HomeMy WebLinkAboutNOVEMBER 14, 1989
.
.
Planning Commission proceedings are tape recorded and on file in the office of the Planning
Department.
MINUTES
ARCADIA CITY PLANNING COMMISSION
REGUlAR MEETING
Tuesday, November 14, 1989
The Planning Commission of the City of Arcadia met in regular session on Tuesday, November 14,
1989 at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Arcadia City Hall, 240 West Huntington Drive,
with Chairman Larry Papay presiding. .
PLEDGE OF ALlEGIANCE
ROLL CALL:
PRESENT:
ABSENT:
MINUTES
MOTION
Commissioners Amato, Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
Commissioner Clark noted that on the last page of the Minutes, it should be "Foothill Jr. High" instead
of "First Jr. High".
It was moved by Commissioner Clark, seconded by Commissioner Szany to approve the
Minutes of November 24,1989 as amended. The motion passed by voice vote with none
dissenting.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Amato to read all resolutions
by title only and vvalve reading the full body of the resolution. The motion passed by voice vote
with none dissenting.
OTHERS AlTENDING:
Councilman Charles Gilb
61iy Ai-iorney-MlchaefMlffer
Planning Director William Woolard
Senior Planner Donna Butler
Associate Planner Corkran Nicholson
Associate Planner Wilfred Wong
Assistant Planner James Kasama
Secretary Silva Vergel
.
.
PUBLIC HEARING MC-89-D89
1 D2D Singing Wood
Chia Hsiung Un
Consideration of a modification for a 37'-0" front yard
setback in lieu of the 62'-6" average of the two nearest
developed lots (1004 & 1032 Singing Wood) for a
proposed new two-story residence.
The staff report was presented.
Staff stated that the subdivision was approved In May of 1988. A tree preservation plan was required
but they were not required to save any specific tree.
Mr. Woolard said that each Homeowner's Association (HOA), in their resolutions, are required to save
certain trees that have a diameter larger than 6"'and anything bigger will need HOA approval.
Councilman Gilb felt that they can build around the.tree and wouldn~t need any modification.
The public hearing was opened.
An-Chi Lee, 3711 Long Beach Blvd., Long Beach, showed the model of the proposed home and said that
they are trying to preserve the oak tree and the tree dictates the location of'the home which
necessitates the need for the modification. The proposed house is 6;600 sq. ft. and from the street
will look like a one-story home since it will be 5'.3" below street level. The HOA approved the
removal of the tree and he reassured the Commission thatthey will plant more trees to replace the old
oak tree. He explained'thal'lhey can't move the house back because of the tennis court and that would
mean that they would have to remove 2 oak trees. The maximum height of the building from the street
is 25'.
Robert Henkel, 1065 Singing Wood, Architectural Review Board (ARB), remarked that the two homes
on either side of this property have a setback 01'62'-6" and it would be odd to have this house
encroach into the front yard setback as proposed. This house .would not be iJ:1 compliance and would be
out of place with a 37'-0" front yard setback. Originally, the ARB looked at the existing house which
had a 40'-0" seiback but after demolition'the ARB realized that the new house would be out of place.
Mary Meeker, 1025 Singing Wood, was concerned that the builders are building for speculation and
thought that the modification would be detrimental to the area.
Alfredo Jose, 1004 Singing Wood, said that he is to the east of this property and said that in the
peginnlng he was in favor of the house but after being made aware ofthe modification on the setback
he is against it. The old house was a single-story home but this house will stand out with a front yard
'setback'rriuch lessthan'thelOldjacenrneighbors'horTles which'have'much greater setbacks:
Judy Draper, 939 Hampton, President of HOA, felt that it is not worth saving a tree and destroying a
neighborhood. At the time of the subdivision they were aware that the tree would be a problem.
Heidi Rosenbluth, 1001 Singing Wood, said that if the setback modification was approved it would
destroy the lines of homes.
Mr. Henkell, submitted a plot plan of the home which is being proposed next to this property which
shows the setbacks.
In rebuttal, John Piccari, 1020 Singing Wood, said that they never intended to ask for a modification.
They have worked with the,ARB before designing a house so that it would meet'all their concerns. the
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page 2
.
.
proposed house will be a two story home but will appear to be single story since it is 5'-0" below
street level.
There were no additional persons desiring to speak in favor of or in opposition to this item.
MOTiON
It was moved-by Commissioner Clark, seconded by Commissioner Amato to close the public
hearing. The motion passed by voice vote with none dissention.
In answer to questions from the Commission, Mr. Woolard said that the house met all of theARS's
requirements but not the City's.
Commissioner Hedlund felt that they should redesign the house to fit the lot and eliminate the need for
the modification and,they should save the tree.
Commissioner Clark agreed and said that he doesn't want them to deviate from Code and they should
comply with the 62'-0' setback, The house is not the same profile from the,streetas the house which
was torn down; it is a lot higher than the previous house.
Commissioner Amato thought that they should meet Code and that it should be enforced.
Commissioner Szany said tha,t although he feels for the owner and the architect who has gone through
such great length to draw the plans he thought that the modification is too severe.
Chairman Papay said that they should be able to design a house to fit on this lot. There should be
uniformity in the setbacks.
MallON
It was moved by Commissioner Clark, seconded by Commissioner Hedlund to deny MC 89-089
with the findings that it would not secure an appropriate improvement, or promote uniformity
of development.
ROll CALL:
AYES:
NOES:
Commissioners Amato, Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
Chairman Papay'noted'thatthe'reis Ifflve working'daY'appeal period after the adoption-of"the
resolution.
PUSLlC HEARING TPM 89-015
11836 Clark St.
Clark-Goldring, Inc.
Consideration of a tentative. parcel map to create two
lots from one lot.
The staff report was presented and the_public hearing was opened.
No-one spoke in favor of or in opposition to this item.
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page, 3
.
.
MOllON
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Amato to close the public
hearing. The motion passed by voice vote with none dissenting.
The consensus ofthe Commission was favorable.
MOllON
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Clark to approve TPM
89-015 subject to the conditions in the staff report.
ROLL CALL:
AYES:
r-oes:
Commissioners Amato, Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
Chairman Papay noted that there Is a ten day appeal period.
PUBLIC HEARING TPM 89-016
423 California SI.
Rebecca H. Lu
Consideration of a tentative parcel map for a 3'unit
residential condominium.
The staff report was presented and the public hearing was opened.
Robert W. Kirk, 423 California St., said that they will build three detached units ranging from 1400
to 1700 sq. ft. and they'will reside In tile larger unit. They are in agreement with all of the
condiUons in the staff report.
No one else spoke In favor of or in opposition to the tnis Item.
MOllON
It. was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Amato to close the public
hearing. The motion passed by voice vote with none dissenting.
The consensus ofthe"Commission.was favorable.
MOllON
It was moved by Commissioner Clark, seconded by Commissioner Amato to approve TPM 89-
016 subject to the conditions in the staff report.
ROLL CALL:
AYES:
IIOES:
Commissioners Amato. Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
Chairman Papay noted that there is a ten day appeal period.
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page 4
.
.
PUBLIC HEARING TPM 89-017
450 Genoa St.
Steven Chow
Consideration ofa tentative parcel map for a 2-unit
residential condominium.
The staff report was presented and the public hearing was opened.
Mark Chow, 603 S, Russell, Monterey Park, stated that they are in agreement with all of the
conditions in the staff report. He noted that his brother is the developer and he will be living in one
of the units.
No one else desiring to speak in favor of or in opposition to the proposed use.
MOTION
It was moved by CommissionerSzany, seconded by Commissioner Clark to ciose the public
hearing. The motion passed by voice vote with none dissenting.
The Commission liked the project.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Clark to approve TPM 89-
017 subject to the conditions in the staff report.
ROLL CAli.:
AYES:
f>,()ES:
Commissioners Amato,. Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
Chairman Papay noted that there is a ten day appeal period.
PUBLIC HEARING Z 89-004
The area bordered on the north by
Orange Grove Avenue, on the east by
Oakmeadow Road, HaCienda Drive and
San Carlos Road, on the south by
Foothill Blvd, and on the west by
Baldwin Avenue.
Consideration of a zone change from R-Q & D 15,000
to R-O & D 22,000.
The staff report was presented and the public hearing was opened.
No one spoke in favor of or in opposition to this item.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Amato to ciose the public
hearing. The motion passed by voice vote with none dissenting.
The Commission thought that it would be an appropriate change.
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page 5
.
.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Clark to recommend approval
of 2-89-004 to the City Council.
ROLLCALL:
A '(ff,:
t\O:S:
Commissioners Amato, Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
PUBLIC HEARING REVISED TM 48199
49-53 Fano St.
I.U. L1m
Consideration of a tentative map for an 8-unit
residential condominium.
The staff report was presented and the pUblic hearing was opened.
II Ung L1m, 45 Fano, said that he is in agreement with all of the conditions in the staff report.
There was no one else desiring to speak in favor of or in opposition to this item.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Clark, seconded by Commissioner Amato to close the public
hearing. The motion passed by voice vote with none dissenting.
The consensus of the Commission was favorable.
MOTION
It was moved by CommissionerSzany, seconded by Commissioner Amato to approve TM
48199 subject to the conditions in the staff report.
ROLL CALL:
A '(ff,:
t\O:S:
Commissioners Amato, Clark, Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
CMifman Plipay nbted-thantfere is a-ten day appeal period.
PUBLIC HEARING REVISED TPM 89-018
1000 Fourth Ave.
Kenneth Huang on behalf of
Romani Construction
Consideration of. a tentative parcel map to create two
single-family lots from one lot.
The staff report was presented and the public hearing was opened.
Kenneth Huang, 8369 Windon, San Gabriel, the engineer of the project stated that they are in
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page 6
.
.
agreement with all of the conditions in the staff report. In response to a question from the
Commission Mr. Huang said that the special 35'-0' setback off of Fourth Ave. would not be a problem
and they will comply with it. In response to a question from the commission, he noted that the two
new homes will be consistent and compatible with the other houses on the cul-de-sac.
Ilene Steven, 1000 S, Fourth, said that although she was notified of this public hearing, she was not
noticed at an earlier date when Chris Construction was proposing a development and asked that it be
researched.
There was no one else desiring to speak in favor of or in opposition to this item.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Clark to close the public
hearing. "The motion passed by voice vote with none dissenting.
Commissioner Szany commented that he likes projects that provide large lots, and he would like to see
lhese houses go in without modifications.
Chairman Papay indicated that they'are on record as frowning on setback eilcroachfnentsunless there
is a good and compelling reason.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Clark to approve TPM
89-018 subject to the 09nditions in the staff report.
ROLLCALL:
AYF:S:
I\OES:
Commissioners Amato, Clark, Hedlund,.Szany, Papay
None
Chairman Papay noted that there is a ten day appeal period.
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION
None
. -
- - - - - - - --. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
RESOLUTION 1425
A resolution granting CUP 89-017 for the expansion of
an existing service station at 4 W. Foothill Blvd.
Mr. Woolard read the title of the resolution.
MOTION
It was moved by Commissioner Szany, seconded by Commissioner Clark. to adopt Resolution
1425 to formally affirm the decisions of October 24, 1989, reflecting the findings of the
Commission and the votes thereon.
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page 7
.
.
ROLL CALL:
AYES:
!as:
Commissioners Amato, Clark. Hedlund, Szany, Papay
None
Chairman Papay noted thal'lhere is a five working day appeal period.
MATTERS FROM COUNCIL
t-tme
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -,- - - - -
MATTERS FROM COMMISSION
In. response to Commission's concerns, staff said that usually the public is unaware of setback
violations until they approach the City. He also said that the development of condominiums on south
Santa Anita and California are consistent with the General Plan.
Commissioner Hedlund felt that a study and a possible teXt amendment should be done for R-2 and R-3
properties that are not suitable for development because of their size and don't fit.
Chairman Papay thought that this would leave the City with a greater potential for law suits because
it would be Interfering with the owner's economic situation.
MATTERS FROM STAFF
tIklne
ADJOURNMENT
8:45 pm
i.(;ll/VY~:'>1_) b'l'i;1-&T.l4.
Secretary, Arcadia Planning Commission
Arcadia City Planning Commission
November 14, 1989
Page 8