The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About0636 " o ~=- -- . . . RESOLUTION NO. 636 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA, GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT UPON SPECIFIED CONDITIONS FOR THE STRUCTURAL ALTERATION OF AN EXISTING SERVICE STATION BUILDING ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 165 EAST DuARTE ROAD IN SAID CITY AND RECOMMENDING THE WAIVER OF CERTAIN MUNICIPAL REQUIREMENTS. WHEREAS, there was filed with this Commissien en the 5th day of February, 1968, the appl~catien ef Deuglas Oil Cempany ef Califernia, as ewner, fora c.onditienal use permit for structural alteratiens to an existing service statien en preperty knewn as 165 E. Duarte Read in the City ef Ar'cadia, Ceunty of Los Angeles, . State ef Califernia, mere specifically described as fellews: Let::) 19, 20 and 21, in Bleck 62 ef Arcadia Santa Anita Tract, as per map recerded in Beek 16, Page 58 of Miscellaneeus Recerds,Office ef County Recorder ef said Ceunty, tegether with the seutherly ene-half ef the alley vacated by Ordinance No.. 661 adjacent to. Let 21, Bleck ~2, Santa Anita Tract, except the interest in the seutherly 10 feet ef said alley, nertherly 10 feet ef said Let 21, easterly 12 feet ef said Lets 19, 20 and 21 and seutherly 12 feet measured at right angles to. the seutherly let line ef said Let 19, cenveyed to. the City ef Arcadia fer street, alley and highway purpeses, by deed recerded in Beek 48339, Page 132, Official Recerds ef said Ceunty; and, WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly held en said matter by and befere this Cemmissien en the 27th day of February, 1967, at . which time all interested persons were given full opportunity to. be heard and to. present evidencej NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ARCADIA, CALIFORNIA, HEREBY DETERMINES AND RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: -1- 636 V"" " . . ~ , . SECTION 1. That subject property is in Zone C-1. The property to the north is in Zones R-2 and R-l; the property to the west is in Zone C-l; the northeast and southeast corners are Zone C-l and the southwest corner is Zone C-l and C-2. That the location and zoning of the station are proper under the terms of the condi- tional use permit. That the granting of such a permit will not be detrimental to the public health or welfare or injurious to the property or improvements in such zone or vicinity. That the site is adequate in size and shape to acconunodate the proposed use, and all yards, spaces, walls, fences, parking, loading, landscaping, and other features required to adjust said use with the land and uses in the neighborhood. That its location at the intersection . affords ease of ingress and egress and that it abuts Duarte Road and Second Avenue which are adequate in width and pavement type to carry the kind of traffic generated by the proposed use. That the granting of such conditional use permit will not adversely affect the comprehensive general plan. SECTION 2. That for the foregoing reasons, this Conunission hereby grants a conditional use permit for the structural alteration of an existing service station on the above-described property sub- ject to compliance with all applicable regulations of the Arcadia Municipal Code, including those specified for drive-in businesses and for businesses in Zone C-l, except such portions of Chapter 2 of Article IX thereof as may be waived by the City Council, and upon the following additional conditions: . 1. Water service shall be in compliance with the Uniform Plumbing Code and to the satisfaction of the Water Department. - 2. A 15 I raa1.US cornercut;-or 1 at I)"'CLL t,e Road aha 3ecend ."'veRtlC ehall be ei.llil^"t,prl tQ tall City aHei the PIO!'u"o:J. !,l",utl:lL' shall <G8 sa1ftca to lIlairitai.. tho: n:qu1.rea J.~O "q. ft. -2- 636 , , . . .' , . . J. Pc.&. in"ctsp gp~1R8 Ba~k vf Lht:: 'I:)ldt::wtilk tl.uJ l-I1.tJt:: dL"t:iln- agEl te gl:l'e1:"," LIH"uugh LI1" vul J., face eh.all Be iRstallee. 1:8 lIIeEl't the app1"'nu?l sf the Dep-i-ptm9Rt Qf P.,h11" W'"."lrs. 4. A decorative solid masonry wall shall be constructed on the north property line when the alley is vacated. SECTION 3. This Commission further recommends to the Arcadia City CouncE that Condition #1 of Section 9275.4.11 and Sections 9275.4.12, 9275.4.13 and 9275.4.16 of the Arcadia Muni- clpal Code be waived, for the reason that the strict adherence to said Sections woulc'l be inappropriate or inapplicable to the intended use of the property in view of its proposed alterations. . SECTION 4. The Secretary shall certify to the adoption of this resolution and shall cause a copy hereof to be forwarded to the City Council of the City of Arcadia. I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing resolution was adopted at a regular meeting of the City Planning Commission of the Ci ty of Arcadia held on the 12th day of March , 1968, by the following vote: AYES: Commissioners Cahill, Godfrey, Kuyper, Livingston, Parker, Stewart and Lauber NOES: None ABSENT: None 7/!~ % 7cw-?-u Chairm?n . ATTEST: ~ ;;fJf~ -3- 636 .I" . . . February 27, 1968 . TO: PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: PLANNING DEPARTMENT C.lJ. P. 68-3'PROPOSED AL TERA TION TO EXISTING SERVICE STATION FACILITIES ,- 165 EAST DUARTE ROAD - ZONE C-I SUBJECT: APPLlCA TION This application filed in the rame of Douglas Oil Company of Colifomia proposes to make certain alterations to the existing service station facilities at the northwest corner of Duarte il9ad and Second Avenue. . PRESENT ZONING AND LAND USE . The subject property is in Zone C-I and developed with service station facilities, The property io the north is in Zone R-2 and R-I and developed with single family homes. The property to the west is in Zone C-I and developed with miscellaneous commerciol and residential uses. The property immediately to the west is a vacant lot. The northeast corner is in Zone C-I and developed with a service station and a small office building. The property on the southeast comer is in Zone C-I and devel,oped with a service statian, a meat market and a liquor store. The property on the southwest corner is zoned C-I and C-2 and developed with a service station and a shoppi~g center. EXISTING DEVELOPM: NT . .:: The subject site (approximately 23,000 sq. ft.) is presently developed with a two bay service building and three pump islands. Two pump islands (canopy covered) are served from Duarte Road. One pump island is served from Second Avenue and is not covered by a canopy. The subject site is also used for the purpose of trailer rentals. PROPOSAL The following alterations are proposed on the site: I. A ISO sq. ft. planter is proposed at the southeast comer of the site. . 2. Existing free standing sign to be removed and replaced,with a new free standing sign having a total area (4' 6" x IS' x 2) of 13S sq. ft. and a height of 20 feet. . ~'~ &:3k . ,. . '. . ' . . . C,U.P.68-3 February 27, 1968 Page Two 3. A five foot high decorative screen wall is proposed adjacent to the restrooms at the southwesterly end of the building. A two foot high slumpstone planter is proposed adjacent to the screen wall. ' 4. Outside t.ire cabinets are proposed to be removed. , 5.. A!wo foot high slumpstone planter '(3' x 23' 8';) is proposed along th'3 northeasterly end of the building. 6, SllJmpstone veneer is proposed to be Installed along the,lower 2' of those portionsci the building facade fron,ti.ng the street. 7. A23' 6" x 24' canopy is proposed over the pump island adjacent to Second Avenue, ANALYSIS . This service station alteration isa proposal which would bring the entire station site under th'e purview of the Conditional Use Permit procedure and regulations. There are service stations on all four corners of the intersection of Duarte Road and Second Avenue. This intersection constitutes the easterly end of the commercial area between Santa Anita Avenue and Second Avenue. As such, the station would not interfere with present a future pedestrian traffic in the commercial area" Duarte Road and Second Avenue have adequate widths to accommodate any' traffic generated by the service station, , .,~ : : The R-2 property to the north is separated fro~ the site by an alley which at the present time is un improved ond planted in grass. If the regulations for a drive-in business in the Conditional Use Division of the Code are app I ied to the station, a mo're harmonious adjustment to the area and community will result. RECOMMENDA TION . The Plann ing Deportment re<:;ommends the application be approved subject to the following conditions: ~."..<--, , 1, Water service lGt be in Compliance with the Uniform Plumbing Code and to the satisfaction of the Water Department. 2. .l'J~ -+-~J5' ra~ comer ~ atc.Duarte ~~and Second Avenu8olana~propo~planterl iO ~m~i~tn the tiquired ISO sq. ft. -.\ ,~ '. '\.~~/--,~ " , . . . . " . , ., Il v"-<" '1 I'~,.,- , . . "p"p , 6(~ C.U.P.68-3 February 27, 1968 Page 'Three j 3, _1IllifI't perimeter d~ains Pack of the sidewalk !!nd pipe drainag:)o. ',Pi..L. "tt'" ~.?1~ gutter throug~ the cur~~ace~~~~?~~?:,_ I!. ~ )"~ --~ r: ,1l~~.JJj.:r:: ;~'l...aw.-. ---~, The followlng'reg(jlal'ions are recommended to l:{e waived as being inap- propriate or inapplicable to the intended use of the F'roperty or to the property itself. This application has been designated as a var;iance and/or conditional use permit application to permit the Planning Commission ta recommend to the City Council the '!'Iaiver of inappropriate regu/atio.ns. ,/ ./ 1. Sections 9275.4,12 and 9262.6.7 - Utilities, be waived as inapplicable. vi y , 2. Sections 9275.4,16 and 9262.6.8,- Storage and Displays, be waived to permit, oil display cabinets, windshield cleaning equipment and cash box on pump islands, .~~ c;::6-6.z& v - 3. Section 9275,4,11 - Landscaping, be waived as inappropriate. 'The pump islands as installed do not provide sufficient width to allow the required planting .trlp. / 4. Section 9275.4.13 - Rest Rooms Location, be waived as inappropriate,. The rest rooms, although not located in the rear of the builciing- are proposed to be adequately screened. / " 5. Section 9262,4. II - Free Standing Sign. Such sign is permitted if approved by the Modification Committee - with the maximum area being 100 sq. ft, and a maximum height of 25'. The plan proposes an. area of 135 sq, ft. ond a he ight of 20' . ...<Aectl.Ph 9244r~htoPug~..S~~rd~~#€'~~. , -'~i~~ch,"-6pproximti'relydo'-to 25'-;- V" ':: Note: The above \Vaiver does not exempt the applicant from fulfilling the remaining code requirements, including, but not limited to signs, landscaping, irrigation systems for the landscaped areas, and other appl icable zoning and building regulations. . tV~~ WILLIAM PHELPS Pianning ,Director WP:ec . I . AC-LC>' _..~:O-:~- -..... /' ., ^( , ("" " ~ , ' /^,~" '" ' . , ,W \. , ,"'r~' , ,,/') 'I " ,.",~, , ,) ,"" r , ' ",,.,, ~-..... ,,;''''(-' - v --- ~' ... v-,,'- ~:=-- - ,,~ G.I>"~O<O.~ ~c-~ ~ -, ~- r~-==-o ~ .-- , ~ I . ~z;--"''' " ~.~ ~ -/Zs.' I} 1 I t t --..-- . .' -!- . I .--... ' ~.c..,-'''~ _. Po~ ...-. ~...:::::: ~.: --~ ~ - ~_I". -~"., - - ..~~-.-- ......"" ................- ::""~-:::F~:..:...:--...._y . ~.:; =~e:.r.~:'..:I~I~ ~ ..:..::.,~:"'~.....~.~~ ~..:; :,::.::-:r. ~.::;u,::,,:,,~ ~.=.:-.. ~:~.~r!in~'... -:::::'l:.~.~':. i!f':...:.~.~':. -.:a=: ::::r~';";:I:-'::::' ~ ~.. ~ :,:::r:a:..-m:r=-:-'::" --:". ._.U,_f!. , , .'. .---"-~~-- --- DOUGLA;-':' - __.a OI'~ I ~"'Q ~-v? - l:5i!'rl//CE ~---- I 1WA1~ 1J!:T;o.V , .AC'~ ~-e -,..,,,-~~ -.- _ ......~...'.J-<I -~-_.. .-., ., . . , . ", . . . '! .. ~ .... . . .' ~ 8 i II . --. '. 'Ill MIl 00.2.8, ~ CALifORNIA 'GO ~ '.. ,. .. .. .. .. - .>0 .. .. .. ,- ,.,~ ill .... ZD , '~ .. " .. " ,. :!5 Z. " T~ ZI !~l . " AI ~, A A NI I. 3l /; h ; I. -~~ I : j '" ) ! 11 ~~::: Ill, 1~_ ... . 2 . ~ ~ , . S ,. II " .. " ,.... ~;ll . I ' l!olt. .. ,.... "" .. .. ,,. .. .. .. .. If.Llf ~st: ..; ~ , . DIAMOND r ,,,. .. .. .. ,. " .. .. .. .. ';.;;.nl~ ,! ... ," '" III' ." .., fUl ttll .., 16' '" , =! " U' so, '" 19 ~ 1~ " ,. " ,. ~ .. Z' Z> 2Z " = 3l . ~ " !i,1 ,.. :::~ J '" &i . n 5: I. lI--Z-- .' 5 .... , e . I. II 12 I\~' ,~ I' E:,' I") t1' ~n '" . . '", ,,' .n III ~:)I~) '''' all (-411 150 "51>'1, .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. lA, _ . ~ ELDORADO ~ ~,_,.. .. .. .. ";:If i::, .. .. .. .. ~) 1.11.1 i I (Jot) 0" "" t14lBol ~" ~ll ,.., ,.., 2. I " " ,. .. UZ7 ..... ., 29 22 ZI 19 i I (..'jlla . " =" u. Ie ~ I ::~3 ~. 11 ~ I:i. . l'~;::; ,1 ~~ z . . .... 7 . . 10 11 12 " 14 "" m ,,~ l~ I ," '" "" ">l .~~ .11 '''51 "., '" liIl'" Ii, ! t:l'." .. .. .. " , .. I.. .. .. .. 3 fANO ~ ~ "~5, ~\~.~ '0 -'0 !IO 50 AO .3C:t ",0 .-0 11t 141,!- ~J:l " ~.I (II;) llal If)~, 10) (U1 iiiJ ,U) (a' ) zo ~ J ;;,~13'!; ~I ~Q Z9 'l&" 21 24 25 2,c Z3 ~p. ,,. 1=: '~~32~= ~ ~ la~.;I:: J ..... lI:l. - .,. I; :p 1=.-- f"" ," ';' ' 17"~" 1 j J ..\i ,,- em -- ~.. 2 4 ~: ~,' , I. II 12 ~ 14 I. ii , i~e~lc~"" ':) "" (i~') ,~, ~, (,n (n) enl ~~' ,."J' Ii I .. ,. .. .. .. .. .. .. $ CENOA '. Jl ~'~ 1 ... ,",' .. ,. ,. " ,. .. .. .. ~~) ::11~\,"'" ,11 '0' 11.' " DOl "" "" "" CU1 ~ "z" .. Z9 z. Z7 " ~I .11 ~. " '" 31 T Z. z. . . ," RI C . dnl.ti! ~ . z . . I" . " " '" < '. :F ~ 7 . i,~l ,. II IZ l> " .. 16 17 I. ,. "1- : f; ",,,., h~l 0') .. "" In) I':' e~ (". (51) II ,.10m, , '"' .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 3 ALICE ~ Z ~ ~H, ,.. ... .. .. ... ~I .. .. (.:, ..I .. ..0 ~. f11. (101 "" "" ~l' "O! .., " Z, I ~ ..~z ,. >> )Z 31 ~~ S!) z7 Z6 zs Z4 U l;, z , ~ ~ ~ Z3 .~; I Z ~ . ~ II" " ~ 10 ~1 ~ Z . , . . I. It IiI .. 15 .. 17 19 !:;::I ~'ll 6 ,,. ('II n,) Inl " l:sll mn 14,) I'" ,,) " ,,,tt,,uJ;'"5: I " .. " .. .. .. .. .. .. ~ ." .!! ~ I ~ , ~ ... '.';,., "'\~ , n-- . 27 IL ST, s 1011,%1" ,1.:, . - , ~;:l .-*_~, )) _.~ : ~t)4@! ~ ... .ij~;;~ . ~~'z :'- xC I '::111:' i':c)n~1 ':') ~1 W =11~r;~~ f:;'I!..~". 21;;0 a too 1101lUl ~ '''1 I ~~ ~, 30 29 2.(l 11 Z4 Z5 2. U 12 ~lG.:: :;) / In S ~"g' .' / I'" ~ - '. :&:: ... ... i( .. ..I .. .5 , 7 8 9 10 II II 13 ,\4 's __IJl.~ ~l (1") ,.nl~" Its! I~_" n"., 4ll1CJI 0.'1 flU 1!!I"l 11ii'S' 1"9~50_505<tJ.0505050.ltO.M5G"'. ... ST. s . . -. h .l Ii !f: ~IJ. .. Inl .. .. I~ :~ .. 1111(1 \,i1fiill III '" "' '." nul n. nnl '" !l i '.. n Z8 Z1 T '" zo '& ~ . - .. .z 31 '" T " z4 Z, zz l' '! ,. . ~ \\" ! lSi ~ "! 3 ~ . - " ~: , 3. U~ ~:"' I ~ z ~nl.~ 7 " ,~ , " '7~l . . . I. I)' " II ~ ~~ ,.. ~;t' -- ,,' (1l"lf~n1 Il~ fln1 "" " '" . "' m I., '"s I J: IU .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. ST. I f ~ 'I . II' .' '" 50 " .JO 50 50 ~ oM >> .. ,':. .NZ~\!''-I ~ _.~ gll fUll ntl nil) 0.01 111.JI)Biun... om 0'" "In" )2)IJ029le172'IJZ4 n 22 zoi: 'I ,a 14 ! , I I. ~ I' . , . , la;~,~ ~~~ --, ~ ~~ 0 I"~'" !I ,..._2'" 4 .. 9 10 II IZ I> .. ,. .. .1 -~;l nl) '''' '" ISSl '" '" ... .." "' n' .., 16,:;:" I" ,. :Ml ,. .. ,. .. .. .. .. .. .. ., "~ I II . ST, I ; ,r::; IS 300 50 1: :; co ~ OlCl!U.lt'l2 1.;I~,~ 33~" -' !~i1 ~ 34"~; ';; . :~.:1r ~g3 :;;Pt 1,11 ~z .~ "l S II S Iln) 40 .. .. Inh" .... 50 UlflM nw It... Inl U It, !I02IZ&Z1Z'Z~lA .. J , 4 -' " ., 8 9 10 II I'll 1I,}nll 111 m01tllJS)1S91lf ~ 50 50_05050 12 " .. " '''~;: "a- ".\ ..' , ST. I t g 3C;_n, ,. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ,. .. .. .. ... ", .., IlSl '" 11.) "n ... ", ." ", 16' '" .., 21 co I II~l " " " ., '" oZ' .. 21 Z. ~~ Z4 Z> zz zo : ll'-,.-- ! ~ ..~ T~ 11: , .. : 1 - ~ :E..~_ , .;f~ ;.' ! 1& ~:' I,~ 2 , 11 F: . . . 7 . . I. " IZ .. .. ,. I'n, I ~!' r~) IIIl n' Ll.' (In 1~f) ,,' ... ISll I. m I'" "~J I 10 1'!Io .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. r ; , o Z o U ... '" v . . ST, s 111 nlll (In) 1C1 so )C no lUll... 15 3Ci 35 :)41 )) )1 31 )0 29 2& Z7 . A T I ,. ~" J .- . + .. .. + ~ ::~ . ~ 21 i '$! '.0 IS,16 11 ~ If 12 13 J" .. '. ,(p 8'7 ,