The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About0647 . . . RESOLUTION NO, 647 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION ~ <0 ~- t;- OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, DENYING THE GRAN~ING OF A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO MAKE STRUCTURAL ALTERATIONS TO A SERVICE STATION LOCATED AT 201 EAST LIVE OAK, WHEREAS, Mobil Oil Company, as lessee of real property located at 201 East Live Oak Avenue, has applied for a conditional use permit to make structural alterations to an existing service station on property. iocated at said address, which property is more particularly descr1.bed as follows: The porti.on of Lot 55, Tract No. 13217 in the City of Arcadia, as recorded in Map Book 264, Pages 26 and 27, in the office of the County Recorder of Los Angeles County, State of California, described as follows: . Commencing at the Northwest line of Live Oak Avenue (100' wide) 76.34' from the Northeast line of Lot 55 then North 90 50'45" West 101.25' then South 890 04' 45" West t,o the East line of Second Avenue then South on said East line and Northeast on said Northwest line to the point of beginning; and WHEREAS, after due notice as required by the zoning ordinances, a pUblic hearing was held on the matter by and before this Commission on April 23, 1968, at which time all interested persons were given full opportunity to be heard and to present evidence; NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, HEREBY DETERMINES AND RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. That said application was filed with respect . to a nonconforming ,service station site to make a number of struc- tural changes and additions as set forth in the application. That the proposed landscaping does not comply with established standards; proposed and existing light standards are in excess of proper height limits; and location of and provisions for screening of the rest rooms are not jn conformance with the Arcadia Municipal Code. -1- 647 ,/ , .~ . . SECTION ~!. That for the foregoing reasons this Commission hereby denies the I'equested conditional use permit for structural alterations on a nonconforming service station on the above des- cribed property. SECTION 3. The Secretary shall certify to the adoption of this resolution. I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing resolution was adopted at a regular meeting of the City Planning Commission of the City of Arcadia held on the 14th day of May , 1968, by the fol- lowing vote: AYES: Commissioners Godfrey, Kuyper, Parker and Lauber NOES: None . ABSENT: ABSTAINING: Commissioners Cahill and Stewart Commissioner Livingston ;:Zf'~_ f ,/~~ Chairman I ATTEST: Secretary . -2- 647 ~ . . . April 23, 1968 . TO: PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: PLANNING DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 68-6 201 E. LIVE OAK MOBIL OIL STA TlON APPLlCA TION This application is filed by the Mobil Oil Corporation, lessee of real property located at 201 East Live Oak Avenue,. ZONING AND LAND USE The subject property is in Zone C-l. The property is bordered by R-3 to the north and C-l to the east. The 3 remaining corners of the intersection (Live Oak & 2nd, Avenue) are zoned C-2. . PROPOSED USE The applicant proposes In continue the present use of the existing service station and upgrade the facilities as indicated: . Scope of New Work General Contractor 1. Building Facade Lighting: 2' 6" Sheet metol overhang with indirect lighHng under eave, 2. Pegasus disc: 4' 0" P plastic disc with interior lighting (MobWOil Company ins igriia), Pegasus disc to be placed on 3' 0" x 9' 0'" sheet metal wing wall. 3. Building Legend: 16" upper case and 9" lower case plastic letters, reading Mobil Service. Legend to be placed centered over lube b<;1Y. 4. Asphalt patch and sealcoat asphalt. 5. Cobra lighting (2): Yard lighting at approaches (16' 0" high pole). Remount (2) existing on new I. D. sign. ' , 6. Concrete Pad: Raise concrete pad at tanks 2" to be flush with asphalt grade ond replace one concrete pad. 7. I.D. Sign: 12' 0" Mobil sign. 8. Yard bumpers: Remove existing yard bumpers and install new precast concrete yard bumpers. ' 9, Install new heater in Sales Office. 10. Electrical Panel: Increase capacity of panel to carry increased lood, 11. Rest Room Refurbishing: Up grade, new fixtures, steel partitions, painting, etc. 12, Island Light Fixture: Install island light.f ixtures ov er pl1l1 p island, 13. Planters: Masonry planters as shown on plot plan. . Steel Contractor I. Overhead Doors: Instoll (2) aluminum overhead doors in lube bay, 2. Install 5' 0" x 10' 0" X 5' 0" steel trash enclosure. 3. Sheet Metal Doors: Nev.- rest room doors. s~ (; Lf1 ;I; . . . . . Conditional Use Permit 68-6 201 E. Live Oak Mobil Oil Station April 23, 1968 Page 2 Painting Contractor 1. Eliminate Red Bend: Paint out red base on building, and red stripe on canopies. 2, Paint scterior of building. Cabinet Contractor 1. Install Murlin Package (sheet metal cabinets), in the lube room and sales room. Glazier 1. Repair broken window in sales room, Landscaping Contractor 1, Landscape planters. ANALYSIS The proposed request to upgrade the existing' service station will not adversely affect the surrounding properties and will bring the site more closely into a conformity with the Arcadia Municipal Coda. The interseetion of LlveOak and Second Avenue has a competitive service station on each corner, There is an'Oronge Julius stand to the east of the Mobile Station and a single residence'on R-3 property immediately to the north, The following is a brief summary of drive-in business regulations as compared with this application, Location and Site Requirements 1. No increase in ,;ehicular troffic to a residential district,. Plan Proposal Complies 2, Does not interfere with nearby commercial property by disrupting pedestrian traffic, Complies 3, Will not create increased traffic hazards. Complies Lot Area 10,000 sq. ft. minimum and not less than 100ft. per side. 13,00Okq. ft. (complies) Parking Requirements 1. On site parking for each employee'on duty, 9 spaces provided in rear (complies) 2. No vehicles may be parked on the premises and offered for sale, lease or rent. Does not comply 2 - wheel trailers offered for rent. . . . . Conditional Use Permit 68-6 201 E. live,Oak Mobil Oil Statian April 23, 1968 Page 3 Accessways Two curb cuts per street maximum Activities permitted and prohibited Only those activities dir<lctly associated to users of motor vehicles are permitted, ligh ting 1. 15' height limit 2. Outside lighting ,shielded to prevent glare, nuisance, hazardous interference, ,etc. Sign Regu lations 1. One free 'standing sign not to exceed ,150 sq, ft. 2. No moving signs 3, No roof signs Walls None .required except adjacent'to residential .zones. LondscaS 1. 5' panter along street side except for curb openings. 2, 3' planters along walls:ofthe. interior property lines toa distance equal to the front.building line. 3. 150 Sq. ft. of planting at intersection. 4. 30 sq, ft. along building facades. Utilities All utilities required to be underground. Rest Rooms To be screened from view. , ' Trash Areas fo be enclosed on 3 sides by 5' block wall . Plan Proposal Complies Not indicated Not indicated Complies Size, not indicated Complies Complies Existing 6' block wan on north and east sides of property. Not Indicated Indicated planters deficient in length. Planter indicated approximately 64 sq, ft. None indicated. Complies Screens not indicated. "ight af wall not indicated. . . . .. '. . . Conditional Use Permit 68-6 201 E, live Oak Mobil Oil Station April 23, 1968 Page 4 The Planning Department recommends that this request be approved subject to the following conditions: ' 1. Grating-type catch basins be installed behind the driveway aprons to intercept droinage ~nd pipe it beneath the sidewalk to the gutter, Section 9262.3.7. 2. Trailers now being offered for rent be removed from property. Section 9275.4.18. 3, Rest rooms be screened from pub I ic rights-of-way by a decorative .screening device- and subject to Planning Department approval. 4. Zone C-l regulations and conditional use requirements shall be complied with e)(cept the following items where the regulations are recommended to be waived, a. Landscaping regulations should (Section 9275.4,11) be modified to permit landscaping os shown on the plot plan. b. Display regulations (Section 9275.4.16) should be modified to permit oil dispensers, windshield cleaning accessories and cash boxes on the pump islands. PLANNING DEPARTMENT WILLIAM PHELPS, Planning Director af'~/~ CARROLL B. BENSON, Assistant Planner WP:CBB:ec . S/J8JrEcr ., ~-~ . '.:.~ ... C <. '" 9 ~ II I III ~t"1I1 . . t.= THIRD: .-- Ill' .tJt' It !1IItJ (I~J nnm 84 i ~S2 '1 SO . (ItOI)l'I:M). 41 4e. . """ .9 so . .. .. . 343S3637 IWoOf) (m:>> ('tft1J fino ..~... Awa.5 FOURTH' ,U """' " . \1_";,,,.__. o ~ % i % u .. .....0.. .'IL ' i S' " .. .' "' " t ," \ L "=. i' ,""'< l !" l 4 M .. . l.. , I I l' I n~ . --"'-"- ~-t.. ";-fr t"'~';" ~ i " ' ~-- It I~ ~ 1 I (UU) I (tun In.") ~ , (IUf) " -.-. -.,.-'-' -'-' -.,---. P:;tI'!!! ~ . e .on'~ ........... _ I_ t!) ~..~.. G) .... .,'. G) ..... '-II'" ('J) "......rI.., M u. .....,m '" ...,,::111- SIrE. H' CUIID RUt) '" -;: M.B 259 31 10 II .12 nnn (lIlI1 (J.II) . 13 .. I" twu 'UOJ) 601 II.. "51","6.. . . . .. ~ " 43 ! 42 i " 41! " --i-- --;. l i;2 -~----~ . .. - ' ~1.'foJ ;; --.--. --. . 22 C,fJ,P,'68' 6 L n II I " . "AVE.' e."" .. "'" C1M (11m = is . TR C .. .. ('I'''' hut) .. .. 6 z . " ...,,~ Ii! "IS. Z -. .. ChOIJ hi.. .. .. .. .. rttnl {1I1I) .. .. .. .. N 12 93 M 200- 0 . . ~, c ~ " \0 ll.'\o ~ , nUll (IuS) In) I' 110 D NO nnl IJOfJ . ti ~ to t() '" lM'UUI 1111) n'lI) H"HH () 0. , , Ie en';; CUt&l 14 I" NO, 1 6 ~ .. .. . l'1m OtOlI (lU)) nuu (Utll (UJI) .. .. .. .. AVE, t , " ... ... .... :llI o o PI r r , , .. RA T .. - ~ Inm ('I."" Cttotl i\i II i III C FIFTH AVE. : , . . ":M~ ~ !i II..'" ~ I ~ - I a:.t , ~ ~ ~ ~i len.., ..... d ! ;0 -1-'" ft:'" - ~..." ;0: Q):I\>> ~.A. s. :tm~(U,I)'Ollt)~i I M ,u AVE, It"" ~ :1.'HoI" I ... \111"1!,!10)~ ~.6) ,.@:: 'l-2'_.;.-} ~ (!) - ~ '..!o'"'..J__"H..f!: ~: -"--If ~ ----~~..t: '" .. . . . i (..R A C r l.~ UaICIl4!1)Ct 1t1 AVE. : [1 "- -'--'--' '- '--'--' .--.-- '--.--. .. r PL....T'" ..--' r , i , ; . I io'a,~_ e.u ./J'li' , I o;;'pc.li<; , 10 ( . o \ , . I I' I 111.,..7 . --.--__......_..____._.... ....- .-...-.-.-. --~---'-:'--I~' ..- ._'~-_.._- ,e"1:'....t...T I.. .oj& . ..-',.... -,- , , I' .' t__..__ .~. I '" ... 2 .... . ~," :.' .... r I -.I' ~'f tal ,'1 ad !,Id . ...., It..... c"'U ...?: " .!!:u. ... ':J '2 III "> -4 , i f ! , __ _.-.-J I ~6,Q.1'O.lE..,i"f..) rio' .. 9",,"&1,,0 . I ~ '.0, ,.'1.0 . ..,c.,A . ''<M/.tf. f'-A ...r"> '" 1.111""" - .., 0:0 - '.~:, . ,;1 i , ~ )- 1 , I .. . -I,y' I. ~"'C;1IU' ~,II...e;1I }(I' .I,,~;'-..., ' !"~LO~ulll ~"l$ /Jf .i:. ' ~'Q'" ll" , ,~."CI (If ",'f"l . 'fIfI,~O J,'I 1/ ~ "-. . 'ti,"" Jto....~'f ! ""-. ,;...- .,j- "v 'Jf' .." ' .~ .... ta ,c, "-.. ~.. . .:~ .~)) " . ~ ..., /''' ,/' . -~ .'b>.t' '1:1 J I '~~.' ",Vi ',.,f'1 , ')0 t- ~~~., 0 (~;I "Jt ,!i ql ~ (/1 0'" (I ~~ ;-..,.':.... I.:ij ,."e; 'V ~ "-:.-::;i!I.AJ. "v , " ,~. "'". 'j. 'I/q. \' ' 04'" '<(1"0 "..::r:: ',. , ' \ \~ \ , . , . , ,.0 1.,,,"'1 ,I'i~,,"fll "'"'\ ~,~ ' , ~~ . .. . p&.Ao,.'fElI --" 'I"''' -' '\ ,-,'l' ." "".co: .- ~...----~-'-~" --- ~...i -----. C(JP.~'8-" , ,iI., . 7'.....-,; L.. ,,,' 0"- .b."a~&Jf -.p L.OT p~,.,J- "," ,,-' .. C;C.AL- . ~"c .. 4' ~","' . " , I ,,' :MOJl,II_. '0 ,~~. ~r2.R?~TIO!-!. - -- ~.- ...,. 11' ~ "-J~ ._..~. " "" . . . . ' . .. .. NOTICE OF Pl.!BLlC HEARING BEFORE THE ARCADIA CITY PLANNING COMMISSION C. U. P. 68-6 WHEREAS, MOBILE OIL CORPORA TION, lessee of real property locatedwi,thin the City of Arcodia, Colifornia, and hereinafter described has filed with the Planning " " Commission of the City of Arcadia an application requesti~g a condi,tionaJ use'pefllliHo,t; the' purposes of upgrading existing service station facilities on the following,.Q,esc;ribed property: ' The portion 01' Lot 55, Tract No. 13217 in the City of Arcadia, as recorded in Map Book-264, Pages 26 and 27, in the office af the County Reco~der of Los Angeles County, State of California, described as 1'01 lows: Commencing ot the Northwest line of Live Oak Avenos. (100' wide) 76,34' from the Northeast line of Lot 55 then North ~ 50' 45" West 101,25' then South 890 04' 45" West to the East I ine of Se~nd Avenue then South on said East line and Northeast on said Northwest line to the point af beginning; ~~ The'p~operty is commonly known as 201 East Liv~ Oak Avenue. NOW, THEREFORE, NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on TUESDAY, APRIL 23, 1968, at the hour of 8:00 o'clock p,m., in the Council Chamber of the City Hall, 240 West Huntington Drive, Arcadia, California, said Planning Commission will hold a public hearing on the question of said proposed application, and,an opportunity will be afforded to persons particularly interested, and the public generally to be heard-on all matters concerning said conditional use permit applicotion. Dated: April 12, 1968 PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA R~%jL WILLIAM PHELPS, Secretary of Arcadia Planning CommissiC?n NOTE: On file at the Planning Department in the Arcadia City Hall are plans of the service station facilities which may be seen between 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. Monday through Friday.