HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 12a - Ad Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee
DATE: June 1, 2021
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council
FROM: Dominic Lazzaretto, City Manager
By: Michael Bruckner, Deputy City Manager
Candice Cheung, Assistant Director of Recreation & Community Services
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF PAUSING THE STUDY OF THE TINY SHELTERS
PROPOSAL AND ESTABLISHING AN AD HOC HOMELESSNESS
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Recommendation: Direct the City Manager to: (1) Create an Ad Hoc
Homelessness Advisory Committee that would provide a report and
recommendations within 60 days, and (2) not proceed with any
shelter options until such report is available
SUMMARY
Individuals experiencing homelessness are increasing throughout Los Angeles County.
Over the past several years, the number of homeless in Arcadia has also grown to
levels not seen in recent memory. In 2017, Los Angeles County voters approved
Measure H to help fund services to prevent and combat homelessness. The City has
adopted a Homelessness Plan, partnered with neighboring cities and other agencies to
address the crisis, and implemented first-in-kind programs like the Homeless Resource
Hub to assist those experiencing homelessness. More recently, the City submitted a
letter of intent to examine the possibility of developing a Tiny Shelters pilot project in
Arcadia.
Due to increasing community concern about homelessness and the Tiny Shelters pilot
program, on May 18, 2021, the City Council requested that an item be placed on the
June 1 agenda to consider halting further investigations into the Tiny Shelters pilot
program. The City Council also requested that the City Manager place an item on the
same agenda to discuss empaneling an advisory committee on homelessness to gain
further insight into community concerns and to develop comprehensive
recommendations to address this issue.
It is recommended that the City Council direct the City Manager to: (1) Create an Ad
Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee that would provide a report and
Creation of an Ad Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee
June 1, 2021
Page 2 of 5
recommendations within 60 days, and (2) not proceed further with any shelter options
until the Committee returns with its recommendations to the City Council.
BACKGROUND
Recognizing the impact of homelessness on individuals and communities throughout
Los Angeles County, in 2017 voters approved Measure H to fund services to prevent
and combat homelessness. Throughout the past five years, Arcadia has applied for
multiple homelessness grants to prevent and combat homelessness.
On August 7, 2018, the City Council adopted the Five-Year Homelessness Plan. The
Homelessness Plan addresses homelessness through several strategic goals, including
training first responders, strengthening the Coordinated Entry System, enhancing the
Emergency Shelter System, partnering with other cities to expand rapid rehousing, and
expanding the Countywide Outreach System.
On October 15, 2019, City Council approved and accepted a multijurisdictional
implementation grant with the City of South Pasadena for case management, including
a case manager, motel vouchers, and rapid rehousing in the amount of $292,200. This
partnership was developed out of necessity, as the cities did not meet the individual
service demand threshold to receive funding for homeless services alone. Throughout
2018 and 2019, as it became apparent that the County was unable to address the
service needs of the San Gabriel Valley, the San Gabriel Valley Council of
Governments (“SGVCOG”) took a more proactive and coordinated roll in applying for
Measure H funds and revising funding protocols so that monies more fairly flowed to all
areas of the County.
On October 20, 2020, City Council approved and accepted a grant from the SGVCOG
from Measure H funds to address homelessness in the City in the amount of $380,000.
The grant included encampment clean up, first responder outreach, emergency
resources, a full time Housing Navigator, administrative costs, prevention and diversion
funds, and the launch of the Homeless Resource Hub. The Homeless Resource Hub,
located in the Par 3 Golf Course parking lot, provides free showers, laundry facilities,
resources, first aid, meal, job training, and onsite case management one day per week
and has been successful at connecting clients to housing and other services needed to
get the unhoused off of Arcadia streets.
Providing case management and resources has helped individuals experiencing
homelessness; however, housing is still the primary means to help get individuals
experiencing homelessness off the streets. On February 16, 2021, the City Council
voted to submit a letter of intent to examine the possibility of developing a Tiny Shelters
pilot project in Arcadia. At the time, the City Council did not vote to proceed with the
project, but rather just to examine the viability of Tiny Shelters in Arcadia at the Peck
Park access road site. The Tiny Shelters pilot program would study the efficacy of
adding 15 or so shelters, food, restrooms, showers, possible laundry, case
Creation of an Ad Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee
June 1, 2021
Page 3 of 5
management, security, and other wrap around services individuals experiencing
homelessness need. In addition, it would be possible to relocate the Resources Hub to
the Tiny Shelters site. All program costs would be paid by grant funds.
On May 6, 2021, the City of Arcadia held a virtual Community Forum on Homelessness
to discuss the issue more broadly, and to hear community feedback on how to address
the issue holistically in Arcadia. During the forum, and in the days and weeks since, the
City received numerous questions and emails about the Tiny Shelters pilot program.
The City Council recognized that community concerns surrounding homelessness and
the Tiny Shelters pilot program are complex. Therefore, on May 18, 2021, the City
Council requested that City Manager place an item on a future agenda to discuss
pausing the investigation into the Tiny Shelters pilot program. In addition, the City
Council asked for an agenda item to consider empaneling an advisory committee on
homelessness to gain further insight into community concerns and develop
comprehensive recommendations to address this issue.
DISCUSSION
The Ad Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee would be empaneled to study the issue
of homelessness in Arcadia and address a wide variety of programs and services, as
well as funding available from federal, state, and local sources. While the Committee
would surely discuss the Tiny Shelters pilot program as part of its work, they would also
look at other programs and policy alternatives to provide recommendations on a
comprehensive strategy for addressing this difficult issue. It is expected that various City
Staff would assist in the Committee in its investigations, including the Police Chief, Fire
Chief, City Attorney, and any others needed to provide background information on the
magnitude of the issue in Arcadia and the options that might be available for the
Committee to consider. The City Manager and Director of Recreation & Community
Services would facilitate the discussions and attend every meeting.
In order to ensure that the City is addressing this issue with urgency, it is recommended
that the City Council authorize the City Manager to appoint members to the Committee.
The City Council would be encouraged to make recommendations of people that they
would like to see represented on the Committee. The City Manager would make all
efforts to ensure broad representation so that all points of view and various levels of
expertise on the issue of homelessness are included. This would mean having
representatives who have spoken out in favor and against the Tiny Shelters pilot
program as well as other homelessness programs in the City. It would also mean finding
residents from all parts of the City with as many age groups and backgrounds possible
so that it is truly representative of Arcadia.
The Committee will be subject to the Brown Act to provide the fullest extent of public
transparency possible and all Committee agendas and minutes will be made available
on the City’s website. The meetings will be open to the public for viewing the
Creation of an Ad Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee
June 1, 2021
Page 4 of 5
proceedings. If the Committee is interested, their work could also include surveys and
other data gathering efforts to obtain input from the larger community.
The Committee would have approximately 15 members in order to have a large enough
group to have all viewpoints represented, while remaining small enough to work quickly.
It is expected that all members would need to be City of Arcadia residents; however, if
the City Council wishes to expand membership to residents in the County
unincorporated areas surrounding the City of Arcadia, it can certainly do so.
To further ensure expediency, it is recommended that the Committee take no more than
60 days to study programs, services, alternatives, funding, and other strategies to
address the issue of homelessness in Arcadia. This will require commitment from the
Committee members as well as City Staff to meet regularly and turn information around
rapidly. This can be accomplished; however, if more time is needed, the Committee can
provide initial insights and seek additional time from the City Council to complete its
efforts. At the conclusion of the Committee’s work, a summary of their findings along
with any supporting recommendations would be submitted to the City Council for review
and consideration. Any programmatic proposals recommended by the Committee and
considered by the City Council will be studied in greater detail and shared with the
community for feedback to the greatest extent practical before adoption and
implementation.
During the period that the Committee would be doing its work, it is recommended that
the City refrain from taking any further actions on the Tiny Shelters pilot program. Once
the recommendations are known, the City Council can then decide whether to conduct
further study of the Tiny Shelters pilot program, abandon the idea, or approve it. It is
expected that the Committee will request information on the Tiny Shelters pilot program
as part of their work; staff would gather that as part of the mission of the Committee if
desired, but would not advance any applications with the SGVCOG while the
Committee is empaneled. It is very possible that the window for being able to accept the
current cycle of grants may pass during this 60-day period; however, it is far more
important for the community to have a unified vision for addressing homelessness and it
is also expected that future grant opportunities will be available in the near future to
address whichever approaches the Committee and the City Council ultimately approve,
so there is very little risk in delaying.
The issue of homelessness will not go away on its own and it requires local solutions
that are tailored to this particular community’s desires. The causes of homelessness are
as complex as the very real concerns surrounding them and a thorough, open, and
compassionate dialogue is the best approach to making strides in this area. Pausing the
review of the Tiny Shelters pilot program and establishing an Ad Hoc Committee on
Homelessness will make this possible.
Creation of an Ad Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee
June 1, 2021
Page 5 of 5
FISCAL IMPACT
The costs to empanel the Committee are likely to include staff time and some materials.
Sufficient funding is available in the City Manager’s Office and Recreation & Community
Services Department budgets to effectively resource the Committee.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council direct the City Manager to: (1) Create an Ad
Hoc Homelessness Advisory Committee that would provide a report and
recommendations within 60 days, and (2) not proceed with any shelter options until
such report is available.