwest of Tree#19 and 9 feet east of Tree #16. It is situated in a shrub bed. The tree is surrounded by Cast Iron Plant. Tobira Pittosporum and Viburnum shrubs. There is severe Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue on the west side of the tree's trunk just above the root crown. It is crowded by other nearby trees. It leans and grows 30 degrees southwest. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The crown has been headed back and this has produced epicormic or sucker growth. It is producing new leaves. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#21 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 14 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 25 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 40 feet east of the west boundary block wall and 6 feet south of the north boundary wood fence. It is situated in a shrub bed. Indian Laurel Fig, Fern Pine. Citrus and Oleander grow nearby. The lower trunk area is intact. No mushrooms,cavities or decay was observed. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by the neighbor's Coast Live Oak. The subject tree's crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical growing mostly south. Overhead utility wires run along the north side of the tree. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Tree#22 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 10 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 15 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 20 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 30 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is near the northwest corner of the subject property. The tree is 10 feet east of the block wall which runs along the west boundary and it is 5 feet south of the chain-link fence which runs along the north boundary. It is situated in a shrub bed. Oleander and Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. The tree leans 30 degrees west into the neighbor's property. The lower trunk area is intact. No mushrooms, cavities or decay was observed. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by the nearby neighbor's Coast Live Oak. Overhead utility wires run along the north side of the tree. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the crown. The tree is in poor condition. Rating: D Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 8 ITO McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#23 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 28 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 24 feet from the tree's trunk.The spread of the tree is 42 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet:all. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 55 feet south of the north boundary fence and 6 feet east of the west boundary block wall. The tree is situated in a shrub bed surrounded by Glossy Privet. Viburnum and Tobira Pittosporum shrubs. The tree grows upright and the lower trunk area is intact. No mushrooms. cavities or decay was observed. Minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the tree's bark tissue on the lower trunk. Orange growth cracks are visible on the trunk indicating that the tree still has vigor. This single trunk specimen forms 2 co-dominant stems at a point 17 feet above the ground. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is semi-balanced with minor asymmetry. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is normal. Minor flagging and dead foliage was observed in the crown caused by Oak Twig Girdler insects. The tree is in excellent health and condition. Rating: A- General Observations The subject property is situated in a single family home residential neighborhood in the City of Arcadia. The subject property and the nearby homes in the neighborhood are attractive and well maintained. The subject property and neighborhood have a considerable number of mature native trees growing there. This area appears to have been a former Oak Woodland Plant community before it was developed. The subject property has numerous native Coast Live Oak and California Sycamore trees growing in both the front yard and the back yard. There are 5 existing Coast Live Oak trees which conflict with the proposed new single family home. They include: Tree#9,Tree 410,Tree 411, Tree#12 and Tree 413. There are 2 other Coast Live Oaks identified as Tree#3 and Tree +8 which must be removed because they are diseased and are in danger of falling. The removal of these 7 Oak trees will require tree removal permits from the City of Arcadia. Recommendation Based upon my inspection of the subject tree and property it is my professional opinion that in order to build the new house according to the proposed design it will be necessary to remove 5 healthy Coast Live Oak trees. These arc Tree#9,Tree 410,Tree 411,Tree #12 and Tree #13. There are 2 diseased, dying Coast Live Oaks identified as Tree#3 and Tree#8 which are hazardous and in danger of falling. These 2 trees must also be removed Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 9 g• McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Recommendation-Continued for safety reasons. The proposed removal of the 5 healthy Oak trees due to conflict with proposed constriction will require a City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for Removal of Healthy Trees. The proposed removal of the 2 diseased.hazardous Oak trees will require a City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for Removal of Diseased and or I-lazardous Trees. In order to preserve and protect the remaining trees on the property I would recommend that the following tree protection mitigation measures be followed: 1) Temporary orange plastic fencing should be installed around the drip line or farthest point possible from the trunk of all the protected Oak and Sycamore trees to be preserved prior to commencement of work. 2) Minimize excavation and trenching within the drip line of the protected trees. 3) Roots which are cut or otherwise damaged should be pruned to the side of the excavation with a clean, sharp pruning tool and kept covered with burlap and wetted caily until the excavation area can be backfilled. 4) Minimize storage of building materials and equipment within the drip line of the protected trees in order to minimize soil compaction. 5) Prohibit dumping of foreign substances such as excess soil.concrete,cement. stucco, paint, etc. within the drip line of the trees. 6) Designate an area outside the drip line of the trees to clean and wash equipment so as not to impact the root zones of the protected trees. 7) Pruning of limbs and branches of trees shall be performed by a State Licensed Tree Contractor under the supervision of an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. 8) All pruning shall comply with ANSI A-300 Pruning Standards and Best Management Practices. 9) An I.S.A. Certified Arborist should be hired to oversee and supervise all work within the drip line of the remaining protected Oak and Sycamores. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 10 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Summary/Conclusion In conclusion,it is my professional opinion that in order to build the proposed new single family home based on the current design it will be necessary to remove 5 healthy Oak trees identified :n this report as Tree#9,Tree#10. Tree#11. Tree#12 and Tree#13. There are 2 diseased and hazardous Oak trees identified in this report as Tree#3 and Tree #8 which must also be removed for reasons of safety and liability. A City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for the Removal of Healthy Trees will be necessary in order to remove the 5 healthy Oak trees. In addition,a City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for the Removal of Diseased and or Hazardous Trees will be necessary in order to remove the 2 diseased and hazardous Oak trees. Remaining trees to be preserved should be fenced at the drip line or as far from the trunk as possible. Dumping of foreign materials within the drip line of the trees shall be prohibited. Trenching and cutting of roots should be minimized. Damaged or torn roots must be pruned back to the side of the trench with a clean, sharp,pruning tool and kept covered and wetted until backfill can occur. Pruning of tree branches and limbs should be performed by a state licensed tree contractor and supervised by an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. The pruning shall comply with ANSI A-300 Pruning Standard and Best Management Practices. All work within the drip line of the remaining Oak and Sycamore trees should be supervised by an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. Tree#1 and Tree#19 should be monitored for further signs of decline. A Licensed Pesticide Applicator should be hired to control the Western Sycamore Borer insects on the trees. The remaining trees should be routinely pruned approximately every 3 to 5 years to eliminate dead wood and maintain overall health and safety. Limitations Information contained n this report covers only those areas that were examined and reflects the condition of those areas at the time of inspection Tire inspection was limited to visual examination of accessible areas without excavation.drilling or boring.Arboriculture is not an exact science and there is much that is still to be learned about trees.The observations and recommendations provided in this report reflect the latest research,knowledge and training available through university and professional research.There is no warranty or guarantee,expresses or implied,that problems or deficiencies of the trees or property in question may not arise in the future. Thank you for the opportunity to serve you and your environmental and horticultural needs. If you have any further questions, please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or you may call my office phone at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, cam• i! �� 2. William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists i7 Certified Arborist#WE-4578A 7 International Society of Arboriculture L Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page I I . • .• • • ... i • „ 1 ... '-cr• -z: V-,- "c'cl--: i .-;- ',.,hfia-Iki • . . . _ . —____2.,fi..f — ---- - , ; 1 /77-4.'-'% . ii.Vt'i.t', , -.. ,.;"A•,,,,,.,.....—. , 'I, . ••it a t! ':, • "...111 4.,......„y ,--.t----:-.--: ...Z'7 t-• ,A....V.M .11.4 A 0 I . t' ; += . A rf,t'7,c;.,r:,;tt - =!i-I..- - -'"-• .i , , • e: / r - j-F- . . , \ . 1 - / ;..... .,- ..,---!-,---,...,-..• •.:_, ..... ..:-:-.AN c,. . j.-L . -..., , ... -, 1 r..,._;”3:•-:!:-:1,,,,= -,4--_:: ',-....-7,-- _-• •-•:- — •.7* ) i 1,-.4-7,ti ,- _T„k-!:-- - -•::, - -4, ...*6, :.-,...2t.4, •-• _ -- • ...._... - . ..t::_i__„.___ci.---•_t-:\ -- , _. „,.._..:_---,-...... • ...Aprstrio ak . , ___.,....N.c..,- _...... . viiK ....... , _..,__. c:.1 / ,•,c . --........, 91 _ • - .--. -- .,. .,...%•,..-ii:. 4...,....;:-....z :...: .„... • .- • %^151.3 :,CO'6 v.) '11(11:-.)Z1V CP 3 '.ii : V 0, 31-,v11 - : 1 41 a • • �� ,i a •a�, r'' '1 'I ^ p..:'1 aW'a �A1 'I".4,;'4,0,,A: °'' f� ••� �• ' i r. A` ' ,m. ::,, N`_C Y 'j1 11,o ',.`�,, 1RF• ` �'I•.. r' ,r�• J!'� �!�(` C '� /t!�, ,�. v /' �. • 1�Yy+��6+ ' t �,11�. :-..,,,, 'J, r`,F•' .11:111, { r� 7:::.:-.., '���^�O/ ,' 1 ,,1 3 •.j�pjIVJ!',r •r� :��,! ,..�f"y /, j.- ' i. i - "►.%k ` ♦ ". y� , '�'. ,� fr, �, . Y'a► RI it ��it�' f(��1: n,',� .c} /�,r .' +�+- i✓ A d 010..�?• �,; y '�.( , 4 a� ` .� � ,9.! r •�: '/l,ly;•.y��u,�� I �a 4'1ay'Ii �I� � a". � 4 ,� /• ~*.N �Yt.YpiN< 4. , 1.. •• ivt' .ry ,V'�x'.l�r "I �tl ` ~t a' •''•�,��•'ltJ � 44'.‘:,:t.......,:1;.i .r'v ., ����11111 - ' r ..n :"Y.• t¢ n ,• ,;1 ;'fr '. �, ;� nk j�e.. • a "14C11. ? ut k , :3)• y r 1 Sr'L t( 41 5 �. `iE r• +My'. �'• 'y t � r+k � ; , . .'`r r t. �, � aY, 4r • ,, •./� ` w • ,1 J� +. . `i T , ,1! � ;.,„ A• • 4,t• ti 4,‘,•;•,-- •y.I�, i' 1v "IL •„ti •••/i{ x _` ,�,�r ,^M�� ,y �5•l4' �t�11 _ •►,,i '•l'- r r ,I' `` it; . •l ',pi.... 4" : ), a 3 'tr v , „K.' /// t; , i • T” y�,' �ryf ,r-� y,� x.14'. !. • ' y,i. 'J� y A{ r� (• •1,• ,r / j7J�i4 �.�i t , f a • ��/Jt �Ni • rl +tt y^i It A. 310 .` y ::!'".....4" Y V! M� • a{ s,� ► ~- •,�tt 3Jtt r. ,1 l }y ` ,f'. wY,! + 1!iff '��i� ' 4 t�. f� J.. i f i / 1 3 t' rAlt- s ' • • , r. : . ' - v.- ,-. .k. -, ,,• diiii,s, .:•gc.,..,, ...t, . , .\-$-'•:•'::: :•:`, •, .'. ,..*,,.. - • • w .:, - . .1:k ...' ..' v': ' : • " .J a. • . • • I S i � �.,i...„� •'N.r ' •• is . .'rvo' . -„�,. • • 'sem• .Jt n \, S- ! r .ir:< r•, , #,r 1r (�'' el te�a•� 'lir'Y tg.{ Y {. ti • .t.„... . ...., •i. • • • • • h!1 ',;'1 � • '3',0 , jl ' 4 t� J f r ('0 it't f?,•10 ,r,, r , • , /4;, i , ,� 1 ,r • to IN 1 ,o � I `det, , ,• ,, ,`I��i ♦ y''M1,, 1 C•oly ' �i rr I,, � ,/1,. I'1/'' ,,� ,41 e, ,) }' I� • 111111... l ,/ 1: r r.;• �., .,lt �' ',W I(' 7,1 * ' .• !1 ,.''*1 _ '• .t 4. ± ,• •, .�,� ,i ' ,1fA,i .uy. NJ•�'r��/J "�1�is, r,,,�tl•�,. : �.4.4,. r y4..• . 1 91r •� r 1 A" if�,r, Y, 'is , a? 1 'j• ,.; ,�� , . � I 1� l /.r'' r,rr. � Ir,• ;, � , J'�Ti , ; � A , I 5l' y .i �� I/',`/'• 1 ♦ ';.f �..f/ J / t• '`. • - /V/ 'r'` r• '''''h''.0, .449 '/ir , 4 , '4 . I: i ,1 y j • / i ,u r , , . 1y `` 1. r I 1 a ` ' `,i414-.4, p, •I {' y.t,r .. , I •i y5^,', �.i'.' ` tit'/- .f ',' �; 111 ; ,{ ^`i! % ,, •l� * /r, / j� • r . L ./'.. y "'1 !1 '" r °k 'r 141' "e� / •l 1 Y•► 't ,... ..„.• '-1: .1 4,..„ T- 8 i •i ') A •<1 • •..,f j " l N .1* if 1•1 it,,!, I� 1 {I,, i:,". 1111‘": , 7 ,, • {< .tA •,y�,' '''''';40 :'';y'' ; r ', , ,, , v -' , , ;,, , ';JAI/y , i ,.�'/�I , p;f /,• , r�, • �f i v, ' 4• /' ' +',� / f , : , '/ ' , 'I ,'�' '-1+ yr .r! ' .l .,, ..., •. ;'14 t n 4.„, . „.„ �, " ,, 0r17" r . r(, • I , • . ' , I� . •l, , , I, NI ` I , , , - �,f 'll'• ,l 414I 7 s � � 1,r ,, • • Ali •4+'r Llry '/ ,, / 1►,�yA1 r ',>ti ►/.41 (r M ti e *,411*..,: �/ 4' ,/,, • `./. , t Vlb r; M,� a !' A• I r ,..'"vii. 1� . ' • 't I , .1i/hifor sof,'PIA 0 /'/ '' r ,1 '.' ' ?,,'�,� ,.. • '�� r ,y�,r ., � , i ,r.y. .j, l'. �,/. I', ryll ''/, I , .%,1' �7 1, �' ,I I I , '.. ttlifr A ♦f • 'L "�,..y e • ., ., • •" rti 1 i `w•1�t Oh. r I., ., ,i, , I y►i/. 1i {[. n �' •' , 'I II •�t' i� a Ii1� ,*."ie,.. /r d. I ii ,A,�'. , • , t••,L /'777 ., A. 4' L,• • A R,y , , /,I �1 i� 'i 1 , / ,/ *' • �' A >L"y .. I' '} 1/ I{ "iI; /I 1 /'y^�' i 1 t1 I� Ire' / 7 yA% '' ♦ 4 1 /i' "i ! men y ,•I�'i. "j" r„ ' • •I '' ,, - 'I / r ; I ,J, {• ! f, ,'#, l' •I A"°'/ p ~ �t .,•-• rb '".��• Y I r•'I'r/„ '• • �y /3, ',I ' r r' / I ' �. „ � '.'� ,', /'I'l) �,'1t , Ali l• i� YS'. ' 10 '' 4 wri' 4 I .'A •Iad" I J /,,41:1, , 1,A , 4 a '' .y ':.I •1,1, i 'I. I, II /' 11 y 1 1 .. /� l� 1;71• ' I 'i •'r• ' •1I y /IM, y, I i' • i Y tea, • i' - + � k•C•./` - �' . , , A(v,. ., .. • f/r'�',r k•,.11•\ •rt...., ,+-,j• 1 },-,---r,I ,• ' /1, 1. ,x(,-11 � ' r (' , i';' r /i,. 1 ., ..!(/, .: ") r f t';♦Q. r �� '4% 1.1*t. ' '' - .!� A4,+ 1 • -' k,',..it rht I w• '" , i.l ., ✓f 4L� Y './. ,r , ," r' .4:4 4°4• 4 '+ r •.r p •� r a r '1: ,+ { t4.rrl"'•'7'. ., s '• '5' t' y• '�•. •fi N '✓ t • „* .'�' . .40. • '-i,!.04 ,•'i' .1 • `` ' t 04., -.. h.xry ,d;..', •'J .� L '• I.Y' ai 4 .,'5 G •• :A'.'.•, _ , t 9'a,_t •-i p 1� ((`..'y� •� Y'ff 9 V•Et.rr �� • .y�,, h� '•.�{S • "•il�' 4,... i -� 1r • �., ''•,I•,' • l•• 4�(, `' t`} .;r`eie''%ni. 7I.tl lflJ �1.if;_ -' s,..% •• Y •1 t - • •• ~ �� r /' r•, •I • ., h ` r .A *An;; ,' yC •'154...i%,:11• ;II' '' '�' },. 4 ', .7 ,ta ;iqr i. •'p .j J .r t • i r • r•� , A•„g4 '. }� n44-;• , Y ' yam•,•.� . `,o � t/n ••�1 ,t•. . .p.,. .r••' •Y I. ,}•;• '.��/ r I• t�.. ,J` %4 'M"F"� •'.''L �!' ,- ,. x.f,� A A ,;• e, t• t •1. ca'r•1 .. -..`' T+. •• •y vi. t...�A( '. 1�•' I a' 141i, c'.I_!' s '► d".” ', , • `:11% .�,r•'3'3f'"`tt t-�. `fin•;. .n ' ••.; •ti' ,i +' .; ,. �� 74:3•4.4-,' 'r'".• �414-,""1--� '� 'ij•# '; ;�� ;► r '•� t• , It r 'f 1�w Y • • k .•'1* •ji >� .4- 7. ,.it �� '. -.7'. l •�• — `Y ,\ � � v ,`�••". 1 l`~,}'�. • ,Ilk r• ..+•r r.r j! (gv}".A.n ,�• �+1• 7' of / Y+•r‘ ,,' r• . "a 7tr t + `•1 -.4—. � 7 •.,'', ••," I+'� bh.•' •J.- -> Cl .r—..:s .' .. v _.. t, •42, J • ,'F• • 4 �}• :A4• . `3('� •• �• •;:i'°' , .Mt k,.•, f: t.liz.r..t -.44,4,, ,. t. Y4-K" �,t ,a�' r�, i 7..,1.;-..e.,..,.:1, ti i y` J r'�. y[ • '1' s7' ac�� '-,.•,,......,•,��A '•Y •' •,x, .a { ••.' 'r r a ��[.A if • Lf• t �.i �r.irk, '... 'r- •I . S6•, •.i• .. • N •7� , i y� 't/�. ,V ''v .' -. S4F .Y �r ,i.•.1 J ,.y +4..g.' ' I ,' le i ...:.Q.,. • *` ' 1 . LJ_ll' } 'ihh f T ' 'E % i ""' ^� 'y '• •• �x x .t '1'' �` r` `�J L' r• p� ,� L �# �, r N'•�7k �V,1,•t r " `' ., • • y.• •!' f. ..t 7,R. .. * •j .i.; Q •'Zt' � !-..A ?•,-.`"- V.-- �L y� s y ''.%',!..,, •� . fit'`! •.: K �, 'i� W. `ly I y j, �1 �Y y . ` • �t r•. .—> t' - 1 .i b" .. T 1 "-:4• 4 :q• n . �} .'•: L t• 1N. �`••V'L •t:1.4 Y`?Y•TS• ..may ' f (G'.*'ar'. 'z�' b•�k, .}.',,, j f , 'R` • ..r c :•.L µVG t' a T 1 T t [.,Citta ", 1..p. ,} *.^ ►r .'d 4 ..t:: • ' 1 •+'' • �� ,-e-• -• • J •S . . •.n riry+fit . J••.k . •1 t. t .-iL�' T )" • _• .4',' `'• r .� r '1...�r. P' s t �' ..... t. '.,.6 • 4 JIM') A.IAf1! , 'l / `� • " 0 �' •\''1 e.. .r , �: ,,ji ;I f /'� t 1• w;1 t JI t: • c\tio -. • • • �+ l• ly?'. LS . n � tip { . ` yi. �` " .r. � 4 � / - i �' • , 4. • I • R ..r . - . y•` ! •,• ►ikTr "r • '+( VP', ~ .;5'' 4� 'I I. .t 4) Yk • • F a:' t ,L ' Y • , • LisSp - •' ' . 4tc•�,, •. ' �;y all N.(' ..A. • +•te •"`,. • e • 1 s .,','$'' .ter ♦_ j 4t b • Fr Y s J 0 ,. . } • I� a a� „ . 1 .,1• ,. .. e • �• Itlr •x341. .• • ••••' .. + V'R'111 'r' ' .• f: . • • T ' • :�/. +,7 00 .... �•!- 'r. T t t. / ar ••7••.^l ..r '•1V�tl�,y'` •�. ra r 10 artg/ v ' '•,j'''' x 'A! '. - �•,.' ' 11114ri - / f ' • �• � � v/ W.”1 �. ','4r / •Y•l� tl'V: -+y � '.:. .. r ° rfv .y'.Ty. • I '. • ' /,:•: ••.1;,• .,• i•• • • v144, " � ,t Ia..';•. . k.'• .. 4.‘ .., 1 1 .. ily,',,,,' .../ 1 t- ' o. i. •t —1,011 •)• A • • • i . • f ,to •'.`'t•7 . .. , A �� • L' 'f •' •.. itioll "tR . ,..fi,- ,,Iir ..,,. v.:. , v- , ., ._ :',4 -,-..• jilt rM (( y. —7.144p , n 44 , f- " , ��: +'` p.r. te - -- • Jarmo ' r ,,•'e. 7• - f w_ may ' j r �.a '• 'r •`,4 •'�" �" tf- - -ply visev.• i • ... – 00. . . . ,...".JOT. i ,. , ... • .- • - 4. �Jfi _ ir*" sa.E b.. __Tr 'y✓ • ' •• fry .'!`,- • .� • • - wr Mfr + " -.14. ' • b • 1400 r �` x - • _ ' i •IY •S` a `-. 'AU '- 44 J 4 . •."y,L��-W r.wr..r . ice.. ' • jt� • o f T- _ � ' � r _ 3�. a •-ems !r _ - i I+4. i • 'li ' : i .4!',;.,r If: x.• . a• ' '`c • r' ,hie. � t•'•y �• L4 ••/ M• IV) - •. . ;. . ., . t PP f.f. ' Stip? 4.54. , . - , ..., . , „ A . " i0, , ., . � , , r t fit. , ' ` •,•• • • •r f 1 s •� ,�, 1. t•. -t _ •� - . �• 'r' . i `! • keit. • •-,�N,'1vI /+t!^.` Z '^ i' - f '"l. Ir •R'1"r y♦ • _d '- t� 21 ' � "St/, * ,r • 'Y" .41 '‘',•70t1,0.1;:.,.°,, t 1. , +I,A'i•{`Nr C r: ; r Y r r y" �. r •i}L�{�� ! r�sr • •'' R `�'Ia i����.•' tJ \ ,} arf•, < ,� f• i1• �! ` r •r ra' �Y •�! ' 1• b -.1 +M � • - LLI' s�•r�?s '. (. y.:�t _ +4.1'..4',1/4:7•b M -r ,' !-: iv.' '1ti •, , i t r I1' ,f Y• r„ 1. ,g.4•.'/=-ri'a,..,.- .' '; r. ��104: '1R1 -0P 1 mvir\ ,1 0: ,4'�r( rb�,.i,1 tl 't' .. ,!'•j/ •r I rj .,` 'f•Is� r y .r .'"r"' 'r , . i�'.. ,, . '.; � i!!t ku ��`��y*�. ' r� 1. 3x � V`*� �j��1/ r tr .� }. 'tv tc�lh ' 1 L � yi ljl. "••• ;�%��i. • _ r's' �•.tr my, tt -0'4',.:,,,A.,. ... Y :. '* 41`.• -,•:.# �' ��'tA#r"SS1' � N, ' r .7 GC• {r4 , }r ,yr , ). .4. er. •, 1. ,27...4..,„ _` .,� ,_ .• • 4 .1-, 1 }, •tss.11/4',.1....4‘,. '�•`'.1'r tY•' I r + •• '�l!x ` ir— • a,410".' y.ti a r�, §� '�f.y>r. , a�i r 1,102,,,,?)�,t ' � , "'y� %T.'.•-i't`61� '� ,y�y �c :+ fa.,,..w�G'.+� ~1 • r.,'i• 4, r 4)'' j \.r. • 4.—$.'..W is ,'r, ,a ..' tlY. , •w ry •�. i }.,�'� ~.•.•r 11'21 '*.{ +, '�' •4',/'r=1�73�� x,11. ,:ir..•.�.. .;„'"•,-.1,:4,,,, . �t t °�r ^��'-'y',h"+, 'At..M,,:.! fp', '... ;"•Y ;;,min 1''. •'r� i1''�}`. '� , r4•.,; i�;r `' + I �;•�I ' F,t '^f11tl•,"rj t '� A': t r�.1. iltfilT :d':' �t`� -,..1,7,171„,'..-•: Y 'r s.. ^' fn ,r .-;,� -" -.f ; yl .•!7..1 " :,1. e 4.:P? 4;'. �,3':,!,'� :,f 4' =f. ri+T,; "' « r4•ll;�' n.Mn i; M 4 �x �y., j '`'�;� r� s ;.•.."f f � i'.S,II �li�•2:� '` .t,.', tF Ct'is • .� Y..1�+��'� r � ,&•1= • ti • 1 w'• '�pr a ?' r- %. .4"—,:;::..,• ,:t vii. F i� • �! •7M ��� �r, v y1�. y j1��� may, �.`S-'•� ,,A'u` 1+•J• �• :• r �+;I J • �,� �..n,}tilr, ':� .! '�,. ( # 7' r.•?� + •�'l�a r r • ` .1' r 4 w .r� �r �". `t .•y lsF3' T� a.;` '}q r 1+9n�il.. .:,is • >,r.' y,1,•..,• �tS '4:41 cS �'' a �►.• r `Slr . s '`. i if,r•1r+i t .I+ 4 r '�r p �'F. ..- .! r� :4444...lr L•' +4 •• ' , ! /•:t,.';.,_".'. t srj, ° ' .y` t = .t 1 ♦ ''�..L tr 't• ., + ,.. ;F t 1. C.r ' jZ.4..4'. ,Lat�1r�,e'r '.•r•�K >�, ~�' .`C, ��,•K• �r � {/l �.�y� ,.�`' �%• �1 J�•�t ':Ifc'!rp h t Y`.`' ,,e ' N.,JI' � j+'Y.1�j,'�f� i■ij ` '.p � v.a , rNd ., ",. '.d'qr .. .. .. "Y.•1411'�(} ,tf. o r t. r1 '! _'t• r'rl,. ;' (.`r'�.ti• ., ..•-•:\;, orb -c, ,r° •tiy •l ' `3 '‘'r. i •s ..M4 r .. �, '' 'i'- ,. 'ti • N • '•:0' r, 'td. :•,,V X;k : ♦ r • t!I •,j'N•• ,; .r ./., • 'w. .' 1 `a 1 ,�4 %1 1 :,„,t '' it �►' yq•, r. .. �► E • t, ?�ti� .,5�.` _�'.A1�. 'Ayre p;' c t r t9• .� , t f7-21T` ;k4F.rt, ,56�„T?? 'r ;4t)''''''. f �l•l� -•. .t. � •',. .�,... �C a' '.., yl�w �. etc z - o•. F �i ty'7 l ir' . s '.fy Xi,.t r k k'! a� ✓t' 4l s5: ` :, „t r;. .-..'•,--;l.`9 ti 1 tam' �" rr f•'t..,. - ,. • j� :.`+i%t.• • ,°17:1-ISt'1 •`'.•r,+ • •r'. •,:, •,, "• �.Pt",•r• ••. t r .. . 1 `, i .:�, •' 1�1'' •' - _: , t :'�f�.t �r•SwtLv r r� ,�1 vt � �a. t r��•''. '� „ ��Lt 4r -�i.� t!..,, � • 'g� ' J.n , • , ,(:. � 1 fir. t J 1.i K.�, • 1�t•'.�1.�,;,� a .r; t� ,•4� 4 ' „1;r r z r,'4�5 ,,ij• a� 'x' .; !' ' +: . P �"��'= ).°i t .+ `dt tr. .. .. r::-_� \ '•n r. ,. • Ir�y r1J,��;:1,�� 1;���4 _+. ,� �r �t•v�.. '� 6.- et .7t� a / r.��. Iti...�y `` , n�•`-,�:C •,�.f',y,Y ,i}' F�� •! ..�•.A• R1µ v •i� -. �f ,r• .� -6� t. 1: ,r, ,'A.�s. J. �' -w <:�'� p6� ,..;•. a n,iV�.�-ti r •> 1Y, ~t VF�ra •.•- 'p_: t • a�t` rr'r ' fj rj> .,,,, , ,i4;„.„. ..1:.:.4 �+ • � 4: c+ , t V• ♦ •114{''+'.• . t` r. r ~rr t �it, /�' I ,r-,.. ti i ,,q,.-�'S!r=e`rrr, .,�f' t -" ii�.•+.� dt. r• ^• r •/'-'' u r. "'' V . r'�` �"- �.. . , ,`S '1 ": :.1 L't . . i f11: •,r.4 11015," ,s, $.e ,o 144% :">Ir• ,5-.• ` r \;�-"4'•z- rr :l'` ''G ,.t`. ,, %:x . l y T '��-,r/ .. t',,,v..'�• r'.c /# r .1? �r4 ,a '' • �' T. , � 7 M r. tf..II. Y y` .tq ♦• ^ •r '/ � • ti,i 11 +1 •} j t •f• r } i'' 'ar " 4�•!' ` • +' r D1'�` \ .1 P• , 91• i ,t 'ti q...� • c,. / • f ?+y.. ,yC • 41," ;..6...? y _ .. 'ill, (^',"^ - r " .,A„ .. ^ « ��rtr, �a ! 'X� '• ..,1.„4"+. .. • ..... , • .' M 41 ..r.f5• •,e , *� Z �.�� _ s- .st .1• :''t' ! •. F v . . t p +4ii `y{1. t I • 11144 4 t 4• t jili I -' i I0» •A► \'�4 .. •� ` 1 'A ro/ t' le ! t �. fpr. .':� • A 64- • 4- - v J*• •! r c'y. :. }`r. i', t I :f �• •� � ,yrs _ _- • •�7!'� #2....„....,-- r. _ r ,� • :�.+�. - r °7 41l♦ . r` •a s S -. ^� � .1 #~ i.r,qy "_ _ - - _ _ �,I•• • ''�'w..-. 4.•>l��y 1R It. 1' S '.[ w L ,� .w" �- , w� sacl�r••'`' .. * '' ^44�hIta>V :r wc I r r i' 1. • :F• rte+'.#tit a' a • • r •.f •ti : J �' - .A - • --- ',,' -,.- 41- 4- .,,i . -, ‘.. • . ....„ :__ lic.olk Iv''- .1 44'- -& " 1">-. .. - •-14 ,_•.. • • :las , .4 ' l*Lk i, .!.ft,-- '' •• -,0101,. - i '-:. • .' - .7?.• i ' ,.: • . . — ii.- c`_-. 1, _ . \ia�_' :. moi, � � `_�"lT�S -I,' - ..• i .... ,.. . • ‘„ lellt k: • -•: • '•. 14.4. ' V 'k ' •yIS' • .r. ,, At••4:„, •. if• ,_ •• , . , f. • ...." f .- .. • dr .r - • . ,4 ..,. ..... ..,.... ,,,.., , .. , .. . . .0_,... ....1. . .. •-r- •.. 4•• • lile/ ' le' .• ,if 4 .i _ ig . - c. i It It a•� .. es. , ,. • t` _ , ��•� ` a"yi" A. -1,"-, - .. ' • 'Ti •J� •twY'•y ` t ` , , 7 'r - . - a •-ilw. ` Vi t: .• t ♦ %. r NIIiiiiirk '- -- "' 4. * .4... •••'..• ..4. •''‘'•••••••... -Alf .. I r il i ti 'S, + r , Y`-' - - ' A .h S$ ala. -r • ' - +R _ '_�'1 rr ' a�* )� J '• • '* -.4 liji —!:-...i.r •. � 'Y, ...-•0•.•1�'� „sem ,• tom• J.1e,+11.'.` • r1`�}'r�'r,.I .r g*.•i --2 r.'. • •• t \.r t W• » t• is t►-L 3r-' y� '}.`�'� t E p^ r SL '. iti i. `£- '�.i. .5`• • 4464 y `I/rt•, • - a •}y am �' 1.. • ,.,♦ • t:..x'' .."7 : •,-. .-_ -- .. . .1 t • 4:4ril,melte VP'... " • 'V. l*,..014- A - • • • • c� �.'I' {2 : ,;i 1 l' Z. �,i h ` ,tet -,.�� •t �`' 4 Ill �'F,. • .- w -_,.., - .,,,. „,;., . . . ._..„..:,,,,,,„..,,,,,„ • .:..,,,.. ,.. ., ..,•_. ., .14 ..... 5._• •040 a} 3 r +^,i . , • '•• • - y• '~' fir _ Y t . mi.,. ... ..telf,, ...?1,1p?i, .. , •*, i t a ♦Alit. S s, .t✓ .^ ... te- • \f�. • `• ,....,,. . • fir•_ ... ,. ..1"t .-•. -- •, ' . w r ~ `tf •,. • . S' ``.l a i- Kms o.�y r • r '' k4 i . : % . . ....4 s. j'• . e- •.;- s',...-= • s. ` •' •{ • ¢. �'f !- • •_:, '; ..r mow, t '; ' c r ":`: • ,, :• Y ; \ :s ` -; 4' . '—r' . �'' .�` +#eta ,• ,• �li ; •• w , �y ? ' . • :, 41. • 'A! = ,I :t" 1.,1'!.1, • '-ii.:Ii4146;.N -.A Eth - ir . • •. iaN •'•r-.11 � ; • ' . ,lik ,. _ .. , ,...,,,,no .. .... , _.... ... ..„. . _:ate • 11 :,* ,c'' .4. af1.a .•'r."'' �'`^""' �r'r �. •�y�S 4e. .\ . . ,. �i - !if?. t'}r.yet J - 7\ 7777 j .y.t.-- �.. .. •v.Y it_ 1 ,-`�..' 4 . C• /ir"�'T"v'•;-t• 55i !!!F ; 11 d F.t T .• ` ,, 411• �,. tiki . r '•l _ i4 F1. r i ,t.,,,.7; �. to i. A. • Iter. .. \ . • rib, _ - ,, ,.‘ -,-es.--... -4. ..,,--"4:7_ It ',r r `z1I�.". to . Y• •,e�.�� r _ ti r ai ,\*.moi -fit - ,,4, ; e. !)t. ' . • 4. 4s < ht' - r• � • •. _ ' ' '' •ate .. a: • .v'-:;---•'..j,3-': 'r. r.r• sp ' ►• � r '�, f. c.{ •r r 4 •1 .• 74-r... 4 Arid. t( _I-. s • r .n r r� `" ;J y I. � t Q r , �i �• �^ ui\ 'ti j •1 t' � arc - Fa h 3 L C ? M • j �, 1 y ; is 1 7 �.*��y• 4 - .;>. 1st. �`,¢i S ��`ti:` ` .• � . x• f .he [`� '_ - +Y •ma .' l.' .L .y ,f` art/ .. ; . • ' G...a.) .,. . -- , +, ..t • * • .. `\, ' :- R • ;•: ••-•-,- .•• -.,•.•-• . • -- '• • ' 4 -•',- •--'' - 'A .. . • • . ...• '• t • .• -, - .0 S. • , . A- •••.‘• t ' - • . - ,.. ..- -:. • -4. -• •: -- . .,-2i. •.., ...-:. 44PC • -- '- • 7 - I- .' .11j1;1;k ..- . -. s 1 .. =.' '-.-,,„':',.,. '.•.k'. ..t• ... -.. ' . .‘....'N.2• .'.;.'.. •-'in• ,.... Z 4 • •- se•- 1 - . 4-` .•• 4. .X,,.• •. . c .._.11.t.'114.....410-s':1,:.,..1.1'.1.:,:141;'..,.;..:e::i.i.:1,1!::-.:i,.i..':..,......:;,,f‘'*.',..,...".,.:7.......:.74tst‘k..,."4...":. ,.,,, .,,,,.. .;}. .....,.'t..:ii.:17::......:,..:1.....-•..:::::.;: .k91:::-..1 ...Z;,:t7.......•lr,.;.11..:...1c:...I.',.,17...:',tli:::..'.7., t". ' • - •• ?. ..:41'.„ 1 . ... .1• ..1 .. . .' " -;- ; ,rt:!:•, .,,-- . - ,e-•, ...... „ ... . . - '1 .... -.N-4-7,-,. 15::::•t_:,. 4 11.4s...,.•-..., 4 .i...,. - '.."; .ftik..' • - .' '..-•L•'• ,..,•••&.!.-, . .. •, N.; • :.. .n., • ., • •- - '1.... ""'. . -%-.1 ....'^-4:41:9'144^" ' . .• - ' *. ..._:,...4,.Z...r,:Vito, 1" ' je'. • _ :tit.. •4•,..2:•• ,... c.- 144 •40.,!if . . S. '• mgr.; iit. ,.. t . 4. :----• --- -''4, 'a ,. • ' . • - - - - '• '*• -. * . * ' . . ... . ''''' '4 .C!:-.-:'`.',..t*.`r: - $-.,1/44,‘,...).; •., ‘,30,''....dzs - ' • . -.i.s • . --\„441T ' - , v,, ,,,,,„-,i .. • , :. .4 .... I.. „...••. •,..y, . .•••• _ • • •-. "lilt .-.`1, . '.1....• ,t'''''' ‘, ..,.. . . ..•. • tv ,-.. !-4z1S4 ...,.., • 4".•••• :-••• tRiA4 -,, tete- , ,.....A-,...,..... : . ... ..r . ...AS,: •••• • -2.-.1-•-•-• '''.:....:.'*, 4 • - v A :.).,. -"Wt. .... . .,•-•,. , '''' •..$. I 51. • r ,5,;,,, • '1 -- "'•-. .4, ‘4' . ..'• 71' ',-• .t&:, y_ -1. - ,• . , - '4 ... . J A-. . , ,.Vr.. ....:-.-.4.. ...* , ', .5",:- 7_,•4k. ... 1.- :•• - .„ - s • . ,Jr., ••••1..",.. . - ,.., \ . \ ' ' %.-.. 1 o-:•-,.' - . • •'774-'.15.,- , 0 .• i .. • k 710. % • A. .146$ , .iiji.it r , , . „„.....„, .. , " :. .4-•,--.. 710. -, - -",..Fit ••:, "..---Z.,..... -?Ik.4- Z - •/- . •,41+46V, •• , • - .,,, -..,.. -.. ,--, - - • , •-•.` ,... •• Itkia, . . . 1..i , /.. ....11••1 ,J.-, 4 .?.. ... -.A, ' .-0.7: t-4-•:* - -. -e' - t7. ..; ... • .. ,:....Nip- -r.,•%,-** !... '••••, .t -t, .• • .Er• .4 . •••• -...• I •••• .- ' - Z'`i'..-'X4,'- - "."."- -7 0' : 1. ' 1.4. V el. • .1' - - , T• , • ‘; --.'"P J ...Alt ' . •, -..t. . `... , ..i.. ' .11iO'r '.-''..";• -'-';' '- .--:0 • •'.' ''.--i '' ' ' i , - '411i1,. '.‘.. .., -•• 1 4•.. .4".-...• ' 1...,.!_.,-;+-;• -'ZI.L'...•' - .''"' . • •...4.• , : '-' ••%;... I: 'Y. - . •_ .. :. • • .,.'. . . ..,..7‘;`.., _,.. ...u- . '• •,- _....04.... •Ii- • ,-•- •' 1.. . ... . .:-..: . ' .It. ..:SIL , ...• . .: IIP'. ..4 • .4i.„..*' .kle,'. .'... '.;'11t. ,7 1.'•• - ,.. • . ... ... •• -Wk, .:7)..'`1 ; •'e :.. •:. • 7Z ).' .-.- 40....t.:1 ••• •,•''*, ) T:•-11.14.-,'-'11 . , ..4er....-P. . U. - - / -'- •- s ' 1.- 15:i-1%.•'• ':"‘. P•:. --- ' • ,...;.4 .. • ..1'..ir- ...." ' i,• : t., ••- ill ... 74 i4'.;1 0. . 1." 4.•••••.' .. ' ',Vat' '•• 4.".•• • ..., )*1 ..._„,,. '...'. r.;. ' • '" .."4"i r• '-4'• *,,•,.. -.-‘71 r-*ve,-,i'"•:- :.' • ' .e*:."-7 i ..,-...,,,e, ,,,,, .t..ai • •"0 - . % ---•... - •• ., -0••.4. '° .' ''''' a "4,10z, 11 ' -'- ''."'::-.. z..,,,...J.. " 'ci•'No yr • 2c:.-:,...., . ,06;2..-•so. -- . !. 4-.e.t• ..-:„....-- - • -- . lak . 1 . - - • - 7 • 4 --i•-• .r......) 4.:-.....:44:, • -414- - . .-. • .; _.-...,,,..,,,,„_____..pt x ..,, . .. , _... .4„..). . ..,..,....... -„Et itr • . . ,. • ••'.00 ,• , - --.T..-"... ...'•••. - •-..'es-1. ---r•lr-je...A.%,.',. • '•,:, - „data...,i1..,•: . • . .,.•.'''.:IN• '.. 4 • 1 ).' .'- . ‘-.. .-*''- -... .••• --''' 'It'• •' .C.•-1k---:- . 1:/- •-47,4 L i 'r,i, 7-• -,•... '''' ; % . • . -„; ......4t.- ..•- .-Ay,--....-4:-•:,,-1-..t... . . -‘• .-*Ls.,-..-. x-, .4 't • • • .... ,.•:.... , /.• ,: ., ,....k.... ' •- - ..'.•..3r4,. ....•.--.ID,:*AA...4, .*:..z.vs ..,.. . ... . •4. .1:......s.•.r.t.... _. • , - - -."- .. ....:' .•-.' ; •.r`',..?-: :..-,- :N-41 '..<.-)::,-;:- 1,.; , . .;. * - A....;• -4'r-1% -..4.!-. •A., .-31; '.4, _. ,. . -4 '. • :.... . :,- -,...4F2.1,' --N. : _. .• .:•! , .- •4 e'l• • 4v , , ,,. • A.,. - '`. f. - . • Ar • . ° `'ig •'• ' -'-':'' 'f\*:-i' ' •••,-1 ,- i-- •r...e.. 4,1k*.e4Q„ .w.--0" -- .,- .4- ..-- ,i-.-;..., , . P. , •. ...( , .... . • ....-ei. .- •.,..sot...•... . '-- -,-;••••':•' .-•-,-4,4 -,. ...• - ,q,• -, " - • :::„ • •• ..„, ,- , ,....,,,,-,. , . . --. - • - 1., - f- .„-• -e • $::. _.4.: 4......'.- ... .4t E. ' :•••,. , • . -340' ' --',4= %•,' •--..., • •'. .,.. " • '. :,,.:. I"'77...',-''.': -)...,:,-"'.- ' ' ''• 1 .; . -...."41t, - • .•- •' , ‘. .--'• ... • ts kik :-.1, ,• ,. , .1,.. ,. 'N.. 4:•.:• -. ---i A.".• - it l' - -,',•,..,14•: .-- -•• - ....• ,J4#‘ - .-.• ... '.--- ,it • -, . i •. _- „ :•• d ,iiii • ' • , iTsetfil•' . • ..,'. .. '44 • .•-.... .1 .-.--4-.-• 4,1'7.- .- '`. • '• -. 4- - '' •- :.-. :' et...e,i-.,,,• ....•••• • : ..r, . ,... ,...., ••,•.•:ir?..,-':v ..-. " ....• • --.. •, • %.,... t.- 4, tor.'-c s• -. .f.4.".:. .,•4'4-: . .. 414."...411k• .,.• 9-'19(..„1/1'• .-:. • c-4_ .4_ _ „. , '•• _... 444, : J. ..e 'S. ,tret.o/.- $. •14'..1.•,'.. 11....Z•si* e 11(h-Its :7"." - ;.:.'' • ,... 'O.,. •-.. _...4tk"'.'* • N..1-1.•'61..4'.f ..". ... J.. ••:".•lil •''. .'4. • \''.- ' ',.‘ '1/4.... • ' %-i•- . 01' "r•••••'!" •--'1..'. ilVi . -s• , •;•/.. .itiv,•;., #5.-v-::-. „-,.:.- .z. ; %,,_ - • . - ..• ' •• . , - -. • 4r7.1,qt...t*,. ,. „„..,,_,.• ,. .... ,..,. , . . %. . • - ''.4''4" ' • '' • 4.-t.1 s,. '-: 1,-W 44 ti-•••---`.,4 '. 4..i: • "; •..,...'••: -.-- • ,,,," .... • ,.. ...141fT. , .••••• • kkelk .. , .• , •-4. , p;ii‘. Ifit, ...,_ .. . .. - ,..•• 0 ,.• - . .. -. ; - „ ,, . - , • . ..- • • _ It;7.. :•;.: '17-4,‘. •.:.._-,v.• -• It .... ......-,,:,.., ,,,,,-.,,, ,,I.i...r.:,-,'... , . . . �� •ice. - - . - tf _. I/ W.= f • • k .. - -..# C� ‘1 ''..‘_,f : : ,j. . e. / - —-fit ` _ .., ,,`.:. ' ti J - I • ter.....- ....___e_____,,,-.--..............0-,...,.....; { �J ii7saipronc...0...., .. _ _ i .......,,,,r,„,,-..... 2 - HT ice^' , . - • N - s ... .. r.--- r J 4 -.....-jam-q b �, ti / -` , y - at j "!-•' ti 0.--,, _ .1.-- _ - 1 -''fir' • • 4a i } - t ..... 1 ii r (# t f.,_ { : ._ ( I a y _ , _ . _ i,° k � J IA 2 l' £ a r 0.1.#•• ., ;1 t'-• A , , 'II,. °‘,. ."..., . ' • , r. / , .... .1 4165f 4-4-41..7-4• ,. - . -a& • . . ...*. 0. ke, • 10.-- *ow 'l '4.14t\t`. 0 1 1. •COV :11 . \L'',_ to •I-wl.,,. * .,....,... 411/4 , 'S• . ' ,:-•• ' ' ..' .; **' •••••• • v" •' , • ' ... . .. . pi. • is . . -I .., ' ' - • If%)--* /,11$11 ***'". " ......, i k 44,.. ‘, ,'"- I., ,- .,•-• 7' '' '' 'Iv 7*N% .... ;' - .7‘ '41Pris-s' ••--7. - •. ". . -4PC ' 4 : ,, , ....:. .......... 0 . - • •;',.. . .• ,s' ' r, k' 7: ,•• • '"- ' '' , , ' ( '• '. . ''' :•••• '1941 ' • • - ". °•‘. •. 1, ... 1.'''" 1:: ' #joi."• 1 ' 4,44fe' 47 I ' 1.4•• ' I _ , , - :."Ird - , Jilb% • • . 46; ,,' ' - ' . -',' . " • 4.- .• " •,,,, ..' ,i,i+ . ,_ .. % •4- la-,.'4,_. ' 14. 'to..• ...-1. i• - i•-/ ‘•. • •''' ,.,• • ....... 41. • „It* .. -.., ., . ., ., . -.___,,•.,-..›1.,-,.. -.get- . . „. . - . . , ,..1..,,,,, ,,..,zi.. . ...,..,. - , (.. ..i... .0 . ...- , -.- .. ,. "I :- --$ I t . 4'V ''.'' ' 'g• vs. f' , .'lr.114C . .,•,. .1 . , .vie,. ,, iir .,54, ,c, . .,14 oot, - . . Iv . . j. .., .; .. 71: „-,, qi7.g, ) -ill • r. .. ... . . . .. 4'1,4' •V-- •""• •A-. . . ,.4.4/&\. • , •„.. •'.411P' -.4 ''' ) •,. • •• :. •Nt,- .. -l . .:- - • .. , „.'•'•t` . 10 11. . •!.. • ' • •• '_ • 7•ti„ •' Sc. S..4% .. . •' 7 A . . iiP• • ifo :1111 ." fi •. ''' ' , . ,A,L.: e,,,• .-74' ' • ' : •• ••• .. -?, - '- It.,, , ,...e.,.. . I • i. , ., . . ji $• .01 IfAN • • •.." a''''', 11 ' .-•' 7.1. :.44::!. ,..,:•..41 .1. • % - ' ''• • '- •••• .4;‘,•••'-.i.$ ••• •4 ! ' S. ''....* 7,t.:..,-.7.....7•,:ill',•• If'7 Tr'-;7:•I 7.: '"•0 • r • ' ' i ,,t7''• +1.4s,.. .. • -,...t41 ' 7'A7. "' • 3'....• . ..••••.• ' I • 'I lir ir. - ' • 7' 461' ,' ". 171 ''- 9.. ' f.teli.14".'• *.4(.6:. " .40:'I -.4, ,. ` ..• , • .. „IP*,A . ' .iltit4 • / '.,- • • za '--, . • .. 4 'S ., - .• .- •I‘Nil, ' . ;, .1 . „ •, ... ,:, ....410111, , ...3. . • r 4, ., ,.. 1 ,. '4'-••.•11 ''.N. ijr . - a . • •ttL' ••••.-• --.1..- ' • • . .1Ard.;? - -SZok,(4$ Ipt- . . ,. ,. •-• ..,., ,,...•,-,,,.. ,•11 '''' ' ' : • •• '. ..• 'r•I . .4 V.' . •..•• ' ''' •. \' ...t •. ' ' is ' ,• ':4-....,, '•177., ,,, ../. 1 •' .4- , .sr -: 4110!,„.. ., '.., . . sr, .. • . . 1 •• . • A,..,.- - If.' •:. - " *, • ...... '4! ,4,,.-. •• .1,1„,--- It,. 14 .'"40if . • , a.• •. -4 • ,..:.-*• ,f,'.61.f.''.. 7 -. .. - A. t. -'4.' •. •r.....,.. •y 1414.".'. . . . ..• • Ai' . , • • ' ; •.' . • '1:. .:; .lit.l'..›.- !•••.(e.....4 ' 40.'•. 11'..'.. • ' , '. 'X • \ %..., , I. :`,"`,t : . 4 iitha.....,,,, .. • , . - • - • Z":7. '.1',; ..•,,,,' • es " ' '-• .- • •4. . 4) • • ' "s, tv. • <41 S. ;1.. /.1t1..:.+:•• ••;# • -• a. ',It: Ifr. e 1 , V.,: Alla•Z,11/16 I'',.4.' l'''T.'7-:›sht:,::4.1;01--* • '. •, .. • ' " l' lk '''.... - ...141117i'•,,,••i: ' ‘-1 ''..• ..1W. -'' • .. .k '' „41154. ...t.if1.--. • .). • r1/4 'J•: . ,r,,,--,rt -ef. iv.lIci, . ,:, • 0••,••N•••• Tisa:. : 4, ,.t.0,1 .7. c'.''" I . rt. • a - . .' ..• '-- A.d.:',..•..i - 41. - ,.. .,-;Al* • .-r 4..'t iip,.. ,.,... 1:1,....,•,.'_ .- ,- '0„i.,‘ a* , ,•s .. - t ' . ; 'L, 7,+It•" •A: .. ril! ,;.',.f.94 .1 . • . ,''' ,, '..' . , '"• ' "‘••'"-,"'"? . '., - -,-. ,,, ..,i- - ; Irtie_it114;4'-!•1.riii.i.P.-7--. - '•_," •. ...,,,,......,,,, ..7 ,,. . ,....; , . .:. . . ,t .,, 5,..,..• - I . . ' . /4""..' - , ' ' ''..'.' !•:' ).'... 7- ',. .-.. 400.4 N'.: f.' .4 '':,;%I\''• . . .• - N . . .--. ,- . . 1, , - • )311 t•-•v• "":,.t.. •. - ' "er•-•t:-_• .." c 1 ,,.- , `: „Al' il: t,I---'''...., i'. -.-4 tiil'-.--,.. ,. • -,!,%-- ... ' ,.'-' . .1-1'. 112- , - r i•:• ». '- ..;,. ' ''i-14. • ; *Ar.' ' -'-' ;'' ' ati ti 7..". • . 4.441:" k'i .-,i•)•/ ,'\••--A- 'i. ..._Alt• '1:44.00 Af.e4 .••••12.•'.,. ''' / •( o ' . . -i. 4/' • ' A*V to, ' • li; •",..w• . 1 • ., A U . - .1 Vb. .: • • 11141.1t2;, J... ...i : , , ; . •"s .4'. Y. -. ,,. . • $r • ." ' • iNtri.4 4AL. 4• . *•" .,,_„ "?'4. ''."- 'sI'. - " "'• ' • -'• • 7,, •l''sic: • : ''' -.nil."' ;il -jp: ••• . 7. 'PA a• ! 4--'-:.- . j . !-• .,.,•., , • . • 41'..-1( '''' ' *Iv * '-trirt'AC ' ' -II ''' ''" •"frts1P1.44'', * '-1' -A. '''. .5te y - . .., :. .,....4.• , .. ::. .. .-., ...,, , ...,i..,,:_.,„• . i 4., • . . ..: ... ,- 4. 4..arA,..-' .- • ,,.a. - .. ... ..!-_..,..,,.. . . - ....,*.,.......,!, ' :.-7-v ...*:f ; - .,.; •.4..,...•.11,1'.... . 1 • •#,' - t.'"r' • . ''',SI ' , r... -1••• „ ., • ,, At'S' . •kr N ANN.g...., i. , • ..•... -- 4•,,,,. ,-4s, s I, ib-L'' '. ','S'. ''' ,:. 1 St--• : ., !I 1, ' 1e'31... •'' ..- ' ,s . I% ' Si'•: ' 4 • 111 4, ..... {1. ' '. . . ., ' '' . 10., . -.1 '• '. -•-•-, . ,. • •,-;', ; . 4'' . .;.-.V:-. " ' 4. . 'N' " s•';' . I e - " r . ..•• 151,0 * • I, . • . • '.•.' :-.4. • . f..s.K.. -'" '' •' - .. ' '..' -.+11L••••'''•. •• - • • - " . ... • .). ,, ,. ,,', . • • - • • ' . - ik• '",, '. i 41 .' 4'• - it,--• ' -• A"• • • • • ..1 • • ai•• - . • . ..• . F: "...*:' :,4 ----, - - . . ii , . 0, . • . , •••• . k,.... •.•-• t. . • • '../.•-• .?...,- .,:p.. - ,.,,(t. ..40-4, -.•1• f, "- .'i• .\-E• ". '' , . , .4. '• ' ‘AIR% - - • . • ir ..'. • ,,,, a . ,..,•:. u . - , , , IA,, - • • •+4 4", - - ...'' ,-. 14.. -./ •• :of t‘ . „,...• • '-'.. -.• 9•.;'' + ,*',., ..i•-ifirs::t.4 • ',F otig .i.,.... . ,4?- ._.., . ..._:,. .. • .... .. 4.. .. ri• . „:.ar.••-- i : t . :, .. • . ' , "• ''. a' , • .. •. 4' ' .1. r• ' 71.4) '' ‘-. / 4..•f,./... ' •-'• • ' . •-,'', ' • • 1! .' ''''' e° !t: ). itV • •-It ' y • ',0 ,z -*.i,,,„ ; (,./ . , ,i,.„.,.,4• ' ' . •,,.?..:',-; ' .' .,.., . ' i. - -,, . .'", ,',a .,. 4 ....• tt''',..' ,p'' y P'14.7 ,%). ••,-' 44.,,, , 7:• ' . I '. •', r, .. *it,:Ilk• ,' , •• . • , - ,,- •s , -. ,,. i - .C. '''' 1=N;2-..4 . 4 : '.!it-1:•,', ' . . ' ' . ;Jo. ft-,. • •• , Ili• . •• • ' ' * r*•st., • ;;rs .4, . . • . ,.. ' ' • , ' .,!. •- • ' '.." ,-..til,' ' • . , .- ., * • '„It • ..: 'A. r•••‘ % ,,„ -. .?, v. •,..,, ,.„.,• A', .1.,......,'i........!.. ,r, 1,1 j,. '' ,•,* ., . Fol 15, .. a ....• • ' i ,,1k . . ,. .. • ' . ' , :',' ;•'7'.‘ :'',.:•;?,A.,. , ei07k:74,•,' /11, ,....., „t ;..1 ,5.;3" tr,R1••."7.4.1. 17.; ' ;,. • 1,1 f• t•1,..1..;.- 1” - ,,•• •"C••‘,4, : :e •,.., ,i'• t *i •t• • t.s. k., '7•-. ,.•.i, , '• 'Lf.‘ -, -' i ,•4 r : . . -: .. - i.r:4, , It.,,I,:::(0_, 4. ,st• " ..;41'.... ..ili i . ' ...:. ..!.. ,., •74.1.-iiti, .r, 0.,.. Ili, .....il. i'...''' V.' i. • '. .. ' ,...'‘ A •'I.,..":.• 'i' ".- ." ',Itc:).„';•::4/ --;..4'" . '''- •. • , 7 '" -. -.;• 0 4::.. -... 0•14 ..:7%DSO° , ,,,, ,,,,,,,a, • , •. , I I', ,! * • i'• •V Ilk*. , 5 tr '. " •'.r"r'7,.k.'''.1,i'''•5,,-•.! I 10 '- ,,:. I;, , .0 •. ,o,, ,.. ..,e•.1, .."• 44 ' "14, ' • e • , . ,, .4 ,-. .. • .!,,.. . ... ., ..%,-; ,,.. .. . ._., seA, . .. - c' , .. . , .. ,„: pf ... o( rf ' j,. i .7: Awe .1 II - ,- itV;41. %-': !IR 1! - - ..3i,k' '41P '.. i . l Z Uik. ,• O' Ai * 4(11JV:A.Y4:1! ,(. . -$1 ' , ' '''' S Vi Pi ` . •••may'' r i .'� ?..^ '• � . r ' a• rt. :At A. 4.;-. - . it• •.;, • 'sV.., tivi I.. , ... , , t V. • « So • 1•� �.^.- ., 1 ♦ iii ,+ a •-i� __ i .'!_� �, .�. .. • • .ir . • .. . . .,"torppi, • .t.,%;1:0:04.,,,r.: 1\41itikt.,, , or I,, 11040 I Vie N3,7 k .....:.'llii•P•••• ...,-..i. lig?;.„0. -+ . • 4 :-..4,Y1 ..• _mi.....4,... • i..,11.. r+` Jr. " l+ +r • u�l , + r . `� m `t\`• L '` '. :i. 'ati11� - „o• :Q - _ice' Ii.� ' r• ••�. 7" • , ` fit 1.•• ,.. • . 4.,. i. ,., . :. , _.-., . :.g. ,..--....,:` ,..::Jr::-... ”.,„ • • • t• t r•• �. ' . w testi �, .V -t— .. r �' w leric. l. .���,� ? I. }.G r:.. '._,I - O. • • „lilt- -,.. -t .,sitet,N •'fir',t'i �. .�ec�, � � .. • f.••" . ' .. • • • 4 • �' .::_a '� .4:5-1 ��i�,t 1 e t A • . •• ), � • 04 .i .t sal""'•' • ?t , \ • SA4 r - r y 7q' 6". ' 1 ' yti+.. • s.. _ ,ikit. r A " t , 'n _ r ._ ' 16.,...k:/‘ It .41,,,k. ,c a .j01? .; xi.,, Ati3 A1)J,•, - a' i , tom.. ^ D:T• "• `,•t Asi. • • +2 a�!_ tw T {, / « : ib•td f -� • K • a :7;.:;; ''.1c;,:,..1.ii*::: :-: '742' . ' - `Un.f . Y ,, ..:4 c, 7,4;7 s� � ti: .A: � : +^ f } • , •�- r, t.- v: - 4 - , -ice• e - '- t�^ " .ftipt,ig '• -, - T • _.1...,111-4.--- .' r + ,pA '', t r 4106 tS.' -*, ,. - `w-+ .. .-y to t....;. t — •, .y • . , ,r O yl 4,....,.., • " meq' ,fit, �` J y:: —ki.- '..• - x i s • .'• r v• y t a �: ast, ;n. R 'e ' t• 4� •ZI- ' •V, * ..,y _ �. ...•syr , ,* ' .N.ii::.,.....,_:: .A .r ....,, . . , , 1 J Y.. . -1..•: • eiIt • - _ ?,�,' `_ s 1 .��'•.Y9 : •. y,i t' •1 ,.`Ii, ---Ji , . 'x ti .may[, - liiie . ., ,...... . .. . _.: .„_, __A.__ . ... • : .. .. . ... 1„, . ... ... . . * * ..X.• ,, • . ..• 4„;,.. ...,,,,,. .., • . . . . . ._ . . ..„,:., .. ... .„... .,__ : 4. -..• II a . N. •-4 -r• ':j, •r'. y:. • w,.'.=. f t- f 1''�•, y,�a�: ft jlt:If 1' .:, ,_le.,.....,.__...._ .. - - ..L. ''''.. . ... ' -s '''' ' :. , .•,-'::".. c:.1-. ;-:-‘4.::: _.- :-.'-'1-,, -' :S..,;:,,:t:. :„.„. ' 141.:;.:::;4.: ,,,.v, , -- ''''I-!. ''. . 4ti- ,. . .,,,.• •Vile:—.- ...1.,,,- a.44trlitz, le.,-...--.:.,..t. :.,.-...,...,- i y .,,,._„,...7.,..._. 4...,,,...,,,, ,,. . :til,.. .... ,th (iptit.!. --:.."*.-,•----• . -1-‘'''f...:•-;', '•,t t "'r , i, •�}{�'' -.:41,1&11.,, ...IA `j._jZ* rp !`''* -:•-,,,:',.‘':‘........:4‘... ,a�•. t,�` r� • • Ar11* yy r 'om�' � •�Y r -+) t '1.0-'4. a • • . t _ . , - - • .. -.T -.- -.. ` ` .,;«ter L;.•-- • ;Sr •if4v„ i• -f ?• -01 V•L t �f -}' �` ,r ` •!'JAJ,� '"r• ?r. °Y yil;, .rt- ;M y ` tfa' A��,, 3_ �,,1` ! rj :.•,,,-;.•,..."--: ms` :y -v . tl.it s , • • y , yr ; < Sif"!�i, '• r,y.4 4. ,, ,4{ • %.. ` c 'tl ` 3- { _ ori C * .• ♦ 4J'. - - �► a • : ':' t • x•=•Op �'r+J `If t r.3'.4f... �s • • •-•,:a.-.;_..i.:-.4. f. � - _�,' ,., e-� ,.„.,„.,:.,,,-,t, E• c; % '- =. �;' 1 . �iv' ?• '-a'�i ce'... .i' • :1-A.. il sA .- b � ' 7ct . .r. ^_ Jx' -'p. h� . yt3ys � •" gti . -I! ii-4... f .Itc fS s_ a. ;p �fi yam � "( .NSR-` ► - rt �i. ". S ;' � ./ � - ",• + i+- LIi • ;It .- . ta, -• i 4 ". •1•• .2 P�.;:. :-1), _..4' t •-• • ?a•-f - .. • 'A. ....,,-•,---`•• ► • • ,- -.4- . <.-.' . .. �+ • 4 :4 4 s-, .r,- --� :'r ). .rte . ° .•• • •.` �• . ` : •- 2y `.,moi? a• s .. ....0.1ki, 4c.t.:. -- • - .--. ',..,J. - '--. • ' -41t-,410 ..t. .,• „Iri, y -'� . .--.141.4-- -,,--4„-- • 11141 --__ =`" 4-.. ,. , •',_-e. , t l�.' - ,..4.• 4-....;..„(r. .• ..A vw ,� ,. 'r .y, , i -�_ ' If� .4.. 'v�" •", _ -s i • • ;�} =fes '4 kip 4. •r` Y-SY ? ;r ef' I' �-. f. - yam _• �,- i Wit, • ymoi. lt . ' 1 +# . . r. `, k,g ` * - t/ - a.. . . 'G - . =r 4 • ' . 1`' • • ' •- � � Ch e `` - �, • "0654741"A ' • '411: .45 i:.4- ' �Q, ?� • ".t• .. !'t•. • _ - •.d• ' r • .a �...Ar • -•<• • t -wry T. • - r•.. y: i- . � • % � -,.,. , . g • `!1i r - ./ • 11 i A y0 '�14 7 .,7, ' ,r.:.•<, .Ira - { 'l., 1-, x•,4 l -+• , ..-"f - ' J �, _ ` Z,T , F, f. ,9 ..-_40 '". r i ♦ -=.i ', '''It ,} . ,R.- - • 17 • • • A t'Jr.i'•4 w - •. .,1. .... ..a... ,,�: +� .::.• V. r i . pc •N 1`/ r•. '. . ,'i-- ,„,.,. t ' ' - . . , Ai- '' , d, „7. 4 *., ...4 _ , , Air, • .;of • -,11-1 ,,te . ''-.4 :: ..:.' ' s'• 4, ‘..., 1,,Ilt Air / I A. • `t ct; ' - ., 7Ff '#-'.'F =. , .iv:i I•,• 4 /f hK�.• ...of- . ' .•4,.1 1`•t. • • eta t ld k + ' V -I /•? '• .,--t.ZIz • • . • / ' ii .... . ,, .,i e, It, . tv L t Y r 1 y►l' , "i� -a �.t ,, ,,}I�� `'- ' '� + ` 10. .. �,'... y !4 til" %i,i' . .7 .• `11 !i►; t . 1 .7 '-_r vl�y. ,4 .?g.,q• ..4 s s �,�, I. a /. . •1.�,. ' j. ' �• • .'t „` ...mfr. ..i:. •• 4..!'-:.:: 1';2 41 Yt' ;'l • ?rte , - 4 {, , rA ti' .} ti} ♦. r. Y � .r iMx d r 1 s,.• 7• E ` t >4 > :::4,,,'''.4*...;*:.......-,i � y' ••r• � •S. 7� .i ,,,,,..•r + �► L . '4+t, R� r 1 • 4 i J. p� 4 t ,T' '*~ .•,, o o ' f. i. . ,-1, ,i I -s t { i i? i. t I' a ,*! , : ski, •��J• • •. 'illN� .• V d ,.,r tir s t. ,Z...,4.• '•' :4,� +�i cra. '«' yam. r � , • I. .. 44,....11t L '�• 7. ' i '•• ;, r *' ,� he r , '{t, ms- _• S_�' 1 7 y �� i lx= y , i 4. t N' ,. L r or, . ..;„....,,, • , • • • • .1� �3 • r•-,' - .: ' '4,. 1 !• alai 1'., r;a'I tiG , 7 t re ?t i, I• 3.4.. ♦ l } • " f dry 4 „ •i .J • !� A .► w' t,. ••` L ARr, `� r 'a ',14 r 11 •�,• t 1 `', �._.• ' / .. ' , • j�. Via' ��, , '. ! w 1,� '� J .�. `�'t1.7�tr�M+ f�,., F, _ l } `I •1i ,� ,I t' ft'. f .�. , 6. I1 as• ,. •'- 1}�!]f it• , •("�"4\ \i.. " .}'. r S. j/� ♦, �1i y �kr jS i • r aft', Y¢1 �; 1 W.rf ,N v b yY • .��. ' s • ;el' ), 1..1: - : . , A ,f ''• t, I. - All • • • • . , • • PeX. • .. •--•• . 711 0 . : • iltft . 10, I r. • , liF P'• . - • • ,4 4/* - —- e •-• ...op. • ' •,_,.• .10 .15. 161 . - ,.., 't`'.;• i"'' `• • * . •r! ' •at • 41-e* • r Tr 4.: 0 , . . 1 , 'M • ••• , I , •** 'die 4 1r)-.' 'vv., ,• 44 • . 1 - `• .. • ' e#. , • 11, jow: . ..I. • - ; , Tit. % I I, •r : ,, - , ..f , • . ... . . 4- - , ..-• * • 4:'•••, • -:.•4, - • - ....'- , -. -.. , .. . - . , • , ... .....- ....„ e . • -,40, •4 • So• • l• - c.-4• t . . ., 1 •• .1r1.'...0 i s• .VC* .1 . 14,-.12 i,pe aqm•. 3••. • 440‘ 4-Nt * . 4s. rAr 4.4 - • lip— . '• • ;• *cv • 4 P.''• "' VA : S. S. . ,. "!...v v. - ilf. .''• .."0 " . . • • •., . /0.. a- 1 - • 4 *1Ir 4 . 4 • • -• — . . 1. lt,•‘ `..:-•. - :, , h• 4 N"44 ! •J" • .. . . • _. • ' ' at.17„. 6_ -- • 4.411—°. . ) i"%"' g. •• 1 le 0 It. ... . ,1 ::litl A • - . . . ::. or' J?.1 ., N •• ' • "tr. i'' - kif ,- -., .. -. , - - - - 1 t. r •I• • ...•• • s -e. ,e,_. . v_ - • : s.: - rs• It V • • ..' . `.t.ylf • ..,`,... t• •. At :44, 1,..s. . ' . 46 •f. .! ' ....' •. • i r '4.1t. '. 4. . - .4 . • 11416' t• 1 I - d'r 1's f . 41. ' • o'. •1 IL% • ••II • 10' . . ...• ' ' ' 14 4: . .1•Figii • . 'dik* • ....C' " ., : ‘.• '0.' ,.. •• ' • ad• . 411\ -,11 .• I •drit ., I ti• 4 OS',.. ' a ti A112•5r ' . 7, \--• vf ^4P ; ir Yi e V'IV tl -'— •• 5" • .• . • ... ...--- - .. t, i. . ... , i* , .., • •• *IF . ifir S ...—. irf * Ail .$ • t.. •i• .. I . r.. • , . •1'•••• ..'. •. •• •,. . • Ilk• , 14 * 't14 .•;*Aer .' 1 IP'$ • 101 , k . • : . .vt._ .. . 2, At ...P. , , , • • . •*t.. ,- . . _ . . u. . k • s•--c ;L. ..' Ira/ r 7.• 1Nr, . . : -4, ••,• • :r '1- •, /10 Ati 4 k aft • .3: - .,• ,;#1,k % 4.• t -,0 , •'- r - - -0. -• :IL- • ilf •• ' • ••••,- ALIt, . • -•-• 111,1 -. ' t.- . . , .• .. evt - , •. . ,.., c • - . • i, • .-: - 4 s • " t"-$11,,A ' , - ,:lbil...'46. • - illt•e'r••• • ' •••••1110 5* •-•,. ,t -.. • ..• a ' '7L..; • - 1,.. - s fi . - r.'01. • , ••.y. -• - , ,. . . — •••07 .e. ' ,r. • •••• ••-• ••••_., - "•Ise-- /44* ..it: •"' , # it $il A , .1. ' !. • .1.- - •••- 411roc„. •- ir r • • .* .•••! • - ' •-• '' -... , — — — • •, ' s '' :0t d , ... -ke 4% 1 41,_ 111j .ek • , •- ` • :AI • :• z•1..: • • .... •A• '.. T .- . • •it . r . . ,.. • % 14, . ., - . •.• •• ' 1 t • r . I ..• - f ••• 111,,• • " ' ' • I ) , ... ...4. . .. •. ••• .I. • 11. . . _ ,i •••• 0 • • ••,p . • • t 2 • . - . ft"' ., .• .• / ' t ... .. .1 .. . wor; . •, 4,4 ,.... - . ' 4.:•4.0 t. ,I , 11 111" 11 ...._ . 1 • .a.' * • -+Il : ••• tri, P • 1 ".."4111111111L' ' f tilt..(i .....t. t I • 14 r' •-: . i - '...P‘•‘• . 4 • , . . ‘• 1.• '''. P"'' •• l• • .81. • go ♦ . imps,• •M `+„� .A.11':Q • c`\xy1YP;;'ir ,S. f -,, r..� y L. ,'i 'If � l•l4MI • a . .• _ rr • •:,,..-.N, • „," -A, t. 4 It oti, Y.-A. • :-.‘v... ••iit, v... ,,,,...t.,b., . . At. , • . . .. • st- �...Ik r . I •,./*, h.rY- - ?• `.,`i..+• \ Mt'. i. e Y • t- ter •',. •. 1. _ ` •, • • ` i..., 4• °, i , It:• �� &` ,�y! , Itn....:-0,- ^.Ti,-.1r I.- �.• • r t.+ - ^, ,{i,,j .•' 4i •; S'.� • Y' J�•-,l'l IF+ :Y" 4k•. .. '1 10� ' ••,. i+ . F • r. tk z st4 IIF. r., ,a• i .`• !f" �= t _• �'r, i Y `^4-• . ! • X •• .r Z • J 3 il ,tri. I�J • -�{'�,7Z x•h� «` 11 r •` t, ~. I G_• .—_,.: ..t1*.,t '. {' t• ••�'R .i _•/ t:r ,r.1 �.� r Vi i,.0.*:'.'�i • • •s. ,� . y; r •.itaar .. -4 J '.4\.' # ' •'Jj • ►G .. ," 14-1'`..- ..4,4 `L • • . . .... " ":"4 %,'. .r 1 .41/41. ... 'i �G ` • Yp(+ -fftt .- c � �1 • �r• rd „...g•••..,-,1%r r ^..•:; f' ':1!�' .... : .?•4, - • Y "`f d %a das` t. - � �� i^t r : •� `rr _Pt ...� • ; ^� ♦_ it :rida�, ,C `� -zi.,_ iii • •.i - y 1 4.-- ,cst� .f; {.��.-1 41:444:,, ^:`�4x �,`IT _ s em•,v.'� il. t� x a” �'�` `T'.••�- am: "T7-\ -4.3 ,or-,,,,...: Ya ' •a ' K'�7�.• ,,.i-- ..,"0'�ti^ - •, •.-._w864c:•• .R•'• alter c-; - -.J =- v `'` .. ' �,` ti - �j�t .t�v�, .. •�s- ..�:R .�•7�': �ii.�.r� 'a'•` • 1' rc'T •• �" • if- K. it k , .°".1C-1.-i. . ►. •�i e • yi( !,+'w. ri ? •.,ia`.v i. , sem,•. =' .-,,,, L .- i i ,.may! ' ,y .r- ?*at,'),.---•: r1 -r - !- *- . • t+ M Lair '� 1 LL � ' i i•�Y xikost`r r al- • • .+-• ``y� 'a'-yt �1 f� M +1 . -: , - / !.c t- ' -4= • ,. ?44•! . �• •1 ' . , r f ; - 'I•` t i • / •• ,.._ a +-. y1� . : E 4. sa , .ct • ,. w : s ^ � 1 ii, f• � : it -ii, • • 's , -44‘�{ r r ' t , .' .— . 41r " • t . a,. ,'-iS • j ., ".1114, 4.4/4 , ,,a..' if. t ../. -.1•!_ 4,, ' . 4,0,•,• •".- ... '''' -.04. A.,„ -,-,.. -- t t r .Zr • ` r r, a•; �� •� �s'V�' ` S' .� • Jt ?1 +•^�'� i. i r 'r. r k "`t - r -.4''' .d •' R '` I /4.�+` ..1 •:1,4:;.. t l ,. y�•,- 1 3�" GYM ".,_ w.t A , fit- ,' : ?"1>•\ 41 41 1.,,,44.4. .d ., • ,, ••.� ''• .y'_ k.:`4. ;A .. ��" ^,. w' ' .Y '•' . lk,.\>• `� \] ''kd..,i,:S s4,,stil41.P.... ``- ,,A : is ar > - ' ��± K,,r ' •• 4:,,i.,:4 • 44,, r' y .'4' n •IQ` .�[, 1 }l - - )',i4 ..4,� -�„.. .,...........0.-.....i • Jr�+ `� t'``• • Is 4. i� • 1a1�•( - ,. ��_i _ � ICI i• �� ' . ; +�. +M ',1. ",t, '• -+ I� + �� •i!' '. t,"w_CI•3i r • .`if n a,,�SL.:••.�i.Yt ,�4r - _ • '/ r.r r'H_ - 1I ' 44 +. . N1.y - .1 + <kPte. •: ?'a• _ t .1 KT: ,�.VJ'\t 3 t 4 .}., /44,w �,,} r`i '.;mo i • iii- .+ ' • -N. .f. , " !.' 44. 1�` • • J qr :N R' LAS . t•.' F:... w' f QE ! ! t •' Yt ;�:.- - ,moi.' • �.y+-�'�. .4- • .?' t►� z+_�a�:f'' iw� � f _ V f • • y ,. - `''1'r Y_' .�_ <'!`�i�I...7"-,•1?!:' � .►��� '� `• _,.. •"J'�� '1. e Y -,,-..--`t:. L • - • �- ,' ,'. t''�.. -.;i.411-.. -0'0 r- -1 *4- .,.... _ y�' • • /' `1r.}Vit ; ' ? t ' i � \_. r , .. .z • its iitv , ..... . 44.-.1---- 4,11 •:'.,1 - 'R,. ,,•:,, �t '', ,t 'v .t s� '1 i " r. 'tiz. ‘411{ ...,' 1__ , Al._ '�'`�•I� ,,,,'^`�y,, r: • , f' f 4q. � . � 9y '.• Ly: `!1 1■i:' r Az x; 7/1 _ �fti f- 3%it '•' `2 •.''tea., '-''- ,Y'4 ~.4 ,. ..j. .-"�'i. `"s. •/ `.'•. . • #Y -.• -cri• ". -' -- �^ } t • �_ • tic` y! 4Y ` ✓l. " i` , a I; }�" r t, , ,vj w s,` - lioft'' r - '''.' bl. --4.. .41•16'• -4., ',4-i=:.,,_• 4.ar .,.it.:"`r:-,:i-Zkt‘'*5 .t..•i --_ • ,.0_,•.,• • • - -�n qt I. „�, .r;:-,`"9t . . .4.-5y,.+,'.,, .w,• '-• " s /':Y.. et .. .!4, .`t• •,..:. •.it- • i - ,. ,'f. . . •4 7-::�: •,��a.,F"'`., i`i4 ,,.,,'.• 'Y.Y� , !f l- .t 'ir '. • % lir rr ti•j •••44••• i v ', rF: 'L4 ''}i ç- S. . - •% • • . R . . `jt f -• 2' ' k , y - ,,.,, ', • • t . ,-,..• — - _• \.•Yt,.. ; v'f4hi r r'� -__,r;_" _, - „A. -. _-A, '` y r. a l�j 1/',,e 4. y f ." 'Q 'i� 1,..:,,•- .,,,f...., x /�. � Sim r • y�e - f 1 4;t• \ J �' q • ,••t `3�rr O.Y. y,/� 41 •. lir r.'_ � +,- .'��+.`ill .. '. .r. . ��. -3 •• y•j�911-�•.".. ..1:;i..'4-'• :V �,1. ..1. »'tt•.- '�•v�-*,� •�1 �> 11, ti tr' j .. • ..vifipoi,-,r- .' �' t� 7r •` �tJ� ,L I.�•/ '�rk`Tif) •'•�.) i Ly.. .- Y` •• 1 .1 q�•I„i ',S.'g .i• r 1 1.A 4,,,,,,,,....-_,„35,: .y. • ! fib.-t l,� •. ;lint� . . *I • -- . 1 ':- '''': ' -4: ..- , --.„ .,-. V4,1n4--• tf*. ''' tr''' " * .n. - G;1T _ ,�1.-. _•r 'r>� it O \�`ti},Yr iT.l�' .., l ,fr• j+.•.�`•gl�k�`f -r'ti .... - t _ ., rt` "� - � ,Tg t lql•�� a 1*i' .1 r .' `' �'f• * � �. ��III���t�h./,,,,,..,:;/ 4 ti j j Pr •7 r ,1y a ' a� 4wJ V. C.� ' ��. .�r• ..j � w ;I.t �';liy` s, f r,77; sJ..Y11,f�i j p•', "5 � q.. `• !• cf . 4, .• , r4i,V i • tea' y%l • ..„' --7.4,7 Sr•' ,� 4 •-., Ve ;�\.. ,*� �a F b 1>,'• �. 1 . ‘ • • •,,Yr! It • • w7 'SY. f ' •,J., , A + '✓=_ '!r '��. ;1. ., y'• '.,„„f„ .,.,.;....4. 1 r ,, -. '.s1l;{!j f r • •. } +i 1 i. ,� .�•.-r;, i i i i'!!'P, •r i - ''' _3 • s. 1 1." *rp,4 'f♦ • • L '.�J • , y-(, :' i' ti+�f f,�t,. i(r �k „,.;,-;.4,.'.• •i.' , • '' ,,, . . • .�'r ?. .? a i+' p! .. 3�0 • • .a ' .. •1+t s '::•4• iv, „,;-1-4',-. ,1'' 4• �c4 •.l 1'T �7'. r r L/ 1 , • „r 1� ,• ;.1,1 ,y • 95.` ,, V4. ,., 1 ^.`..11. t - •. •vl... • • • •• y •• • & '.w �i 1 s� •vii, ! 4/ !+'U� 4. vet* • "�+ .ie' • � i o.4., -',.;,,:,.. --• \, • � • 't• <. 4 •� 'r ,� :i. Y,yo: .: -ir>r.•'i. 4 C;..RL�• � � •c i ” y �.1 r # ` • K ; y`+ r i * -rte ,,,,,•,!, r 1 ti * ry • Y t r ? r i (. ti• 4 • '...�f fr!'<}a�, • y,• y,, h /r4 :P �• r 1 ..••* '• ` ,•�... �i 4r r +� +i �f'',rk . 0#4. ,,,0:. ,. -. .:;4-.-2,,,,::. ,-,, ;�` r. .4L` f' ai�7 ; f>•,'ti i '1,., i; .:0•x' '' '' -.• '5. ;t h.°.;.*/.1;.Mti':'' Y'+�*�" .' "4;1 4 + �c �,�.l.�• ,. i�•� ��y�':' illJ'?' J ,: �..,�. .. ,J�'.• 5;,,,•*'e ` •',~` �,'• - •�y } (� ,�•�,.(. 4.9' yr yZ/�r�,,+ � `. `• �'7 .i. � +.7 r�•' f. 17' •• t4.,. ✓ 1 .b, 1 •� • 1 ` 4,r ( tS'� •42' 7+ •'T' 11+r„•},�' ♦ t..� 77S s- - 'ia. r7 .f ' ..~ 'ar• 1 1 '3 . } � '�'1c"<`Mtia f!C Vt. T `"!-,•` � E. , t �`' 7r • '...41 -• .., t .} .. '44 ''' 1 r+'j �� .Yr "��.."p411 •: .. `.'r '? .} 'R ,`, 'b{ CS 91b • ,� -r-yr.' {14 _ }i • ,16. •, 7G 5,i ,`.• �.•,„., �+ . yY t 7"It'1, r •ir" '`.,. ''', ,..,.A-Pet.; ,(-4 .4 ,. . ,y/ i 1*. Ji^' mit j• K�1 a'7''�)0,,.'1./. ''.•. 4 �f V ',',r-•'1 '• pirr5 �. .'for -'R • s.cr_ '�.p{ y .�J '�'�' • t r � �Fb , ,,.:4,..,,', � 'f4 k"� , C +�� :LIr •.....,41.4;11,..;:,t , i' yrs rrr {+a�r J'w 1 rte +'�. '� I. ...,, ,-:.:,... .:0,1,r...! • f. s 7riti:1,1� �. V7.• 4 '� rp 1 Yf ••.� • .A , T .' * 4•-, '�Fy,•{.��~ ,�.•� A r." � -'� +,,. � .( i• �'�`�>:vtir �8.' -ti`f•f� AY�•�+, � .. ` ��,c�,�••r �•� , s .:.•tif4t. fr•J, y'' . - r1 •.i? j a .'Y .� >✓F ..--.,,!'i!! r't,'a- se }, ',?,,, •.-�� 7 ,;t�y r 1' '. ,1� 1 ,y1 ,• �, .fir • ft - tom*{ 11 U r-�.•i !' f +l!- { 7y 3'y. '3�'Fti 'S •. • f". Vi- 'i i ., :felp. � 4 1, •41•/ tYt ,t ♦ �: �r M ,11, •� , •- �,:r `r r •� 4 tr ,i :'��;.✓' 0 :1 .t.`v: 'if ':' ,•6r w^ s � s ‘! '.:-' .1'' �'�r }_. :'i '� it • .� •� Yi 7y� ' ..1<11. AC•:t ti. 'rYr rR kr', • _ i�' 4 '` . . LC"'1 •y,., • ty ... :r �' '1 f t.r . ...:4,11 ;!'... • •. fes• ;�, ' • ` � ^ t,'rfil� t . r . . ¢ r •,�} '1'\. Lr- i...-,4:3,i- t Yf ; \ ,00:-..-. r i� . Js.i , "D ' 14.1. .1,11 1 • {:", y y( �. >r �� !' - �'• , 4.y s y-i y .,' J 04 i 4. ilfai • N..,Wf lat.. ,4 • •'I+' ' '14 ' 4y • ,_( VyV tet'." r ' !,; .. "i-p r. -Pt-'i,. ,,,� II • • • • L ( A 11 teirw ' •'1f .w °♦� � 1r'N }111r �+ • "���L 0 h r d • it , 0.. '�rpt' �` .K , f t' �c1 ► (' a 'r.'� +•1 v`ti� t IA" V a,"•1/4''s y 1 n la''. 4- i fq �, K el {+ ,�' ,t'Y''• r , '•t r, L td._• v �int / 4, • • Ir- 'r�;' i t}%� •� � �', .{�� i1 1 • • Ne 4 3 e, • 7" • • • Y t f ;,, •.1 ^ a . ( t 4' le"• c .'' • r c.• • f•. • , f, ,. Y 14:.f.'„,404 • a•`Ih" t S` , , y. ! / n %i .. > t t� Lx t„ yr A ' . r� t •� 1. • • • y 7 1 �14 . ,{� 1 ` �, , - hir • . . f , { � !� , A4r '�' ' 'ra. , \ �'} • I ,. ,.hr 4:••,... , 0:. , c. . wV44 '+ r. �'''�j —0,4 ¶ j • 016 • ''. , .1- ,, ti t, '•� '`fi '1 * ' %t ♦�"'y , Y [R r / ..y", � fW L » t `►' 1y • PIN /r •', 1 • y _ . 1, r{�.ry �, • f ;( ' ; i ,iiiiiiity �� �Oi• '• • �,Wim <�.•+,1� i '`.. v -, ♦)1 1 77, S ' - j'�' % • • am40\ • • `�e ' � a' Sa • � urj , •41144"4. � Y♦l: � - 'Lil - .�• ( +, •.'4 1 41. [. •tn ' I , •• setaNit ,i + 3 L/y� telill • � , ' .... - •t1 , •,11,E 4 �A_. .� .l ,.. 4• _ 70, t • w��1 .1jsr �). •• S •• ft , `9 9.• . r 'A,, J •'. f �� • t r , . rtw,a. � 1 ,.S.- .(..'�G {. r ♦_ y , r + c • •� 41' �. .. ` tiv � +�� � I 1 \ f ;r Vit ,�;- ' 1 - '..� M , ! • 't v It . -ry ^` ' " �-' ° r y, I ' J * - l i.L ,./ I' `�' 1 ti .• i. -i' ,: I dy t; ri� L l + ' �* • .•s � r4 r,,ti '& � r if ofiioczyIlk- .,, `t_ , 44� i , 9 " ° ' }. • `-~rf In. a' y •• 1• , I A • r: f , r • `*..`, i y • y, .�ia.+\ _ ,,,it' -- j/ -.% 7. `:`41""°• , • \..• - At Ai y' . _ f �,4 0� r`"r � .4�1:4)4...' • for `; 0. � •. ,.. r., .[•,�..y]�"•� A' .:s 2! t•.., r, Aft ` �.- M • • '1 w • ....App, A . ii��/e``�t .,',. r ' •�1 '8 •' \ . _ j'"t��+^ :�" •.•�i r 7„Y a �','- •. .�i. '. •tel}•..g• '. J�, • -II •I f-• ++ ,'r. y \.. • "�\ • • '��.t_ .,C,,, r "it 'r L" -.'9 h 1 11.41111.0.4.2"� - 1•••••$f 'x•'r '�' \ - r µ ...T.4.'� �` J'• '• • .• • ••.." wipc rf-r-"1 • ,:,....4...„^..„ � . - • Y � i l • , � � •'1. c • . J ' 3 ''t • $ 'f• ,.t11 7' 5 ', , • ' '.` • -,.• � i t rr� r„ A 'n r •„. ' . l h :'.44. Y -a ” `j,• t i : �,�.:;if6 . ii . ti , ' r> . ti •' • KTt ' ' i r> ty1 ` t '. �Ptf , 7� ' a.. t mg • • • • �. \h. ,.•:-,- ! .\ { 44 t • �•) !. ; 1-..,t,•1• L yid`# A l , .... H 7 .r„” I•:or, • `.i.,—•.,•' .Ri ,) , -t 4`A ',,:a.4y , i� y_ i}` i .d'.• • I'R•»' r r•• �i�• R . { 'r • y.. • Yid•• Iw 4. .� d � .,.+ ' .�• of: . rl. !.` ••a' K ?!* > ,.•, tri" F • V �T 1•'' _. a.. �, �!' +.•+li.l '' tt �^ -..111:'..7 i .-111111#:°--.17M6'-: y�/�+;yy n f.. • v. .: , .. •, y "':•y,,,-s,t� •,t, .� .,` t .c,_,''C+u. ' �. v.i�''�,�i j a�' bl444: i f _, "'1` } r k. � ' Y -1f t n,:#*/ ,r... 1 .: • ..K y i � i' - � K-•• „ag • p _ � `Vt•+�►M;;�+•.a �,Ilik i TAr. 4 ��• '`s em` • .. - .w' ., a.t .i .,.i . -`4.- '1 SCS. 1 ' .•, ' .ft ,'1 f• *,.,1'` .V1 • •-•:-..-:. fis•� :Zi .6 . •.,[ &.� • • � - +• • a ` ' 1 '1 t.^ ,1+'` Vii'• - w • '4.6 • 5 .-_,. T 4. 46.7 .,,'_y = �' _ i •y. « - :rt ...- •,- •,` • • A'e f ^t 'fi + i • ' ,•t • �i\fh t• • .L i. 't t1 • y ••414' .---..1:-...., 1 ,�'y. i t r • ' • '`r .”. L < + • ''..1,',,c1" ij• `. '1►p.«Y Rte` ♦', • ,'J Y 44-t•' A. {{•.,(('"' •A. • • if, ,. 2...,4., . . _4'.,- . . . •,,.. ' - ',.4.i. . •r.s. •f, ....., V,V,' ,i, - 49,,.)..iri\t,.,..` , .,,,.% •,...:.;••,"Pt•t:., .."1"46,.1.114 i' ii.'14,4,..,47.44,'• ••,. -'''''.-: - --r ••:••'..,‘,•. , N. ....,_ , ,,, , -). - , . . .,,,, . .,_ ... ,. . , „„, • ,... .,, to, ...A -.., . • is,.,„, ,. ., . _ .7,, , _...,, ...... .,,. , .,....,- :-. • . - "ti_ o . ., 6. .. ...si*. ".xt "".,.'s,•-c-, P-- '. "• , ♦••� }.... _ t"f• tyi ,.+'.fj'.' '.. 'i1+" • �-. V \t - ter•• i ''mss.+ 1, T r A ;i S I7 �yw� a`' • a j •�y�; y�• ,r� "i�T ry `'. , r , ll , �t 046t, c 1;* Y f i ' ,I,*}7^ a • \ !4 .1 1,� 4 _ `` �' ,... . 411:1114kie T .,,,:--41,\CNIV. 4\.t. ik'j N• --') *410 •ike \JINPOP . 1 t A 1,„ A 1 . • . • )41, d are....:.,!• y• .. • 1, „; �. ' :i1f !► c. '' ; a:'' , `' c. -s ,::`.....'..:,"I' .: - ."..,•,. .,... 0,__ ,-: ' .... I * •.:7,1..,‘, 4' ,.• K,• •', 4• .t, . �X4. .4�"1• is -..• ".4 g••' . - .•,.. r.6R;'yip t • < 1 :y +�.. r• // 7. Y t t ySa .y 4.% • ...,-..tokr , • y.7, s1 4 i S. 1 '4 A; i` : c:t,y Ct` .,,... -,.. ,•,. ;. :„ „..,, - - . .-, ..r.....:,,'•_,,,, ...g . ' 1.,... ...,-;-,*--....., --.t..,---ir' _- ,:-, .•',„ ' ':. --. . .1- _74-:- :,.,- ..,___, _ : -.41k'-'4(s.. ',, - '-' '"r- : o' • • ,',,' • •,- ••• , . *. •. 4. ,--•. .c, li +� ' • _ .,..• - i' . (�^N 4 ^ • 7571.+�f. :? -..•........4:1 F1�S _ t r c}. ',..,.;...k,,,,,,- .c•. Sj ; 1,5 ,it •.' fy • -74: ter,: - )it • 'r• P--.. . L . "� •i :j,Tt Y',t r . - .r l + "G--a- v .•. , •... i { 3 -I'ft'.+ ify 4 4 -, �W � .,.. -,v.„,,,_. t I.- . • ��` � GC• i. c�7 +� .L iS _ rr�. = el . �{ `�- •• • s ato •`-r. 'tom % i • .1 V . .i -..1., t 4►+ - y• ' '� - l _ S �.�. , . •;,:. . •r .0, `, 1� 1F• _f"•4 w ,fit`:•. - � .io F�� ••• :t ,� - ^;�„.�• r�i l� -� i •''�' • f Yiii6l /•t►\ ftl -' ,a_f ~.-•vim, +G_ " ` • ' .' �.+ �..� ,. �'' ,_4 t- Zvi'. _s.--: s. - 7• d;. • ,ref. 4Z' �' - `•. - rte,-t ` r _ _ Y • s • � s 3,7' -*' xi : i ... ►.Pe fir �.: ♦• -MA' - t .,-4,1,,-- c _C4t �r o -rj 1 ' :J•. r i.%t'. � 1.,'•.7.41 t: ryIL t IF* of:',- *-4 • . „..„,,, .._ 4,. ., . .... ,,... • . ia' - +10•"" - r' - ice �•'a ~• 1 iT 5 • ..=tt � 'y�F' a-� s- • t •.• _ - .' .'+ �r • `�a ,-,4Y;` to � � �. - ° t` '-'3e3'...,4 . **ft' ,k .. - •'Sr'r"tip 6^.�C - • .• ';�5 ss ^,.: t i. r , kms.. :.. ,....2 .1.,.., ..r•!! �4 ti` ,i« -• J rST ' i{ c 7`� • t : w • .11 t3"'. 1• 7 - .. �.. • _„fi • + ilk\"' ;t w ... + �, ,'R 1.40-,,,, + .;S Lti._` r s ` ice( • . Id `� Y,.<�a ``�. \.. a Y' . , -4.�♦� s ` 'IIF•. '► • i .k `� � • CJ \.. .. ..t.1_, ,iti...p.`.-'."b•I'4- • -'' \ -:-....1••-• - -. '''' ' ' 4 --• • ‘4. •••' ••4... ' '.. . + 'y. t' 11•. �; r.-Y� . t'•s lt` Y. 14 lt1a.-..` .�---- .yY.4..- ._-.s 1 –4 14 ~`l • .,i�R� -t(.^ �• 'f. Ir..... ..es+• ` •-,.• , •rs,-3' 4,1. i - .P • - a } ; 7 ` �• rte. , -• �` l f►- _ ' C . •j.• \ V .rte Z 14-7 ‘.. Allit''', 4 4 • • • . _-.• 4 - " 't t '. • . .1. .• • _. • - �Y� fir/ 1i la • !. -yt � •rel �� !.-.J+ •,._ _ - ��•,.i �"';. -f / ` •• - 'l �� - �..f '!`f • ' ''i• -� �'1'`4 y. ' •' '. fi r'F 3h _;y • 7. • 3. 4.11 •.. • 1-41' .. �� , ' �1 _I ' ♦ • ' - •�t `' • '- -.4.—r• ii " • --,4,10Ci..I ' • ,.... .. 41 . : -'i-•74°,4 *4 AIS4 , K • `'•,t may`•,i -K . . ` v + • • 4- „ 4'Ja i`�, �. . 5s ..: l ti .. , , r AL- ,! i-s-4,:•;%,„iy, -', ' -‘-'7?1` 1'7; :,.;.'-;,`V 1.li.i ' ' . :Ai % • .$.^ti.�. r. .' t • 7r/v.:.< = i. - �i' - � ' - t �_. , . • .. . - ,� '' .s, . • .. i 4,kk 4"",.. r 4,A4, .. .,.-1Ib ,•"1. • \ 4 .-.1.-- '• - .. 4' ‘1411iii -....-6":' i- `I . .""fegiakt:' '''.-.4f 7" .,A . - .,,;.4„ 4, . . _ .-. ,„ ,. 11,1. .. 4. .,,,.. , . ,...„ , . .,... . .. IR-' _ W.a . a.+.:�. '•\�.yC ! •• T;::',„t• •rte•- ,• •. •� r • / r rye !w '1 .c; . ,, - - . t . . y , a -y ��� • �, ,- "= 1. _ '•ak. ., . 3 3 T'•- - Itkir sr-_ , 3 . Y ter ..'•t '.Ya Ir y� moi • �y ! !� 'yV site:ti 71;. Aft• Y _ ITV, IC: -. f • • • • .-x . ma} Sry r: t 7" j .........• - +5,�'. 4 :ai cy4 t - • � N• � jT.'. ,1 ` �., • ,, \ y-''ZX . ( ' •:•-*- -''' w 4l; ��4y 4...4 �r ' tYF • ' + � " y"' �Y ! i .a.. tii, _ y ,, ,s .a ... � ;,,,-._?;,.,4"....-,....i -- Y`i( a, r _`; + • 7. '�yr. 'YET•G'tt •tTo 1, .. t 44. 4111 I - s'.t1 -` '..z 'fi J % • f �'yy s. cc .:; �. I. .y �,a '•�" <'�.. t'y� t.• L�- �1 vr, •�1A '1V_. .K • ` Y:, • • k • • • . , .' > . '. '1'"';',,co- y + " r ' r� •` 'j' j '4� • 4. 4. 0 rr .t„- ) '? P_ A _ o• E4l ,4'.1tk \ ��s4i3rMt �`t' Klai -'i `-E2 ,L c iy 'it t. 4_, a- - , aiw.._ ___, `411111i. 4!01- .,9' ` 4 -0 4 ` - =• ` 41 0.440401 1t - ;��� i • t.•6, j fr• i •• a yu•Joa .r'e- ;,,. vo Av\• -- l! • • '. ;41 • •�' • ' ` Jr_ Ur' ' • g ' ..r -'•r1 N - • • , h � X J ••{ • • . i• • aft ...... _ .. iki,. 1 . i , ' i ,,t Ad-,/.. t v• '.,, '' ',: • . • \• -,E `t ,11 ,,G+ , -•ate` r e :.\ A'; • , t •,. y •L �' _ •r. �nfr r ♦: Thi a �� . • 1. •6. .""�►_ 1 ..,, • irP4S_14% - ..--,;..,* ', •z -'-..,:_;,. .411,,i• - xt::', V , 4*,''',-t '. -+. Pt'+ .?fit .. ;T 4- ,.•-fes''L.,t{ */).• . r..,• ; ;y.� . 1,..t+~• • ••11.'1 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT Mr Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 3 LOCATION 111 Hacienda Drive. Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade Note reason for any variation from 54". 40" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure. 2% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site. placement. and contribution = (90% site + 90% placement + 90% contribution) _ 3 = 90% Notes on site, placement and condition 90% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 81.482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 81.482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60' box tree 52,964 HortScience Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept.. 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provded in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree $62 00 11. Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4 4. 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 1149 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) - Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 1125.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost (Line 9) 572.730 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost (Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note we generally round to the nearest $10). 51,178.22- Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $1,180.00! References International Society of Arboriculture 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT Mr Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 8 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive. Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54" 1 g., 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure 3% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement + 30% contribution) _ 3 = 30% Notes on site. placement and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 81,482 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 51,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for S2.964 the installed cost of a 60' box tree HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept.. 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. S62 00 11. Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4 4. 9th Edition for single trunk trees Multi-trunk trees? 283 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) - Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 259.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost (Line 9) $19.038 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost (Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest $10) $154.20 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest $10.00 is $150.00! References International Society of Arboriculture 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal 9th Edition Champaign. IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento. CA. 23pp HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept.. 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT Mr Ramy Zaifman Tree No 9 LOCATION 111 Hacienca Drive. Arcadia 1. Species Quercus adrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment Cons der variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade Note reason for any variation from 54". 14" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure 50/0 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement + 30% contribution) - 3 = 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition. 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23 75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the irstalled cost of a 60' box tree 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 81,482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for S2.964 the installed cost of a 60' box tree HortScience. Inc Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept.. 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 562 00 11. Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4. 9th Edition for single trunk trees Multi-trunk trees? 154 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) - Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 130.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost (Line 9) $11.040 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost (Line 13)x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note. we generally round to the nearest$10). $149.03 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest $10.00 is $149.00! References International Society of Arboriculture 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign. IL 143pp Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento. CA 23pp. HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept_ 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT Mr Ramy Zaifrran Tree No 10 LOCATION. 111 Hacienca Drive. Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 12" & 13" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure. 8% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement + 30% contribution) - 3 = 30% Notes on site. placement, and condition 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23 75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for S1,482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for S1,482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60' box tree. $2.964 HortScience. Inc Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree S62.00 11. Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4 4. 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 246 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) - Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 222.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost (Line 9) S16.744 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost (Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest $10) $361_66 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest $10.00 is $360.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000 Guide for Plant Appraisal 9th Edition Champaign. IL 143pp Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept . 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT Mr Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 11 LOCATION ill Hacienda Drive. Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 20" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure 15% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement. and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement + 30% contribution) - 3 = 30% Notes on site. placement and condition. 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for Si 482 the installed cost of a 60"box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 81,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for S2.964 the installed cost of a 60' box tree HortScience. Inc Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept.. 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines prov ded in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. S62.00 11. Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4 4. 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 314 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) - Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 280.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) S20.960 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost (Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest S10) S848.86 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $849.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal 9th Edition Champaign. IL 143pp Western Chapter. International Society of Arboriculture 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept.. 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT Mr. Ramy Zaifrran Tree No. 12 LOCATION 111 Hacienca Drive. Arcadia 1. Species Quercus aorifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines proeided in Species Classification and Group Assignment Consider variation from Species Classification? 900/0 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 22" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure 8% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement + 30% contribution) _ 3 = 30% Notes on site. placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 23.75 aGroup3tree 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 51,482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for ;1.482 the installed cost of a 60' box tree 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines proiided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 82,964 the installed cost of a 60' box tree. HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept . 2001 • • 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provded in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 380 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11)-Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 356.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree(Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $25,052 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13) K Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4)x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $541.11 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is$540.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept.. 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifrran Tree No. 13 LOCATION 111 Hacienda Drive. Arcadia j1. Species Quercus adrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. 90% variation from Species Classification? 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above trade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 5" & 17" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure 80/0 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site. placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement + 30% contribution) - 3 = 30% Notes on site, placemen:. and condition 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 23 75 a Group 3 tree. 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 51,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 51,482 the installed cost of a 6C" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines prcvided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for 82.964 the installed cost of a 6C" box tree. HortScience. Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept . 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. S62 00 11. Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4 4. 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 247 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) - Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 223.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost (Line 9) $16.806 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost (Line 13)x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5) (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10) 5363.00 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest $10.00 is $360.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign. IL 143pp. Western Chapter. International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim. CA Sept 2001 Curriculum Vitae WILLIAM R. MCKINLEY—MCKINLEY & ASSOCIATES 1734 Del Valle Ave. Email: william@mckinleyarborists.com Work (818)426-2432 Glendale.CA 91208 Website: httj>://»a\\.mckinlo arhnri;t> m Home(818)240-1358 SUMMARY of QUALIFICATIONS Practicing Consulting Arborist. Member of American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA).Certified Arborist,Internaticnal Society of Arboriculture since September 30, 1999.1.S.A.Arborist#WE-4578A. Recognized Oak Tree Expert throughout Southern California. Prepare arborist reports for developers, homeowners and attorneys.Assess the landscape value of trees.Assess and identify hazardous trees in the landscape.Provide]hillside and Oak Woodland landscape and irrigation recommendations. Provide expert witness testimony on arboriculture related cases. Public speaker and presenter at community service group meetings,homeowner's association meetings and speaker at professional seminars and conferences. Presenter at Trees,People and Our Urban Environment Seminar,March 2002.Arbor Day Guest Speaker. City of Glendale,March 2005.Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2010.Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2012,Arbor Day Guest Speaker,Glendale,March 2014. FULL TIME EMPLOYMENT HISTORY City of Glendale, Parks, Recreation & Community Services Park Services Manager-Contract Administration 2001-present Performs contract administration for Park Services Section. Manage grounds maintenance for sports fields. community buildings,parks, medians,and historic areas.Administers the City's landscape maintenance contract.Writes contract specifications. Administers the bidding process. Awards contracts to successful bidders.Conducts construction meetings and oversees the construction and inspection for these projects. Performs and assumes all former duties and responsibilities under the former Administrative Analyst position.Writes amorist reports. Hazardous tree assessment.Serves as expert witness in tree related cases. Administrative Analyst 1988-2001 Administer landscape maintenance contract for medians,reservoirs,pump houses and misc.areas. Administer and supervise the Division's Work Management System involving the scheduling and tracking of work and performance of over 50 full-time employees.Supervise one part-time data entry employee and supervise and coordinate with the California Conservation Corps,Boy Scouts and other community service volunteers in the parks.Supervise,monitor and report water and utility usage in the parks.Administer and supervise all tree planting projects and programs including the Arbor Day and Urban Forest Donation programs. Assist with budget preparation and acquisition of capital equipment.Prepare Capital Improvement Project specifications and assist with administering contracts. Administer the City of Glendale's Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Coordinate with Planning. Permit Services,Engineering, Building,Neighborhood Services and Fire Department to insure the care and protection of trees,both during and after ccnstruction. Review grading,construction, landscape and irrigation plans.Modify and approve plans as necessary to protect indigenous trees. Perform field inspections on hazardous trees and make recommendations to park staff and the public.Serve as code enforcement officer and paralegal during Administrative Office Hearings regarding Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance. Perform tree and landscape appraisals.Served as special show and marketing consultant to the Glendale Rose Pruning and Garden Show Committee. Assistant Planner-Parks 1983-1988 Assisted in park inventory development and implementation of the Work Management System.Served as guest speaker at the National Parks and Recreation Conference on the subject of computers and their role in park maintenance.Supervised the Capital Improvement Project Construction at Pacific Park and Brand Park.Coordinated with and supervised California Conservation Corps.Crews in planting,staking and tying hundreds of trees as part of the Arbor Day Program.Served as Arbor Day Co-Chairman. Glendale Rose Pruning&Garden Show Co-Chairman and President of Glendale Beautiful.Served as Ways and Means Chairman C.P.R.S.District XIV. EDUCATION 1983 California Polytechnic University.Pomona Bachelor of Science Degree, Park Administration Graduated Magna Cum Laude,Grade Point Average:3.57 1983-Present CEU's-University of California.Landscape Contract Maintenance.Hazardous Tree Identification&Assessment.Specimen Tree Appraisal.Advanced Tree Appraisal Theory and Practice.Tree and Landscape Liability—Trees and the Law.Oak Tree Symposium Graduate. Knowledge of oak tree physiology and native plant habitat.ASCA 2007 Consulting Academy. National Arbor Day Foundation Graduate.Symposiums: Construction Around Trees:Trees and the Law. Recognized Tree Expert:City of Los Angles.County of Los Angeles.City of Pasadena,City of La Canada Flintridge.City of Burbank.City of Calabasas,County of Ventura.City of Santa Clarita. HONORS & ACTIVITIES 1999 - Present- Certified Arborist-International Society of Arboriculture 1996-1999-Secretary/Treasurer. C.P.R.S.Park Operations Section 1994-1995 - President, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1994-1995 - Treasurer, Glendale Beautification Advisory Council 1992-1994 -Treasurer, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1993. 1994, 1995 C.P.R.S.Park Operations Scholarship First.Second and Third Year,Graduate,Pacific Southwest Maintenance Mgmt.School 1988-1990—President.Glendale Beautiful 1980, 1981 - Twice placed on Dean's Honor List 1982 - Who's Who in American Colleges and Universities 1978 - Recipient of Wayne Striker Memorial Scholarship 1975 - Awarded Eagle Scout Rank,Boy Scouts of America Member- American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA) Member - International Society of Arboriculture Member - Western Chapter.International Society of Arboriculture Member—Glendale Beautiful Past Member - National Arbor Day Foundation Past Member - California Oak Foundation REFERENCES Randall S. Stamen,Attorney/Arborist (951)787-9788 Susan&Gary Sims,Sims Tree Specialists (951)685-6662 Peter&Diana Harnisch,Harnisch Tree Care (626)444-7997 PROFESSIONAL SERVICE FEE Site Inspection - S100.00 per hour Consultation - $125.00 per hour Arborist Report - $150.00 per hour Public Hearing - $200.00 per hour Arbitration - $225.00 per hour Deposition - $250.00 per hour Court Witness - $350.00 per hour 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Arborist Letter July 20, 2019 Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck,NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: This letter is in regard to two Oak tree inspections which were made at the request of Jim the Project Superintendent regarding your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia, California. The first site inspection was made on Monday, April 1, 2019 regarding the condition of the Oak and Sycamore trees and their roots along the east boundary line. At that time I found that the Oak and Sycamore tree roots had been pruned to the side of the excavation where the new wall footing was being constructed. The Oak and Sycamore trees showed no stress at that time. The second site inspection took place on Thursday,June 13, 2019. The purpose of this inspection was to inspect the utility trench which was excavated near the west side of your property near Tree#23. During my inspection I noted that the large woody support roots had been preserved and spanned the trench. Only small roots had been cut back clean to the sides of the trench. Despite considerable construction activity in the back yard of the property all the protected trees appeared normal and healthy. The tree protection measures previously stated in the Arborist Report are being complied with. I stressed to Jim the importance of continuing the practice of wetting down the exposed root areas in all the trenched areas twice per day until backfill of the trenches could occur so that the cut and exposed roots could be kept wet to reduce stress and promote good root health. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or my office at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants • ' �ryL rid :•`��. i ,, (./. r1 .r• t it fy .r `r$ t, P. 1: 'w ,• it r+'%' n•, ), �r r y# +'I •r r • ,,, ,�'4.� � •.tf �• t.. ••,A. 0 •, t• a•. ../j )1 tri +i `. �•y t.. •• y •+ . /K� rn�i.. y, •. • ,1 , • y v. r. '' 3:"M1 .'�' •-:,' '� ••i� 10,4! • ., ' •' j.. ,, ; ,. ;' ,1, I••, T ,'1•'�•' '' • 4ft '.U. t • "%.,•' • ' ••X 4' ..'• ' • • •L' ' t.: " 2b4" . . 2• •'t % ••k -•‘-??111 -74.r.410111V, ' # ' '; -•'".'' .' ''"-f .e ,....A.,,,-00", .• -, :•-• h ppft, w • [t l' • % f r' • ` • 1 , .0't1 :fit • •-'J i• !♦ •�� • t. • 4 " . V• ":f.: �A ' 'y. • � i •t4j;�'}�' ` y� �` t r ' ,•,. • rM j I7� + , ,' ' - • ` ,, ^ ♦• • I. - IS :Yi y ' ; .'1 'M } f 4. Fry c% w •:4_,..,_,., '.� ` id : * { y 4. . t - ,,. Al +y ;�* , ' V It • >rr � a A,•V • tet ,. ' , " �X' ;11 11 NI* • ,� ' I/r 'F •rp a p: 11�� ,.' w ��r , , .. ....... .,__ :___.' _ _. : PA1 L k7V p. it I, ,I ..._......050 „. iii _, I 4,tIVIIVil/em .. _ - sem' +.<.� �� �r _,tl—,q10110l j� ,'_,i ».•• - .t.. ,. �M - ...i, . . . ... ., _. . . .. ., - ._ ,.. - .-- .- . - J - ►•. - IP - .. a- ';� tea'901140, --V..,) ,wa� ., • .4. aiC - -- _ 6k � 1 • • . - , . -;j1;;kt,.; • • `. 1, 40 Y „ { .. r' t keN,L , :::".‘• .: : . -. •:. ,t t�R • . f' y 04. '� 5 `� - .i .""rte. ,, r .. } � -.r ,. _:a 64 yame. , - ♦, O ' R- r • - y(K .% AN- . Pit- • ..• r .._.r....4,.....:. ,... • : .., ,, . s. iii , 14,...t::(7:--4:•,,: ... .. . ,.'.lit ,. .- .., `, ♦• l i i?„. ..›. • • it- .. ..... .. ,...., . ` ! x. I;: e. f V' '-.s 7 f r. , . tri ;r 1 a q. , ,. j ,t_. . et-V,,4:f, 1..t, .,-:4,-,...t� i. -,.r' n -',.!,-. • 4 a ti!! , 's r •t -5. csy cam', t• _ i''`�— 1 \t•M1 , . . 4 ,< xS i • -..� / --_ma k' .y-s ;� .. -Y,.' i f. 'p i :A .,..i..4 „..p...t.,—. '.., '-'...-'I.-,.-t;,:, ' ......,,, .',,,,,.. r y. - Y'- 111* t' �_ ` !''_4a'`?\.* 4-'.-t ! 's 1, ., ' a • x ... 1.• ,'' -k't r — -'L 7M' �? •w ; # ' Y ` `ate - - -40. '+ .. 7 tea {' - { �S. L • h ; • ..– e; 4' -7z . I.,, .� 72,s, • i lir' !,dttNiztlel,..k_,, •:-IS. - • -• . • 4 `a` K � 64' _ •9ugr f i � s. • �h •� - V. ^' �.1t Yrr _.. _ + .'Sm a ' �-. _� ► o `�i +• 1. 4. 's r 1,-/R t rp der �1 No. or P.Ns, .,. ..... . . .. • • .. .. .. . . , , , dit-• -.• --... • ,,, i II%•-.? •: . -' •• •;" I- v. - .""1-7"'Vqr7,-..' . .,• '‘.•*, ..,., - 1-4' ‘,N,, 0 -. ' • '•''. 4 • t ,4- 4: . . ,,E'. , • , ..,. ., 4,2,, 4. •: `..i .,,• 'N top ir 1 •• •.• tool JP.;••••••' .- P. , .e II i ' .' . ''','''. ' ' • Atir V ss, ' '' If%1 44) • . . - ' bl •- it, . - . ':. ' ." ' ..., try::.,,,I,. 1-- - ' - ' " ''-4 .'-. '',('-• Ih;e •, ,.- . - - ,.. , ... .. • . 4 „ . . . . i . liopa,s.• - ' • ,....,,,- -.4. • . — .• . .. . .. - 4.--vitri 4..„-—, -‘.,...,..4-1 ', - - ' . ---• e 4 . . , . • .'11111.4i,, '11. t- ' ..-4,11„„' ," . gi. ',..,, "'Irk ' -4,'..'"'--•Iv „', v,..:I 4„,...,o .se.,,, , f . , . ,.., , , •. i. ,-..-' •, --.„,- .vt. ri -s,, '''"4- ' - ,, • • •- . - •-, - f '\ •• --,..2--.- r, •- \ -: . . i' s.,1 * IZ , 71,- " ' • , :-.,•-, . .- ' ,1$.0 ..- 't. • • ., -. , fite 7 r' . , .. . . •' , Ciik A ', ' `,1k-'' ‘•thr. *Nr—dr-r ;..- . ', 4. . i .-,....... ••••• . , ,N1 ...,.... '''' • . . - . •••••.„ ' . q .,,,,,,. ...,,,,,_,_ _.. .., t ,,, ..„,„,,,, / . .. -.11.• :. • .. ' — .7--„, __..-, -4, .- --1.,f. ;ie. 1. '.-i-.• - r .44 . , 4 N.fir. ...,....40 -44, ,..), :..., I 4 A . , . .- :„......... . .v.- .,..._,. ...,...?. :........-},-- , , . . ..... , .. . -,.. * - .„.- . , . . ;. ,...., - ‘ - . , ,;. ..„., .,. . , -,...z, -.r... I 4. ... • 4 ," ' lir '70'. "'t :44; . . : ',..-- ' -;, :,. •24‘ — f- -:-_ 7‘' • - . •, . • ., .;-.. . %.1,112, 7,. ._:•,,40.4,4, • I 1.- , w, - .-:•-. , . • - ,, .,- ....- , . ,,, „,' ,-. • • - ",--- .-„a'•-- .. . '44.4...,-1-''.-'',• • .;',; -,.,..., .a•-, ...- - L.-4-, - --. , r''. etilit';`:':.,-..,.,:, "" ' , ..."-- 1 1..44- 4- .. •'-,r- ' ‘..--'1.- tr--:--., :if*.•(-:". ':. -'''''.."' . ‘030-_t ,7!.,• •. ,:a, llikAL1• - ' -•-• . ' - --V=1.. 'N.. N... .4.tirt:•,0- f. i.' - ' '' •-- ' s•' , ., ,.. ,, ,' ..,1 ,'..7 ...,_,:iffeilo ., .t. ,_ ,7.4 .., , , . A '••••'•44 . 4t.#"; L' .-,'' • see ir ''• ' - . \ 4•-', 1,.,..' ''- • ,-„. .: ' ''. - 1 '• 1' - - ...i, - . ''',..'-‘,...--1;;;,%- '!„-1,..."- **....: ..•.•:‘,„;,....:-.•,;;.-:.1Sit:::-f:•,,-;1`-,-;:-.,. ..'..- . -\' -•• •\.,.::‘, .,. - ..,7- ...„-... ,--,_•-• - . _, ..7,0, •,r _ - , , • P , * t7' '''''',*;. --, .4'..-•.-_:`‘' ,,,,,:,,, • 0.Pft•4. - -,* ... '. '‘ • , " •61:7.7,4•-• :. . -:..t. ..k,.` N' , '-- , c. .,-7•••:,-, : • - 0. • . -'---- . .--. -i •• '.'N'-4• .'.-t-4 , *°"P' • - N.,::.--. .,.. - gip .-. .4-Ni'.-`i• „....._=„•"` - .-_., • - - -.' ',.• ' ,„ , '''.-0.: 3-,;_c,„Wit _ '••.......r.'. --, -,,,• !... .i.:• ,a 4 „,_. 4-..--......,_ 41 .. ‘S7 ,,,4"..,, . • , , .• - • " - - -. .....,4- ' 0- -, , '7 •• .,•,. - "` r‘.4....,1 ' '•"-"'1' ,- ••• •••-' \ .....--' I•, k.:-. .i...'• ' ..... -. , "( '''' si.:.„4..,.)':'-4 .'!,, -. .. --4 -:,-..- clk t vi....""4"- -,, - N S,,,.. -4.- -, „.• .„, I :.. . ‘ - -.., ' ?,*. Ao,..--p,1‘4,. -, w,• .s'-`t* .'4' 'It. '' .41-:-Mills' '- .. ... . 0...' - ,..--. --- ; ''.• . • A _ (, _,-.` 1 - ., -' .?', - '.---, j ••, auk,. .,. . 0./ •••-- . _-, .. , , _...‘ .,. ..., _.-•; ..- .„ • ,v,,,, .4 • , 'Ft,-'14-.,, .. ,... V- • sq,lity -•• !,'-- if ., e r -4••rw, ,... -, -;,.%.. .•' "' ''': 11,,=;; ,I, i, • 4' ,- .-- '' . 4*...-.- -Ag ,41 ""--- ''''-'* - - - .- • . ', . , . ...o. - , ,: . s _-,,,-,4k, --.,:_ . ,„-- --. ,-,,,iip ,,, - --- - z•-•, , 1,;,-,rii co — . -- 1 . . - • : . . ... • ,,..--. - . . . , .. ,...,..„..._,--„- -ar- ...... ,,......;--:r_.A„.; „ . .- '1 ..s• . • . ' • . ' ' 4„..---;14. a ,. '` '''' -;,r--- 4,,.. _ - ..' ,-..4 • • ?,',,,,-•c••••.:( ,;„1.:iiik . '• vie,-:--:,4v.--,7-...,,, - , -Au., -., -,. . ! ,---.i* ,,....:-..'1, .__,..,- - ,,t,„A ".f. A i.-'.....71. , -,. ..• - • _ ___,:". •*-4,Ah. ---- -...j • ''s - ---7'..*-.-:,-Y. t-s-..Ar•;-- -' 7. ...1klit; . /04,, - /., Iv, ,a,..; 4. ''Th.`,;-1"- - • - ..., ........• . ---,--_-• • , \,,,,.... .... ,,it.. ,,,`V--,z--•••-N....___ ; .7-.!•i "..-^ agV0 .\<....-S,,,•, 4 „...... ,.' .' .-•.....- X/X a- - - - - - --. -- - - , ., 1441k,„ir:f. •• -7:-'7..N,, ". •: "k• Ar.. s 4 ''•••• "--; . 1e. -. 7.-'4ft:' '''';- . a- ''' . - : •'-:,-.2_,— ..,.... * ' m . ''.?$, 2-.': - ''. _Irv!": 7 N. . __, ,#.`V-- 44h.f:-.; :-...1.1 .-•,...4.--"' 'Cii- ' -',•-tAi ‘ ...„,---,"4,- „.2 _,,,. -7..,- .• ..-t•• .:-,-, . • :- '.-- .\( 4.41,6Z‘.• I.if.'r, .7,,-.`40-'4.-- -C. • .. --. • .-- - •....- • •- - . ....- , "'' 3:i•'''.'`,.. --I'-'- - .-.. •7.4 -• . ,.. N,-."- -?,:- ,T . . N,4,,, _•:... ' ..".%. - -:...,_:•,-St__,,........:, ..,• _ •,- - •••:-.. 7,„:-.----- ,If _. _ __,. . .. :. .... _ -,. . ••1,••-• .. , .tim ..., 4_,. - -F „.. ..,,,-...,..,„4,,. .. . ,- - . .. „..... ., .. ..-If1-•`41 , -- -- --. ,-. .- ,..v4' ••41,- ..- .....,,.- 1--...--9' -. '.'- - :. 14•Ag , I .1*. • .' 0" 'I.C- -Al0 1. '•..4.'- • 46:Ar ' •'•-•• .•' " .•'--.- - r . . •--'.'.• ... 4,r,r.).. ..`,..,',.....40'...„ •••:e:,,.; , • .t- •• . . - , ..•.r.it,---.-... . '4,4 .‘,11.1.7,121,.. _41...._•_,... : .,• .;• • ',• ' 'L'.• . "•440,11" ..•-• ' '.._"- • •:. ''''-- - - ' . ',- - ,- . .) AO. ,,- ,--.., ....„ .... ' '. ' -• , -.t.,!., - . - - • ,1!4,s7r..- .. - _. . .... . ,., ,4 t ' •.-r _,.. . %,..t . -` •----- r..... -.e. ..‘..__. , ...'-...-----, . r - - ---' . •. . .., ,..,.,. P, , --‘,„4,-- , - - . • . - .. ,, „., — _• ..: •_ :,--.:,i-!..-... --, - .,. . .‘: 4-, -• i/- L\ . _ ''Ofil:' .....411" ' - j. 0',4 ,,L-I"-,..4 ...50 .-#, '' i! •" .......:.,-.. •':T.,_ :, y.. . ... 2,-1 ,- ,:\.1 , i .ii,...:,: ..,,i:212?,‘.:1: '"---• '...*.s-.'....4' -. -.-- . . , v. -. ..04.7.' ---. -.:',""Tr. •-• --0• ..1 . ., . ... -- - - •<t.:''. Iv , -. .141.,„. . n. .. :, .... - . . , .. , .,,,, .2.04,.... . k '----"v- '7--.•gig. ,•/" , . - .... , .1 ‘-• -.1 -, -.04-,.. - 7 , `" i "'N , '''..i• -a •-•'; .., ... . .'" .- -'1 * '7 , .•-,.- - - ' 4 4.,1**.i. ..1.0 ' ,.' '1 . . . • -, 1 . ' ",•1•Vi?', :.•-:-'1•' ' tV . •. .-_. . .. _ • '• ' z,' 4 -.'-,,'• l'..".-,_,, ...A,.. . ., .. . , , . . .. . ,. .' ;"*.7,...:!•-,1)'''','' . . , . ,. • ,..- -• 1 1 c1Z° ate 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree Protection Plan 111 Hacienda Drive Arcadia, California Prepared for: Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck, NY 11020 Prepared by: William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist #WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture 1734 Del Valle Avenue Glendale, CA 91208 Arborists and Environmental Consultants 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 September 20, 2018 Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck,NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: Recently Peter Sun, City of Arcadia contacted me concerning a tree protection plan for your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia. I was asked to review the plans and prepare a Tree Protection Plan for all the Oak and Sycamore trees located on or near the subject property. This report is a supplement to the original Arborist Report. The following report summarizes my findings: Background On Monday, September 10,2018 at 1:30 p.m. I met with Todd Bowden, General Contractor to walk the site with the proposed building plans and identify proposed encroachment areas near the Oak and Sycamore trees on the site. The Tree/Site Inspection Section describes my observations concerning the subject trees. Tree/Site Inspection Tree#1 —There will be no impact to this Coast Live Oak. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline or approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. Tree#0P2—The proposed new driveway will encroach to within 8 feet of this Coast Live Oak tree's trunk on the northeast side. The new driveway will be excavated 8 inches from the existing grade. The impact to the tree is moderate. Minor root pruning may be involved.No pruning of the tree's crown is required. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 20 feet from the tree's trunk however once work in this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to within 6 feet from the tree's trunk on the east side. Tree#3—This diseased,declining,hazardous Coast Live Oak will be removed by permit.No tree protection fencing is required. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 1 � t 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#4—The new driveway will be installed 16 feet west of the Coast Live Oak's trunk. The existing paving surrounding the Oak will be removed.Minor walkway work will take place within the dripline. Minor twig pruning of the tree canopy may be required over the new driveway. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 30 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#5—The existing driveway will be removed within the dripline of this Coast Live Oak. The existing house will be removed.A new house and footings will be installed in the same general location within the dripline of this Oak.No pruning will be required. The impact to this tree is moderate.Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 28 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#0P6—The existing house will be removed and the new house and footing will be 2 feet west of the current house location.No pruning will be required.The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 25 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk on the west side of the tree. The south fence area can remain. Tree#7—Coast Live Oak will be preserved. The existing house and patio areas on the south and west sides of the tree will be removed. A new house and courtyard area will be constructed within the dripline of the tree.The new house will be 16 feet away.No pruning will be required. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 25 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to the area immediately next to the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#8—Coast Live Oak is diseased and dying.The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#9—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house.The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#10—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 2 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site inspection-Continued Tree#11 —Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia. No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#12—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#13—Coast Live Oak conflicts with the new house. The tree will be removed by permit from the City of Arcadia.No tree protection fencing will be required. Tree#14—Coast Live Oak will not be encroached upon. The northeast corner of the new house will begin at a point 14 feet from the tree's trunk.No pruning will be necessary. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection chain-link fencing will be placed at the dripline at 12 feet from the trunk however once work on this area begins the fence will have to be relocated to 10 feet from the Oak tree's trunk. Tree#15—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 37 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#16—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed. There is a 12 inch stem which grows low over the existing lawn which will require pruning back to allow 8 feet of clearance. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 28 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#17—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed. The tree is located 2 feet northwest of the old shed.The existing shed will be removed. Minor pruning will be necessary to trim small twigs and branches to provide clearance on the west side of the tree for the proposed cabana. The impact to this tree is moderate.Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 32 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 3 41 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#18—Coast Live Oak is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is minor. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 14 feet from the trunk. The tree protection fence will surround the perimeter driplines of this grove of trees. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#19—California Sycamore is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the driplines of the surrounding trees.This tree is within the tree protection fencing perimeter. Once work on this area beg ns the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#20—California Sycamore is part of a grove of 6 trees near an old shed.No pruning will be necessary. The existing shed will be removed. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the driplines of the surrounding trees. This tree is within the tree protection fencing perimeter. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be opened to allow access to the shed. Tree#21—Coast Live Oak will be encroached upon. The footing for the cabana measuring 12 inches by 12 inches will encroach to within 10 feet of the trunk.Minor twig pruning will be necessary to provide clearance for the proposed cabana building.The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 20 feet from the trunk. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be moved back to a point 6 feet from the trunk allow access to construct the cabana. Tree#22—Coast Live Oak will be encroached upon. The proposed cabana will encroach to within 12 feet from the trunk.No pruning will be necessary. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 15 feet from the trunk. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be moved back to a point 8 feet from the trunk allow access to construct the cabana. Tree#23—Coast Live Oak will be encroached upon. The proposed cabana will encroach to within 17 feet from the trunk on the northeast side of the tree. Minor twig pruning will be necessary to provide clearance for the proposed cabana building. The impact to this tree is moderate. Tree protection fencing will be placed at the dripline at 24 feet from the trunk. Once work on this area begins the fence will have to be moved back on the northeast side to a point 12 feet from the trunk allow access to construct the cabana. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 4 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 General Observations The subject property appears to have been part of an Oak Woodland Plant Community prior to development. The trees growing on or near the subject property are primarily native Coast Live Oak with a few native California Sycamore trees.The proposed new single family home construction will require the removal of 5 healthy Coast Live Oak trees by permit from the City of Arcadia. These include: Tree#9,Tree#10, Tree#11, Tree#12 and Tree#13. There will be 2 unhealthy Coast Live Oaks removed from this property.They are Tree#3 and Tree#8. The Coast Live Oak which was previously severely cut back will be removed as per the City's direction and a replacement 36 inch- box size Coast Live Oak will be planted in the back yard approximately 60 feet east of the west boundary block wall and roughly 6 feet east of the west boundary fence as per the City of Arcadia,Development Services Department letter dated July 5,2018; Healthy Tree Removal Permit No. TRH 18-04. The City of Arcadia,Development Services letter dated August 30,2018 states that approval of Healthy Tree Removal Permit No.TRH 18- 09 for five healthy trees#9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 and unhealthy trees#3 and 8 is approved with the condition that 3 replacement Coast Live Oak trees be planted in the front yard. The size and location of these replacement trees shall be determined by the City's Certified Arborist. I have spoken with the landscape architect and have reviewed the proposed landscape plan and it appears that the proposed design and improvements will not adversely affect the health of the existing native Oak and Sycamore trees. Recommendation Based upon my inspection of the subject trees and property it is my professional opinion that the proposed new single family home and improvements have been designed in such a way as to minimize the numbers of trees required to be removed. Just 5 out of 23 trees will be removed due to conflicts with the new house design. The other 2 trees to be removed are diseased,unhealthy and are dying. Their removal is completely unrelated to the proposed construction. In addition to the tree protection fencing requirements already stated earlier in this report I would recommend that the following tree protection measures be implemented during construction: 1) Install tree protection fencing around Oak and Sycamore trees to be preserved prior to commencement of work and maintain fencing in a vertical,upright condition throughout the construction period. 2) Minimize excavation and trenching within the drip line of the protected trees. 3) Roots which are cut or otherwise damaged should be pruned to the side of the excavation with a clean, sharp pruning tool and kept covered with burlap and wetted daily until the excavation area can be backfilled. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 5 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Recommendation-Continued 4) Minimize storage of building materials and equipment within the drip line of the Oak and Sycamore trees in order to minimize soil compaction. 5) Prohibit dumping of foreign substances such as excess soil,concrete,cement, stucco,paint,etc. within the drip line of the trees. 6) Designate an area outside the drip line of the trees to clean and wash equipment so as not to impact the root zones of the protected trees. 7) Pruning of limbs and branches of trees shall be performed by a State Licensed Tree Contractor under the supervision of an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. 8) All pruning shall comply with ANSI A-300 Pruning Standards and Best Management Practices. 9) An I.S.A. Certified Arborist should be hired to oversee and supervise all work within the drip line of the remaining protected Oak and Sycamores. 10)The recommended size for the 3 replacement Coast Live Oak trees in the front yard of the subject property is a 24 inch-box size tree. This size is the most commonly planted size landscape tree because it is large enough to stand virtually on its own and the root ball is much larger and more well-developed than smaller size trees. This size also establishes quicker and out performs larger trees in a short period of time. Summary/Conclusion In conclusion, it is my professional opinion that in order to build the proposed new single family home it will be necessary to remove 5 healthy Coast Live Oak trees from the subject property. It is my understanding that a Healthy Protected Tree Removal Permit will be issued under the condition that 3 replacement Coast Live Oak trees will be planted in the front of the subject property.The size and location of the replacement trees will be determined by the City Certified Arborist.A proposed replacement tree planting plan is included at the end of this report.There will also be 2 unhealthy,diseased,dying trees removed through the issuance of an Unhealthy Protected Tree Removal Permit.The Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 6 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Summary/Conclusion-Continued Coast Live Oak which was partially cut down will be removed under a City Healthy Protected Tree Removal Permit with the condition that a 36 inch-box size replacement Coast Live Oak tree be planted in the back yard.The proposed improvements will encroach upon most of the dripline areas of the remaining Oak and Sycamore trees. Once work commences in these areas it will be necessary to move the tree protection fencing in order to perform the required work. The proposed landscape plan has been carefully studied and reviewed by the landscape architect and project arborist and this design should not adversely affect the health of the Oak and Sycamore trees.All construction work within the driplines of the Oak and Sycamore tree will be supervised and monitored by the project I.S.A. Certified Arborist. If the above stated recommendations and tree protection measures are followed and complied with then the remaining trees should survive and contribute to the value of the subject property and surrounding neighborhood for many years to come. Limitations Information contained in this report covers only those areas that were examined and reflects the condition of those areas at the time of inspection. The inspection was limited to visual examination of accessible areas without excavation,drilling or boring. Arboriculture is not an exact science and there is much that is still to be learned about trees.The observations and recommendations provided in this report reflect the latest research,knowledge and training available through university and professional research. There is no warranty or guarantee,expressed or implied,that problems or deficiencies of the trees or property in question may not arise in the future. Thank you for the opportunity to serve you and your environmental and horticultural needs. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or you may call my office phone at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, -#.2://4:g.#1—j r William R.McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 7 • PLANTING LEGEND EXISTING TAS SPEP c N4IRf[ SpEGIYEN 91RUBaAr-SFa(PNs GROBI_LQYFBS EN,E1 EFEEs ANO OAK 0 uVS.. rA A )- _- ffi35R r[N(R,R'ASU4_Y(42 * PNVG r kl 1�E8(A4lYL4 .. RY,14—,u r REEs xorzo aN PIAN To •. .wAxnAL EUROKAr NORNe Av(J7 ieAi:Fao tf.:r oxw.vLxlei SArnVA a+) 3 aAL�r' i TS... [L::-.3. (�orr`vAim uRN e'ME( FEUNN ANo RRo1Ecn:A ��"�� BE+�uY�d>r . ® - CA4uuutA ML:'A)A - Y[FuiA[AN A..Ly O IS Borl i;_ je C ]Gt I .€L YAS'ELVER SRtEAN' ...-... (g_;�p�. (A�� BUXUs u. CBE l'.714C[ll;'Y4'i CN' a Y.AATEK:L'-RFE + Ar•TR2'EXKI rG InEs(N DASNEO !si BOXI GEd a PEC aVANEBE Ynttt(M 1 i5•MN IR6,'ND-sxAM BOXvxMq IUnARr(YI �� ]Gl C [ Mi OD[diM(JI r (BAdt VnRD) ` ;LR[S)TO BC Rf+E0VC0"'" �w{4� OU NU GA- 7 N .. XVy Y.IML ! % AfL RCMOVAL RERM1 * 1]'eDN PM � 1pXxMD ICPURV() 4 GL I.ND LSE BoxWODD(J) 1 .• , .uwx r6w wWRMwlr '•'•' RIONNo mYEn IR+ '• UMyS O Su, a FRA TANS._ C 0,iR ! 1rr: BALLON CONTAN(R .,,._AA;Ob7S�LF-Ek .-__. y /�� M 5Y yARBL(py(�{ �� �16'60X I$�EET oUVf�) `/ -S'at IIIAABLE�uiRSON KALI(i) 1 .�. 1.'00-Y.. +kra �AY_roAANS M 0 -l. N;z0PMN(I.0 mu l" ' N NOne EPrN00tiMti' AugRLS © 5"3-2LZAeaWuz.(JS 33iCfwwAmrBbwRMT-Cu) ,;(1A-4 / 2�;10XIGEEGMPfr.—... 0 5�iBXnLLr;d,vt., M1WNui 0 GYrtA µSu ....7',1V CO * 3.qC. CryBuM. UNTC:z0.e, 0 T C—1-_,tea cltN3 ER!I) 0 ]-MOX IL,:ppa,nas(CM) & SG1in?41D4: P PMCxTEAWwiiNEvM_\ +N)6'NI VI. (N)BOO 5TA7R 61O (E)TS A'TO K.111 MT.1 (q 30.OAR w OYTOOOR ff r. M R[xG xEr ORr E BFHFA lx CANWv \ /-WORM R FAR -(t)OAK TO RERAN ` (N)S6'N vri.FENCE / r(N)X•N.w i VETO( 1 ALL 1Fe MT.NCR N w[A 7AVG Y MM tY MOR Ar Alli. r-- r EAOOnn \ F .(E)DR VGNAV TO BE REMOVED IS•�4® \ .... ..� (I/�/"".. i rl�..��-C „...--.(E) ;.F NG BROWO:47:',„:',..A". 1• All A r trt nVER-ria I� ' ,-- Ex fNGN S FEE Iiu !NI;TRW.00 0ECN�` 'lyj„1, yk,a s,. .,10.‘",.v, .)6�5515po {�"tow_•it my ✓il A /W %7�irliV F.i y. s. r' // "p: ELs'"'la`�",- ''�.'/�M 'i s °.s�•° Y 0° t'°Y°'r�t'I' ',�T E,r°°a F,_ Oi 04-„ '� J h•IR Rt.,1 i�a aiA .:• ,n” 1 rtA'7sRa :II—,.� 0y �I': rRNNEioiunwr tlw uRNnnG EA�T cALLONO m ORA.?TIDE ro REw c® F _ x €b Para .,,,i,,,,,,,- .-..x —,i • _. o •- / •+mN w PAFNwAr r (N)e•w..FENCE \\p9� - w ' 'J,Q y X L o-, a......-.«-- `tUrENEE 6- 601-00.?,qt, p?'> ,44 �L,n t _ ® l'--7"7.&( oAN TRas ro e[ —'� rEv,({)}ids• O jO*... �ff (E)OAR TO REMAIN Mix v` III A---4—•L' ., -�Ei \ ...;•,,,,10(...)- 1 ..:t.:...... . ' I '; • .... ....... „. ' rco,--:',4,---•,-.,I. - ',"4 • . air, 1 T-',7-rt'":.?-.;.,.''.'"''''.": .': 1. • .-- " Ir: --7-- _ I. - .; "1 '':•,'itr).,,i. ..... . ...,-,.. 'ME" . , 1 , •i t -,...,: ,.:::,.•! 4... : 1 \A---::•:-..:::-. ,: 0:, \,,-:•12: .-'._ .- • —N ..'_-__":"t..',:,7.,- .. '43:-:.. ';i,--..--------r i ' ' '. ''''".. ' ( leer, ' -:,... - --. ,!___T. ,j,' ."!' •-,'-r.2%,`Vgacy ‘-- A 5 , - .:ge- IN,-: .. =I Tr 1 . , 1, • -.....A..1.".° , .. ..:P.7.,..--,,e.-..!.,.:::..•.t% , ' ,. .... ''''' A 7 ih..-"'" 0 1 \AIL..„ -IfalrEllg:11,77Ftlx.,4', ..1:04 VOW AtO, . 1 ts,4, : -•i::::1,::::::-:::::::::::-....:::.•.:.•,,,,,,,,,..) , . • — a . . : --. 1, i:":-:;':.•--:.:44.44..-::::::-:i 4:..1 - '• , ,...-- , -,-....... ' . ' .... '41.4 • ., ' 411'22'11'j141,...''A'Alg5.404',"" OA b 1 Y:"•-•-•:ri-- ' 1. ''n"' LI ,:.:, :. ' .. . ‘ lel!',414N--7.-e - ..,,4,-...., , ''''''''.''' , ' ' 1._,...,4 .-• ,‘`''''. . / . "....;•-,,,'"''1,.4.5...-4D`''i. -..490‘nmarlilMiLl,e. 11: I t.., ,,, i I ' —;i----± j, t II .' 3,114 MENIVIV AV) 't ( ; 1 . ..+; • • • 20' ' illW l.. oigiii�� d RNAME1 SCREEN • VINO t 0 dirlill011114115' -. . .,.sas, .44...4-.,,, ,,,,--.„-,•„--,„ ,-'"-.0'10 '-''1'.7-v4.•‘""""*''-- --.--.-`e.7...........,,,?7,4 , ....-iiipia—railiv cimilp.f.s4v:* 4 _ At --iiih-W2W41,_*11,11144,\11, *k\ '''•-••!)r4t:ts -'•e‘i.3•1-)-' • • -.. • • -' . - . ' • • - : - - -. •--1411",ttliel.,::::f4e.,.."•44:A' '10----'-it ,A . .1a1IP P.-- 4 tit'''414 4111tAittlWr't ' : %.: -:' ; '. ' ''' * . • 1‘4‘(.4. 114"47 ill) °' 1416' .'12 ‘ 1 W P tACr741tF-gr- iLib. , titlittr p.4 Tr 014,,,,,, ).,-.)•.,„) 0;t' -... .' - . i':.,.,s-, r,l'e, ...CW. ' -110,% 10 ealioNrilit,op, 0,,,.. ,. .), • \ mw —. : -..7-, pa ,PEA ,GRYEL Q f r ' - " Q ' * t 11; 4�` 4,00 , Y • ,0Edi, ' -• A _ (N) s POOL 1,. woe. ,Ali . . .:• �, 4 SAFE FENCE �1 O;a , ''�• .. .,A . ,- `� �*�Olik,or wax* `.. n.. ..' 10I`00 _' .• e°.ew;� *-7077 -.'.-.` v ... • O * * l ,�l1""� Y ---1:ral..c—�#6',,O+e,,0, 1bis�i • w p ,o sto Y • . • . . . - ,�, ,dG .�L L ig• v � 3�� . ..4,!)T.2.7°....rjolglielialirriallillittimil" * * " * .*.'.'. .. . , . - . i . , ,,,tr,,,I,,,,,,..,,,,i.„,,,,-.„t„,„,„. 1.•.t , ,1 Jird /irk• n1� . . . . . . ' -" ''' *11,, - '------3 -A AlOgi'VM•1"012):CfOr.IRMEkra :10A'Air., r'Alt, * " ' * " " ' ''\•la�ill r". r- . . . . . . �`ilm .; �.� x wiiiiiman I, ill1._...,.... ( r O. -412.11 villa���' � /...' m..". . . . , �� ,,.-.* LjLjf- ir-ril /���® DIN����" . . . .g fi� p�. v�.. Li . . �, . g� tq ��..I.Iw _. �;rA dit 01) -13'---5° .' 1 q.a.-5 I- -DAIL •r s� w +.'0„ '.'0 "..' .c o.'0.w•. .* 2. °' -F�(a `. rii. 00 ,,,, fi, , ' . • .• • .- •• %, a . . .,... . .-, ‘,. s, . .. . . ,, 4 ' ' * - '''' * N I., ,•,....A... , ... ,,,, , ..... , timool . ,,4 . ' - -• .., • -, ' ..,, . . • • , ._........,_......,..........„1, : . . , . ,‘: .... . . . 10, nr 4- q n } • I _ x Vii;,. 0 . . . * . . .,,.• ,.. .••0,, a , ' t. f . , w !cry, • ! �j y�1,....:-.-----:-:----� • 0 A� ppC t y " ;--- :•. • • l (E) OAK ,, . �, .'. . ',y! l• 4Cl� F • G ' 4' TO R . m '-',''‘', gr--• -"-. • - ' '''''•••• 'cit' ' '. ' - ' ' ' •%-'' "e'''; ' l' itt e0 Ai rm. auk igoir.o.tivirmi ' ''' * 4 ,''„f$,,$1 � "'0.1►.,--. • rpir.i,..ii a ,b fii 4 ds�f�>*FIIt t"j. ..,, .te srir � :4ata ... . , . •Via• '7 . .. i''4 I ti .,........s.........4011 a i . • - ,, :;',' ',, -v ill •iYVi. .pr.4 "- t� s e hwLI ®:. h:4Ra" is . OIt�t•t!�(iiaw ,• . an • Curriculum Vitae WILLIAM R.MCKINLEY—MCKINLEY & ASSOCIATES 1734 Del Valle Ave. Email: william@mckinleyarborists.com Work (818)426-2432 Glendale,CA 91208 Website:http://www.mckinleywboristsscorn/ Home(818) 240-1358 SUMMARY of QUALIFICATIONS Practicing Consulting Arborist.Member of American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA).Certified Arborist,International Society of Arboriculture since September 30, 1999.I.S.A.Arborist#WE-4578A. Recognized Oak Tree Expert throughout Southern California.Prepare arborist reports for developers, homeowners and attorneys.Assess the landscape value of trees.Assess and identify hazardous trees in the landscape.Provided hillside and Oak Woodland landscape and irrigation recommendations.Provide expert witness testimony on arboriculture related cases.Public speaker and presenter at community service group meetings,homeowner's association meetings and speaker at professional seminars and conferences. Presenter at Trees,People and Our Urban Environment Seminar,March 2002.Arbor Day Guest Speaker, City of Glendale,March 2005.Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2010,Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2012,Arbor Day Guest Speaker,Glendale,March 2014. FULL TIME EMPLOYMENT HISTORY City of Glendale,Parks, Recreation& Community Services Park Services Manager-Contract Administration 2001-present Performs contract administration for Park Services Section.Manage grounds maintenance for sports fields, community buildings,parks,medians,and historic areas.Administers the City's landscape maintenance contract.Writes contract specifications.Administers the bidding process.Awards contracts to successful bidders.Conducts construction meetings and oversees the construction and inspection for these projects. Performs and assumes all former duties and responsibilities under the former Administrative Analyst position.Writes arborist reports.Hazardous tree assessment.Serves as expert witness in tree related cases. Administrative Analyst 1988-2001 Administer landscape maintenance contract for medians,reservoirs,pump houses and misc.areas. Administer and supervise the Division's Work Management System involving the scheduling and tracking of work and performance of over 50 full-time employees.Supervise one part-time data entry employee and supervise and coordinate with the California Conservation Corps,Boy Scouts and other community service volunteers in the parks.Supervise,monitor and report water and utility usage in the parks.Administer and supervise all tree planting projects and programs including the Arbor Day and Urban Forest Donation programs.Assist with budget preparation and acquisition of capital equipment.Prepare Capital Improvement Project specifications and assist with administering contracts.Administer the City of Glendale's Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Coordinate with Planning,Permit Services,Engineering, Building,Neighborhood Services and Fire Department to insure the care and protection of trees,both during and after construction. Review grading,construction,landscape and irrigation plans.Modify and approve plans as necessary to protect indigenous trees.Perform field inspections on hazardous trees and make recommendations to park staff and the public.Serve as code enforcement officer and paralegal during Administrative Office Hearings regarding Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Perform tree and landscape appraisals.Served as special show and marketing consultant to the Glendale Rose Pruning and Garden Show Committee. Assistant Planner-Parks 1983-1988 Assisted in park inventory development and implementation of the Work Management System.Served as guest speaker at the National Parks and Recreation Conference on the subject of computers and their role in park maintenance.Supervised the Capital Improvement Project Construction at Pacific Park and Brand Park.Coordinated with and supervised California Conservation Corps.Crews in planting,staking and tying hundreds of trees as part of the Arbor Day Program.Served as Arbor Day Co-Chairman,Glendale Rose Pruning&Garden Show Co-Chairman and President of Glendale Beautiful.Served as Ways and Means Chairman C.P.R.S.District XIV. EDUCATION 1983 California Polytechnic University,Pomona Bachelor of Science Degree, Park Administration Graduated Magna Cum Laude,Grade Point Average:3.57 1983-Present CEU's-University of California,Landscape Contract Maintenance,Hazardous Tree Identification&Assessment,Specimen Tree Appraisal,Advanced Tree Appraisal Theory and Practice,Tree and Landscape Liability—Trees and the Law.Oak Tree Symposium Graduate,Knowledge of oak tree physiology and native plant habitat.ASCA 2007 Consulting Academy, National Arbor Day Foundation Graduate,Symposiums: Construction Around Trees;Trees and the Law.Recognized Tree Expert:City of Los Angles County of Los Angeles,City of Pasadena,City of La Canada Flintridge,City of Burbank,City of Calabasas,County of Ventura,City of Santa Clarita. HONORS &ACTIVITIES 1999 - Present- Certified Arborist-International Society of Arboriculture 1996-1999-Secretary/Treasurer, C.P.R.S.Park Operations Section 1994-1995 - President, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1994-1995- Treasurer, Glendale Beautification Advisory Council 1992-1994 -Treasurer, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1993, 1994,1995 C.P.R.S.Park Operations Scholarship First,Second and Third Year,Graduate,Pacific Southwest Maintenance Mgmt.School 1988-1990—President,Glendale Beautiful 1980, 1981 - Twice placed on Dean's Honor List 1982 - Who's Who in American Colleges and Universities 1978 - Recipient of Wayne Striker Memorial Scholarship 1975 - Awarded Eagle Scout Rank,Boy Scouts of America Member- American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA) Member - International Society of Arboriculture Member - Western Chapter,International Society of Arboriculture Member—Glendale Beautiful Past Member - National Arbor Day Foundation Past Member - California Oak Foundation REFERENCES Randall S.Stamen,Attorney/Arborist (951)787-9788 Susan&Gary Sims,Sims Tree Specialists (951)685-6662 Peter&Diana Harnisch,Harnisch Tree Care (626)444-7997 PROFESSIONAL SERVICE FEE Site Inspection - $100.00 per hour Consultation - $125.00 per hour Arborist Report - $150.00 per hour Public Hearing - $200.00 per hour Arbitration - $225.00 per hour Deposition - $250.00 per hour Court Witness - $350.00 per hour ore McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Arborist Letter March 6, 2020 Mr. Rainy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck, NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifman: Recently you contacted me and requested a final inspection and letter of completion concerning the protected Oak and Sycamore trees located on your property. On Thursday, March 5, 20201 arrived at your property located at 1 1 1 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia. I proceeded to take photographs of all the Oak and Sycamore trees growing in the front and back yard. During my inspection I noted that my recommendations had all been followed and that all the existing, protected trees were still alive and had survived the construction process. There are four new Coast Live Oak trees which have been planted on the subject property. Three new Oaks have been planted in the front yard and one Oak has been planted in the back yard. All the new trees appear to be normal and healthy. All the Oak and Sycamore trees have mulch around them and irrigation has been minimized. After inspecting the Coast Live Oak and California Sycamore trees on the subject property I am satisfied that the contractor has complied with the tree protection plan and mitigation measures as outlined in my Arborist Report. At this point I see no reason why the project should not be approved by the City of Arcadia. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at (818)426-2432 or my office at(818) 240-1358. Yours truly, William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants F/g4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Arborist Report 111 Hacienda Drive Arcadia, California Prepared for: Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck, NY 11020 Prepared by: William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist #WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture 1734 Del Valle Avenue Glendale, CA 91208 Arborists and Environmental Consultants • • 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 March 9, 2018 Mr. Ramy Zaifman 27 Tanners Road Great Neck,NY 11020 Dear Mr. Zaifinan: Recently you contacted me concerning your plans to construct a new single family home on your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia. I was asked to review the plans, inspect the trees and determine which trees would require removal and prepare a report. The following Arborist Report summarizes my findings: Background On Friday,February 9,2018 I received your signed proposal concerning the Arborist Report. I met with your sister-in-law,Nancy Chang and Christopher Loh your architect at your property located at 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia and went over the proposed building plans. On Wednesday, February 14,2018 I arrived at the subject property and began measuring and evaluating the health and condition of the trees. The Tree/Site Inspection Section describes my observations concerning the subject trees. Tree/Site Inspection Tree#1 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 19 inches in diameter at D.B.H. (Diameter Breast Height)as measured 54 inches above the soil grade. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 20 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 7 feet north of Hacienda Drive and 4 feet east of the west circular driveway entrance. The tree is situated in an ivy bed. It leans and grows 30 degrees south over Hacienda Drive. There is epicormic sprouting on the trunk. A small 5 inch diameter cavity was observed on the east side of the tree's trunk at a point 18 inches above the ground. Minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the tree's bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. There is decay in the old pruning wounds. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is severely unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 1 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#0P2 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 18 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 30 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located on the neighbor's property near the front yard of the subject property. It is 34 feet north of Hacienda Drive and 6 feet west of the western driveway of the subject property. It is situated in a shrub bed surrounded by Privet and Camellia shrubs. This single trunk specimen forms 2 unequal size stems at a point 6 feet above the ground. These stems form a narrow V-shaped crotch at their union. There is included bark tissue at the union creating weak structure. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by other nearby Oak trees. Bleeding cankers are visible on the lower trunk. The tree is exhibiting signs of Phytophthora a root disease. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Tree#3 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 40 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 40 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 80 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 25 feet north of Hacienda Drive and 22 feet east of the driveway along the west side of the property. It is situated in an ivy bed. The crown has been pruned and raised. There are multiple bleeding cankers along the lower 7 feet of the tree's trunk. This single trunk specimen develops 2 co-dominant stems at a point 10 feet above the ground. The stems form a normal U-shaped saddle at the union. The tree has a 3 foot long vertical stress crack on the north side of the trunk. There are sunken areas on the trunk just above the root crown. The bark tissue is checking and cracking along the lower trunk. White fungal tissue is visible where the bark has exfoliated. I sounded the trunk and it resonated indicating that there are hollow areas where decay is present in the lower trunk. The foliage size and color appears to be normal. I would estimate that approximately 20%of the tree's crown is composed of dead wood. The crown density is sparse. The tree is clearly declining and dying. It appears to have Phytophthora a type of root disease and heart rot decay within the main lower trunk. This tree is potentially hazardous and is in very poor health and condition. Rating: D- Tree#4 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 24 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 30 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 44 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 37 feet north of Tree#3 and 5 feet east of the west side of the circular driveway. The tree is situated in a 4 foot diameter circular brick tree well. The base of the tree's trunk or root Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 2 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued crown is located 9 inches below the surrounding soil grade. Oak leaf debris surrounds the trunk. The lower trunk area appears to be intact.No mushrooms, cavities or decay was observed. There is minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree leans 30 degrees southeast. The crown has been pruned and raised. A limb approximately 9 inches in diameter has been pruned and removed on the east side of the tree's trunk 6 feet above the ground. Old bleeding from a wound is visible on the north side of the tree's trunk. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree appears to be in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Tree#5 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 18 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 28 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 48 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located in the front yard of the subject property. It is 15 feet south of the southeast corner of the existing house and it is 10 feet west of the wrought iron fence near the east boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Star Jasmine ground cover grows under the tree. The tree's roots are partially paved over by the circular driveway and brick walkway. It is a single-trunk specimen which forms 2 co-dominant stems at a point 7 feet above the ground. There is included bark tissue at the union of these stems creating weak structure. The tree leans 15 degrees south. It is crowded by the neighbor's Oak tree. The subject tree has narrow crotches and weak structure. The crown has been pruned and raised. The tree is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Tree#0P6 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 20 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 25 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 30 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located in the neighbor's side yard roughly 10 feet north of the southeast corner of the subject property house and 2 feet east of the wood fence which runs along the eastern boundary of the subject property. It is situated in an irrigated shrub bed. Tobira Pittosporum shrubs surround the tree's trunk. The tree leans 30 degrees south. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#7 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 24,24 and 30 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 25 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 50 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 3 OTO McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard. It is 7 feet east of the western house extension on the existing house and 24 feet north of the main portion of the existing house. The tree is situated in a 14 foot diameter circular planter. Camellia and Gardenia shrubs grow nearby. Irrigation is present. The tree has 3 co-dominant stems which form a union at a point 4 feet above the ground. A fourth trunk or stem was cut on the southwest side of the tree. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is balanced with minor asymmetry. The trunks have been cabled for support. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in above average health and condition. Rating: B- Tree#8 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 19 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 31 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 31 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 15 feet north of Tree#7 and 7 feet northeast of the northeast corner of the western house extension. The tree is situated in a small shrub planter surrounded by Holly. Irrigation is in the nearby planter within the tree's root zone. The tree leans 30 degrees northwest. Bark tissue is missing at the root crown on the west side of the trunk. The bark tissue on the trunk is checking and cracking.No growth cracks are visible along the trunk. There is minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. Old pruning wounds have not closed. Decay is present at these pruning sites. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. It is crowded by another nearby Oak. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. It is stressed and is clearly dying. The tree is in very poor health and condition. Rating: D- Tree#9 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 14 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 25 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 25 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is northeast of Tree#8 and 14 feet east of the southeast corner of the existing swimming pool. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Azalea, Camellia, Moraea and Ferns grow nearby. The lower trunk is intact.No mushrooms,cavities or decay was observed. It has co-dominant stems with included bark tissue creating weak structure. The tree leans slightly north and is crowded by other Oak trees on the south side. The crown grows north. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 4 it. McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#10 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 12 and 13 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 35 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 57 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 35 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 11 feet southeast of Tree#9. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Azalea and Camellia shrubs grow nearby. The tree leans 30 degrees east however some of the limbs extend west. The tree is semi-balanced with minor asymmetry. It has co-dominant stems with included bark tissue creating weak structure. The tree is crowded by other nearby Oaks. The crown has been pruned and raised. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#11 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 20 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 24 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 30 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 9 feet south of Tree#10. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Camellia shrubs surround the tree's trunk. The tree leans 15 degrees southeast. It has a vertical, linear form of growth habit. The tree is crowded by other nearby Oaks. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. It has been pruned and raised. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Tree#12 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 22 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 32 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 34 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 31 feet north of the northeast corner of the existing house and 15 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub bed. English Ivy grows nearby. The tree grows upright. It forms 2 co-dominant stems with included bark tissue at a point 9 feet above the ground. The tree has weak structure. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical growing mostly on the south,east and west sides. Overhead utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#13 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 5 and 17 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 30 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 41 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 5 .7. McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 17 feet north or Tree#12 and 14 feet west of the block wall which runs along the east boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub planter bed. Camellias and Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. Oak leaf mulch surrounds the tree's trunk. There is a small patch of exfoliating bark tissue at the root crown on the west side. There is minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The crown has been pruned and raised. The tree is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown grows eastward. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#14 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 12 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 12 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 22 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 30 feet northeast of Tree#13 and 3 feet west of the block wall which runs along the east boundary. The tree is situated in an irrigated shrub bed. Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. The crown has been pruned and raised. Overhead utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is semi-balanced with minor asymmetry. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood was observed in the tree's crown. The tree is in poor health and condition. Rating: D Tree#15 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 8 and 22 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 37 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 37 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 6 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary and it is 40 feet north of Tree#14. The tree is situated in a shrub bed. It is surrounded by Tobira Pittosporum shrubs. Utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The tree leans 30 degrees south. It has been pruned and raised. The tree is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree #16 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 12 and 16 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 28 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 33 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 45 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 23 feet west of Tree#15. The tree is situated in a shrub bed near the edge of the lawn. It is Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 6 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued crowded by other nearby trees. The tree leans and grows southwest. The 12 inch diameter stem grows low over the nearby lawn and may need to be cut back. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. Dead wood is visible in the crown. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#17 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 17 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 32 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 34 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 28 feet northeast of Tree#16 and 2 feet northwest of the existing wood shed. The tree is situated in a shrub bed. Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. It leans 15 degrees northwest. There is a stress crack on the south side of the trunk. Heavy Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the bark tissue along the lower trunk. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. It grows in a westerly direction. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree #18 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 10 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 14 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 18 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 50 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 26 feet northeast of Tree#17 and 3 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary. It is situated in a natural mulch area. The tree is crowded by other nearby trees. It grows northwest. Overhead utility wires run along the east side of the tree's crown. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Tree#19 is a Platanus racemosa or California Sycamore. The tree measures 18 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 27 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 70 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 9 feet north of Tree#15 and 8 feet west of the block wall which runs along the eastern boundary. The tree is situated in a shrub bed. Cast Iron Plants surround the tree's trunk. There is missing and exfoliating bark tissue on the west side of the trunk above the root crown. Severe Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the tree's bark tissue along the lower trunk. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised,headed and topped. Epicormic growth was observed near these pruning cuts. There is a large 7 inch diameter dead limb on the south side of the tree. Decay is visible. It is crowded by other nearby trees. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The tree has begun to grow new leaves. The tree is in slightly above average health and condition. Rating: C+ Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 7 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#20 is a Platanus racemosa or California Sycamore. The tree measures 14 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 18 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 18 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 10 feet southwest of Tree#19 and 9 feet east of Tree#16. It is situated in a shrub bed. The tree is surrounded by Cast Iron Plant,Tobira Pittosporum and Viburnum shrubs. There is severe Western Sycamore Borer insect damage on the bark tissue on the west side of the tree's trunk just above the root crown. It is crowded by other nearby trees. It leans and grows 30 degrees southwest. The tree's crown has been pruned and raised. It is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The crown has been headed back and this has produced epicormic or sucker growth. It is producing new leaves. The tree is in slightly below average health and condition. Rating: C- Tree#21 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 14 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 20 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 25 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 40 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 40 feet east of the west boundary block wall and 6 feet south of the north boundary wood fence. It is situated in a shrub bed. Indian Laurel Fig, Fern Pine,Citrus and Oleander grow nearby. The lower trunk area is intact.No mushrooms,cavities or decay was observed. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by the neighbor's Coast Live Oak. The subject tree's crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical growing mostly south. Overhead utility wires run along the north side of the tree. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is fair. Dead wood is visible in the tree's crown. The tree is in below average health and condition. Rating: D+ Tree#22 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 10 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 15 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 20 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 30 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is near the northwest corner of the subject property. The tree is 10 feet east of the block wall which runs along the west boundary and it is 5 feet south of the chain-link fence which runs along the north boundary. It is situated in a shrub bed. Oleander and Tobira Pittosporum shrubs grow nearby. The tree leans 30 degrees west into the neighbor's property. The lower trunk area is intact.No mushrooms, cavities or decay was observed. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is crowded by the nearby neighbor's Coast Live Oak. Overhead utility wires run along the north side of the tree. The crown is unbalanced and asymmetrical. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is sparse. Dead wood is visible in the crown. The tree is in poor condition. Rating: D Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 8 4 McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Tree/Site Inspection-Continued Tree#23 is a Quercus agrifolia or Coast Live Oak. The tree measures 28 inches in diameter at D.B.H. The tree has a drip line which measures approximately 24 feet from the tree's trunk. The spread of the tree is 42 feet. The height of the tree is estimated to be roughly 60 feet tall. The tree is located in the back yard of the subject property. It is 55 feet south of the north boundary fence and 6 feet east of the west boundary block wall. The tree is situated in a shrub bed surrounded by Glossy Privet,Viburnum and Tobira Pittosporum shrubs. The tree grows upright and the lower trunk area is intact.No mushrooms,cavities or decay was observed. Minor Western Sycamore Borer insect damage was observed on the tree's bark tissue on the lower trunk. Orange growth cracks are visible on the trunk indicating that the tree still has vigor.This single trunk specimen forms 2 co-dominant stems at a point 17 feet above the ground. The crown has been pruned and raised. It is semi-balanced with minor asymmetry. The foliage size and color appears normal. The crown density is normal.Minor flagging and dead foliage was observed in the crown caused by Oak Twig Girdler insects. The tree is in excellent health and condition. Rating: A- General Observations The subject property is situated in a single family home residential neighborhood in the City of Arcadia. The subject property and the nearby homes in the neighborhood are attractive and well maintained. The subject property and neighborhood have a considerable number of mature native trees growing there.This area appears to have been a former Oak Woodland Plant community before it was developed. The subject property has numerous native Coast Live Oak and California Sycamore trees growing in both the front yard and the back yard. There are 5 existing Coast Live Oak trees which conflict with the proposed new single family home. They include: Tree#9,Tree#10,Tree#11, Tree#12 and Tree#13. There are 2 other Coast Live Oaks identified as Tree#3 and Tree #8 which must be removed because they are diseased and are in danger of falling. The removal of these 7 Oak trees will require tree removal permits from the City of Arcadia. Recommendation Based upon my inspection of the subject tree and property it is my professional opinion that in order to build the new house according to the proposed design it will be necessary to remove 5 healthy Coast Live Oak trees. These are Tree#9,Tree#10,Tree#11,Tree #12 and Tree#13. There are 2 diseased,dying Coast Live Oaks identified as Tree#3 and Tree#8 which are hazardous and in danger of falling. These 2 trees must also be removed Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 9 alre McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Recommendation-Continued for safety reasons. The proposed removal of the 5 healthy Oak trees due to conflict with proposed construction will require a City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for Removal of Healthy Trees. The proposed removal of the 2 diseased,hazardous Oak trees will require a City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for Removal of Diseased and or Hazardous Trees. In order to preserve and protect the remaining trees on the property I would recommend that the following tree protection mitigation measures be followed: 1) Temporary orange plastic fencing should be installed around the drip line or farthest point possible from the trunk of all the protected Oak and Sycamore trees to be preserved prior to commencement of work. 2) Minimize excavation and trenching within the drip line of the protected trees. 3) Roots which are cut or otherwise damaged should be pruned to the side of the excavation with a clean, sharp pruning tool and kept covered with burlap and wetted daily until the excavation area can be backfilled. 4) Minimize storage of building materials and equipment within the drip line of the protected trees in order to minimize soil compaction. 5) Prohibit dumping of foreign substances such as excess soil, concrete,cement, stucco,paint, etc. within the drip line of the trees. 6) Designate an area outside the drip line of the trees to clean and wash equipment so as not to impact the root zones of the protected trees. 7) Pruning of limbs and branches of trees shall be performed by a State Licensed Tree Contractor under the supervision of an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. 8) All pruning shall comply with ANSI A-300 Pruning Standards and Best Management Practices. 9) An I.S.A. Certified Arborist should be hired to oversee and supervise all work within the drip line of the remaining protected Oak and Sycamores. Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 10 OTIO McKinley & Associates (818) 240-1358 Summary/Conclusion In conclusion,it is my professional opinion that in order to build the proposed new single family home based on the current design it will be necessary to remove 5 healthy Oak trees identified in this report as Tree#9,Tree#10, Tree#11,Tree#12 and Tree#13. There are 2 diseased and hazardous Oak trees identified in this report as Tree#3 and Tree #8 which must also be removed for reasons of safety and liability. A City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for the Removal of Healthy Trees will be necessary in order to remove the 5 healthy Oak trees. In addition,a City of Arcadia Protected Tree Permit for the Removal of Diseased and or Hazardous Trees will be necessary in order to remove the 2 diseased and hazardous Oak trees. Remaining trees to be preserved should be fenced at the drip line or as far from the trunk as possible. Dumping of foreign materials within the drip line of the trees shall be prohibited. Trenching and cutting of roots should be minimized. Damaged or torn roots must be pruned back to the side of the trench with a clean, sharp,pruning tool and kept covered and wetted until backfill can occur. Pruning of tree branches and limbs should be performed by a state licensed tree contractor and supervised by an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. The pruning shall comply with ANSI A-300 Pruning Standard and Best Management Practices. All work within the drip line of the remaining Oak and Sycamore trees should be supervised by an I.S.A. Certified Arborist. Tree#1 and Tree#19 should be monitored for further signs of decline. A Licensed Pesticide Applicator should be hired to control the Western Sycamore Borer insects on the trees.The remaining trees should be routinely pruned approximately every 3 to 5 years to eliminate dead wood and maintain overall health and safety. Limitations Information contained in this report covers only those areas that were examined and reflects the condition of those areas at the time of inspection.The inspection was limited to visual examination of accessible areas without excavation,drilling or boring.Arboriculture is not an exact science and there is much that is still to be learned about trees.The observations and recommendations provided in this report reflect the latest research,knowledge and training available through university and professional research.There is no warranty or guarantee,expressed or implied,that problems or deficiencies of the trees or property in question may not arise in the future. Thank you for the opportunity to serve you and your environmental and horticultural needs. If you have any further questions,please feel free to contact me on my business cell phone at(818)426-2432 or you may call my office phone at(818)240-1358. Yours truly, 2. 27 William R. McKinley, Consulting Arborist American Society of Consulting Arborists Certified Arborist#WE-4578A International Society of Arboriculture Arborists and Environmental Consultants Page 11 111 HACIENDA DRIVE ° ARCADIA, CA 91006 a DESIGN ) I • 1 - . 1 e 1 �� 4. I { fel , r c 7 {I it � ' •-- it I �i ' F r ! : 0. { 0 1 1- 'I I- dA' .Q� iN:7= 8 I _ I+r.. 7;1 FMB i - 6 Y V , I — <W 1 RFSI()FNi F ti 1 . (' ) a/ I I $ cum . 3 I\ I ! s,x a 9NIr �; { 1. I P 11 l= a mu e= !i ,xt,. .., -...i7,,... , , ,, , ... . it- 'r , • . , ,.;1_:•iii_,:.1,;.:-.::. ...., .4z...5-4 • LL ' Y� i , ,:. .. .uy i' ^ r.7 ' fir! ,i • g -„Fc1 -1'Wr i MI' `y•may T,�..„ ,$ t, • -• . 1♦ ;?:4:*♦.4.4%:::.- l': :*'' rIttL{�"- ,..1r• +. ` i • . s._ v \ ., , itIii), \ r W 7. L., d Nom. Z� ` ,i .6 tic. T- ., ..,..4.,.; tzi... .r....•::-,- •,, 'l � i:'w • -4 ^t 1 -.ice iv-It, 7T.1r �irtc :' , � tri•.. .• i.' ' .. CI! Pte. '� -41 " i '_. � 1. i. `s. !ss5' 1.xr1`, ., � � • `, \• A ` �, 01. ` ..• r ;y ap w �';' y,i., 1`;;, I 1. . lilk : \ i * a .- `,fir. ,t- '- .Y • - -'. ` .E , Z4..... :.gat'. �� % ice- .•• •• a -r - `.r�'_"N'• 'h' '. ' • a_z. se' . 4" -''''4i, - _ •. . 4• ' b 4 - . j ..1,"_ -` ) - so ft IV _ � e • 41t4A \,. le 3 " - ' .. .1:.2:Z4 .V.�i: - ,t•.• • t _ _ ♦ Jam-_�.'- •• r E k a ` IF _` ! ' . _ r• _ is tr _ Z Oise „mai�` ? ..�-. .•-_ .�_ '' ':.flit..' - . kb.: ..' ,.e..itilidt!. 4.- ei,....‘'.111A.,..,..... ...... ..- ....:_ _- .' .: 7.:.......744.:S.4144. ....-PI'. �j► ....„:7,7i, _N:1_.-•141::: '.'le-...- '-'.4:4 :I:7i 41 011 -- - , .? Nts 4.- ' 00, i .Xt'..".. .411-';t:. --,. „ it, '�. s : • Z1111 x \ 4•y ' }`{5r•• • y`+• 1 I, 1 „• ,�n. \1YJ� , '✓ 1i � 1`,�'�k x'�..• r� • ' L.a.lt,•ivi!, ;.t ri '•I +rpt IR. r .,'7, (1 1 S. .� ,J �5t� 'ter• itt T r b .,� ,'�.��`• t '?. S�� .r.�•S.�Ry�YT a • .,� e'r `.� k I.}Fi ,.,3„. . �L, ,. •, ,Y r '•• • '� � ',S) ,j,,, , ...•,%.4);,,,ethc,•. 'A - • , ;• . • ' •.*�� .v: -{��1S�,r :%, % Y j/Y•!..,... t?!yb; �'j %'.r:. ,•.,l, S•-A..��1,' ' ' :, ,. r,WV -r '" d." �', r..LS L mss'• � 1) r �r r '+'�rr •t • ' , r, •rl -. 't'''1!•',. `-, , !,/ . • .r, •,c,',-- .•.! _. y. .4 4'•'�"Ct., •� A;. 1, ` ,' ..R S. ` • , i.' 4 rl <n, �1.kc , ♦' •. .•� „ '! ?. • •.j• . ,., ' 7•tre' . �•• i . 'fie f `�•ri 1 ' l=l • .i , • • • • ... i, .•t1J1y. •• it !/mow' .♦ - e :•� ;a 4 •% '• '• ` S ' c.. .• r • � _!♦K/r .r�* )'� ' * •: • •. . .,.,•, . *'`, A'! �' Vis' ', s /,• • �\ IAL C • �, F .�.: L4F !�'7� �4. -lt'.. 3� al. .l r. , t { � •4 _•`S. r •• i'.:5. J , �f 11'11 �•b •."-,-•- -�..�r,, • �i - . Jj1 '�� 'r •�,, 21,� ::' - VI. .•rt •e•rr' , ;''`t.'t: 4' A': 'II" ,ter • Lt`• L el' ‘i,',./ : irk � Nom• , r-44._ • Nil* •• ' - ':% '7Y'. '' '' ,• l•"'; j A.41"t'.t ,1, •:4;"," ,„ 1y -lr • � S l.r?� ,rx ..�.�l.i -..f"J� ^ . ,. ' ,•Y `j t'.i'.e'- .• • ` t, rjr -�C`"[` ,1 i•0„"'' .'yy;f `.. •!• 'y '#-1 044. • A w t •1 .W,� r'?t h+r '' •• S. -.11'' ary ,,t: ''t•-r;.4....,‘.':.> +N t', w{ L • / . 4. - ♦ •n �..• .r-• •.�fi '. ,) S• -a s- _ •!'� iI l 'd.v f M •1, ;et...*. �• y;-mss ._ '� } • `,' >�. YV4 1.` i.. r X .;''Qr•1:I. �Y`; +, - '. .y'r t-4`"1;:y.Y� � � x '� !\ •3 � ''. t ;Sri_: .. .i�i . • �.% �. - S f . .7c• •{.)) , fir y�,I`4� ??4�. ..�''�',,•'� •-,0q,. i• ,J� 1.1a• �(�_ I. 7 j .� . 7-4„,-4.4.-. -. -- ..,..- . ♦- p • ''+ • . [ 1`T y �•/ -e, ;f •�t t,l y y s .7•' ks V � �} r. 3k 4 .jeW1fifi. -'<i j.c , 1 a'r t� Imeka . r r • ^�RRR 4 C�-F3 7'J'—'1-..?:"-:'''.- . • r'..1:,L ?•w j• �^• �t Rs�'. .s. i it- t.r..4. *ter. ` ,,'{Li_ ..t•. 1 Y` r , •. ? 'r.� • iie) -.� ? {..r r'• • Y ••.,. .�. jY. ,, /�I. }r,,t;.3• � . 1 �.�� �iti• ' •�r �,� S r ,.tet• L• , � • _� • a -- ;1,.. 1.. •� � 1 am I ' ♦ �1• •' ,. '� „x0i �V+ ' .. i.4 '. t- *.1";,14,..J4.. '1'R. .apt, 1•' t.,t, .°.i""'.(.?5Y�.. .a � - -+•, ,•' �• `_r. "' `S '�'6. _ .,ai- �' .� Jr*ti• t ��-rr�j l.'�i •� \ • 4ylbk• . �.;. j! c I I '- .J •'�S SC i•A. -.r. 1, y 's` it. �,. '�,CY*� •i • �t did ' ' �liN; .ly �` • l :/ }.. .? .:;-it.,-L'" �. y -w 1, ..% ,ice '144 .��. .44P • it . ''''' . ' . ,. , - AY. .'.itik.1;4,.4,, .11111kk....4,'":31.' "1:114‘ '. -' '''41.'0... .,.,. . . , , 14:, : y •. • � . ^» I17 -c q . 1;3y .'v _ '1c. .s� , f'. x ,'+ 1` r �. .+, , •.{ ' ,•..' •t'e"t ,';. `-_ ,. .may,. .1{;r J # . - �.. • i 9•.: ter 6{ _ • • .. ., , ,:. ,,,,,_,..„... .... , ii., . • 4....,,• .. • =4114 r' •• _ �� .,�„�,,t: .I.• �!Fr -�Y � rj �. a.►fir "' ` ; ,�� Qom. q. k: '•••' — I �. • I •yI e r • a r i .;.i i: r1 il.' 40.1 - ,@ 'f 4 s�1 • • ` '1 r, • $ -'' ••: • i • 7 '.t,,, {• •i ;,tl3 's 4 s dye: r ir• re, 1•1416,..,VV • •71y • V 111 } ---g .�tC' ' t.VJ s . - ' - ....• • .-..- 747. -.-.7;'".14:•"...„.44....,"' ••••••,.. ..... 0 ....7.....--s T \ \ - e 4 ht - '} L' • i s - 3. r; • t..... IP ,,. ......co.� 4y wv t` •y. ■r •, .r .y �. �f:, (. . r�� .�,- .2'1W. .. •.l kyr 4 . _ ., aiiv. f A,' 70 7• TA1 `nsrrr �4 �..- `e ,Y tt J.:1l i . , E ` • '1 •R ` ` , • .P-. 4 4 t: • �.. +n.. • I i! a to .n� 4 ,� _ •r J JL atw f _• li_ ♦ r:. �, • a s, e 4 11, y� . ! t• v. —..i? ,ar— I- 4' E.'.�� t'1} r�r'l r.,. :9 (� sr"nS Ilk' " i.; `�1'�fF.:. 1�' _ � ►i ,/+. - .+ 1 .:4. ji E 'C i`yp t t}.a�, t� is «►� :4414441 .. �, e alt" .7 .. i [���• . , 4 e re - 3i ` Ir� ` i- :- ,,!,' ,-,i., , ir •i '',7- .. _. .',, mry- •'' . a 401.:"7 ,,• ' A . it.t . 4IF • , . .. -,i,... 1, t•- ,r� ` ';Y✓ ` • t fi�rr ii. if,-,,,,, ` 'M'0. + L j, 1ti -� .:.L - Wit,. t . • 14• AF, -Itt.i' fii4 4 -r.!. -A,•i /Pr , . •,.•••,•.-:.A...v_:,.w_J.__.- , II i• ,0.. . ......a T r' ' I ft .. gi.n 711. }^ yt. ., 'rte-. • 1 +M0,,,i'c''. ...•k •1'1.° '•. . .. ..,,-- - .. .,i ,�•O, ,r. :l} .yw e { - '+` i!' •t\•$: �!L_,. 1 1 wv '.'•� S•TR. Ope .„,..441 ''�(�.. ,. ,, JAf - y 4,......•41,7t.,.....1.. a F. 's, .. �,. \7.4'014•�`t _ .w ii:"' �4/'. ::7 • \ � _r f _ ai" ..IST -@� Mad �.��f' �. 1 .d' a mv-r- ) l 1�% . l 1 7 a MINI4, ._......_ . " . •� - sem_ ,� .., „,..: . ..„...„... • t.. a.�s •', f r -c.` - d ' > `. -.n:' i„,. _981;`, o -' ; ! ...44.,,;,-,.,";-„,-,,e_ 1 r' e av • 4T j.i..a _4.• ' }vivt -L A. ,2-=t ., +. - r ,+C4 4,.. - '. . ,„,„ .` .r f i'+Y�e ♦�, ,, .,y•, . 4,...-.'E..v `; . ' r s1' '2i• -' l• 1! - ,}k • .� y' t \. 'R 1 • 0.-... , ,1....:.. �iic.:, _ f! Yak ` y - Y. .� f.� yp�?, -'fes. ,n • T • 1 •• .••Pr' r5' ` Vie (x'1 ',,,1014'.. , 1 F. - ^..l . .V_ , M�.• :S 4. � `, >•�f y [t W ie * t� > v 7 �M.tt!•J rte/ A 7. . 'P! M= v :• � ; '� 'f t �tYt' T • .R�Mb 4'r r.i.!. .� tJ t -'4,, - . �R '.e3 rr i :6Y> :t' 4--= 3- , .?} � _ ,.11 `-4'Y . Y. •4. ..-'' .. .�` ••1� , J- ; d �_�_ 1'. e 1Y1 fl, k s•-• •-•;').-4. r,+c - /. aR' r s ...' - r': R • i,�� • revr -.. 4.'1 ��,t C ` ` ' -" 'te , ' ;, ^' . �. " •4':• -...,I-3,-;,;` w _ , ,4 7 '..M !';, we r. �v, ,:.t s %4 .....:".• 1� �e". ... 4• K "� '''.. -v� �i .f :yidc �'-. y`3`"� ;'i• <k �,.. '� • ^ �..+=t ,'t ': iF'�� t• 'I.0 FyQ r^_ 3,i y `. j y '?�, - - tfdt�9 -'°Y� ,1 1T 4. �.?� •4 .yl,,• • 1 •R '•s •�- .r `+ c - - .+•• i' Y-.A1r•Y,�} T '.. Yt sc - • _7/4 '�; �I .. -a to, „o '•YI .( v r -t r4' sa .r �' • • T • 7r�.N'r• 1• .y j r i-' - �r :P � .,, �Vr .,F .4( 'rte O.`, n • .! ' •"-*< 7Y :+ - y + t • .war.- �". .•(rte„ ,._; 1 _ %.,..:t • � •.c.„.....,...,•......-...,..?.., ),.-.. ,.,,,,-,....-..t..- ,, - t,� ,Z - _ �t y�..� , ^ t f 1." }. • `'.'ti,.,,tr .¢� .� X!•• ".! .04.-,,,,, i :.+,�,�, .„4„,..„,,,,,,‘,..::„.... r 4 '. 't. '... '-'t , �;;^:.•rof X�o.� &. S -- - 1"- 4 4,.'F '; • •-` ,::4i }4 1 • - -,'`• -1 '�• 7 ' .. •.-`..• t> •L‘,.'!-•'- •,? y ''2r .1 -, - ,&4 ( •r•'}•i +4 {; 4 r t .r'IS .•}Ry 4 1.-:'''•.. !. --%-i.,1%-... ' y t , •• IC 1 I •.'7f• 3.` tL-,....,•,.`•••• •:....4.i.,-.,ty'.,: S• �'i _t. '.•-•'',d--'._'1' ,`yam{ y•`r(y •.C' r'f, JY": b �I.. 1'1 ' ; �6•�d ''{��y,• _ i tC • -:-'c d • -7.i` �. - •41 . ".•8'; 7. .M1 4 . --, -1'i'. � `r-A,,,..•, { t ' ._ . - .v. x• a •�• 1:•41,,, .�,,r, i ,. ^ J4! ow..r-4t• 4 7x. 4-s '''`. •, _`b..�'.. • 4. ,. f �.- ...';:-•,,;,;,,-; �• •'"4" ,*.- ..t ;- _`t -,!ir. i -• ,j1�i •''£- t,: Wit• tai` .4.- 1"'171..1' Y;yi • • i �?. w ,,"tr.4' �3.'�;_ I kt h K >a' '.'°' .•- �r� -I �1 ;.4 4i. fi.i,,*. 4+ y r•;r} a.r -•, .� w �,z ' • . r • y • • T' • < .' 7 '3': '•''i '' t ''''•14w •••.''-'.71 'c 5 , *i M1 p'� • r v ''•*.-�.., { 1 '`• .J ! . #�.ti -. 11, � '� ! .d.'!✓"1.-('''::,•7 ' t;1 • -* 7'''' �' ,r. .�.a•, �, •X' • t tr.� i� �� T '3 Y} �• �:s.'�,kt'- fS.°"�L' _ ti ° ,.!' . ti►. t `;y•Vim'• Y� ' i�'h� ` �r. . tv Y 7 � s� r• .aY /. . ,. "14 Iti•Ur ?w C.. p[,:� O" I • '�- i :r • .., . ,•", , Irr..,. .. '1;4, ., •'f '- .L▪ + • 5 ' rd'a ,.,y �'.i ti.' . _ •Y r yt5, .•. 1 �:, . , k ,, -';,► w .�77 ' it .% i y. ' Z r �wRlr'i' �:• 'L' .y 4t• y.7/'' 1 t , :r r k ,Viii;,-..N., .4i. ,4• a^"' �y • ... • ..:••. •% .1i. •A• .s;T F '4.' ,iliiiii A R >Yr,' K••. � !','•;.,!, hT*' ,r � .. 4 ; �' .�r� td ;��titi t�• 17'yy, o'L r-• • • y •••'''t.'',.ei • ,r _� . ..0A,� '�i.#. 'g�, . ,,i.,f .yLtiS. 1 ••!R i„Irt t 1\ ,,1 sL f ` :�• ;-.iis,,, ' ".,jY r _ �• 1 f +. '' ` 100,;1;' T ••' y. r +� J ..• t. r -,y't>r. „ �( 4':.t - y drt 4� ',.•4 t'. • 7 +��# ' 7� 1• ,' `>', (: •I'', (Y•,i ,.'4-7.rQ *,,,,:-..-0,., .,yy T ! ) 1 ''a• -,-5)..L'i: 0 _.•V$•� ....4.-,.,,,..,4-.T , - j `_' ♦`' I_a .y' .,' .-.1,,�, M ^ !.,v • r, 1,7y1�tl4 ` -r 40 tt. �• �` • y,._ 1•••'!7•1. itll- ;/ •,• - t ,4, i /'�!'rt• �I 'N •- it , ,. .,tr�'r '� ,''r. ..•), •f S!,..3.,•.%��'� 1�'•1,• t�s'*•n4 �• t +'f�;:;� �'`'7!i•.�Cfr .. 'r y ' J .,-.1k.1. 1.M}' ., � ' t _, �t-�s.i/` 4. ,I�'/'. ,�x'f�/ f.y A .:� ,(r/ 4 ��: 'i • r\1 S"I +. y , , :fN i. , �1.0"'1` T '\ '1'•• ,: • se.,i , F <' y' jai •4,:*,. ••! ., i iKaf • • • tow 11 ,/ Ti �'• •:. '...‘,e....-.4.„..&" S� s�ir,-- °Y ?�.f' {�. • : t; cr • • R , rryy . • /3. kJ v r` r'1 .i 1 • } i'`y"' •. . f}+.{��_ + i •, • . `, ; • • ?-it • `1.• 5 ', •' • "3. .i.-r=7 AF.• "� `k .... . r.S ••-\ , '' .? '• �< , �,• .ti` ..,...".,.1...c.1" .,),..y � A� •'�;F .yf. r !e,,,..;,. .,._ y „s 7+ .Yy #:--x,+ . 4 1 ••y'1•'l. v• tie., t C, •.i .y► • s. \t• _n go • ..4.4.r: ii•�: l „tY.•,,�/yi/ ; 1 •w 7 C .4 xl ' tlfA . • '• ,-3„'..t41 '°. '� t+••,�f 'Ill�' 1 i=Y •.' • r 'j'A/�. f"4"'.` ,1%; :4"�'j. f '► r r'"3, 1 PI - a' .� •,. . i t .• 7, •4.1.1 �. �'' �r"' I.'.t�� 'i•Y.: Y - tl 7 vr/ 1 ► 'j' -4Ari. • ...:• yi4!'fia a, � t .):..4-....t4 ,r{C.tis_F� .}T , <: 1 i .�J .`•,. ,, ', ir... . .T*:ff`* 4,4•; •�/ r.� /Y % +7 A0. n ,t, F1 t, �q-,; 4�, K'^'•% 1+-* p i �' ..' i / 2 �, F!. ' ,7;,�! .r ',Y.••, - 1, ., .*, W „ ',1-. < • �•:� ,, ,.zArk. i ',•'`. ` I-.1 ,. gip. • QIP' i • ry --04.--A,, :41 .f'� ;, , t ♦- .f - `-•�, Z1 4 I r ' b ^§@ ! 1. '�.t• }; U, .'/ .•ySA•� -? •'• .,,.' t'4 4',,,21.,.f7-/�,' 4.43,44114t* ' J`�j y .z4, ",:. •• . i ... • ,'"� x *' � :y 't/•••.✓ I► ..a,',..2,,,: T,Y..','.••R•• k• rad,►• ,6. t. • I, i �`y T#�- (`� 9' +,+ sy`J + ' l•'r '•�. SI •-� .} •i9' i 11 t 11* "�,may i f; ... ,r � •''ice n-• rt• • ' , ..-4,y,_. -r . 1.- 4-1 ' • •.; •••14,114:: .• •••• ". .°-. ,Ar-I'll".......' -1,•1, •„4.' ';:. 4v.,:4..tr... •••••• to,,.•.,.1:,..... st • �•_ ',b i�`. 1,4„.7F ..11.1." .. I S ''- #... �- i ^y1 '• lj:M .. s L .7 n., 1 .i. _ , j' ✓":M'1"1,-.4 y;. i+1, F�:' �' ' 4S 2'..-!...._•� , '0•••,,r4„.1 •,Sf ' A. 's • � 4 , !i1" • F •I' Y .,:.t.4.. • x � �y�M +� - .ti 77� •� • �• � � ` l �Ki1y"'.. I'� t.�- �'4�•4 1V+. `ur' r."..-., 4',. r• µ .y. • �� ' %... ..' ''r6.'''.." .: ';4 + At 4 4I 40 ,'V • ♦ «Ty�.if- r. �.+ .� v. M •( .,'•, i ** •' ! .; s.... ' . I. • �. i ,• ' • �~ , - , K•a, 1 r . :i: %, ,i.. �'} t� 777111 a' • IF':«:r fr. \ , /•,' w.' ! _ ..... • tli '` � ' ,►:. { . '•yti ,jf .t 't' y •1,,.:6',..4.,4-..,.1..,,l':..,",:,,.........,...;...,,..;... ..... 7 ;h, >.,..' , 7 ..._,/,1 �.:3 i _`�•F •L..� f,i•r •7' 1�i 'i'►: •'`' •w f'� ♦ - •s4. 1 ..41044.6'.1 am! At4w. ' %. , ..• 1144t. F f 1 A inglitilliW... .11:"111Plait ., +.• • 7r ' • s ry r !� t r • •. • Ilk ' tit.i• • � �. q_ s � +^ ' ` \ r. . , yA ►�. , �; • 4...' %5,,,,- bil.,17A::-.,...',.e_.: jilitbN—' •i Ai . .N ''', ' ' - ; :s.: • 1 , I - Na )nf .1t:-4.' ...5p.„, , ,,,.,. . .4.,, . , • -,' -''le •; .40.z•-ob '- 1 1 1 as 4,.. 4. ./ ., tial.fi, , 1 >w'J dam('♦ : . - , ..:� ,� _ •t• - _ —i^ _, • '*iiip, • iiltor I . '- 4 tikk i. k y. 1. r.4,•:1 `:r ,J.• • ♦�`• :, • - r ••-• II - J 40.0g , 401L-„,...... , •,... . .. -• 1...„ • ir f.1... , 1.0 , !. k . 4 Iii.01;',• 4 • i:414Z i • lirsilirtit * Y ;.1•-'~ , l'4,z d yr i.0.• * tis y t s .a_I • +y y , `. t` ' '• , • `ii 1 n r •� .t7 ,•10. 1 ,, `,�• •`� vhf" 0+► '0,:1.� +• 1' �jn A ' rr '1 ^4.i.i - W !' ;l,' . A :44 • • �• ' f. L 7s i. ham, , •2.4....-.... ji ,- ` t` .''#.; ,!a):� Ga.'s , l".;.• Z• l t �: - -'v 1 •• `iT: y.I . •_ T�. 'Y[ - '` mit y. • ii, • :::. > + . ` %.t. 5-•-•;.'* y • �[. fir y'. , • .§ .- ! + <— ;1;\a• • Al ., .. ,-* ,p,...„,--;, %um. .44 ''''LA.4 iAt•• , : • . ..::." ?.t.• itir, . -- • .: .- • -;..."'".' - ' " ;,t i •V 4• at, '�+. -t.x, a' - ;; _ :al... `` • •• '. S. . ':i* .;st'• err • +ll K a / ti 1 /ii ss-"' S _ I-- -MT„L L. -,f. r.Y --. Y._._+ \ maAa k \ sitil .. -Hr Ito it ., ., 4.. • 3'-` '� a A..�j mitt Fr ' ..' i. ......• 1 4 • 01 III / . G pi.0 + : ; ,,x,41 ►;at \, _ •'1 iii" ,:i. , , .... . . , .. ,. !r. - 1• }'moi i • + +w. ya - •� lit 7Nt 0� « .� 1 I • to t 7 KC. yI ` l > i M 411, Vit:vt N ' .. 1 i 1 '� t y ✓ cr 7 ', C` . �rJar _ i: '•y,�e Y'I+gy .: .f ' ,. ç, -;- 'AL T 7 • • we /7,‘ • Vc .. e•. • . , q •- 1. e • .-� I ..p J R • fr I' �l e "� Y� ,.c. s. *.l _ ,;',..11, � 1'!. t .rwy b. • ..R +.+` (�,,({t.;, • JI•,4� �•'•' 4.:41::.-1:1"1:-..-.. i .CY r - P"' •rj �� • .f'5. '1) --, .•• - t i.. d "7 • , mummainummuniimmemmem Nr' '4' „ ' • j` ,r t -.1 ' 4 o� gyi � i • f ! - i 't` C y44 +,,s. ‘4,. . l, YS 'r A ',Al.,. ',L. • r • kN..--.w ` Fl .K•rJ t. % ,' fi ~ f' 'f. N.rY -' i _ . ^ • .'t` '. ."9 ,. ,'• rk: I i oi . .„ 1. 4 • .. j - . . ,,,, --•'.-Ii4 - - . -, .. . • 41,. .,,st„..."'‘.•ety•-• ,--- • • �. r t .r u.l.r j�a h'.....,. .. ; .\_. ..y 1Y .0 i.1. t- -P-4-1 � eY y i. ' 1 It • lr1 .,I 'V�t .`1• Ji � � •Yr.,4;06 -'-, ,r” - * i'As-, , . -L.4, `�i '° � ... !; -i.. ... . .. A s:,, s a•,,• 4,„„;.! _ 114 • y^'., Q. A• k ,,�1'4. s• iq' s' •�L� �Cy A.,4, •- A .ty .•:cam + f/::' ti'r-.a�s1 i"l'SF,t , _/ .�.w Y� _tT.. tY _ f: r ��.-�,,. i' 0,. ?s,:,. , .-_ ,,, .., co. ,. 7 • • i rtlT{ ra j..� `• ` ' s t x I 1 f } (d ; y+ d„ ,. at ems* y AP' 3 .,� . • • lt+ .F A • "4 �+�gid, d +c °5 ;,1,..4::„., y ' 4 . :4 .. -. ---,,,.:{7.,_•:.,,,,,t• - C. h. . .R:. le ,,.- :l•t}• r t .t1T.' 'i t k '�'4�• ~ i 'i` L. ^�n '�` � !�^ i•. ��t f" lit f �'� f + '"•• ,; a �•q :` A' ', ' ,� '• :' rrr: •�` F. it ��ld '.. r.' .� - r .' "1N• ;4 t: ,. r' '. _�j ':7,,,,,, �;. '..J. ' et....4 :;'•-•440-.....,,„,.... ',',..i.h.,., . . . i ....... r 3 , 1 ,, . . . I ''' i _ . , :4 ""'''''J . . . . • .. . „ ... A - ,.. . . .,.,, ., ... .-.4...4.4 „,......„. I 4, ' . ,,.... 4,,,..„. .. ,,•, -4,„.,-,„ . , . -.,••• it,•4. .:„,„,..-s.,..s, ,,,, ,,,,,41.4:, . .. .:.,.s, • I ' - 'L 1 • , ' .•.. , . ,, ,.. . .... • 1 - . ,,,,,• .4,,, , -4,4"-* • , . i • -.4 f .. , r , 1/ '' ....' 1 ' ,f •-•., .„ • r .,_ f - i .1 i. Ic )jliii- .._..._ . -.. t • i ,.. . ..., . •• ... . '.••• * -. t ' ' ' • , , r ‘Irt4130.1k, rafr., ' ' • s r ,..,,,. ,".or' ..,, .• , •• :., . o ... , '-. . ,.,,,,:"Ivri,•;••:1-:."4,•2'...- ,ti: ,, „. 4 _,..t.toris ..,.....(... i......,, ? • i r A 1 / ' ',,,j: jilt. ft IL41 S'- ' ','• - i -- „ , -,1.. Li 1 - ''''''''. .) .- 1 - ' ' '• : '-' 4 ji ji , , • ,ft,- ,, .. .- ... - - -., - S ,..,,,...,.. , lsi..... 1 -... , .'. . ;, , 4,..- • f t) )4, - .. ..- .. . ,. • , . i '- ).1., .., ( .... ,), c -- ......, , .., • ,. ... .1 A y t „..„. ...- .. ,p,--„..„. t-,--.1-4..,:‘...:-. • ..;::'..i. ...„..„-t.:',..,„ _- ‘.. '' 4 • r ,r y ' ' • ;-.•••-•-I ;' ' ' • ... 4'''''''-'7, - '.1.:•,:r7,7*L'''' ''''r:;'''-i•• ,)".•'-'-•-' ,,,, :.:':''''_ ..i .,,r; ,: : 1.. \.,; 'ti:..:_.:'':__:, .., .. , , ' . , :i. • , ,...... ; . ' , •r$ • ;. - • . .,., . , , I ( . ._... . . . . . ... oe,, -•••••%, ...., • •4.,,,,, ' '1 . '4 k --'t, '.. ---.", " '' • . ...,',_ ' L ' , , .... . '''• '''', ,.. '44*..r.• (*, ,..--. i c 1 . •, , •-,.... : v4 ', - . . -,, „ . .••• .... . - iik,'; -, -- , • - '-.k......,.. .1 • '-‘-‘,..,I ,r . • . i i• _ /IN. . 40.- -- 6 4---'- •64-. '''&4•1- ' ' \-'' - '4 'k; • n - • ' ' r' i , • , ,... _ A .,._"\- .... ......_ • .,. ., , -..- 1 . • ',C4f4Nf ''',. . . ' .., .... . ,.,,, . . , s , . ,,.... 4 I- . ._ •... 1 - . • NI - 1 ,1 , ": , . tC1 , .-.."11 sy-: 1 I . 4 ; • ', ' . ' 1 ' , ;...: '. ,.. ..,0-.. ... .'.47 '•• ,416.' 1 1.. • , , - ... . .;-' .„ $ • ? ar4 tit , 4 •• 'irl ''• • _. -1 . 1 . , i . . A-...,,• - .-. - si • / '11...._. / 1.,),,.._::./ TI:. ,,.,1' .•.f :,... ir. si-.. . Nit 1.110 ...01._ .... ---- ‘1 -- ill : ' • • . / ,N 1 . , I " - • . ..- -,.. ...i. ., --• ...' ......... , I,- ,.:. . , # IPp : .... .., •, , i .• J * ' ' l t' '11 , • , . ,. ,. , ... '','. . 7 . . \--,. - . , J ,i, . . I i.,-) -...) ., , .,., 1 . • // I • -,,• r •• -N • •$-,, .. i i ,?/ 4 , „ , iT,_.,.(, - j 1 ;::: if 1 .- . --, ( , I, , :I ' ..... .4.1 • • \ t *le‘ t ' ' .I. ,, t''Ir.' ' ,. ,.. , 1%. t ; ( le Vklill , , -.... ,. .,.r, Ar. ) , . j I ( i / 1- I A 0 1 r / , rte- •J 4•'* 7 t { N,• . 't{airy . .( s9"•N. - ' • • ' y •' • •F `CY •iptli•1. 1 i r . Y ;' -_ - •!i ..1 '',('n, !•1! �...T ' f' ,... b - ]A 1... t •�; .' y- 9.�f•. -•, 4 r P ' :.. •', .•4°00'i'1 , . if • • ,,..r.a �'�';���,re;, • Ai- • • sl` '"Z• •''y ,,lv 4O',`�_ {': 7„..,,,,,,,,.. . ,...t.,..,..::::,,,,:r . .4,, , . t, ; , '�, • e.r, • ! wi• ts7'• '*I%�, / ,Ar ��• rl` . . - . -* . a4 f ,L'. , �'�' s, ►.- ) 'j :,. y•:� I + ,` •te•l, !y �. ..P-..'-'• � • ,.1 • , �, y --/�.r • `^�� •*'', •T 4. • .i- - .�'` r•'I,r.ice. : • • • �J • 1 e *•. idl!•.. IY 4 t • •, y:.:•K� w r : • 3. ' .4.‘K AL1 + i� i \C'V't •, t 1 • .4' fY.'vj�f1.'• •- • .k et1 ;' ,-�� • ',;fir • i» �` - 'K I T '[ . t. r p -j •.1fs , ft r • •• • • ..r�LC }✓ �, ¢ ;7 41_• ' • ,tiij: ...fir ;� - 14141010 T J... .•`1. /r4•;'.r • .. r i .tis . • ,s-.. ar„ • • • ;t ;, r• } •- .. � T,-._. . ...Air.%4.. -, `• a„, 4 m �f -it. . ,--4, •_,„,. .. . -;,.2'---,g wite414: .... -- • i It. .'-‘' ..'' . '' ' - , -,. . F•,, • �. �`i_ /i:�? r '!"<i:y�y,t' 'r :. , •.y' • if mar . +~ A•r1Ct ' f J' 'Y - '♦ -, j a 7 .4v_.,. ' t.,-. „�;- ;# . i �^�•�t �t�• f. 1� fi t. 'x�-•r.% H , ►t i .�"'S►. r,y'�y-, i. 'kg -,ifs - j ..•.a .. .,7-,... -9 t .,�' _ T�' i'+ , .I a ' • a _ I '`. `` ',fJ• r'r .•• .Sy .4•ti Jn. ''!'�.4....,..4 iii:':-. t.• • 404 • dillie i. .4'..,...;,.,1,•'1 2,,...i ‘3'1.' - 1.112. : s ' ki.4.13 4....4-#•• i• , 4 • A 4 41t. t: 44 Ss 14. Yj�{[I s •�.>.. '- d'immeekvierwalr .-11.14 .- . ‘1 i ' 11.1.-. 111111:i 1•404/44#'4 ''‘;\''' // :.4. 1,,*.1 s:4.. -.Nt: s:.."'''''.4.1-e:**,''. . 4 ► a 1 _ �� �� +1.• �+ ,sI jMl1 —� f // ly is ►� 'Aa +, II iiii:1,1 0:1" . -7.1;4 ,. . '441144 41, •I ,it, • ►• e y � • -/". tc; . ., . „, t,. 4k% , "�E,^ . r y a � 7 es• °' `=, A'rr.( i, • NI.N T74''‘,4i . • •••40. "r '2.,... 1....rf.tr •'. . .s.:..-A1‘," '^ it:*14...b 1'jl. • V. v vim • � , ,„,,b. 5. -.• _ '• fir" ' ,s �E. �(� .t14-il• -1°,1411 to .'. •1 1'f ', '`, 7: •.:•r-•,,. • ''' • • *� ,.. .. ,{E ;•- ....,... '*446— :4144c • :V• ''' • • 04',,t A • ,,, "'H. 59. .. . + • • •t F _ it. r * 1 - • • ,,t," .14,,,,, ...t., • 7P A • 4 .,.., . t el If • 4,;' - A,. it Rt. �� r .•' :*Y;titiiikI • 4 . .. . 4,4,-,,,,* �• r � • . • _ , •, ,.., , ... . • • . - - PreA ,1,..tk - • r' -....40 •,••••■ t, -•• •.5116er.' 1 i''' -A . ,Allidllir." , ' i„ Vet ,i', ' ' t ' ' •'t \ '.. ..ir, . .• .....„ ; Ix illk folle '11 A., , - .;Ili Asi,•' •.-001r. , i . - - • .4" .) *Aig:)4, rkit iiii))7. ' • .•'' e J ,,..7.. ,,, .0 , ,,,, - ..„. .1 jo,...It g •it. 7 .1 )1 1'. . ' " .' • - - • 4, - i.,.Y .„.. .......1541, , . _r_.:0:„ , .,.. • ,....,,,,.,s. • 10 -If • , ..., ,...., * ,‘. , I-• -..•114,_•• . . • t , ; ter.- ,‘ s. .' ‘ 14‘. ' k.,if'iv , ,. 4.-4%4 ' /4 ... . •- • 4 . :1,21AP 'a,• „ .. - •' ".' i it 4 A - .• • . . '.. •F"t „„..,,,. •'-4.00- •11.411.f.-.... ir t‘• ; • , . , , . • 4 - ., i't., ,-. . w,.„.. Fr , - • it. - , , •.., , , 1-,„. s.. .... .. . . . , • # .,,,* _ A., -...-, ,,,,,,„. -r :,, .0,.......• S . '4.'lit' , :•.f.' : , '4.:, , Kt • __ -v., ,...., ,, re TM' • o• - 1,. .1. _,A.: .. 114 ,. .. l . jir .-- kz, 1., .: • • -- . t. ,_ - . •... tI Ow- i ,,,,,glo -- . • • .. . 0. •' A-01,4-1 '-.. . • c •-*,'.• ' , • - 1"4. • • -.1.,„.t • ..--,ir _.. .4°I,' ' ' ' 1 ' . • '.' .10.4' • - k."." - '$1,o?fil---. , ' . . • ,` --' • - '! ....", - : :"• -• - ,-...4_21,--•,-....• .40-7 'Di lit'' •• • • • ....• • .' 4 •(I..; •. ' ,.. ' • , . .- ".t. 1417'..4.. ' ' 464 -. ....I ..... • . 4 ' ,. flit - • . • ,ii, *Mk r I • . • •7:1",: - - - - !,1!..0- .•- I .-; , . fe . di:i, . *litti .1(' ,,, ,. 7fV•• 4 -..T... ..,* . - s. ... .. .7 lir . )'-i,--% nt • ,'„ „..i. , „ . -...•.-. -• „,.. 5 ,..- ... . - , . .• . . .,. .. , d: *: ' • % r • )ir -,- _ ,..., ,,,,;... • . . , ,,•)„.,,.........:._,. ... " ..,.... ., .....,... ...., . ., .., . •••,0a...7.,.. - ........... 7..-'4 A' . : ,. , -• , .f" ..‘„, ' A: ' ••:•••• - ''‘• , , - . .• • 'A it'' ' V 4 P*,• t,,,..4 :-,•-g4o•i-•.•.•*,'...,.'L t,.-'s,'i---.w,.s-t,-•i%.i,i.5`.,-,•:.,A.-"-:...•.4•.':',:-•-5,'*;,X:.,'0.',7. ,"'1 ',, ,, _ • .- • '''..• ••....... ..•f..P• :-T•.i ",•s• : t ..-- if ,"),.: • o.AiNr'. i ' O-r. • , ; .. ;': ,_,c,,-,,344•• 1rJ,- is ..-,-,.„,_•.-.'.,..., '-•'• •••?-. •..,, ... ,-..• •• , ... k .... .'- • l•''''' ,-1.4t,•. . L •-•,, ' -0., --, . ---7.- .. '7115' its4‘. ' ' •?•10 s .„,t '; ' ,,,? ...' ...." ' s. - . ,' ,',•,' • - g., 4.- I•••'- . if i• '• • :' • „ • . v•P lb" '•, 1 ,,, : Illtg•,,.. ....•` '..'$' , ' -'3.°`-lf ....,;'• ' .7 t , . ••• '' a 71 1 • - ' u•1•40kf''.'- ••k".' Itii• :4'1''. ''• ..-I.- i .i ..''. -' •. .' • - ..," . . -'44% .. - .. ' , ' . - -... % :-.4. .. •. . -. -. • IN k .<.- . .. - ,.k. .. '• -• ..,.......„4 • -.0 ,. -. ,.-c - , • . ,..„, . • •• -.;• . ., ,-,.... • - ,., , ., •. • , , ' -- to: ' .7. . . • . . • 1,„. .....• . .. •Ar , • .• t . . , , .. - ,, ••., .., . •A' • r ..: .- ...- wr • .'4•-•• • 41'1;..••;.1.4 :., . : i.(N. _,tti,r,,,•_; . . Als -i ' t•-j•tit: . ••.' ' '' l'.'(IL- Y.,. .; •illt-ye vr- ',.:4 . . r- ,„„„-..tio d l' t...-4, :01 . 1.:- •,•. .,„le ,,,• . l• • *- ,, ,7611.V.m , ..,. .,•*?;...• ' '___•„,-,4":.t _` 171 rs.... l , 4•- • . . I' , p‘ ••ii , h „, „,.. , . • • 1:. • . s.. te„.....,,,„. 10 .0.-. -.,. ... • •• ••• I .. ,. , " . 1 • '",p• .01.-'916•',• - OA 2 ' •- •• ' :` „ ...A`r. , Y; AV 1 . ' ' .u.'.r. ,'1 •.' :s• '':•4';.--.-ie.-';'",14,;. A.' - !''''' . '4.4,-..••.'I'V At, 7; ---, ' '. -': ,.5S.;,'-,,- -a: law •••' .1#4.t.' • ' ',;.... .--•,. ., '-.. ,0% / , , • ' . - ". '‘• .r., -4" -4‹ •- 1 lig -- - • •.., 1 '•-• •.' ' . 4••• q •,,,,,-qtelpf _-, 4,.. ..P. .„,---14, .--=4 -• ..k..„ • • -INA, '.s,'4.:. c 7'--'•.:Y' - .Ate:!:•15',.%-9.1 -14): * ' - ,?.,., . s' -- 'r:,A. • .,, - Y''''1.- ..,- •I lot ;•• --,- ;:i- • 6114*---- -. -•, ..p .--,i;-._ - - .4_ % p ,•• _ - •.,..:: ,....., - ., ,... li,,, , . :: t • • -S• ' - ...b.-• . *'•'-. .0P• .)7 ..- .-' -. . •#s - . .< . ,Asffiet . ..., . • .1 - ' , ,....,'•••:t7•ri'-i'i.• .*. ' :..., , .-- .,„ . . •.t. -' • ..,..,.I(:':*.6.!4•'..,1"6 k-..,.. .•lo'' r, , .14., w--- - . ".• ';‘,,_„., •4 ' -, •...• - r•-,:. ' '-' 4-1-!_if., ,,:"' ..?-." WI" ••,.? -' ' "',..C. . .1' ., _ .. - . -, „+ l.",,-• ."ir;-,it,. 'f.e, - 14.• : . . .4i, , .; .,-,._ ..-"' 1,•*,,,N, 1 ,. ,, '. ....i : 't....-.,?, , :„... .. . .!..1..,. , .., .p ' 4,' ,•',....,-'' .1...4 1,t-111,` 4 .r) • ' 'X . . . .. ... . . . . ,r.•. ,-t J'At ,'.t. ", ^ k0 • - - .. • -4 . - A• .;v 4.- •... •vi`4. .. '-.-1. .Z4'''''r • .01: - ..:-it -. .,„- : - -.0r...' -,,,,, •“ . . i, . , . _ -4-,' ' ' N ' •' . '-.4:`.e. '.' •' Al?).' t f • ''.1 90!.. % ' . 'e'...%tt`i- .1' ''4, ,t.71. • • ii3r- ,..‘ _, • . . • 7. • • flt: It? N7r. •1 . • •• "? ' , t t f.' ' .• ,4: ' • ,, . - 4$6 :„-Ir,.- • ;.. ,1 '1: ' •• ' . . '_: .*,....:::.--12,0:!" .i. 4,,''. ..,-. •. z...1:, •.-.' ,C.4. , '41$4' *• •', • r. . ' .,.• • ',Il - , ' . • -,v '°. . 11 .. . . -.- ., ,/6. ke- etz4.: . .-Qif . - . r'' rrtt....311.• , iir'.• • . . . •.""x :•• ,..• • •. ... v'i •-e!‘"'. • • •it. 1,- , • ... ..,` , ".••• ' •• '. '' • -"•4'• ' - I ... ...,,,fit., . ....I . ...7, •..,„ , • . •• u " •X• '' .••• lit‘ :,•• • . ., . . 1, , '; y 4 -..,, 4 ,iew a • , iiitt, .'" a '• -, ... u.,,- • . k - : . . .. 1..„.••:4,'••• .i. •..? . f ' rhb V' Nr . ,,...ir 40 , . , .,, ,, xi , , - • .., . .., , „ r, , ,, .' .,,4.•`tr. ... • .•44 - •,y,,,,., •• - , sr's.C . •-• • . II t te i .; :"• ), ,. . ..irlyier. ir'IP/1,..1 • „„ . ''. • ' ' % •.1 6 .1• ,s ', ;•9tt' 44s, t s •' ' • ;, '' ..t,,,' 4. 4.444'44v,, ,•' ''' .ig.- - : . 4,ir,... „, . 0 ... . , . ., .. , • .., t A A, '11 OrAr . . '- ,'....“ : . . ',O.' • . . • f'',, - 1„ . ',,.,, • e4A ..-,. . 4 . , • '' ; t 44 -91,1;'''.. '4,‘ '' ' ' ' * • - •. i fel' • • * r A LAY/ ''' ii.' .",... i f.' t'S - ,j ,„, "• 4 't C 1 • • ,, 5 -, , 1!"' ,,#.1t , 0 ,-,•/' •/I" 11: .,. '4 , . .''1';1 .VP - '.'. . '- ', •..rt 4 4- ',•' 41',.. ,.._ fr.-, r,,t.,4, • • • wow t' -af.' '`-4 -- 4 -'. .�•, ,' • I r - 1,--''""C',...,f ,ti1ig i ,c.''_.r r ! ...E+•" `sr.• • i: r � '• . . M; . " . Q ,„, - ”. - ,w . ) , . ,..:4,i• x 4 • r �t • s ,,i wit;'.', tr ,It?.R. � 'is l . , , t i �, A ".3,k • y , +* . 3 '0+ . ,.Aili' ' ' " it ".111/.alr .romw ' r ;, % -� .r % R } a • ,,, . - qw .0112 • .wf}Ia '" ', r ' r f ,. , ^ 1JJr-f - , * P„i.4 � ` , I• ,il • - - �a ,G;l' � , � iI 1�`'�4 �Y r� 1 .�:' C ". �y'�' r , .P , � , isi4 , ,r, • 44 ,.. .11.—...,",..0A1''-- -L. :-:•.#1.',•,:.-•..b 3::':..11-,,rt'::,‘'',,. .:::* . ' • .4-1H- - ..4kt:74". , • s. tp .i ' � ti .l ,�tL ,x ... � I' . ..••• . t—• \, 9s 11 I � • ti •r 4y. = :� • i , 4 • s`y 1 /� / '' `�.' "�. 'E t � .- _ , i /x� ;_ 'fit -� p - ,i' ••�• .• • ♦+.;:4...,...,,10 f - { ' • :4. f • • tt t; k � ,i,If`I _* ' r e.',/ ' .4t .11 4 f ^' 4Ar ,l t `7 s ,l•-' •rY , ' SC 't t sr-.. tea ? ' . .fr • • "_.•,•-•••7 Y. a 1x s { s '> ti YF. 5 -,.1,,...•,f} y �t�,► Lit t + .YM Y 'Z •f. , • ' e• i,Y• '�! ✓. �.�15it--c,•;,..., ra' '' �•r ¢ "► +�ty,� • M� ��' r �a �` '*taYv } yhe. „•�' a r. � \ 4 k ^trK.�#• , -4 " 4.4.!...- .,--4., +• it/t •' f� ire '''...1. 1. `a .i. .3" • '/; 'dti- q' r 3.4_g j,i , i j . M,. y • I 13_i►..x ,j, ,:,.' .xJ'K 7 '�'if �b �' .,, i, • •E. • *ti ' a y '4,¢Y aYFt � •• ,• . , lr i} av r r Y. 5 T +td • .-* .., f,j • Ei , .. 'NW:. ...N.- t N.,` ,� '', ` � i ' �,; rv! t . {; r. y+ k 4,_ ..• q: `M • '4, •.�, •. r;r•0, } 4f ' ,• .I L• 1 ,„ 1 C '4 . A,x �# t ,i' - 0,,a.,tu,�' -, t �. ''♦• . :�1. sa 1 r t 5 " rbt r Cx + T Y yK. . s, �. � r I ' tpt. r E '' + " (y( 9�, tt,y M • ��1,,,,,r `' ..'' , -` '' ' f: i► , • • ea 104.44 , v , r.• jai i 4 * ,'�;<.s �. t '.• , a. f'�r,444 f; p:rr,;.f r T 14 + t t~'R .t n ' '.Ity .".11.414s.,,,,,1:1'0'3,1 t tl', ,� t, a 4'4„..4 A, ,, t,• 2 • . • �,f' Al IP .�•, r♦ �y'!i t a o Q. f o .i Rrz' 1 , Jl .1•u,' �• j k sh '� - ti'. �ir.� 7ti , <, r�`30, t .' t • r • ., i4v. •••, + y•' r �r • . S .fit' " ! ;C,i �, 'al'-J •;�L; r`el. n,'r r , r , " a' .,r� ( "EE __ .+., - ,. - , , Ati;kir'‘, • . 114L, r r ''�,. ' r tet .}' `' • t `.". ' w 1 ' Or r. .sem' af.k wE 4 • - i �•y •...,",,,,4,-,$•4, im, ' < . '" S.Y' .4.. '+ '4•40''. `►.� ( • liti 4•F# YF� .51 �' }"r3.a,_-:ti• • ..r1.r i• •A ,,• � ' .i a`. . � . i r • '44 M` /'C 4 'l �, I" W i':a '. ...i a .$,44 /r' $ �t ' 0-�~ 1,pa a .4 `• ...{ 4.4.•-•:.,e '�1.1-.,L,..,,-t` • y+ 17 lie Yrc 4 ,C _ .. ' • ., '•.. - ,F .y: • '•J.. 3^} J ; Awry; At •a • ' r. : � � ; a' •►• tA > • ii y . . j '--,• iti • ��. • J , '.. -_•.:R" -"-. -7- 'A. '-a .. ..h 0.,,, I•'.. war.. r w ,;i . • t. •yam 1* - li - ii. 11% iii • t ' t 'r : ty6! os / • k'`' , # - µ 10 •�` ., ,'a X • �ys '' ` r • y • i ' , wa < ) . � , 1r4., _ ri ' r* 1 4,-....,-.:*,... . t � • ` _�iy 4' -•4. A t . %.t.„, t 1 , t4 , 7 4 ,,• ),_ t 1.. , r*�..Y '� L.y,„ e ! '`mow • iiii 4.'...4:4t,_ ''''' ::V..:-$ , " .. . ,... ,,.,4,,.... . . • . ‘ vir . 4 .sli.,......, kuriir..5‘, 4 . *..'., .... 11:111‘ ,..,"'r .. 4141011110r - I�4 - - • ,• 44 �•• +'n. 4' w. A _s wig , • •a 1. , , • f 1.,,..,414.;., .s. • / �,j. s, fir,='� e A 'd's _�Y. .,�... ' + ' 1 . • . -.4.4,-. y. A; .A 'i 1, .r•'h ; r 4 ' ± ! ♦r :. k {{ w , ,..,A0' AK I ir jel • al..- lirolk-i.-••• , . .. •.- .U`k+. • sWli". 1 " 5. • •I •Lrr• • 1 r� ,I .. �r .r.. ,ry�T*- ;� • ' ' . WI • • • 1: ' ,I. _.& �tt t • ra t . IF. ••� i • � r .'.vti , • • • li tt� - c 'Y r i r: 7 It ,, 4.441., 44%4 so,. N. 4.ki • i'•f . . . � ;. •r 4. 'elft.44 , :S . - •' S • el. ? tt t • r . 1�. f ,53 a *** 0114 IS,. ' .' • ' '•. ' -' 4 .` likAt i • w • : 2 . Y' . _.. --:. • 14 '-..-....-4r •v ,.. i )..ii• , ,.,. • .. •1. '10, c••• - - .,i ttej 441,s•-••....I, ,A* •,,,.... , — v.*.0 4.1, • ‘....E4,-, .. *r ' PK ' i . f ?-ty tet+ '.� . .0i, ... .,,,., s . .1. 1•• .. ' • # ..,a, ...t.•••• • t. , . -•.'L, ‘.',`... ''-,',. ' ' '- , -.'.....'''..A''*.:1 ....: -- ' .0..'7. ' ' :' 4., .'"-- I-.. -`-:.0 ' - --41 , r •.$1 4.,174, .'4 . 4... . --...%.. lit . ..,111 'a.' - 1 - ' Ale'jOili-",...'r:• .,,.47-, . - , a', : '-','"-.L.' , .: .1.2mr. 4, , , 41 • :t.* . 81 ' 111, *- iri..: 4.!4 ..,.1 '4,11,k,L. •ir 1.... . 4.1.,.„ ,..,-..• .,.•, . -,-. -:..,x.-)4.-e -, -• : ...‘' . ')- . .-,. _• , •er ft'-','Ky . '14, ' • • '.'; ,,... .00 .•',‘-•••';••••o' '-',"•.' '• "r. • -'. ,-'`..7 .. f',•'.- •,,k,s„.• ss 1 s., s- • '‘, • • ,*r 1. ... .-,44 'ti -. '. '.*d'1,0 4•''.. -' . '. ' ...CAVA, ' •1.'' ' ' ... • Tt s' A 5.* ‘%4i • ''1 '•. ,, • ,,, ., , 7, . 4.. .....,,-.40, ,,,4, . .4... .,,,‘,•• .• • ao,-• .,„;;:. L.,,t,'1'...•4 ..k 1 I 1 ilii• - •.. '' .:t '.. -4.:'. . ...''',‘. • . ', %' ' ''':_..'1,•' '7! ,..,tier,,. ,'7? ''..':f, •t:' P'..v-4..':4Art:#4...Y. ...);:, 47,:,.• : 1 4. °"M4,b . . " ' - ' •• -•,, A A ,'....V' •''''1 •*,..•• IA '' .' 4 • ' '-'Y f' stiNikAce t r- '' "'` _Ag- . • It , . A0*., -.4: s-••.• , -%, '`'i',14,k ,,,.,, 4i,,,'` ' '•• •''.1"•••'. .%., .."., .....0. i•:_51 Ar,11/7•7.110.4:11'.4.'4 '......"". dillir - , '. .. ''":,.7"-A. g :4 -. si. ;:i.:41-•1 lir e -: . 1. gor ':',. -4...- • ,. 4 ?4'..se 4., 4. ..-,. ..-.• t. '‘'Wi • •41 111.' ,t'.. ...,. 11L7i. '• ',' Ckt'V , al* .. .41k\4: ' .. 'k.•: • . .'7 .. 11'4111:.4*Ai 1 .N ' ." -. ''•.. ..-4r ,`, .': . •rt; :‘! '...4. :11". ' ' --*_•; 4. -,,, :.7„, 11 • -4. .,*i.. ...it r ... .. , : ...i.k.,.q4',0,4' ,, f. ' ' . . , . :-. .,,. •.f,;(,,,'t ::. .- '• ft"ot.,_ ,64..",."---..-- ,,......--,.,.• --:- ;et.'• - A...W.e • '4 - - - ' ' -ice* - .. 4 - '4. " s' . • '''''t' '.,. : ' '. •7'"C''t.',? :."1/1• „ iok•' *'1-ke.'.!:. .. it, • ., ) . • • • , . 1,....' • ... P,- ., ' 4 . ,c, . , „,., , . iw... .: •,$. , .. •2..7 - , •,‘. r .„,....,.. -.(s • *' ' ' ''Is'N' l' • ..''44' ' '4",4.:.,k1, ..)."' ','4. i`',,,l''''. :.-C. . -,:.A,- -•' :• '•.-. ,- ' 4 . • '- • ; N • :144.'4i '.S1.,':-` it • '4.'''It -'' la • - " '''-' -',,.'..t' ir%,. '4• .•-•‘. .--"I..14417.....• :'7- : :-/,`Pir -.,.. . - 1 ''-14" P.- ' -4"'" .6 .' • :.k""""irr. o't,.. -,,....'.-- r"- ,••• ,,,, 1 .0.. ....• ...:r 4:46-,...,._,-.0 ,. '•.._";:, '.- - -13, -4, . ,., -..- ',. `,,,,:„ - • , .., , ,, .-.s.., • ' i.:-...‘..1., s. ... ,-.(i. ., , , - ' . --., tir . .4 t„,, ._ , s, . • "''. - ‘• , ''`' .;`;‘,-I".'..•\•,- *.rf:`,.. .---- „...,. '' ' -.'- - Airiterip'•;:i.:••--. '.--t."' a .. - . p.,..•... ; .4. • -,.I4;I I.,4•-Ns•'.4'..''.'.'I''-...31-.,._,-,,•''-..'...-..,.'.•%":_.''k''•.,4 •t....kh..7.-.1..,:.-.•,kf.•‘,_`.-..`'_i-.•--.0.,,.•:.a..l.'.;,•••r.,.-!••.-,".7 l"...;,'Ari!-'"_..-•,4-`.g.•.;•-.,-.-1,i-'.'1"-*:."-"-'.'.1..1',.4'A.'4,-r,,•,,A•,•",.,..•.,--•4...'.,'''•,,,"..f‘,--,,;i'„';'..4,•,,.,..-_,';;.,...•.-:•i- if."':;:.'.1 • • : r : 4 _„:„0...,„......14-7„::.7•„:,,.•'".--'1/4.:.,,;',,.:c•,:;...,,;',•-..,,4•a!i.,•-",-*_l,"•:Iotrptti,.o..*.,7 •-.•'..•,.•,t1yl."..0.7.6`:.;:•i,•. ..' .,.-4...4-..-.*!,'" „• 'I.,.."rii.....ltE.t,i..l.. I.diirfst -....•• . • i- ,... •-r•,.,V.••)i , -",•77:11144..71,7it --..--...--..-r••• ': --- ' -..." ,..-‘ 4r.... '•• 4,..4',.; .!v.• , '...- .... .„,;•''',.:•; . ' ,•::/q.:' IA,'. Sr .'::.:14-1;75' '"''' ' !..ss.'' l' . ' - 1,C..., ., Yi„..., •2..', ,„,i,., . , . ., . J. A',.sin,._it,.•111.11. - „, ' . . 1', '''s'''',.'si- . , .:, *!. • _. • . -'' . ,.....• * 14..- -. . • .47. •.4.' .-,,,,, 4-..-17'i.- . 0., ''' .-' ..,:s '' ' ''.'. •;it ''' - oN. ' ' .c."--..; '.:4`': i; ‘, ' ' ''ye.Pr -... ''''` ''' ... . .1'... ., •_; / '',,,tin.+, ' •'-''.'- -..' it:t*' ... :*'.... . •1...- .,' " .'1.'i '‘'' : ''4'.' .,:- . '' 4... •• .1,,,..)'• .„,.. -, --c-, • „ -,---,-, '-'4 ''s7'--.• - , .'.: ' ' ''' l' 'e .,;'- ••=1%,--ii.4-.-- -;,:-.' Air - ..--;-4,,.. ,---) .4''1.. : -44.-- ••• 'a •• -''. .- '.• ''' 4''' "• '' • -,..,i -; - ' "'" '.• -'. ' ,,, :%•'-' ' .''. ::'''it ..''' -''' ' •;,.-`4•;,_•. '''-,•'f' ...-..:i.44.::',',?;.2"- - .. ';:C.• • Z.' '' .0... , .1 , „..••••• ••.•.,, . ..-, ,,,,.--, .•• .•,,jag. ....-- ,.r.44.-,. , :.: ...--.), • ,... -- , .. .,..z._. r..-,..,-4•,,,,,--_ -t-jr-.6' ''' Iii... ‘,4.... r'.''.: :: .'' '• - '''`'IAN"4,4 k.;.''''1.! ':r ' r:r.-rf,...'..4 t. . :' ••/:' ' -....i 45- •• --. • , i---.- •i4r,.<;.•-y4 -....1 , .,,.. ..<•$,:... ... ' ' '• :... -1, :.' 2.?'.. .',„''''‘'t 4,f"..tas.-4.' - '116-Le 4'. • 'V v? ' ' ," -'1';'t. ' . • ... ., 4,....,7,-. 7 , , 41.• „„7, "' '10: - . b4441.-• .,14,..',"4.-,r,'`:,,,t 4.•s, '''''..4-1i;"",.":41:,-1' %;.,' l'.4,;47;.',..,... •:-';.+.:i ;:'.4,17 .i=,..,••,., t, ._:-..:.. '..,...' .• •-'•••":',';'i.,. ••••411;-•-,-'t '•••'•.:;.''" - .1*!,''. • • =.....•••• •- • .' ' " 'r. ,„ - ' A x'46 •.,-" - ' '' ''• •-'' *--.- P'sr4::r • ' ,..! -.. : •.' ,„,," ,r.._ r_-- -:40,44. ,-. • "" ' * ..'' Y' , .. •-•:. .- -7 - .,< 1. t•-•.-•i''..-"4.. - " • . • . • ''' * ' ' 1 il J...ilv it. . --, --.,: f . 4, - ,, . .- ,f„,. ,, .14., ',4 - ...._ zileilli,,,.‘, 4 t•,-,- ,.. ..-0 ,...e' , "i, ''''.‘-,•.1' l''''''.- '- e-' - te-..4., .1.. 1,,,,, . rt • .,- - _ ... ._ ..,., . . ... . . . ,.1,-- _,, a• . .1. I....42,. ..,-, .:-..-.le: A•4''-. •- -ji.,'.'1.•::ti'. '.,.' ::7. -1 ,.,- .4.11S4 ' oln ' ''Iti. ' *. ,. _...-,.. -,,4-.,,..,,,.. ..-:,.. 1, .ir ,i. - - ---.. ...- 4-,..._....... 4:i ,,, ...,,. ....e.....5,5...:x.,......k- I t . . S :' .4f"" '. .. , ' • - .° r li'- 11.11 5 " -..te.:- . '':7 ' ...:::'''...-t:t-,:.'1146k '• 1•'., . .5.4.4411e ....1*troll-:' '::'•'••47--,4,4*,!--C.:.;!":- ',"...it'':::''',-...141'-._ :.*•:',-;.,:"' • •• f '' •'," •,`•-(`-• • ' 16% ' 0.• ,• •- . ,, •',. ,. ,eJ „(e'. .•• „,,, . • •-,..' '"...4p,.....,•-.,il.:,.,,,..•••••.,;,1-` • • ..,, •••siir•,,., ,- •-„ 1, '- - . -'"i44. ',..;","`:"-a-c`:-. te,•••. ''.. : . A ••: •''.,,,••••-. ,. .. .. 2',.r. - ":-,,••••! '. _ •-•. .•••• . • '-''' .• ••.':•'' • ',;.'•-.., - 4-t... . . - • ,461,V14.-1,-,, '--- • •.' ''...k • ,••_, - -'• . ',,,..','•O• '.` .,11. 'I-i. ''''!'• . - -`4F-..ill r -'-•-•' .44,4 '..it. '' -4' .,--. .. !-. - . 1.•- ;i.....z., • .- _..- _-..,.: ' t.----_---.. i .,..:.-.. . .-zAt 74. 41. " l'',, -' ,* .,.iiit tt. : •' ',/s4' 'kV . ' . i.4 '•"‘v• ;:4 ei'Vlillk„. : - '''• '-', :''' ' ' .: 1.- ft. - 0' 1.•,:)''' • -'. .e.- • lle. .- . 'at‘ . 4--''''. - . _s7 • '‘,. ,s' .-- ' ', .-•• 4.. ' •'41 t 4W -.*'''N'' ... .'ti- ' .4 ?•.. -., ' ' •t , ii.*t ,,•;t ..0--:g• .... .• - %lid*,..41- ., Ahstok. . 4*.iik_i: ''.-.1- 44- , •:•., - ., . ,..,..,1,7'. - .0tf''',47, -. - '-.. :7'• G.: ''''• "*-• - -0•t‘ -#4." •-At..4.,. .• ;•''.7 • ,:..•. ', •,;it'v,--"....#.1,-•,•.- ".ak.-, -.i.,..,.. . ,444,%; ••,•1,4„,L.- -.'. - •;41'.."t, , •".-4- •i . • 'At - "'- '''• ':. -:4.{.• "••••:-.•-•••'"P ' :4 ••=17. ' ' : ' ' ' 4sfi."- .31i , -' "...IN '' ' :-..7;' ' 4 ' '-r.. "It. - -.:-. ...,3E. ..;•.,, : -Or •-. .-... --,- ---7,-.•%**-: _. - a.- ,,---)4.2g:'•- '''• '-•- -..,,,sC2.- .• . 414- • '-','1,74tic„..-- ---;. .• AL:..s. - ..4.! -3.....„4.t-- .. I . ;"--* -ii•-•'' 'T, '' •. ' . • - "t----"' 0 -,:i4„›"Jite,.4` s,.,:"..; ---:'"4"--.1 , .,,,,,,47'.':";::.•:4;;.”.' ' .1",..:.: '.,„..--!1:2.111?..i..'....,'. liF01:-.• ''., 4 :.!•'..,•' ' - 1,;-4 -. '"....-. '.:•.'!'-', * : -' f.r.c`--71.7 :,. AO'. •":'..' •• . ...,00(-4,141',. . •• gle.''.-....:':15?-:-'`:. +1 •-•'' . 7...:„.....;..., ,. ,i'...'..,,. ...,',,.• „..,_ ,..,,,,-: _,..,„ ..-Z.S ';•?,.....ti"Jiro' ' • 'r' I• '.-,....r.4,:;,,..-.. .. .t .,.._ .• Voir'',I, ••••- "- -',r, ,,. .• , . --....- - . ' •••••-nt• -, ''••• _. ...:e,P7,47," -,-- . '1' • ,. 1. ::..' ... .s. ... ' -.'.:,':.•41„t..%.1,..'•‘: -: .7'''''',,,,,„:-',..„,i ,...t' • ''''':'.,=....:-.:401.: ... . . : _.2'.. 1., •1:; , % . : , .4 c''''..,.t-,..' '• . .„ - • .. - •-•t,4-4,"In - , "..;•-r„, 4",k,-,,,,, ' " .r ;:,..e._ -1-"e": .s.t -.,e,-,t' „4:1.11.,,,- .,..7.•• , a ..... -...• :--- , - - - :0,.. ,, - -N, .....?.... ..-v... . , . f•' '..: . ., ' •4-'f....S.y. , . _ '• ..'''':•."c*:-.4. ''. 44..*: ,4•6`4,'• i's:....: ..2"t-...: '..",..' :c, : ..",'..4.9''..., ,.:4_ ":14, • f :.' .31.,,tiNt,-:•.1',, :', ' r' (,.:*' ..c.; st :I :. 1 :•4e. '- - • !4,,':•-..•-*•• , . •••''' '_•. '-• ,/- -1-- ift, _ .4 .-40. ,,.. , • • .4 • f . , ., . ' .' ''.. ?., . •.•,. ,_. , . • ' ' ..4 '*1&b.n 45t 't-,.....: , , 'Oq. ' C ,t, ., ,.y .. ; '0. , . • ,,,,„; '?.' ke. ' 41. ' :".:':. :!`tf:,-,,,i.:;.• . '-.' '14Y.,...''''1/4001•3:••‘-3161-,:l.t.:= W...14-74 1' • -. '''' • '-..-4, ,A.• ..,.,,),. ..,. 4(0: -,Tt.•••.,-, :- . ., .... iiiif, :“ 1-. -...0.7.;`,...4" • .'t,4, ?.....44 • - -,-*, ' . - •,:..t...-1";i2 '' ' -'-, ' I:"e.'„fr 1 t' -1: . Ntk 4'7 ---4.:- • •••"...*',' ' --.S.f.4.;-• .- ' r-''' 4 , -.... ., . • ---ik•, . -'ilt.'"'• . . •'. ,-''•• '• ,....' .,. 'f'•-•:44.! . ..• ... :.„•' . ''''' •"*. ' ....*•;,. eii. ' --1,• ,.. . :,..,,,,' .•.- ::--,,,,'......„#,.,-1•.2. 4: 4 4 -.;' , .i.,%.',-.•'''.' t f " --, ..,-- .+.• :, - . '...', - - s":-k-' ,-- -i4-7 --i':* - -:- -.,:-. . ' ,., , , A : , ..,r,•4 „ - -•,.'-;' - ...ail . •.-'' .. • '''t: -. :-' •-;,_. , '5A,...-`, - = r ••sff..v: - . IL. : .• '• 4 - ' ..':'.-- 4'. 1 ''''. "c0.. , r 4' . .g.,-ii.,14; •-.2-24 .,'•1*. ,-." ''10",......,' , ,7'''',, .,:',':-• •• . _,,,- .i.* 4. • , ...i. ' fe -' 4.'.-.:- '.'' .*. -,...'-.' Nif 1, '.- ., ' -..1:'-'.'', '':.f. ' ".-:' "1:: . .ei..-v:. .•' ' :ir "‘.47'• .74r , "--'" - •'• ::•'‘ ' 1 2ti,-.- ` •-P-' • • - ": ',.-- ".--:,--.1,4r ; .- z i".4 ' - t...I.*:,4';'''s4ri:'‘... ' - '' 4,,,-.0 -,.. - ,- '.- ?iF.---. - ,. .....",e....0 ..-.'..-•:!'- '14, . .,:-.4iK., ',..,...:,,::. ...Y•.,, , ..,:.4 , ,,.-'s•.: .. • .it. -, - - ..,_-. ., 5. .4.•::.,; , . , „/ • ,-. _ , . .,-. ,,, . .....A.. -,..,_-„-- v.. •. ......, , IrAt-Ilr:0-,--- • - 7... ..fr, •'.,.'s.4.' ,,---.;it,...-. ., 1„:, - ...'....a„. . • . . OM. ., :, . , i 4. . rlirp '' IV ' • it' 4. \At* .•• . /C: , ' '.. .',,'' •;t1'. * ' .t'' . 0 ' ,,•'' " ,k-lt "ir, •' #. .;31: , 4-A.,,,Lt ' ,3, ...,..i.•;.;ri,, '..""%• ,,, ',,•'''i"-:"''''' Vt. ''' . 1 . ''. , `...0 ' - 2. '' - .•. ...., , . •- '0, , , , As• - ,,....: i S' ,.5i .......', A ,e. ' .`-x• ,.. i-2,.; . .o•r•T 'I... ," '* i • .,,,- -,* $g , ' - '..•4.'. . ,; : :' .'''s . i't'' 't:1011,431r. ' ' ',' - ""1' A Ifi , • f -41. .' • I '.A `t , ( - rl w . t li. . � •p • •••'16 1 i I, ,,,, . i_,i ' „?•„ \ ; 1M / '` i' . t�, � Y 1 k , racy 1'4 • i .r/`: �4 % ;•-.-•-''. , � 1.41 ,, a \ , S A ` , T "" 1 s jY'. yi 1 0R + •S ti !'4` [6 i . SI" , '40 • 1I , , , k a. " • t , ! .. vr` - r J, - , e • I, if' • ` }: ..�'' �� ` .% f ' r '*T.itt t «y I r E•.,t`;•• s f _ it 1-•t -s ,• • _ • .A n t > r .• } Y' .,,,,.erg • ,,.i i y ,`v X..�,• '1.)i , ` y(., �� �. .5 7. 44 t' � -�• `'i�. t. f. .i\: •� 7�,�\ • �a" t` ti/▪ )+'�-y� � .wY* \•* +►,s ..sr• .V �,• r16 r L„•ei .� �i.. � 05:1-. s,,.' � �. ',-„,.,1„,,,„,:t.,.._,.; )F 4 � 3k.ft:\ ' 1 .--, ,1 -ter >�~ ..,t. �.,,• , :1 , iiv .� . ` l . .e ' s >► � k._ ,site fJ,:i M,`,,-fi t',€4•,s_1{�` y„r r". •1,«. r ' • s $ . . `- 2 ; �.�?, Rpt + �� 1".11-1%.%14111. r x,...f.'...,...1 sC ' �vZ i •�,' • y® ' # ,� �� r +.y`, its" L ,�• w,,, .j�; "*),- •,, '''' • P : ' 4 liC .., . . i ,•,• ,• rs ..lc, . , , . . . , i.i' .., . ., * • . .• • .....• ,-,c, >, it, , -, • ,,,..,,.. •% 4 , • . ' 2, ' '.%Yt 't., •• o, ..si. •4.it, ;* 4y firle• g- ..*. 410. .•,, vpi • ' .\i../.:, • 40 • ,1 • .4 ,.• • , ,4,,,,.1.• ,, ; 41-7 ildh4' • , ' „,,.,'‘. • , • . .. ;4,,,,,,„......_., , „ . . „...,,. .,, , ,,,., 1,, •, ,-----1,,,„ ,4,, t st ••ii: r'l- \0 : , .. f' r'r e r , 0., .• , , r,e), • I .0 111.41", a. . "jj..•,. ^tr • ' l'ir•-''' '''. ., r.'.'4,1*.• • '.•."'1';A, r ' ) ' . r.,•....• .,1 ,, ' ''''' '. t•• - ' 'A. ' - d.I•4,.}• , ".•,4 * , .0,* ; ., , "a.i.%,,,: .4.. • . .. • 1. e a.wrat . ,-., A ', V, 0, • ,. 4. ...• ' 1'1'''-';':. - .'4.:...• l'k.r. '44'0 ,', '..•1';‘:''-.,p-*1:,',..,';,7.; _ -fi-- , .,;, 4V0 .,„!,,,,,„ 0 ..4 ' •':. . 4. " 3, , ' .'i ' ...,' . '.-ri• .4, 'lot ' •" `11'1.. . .. „ ilkilp , -,et.',.., .,,r,:r , ,. .,:r, J.,,,vi ,...,?, . -•,, • .., - #•,.., ., • ')A . , • '' :':•,,* •'''.',0)- ' 7:1'' 0 e:11`,.--, .4:'r' " --":*P.' 4"P5'... ' 4 41% ',.• -i4 - , * A 1 • t 1 'Itii.. - ' 1- ' ' :`,..., - .•.`;r, ‘::-., pit„'l t."-`1.A:'''- , •;',:7( .A-2 k;'' ,,•'1.-:"..,-: .:.,.',14:44fit..••. , .,..:••yli_Ft'ik,, _.0‹. lc.' •), 1." • ' ' • .•.'1Wr-. ). ' 2,-Pi' 41' ' . ' ..,,...,,,..; ' -i.A.,re,....,.16 '-ilit4.4,4;;-,i+,- •(`-...0-, 4o, ,...ft ,, ; i,w-., .7. • ., ,. -,-:-,,-••- • ,,,,-,A.,.•'-' :. -- e! `* . ',t**_,,,r'l* A ,1.4;I , •4,11 ' , n" - `4,1%, ' •", ' . + A,„ , ••!„ :.! x-r--. -,, ,gr ,:i, titf-,, ..,„.. . .- , Ark ,,. , „,- ;., --',,_, 1-:z ,,..- 4,- sg,,-; ,..., ‘. .4,, • ,,,•.- . •-k,,,,-,-,..r-i-e„ ,. -, -, J °I ,• 4 , •,-,• • ',' _„t:-'••,''''• . '14:4° ,..-QI' '..,''',-;•:''it. - -: .,!,.•,,,. '1.-Aki 44J4 4":34.. I. '1''•-••i: , .. , . - .."•,( i• v - iter ',C 4k- ..,, •--. .,:. • , .. ..• - .-, ,,. ),.;, ....,-.,.. t,. -,, -,'....,A .., .:,,,:!.... -,..v., !,', --, ,...•14. '...-,--,...1,.,' :reV.`Li24*^.: , ,,r,--.10 *-*- • t''• f . N,, . .v 4, ,•,..- , 0, ' it,'"'.- , . ' ,.. '.'' - ,. '.v . .,'^- •,. AtAlk• , ••••. , .. ,i, -.•• -f....,' ...,,,,.:: -.• fc, •' • " ' pet 4i ige,-''P 4.t'. '4'Ar-Ili•';. " -' .1-' ,... i... ,•,, ..‘,....% __2..-...31',. ,, ' 4 44.r'..,;1%.!,IN:.. "...-4441-,-, , •,,:-••3,110o-,.,•-.,*-",,tr..,! ;.+;-, ,, -,•'' ..,.:. • • ,,..-. :-.•),...s; '•'.,.,,, : 4%; 4,&r,.'ir•,:''* -., Vil• .•• '0, '' • -Aft - ,•••••••••4: 71.s. v"-A.2: • • 4. • - , 1•-' N ' ' k - ' -• .-v • X • .--.. 4-' k, • • ? .A. . ' • . •;II ' ‘..4,1,,A' • ,'Zio:- '. A . '' ..,:'• 'T'I. ' ' ' „..,•,a, ' ' -: :?•• ••,,,..:- •.' .,' ti-tt,- .,, ?,51,•. . .- ,:-. ., -. 11.• .- $41. .,,-0,,,,,-. • -.#4,'-- • ..4.• •- --1,19,444 '..'4' - '' ),r. ''' ,•-•-s7,%.:'t-.....-t%-:' • „ ,,..i•,' , t•:: '.., 'ej,:0„.1 . ,.); .i .•kc, .;(If)1 "'• . ,' . ' ' ." .,,•_, - =•:-,,... 7 .,•, at•,.1.-„., y ' :.,' 0 -! ' l,' . .: 1•4.e " .4; :.' 's-,' _,,,b_.,'• A-i4,5„,ra,/, 5:•.,tr„?..A 4 4,9 . ..:' **-- ''75''' ' 4"111:F., >e'i.. ..'•!. "le .4 • :-'' .' . •, •A:, ;.•-•..7.. •- -.4-.;dv.',,,•1• : ' -... -v., -,N. ',if .,--!, .• ..- , . ---, r.•• '.i.,....„,- -.4,-.'- • ,•,.:„..-- -.,, ' •••',-),•,,,, ..• - j,:i't., • ?.--.,N., "- - ,i'.4'. '•'. -7 .,„$;::. "„ , ,, , 4'-,,-,'. -- ;... .4:r 1:::t-',. '4,. 3C, . ....;.'... '1".': :::f ,'',.. 'IV: j'y '' '•. :6-4:' i-f •,-4 •-.. ' ; .4'Y 'tar -' • -.4- - Isif :-M"' '•-'- 1 lit‘i,'-'Zli. 4 - 0 S• 1 V *1 ‘4` ' ;,....1, _g.tve.1-10, .; ; ,,-.. -..1.-v;.. . , ,, it 1 -:.4_ . A ' -' A"' ,,,.V.' I.,. -,', • 141,1-1/,' : t J••••'"f,• ' ...'..,,r..', ;' 1 *71:: •.- s . ,,,„.. ,,-7 ?ii - \ ' .':'--5. - --A, , • ‘ 'd•‘' '.... ' .41' ''•.;,:.0 it,4 1 • ...•. .1 4,A A ' Y. '.. -!. • ''` .. , 15:•414,%..• ',...' ,: .4110A-: 4-, ....z-,....„. - 3......x, , ...-- ,,..In ',-.& '-v., 0,,-•-•.c.c....... .-•;•,- s„, . 44(26 it.' '7 ' '''''44 if, 14,, ...74;t•t ,. ;, .. ... ,...Ai_ 0.,.. . , ..% . ,,t) / 4‘! •• . " 4.- , •3 .......4. , :- : 4.„.....-. . ... ••:••:-._ .,-. ,:...,.,. ,• 1_,,,. ,...:4...• „, •,,,%ri, •,,,t . -,,, -.; ,-•-_ _ 4.,w.,..,;- ,, , ,.--) . - 4 '''.• 04-.- ,-..% • t ti* • • •,,- • • •;'it.$1 - - - • . --•,pe.,, 4, tly: . .-to'74.-.. 4••' At>• .-...;t. .•••••••'''- : •• .r•` •• ' ,.,., -.4t-•' -&..471,4C , -• ._- „,• N. •,•!" , " VIA,- ''' '' - '''''...., • "' '. --'z' "- if., ..-, .0.1 s , • ••. •,..., , ,_-:-in •-• -- 4.,t!..,-„ .', • '. Is,„ --.., . " , :'; .''' ;,..--4,--- . - • _ .-.t. ..., _ :. .: • ,•,.:.. , 7' .. • • .. ' .' ....•t-,. 'lot'," ' 4.,1.^...F .•••'..',9k-Sp-. ,,,... •"" „,"' ,,,,'", t ,''•, • „.1,,W1.. •-•- -,." - ••- .- 'AL .. . 1-••"2"ir 1 1'4'4.: 'Al ' --. :., .*:.:-.-: . -f -1......".1 . -.0 :- -g. -:4:"... ,kr"'.4,4'.'%'461* ":.'...,.. ' ' i••'•'- - i. fr'..•..10 *.... - : f ,- . •:•....'""i • ' `- 0 i • '3" ' •-• .s. .i- .A.4...' - . ..'...,,:41.. '4...: ,..1.--,,,., ,,., , , ......„..q,1-:,,,„, .-ze.-...;.-• -.7.= '';::.* '''filipi,lf•, L k, of ..: .--• . -- •, 4 .+-..-' ' -.1-1-4 ' - - ,; : , ;:' ••r-n if,- -', ' ,-- -. W . ; ••-',...A!-. • • i"'-.14.,-."'‘‘;14••••• ''.•• • ifttr•". :`••-•1„Z••• •••.. 44 •14•-?-'7 , --X . ''..-• r .4•:""'' r'oiki•ii. •'.•?•-'''" - t •;‘,Ii ''f.: ' --4.•-•. la' I.- tr4,..,, - ev'- , ,:1141 ....i c--,. -1---••••- c ',,,-- . •.,fti,:.;-4:.,,,.. '''-'' i':.. : . :-. " „' si . • • ' ._.. '' . ...20041-• • '• ,i,' ' It v',,a A .. ..• r‘ . . - •,- .. - -,* ... ..: '*.':.••-•'".. ''-• . '''.: ..;!,A. - . * `CI,.:".-' v '.., ,," 4, `; .";' .,, f..'•-•.-•••X): .• ' . - .- .•%11, ' `,.. '''..'i_61.1•1,," :, ''' i", ..‘. '‘'.1rX TflAr...:- ' .10-„, - -'.-'.4 - *•-' ' - ' ' , t;',. ' "tt -',, .-- ' ,..,':'14144A '' ••••- , " . t.'• - .-:f".: '1-1Fr-i•-'fi' # ' -P' - = $4,10;;• vf-;.-4 , ,,-;.v.. , :,;13,-,. ... -, , •.;.F7...,...--- -e.- ,,. .,,. -.... - • sk Mci. ;01- ' ., )51/114:'7* ..,1. -,..,'s:''•'/".•;,T$„f:-i:.0, /. , .*4:-'.- - *.;:k .-,c-; r"):1!‘."1""r't. • irl.'"P•.... 1 ' . : " ..- ' f4t,,. ' .;.. ,-•s-'4' I 4 s. I.- , . -• .,./'•' ,,(, . , . • - - •-• ,,t , . ., . . , , ! ‘1.. .4t-,/,-..V s' . ' • ;I.'. . 4. ' - .- 1+r-tr;'....::'X.' v ` -• •,Z.,‘ •..• • •410.,, , ,i.A.V.Z., , '', ;;*•,-.... 'r''. ' ,„--- =e • :, ,- - . 1 ,'-',,..• ;' i.`44.10q-'4"7 • c - 1r4 7-r1 •I'V r°';'''' -'-'- ;-4,.. ". "4 , • , •.1'50 . ' :4" ' ,- . 0; ,,I....rot 1. •77 ...4;,„, .. -.;,,' ;•••?irp,, -',.,- ..,-• • .4-,.;.,-- , — •-,4„:,:•';--- :1'..- J;-. ''. *,,"- . ., . ',fr..4•ii' Pr!' . ' f;141.44 . -cie. -- . •'-'!",iii:' 1 • ": - ••- . .• , . • , • e':.%?t,-.' -.•- /' : •, .1: • i• • - 1'0 - ' i ' • ' . • It ,...... • ... $p„,,, 41... . . .. ... . -...,...,,. ,,-•• ., . . A -.' \'' 1 t .... ,ii. 7, ' ,.i ji, Al .1,4;-f E,0,•-• ," - '''' ",':'' t „, -,' .1 ' ; t- io•-• fts--. , .. ;,....• ,,:Ari.;•- •,.. _"•• ,...., 41, i• ,...v_, ,. . p .., - - --, i ..o r, . "... - • - ,ii•• -,•-•. . i . - • 44,. • 4 .... nv, :..*.L.' a'!•-•,Aiv- N,,A. •i• -•, , 4,‘.., • . 4 - !.. ' 4A,.. 751 1":. a` '.- = • c , ,i,-.. Aiaj.,..• -; ,. 40,.. ‘ : .' f-•:. -,..._ I ' , .e•-• `1174 - . / i t . 4, '.'. ,''' 'ki• . s : ..' ..e..• v •.- "- •• ' , . , -.. . . •1 ' t • ' " 4 -)11 1' , ,,,... •AC „ 44..t 4. 40' I. 0a,t, .„ •f' •-41. '...t• • 1§, 'I- 4 '-?• ...P II. % s., ';1•:: '•/ '`., ': • ' '7- •--.-. .7„.41iiiiii-% _ , 1 , . .. . - .,••,,,.• '..,-sw,-.. • - , , -..4._ ,''7*. _ - ..-. - '.. ' - • ''' ' ''". -5 • • '‘. i in:A.,...„.1 . 1.". • ., ..4•1r. - • • "...M.O.. 40.1; lit • .k ...„ Y. • 0' • , • . , -., .6.1,-.... r• - t•• ' r' .0, . ' . III .1.•. .1... Y itri, . Ar• ,. - -- — '' -- ......... .• e .....-. •, -1,-,kr - ,, - Alip talk . .411.i 4,,41'-, -•-.: ' ., .*; •i.414 alb:'.. '-, - .4... •- r; . , ,. . *•,... • I. 2%. 1 lir . ...l. t. 4,'.. .-• 44 .. .... • s ••-,- ) • .., - - - NIX -..4.4444111111•111.1114.--..........44 . , ..,.. Y �, • _i.:" ......y, .4 fes:. r, 4110 • • i='rte, �, :M , _ y. , , 111/10 „Ae, A-• • • � • 1. 'ti . + ..,mi.,. `aSi_ ��. �` t- ly f L - `f7r ,_.;4,......:, /sf% 2 ' - �. • •,A. 4' _ , ,' ♦ 7', - -� -".'-- 'T � `, r '...1...,/P.- • :, . .. - f • t. •`+ • -•"tiiKLC` . ,. ,� f �� , �i s „.1_ =�' 'rt � �'311t"�f ,ti g !_ t” ' ... er' �F+ =/ r 't t motif ••s`' ' c #� : ' ; ? trli� fl .K. •S i P s: '. 4 I. 1.. F - . , 's f a 1 ��-- ',,Fy '' • % -c * __. 4 . ,4,44e. , y 1,...,4:-. . 4, t-.. .•..,,. ••.-a,1011".`AP' .. %le,. , . --,r- , • -- •. 1- Ns. • , • • L ' .c\'s - Vii:' 1 C .. ; I� . . j' i 1 r, .:—'t' .• 1 15 �, ri r .I' sr .f - - • � •` — ?t� f .. ". �. 1.�..`� • 5k••'•••-• •'- 3:,- .-:".. F ...ie.i • • r ' •`ma �� `Y • t S _ '°Sr 1I .•ti�" •' 1 . r•,• • A T: • ' e . c t • �•,, '..,;`• 1' 4' " • • • .� � 7 ( ` . ti4a-'L c, . 4 �, � r *=K yr ` � ` ` • ...t•0...• +.1 r .4 ; i. , v ?{ . 1Loi ---` v _ v.i r • �• •w • f � ' _ ;,. i ' W.nR :.14 • ,r • • ,t ,ittikr. _s . ,- 4.;4,4Ati‘•.24.., ' ....6• , .A. . • 11•'t , -ie. • ...„ „. 4.._ , ) < — , .4. • A,rill., ( . ."•"e'S.." •,• -.' .14,44t,••-•• ••5• y kt. 4 - .4*'.441•-• -1'#44',Ilk 4 ..4'' t - • - ' --p—s:illith'-‘ • k#4.".:'-- -• ?`` .i - f. �' .!a '. fit_ .� {, .» 'M ' `�. .. +.. ., rst• +. . • s • � - . r � t y • �y '�� .,,if r \tit' ,' .•`.x1 wi - • • vti �M • F • t -• A,4 •�. t b t ` t.. T.,.f v_.;,...:4 _,4.} !I GJ• L$ 4 , (` � , ' 1 •�t`t" • ^#1111 's., . %,1"� +r r! rr • • `• • . t < '' ''y. . Ir - .4v:IL. • i as re -4• +,4,'f. ,,y•�•^ '•• l- • .� , l �t Lf • �: • _„ !r) y � _J.;, ` '' � Sia 1,\''• j, 'Tr }` �e1• ~(�-t }}• 7v > •C"ali,f•7' At• •y� �- f..�, - S-L •` ,1It r i . •t` { . _ 'f _1 1 ., .F+ .,•f7••, .t: f r'` i' • ■i J1 • b }i 4 r J., '� e 4." ••"f" ' i q .;" :I,? ,r - "1 •Z' i • *�„ 4aI h. Mt . �41 ,'w � + ,1 ' � ' ! r � 1 � ' 7 '`' efj~ c a r ,. � "� •5 _. • i• 1. ' n a 1 Y1rl'j7 r ` tet �. �[ + • ./ ./ • .'«, o••` .-, I 'M•✓. 4 iii„ •r '` ' ':4C. � .. .• `.ti's►• /�},. ,---{ ^'t• v t j, 1 ti t d1 ..-.. A_ iii r 1 `ftp •� �..� /� alp. r .�1 Iu �? i' 1 I -.4ittlip .)11/5 �� F + ' %l�'+''#' • ' • rte A -*:A/i / +.,�!• _ �4f,, It • h • " it L' ♦ t. I.( rt. '� '�j ', ^/ , F V.' '� - ,,,:; # '7. 7',N...R.Ic.:,-?d. ti,„ --r7 1 . ,' 1l• 'r +M r" ...1• ..•' • _c,..*,,,;„,_s t 4 y. 1.• . • r • .. • Alt 41 .• u. r' _ ?, >, y{ • _ :,411 . • '• • 4 " ':� T. • 17 , 1,(•jgiC�-T-'- :.. ..h • •' Y k . ' 44.. . it,* 'IL% .4 ot' P!--itit, .;,,..,,,,, ,,..,,: ,,.. . 4 ,- .., 4 •`'..> ' • 7.•-.V. •-.air-2.- iii • ; # .# .��,��� t i' `•. 1 ,. 0' +,,'i' ' rte' • r - " r Wf1 1 • Y v A • - , t ,t 71 L. ! •1. , h : VI � 11 '•^r7. I 6 ,moi � 4'1; '4! ' •I • i J'1 �' *+'" Y ��' A` • �' �I r' I x•.71, .'�„y i. *• 7 ' • .."11''''. . s • - , -. • �• � � .•,. :$3.146 . da0„4. ' t' `' 1 f � e41, 5 43.1il.S-... 14 •41.. 'IA 4, .,. ,..6:11,14,41Pir-IC. . ::.%, sr_i • ,,. ..., ,8"..,7 1. • », ` tib` 1 • ? ;i •\. ^ ; = 4 . ; 'fr.. 4.;*,.......t.„. )6:6? *. / : ' .6 ‘ • • • I.1 -- ''*'''• 1 i;*: *-''"f•:. I -..s.' . ' -0.1 .i , .. 1 . • / , -• • . ...,..0.., Ndlegir **c....., „:-, . • • 1-,, „ V' ''' / , •,I• , . 'ix, , • i . , sooe'Fr't s•.,', . - _ r ...flif..47,'•;:.. , ...t.,.. . :,,4 ,.•:4:-.. ' .' *I .1; .t.'..r,ter' -t; '7...4 I 14 i ;,,.H• •""..p' .4.• --444,- ' 14' I.• •-r.,: • i`. •• - • . 4-4 . • , . . . . 4.•'•4.• 4..t- • -.. A -*:cr.• \-;;- .",- . ,-, . ,, ' -,, -.- Ili' • 4, 4:, i sis • :" -4-`•• •. s .. -4, Adr r•ri. ' / • 'a• . - - t . .4%,,,rri-, : ; '.•• - ;'' a'. - '-''''"--.'.-. ' .• . r• • •. 1' , , • •*1 1. ..., ,.--- • -,:•-• -, 1.7. •-:... -......--_ . . . . --.---,- .. ..1 i ,,pif. '.. ,.•.'. I, ..-,- . ,.: ' . , . . .. t,..;4:2,.•. ' • ---4 '- >%...:;, -..1r..:...4'."-- - 11--. .It' .40- ,.. ... .., •-•.. . •-•P, 'f ;• • : 4, • ••_•• .._ *t• , .. • ,.,,, • . -..-1 • ....-- ,,.-„, ,0-.. ....,•.44 ' . .,.! •# 141,.. _ . .„, . , , ,.r „int „-„Ir'-. • „,. • I N:..._.4,.. -• -'111P, ••• • ' 0'..it 14, k.,„ _ . 1". ''''' • ---• ' •i. •• %,-- , •• *-, . _ , > , _itilai; .4 -• "• 'A io`•- 1' ,. • .-. • ' .‘• '• 1.-i'../It': ''';‘‘ ' : " .- - lit ,, ,..... '1 1 • ,,,.. • _ ••." I '''. ...;4'..''''' .......- ,., ,4 ••,- '.,* .• '7 1- .. ;41;*.:-. 1 A.ij.1.• ' . , . . ..k ----• 'T., LI • . ,6' 6 * : . . f' i'..• ' •*. l* . , • • '' --.1•1:ti...•• '• **1 • .;• • •.'661!. 4,;•• -44.t904- 4,„ - %,- • `. • '1 it • iii„,!.--, li_•-•;..--.-.7,•• -9.4- ,4,4!,-. ..•?:• „•- -.. ..• • . A .. - ••-• . • - - . • ---\--, ,. . < ..„.-.---;.• .,-''''A •,.%J I'4,•..." •. . ... .• , : .., f.• . '... ,,,','ilet *T-.6411 , ...i...,.1: * • V...... , ;. 3.6' •., -.,, .4 . ....., , r'' . 'ft , - .--.• .•. • .1 44:. ,0:! ---* - ''' . ' 4-. -.•* .. ,•1•.„,„" „At . 7 ..-•IX , .•' %. , ..... V _..,.. ';',.f.•4v,ay,.,,t..,.'AIL„,_4„ . , i';4 P..•4;', . 4,0„, '. ' . '''Al'''t•"- 1 ' ' 4-'....;.F4..,".,- ‘ _..•1 I- 4/b.• . At '.•• ; r ; 7t'.'1 ...- . . ' • . . • . "'"' ';'` ..4 . '•' • '''•',.1'4.( ', ,-,- 4 .1 .1-- '7 .-,.. ••-f'' ..".'' ,.'.4--,---. -,. '.,‘•.'.. -4),,r..--. - ' • ••••a' -* -•• •• • ... . '. ' . .. •t _ ..''' th : .t.iP1 t . • .•9 4 '.' '4„ Z.•-. • 4: ,., -..4,-••••,-,,,,',...i , • 14 I - . .-:' i - e- ,.-:'4- .A.....m.•-'4.7'1.' ..,-- ' •C.. ••••444i;,..• ..;• ,- r"'-';';'* .7.7.-•••-: . • . • • , : .9. k- .• .1 -, . ..... -,.._ • . .; . , ,., ,,,';141.,,q ,,,. 4,•...... .. •"-•:-.4 : , _ .4. ,14.' .: •.••••.1. . -„••.4•••„4. - 44*-4•4:•,--n-4_,. ',;-.,. 4 -,--•!-.-- •-',, ' . ' ',i,.. - , 441•P'3. --4-f.,,t-.. 14.-- .'- • --- - _ • 1-...' f...--.- ,-A r. 1-•••i.- .-',„•-- L.:" --.." re 07;„. 0,,..:-;.:, , -- - .-- t• - "se...h 1•...7:' ",,*•,,,,..it•., •;.,..14,4%,, -....„.,-,, , .. ,,- "I, , • 14.,.....„.. _ ...." .•• ; ,,,,••c•-*,,-,4...4.k--1.- ..2.•.'...; If.,:-.. '. /4,:• , -,, - !`-' •-; ''•' --.7 -1.;•%.41-.;:f•A 4 1.-4- ..,-. ...,.. • ••- ,-..,- • .. - / ' 1- . ` . ..tot '-'r--* ik,..• ' ''',-,q r•-•-•<--<„ •,,..,;-x, ... .4' . ...:, . .-..I"' •--- '.'-,..ift.*.•',.: .• ',_':,• .,r :• ,,, ,-__,-- .. :..- i..- .i. ' ' :./r . , . , •,_*- . .... .410, ‘.1,- •, .. -4.:,.1, ,,....x, . .-.••%.,-.41-- .,. •. „, ., -.01P .. .. -,,,16_,.• .•...t.- •'' •'.;:.',• , ',-•- .., ' ' •,, •11..-*--,44'.• •'..•,,•S'.•L' 't t-s' ik .,,.... 4 ',..;.•et. • 6 ,1 -. -:-..• -• 71Pd" i4,--,-. ..f. • ' •= .' = .APIIP. '117,171: F:..- it. "-., , •,,,, • ! •,7'.. •-..4.,' ..,*"./f.„4,- ',. '•it,,,"-4:` .• ..',_, 431.;, . ,,• - .„,m67- -' ,',„ ,, -r.-#" ••;-",....0.- .. . '...NW,' ,.. -. -,-• ' - • - .' •-"_t't - ' 1 t;;•",q4,4et"---- -..• -.• •I'`,•• .4 - . • mok-7-.., :4.7, • *. ' •• • '41,16:.:., i • • .......- . • - -.0 - • -',-- .,-4,- .,,. ,5"..". - .-- • • ,!.-, i•., 4 '. '" ‘• - • ; - 'A...';: . -- '-•••• '-'''s ', ' '' -4.-'"Ift- •-•-,..‘ • , ,.„ 1. . , -.,., .8...4,y,-.., • .-, 114. .,.„..4•• .-„, r. ... ' - . . . . , ...• . ., - • ... .i, ,:,.„,. ,.: 1 - ..r.'• -.. -•tip_s_-..-0---,- - .44 :'' 'e.. 1.-' . . .'. ' - 4' . L.1:, ' 4 ' ,• 7 el '7.-m-V• , -- • 1 • 0 s•-•a • cr--1. s -t, •' 1. .51,..„)-..te.-. ',.. ....-,.. ',, ,:-:-.•. ,_, ' ' V•1.--...•-J- . ' ',=•.,* •••• a•-- .•• -... .. • -.„,,,, a .4. • -4.-1'4.4.... , •. , r. . ,,,,,„....., .., .... .,, 0. ., ;.: ,04,.0,-; I At,'s. ' ' - ' 9 ''• ' • ' "4".-.."-----:-...____•:.! ,•,, .,, ,,,,.•..,. . .-. '_.- '- -'!1"••-.1,V-1 "". `.* A . ..-'''- • ",.-•.'4;,:l.i;E-•: ...1-i• ..14,t4 7.!i' r::: -. ..r... .. '5" '' ...- .• , '••.Nt''.'..Ai....-.4‘..., .,....-•1,.. - - ;;,...41 Ift..,..4..,0 -!.. h . "' • - 4.3- ',- • + - ... ,;'• ;;;• ,..1. .;• ., rili .••• ••••• ir' Ite- '4' ..,,' r•• ' :.;,... • •-•.-:•27.4' 1 ' •• ' ^:. . 4 ' a r• r'-'.;1."‘ t 4 :. • • ;: •'•...• a 4g4; 1°'• '. . -se•- -s- - • t,.. ' f• • ; __.,.it,',.:, - - - ' iiiit'%--?•-31=Z .......I.,'• -.. _..-•:... -.- '-, A,L,-- ." P.,,,' ', '4„` ...••,,'•-*".. . '5.1.••., --''-- • ;• '-''-' •• ' .iiik-%1 ,•S''' - •-fri•i'. --- • •• '•Y••••?.., ''• , i,,,r id. a 'st•,' '. •V - t +4, . ., ,,,,,A It•.,,•'•' .:fir f: -0•!•. et:.4.•-..• ..• . '- 7.s• - - '•• . ., , • •,_./t*,-,..:-..,‘ op z. ,y,- .--,..,..,:.-.-,'-. . . _}, ,,,,:-„,:-...,..,*1-•.,!.N•,..•••- -:"''' '•,.i .....-. -!'2-47,-.1 .,.>" -.1., ••-;'-'""i* •I '•k•-,.....4t. --i'''llgir, •• ..'-. -'-' ..' "•:. -.• -i-: ,,, :f.:.,..r.c2".• •ii.„. a- lilt,' - , l'eN*e.-;--'--•' ' 11‘4.-,i,:',.1.`,--.,,,,,.. - , -1.4'V-' '-',.!,`,. ' '' •:. ,,, ,.i ,r.- u.-.‘1 , , .: 1,.,..--.','z. ..:ii;,. ..-1 .:••••41,1 - ); '4 7 lif•,'-..k. ‘'7. :v•. ---.?'.,....- .. ,, , - , , -.- - -fli, ....:-.... • , .,;,.-- Y.,- ,., -" ,-.:.!.....,,„. .-,,, ..:,...,4. 4.-.•74,.•, 0-1‘ • • "-.• •-•' "';24-- -„Av.' • ', - ."* ' ' -••414-;•,•:.- ,'"„.7,.,4•44,24'.• vl . , --•J i -,- ' • '.- '''- tr- *!..?",,:•r -..„.4-,.. •“ .-• -'`,okye,,k- r. . , ‘7 ' :..,.... • , 7 ' .4444 4. ..,... ' •. ' • “ , i i' 't.t f''.'.1'*1 r'14::40; i..' :'14,.4.1'i 1...::4)):.. '.•'. '-t.'.'' ‘'i e:7":;':: 1:.i .4:1.''..:....S.' 4'''''''1::i';:.! C...1. .,. , '. ' ';,,, •,,"- -!• . . ';'• .•:,,,,.. -,•4 ,i , ,,-• -.-, .• • ;•••'''''a 4".•',..- . .'',.,..,,„ 4 i !" • s-,•-••• '. . i.-,-_," . w - -'-- k,;_•,-/t, lir' • .f., v • ,. . -..4-•%14. e •„,• . .• - ••,1":4. • .- 4 lt.lig• '•.. ...0-43., 3, ..- •....- s,..- • 14. 4-1f ,-' •-•,-. .. .. PI'? 3. •-..;••-•••••:".."-•••••,-.!..t17,,,•• ':•-tk. '---. . - ...,:-•;,20-4 '''ir• •41,•'4,-.' ." 1 . '4.- , ' •'. 1, 11;••••.••'4: '''. ; •40001 .-..•,.,', * -...-,-,N,.,',1 • , _ ‘ '4`i 2" '-;-'' -.oft-- : ' 4-'1-(' ,.':i-.•A.)"-'t7T -• " '4.,.% .",2,'1'."4.- 4,1ir'- jitrakt1 4' .70 F''',-tr,,r4r 1...ak r,ft• .,•• : . A' .•o'.' .- ,-: '40 ' ' ,...- ,'" 'si' flf. • ' .4 ..." . ', ...s` ', , t . , 1.•. _ill ,.- _ - .! 4.. ''1.,_,,' 1 .1... .- '. •" ' - 4r1:-...?-...-'•I''., •A -, - --. -..4 ,.... ..-, ,..,- ,,ft.s.-.--le: r: 1.0 -,L-..'...,. ..,,--,e. - --,.7.-4 . - . • -.-1,-v 1/2,,,.. r..,-,... ;hi•'. ' 4'• , . ' ,••-• .4'. . 4; `,"'::''. •. e GO.. ". 409k .44t/ "' ' ••••••'.• 1' ar v. .• :.., .'4.... 4.•. •••• ..1. •••'41,!•. ••• '•'•'ll• IF "r24:4e."?' ''.'"/1 4' •••r •' .,, ..4,4 • *'.'• - '...-,4 • fr.- , ,, - *r-e,•,* 1- -t..f., - .,., --, -•`;',.A.,-!,,'''...f.,,,..' .._..: ‘.•:„_.__., _ ..4.,...i•.;*,... ; ;:' .16,14.. '.1..sttfets'4 :''''••• .. . ::. .'' r,, • '0*,. „....,f,..• •,,, h. .SP`i-1 ,• , • • .... e '1., '' ..„,„,., . 'f*•* a; #.,lie .... . '.*'' 3;%, '•?:* tki,. -. ," . . k''"a••-‘...Ott ' -• ' ,'. ''•--. - „r••'-• . : ,•-••.: • .••••••*-{ 'f„ •'.*:" • r, , ''" • •,.., •-, 0." '•' ••-4.4 • ''•• -'-. t t - ,7'1%, 4t, '...? ' • , .' ' :44i.,14,, •••• •4-' -. • , '','-'74-' -44-.. .'••.' .." .•#r, ' .•••• . ,,'-',13) -4, '7:4-,, .r';.' 'r' • ,-,„.....,i.,.•*14('-' ...4 , • 4,47.1,46.. A , „ „.,.:',ri,- , .:•,...,P'''..• ,,, .' 'g.-k7:.,**1•AV,471.„ - '•.;'‘' :,.e...:3. ,,,, .',..'ir t'1,4';'.!vi•• ,-•.4i.,,....."-,- ---w- „e ,,,-.,.r,. ., r -0 ,,,,iir ' t :449',.; ' -,. ' '. . ;. ---'.1'•'' - °••••••• ":,O.-.''..,":9,, '- ,' ''' - '4' . - '- -I-mt- ' • • • • • -*4111‘4'..*:. .f.. .„,•• , 6• 4••t•;;.• , • • . '.v• . •:ji.'•it.i''".;414S''''',".'ti::.:..P7,-... '..4;"...c.4'C':'-•-,f..:4 ;',,1'‘,.,..1•: .."-4-, ^17'"',- '.....''.- ,Pr 44tti. •0 *- f ''' • - . . ' -*• ' , 44;4'*'' * '• .' '''' ' 6. A,•• .-•••'i' '.4.rt•S. :* y-'•:4. ••••' ' : A.- .... .41' - 4 -,."-,-„, -„: 4.,,,i -r,. . '''• . „ ,'.'„f,:,‘ .. ,,•-•': y•lk. - #•_„,.•. : • 0110110; 11 • •' 1,, * . . 4.11kt. ' .*;I: •. .•'In -1 , .'',','*' '., .Al j'i i r•'.,,i,;41 0 ,... ,,i. ,"_ t. .:' ,-11 6 h . • '. i' ill'''1.7-** 1 4 • 7',,11( '''. -* Vir, '' , ' 'I,:•*.•1, 1.',..,41.r,,,i•-1, ,_. 1.,., ,;-• ',,,; ..!,.;•!,‘,'. v14 i‘,•,•• 4 , . • .4 ., '' .-,,..44', 'fIe i•••44._-:-.'If*- -, ,,:•4••Is'a' " '-,'' - • • u,c=',-)tli'"' ;'-'4 '3"' ' ;' -'' ,. - -'.. • • ': '••:)",,,V, '/4-.',"40'..• .' .., r - .,„,, , '.....--4,4:At 4-41)--•',to 4 i,, . • #406.7f - ' ,.- .9 : --,, , .'•,,,,;:'-,0.,.411.‘,. • ..-, :4.;ti-i ':4,',„., - , . i . .,.,,, it .,,, ,, . - • -i.4.41-!..,"...' - '•. '.:' . . .....-... . '`.4(4.;., '1'.....*.X 7....''.‘.1..,'4a.11;'.:."!:... .:.r. ...'° .:';:;-'''!' -• : ''''''..t ''*.:'.','r i' .,':1* ' l'.,..1'*i, :041;"*.c.4 . ' .• .. ...I 6 .• '" • / • ' ' • '., •'*. * •#'' 1.*' /.404°. . •* ' re' ' 6. • *'''''.1 I.s. ..,, lit",r.4 i„!?,:••;.. 4, • - 4 fr , „ikt, , •. •. ..k L ., 4i ii, .!,., . . • /0 ' • t"..: 1,, .,' ,imit•..44' 4).54%4 4. ',41,k no, "4 -.41'..... , .•(...4,' . . ''• 0 I _;,, . . . .. , . ., 'V 0.÷..„ '•`' '...',"- ', '0',•,''.''' • ."' 4, . 11' , ,.. .„„. 1 J, ' 'kllt•r.4.4(', •' 4% . • ''.i III' 't •'•./* ' '• • • (4.1 .Or • lei:le ... ; ' 'V) ' .I'' •,! i., . ' „. • .4. ‘,,,, i. ti • M•14 #.• . V ''- • ,.e. 1, .4„..', Av., ......-,,,,. • ... • • •` , o .Y • .. .a �i0 ' _ F t1 `� �. • • a!l? ....."4. • ,` ` • ;+.•• N .'1 r ,`/(��i ,4 ti. • 3� t • \ .\• (• 1 ! .�� i + .t•X1•4 K," _I + ,_ • i , -i�'a, =; -w•, i + • 14' ira`_. t? ,,awl +M ,,�• \ ♦`` _J'a. . 40aertitie _. �• ♦ t �� - w�'' tis• ;T: : : ' + * ;�i •- ill . AC 3 - :4 IC„IA • - • *11 .` T * jj� f/ '• fir 1-��.1�' a-, +, •+ 1 4 IT r . t-, c . `t :`T'C �K.' S 46.• � X77,+ V[ 5. lam' '� (�7. a _ ..-,4•;k.... -ra t'v. 4Ai tel•,/ `,• ► - • �~J9, •_ -- fi ' ;_ ••%....-K-3,,:?,;.i^ ., i?^4 . •• • :` �' • A a= t ;. • ram ' t. :1: • : j : '.. ` RY Vit` ``• 1� ' • ii t �'. 4 .,. ..-4 Via. '4 • 4 • • 44, � • :t- + ....1 •.,,t, • 's• .;-.,. _.• itt, .1 • , . .i. ,,, ,,.. . ..., t. t• ..... . • ,,.,.. , N .. t • ti ,� i •• .. ••.77777wiiiii a a�;' - +� �,,.`r ,# • r -. Y1 r. w .. r t +ii} .4 :� • , •". 4.., - -. r•fig," .• ., e ••, i. .,.:••••. - ' -' •4411.1:11.'4' t' ' . • S i'' ' '. 7 • . • ' ,,, lir ' ,T ./ *fr ik -' ' '* - or. • • : ' / • :1 i '',. 44,'',... ,f. ,....Ak. .. ,.4: A • , • , I/ , .r. • i.'.,d.,,,, ,iito...•$.-;;od;1.4 el,•,,,',1:.. . , or,4.:3,...•j.i 6,.. ,,. .. .44, , mr,,, s • .., : ,. . e , .4 . .t .. i . •.,„e :' .4...... W 1%.•••!•41_,:e:.'.4''' 1 4.411c. V/t. .. : ..A '.. .' . ' I '..',i4.4:- ..''''.''1 i.. k'f ,- , .,‘ ,.;41.',.' ,...,.1'•'. .:fr.'•,,,•• 4i: •*•.„4..;, I.'"• '" ' -. - ., e - . t '7'*‘. -°' • '' '1.'4. '. -- -%.°14"..:;-::'110 ''''"idp4f11-',t'' VA'.7.'• 411'.•'',..* •• ....i•• •,' ' ','. ' ,) , •'. ';',:.' J''i$•,., ,re'.4" • 9.',-. .1 r`f:).= :. :# 1'30,.....'''. ' • , . '..,,.."1. ..,. - "`'-'' !4i•'' " '': •I•i•' 0 , , I.,.-1 I!:"'ay.*".'•4 . . 1,;!....t.,:{4.tik:'-':''. ':"..:'.."/'"e'!' ..... .' ' !.: ''. -*. • /") .4. 4. ti‘.'..... . . .. . , ,:. .. .F4F•t.,,: .. .. i, ",,,,„,;,3-,4,,I„i„,..i7.,At-,.•,.E.,.-*....4„.;',:..\.,.s,'14z,..R_,,,7.•4!..'4.1A",,,,t,L,,...,g.J'N1o,,t''I!,t.'•.-,,:,.. ,.4..','.i'.-,..`._,'.•-',*.-.-2)"•1I,4.i'..,.'.i-%tW.,4t....A_,i1,”k;1..••k,.`.-.;.g..•l-.-i,,;,,.": 3-i''.r.:.i'.•.':',•.•••*,1'4.•.,.''.4*-•:--'..:.;';•.'.i'..t'••'.'.7;.,.-,.,i-!g:O:,... . ,2;'..'',.,..'..:,,r",,P:•",'k.",:',,.-;'..se,...y•,'•..', i',•.t-'.•'.,•\..•;(",.?-•4';•`l't"-.,-tt:r',''f.,.•".-.,..-,'.t..•-....f.'.i.-r,. :' i ,',.-*•.1-"*‘'-,:.;'.-,%t",'•')4.:1-;- •X ofhV 6•, 0 7 r * - ' 4 " .? '. 't' " 1-. '' ' ' ' , - , -..j. • • frii•y 1,,‘• , •,6Srivfr'P,- - • .-ilKit....,' '4t-f,:fr...,, ' .'.41,J4-t.,.,•-",..,-,:%-,....-;,. .'....... . . • ./ . •-: ., its4:004 A. 4.5,.. „ I ,,,..: .e.?)-r ^ ...• 0 4. . 'A' ..' t',',V,- "'.'./.4ii;s4,• ••: . V:,•1.'•'*:,',',00,; ;!•%1‘,.,'... ' ,. •A• '.' • • , ,ii, 4.L.,,4,.,4( ...,„.,..4 , , .,.:,4:..,,.i -AL • ' '''' 4, ':.4( :.i',1.14 V. :. .. . ''''• .'': '.• ' ,W:.,....;. ..,.' .....' ..'1.. 4.. . ....I‹ . * ....1' , ... .' i . , r , / ' i V 1X.,1.' :OA t'...,„. -?;:*.:.•;•. . '. '' ; -.:,. ' _ ,.., • ..-.: - -,-, ,S• •4*.7" ';t: . 114 e'!..2%, ...-.'• • \-,.4.,..,,.., • ...` '•,,..7. - .'.. '. .: .. -.•.•. A •;644.. ,.._ •J.,,, ,........,.... .. -• ,- ' „• - ..,,--••••• d•i •"'` W-.. • d 1- ,,,,•••... •• ',id.' :;-':'kl.t.;,• -•'•.d.'•- '..•.' - . ''S. ' : . d l s4:' Fria:•ii: -.' • . • i.•'. • itt •:-• ''..t• *; '4-. ' '' - - ..11'...'' 'i ... .9. .°at.. '-..."1;41'`..i'".-.=":' '? '-!II: -'4, ",- * '''';- *437,41".„.' • • '.- ' ' .1, ,'fel• ' ,,,,i,$„„.,, ., . .,A,],, „..-,,,, .. . .. ' • :its, , t,,,,,%.......- . .it.77}.. . •-,. • ..„,'As.•4;,,• SIE- ‘, 'Syr .„:4 :. :... .. .. .,....•rir,.,-,. I.:: :.• .. •.- . - - ... 7 pk, • , , .. - . ,. . .. .-.440i4 4: - . ',4tf,":01,-.. '::,.s. %, 4.'ITI-. - •• ..: . '' - . ' - •-••- -- .1.. . - l;.:: IN:' ' ,., ''''.• , 1 -:-.....;:. . ,,: ' .3, . •-•,..:4:3.e.‘.., ,.!: , ,• , fOlii . . .. . -:".4,1•T. 1..* . • • ' ' . . • ,aresw. . .: • . 4P,. ... . .. . - . T. --4A. • _ ,.... :• • .., ,••,_ ._. , •,. .... i..- • 41 ,olit ,,,,....,.... . .,'!•• . 1.;- ; " . . . ,,,,, . . ,,,. .,, . i, .. .4.f, • ,.•'.,.V.....4...; '71:''.1, '. : • --diaiiire-2''., :...*:•:'..* .. ' ...4 " .• ...Ak. '4. -- •-• •f '61 ,• ••K -' • ./• 7 71.-;.- . • '', , ',• '.. ' 4`.• 4, i /- .. •• ' ',.•• •N"''' ; .f 44(trigi4147.• ,- 41`. • ' • . gc r' . • A. ... ' r .. . . ' ' -s• '1r -. •%-+If '• I-Vi 4 s 10...%it. 2,-,-. '''' ..4. '. ' • • 4.,. • .4,:.,.. . . . . • • • • • -.' 1('' ' . - ' • - - • 46.- r se .... . - 1*.! ,. •., .1 . .• f,...,4clir. '.;,,P,. ,i._, 1,, • ... , •' ''''.••i• • 1 - -;:• ' .•:,:: '4 ,".., -tt 4 , ‘" . , ,‘,,A,, 4 l• ^ ' ',': "'"t .‘" •"- 2 ) .-, .4;''' = • • .. ' '",6:ein-'.''. ....'-:' ! lititi it .•• fro A ' ,t':: 1 '; •• - :• -,A 4. ". C.,. • - '., -- " 4 , '''-'q • ., * . '',1•• , • ••,. '' • " .4*., .• . •.... • ..r. • . i, . .44 -1-; ..":.....:. . •• . i fc , !. .." ,-.- • N.;,',...-.; , • - ,, . . ,. . .- 4,, 4 , • a• .7, '4 .' •..'' ;Itl.-*" -:•7:,'t-*. •• 4 t i....,,,,t . , : , ...,..4 ,.i. ,,i..;. ...gL,,.'11:v7s:',..._ • ".:.' . ''..,T4t. • A..7 -,•• , , - -/ --:,. ivA, ' '' '. t4 • ?. '- *°' F., -,...-'4,;.:-• -45ii1/4...' ..! ' *--4:'.- '777' .; ., .- '.*'• . 4-'4 •,•,'--- •,-;#"•..-1":•*:4 -, • . -';'‘,;.r,*..--.,. ' -.. 44.'4',!, ,:, '% ... •46 . . • ......f-, ......••' 47.3..,, '-., „:1 . .*4,-....... -',.* .., . -,4.) . - • , . .4,,, . ...•••tAa.H...,,......s.‘.- •or•4',le' '" P-,,i1 ••* - . itgfOlf.• t,''.'_.• .7' ''-'*''' ...• • ...;- " • yik,ili. • '.....;.. ei. . . r-- .., "" -_ r • • s. ,, • . ' .741• -. ' s. . , .., . .. '4. .' .+.'.7 Y;:,.. I.' ' .,, . • . .. . #(' rial• • 'A • I 4..n'' . :'''' .'"Or'' . • •-----I___._ ft-4 , .. , ..is .. 4- • : '• , ',. .. ...;i17-k '*:;;;-;:,''"ieS'-:-. 1:.. ,' • a . •,.:1;.. '.f..., i* ...;',i'_.t.!:"..- -;.. .' ) '. ''' . .' ••' ,•. -ft, ',Y.i,.• • . 1•,......e: r" • ..1 . Pt',, •.:". ' .! /,i, '.'-'' .At....tpriteih.A :';;;' j'I''.111.:.'.'.-L. ..6:Js.' ';'.• '.' •. i•VI., '' t -f.t A - , .., .,. ' "• ,, 4. ' ' - • ,fi, :1/44' e .. 'A' '#,,A'',.4.A ' '111,,, .Jo •.4.3. ".:.-:-.4,,i,', te.... , . :. • - : *.: ';.• g k - • ...,. Ai-. . , . ... ... . , , .„,„ .. .1e. di 1, . . ., . - ),4„, .. • . .,••• .m.-1 . • • .•.. . . . .; .• . • . -;-'•;•,, , „IF . - le ., ' ( , , 'Vi,:i,:;/ ii.., .., ,,'...' • . • ...: '. ..'-:41,4'7. •'. , •-.. . i , .4 ,...• . •, • 4,;r•-•i.esi..,-. • . ''..•,.•.. ... ,,T.'%."4 ',' ' ,. .., , i' '-ili. ' li,..:.. -'Y ' ' . ,,.. - ..„ 4 1- ..., . • r,„ ,. , ._..... . . , , < ,-.-.04... -,. "-.:-.•;,;:,.,‘.,. ,- . -..,• ....,,4 4• c.:' i .....• . '.' -*it .. 44, -. '- , . , ..., .... ,, .--.... -''t.,:''`.:. ,•1' • :, ' . • v.' -'," , ,. .4,t ... • • i-4,-,y4•44:-. :;... ..':gtel. . ,--0'-. Illy - .. , . :It: , -,-. . -... • - -0 -;', ... --1;-!,:i47,-..:,,;;34.•-•'/••---ii-iii.0,' ,42`.`'A ' '.."-i 4 :•t • ' ' . .. 46. ,e.-i. ii„..4d...,;--, -feltr.oki ,' - • i • . , r- '......:••••:.:.10..t.i.; , • 1 - III 'fi f,I ii f 1 ....I. :-,.i:"rr: .7 ''''''''.11:;.111,,Z,..-;r4s4,, ,....-1: .'..17,,:-.:::'‘4ifs.!---744'S:: 4;;:'. :. ''... :;.:•,.1i:t:'-••,..1-r-%' L....:' V. :', .....:*:°. ' ::.:•!:. ' :'I:- 4 IN i if /pp -• -,., • •,.,.,..... • .. ,..)!• .: -,, ,.•, 4 ' - iil,,y-.1r. • t•;:., - ...' i..,•,.. . 4 4 // if-". ' ''' ' .7.-1^. f _• . , \s . . , i; •, ' / ,• .. . • • ., 41 \ ,i of Ill 1 'l Ill,,I, ,,, . . • ,40,-. r....,..p. ,,,`,4Y"' . I''' ...' ' '4::1,i I' ,i i If i ,/ „/// /) /414,4004ty.' •'' / ' . ' : . ,. 1° le -'‘ - • •• I . / .int'tb ''!'14 i I.,f" ',' /,/ -,- . ••' ,:::,*I; - ;iii, \ , t. 1 • V , - *,-, , ; •^. ... , e„,.. r • C"*. , -;iile` it a - �)j s � ri: . 1 -! jt 1 : 4,1 rt . tk p . li• d • .. , w ' • • ‘ t . , • , , ... -,,, .,,,,, . . , .. -, 4 a 04 •% ....A ..,;•-, ..- . .., .. .,..., . ,,•,$,..,.•.., .01.:. $, . . ,.;.... „ .. . -... ,0.4„..:, . . ,...- s .., .._. 1,1.0,•.;. . • f r‘ .. . ....,4 ,.. 1.\ ,. ,f.7•.,4,,19 rt. .per �,~ }.`..1..,.,. .'.. ..‘•. }Jr�F. •. ,: „ 4.til; { ,. s, +, b y Pe 1 4,,,,4 ‘ 4 . Aa; ';r •- { ;R Y� ,k-•.�r�t ••' F - -■C.'...u• ..,,Eyy ; .. 'is Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 3 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 40" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 2% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (90% site + 90% placement+ 90% contribution) _ 3 = 90% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 90% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 1149 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box(line 6) 1125.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree(Line 12)x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $72,730 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $1,178.22 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $1,180.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 8 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 19„ 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 3% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement+ 30% contribution) _ 3 = 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 283 12. Appraised trunk area increase (over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 259.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $19,038 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $154.20 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $150.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 9 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1.Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3.Trunk Diameter Measured at 54"above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 14" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 5% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement+ 30%contribution) _ 3 = 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 154 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 130.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree(Line 12) x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $11,040 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $149.03 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $149.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 10 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 90% 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54" above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 12" & 13" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 8% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement+ 30% contribution) _ 3 = 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1 482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 246 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box(line 6) 222.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12)x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $16,744 14. Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13) x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $361.66 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is$360.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 11 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1. Species Quercus aqrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 900/0 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54"above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 20„ 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 15% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site+ 30% placement+ 30%contribution) _ 3 = 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 314 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree(Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box(line 6) 290.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12)x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $20,960 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13)x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4)x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $848.86 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $849.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 12 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1. Species Quercus agrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 900/0 3.Trunk Diameter Measured at 54"above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 22" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 8% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site + 30% placement+ 30% contribution) _3= 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 380 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree (Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box(line 6) 356.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12)x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $25,052 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13)x Species rating (Line 2)x Condition rating (Line 4) x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $541.11 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $540.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Tree Appraisal Worksheet (Based on Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Edition ) CLIENT: Mr. Ramy Zaifman Tree No. 13 LOCATION: 111 Hacienda Drive, Arcadia 1.Species Quercus aqrifolia 2. Species Rating Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment. Consider variation from Species Classification? 900/0 3. Trunk Diameter Measured at 54"above grade. Note reason for any variation from 54". 5" & 17" 4. Condition Rating Notes on tree health and structure: 8% 5. Location Rating Based on average values for site, placement, and contribution = (30% site+ 30% placement+ 30%contribution) _3= 30% Notes on site, placement, and condition: 30% 6. Replacement Tree Size Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. 23.75 7. Replacement Tree Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 8. Installation Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for $1,482 the installed cost of a 60" box tree. 9. Installed Cost Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for the installed cost of a 60" box tree. $2,964 HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 10. Basic Price Based on guidelines provided in Species Classification and Group Assignment for a Group 3 tree. $62.00 11.Appraised Trunk Area Taken from Table 4.4, 9th Edition for single trunk trees. Multi-trunk trees? 247 12.Appraised trunk area increase(over 60" box) Trunk area of subject tree(Line 11) -Trunk area in 60" box (line 6) 223.25 13. Basic Tree Cost Increase in trunk area of subject tree (Line 12)x Basic price (Line 10) + Installed tree cost(Line 9) $16,806 14.Appraised Value Basic tree cost(Line 13)x Species rating (Line 2) x Condition rating (Line 4)x Location Rating (Line 5). (Note: we generally round to the nearest$10). $363.00 Notes: Actual Appraised Value rounded to the nearest$10.00 is $360.00! References International Society of Arboriculture. 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal. 9th Edition Champaign, IL 143pp. Western Chapter, International Society of Arboriculture. 1992. Species Classification and Group Assignment. Sacramento, CA. 23pp. HortScience, Inc. Mastering the Basics of Tree Appraisal Anaheim, CA Sept., 2001 Curriculum Vitae WILLIAM R.MCKINLEY—MCKINLEY&ASSOCIATES 1734 Del Valle Ave. Email: william@mckinleyarborists.com Work (818)426-2432 Glendale,CA 91208 Website: htt.://www.mckinle arborists.com/ Home(818)240-1358 SUMMARY of QUALIFICATIONS Practicing Consulting Arborist.Member of American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA).Certified Arborist,International Society of Arboriculture since September 30, 1999.I.S.A.Arborist#WE-4578A. Recognized Oak Tree Expert throughout Southern California.Prepare arborist reports for developers, homeowners and attorneys.Assess the landscape value of trees.Assess and identify hazardous trees in the landscape.Provided hillside and Oak Woodland landscape and irrigation recommendations.Provide expert witness testimony on arboriculture related cases.Public speaker and presenter at community service group meetings,homeowner's association meetings and speaker at professional seminars and conferences. Presenter at Trees,People and Our Urban Environment Seminar,March 2002.Arbor Day Guest Speaker, City of Glendale,March 2005.Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2010,Tree City USA Award Presenter—Glendale Arbor Day 2012,Arbor Day Guest Speaker,Glendale,March 2014. FULL TIME EMPLOYMENT HISTORY City of Glendale,Parks,Recreation & Community Services Park Services Manager-Contract Administration 2001-present Performs contract administration for Park Services Section.Manage grounds maintenance for sports fields, community buildings,parks,medians,and historic areas.Administers the City's landscape maintenance contract.Writes contract specifications.Administers the bidding process.Awards contracts to successful bidders.Conducts construction meetings and oversees the construction and inspection for these projects. Performs and assumes all former duties and responsibilities under the former Administrative Analyst position.Writes arborist reports.Hazardous tree assessment.Serves as expert witness in tree related cases. Administrative Analyst 1988-2001 Administer landscape maintenance contract for medians,reservoirs,pump houses and misc.areas. Administer and supervise the Division's Work Management System involving the scheduling and tracking of work and performance of over 50 full-time employees.Supervise one part-time data entry employee and supervise and coordinate with the California Conservation Corps,Boy Scouts and other community service volunteers in the parks.Supervise,monitor and report water and utility usage in the parks.Administer and supervise all tree planting projects and programs including the Arbor Day and Urban Forest Donation programs.Assist with budget preparation and acquisition of capital equipment.Prepare Capital Improvement Project specifications and assist with administering contracts.Administer the City of Glendale's Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Coordinate with Planning,Permit Services,Engineering, Building,Neighborhood Services and Fire Department to insure the care and protection of trees,both during and after construction. Review grading,construction,landscape and irrigation plans.Modify and approve plans as necessary to protect indigenous trees.Perform field inspections on hazardous trees and make recommendations to park staff and the public.Serve as code enforcement officer and paralegal during Administrative Office Hearings regarding Indigenous Oak Tree Ordinance.Perform tree and landscape appraisals.Served as special show and marketing consultant to the Glendale Rose Pruning and Garden Show Committee. Assistant Planner-Parks 1983-1988 Assisted in park inventory development and implementation of the Work Management System.Served as guest speaker at the National Parks and Recreation Conference on the subject of computers and their role in park maintenance.Supervised the Capital Improvement Project Construction at Pacific Park and Brand Park.Coordinated with and supervised California Conservation Corps.Crews in planting,staking and tying hundreds of trees as part of the Arbor Day Program.Served as Arbor Day Co-Chairman,Glendale Rose Pruning&Garden Show Co-Chairman and President of Glendale Beautiful.Served as Ways and Means Chairman C.P.R.S.District XIV. EDUCATION 1983 California Polytechnic University,Pomona Bachelor of Science Degree, Park Administration Graduated Magna Cum Laude,Grade Point Average:3.57 1983-Present CEU's-University of California,Landscape Contract Maintenance,Hazardous Tree Identification&Assessment,Specimen Tree Appraisal,Advanced Tree Appraisal Theory and Practice,Tree and Landscape Liability—Trees and the Law.Oak Tree Symposium Graduate,Knowledge of oak tree physiology and native plant habitat.ASCA 2007 Consulting Academy, National Arbor Day Foundation Graduate,Symposiums: Construction Around Trees;Trees and the Law.Recognized Tree Expert:City of Los Angles,County of Los Angeles,City of Pasadena,City of La Canada Flintridge,City of Burbank,City of Calabasas,County of Ventura,City of Santa Clarita. HONORS &ACTIVITIES 1999 - Present- Certified Arborist-International Society of Arboriculture 1996-1999-Secretary/Treasurer, C.P.R.S.Park Operations Section 1994-1995 - President, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1994-1995- Treasurer, Glendale Beautification Advisory Council 1992-1994 -Treasurer, C.P.R.S.District XIV 1993, 1994, 1995 C.P.R.S.Park Operations Scholarship First,Second and Third Year,Graduate,Pacific Southwest Maintenance Mgmt.School 1988-1990—President,Glendale Beautiful 1980, 1981 - Twice placed on Dean's Honor List 1982 - Who's Who in American Colleges and Universities 1978 - Recipient of Wayne Striker Memorial Scholarship 1975 - Awarded Eagle Scout Rank,Boy Scouts of America Member- American Society of Consulting Arborists(ASCA) Member - International Society of Arboriculture Member - Western Chapter,International Society of Arboriculture Member—Glendale Beautiful Past Member - National Arbor Day Foundation Past Member - California Oak Foundation REFERENCES Randall S.Stamen,Attorney/Arborist (951)787-9788 Susan&Gary Sims,Sims Tree Specialists (951)685-6662 Peter&Diana Harnisch,Harnisch Tree Care (626)444-7997 PROFESSIONAL SERVICE FEE Site Inspection - $100.00 per hour Consultation - $125.00 per hour Arborist Report - $150.00 per hour Public Hearing - $200.00 per hour Arbitration - $225.00 per hour Deposition - $250.00 per hour Court Witness - $350.00 per hour