HomeMy WebLinkAbout0588
r
i
RESOLUTION NO. 588
.' 1 ~-l i--:J rl "~)'J ~ f) 1 j
I ,', I ',1 I , ,:',:, I
ll--' ,- .j "' ' 'Cl '
, . - r J I
['j ,-, i '..1
W 6~l.h, I
."
L'. " ;
" I , j' f
'."0d d
.
.
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY PLANNING
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA,
CALIFORNIA, DENYING WITHOUT PREJUDICE
THE GRANTING OF A CONDITIONAL USE
PERMIT TO CONSTRUCT A GARAGE FOR THE
REPAIR AND SERVICE OF AUTOMOBILES ON
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 412 NORTH FIRST
AVENUE IN SAID CITY.
WHEREAS, there was filed with this Commission on the 14th day
of April, 1966, the application of P and F Motors for a conditional use
permit to construct a garage for the repair and service of Porsche and
Volkswagon automobiles on property located at 412 North First Avenue in
.
the City of Arcadia, County of Los Angeles, State of California, more
specifically described as follows:
Lot 3, Block 83 of Santa Anita Tract, per map
recorded in Book 15, page 89, of Miscellaneous
Records, in the office of the County Recorder of
said County;
and,
WHEREAS, after due notice as required by the Zoning Ordinance
of said City, a public hearing was held on the matter by and before this
Commission on April 26, 1966, at which time all interested persons were
given full opportunity to be heard and to present evidence;
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA, HEREBY DETERMINES AND RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. That subject property is in Zone M-l. That the
neighboring uses are a mixture of residential and business. That the
.
proposed development would contain two thousand two hundred forty (2,240)
square feet with an entrance off an alley twenty (20) feet wide, with
parking provided in the rear.
-1-
588
~
.
.
.
SECTION 2. That the subject property contains only one-
half of the area required as a site within the M-l P.I.D. Zone, and
is adjacent to property potentially available which together with
subject property would meet the area requirements of Zone M-l P.I.D.
That the granting of a conditional use permit under such circum-
stances on such a substandard site would be contrary to the plan
for the area, and therefore detrimental to other properties and
improvements in the area.
SECTION 3. That for the foregoing reasons, this Commis-
sion hereby denies, without prejudice to the reconsideration of the
matter, the requested conditional use permit for construction of a
garage for the repair and service of automobiles on the above-
.
described property.
SECTION 4. The Secretary shall certify to the adoption
of this resolution.
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing resolution was adopted
at a regular meeting of the City Planning Commission held on the
lOth day of May, 1966, by the following vote:
AYES: Commissioners Ferguson, Hanson, Parker, Norton
and Kuyper
NOES: None
ABSENT: Commissioners Golisch and Lauber
W. E. KUYPER
Chairman
. ATTEST:
WILLIAM PHELPS
Secretary
-2-
588
.
.
1 .<.: >J/,~, j rJ ,-,/;{,(;; '.. ';:/0:
IL e" - (I ~l'<'~ , '
:U-~ -~ '~~.< "'~t. ~\.vC>v".,~' 1't~~ l
,L~t,._) k :Ci -" . " A l
~~A'~I 'I' i ',,' """ ,.(~
"-- -.... I' "'-."'.- .-. \
/
-, ~L. '--:'_('-~\I\_
~~ ~~, ';, _ " (' ""~." "
I '-' ~', Ii"'l '. i "c,
SECTION 2. That the subject property contains,only one-'alf
\
of the area required as a site within the M-l P.I.D. zon~, That the
.<<;...u, ../-eM'/'" .M.e"""~
granting of a conditional use permi ~ . <n. \:!lJ11 on such a substandard
site would be contrary to the plan for the area}and therefore detrimental
to other properties and improvements in the area.
.
..
.'
.
.
.
April 26, 1966
TO:
PLANNING CO~illISION
FROM:
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE APPLICATION - C,U.P, 66-10
412 NORTH FIRST AVENUE
ZONE M-I P.I.D.
APPLICATION
The application was filed in the name of P and F Motors for the purpose
of constructing a garage for the repair and service of Porsche and
Volkswagon automobiles.
PRESENT ZONING AND LAND USE
.
Attached is a map of the surrounding zoning. The subject property is a
vacant Loc in Zone M-l. The uses to the north are a partially vacant
Lot with an old structure which has served as a residence, a service
,station and real estate office, ano the proposed freeway route. To
the east is a mixture of older single family residential and multiple
residential useS. To the south, fronting on First Avenue, are a number
of commercial uses. The property immediately to the south is an ex-
ception. There is an older single family residence on this property.
On the two easterly corners of La Por~Street are two garages. The
property to the east fronting on First Avenue is vacant except for one
Lot developed with single story multiple residential use,
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
The proposed development would be to construct a garage containing
2,240 square feet. The entrance to the garage would be off an alley
20 feet wide. Two double doors 20 feet wide would face this alley and
parking would be provided in the rear. The proposed development meets
all the requirements for Zone M-l except the Lot area requirement.
ANALYSIS
.
The garage proposed at this location is one that can be compatible with
the future development of this area. The M-l zoning would permit this
type of use providing a conditional use permit is granted. The site
development would consist of a landscaped front yard which would have
the same appearance from the street as any future industrial use. The
opening to the garage off the alley is desirable because the repair
operations would not be visible from the street.
Of importance to the granting of the use permit is the type of operation
and reputation of the two applicants. The present garage is located at
22 North Fourth Avenue, Arcadia. The garage maintained by the applicants'
is re::ognized by the Staff as one of the most orderly operation s of'itS/":'
type ~n the City. (
,}
.
.
,C,U.P. ' 66-10
April 26, 1966
Page Two
.
The Staff is of the op1n10n that building and operation proposed, will be compatible
with general plan of the area, will not be injurious to the property or improvement in
the zone Or vicinity, and that its location on First Avenue, south of Colorado
Boulevard, gives the site adequate access for the traffic generated by the use,
Furthermore, the development will bring new construction to an area in need of re-
development and can set the pattern for desired garage development in the future.
RECOMMENDATION
The Planning Department recommends approval subject to the following conditions:
1.
That complete working drawings in substantial compliance with the
approved plans, be submitted to the Planning Department for approval.
2.
That all other requirements for Zone M-l be complied with, excepting
that of lot size,
3.
That 10 feet be dedicated for the widening of First Avenue.
.
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
~.-)I lAM PHELPs;.onning Director
C('- '//"- (f
.)-1-""":) , ((//-l,...A..-T"/ (
LEWIS C. POLLARD, JR. V
Senior Planner
.
o
,
1OO-;O",ootlCl"O 2" l'I".=lOI~O:oaSo:>>J"O:1050.!ll)SO.!lOI-'I.n-
~ 2. '\,4" IIi)' 11'(;101 :Ul IU'l Inl ItU1 U'l 1411 (Ul l>>J {UI ZO 9 ~
'3 31 30 29 Z8 27 ZG 252:4 Z! ZZ ZI --4~off~
~ ~ 32 ~ : r=., M ~ 18 ~ ~
(i
T ..
M"I
.......-
/'
co
O"N
- i
II
-
-
~
I\O'U..AN
~
\9
')
, ,
U
~
.. ~~;.~: .. .. .. '0 Y.
_ ,..... ..~..~.~ Z~ 21; &; . ; U Z1 2.1 ~ 19
... I 3Z.......-..;;;:: t, Z~~ s ~I....
~ . ~.. ~~ ..1"1 - ~ to E .
~ 'f).I:''':~1-~~ 'j ;'
~ .0, ~'A~'" U :i ""e.
~ "'Ci =':'9. "{ - 0::'''
~ o~~z'-' ~ . ~ t e 3; 10 II IZ l'~~h
~~l I ;It,f" . ~~ .... (1'J1{14.)IUI15l1 I~'::-:;
eo a_\'IIII'I' ~ 1-", ....,., ~ ~ ~ ~ ~o '0 ,.a 9! jl; t:.O
~ ~ ".... "'-. "" AVE. :i
eo ~EJ,ln,. ~ '" 50!lo 'J":~'J'O" ,., co c;.o
~ (llell 1,"1 ,',', ,.,.,,~ D,Zl:- _ 20 .
?o ~1I 1~13S)~ Zl" .....
:::~3'l.e ~ Z9 2& d Zto Z~ Z4. .. .. " B :::
. ,,,"-,,. ' c: . ~ ~'~ '~:'. ~ ~;>!. ~
~ i}hll-,,: s .$ i:~ " ,,~"I~~!~'
~ ~j!2 ~_\"". 7 .,~: ''''0' IZ 0'" ""',, "." ~
~ll.l~1 _ _r"" }fl 1)11:;! .l"Sl 51)1111)" j 1& I' "-
.. 80 :g~t :\;~'I~"" ~ 1.- JI' ...... I"D S.. 11"'" ~"":>. "-
:. : ... "w'n" :. ~._, ,...._. J'''.'I' MJ" N DRIVE ...
::.A... 11 t-uW ~I:T
at> (lGn3G lf~I: i~: ~l D I~I;~ {~T.hli~l44' I~GI~llfl;~1~41ti.D' l.:i;l~~~"~ ~
:::: ,)5 ~(~ ~I 30 29 2811':,2' Z5 24 Z3 Zl .l.tO;r-,;: . "-
_ ___ _ '.'_11 : 11 : I ~ '
.. 31~,: f.;I, I~ r.-' /:.~ ;: ,,~:::
sveJe.c:.t Sl~ I~u;-",~I
~ COLO 'l ~
-.:.. "_ .1!l1' "'0 1-'0 ~ ~o ~o ~ sa $0 ~o !JO so I"" Sf f, :/:{I"'1) I.' ~21 ~o '~
lClo ..)4 1llll111t1 Ill' It,\ (~Ol IMI {U' {Ul {.&eol (fO) ".J (UI 20 ~ ~ J(. nil (liD, (nll
Ir.\ \1., nel Q ~ _
Ji~ H 31 ~o Z~ 2821 ZIi. 25 l:4 Z~ 22 21 19 !~, .2 :~-35 I ')}.)2. 31
gi.)l ~ I~t-.., =" : IB ~~ ;; M ...
~~. ~ v_II\O:fJp . 171;~~_ "l.J'
t.J :!~2 4 5 " ~ 8 '3 10 II tl. 13 14 ItO~:i: W ~~~4 .5 '" 'r 9 10 II 12 I~ 14 I)~
~ >. _~ .. ~.. jut!
'i( 0"' USl U,l In) nl "11 1m e.l} (.,1 .5) 1511 m l'~1_!5 Wi! <( I...~ 11(I01;lI/1l~ 11.1 ?1l OTTl 0"1 nUl (I,.) 1-4)) 1m "'l Inl IJn
... :01 I",f. so !i0 '0 'Q ~ ll\tl ~o .so 50 ~o I..... 1'1 .. ,"0 ....~ ;... I.... 50 !to !H' !I<) 50 )l) ~o 'In -!II'" M SO
" g LA PORTE ~ ~ ST.
~. I .O~~':'O :,,~ 0 .0'0 to ~ ),1." ._ 60 (;;j:;-' IJIlI so 'UIIG I!lOIR)O DO 0 ~11Ml ~
.'301" 10' InJ 'm -'Ill e!lll"" (6')(.,,1 :IOII~I t"y,t1...jIl~ :f'\::; ~m~'.ilflla) : -ltell-ISII'-'l.I!I"I'lltl 118l1lnll"1 1501
l\p ~ ~ : (\41 .&/ ("I __ _ : 1"1
~~ "'Z8~ Z1c. ~6 z:; Z4 Z3 ZZ A21 ZO 19 17 ~a:: 5. 35 !~3~ 32 3,1 ~O 29 2:8 Z7 c~ ~s Z4 ::3 ZZ
. "'<' ,_ -~~... . I AA _ , "
~,~.' ~~/ "~,~_l.." ::: =-- ~ I. ~.. .va -" -, . : '- 19,:
_ ~~"<.".r 'L ,'... ',;i-i~;'?~~ii~:~
~t:J~~""~~;!i,!:~"~I,~,~, :: ~~ ';~:~~~"~'} ~~,~" "" ~" 17~.
'" 9 I (II} S a ~)-~ r,"1 I!~ 12tl 'By p:..,:; 13 0 ,,:- I I lllll In) (Its) Iltll unl Onl 11"1 1.0 ~fJ IW 'f'1 1m 1
:00 "'X ru -'CI n ',," .....,.'lO 5CI f;0 ~ 1'1" III 60 ~Q IMl~' fO .50 !l0 ~ 50 lW) :;Q .so lW) 50 )0 50 OII,l,~ Si 1. CoO ~
..m~!"~!1.:,'''' 5Ti~IJ05EPH 3,: 5T.; f-
:~".i"'~ 1,~,.,~III" ..~" '_"0Il>D:l~el ~~ co =~' .%.1,. ,., I' ~.._ i-:r.~.~. ZI ;: Sl ao
~.I'o... ' ..... fU4J I~ft~~ 1"';::\ :\ lt~\ I':'~' ''''~'' 11;'~1 '0 l~:) -;1 I~l ,-I,!,
C}.. ~- ~ . Ie --- ""~ 1!.,.8 -
= Z" ZS ZA "6; '>... J90 ff ~ .~~ I ~ . ,1.' : ~~?=351- 33 3Z 31 ~ Z9lf8 l7, ZiD Z$ 24 Z~ 22 ZO g :
.. ~', ~;;~~~ ~r '~c~ :14!$1 u =3.341....; I,.~ - ~ 19 ~
: 3 ..... ?? fll0: -9J:-~ .. ~~ ,
;~ Z ,~.( ";"'I-f~~:~';:"', oS?, ~
.: I ("liD) tJl '11 IUl "1'11.l.~; I to'" '- "'.:._
\00.' 1,.'0'0 ~"!lD ~o :>0 I'!>~ 1T I~O
SANTA-CLARA." ,
~
IM-l
L.O"''''HA
o !>Il ~f'I ,,,
nil lilt 1)(. III IUJ
30 2.9~ ZIl 2.1 2'-
-t.~~~. ....
BLVD,:
'" '" "r~"'-~ .---)
,,!... "t
JUlI5QlIl4lf .... -.- .-1
2':. l4 2~ '~~r, tl
i ~~ . , .1
...;( . ' ~ ":' . :
--.,
\8.~:
17 ~;" &J
~-I,~ !~ i(
Z\IU ~
21) ~ ~
1
'"
on ,-It
9 10
CIUl
!l~ 50 ~ )0
l:i 18 ~ ~
II Ie I~ 1~J.~,5- -411----:-
ISll \1m {l41l (5~)lt~'7J 16- ~ -
"0 500 'Co I" s:~ toO_
S1\ 3~ ~ ::::::
1~:0l ~':ll~~ 15~ :,1-1," 18 a ~ ~
I' ~::
L.~.....
IiOS2"
Is:H (1)0
o z C
4 5 to 7 8
/111)
~
o ,
.
,
S~P.-E~R,R
~
~~
341'" ;';;
..~ 31
>Z
" so
5<1141" ...
20 ~i:
19 ~
~ "
7O}(:71
'" Z.
" "
.. "
t,) 10)
>027
2.5 24 23 ZZ ZI
:::.. C~li- ,
1&
I-
~
..
~e. J
~~ '2
~1l' I
s
r
'4~'.7'
I" ii911
If I'} ~ii nl e"l )11
1,I,l)O.5().!i(I Jl.o:lD
OJ
~
17
.
.
9 10 II 12 I~ 14
\~ :
1~'~I:;l 2~
l<l ~ J.o 50
.. "
WHEELER
ON
Ole
34IS1,'
"
"
.10 ~.5<l a
'"
29 za Z'J Z"
~ 1-1,1"
'0
D'D.50 .!j.C)
(SOl
25 24 Z~ Z2: 21
-,'::;;
fill ,...
l,u1
"'
" >0
19;6::
.
.,
18
.
I~
.
.
, IU LV
, .
~ 7 ,,,1 9 10 It
~):) eu) ml (J~l (!1l (.11
. .
, ,
I:~,
ltli15'.:'.~
..
t ~7T
14 ,,-l~~
,.
.'
I
Ztl~
~71
. 5
lI$)ml
o
<0;
.~
-
-
~
HUNTINGTON
J!( JTIIJI' I/A~ N
:;: ~ 341"" ~ X> ,., .101,~' ~.. :>13 ,. f;O ~
(141 161 {II'I' (leil {'~ la1l r~~l (u) (A.~ e!1l
:::; ,)3 31 ~Q. U ?'ltZ~1 p.' t:~ CUi ~~) 22
I 1:1'1 \~.l 2' 25 14
~ 'E: Jl. ,,~ --...
"n'.'''zoln :ll
~' 19 ..
, .
1:1 t& ::
:::'@"3: 0
:!:~1 2: 4!1"
~II ii< l(!I~i m\ ~~l tIll
. ~o -''' ,...
~ rr ~AS.
f.,llCttl:1
7 6 9 10 II 12 I~ t4 16 ;;E~'.'
tom (1') i,]} {S1l (41) U5' (5'0 frn ~-- "
.s.o ,... 5<1 S<l 50 .:loCI 30 ".. .I,n lloU.t .0
. .' ~ I~:J
aT" C T ~"tl",~''''''
.~z- ,,.. 1& 9 10, II IZ 13 ,. I' ~-I;' -;;..~
- 43""lUl F
~ I a (lltllb1 nlnnll([)t1 1"'(I.n}04,,(f5nn~') nl~~
'x,~ 'DJQ lIO'D ",150"'~ ""!JD'O~Wlll")''''
"
U
0/
IBSE ~
ALTA
o
,
o
.
.aa 0 i
In ~ l'~!2I1:'~::'~l!:r-"; , ~ !to '0 [50 ~.. ~ U t ,;:. -
3' 11'" Ilel':le--Il:!:t~ O~(l 1 IKl .u) ''':'1'11~11501 ul (lUl z~~' ~~
lli'illall ;:.::.~Il ~~ ---
3' 33 HI "1\ 3f' l? lB Z7 Z" 2'5 24 23 2Z ~_~
.34 ~ : I I :r: ~ r=:"\.. , It) g :::
ST.
.
~
Z
<
.
L., I,~'--' ~ I7g""~
10 --
. 9'I~nn II 12 I~ 14 liD:; ~
iUlI un 'm CUI em (UI '!l,""--
~1.,...,!lO ~o .... 5<> :10 1.1"5.~
<:
.
~
.
~
..
~
,..
G ~~, "~.~ ~~:~ ,z..b''\~ ,~: __:;.: ~
11rftl1iltl5l) 1m (",ntI41111451111511 m II.'
~ !'II ~ so '0 liD !I.. I..., '0 ~ ..., llUl,)i
..
"'s.
_~-3-~
k'-@l. .
~ 11' 1111'1 tll91
, _::: 1~.I..o.BD
.
=; 2 4"
(II) on
a 1-l.t.",,!SO ~
G 7
(111 tnl
"''''
I
BONITA
o
,
ST.
3
~
Z
~
.. 1,.(0"", 'D !l0 ::10 .J" :;~ Yl ~ _~ so ~oi
~ Jot (I~I ('11 en) (HI ml lJ.oI) m} IUJ (") CUI em
:: g 3' ~l 30 29 2B 21 Z" Z!1 Z4 Z3 ZZ 21
:;~ ao
::tt .50 ,.. .~ !l0 !I<I !kI ~ll !\.ell:!" !lC' ""'''j ~. b
c~.. UlOlln.' UJ51 (I,DI l~l mal ~1~1\ 14~:III'l;I~OI tI~ 1(l~,l ""I'~1 ". ... Z
~ ~2 3.1 ~ l.9 2:6 Z1 2{, i.:r; Z4 2~ 22 (ilio :: 0
u
1 1:::\ , '" : ~
li.':,.
=: ~ .!T ZlS
0;011 a:
18 ~~ ii:
'zo
,.
:: ~ 3<e
~
~
~~ J4
r-I ,/ =--
i \:: !, =-' 1 17 ~~
7 8 " 10 II IZ. I~ 14 u; fi~
em (I" (II) CDI Ull "" (.It' m ~1:1!Sfri't:,
...."'.til",..!/ ..
. Ii · ' / ,'1/ .J, I $~ '. ';'"
: - .,~.... ;..-/....1
~ a 1 4 5 " , 8 9 10 II I;: 13 14 IS <1>1" (;)::
':i-al 1111 lnl'l utn (1111 (1m I)J:I l'l1ll~11 I." 11M It"'. i' !"Il ~\1l.:":!.
110:' ", -... " .0 r8~ 50 .~ r....I_ . "n ,,' ~,,~ ~.,. .,~ L-
~~~,
~~ gez
~
I~I -' G
/liio on
" "
'"
SiI III
J
2E
L
~
r
,~
I ....0.
t ~...
I ~
-
o
.
~
.......
...~-
-
~
~
3
lIQTI!.:-
1I.1f" .1 ,...
10DDI
0PM':"lY:
(;) ,,"K
@""'BI
<!> . "IO-'~
CDU' '", n
<
..
.
.
.
. ~
Id lI#"'''"f,otJ (OtZ.
!'t~'6f WIl't-1>J IN"
' i
10' ~A"'~17
Fli'DJoIt YArlO
j
,c;v.p. G:.~-IO
.
.
NO rz 11-1
~Irz~t
Avts-JJUe-
;n
~
~S'
zoO --t---- "....,..
----J
"1
~~~(--.
"
'"
"
-(
\f
'2
;<
1:/
"
.".
~
Goo'rllc:,f1 MA",ONa:( w~
<:::::::J
:;3....5'
>
r
r
~
-<.
,....
~
1:1.
~
~
','
loot AllM fnfOfU. lIWlCoAflotJ or,719 .
.. .. Af1!.1t II ",(.2A5'
~ Arl#. of E'\),j..",.a4 z.,2Jlo(J
% Of "'-"',Ci1\/'llMtA~DW. 31%
I'AIO(IIJ' ltIItl" (".#BIDII,).I ffla. lK
4'/5 . of fk>olt NUA,.
~ o(1r -
~t..ot e~ArJ
f'7flOr?o~t-r7 C,AflAc"e.
J.l.12. N, ~Irz~ A.vf" - V#f 9, ~I-I<., 8', ~MJtA AtJlfA1'~
.- -,~_.._- ~...
, , ,
P $ IF' 1Ml[)J1l~~S, '
5lt:PAoIR AN 0 ~lCE- OF POQ5C.H AND IoiOL.Y.SWA6&W oCAQ'&
,~~'(~I/~ '
t ,. $b~( ~\
i/. ~
, \ ~
l "'" ~
...... ......~~--~~~-~~J~ ~~
'it ........ ........ --- ,. s::::::-;-'".,.........:-;=:..
........ ...... --- ""'-' -==--.-~~:::-
~~~ ........... _~~__ - - .~S~
_.t:~_~~ - '" .....:~;. -l.:-'~"
.:~-:;"~- ........ :"'.. ~-~
,
.
i
i~-
l.
,
I
I
I
i
I,
I
i
,
''''\
'-,-
~
-~,
,"-
-.......'
~.,.
I,
. a
o
.
/
"'.xl:O-" MA70>JTZY
e..cc..K WAu.b
B8lJ 4'Z
~
'"
-~f'H2'Gt - _,,,,V~,
.
.
.
c..V.p.. ~ Go - I 0